I prefer the DAC Painting over the other Dp!, because that one looks washed out!!, whereas DAC is really Beautiful and the details are so much more clearer and crisper!!😊😊💕💕
I don’t have a lot of time to spend on UA-cam…..this is the FIRST video I searched for after not watching videos for weeks!! Thank you for this comparison. I am looking forward to following your channel.
What an undertaking! You did an excellent job of explaining the differences between the two. I love them both for different reasons. What a difficult choice to make. Well you don't have to since you did both. Thank you so much for doing this comparison!
This was the most amazing series. I am torn between the two. I appreciate the clear elements in the DAC. But the soft colors in the DPD are so beautiful. I do find the hand in the DAC a bit stark because the colors are different from the skin tone in her face, but the original art has similar colors? I wish the animals in the DPD were more apparent. I am curious to see a middle ground between them. The work you put in on this (and all of your content) is mind blowing. Congrats on two completely massive projects coming together so well.
I am a photo editor & I can say it is incredible the difference from person to person what type of editing we like. What a great & indepth comparison. I do agree that both of these versions are interesting edits, both look like a combo of the image. I am leaning towards the DPD just because I don't tend to like crisp lines.
You did such an awesome job on these paintings Katie! Thank you So Very Much for doing these comparison videos. I have always wanted to see a finished painting with so many colors! Thank you again.
Thank you for showing all 4.. to me.. the paintings crisscross actually.. the dac painting is matched to the dpd.. and the original painting match to dac.. your work is simply woooow.. id love to see more like this comparrisons.. its fun and thank for the play list as well..
Hi Katie although both pictures are beautiful and striking I love the sharp colours and definitions of the diamond art club one. I would work on any one of them. Gorgeous.
I like both company's versions, but 1) I buy my Josephine Wall's DPs from Diamond Painting Deutschland, I like their look for this artist better and I love the pastel overload. 2) overall I love DAC's poured glue and scallops on the side of their canvasses better.
Wow. Good job. First I tought I like DAC more, it is clearer, but now I think DPD is more like the original. More aquarellic. Do you know what I mean? The rendering is harder at DAC.
Katie, thanks so much for sharing your wonderful journey with these two gorgeous paintings! I really do love them both for different reasons. Both are equally stunning! Can't wait to see the comparison with the third kit. Thanks for all your hard work and tenacity on completing both!😊
Wow Katie! What a fascinating journey! They are both stunning. I love the ethereal look of the DP Deutschland and I love the vibrant colors in the DAC. They are so different, but I love both. Thanks so much for sharing this with us! Bravo! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
You did an amazing job with these two kits! I'n not into Josephine Wall but I've watched all the videos. It's really interesting to see how the rendering is different and so important. I can't imagine doing a kit with 220 colors, I'm a color blocking girl 😁 after this last video, I can say, I prefer diamond art club 's version. Thanks for sharing this project with us 👍
Thanks for doing this series. I like the DAC so much better from viewing distance than up close. I still wish there was a middle choice because I like parts of the piece better on one company, and other parts better on the other.
Wow! I love them both. There’s more richness and detail in DAC but I know the challenge of 275 colours makes the DPD version a different experience completely. We’ll done Katie. Thanks for sharing. You have been so generous with your time and it’s a great comparison. I’m sad it’s over 🥲
Awesome job on this series! Seriously, that's a lot of work and you did such a great job comparing both. I think the DPD looks closer to the original artwork, but I think I'd rather complete the DAC because I like the contrast and the emphasis on the details. Plus it looks like a lot less confetti than DPD. I agree, it's totally up to the person diamond painting to what they prefer! Thanks again for all these videos!
You did such a fantastic job Katie! I have loved following this series and I hope you do another comparison series in the future because it is so helpful to see the vast differences between renderings. Both of them turned out absolutely beautiful!
I love both renderings. Personally I will never do a painting with 200 plus colors. I appreciate you doing this. What a fun series this has been. Thank you for the content.
I think a lot depends on where the painting would hang and the look you would be going for... in a vibrant room the DAC would still stand out but if going for a relaxing atmosphere the DAD would be the one to go for. Well done for all the work you have put into these large paintings.... I honestly don't think I could even do two smaller paintings twice 😁 Thank you 💚
Thank you so much for all your work on these paintings! As you said it is a personal preference and in each video my eye was always drawn to DAC painting, for the colors and clarity. I had considered a DPD, but was always put off by the number of colors but this just confirms my choice of staying with the DAC. This was so helpful, and very much appreciated.
Fantastic series, I have enjoyed this comparison. My favorite has been DPD due to the soft blend but odd enough in terms of the overall product I love DAC because I love being able to see the details.
I am so thankful for this video. Jo Wall art is no longer available on DAC and I was considering the Deutschland option, but it just doesn't speak to me. Thank you for helping me in my decision not to purchase. I will just have to be faster when making a decision to purchase!
This was the canvas that brought me to your channel, and after seeing it completed I will say I prefer the DAC with the exception of the water rendering in the upper left hand corner that is the only portion I prefer the DPD version. Thank you, and seeing this canvas is what made me buy it after seeing section 2 completed. Thank you for your hard work and diligence
This is just awesome. Both versions are exceptional. I like her face and hand in the softer version but like the surrounding background in the DAC version. Choosing just one I would probably go with DAC version. I hope the Uniquely Down Under version gives a middle road of the two. Thank you for this “journey” and your time in completing both. Peace and love abide with you and yours 💕
Hi Katie, thank you so much for this amazing comparison project that you shared with us!! Absolutely beautiful. I am presently working on DAC’s Spirit Of Flight and I’m enjoying it very much. Take care of your beautiful self!! 💜 Dawn
This series has been fascinating, my taste goes toward DAC. I think it would look better on a wall. Kudos to you for doing this comparison! Thank you. 🍁🍂🌾🌾🍂🍁🍁🍂🌾
First of all, thanks so much for taking us along your journey with this amazing project!! What a gift you have given the diamond painting community with this comparison series. I think you've taught all of us, including these companies, more about the impact of rendering in diamond painting form. I thought, until now, my preference was going to be the DAC version because I tend to gravitate towards vivid colors and high contrast. To my surprise, I adore the subtle rendering and softer color palette of the DPD version!! That said, which one would I want to work on... definitely DAC 😂...Bravo 👏
This series has been incredible!! So much hard work you’ve put it and it hasn’t been waisted on me. I prefer the contrast in the DAC kit, personally, though they are both beautiful in different ways. You have inspired me to do a comparison series next year with two of the same kit from Uniquely Yours Down Under. One is poured glue with minimal colors, the other is double sided adhesive with many colors. 🤗 ~ Kel
I have the DAC one in my stash to do and I can’t wait to do it now!! I’m sorry but over 80 colours would seriously be too traumatising - such a huge project to do one of these let alone 2 so I’m soooo impressed with what u have done, great job!
Well done Katie! I love the hair, and the bottom right definition in DAC but the softness of DPD is lovely! I have a DAC JW and now I want a DPD JW too!!!
From a diamond painting perspective I prefer DAC. A lot less confetti, poured glue and the image is clearer and I think would be more fun to work on. I do like the rendering of the waves in the DPD better though.
Great job Katie! I’ve watched the entire series and it has been truly a fun experience. I must say that I prefer the Diamond Painting Deutschland rendering. At viewing distance it more closely resembles the original artwork in my opinion. I’ve just received the “Crystal of Enchantment” from DPDeutschland in square drills ( that’s all I do) and I’m excited to start on it. I love a challenge and I’m not intimidated by the number of colors. Thanks for your very hard work on this comparison video! 💖
If I were to choose overall, I would probably pic the DAC version. Both are stunning and I'm still in the in-between camp. If they could combine and come up with the middle, it would be great. 🙂
Love this series! I have the DAC version but there are a few colors I might change after seeing both finished paintings. Like the sky around the birds and a few in the waves. You did such an amazing job! Thank you so much for doing this 💖💎
First and foremost. Hats off to you for your amazing job on both canvases. You are my DP She-ro. I have to agree with you and the others that both had their own merits. I was a bit disappointed that for all the colors used by DPD that there was not more sharpness that appears in the original art work. I almost feel like DAC is over focused and DPD was under focused especially with the birds to the right and butterflies to the left. But again kudos to you and I can’t wait see what’s next.
This has been a fab comparison. Personally I love the DAC version most and I am waiting for Aries to come in to do as my first JW. Thank you so much for sharing and I look forward to the dekitting! X
Yay!! Have really enjoyed following along with this project. Thanks for doing this comparison so we don’t have to. Cuz dang that’s a lot of work! Curious, will you be displaying either of these in your house?
I love them both! It all depend on the purpose, i e who I was giving it to or where I was hanging it as far as deciding which one I want. I can't wait to see the UYDO one.
OMG what a difference. I love DAC so much better. Colors, clearness and just overall stunning. I do see a little that I like on the germany one the watercolor effect.. but overall love the DAC I do love bright colors so that's why.... Thanks so much for doing this study. That's a lot of time and I personally would be bored doing two of the same.. Thanks for much for the video.
Ok so I have really enjoyed this comparison. Thanks for taking the time. So I was pretty certain that the DAC version was going to be my favourite. Right up until you showed the normal viewing distance pictures. Then I thought hmmmm actually I quite like the DPD version. Up close I like DAC, from far away I like DPD.
Wow, I actually prefer the DAC version! I feel like some details got lost in the DPD version. The only thing I don’t love about the DAC is her face and the blue in front of the face. I wish they had softened that area a little and used a few more colors in the blue space. Otherwise it’s perfect! 💜
Amazing job! Both came out nicely. As you said, I wish there was an in-between. DAC colors are so stark compared to the original painting and some of the dark outlining takes away from the softness as well. On the other hand, DPD would benefit from going through and cleaning up some of the computer rendering as some of the picture gets muddled with so many colors and no definition. Anxiously await what the Uniquely Yours rendering to see what they do with it.
I think I like DPD better. It’s better at a distance. I thought I was going to be DAC because of more detail but in the end I changed my mind. They are both beautiful though and you did a great job!
Wow… I’m also firmly in the camp of wishing I could combine aspects of both (and maybe make my own tweaks). The woman’s face and arm, as well as most of the sky in front of her, I think we’re done better by DPD. I also preferred that they stuck closer to the original dimensions. The dimensions weren’t so different that messing with the perspective was worth that change by DAC. However, the single bird in the foreground in front of the woman, her hair, and almost everything behind her I thought was much better in the DAC version. I do wish the blues in the sky and face were closer to the original… both companies’ renderings look more teal blue to me than the original artwork. Here’s hoping the Australian version you mentioned ends up being the best of both worlds… and still available for purchase once you have time to do that one.
Hey Katie 😁. WOW!! Your comparison has been EPIC !! I have so enjoyed this entire process and wished I could work on them simultaneously with you!! I have both the DAC and UYDU versions and I can't wait to do my own comparison between those two companies!! I can't believe how fast you completed this comparison! Well, thanks so much for including us in your journey! It seemed at the end of this video where you had 4 pictures on screen (both companies on top and both original artwork pics below their respective canvases), that the bottom 2 pictures were mistakenly swapped... Please let me know if they're correctly placed because I'm really confused, lol !! Thanks again for your dedication and hard work completing this project! I can really appreciate how time consuming this must have been and, as thorough as you were, you finished in record time!! I look forward to your next project and videos, Katie 🤗💎💎🧡🖤🧡🖤. xx Cynthia
I like them both they are amazing. I said I would never do such a large kits the Deutsche one (never say never right) but I went to their website and I found two I want to do. Both over 250 colors each yes they both are zodiac sign. I am one sign with a lot of tendencies of the other. I am thinking about buying both of them & do them separately throughout all of next year. I think that is going to be my big project for next year. A lot of me deciding to do one is because of watching these videos of you completing them. So thank you. Sorry this comment is so long.
Excellent series!!!! I would love to see the 3rd version from UYDU added to the mix! I know it will be closer to the DPD version but perhaps a bit more where it was slightly lacking on DPD. Finding that happy medium would be "just right" as with the 3 bears!! 🐻 🐻❄ 🐻 Artistically DPD is closer to J.W. version. Have you considered sending the link to J. W. ?? I think she would truly love this!! Maybe after the UYDU is added?? Just a thought and something to add like in a short interview with her?? 😉😉💎💎💎
Thanks for the video, I was really tempted to buy one of DPD Josephine Wall painting precisely because the insane amount of colours but I think I’ll pass on that, it doesn’t look that great and you can’t really see there’s over 150 colours in there, you saved me lots of money spent on a purchase that I would have been disappointed with, so thanks s lot!
I was sure with so many colors I would like the DPD painting more, but I actually like DAC’s version much better! It is just a bit too stark, but I gotta give DAC the blue ribbon on this one!
I have loved watching this series. I am curious if you are going to continue this series with another comparison from Uniquely Yours Down Under and a HAED blank canvas following the same column comparisons?
Well done! Congrats on the finish. I like both . . .but my eyes just seem to really be drawn to DAC's version. I would love to see the UYDU one. But, I don't think I could work on this canvas twice let alone 3 times.
Not even close for me, DAC for me is the clear winner. I prefer their more defined version and their coloring. So much better in my opinion. But like you said, it’s all about personal preference. 😊
Thank you for doing this. For me I think that for a general look DAC is more accurate in the color choosing and definition. But the face is completely different from the original artwork. Is beautiful but not the original. As for color goes her hand is more accurate in DAC. But also I think both companies didn't achieve the color of the skin. They did it brighter and is more subdued in the original artwork. Also I don't like the hair in Diamond Deutschland is too blurry. I think I prefer the DAC more
I'm working on this now(dac)! It's my 1st Josephine Wall. Personally idk if I could do 200+ colors, I'm not a fan of color changing lol. I'm so glad you did this, thank you! How long did it take to complete both?
@@DiamondsandWashi thanks for replying! I can only imagine. Tracking hours is hard. I tried it & messed up in the very beginning 😆 then decided it wasn't worth it if it wasn't accurate
I really don't like many parts of the DAC.. Thought I would want to get Josephine Wall from them but I guess I'll use DPD in spite of the many colors. I fell like DPD is closer to the original art. After I noticed the wings at the ears and that one wing does not touch the ear in the DAC I knew I would not get that version.
Computer rendering I love hands down. I don’t like the hand charting at all. I look at the DAC one and I don’t see Josephine Wall at all, even though it’s one of her art work. You can see how obvious each line is hand charted. The DP Deutschland, I love how it hold true to Josephine Wall. It’s more realistic instead of how cartoonish and 2 dimensional it looks with DAC. The computerized version is more realistic looking and more like looking at a photo. Kudos on working on both of them. I’m working on a Josephine Wall from DP Deutschland like now and it’s a lot of work but it’s worth it.
I wish that dpd's image had the intensity of colour of dac's one, especially when they were using as many colours as they were. Both images are beautiful but the lack of colour intensity in dpd's was a bit disappointing.
Both paintings are beautiful. I do favor the DAC. I can't imagine the work you put into them. If you do another comparison video,I would love to see you do one with round drill paintings.
I don't like DSA at all however, I hate how DAC totally changes the look and feel from the original artwork. I can't personally understand why DAC, who hand charts, can't seem to stay even remotely true to the original art when it's a watercolor piece. Their colors are darker and the images become more crisp and don't flow nicely. Thank you so much for doing and sharing this process! I do like DAC, they just don't remain true to the original pieces and it bothers me most on watercolors.
I am very torn. I wish I could take aspects from both and combine them. I don't know what to say. The DPD would probably drive me insane with confetti. Both have great attributes. I do wish that one was closer to the original. The DPD is almost too washed out. It almost looks like a tapestry. Which is still very beautiful. I have issues with how much they changed the face on the DAC. I wish both companies would consider some revisions. You are amazing for completing both of these kits in such a short time. I am excited to see the third version. I would totally understand if it takes awhile for you to want to complete that one. Thank you for sharing!
I still like DAC better. The crisp edges and colors are more satisfying to me. I love DPD's softer face it's prettier. But the hair is less satisfying in DPD's picture. And i love the animals as represented by DAC. I'll take the DAC.
I have to change my original opinion early on in this series and say the DPD one looks much nicer. I don’t think the bold DAC colors look so good after all.
I prefer the German one dac seems to make the hands huge when they should more smaller and the face and neck are not very nice with bright blue drills I agree they should be lighter the German one looks more natural on the wall the dac one is too colourful they should have had used more pastel colours and more colours due to the size of it
I prefer the DAC Painting over the other Dp!, because that one looks washed out!!, whereas DAC is really Beautiful and the details are so much more clearer and crisper!!😊😊💕💕
I don’t have a lot of time to spend on UA-cam…..this is the FIRST video I searched for after not watching videos for weeks!! Thank you for this comparison. I am looking forward to following your channel.
I would LOVE if you added to this playlist and did the same painting from TOWTDA! Great work Katie!!
I have to say I like the DAC better - because it's clearer for me to see. But kudos to you for doing this series!
What an undertaking! You did an excellent job of explaining the differences between the two. I love them both for different reasons. What a difficult choice to make. Well you don't have to since you did both. Thank you so much for doing this comparison!
This was the most amazing series. I am torn between the two. I appreciate the clear elements in the DAC. But the soft colors in the DPD are so beautiful. I do find the hand in the DAC a bit stark because the colors are different from the skin tone in her face, but the original art has similar colors? I wish the animals in the DPD were more apparent. I am curious to see a middle ground between them. The work you put in on this (and all of your content) is mind blowing. Congrats on two completely massive projects coming together so well.
BRAVO! Have loved this comparison. It blows my mind. I love Diamond Painting Deutchland's version.
I am a photo editor & I can say it is incredible the difference from person to person what type of editing we like. What a great & indepth comparison. I do agree that both of these versions are interesting edits, both look like a combo of the image. I am leaning towards the DPD just because I don't tend to like crisp lines.
I agree with you. They are both beautiful, but I think the DPD is more ethereal. I’ve gravitated to that one every time.
I loved your feedback and to be able to see the difference. Good job Katie xx
You did such an awesome job on these paintings Katie! Thank you So Very Much for doing these comparison videos. I have always wanted to see a finished painting with so many colors! Thank you again.
Thank you for showing all 4.. to me.. the paintings crisscross actually.. the dac painting is matched to the dpd.. and the original painting match to dac.. your work is simply woooow.. id love to see more like this comparrisons.. its fun and thank for the play list as well..
Hi Katie although both pictures are beautiful and striking I love the sharp colours and definitions of the diamond art club one. I would work on any one of them. Gorgeous.
I like both company's versions, but 1) I buy my Josephine Wall's DPs from Diamond Painting Deutschland, I like their look for this artist better and I love the pastel overload. 2) overall I love DAC's poured glue and scallops on the side of their canvasses better.
Wow. Good job. First I tought I like DAC more, it is clearer, but now I think DPD is more like the original. More aquarellic. Do you know what I mean?
The rendering is harder at DAC.
Both are beautiful
This has been a fantastic journey! Thank you so much for this video series!
Katie, thanks so much for sharing your wonderful journey with these two gorgeous paintings! I really do love them both for different reasons. Both are equally stunning! Can't wait to see the comparison with the third kit. Thanks for all your hard work and tenacity on completing both!😊
Wow Katie! What a fascinating journey! They are both stunning. I love the ethereal look of the DP Deutschland and I love the vibrant colors in the DAC. They are so different, but I love both. Thanks so much for sharing this with us! Bravo! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Well done Katie! Bravo! I so enjoyed this journey and appreciate all you did to bring this to all of us. Many thanks.
You did an amazing job with these two kits! I'n not into Josephine Wall but I've watched all the videos. It's really interesting to see how the rendering is different and so important. I can't imagine doing a kit with 220 colors, I'm a color blocking girl 😁 after this last video, I can say, I prefer diamond art club 's version. Thanks for sharing this project with us 👍
Wow amazing! You did a at job. Got to say DAC is my fav. Hope your able to do another one of these comparisons. Amazing play list
Thanks for doing this series. I like the DAC so much better from viewing distance than up close. I still wish there was a middle choice because I like parts of the piece better on one company, and other parts better on the other.
They both look lovely, the details are beautiful.
Wow! I love them both. There’s more richness and detail in DAC but I know the challenge of 275 colours makes the DPD version a different experience completely. We’ll done Katie. Thanks for sharing. You have been so generous with your time and it’s a great comparison. I’m sad it’s over 🥲
Awesome job on this series! Seriously, that's a lot of work and you did such a great job comparing both. I think the DPD looks closer to the original artwork, but I think I'd rather complete the DAC because I like the contrast and the emphasis on the details. Plus it looks like a lot less confetti than DPD. I agree, it's totally up to the person diamond painting to what they prefer! Thanks again for all these videos!
You did such a fantastic job Katie! I have loved following this series and I hope you do another comparison series in the future because it is so helpful to see the vast differences between renderings. Both of them turned out absolutely beautiful!
I love both renderings. Personally I will never do a painting with 200 plus colors. I appreciate you doing this. What a fun series this has been. Thank you for the content.
I think a lot depends on where the painting would hang and the look you would be going for... in a vibrant room the DAC would still stand out but if going for a relaxing atmosphere the DAD would be the one to go for. Well done for all the work you have put into these large paintings.... I honestly don't think I could even do two smaller paintings twice 😁 Thank you 💚
Thank you so much for all your work on these paintings! As you said it is a personal preference and in each video my eye was always drawn to DAC painting, for the colors and clarity. I had considered a DPD, but was always put off by the number of colors but this just confirms my choice of staying with the DAC. This was so helpful, and very much appreciated.
Amazing job. I have enjoyed the ride.
Fantastic series, I have enjoyed this comparison. My favorite has been DPD due to the soft blend but odd enough in terms of the overall product I love DAC because I love being able to see the details.
I am so thankful for this video. Jo Wall art is no longer available on DAC and I was considering the Deutschland option, but it just doesn't speak to me. Thank you for helping me in my decision not to purchase. I will just have to be faster when making a decision to purchase!
This was the canvas that brought me to your channel, and after seeing it completed I will say I prefer the DAC with the exception of the water rendering in the upper left hand corner that is the only portion I prefer the DPD version. Thank you, and seeing this canvas is what made me buy it after seeing section 2 completed. Thank you for your hard work and diligence
Beautiful! Thanks Katie! 💜
This is just awesome. Both versions are exceptional. I like her face and hand in the softer version but like the surrounding background in the DAC version. Choosing just one I would probably go with DAC version. I hope the Uniquely Down Under version gives a middle road of the two. Thank you for this “journey” and your time in completing both. Peace and love abide with you and yours 💕
Hi Katie, thank you so much for this amazing comparison project that you shared with us!! Absolutely beautiful. I am presently working on DAC’s Spirit Of Flight and I’m enjoying it very much. Take care of your beautiful self!! 💜 Dawn
This series has been fascinating, my taste goes toward DAC. I think it would look better on a wall. Kudos to you for doing this comparison! Thank you. 🍁🍂🌾🌾🍂🍁🍁🍂🌾
First of all, thanks so much for taking us along your journey with this amazing project!! What a gift you have given the diamond painting community with this comparison series. I think you've taught all of us, including these companies, more about the impact of rendering in diamond painting form. I thought, until now, my preference was going to be the DAC version because I tend to gravitate towards vivid colors and high contrast. To my surprise, I adore the subtle rendering and softer color palette of the DPD version!! That said, which one would I want to work on... definitely DAC 😂...Bravo 👏
This series has been incredible!! So much hard work you’ve put it and it hasn’t been waisted on me. I prefer the contrast in the DAC kit, personally, though they are both beautiful in different ways.
You have inspired me to do a comparison series next year with two of the same kit from Uniquely Yours Down Under. One is poured glue with minimal colors, the other is double sided adhesive with many colors. 🤗
~ Kel
I have the DAC one in my stash to do and I can’t wait to do it now!!
I’m sorry but over 80 colours would seriously be too traumatising - such a huge project to do one of these let alone 2 so I’m soooo impressed with what u have done, great job!
Good job. I really enjoyed your efforts.
Well done Katie! I love the hair, and the bottom right definition in DAC but the softness of DPD is lovely! I have a DAC JW and now I want a DPD JW too!!!
From a diamond painting perspective I prefer DAC. A lot less confetti, poured glue and the image is clearer and I think would be more fun to work on. I do like the rendering of the waves in the DPD better though.
I can’t tell you how happy I am for you!! THEY ARE SO PRETTYYYYY! ❤️
LOVED THIS VIDEO !! LOVE THE DAC PAINTING!!🌟🌟🥰🥰
Great job Katie! I’ve watched the entire series and it has been truly a fun experience. I must say that I prefer the Diamond Painting Deutschland rendering. At viewing distance it more closely resembles the original artwork in my opinion. I’ve just received the “Crystal of Enchantment” from DPDeutschland in square drills ( that’s all I do) and I’m excited to start on it. I love a challenge and I’m not intimidated by the number of colors. Thanks for your very hard work on this comparison video! 💖
Love DAC bright colors both beautiful. I'm new to DP so maybe when I get alittle bit better at it.
I love them all ty for letting me join your new group love love love all your video's your a awesome lady
If I were to choose overall, I would probably pic the DAC version. Both are stunning and I'm still in the in-between camp. If they could combine and come up with the middle, it would be great. 🙂
Thanks for showing this! So interesting!
Very nice!!! At work
Love this series! I have the DAC version but there are a few colors I might change after seeing both finished paintings. Like the sky around the birds and a few in the waves. You did such an amazing job! Thank you so much for doing this 💖💎
First and foremost. Hats off to you for your amazing job on both canvases. You are my DP She-ro. I have to agree with you and the others that both had their own merits. I was a bit disappointed that for all the colors used by DPD that there was not more sharpness that appears in the original art work. I almost feel like DAC is over focused and DPD was under focused especially with the birds to the right and butterflies to the left. But again kudos to you and I can’t wait see what’s next.
The DAC version is definitely on my wishlist and I will buy it sometimes next year
Love both but DAC is my choice. Thanks for sharing this with us 💜💜
This has been a fab comparison. Personally I love the DAC version most and I am waiting for Aries to come in to do as my first JW. Thank you so much for sharing and I look forward to the dekitting! X
Yay!! Have really enjoyed following along with this project. Thanks for doing this comparison so we don’t have to. Cuz dang that’s a lot of work! Curious, will you be displaying either of these in your house?
I'm not planning to, no - I don't think I have a wall big enough for it, really 😅
I love them both! It all depend on the purpose, i e who I was giving it to or where I was hanging it as far as deciding which one I want. I can't wait to see the UYDO one.
OMG what a difference. I love DAC so much better. Colors, clearness and just overall stunning. I do see a little that I like on the germany one the watercolor effect.. but overall love the DAC I do love bright colors so that's why.... Thanks so much for doing this study. That's a lot of time and I personally would be bored doing two of the same.. Thanks for much for the video.
DPD in every way except for the double sided adhesive. I love the more muted, water colour look you get from using more colours.
They are both beautiful. I like the DAC a little more.
Ok so I have really enjoyed this comparison. Thanks for taking the time.
So I was pretty certain that the DAC version was going to be my favourite. Right up until you showed the normal viewing distance pictures. Then I thought hmmmm actually I quite like the DPD version. Up close I like DAC, from far away I like DPD.
Wow, I actually prefer the DAC version! I feel like some details got lost in the DPD version. The only thing I don’t love about the DAC is her face and the blue in front of the face. I wish they had softened that area a little and used a few more colors in the blue space. Otherwise it’s perfect! 💜
Amazing job! Both came out nicely. As you said, I wish there was an in-between. DAC colors are so stark compared to the original painting and some of the dark outlining takes away from the softness as well. On the other hand, DPD would benefit from going through and cleaning up some of the computer rendering as some of the picture gets muddled with so many colors and no definition. Anxiously await what the Uniquely Yours rendering to see what they do with it.
I think I like DPD better. It’s better at a distance. I thought I was going to be DAC because of more detail but in the end I changed my mind. They are both beautiful though and you did a great job!
Wow… I’m also firmly in the camp of wishing I could combine aspects of both (and maybe make my own tweaks). The woman’s face and arm, as well as most of the sky in front of her, I think we’re done better by DPD. I also preferred that they stuck closer to the original dimensions. The dimensions weren’t so different that messing with the perspective was worth that change by DAC. However, the single bird in the foreground in front of the woman, her hair, and almost everything behind her I thought was much better in the DAC version. I do wish the blues in the sky and face were closer to the original… both companies’ renderings look more teal blue to me than the original artwork. Here’s hoping the Australian version you mentioned ends up being the best of both worlds… and still available for purchase once you have time to do that one.
Hey Katie 😁. WOW!! Your comparison has been EPIC !! I have so enjoyed this entire process and wished I could work on them simultaneously with you!! I have both the DAC and UYDU versions and I can't wait to do my own comparison between those two companies!! I can't believe how fast you completed this comparison! Well, thanks so much for including us in your journey! It seemed at the end of this video where you had 4 pictures on screen (both companies on top and both original artwork pics below their respective canvases), that the bottom 2 pictures were mistakenly swapped... Please let me know if they're correctly placed because I'm really confused, lol !! Thanks again for your dedication and hard work completing this project! I can really appreciate how time consuming this must have been and, as thorough as you were, you finished in record time!! I look forward to your next project and videos, Katie 🤗💎💎🧡🖤🧡🖤. xx Cynthia
Hi there! I double-checked, and the photos and their labels are correct ☺️
I like them both they are amazing. I said I would never do such a large kits the Deutsche one (never say never right) but I went to their website and I found two I want to do. Both over 250 colors each yes they both are zodiac sign. I am one sign with a lot of tendencies of the other. I am thinking about buying both of them & do them separately throughout all of next year. I think that is going to be my big project for next year. A lot of me deciding to do one is because of watching these videos of you completing them. So thank you. Sorry this comment is so long.
Excellent series!!!! I would love to see the 3rd version from UYDU added to the mix! I know it will be closer to the DPD version but perhaps a bit more where it was slightly lacking on DPD. Finding that happy medium would be "just right" as with the 3 bears!! 🐻 🐻❄ 🐻 Artistically DPD is closer to J.W. version. Have you considered sending the link to J. W. ?? I think she would truly love this!! Maybe after the UYDU is added?? Just a thought and something to add like in a short interview with her?? 😉😉💎💎💎
Thanks for the video, I was really tempted to buy one of DPD Josephine Wall painting precisely because the insane amount of colours but I think I’ll pass on that, it doesn’t look that great and you can’t really see there’s over 150 colours in there, you saved me lots of money spent on a purchase that I would have been disappointed with, so thanks s lot!
I was sure with so many colors I would like the DPD painting more, but I actually like DAC’s version much better! It is just a bit too stark, but I gotta give DAC the blue ribbon on this one!
I have loved watching this series. I am curious if you are going to continue this series with another comparison from Uniquely Yours Down Under and a HAED blank canvas following the same column comparisons?
I'm planning to do the UYDU version but I don't think I'll be able to swing doing the HAED blank canvas version too 😅
Well done! Congrats on the finish. I like both . . .but my eyes just seem to really be drawn to DAC's version. I would love to see the UYDU one. But, I don't think I could work on this canvas twice let alone 3 times.
Not even close for me, DAC for me is the clear winner. I prefer their more defined version and their coloring. So much better in my opinion. But like you said, it’s all about personal preference. 😊
I'm curious if you ever got the other one from Australia and how it compares. I've looked and can't find it.
Thank you for doing this. For me I think that for a general look DAC is more accurate in the color choosing and definition. But the face is completely different from the original artwork. Is beautiful but not the original. As for color goes her hand is more accurate in DAC. But also I think both companies didn't achieve the color of the skin. They did it brighter and is more subdued in the original artwork. Also I don't like the hair in Diamond Deutschland is too blurry. I think I prefer the DAC more
DAC all the way! Love your channel, just discovered and subscribed. Thank you!
I'm working on this now(dac)! It's my 1st Josephine Wall. Personally idk if I could do 200+ colors, I'm not a fan of color changing lol. I'm so glad you did this, thank you! How long did it take to complete both?
I worked on these over the course of 3-4 months, with a number of breaks! I wish I’d kept track of the number of hours, but it was… a lot, haha!
@@DiamondsandWashi thanks for replying! I can only imagine. Tracking hours is hard. I tried it & messed up in the very beginning 😆 then decided it wasn't worth it if it wasn't accurate
I really don't like many parts of the DAC.. Thought I would want to get Josephine Wall from them but I guess I'll use DPD in spite of the many colors. I fell like DPD is closer to the original art. After I noticed the wings at the ears and that one wing does not touch the ear in the DAC I knew I would not get that version.
Computer rendering I love hands down. I don’t like the hand charting at all. I look at the DAC one and I don’t see Josephine Wall at all, even though it’s one of her art work. You can see how obvious each line is hand charted. The DP Deutschland, I love how it hold true to Josephine Wall. It’s more realistic instead of how cartoonish and 2 dimensional it looks with DAC. The computerized version is more realistic looking and more like looking at a photo. Kudos on working on both of them. I’m working on a Josephine Wall from DP Deutschland like now and it’s a lot of work but it’s worth it.
I think diamond art clubs looks more crisp and brighter colors
loved following
I wish that dpd's image had the intensity of colour of dac's one, especially when they were using as many colours as they were. Both images are beautiful but the lack of colour intensity in dpd's was a bit disappointing.
My opinion hasn't really changed now that they are both finished both have their pros and cons. But if I had to choose I would take DAC hands down!
Both paintings are beautiful. I do favor the DAC. I can't imagine the work you put into them. If you do another comparison video,I would love to see you do one with round drill paintings.
I don't like DSA at all however, I hate how DAC totally changes the look and feel from the original artwork. I can't personally understand why DAC, who hand charts, can't seem to stay even remotely true to the original art when it's a watercolor piece. Their colors are darker and the images become more crisp and don't flow nicely.
Thank you so much for doing and sharing this process!
I do like DAC, they just don't remain true to the original pieces and it bothers me most on watercolors.
Do you know which one Josephine Wall prefers? I'd be interested to see what she has to say about the renderings, since it's her artwork.
I'm not sure! I'd be interested to know, too!
I am very torn. I wish I could take aspects from both and combine them. I don't know what to say. The DPD would probably drive me insane with confetti. Both have great attributes. I do wish that one was closer to the original. The DPD is almost too washed out. It almost looks like a tapestry. Which is still very beautiful. I have issues with how much they changed the face on the DAC. I wish both companies would consider some revisions. You are amazing for completing both of these kits in such a short time. I am excited to see the third version. I would totally understand if it takes awhile for you to want to complete that one. Thank you for sharing!
DAC wins for me. Love the face and hair. She does have a big man hand (no offense-mine are like that) but that’s in the original artwork.
My canvas is from Uniquely Yours Down Under I think it is slightly better than Diamond Art as it is a bit softer
I still like DAC better. The crisp edges and colors are more satisfying to me. I love DPD's softer face it's prettier. But the hair is less satisfying in DPD's picture. And i love the animals as represented by DAC. I'll take the DAC.
I have to change my original opinion early on in this series and say the DPD one looks much nicer. I don’t think the bold DAC colors look so good after all.
I prefer the German one dac seems to make the hands huge when they should more smaller and the face and neck are not very nice with bright blue drills I agree they should be lighter the German one looks more natural on the wall the dac one is too colourful they should have had used more pastel colours and more colours due to the size of it
wow！finally！
I dislike the diamond art club version so much. I don't believe this imagine should be so lined and bold 😑