EFAP Movies - Minis - Discussing Miscellaneous Writing - Fellowship

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 кві 2024
  • This is a supercut taken directly from the EFAP Crew watching The Lord of the Rings, links to all three EFAP movies are right here:
    Fellowship - • EFAP Movies #58: The L...
    Two Towers - • EFAP Movies #59: The L...
    Return of the King - • EFAP Movies #60: The L...
  • Фільми й анімація

КОМЕНТАРІ • 42

  • @aaronmueller1560
    @aaronmueller1560 Місяць тому +36

    One of these Minis better be titled “bitching About Rings of Power,” I wanna see the supercut of all those

  • @ODST_Parker
    @ODST_Parker Місяць тому +47

    Every time one of these minis releases, I'm like, "Man, this is great. I should watch all three extended Lord of the Rings movies again for the thirty-something-th time!"

    • @defeqel6537
      @defeqel6537 Місяць тому +3

      my eyes mist every time just from the loss I feel for not expecting these kind of movies ever seeing the light of day again

    • @councilofkarens729
      @councilofkarens729 29 днів тому +1

      @@defeqel6537 As shite as our timeline is, just rejoice we will always have these movies.

    • @defeqel6537
      @defeqel6537 29 днів тому +3

      @@councilofkarens729 true, and a part of the misty eyes comes from the sheer beauty of these movies

    • @Rick_Harper
      @Rick_Harper 10 днів тому

      Thirty-something?! Those are rookie numbers.

  • @richardbohacik2685
    @richardbohacik2685 Місяць тому +8

    “Everyone should have Sam in their Lives”… maaaaan, that is SO true! Imagine how Life would be so much better and easier to have your Sam by your side. True loyal, hopeful friend with strong heart and courage to face the dark and still see the Light behind it. I love those movies, they are not even different league from other, great movies, its different game.

  • @SiriusSphynx
    @SiriusSphynx Місяць тому +6

    They mention the difference of doing a simple thing hundreds of feet in the air is very different. As an Ironworker, I can attest this is 100% true. People underestimate how powerful "just a mental thing" really is. All the times you tripped and stumbled in life comes to mind and all the sudden you're thinking, it only takes one of those moments, and you may not be going home from work that day. And no, we're not always tied off, though we should be, it's simply not how things get done in reality. Back to my point, if you don't believe me, stand on a high ledge and feel your heart sink and you balls jump up into your gut, then consider taking a simple walk right along the side as you sweat and shake, you might be able to do it, but don't act like it's no different than walking down a sidewalk. That's the power of your mind.
    P.S. I'm not seriously suggesting someone do that. But if you do, that's on you.

  • @BWGmedia
    @BWGmedia Місяць тому +4

    My girlfriend and I are watching the trilogy cause she’s seen them a million times and I’ve honestly never seen em til now…. Finished 2 towers the other night! I sure hope they get the ring to mt doom!

  • @witchkingangmar2731
    @witchkingangmar2731 Місяць тому +1

    Everyone needs a Sam in there life amen

  • @councilofkarens729
    @councilofkarens729 Місяць тому +8

    If only Tolkein could write as well as the Rings of Power writers LOL

    • @darrenoconnell2891
      @darrenoconnell2891 Місяць тому +3

      Yes, Tolkien is a hack compared to the genius of the Amazon writers’ room. 😂

    • @mr_jyggalag
      @mr_jyggalag 25 днів тому +1

      Thank god they gave us backstory of Mordor.

    • @councilofkarens729
      @councilofkarens729 23 дні тому

      @@mr_jyggalag I literally cried butterfly tears when the text dissolved and "Mordor" appeared in its place - @They Sauroned"

  • @NoOne-bj1ys
    @NoOne-bj1ys 4 дні тому

    Its funny, I love these movies so much that I enjoy watching other people gush over them. Then I'll pause it to gush over it further to myself. There's so many amazing details. It really shows how much the people making the movies cared about them. So many small things that most people would say don't matter, but the accumulation of those small details, is what takes these movies from good to great.

  • @slaapt
    @slaapt Місяць тому +4

    Jumping that gap isn't just scary, despite being not a very long jump, for being high up, but also because they are carrying a tonne of gear. Armor, swords, provisions, tools, maybe a sleeping bag or something like that. "I could do that" is easy to say. Now do it with at least 10 kilograms of additional gear (or more depending on the character).

  • @ButtersTheGreat1
    @ButtersTheGreat1 Місяць тому +7

    Good to see wolf again, he's who introduced me to Mauler.

  • @JCRascal14
    @JCRascal14 Місяць тому +3

    Man i just got caught up with the actman AZ situation. Disgusting business. Didnt even know who AZ was but actman really disappointed me. Dont think he realizes the culture invasion going on from the woke ideologues

  • @deriznohappehquite
    @deriznohappehquite Місяць тому +20

    One thing with this trilogy is that it’s based on arguably the best fantasy book trilogy, and The Lord of the Rings books are only as special as they are because Tolkien spent years writing dozens of stories that make up the backstory for this world, then he finally wrote and published a children’s novel set in it, then the publisher wanted a sequel so he wrote this love letter to that passion project.
    If you read The Fall of Gondolin, the Lay of Leithian/Beren and Luthien, the Children of Húrin, or his other unfinished tales they’re not nearly as good as LOTR, but a 2020s novelist absolutely would have published them.
    Tolkien was writing the Legendarium starting in 1917 and only published something serious from it in 1954. It was really an exercise in quality control. It’s hard to imagine a fantasy novelist ever committing to that level of quality control again.

    • @harbl99
      @harbl99 Місяць тому +3

      Tolkien left stuff on the metaphorical cutting room floor that a lot of creators would give their eye teeth for. Have you seen his early sketch concept of Arda as a giant ship sailing on the eternal ocean? Valinor is the forecastle, Middle-Earth the stern. The whole is illuminated by a lantern at the head of the great mountains forming the mast amidships. Mind-boggling grandeur of imagination.

    • @ImperatorIke573
      @ImperatorIke573 26 днів тому

      This comment right here is giving me the inspiration to keep writing. Please don't ever take it down my friend!

    • @mr_jyggalag
      @mr_jyggalag 25 днів тому

      To be fair, Hobbit wasn't set in the same Legendarium; there were references to his "main work," but it wasn't the same world until he started working on the sequel to a children's novel. By adding Hobbit to Legendarium, Tolkien needed to write and explain a few things that appeared in Hobbit so they would make sense in Legendarium; some of those were never answered, for example, the question of free will and orcs. Others... Well, his "retcon" of a ring in Gollum's possession being the One Ring that was created by Sauron imitating the Ring of Morgoth is a beautiful lesson in how to do retcons (and expansions to the old lore so the new things make sense to the old ones).
      Also, many things weren't written beforehand in LotR or planned. Faramir is the most known, I think, character that was "invented"; we even have the letter (sadly, I don't recall which one specifically) where Tolkien wrote in the lines, "I did not invent or want him, but there he came walking out of the woods of Ithilien." The other character that I'm sure was "invented" and retroactively written into Legendarium is Galadriel (there is some evidence to support it, but Tolkien never said that explicitly like he did with Faramir).

  • @Paul-bs5wl
    @Paul-bs5wl Місяць тому +1

    I really think Fellowship is the best movie. In the case of Two Towers and RotK they are absolutely amazing movies, but in both cases I find parts to lament based on what's missing or changed from the book versions, mostly regarding the Gondor characters, but also the fact that Rohan ever doubts aiding Gondor after Theoden is cured. But where Fellowship is concerned I think they made nearly perfect choices with what to include and what not to include considering the restrictions of time.

  • @SentryUwU
    @SentryUwU Місяць тому

    10/10 vids

  • @casualromp
    @casualromp Місяць тому +3

    I'd figure this be on the highlights channel

  • @alexhayden219
    @alexhayden219 7 днів тому

    Everyone should have a Sam in their life. Everyone should be a Sam in someone else's.

  • @Zenocrate
    @Zenocrate 11 днів тому

    “Everyone should have Sam in their Lives”… Or everyone should endeavour to be Sam for someone in their life.

  • @TheHardys01
    @TheHardys01 Місяць тому

    The amount of minis being made off of this EFAP Movies really shows how much they kept talking about the series.
    Rather than actually watching & talking about what was on the screen itself.
    I perfer the Wolf, Rags, & Mauler cut.

  • @harbl99
    @harbl99 Місяць тому

    "Oh, the acting in those films is really hammy and over the top."
    Long story short: we're no longer friends. In the immortal words of Epic Rap Battles JRRT: "The genre's called fantasy. It's _supposed to be_ unrealistic, you myopic manatee!"

  • @ViolentMessiah666
    @ViolentMessiah666 Місяць тому

    Dammit Gary don't be puttin Cinema Roberto's name on the troll, it's insulting to trolls 😠

  • @stevegt2682
    @stevegt2682 Місяць тому +3

    There was a bad casting choice that was fortunately corrected,Stuart Townsend as Aragorn

  • @Kainvverd
    @Kainvverd 29 днів тому

    Writing is all about writing things... Never forget to write the things you want to write. Writing gives you power, writing is power.

  • @danielmiller5778
    @danielmiller5778 Місяць тому +4

    Are you guys gonna watch the fallout show? I thought it was gonna be awful but I actually really liked the character work. Action was kinda lame tho.

    • @MediumRareOpinions
      @MediumRareOpinions Місяць тому +5

      Longman was not a fan. No EFAP planned but he has hinted on Open Bar and Real BBC he's preparing some kind of video on it.

    • @darthdragonborn1552
      @darthdragonborn1552 20 днів тому

      Lmfao

  • @Avariths
    @Avariths Місяць тому

    First

  • @tinglemccringleberry8899
    @tinglemccringleberry8899 Місяць тому +2

    I can’t stand Sean Astin.

    • @Neo2266.
      @Neo2266. Місяць тому +4

      I cannot make you stand me
      _But I can stand you!_
      -Sean ass tin

    • @Zenocrate
      @Zenocrate 11 днів тому

      Me neither. Sam is one of my favourite characters in the books but Astin is so wrong - from the unconvincing accent to the fact that he becomes fatter the closer to Mount Doom he and Frodo get. Sam is a young working class chap - it makes no sense that he should be the fat one. The German actor who plays Sebastian in ‘Land of Mine’ [Under Sandet] is close to how I imagine Sam.

    • @Zenocrate
      @Zenocrate 11 днів тому

      Me neither. Sam is one of my favourite characters in the books but Astin is so wrong - from the unconvincing accent to the fact that he becomes fatter the closer to Mount Doom he and Frodo get. Sam is a young working class chap - it makes no sense that he should be the fat one. The German actor who plays Sebastian in ‘Land of Mine’ [Under Sandet] is close to how I imagine Sam.

  • @DegenGammaCom
    @DegenGammaCom Місяць тому

    You guys are really out of content?