Theology and Sectarianism
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 тра 2023
- I was shocked to discover just how deeply sectarianism has penetrated into all theological schools. Sectarianism is the leading cause of Muslim backwardness.
English UA-cam Channel:
/ taimurrahman1975
Instagram: / taimur_laal
Twitter: / taimur_laal
Sir, the concerns you have are similar to that of mine. You highlighted them in your UA-cam channel; I do it in my friends circle. I, most of the time, find myself unable to convince people. These ideas, propagated by Fatwas, are so well-entrenched in people's minds that they are not even ready to hear the other side of the story. How come in such an environment one can convince them? I am looking for a solution to this issue. I have very high hopes that you will definitely chart a plan by which we combinely counter the issue.
Generations of ignorance and brain washing has had its effects.
There’s no solution in our lifetime. Our next generation will be different from us InshaAllah. Things will be different after at least 30 yrs
Most relegion are idiotic to believe and Orthodox it doesnt free your mind but bind it with limited holy books mainly in islam cauz it doesn't got evolved like Christians and Judaism did till now !! Idea of relegion just limit your mind to one thing people should be fluid take idea from everyone and make best out of it but abrahmic relegion made this impossible to happen especially islam
Great lecture. You proved engineer Muhammad Ali mirza right.
Stay safe sir , you are getting into the danger zone
Indians need not lecture us about what we can or cannot say. Go take care of manipur
@@Nat-Con Every thing all Right brother..
سر ایک بار پھر آپکی علمی کاوش اور محنت کو سلام کرے گے ❤
@@Nat-Con it's been taking care of !! There is not pakistani army there😂😂😂
@@Nat-Con you endorse what Sir is saying.... Excellent
great job sir...please continue making such useful videos❤
Brave hero, you are, sir. putting your life at stake by unfolding such truths that we needed to hear ❤
Love you❤🎉
Stay safe Sir you are actually telling the truth.❤️
Sir, it's the biggest tragedy in Pakistan. First, they passed a resolution of blasphemy of Sahaba, and later on, getting an opportunity, they themselves hung objectionable stuff against sahaba on the dog's neck. And blamed the opponents. Luckily, the investigation report showed that they themselves were involved in that conspiracy. Still, we think democracy will work in our society. These 5 years, temporary politicians are puppets and shouldn't have any power. Establishment and army are fine for our society. Regarding sectarian, my opinion is like that; we have got Islam through two different ways: one through politician/darbari system/raaja system/kingdoms/monarchy, another through suppressed group of people, who always were killed or poisoned by the monarch for showing the real face of Islam.
Dr Sb, our education and social system encourage blind faith in religious scholars and on top of it our education system don’t encourage critical thinking
Great lecture ❤ stay bless and safe ❤
Actually the reason for sectarianism in religion is quite simple, the moment u start using ur intellect to understand something it will cause bifurcation and divide bcz our intellect is essentially a cutting instrument which we use to dissect things in order to analyse them.
Dear Taimur Sahib, kindly speak about the importance of religion in modern times (current and future) for commoners. Thanks in anticipation.
आपके विचारों को हिंदुस्तान मे भी समझा जा रहा है❤❤
Sir i have a request for you, kindly make playlists on consciousness, reality and Evolution (i have watched a video of yours on Evolution but it's not satisfying, So, kindly make a detailed playlist on it with both scientific and religious explanation and in the end, always give your own opinion to it.)
Great massage ❤
Everyone and everybody wants Peace, Justice and Prosperity in the country and whoever brings it is welcome and my vote is for them
Great job Sir. stay safe
Very good lecture ❤
AOA
Sir I am interested in philosophy kindly suggest me some books.
AOA sir g love you❤❤. Allah lambe Omar de❤❤
This is extremely sad and disturbing, agony is main stream political parties never made any serious effort to stop it
❤ great lecture
You raised a very good and valid question…… What is the definition of a ‘ Muslim’ ?
Very good and meaningful clip Taimoor sahab hope your audience understand your take
What is the reason for this dangerous confusion yesterday a pakistani Aalim Mufti fazal hamdard has posted an important video in which he proves how Entire Deen was changed within 25 years of Prophetic Wafat
What we have today are actually ISOMERS of Islam carefully crafted to condition muslims into believing theirs is the right version
its simply because violence was legitimized before his death by guess whom?
@Syedbakeruddin Bekar You are assuming in this context or in general that there was and is a true path! May be it might be just fable to begin with!
The speech given is showing ground reality of religion. The religion is being used for making foolish to the poor and making clever to rulers.
Religion is a tool to manipulate innocent people,
That's why Technology, Program is not equal to Religion, or conservative thinking,
Pakistan will make progress when it's declared as Pure secular state,
sir we need you, please keep yourself out of things which could lead you into a risky situation. I don't think the people will understand what you are trying to explain to them. They have closed their eyes and ears. I'm optimistic but I don't think it's an approach that can be successful especially here in this country. Thank you for sharing the revealing facts tho.
سب حوالے کمنٹ باکس میں لکھ دیں اگر ہو سکے۔ بہترین تحقیق
38:29 agreed with you Sir…..only those countries can develop which can adopt scientific reasoning……..
You are great 👍
Thank you.
enlightening
Sir i appreciate your work but through one or two fatwas from book concluding that this is believe of that sect is wrong and by doing this you are distorting the picture of reality. Given the complexity and diversity of religious sects, it is crucial to exercise caution when drawing conclusions based on limited information. It would be prudent to delve deeper into the theological perspectives and scholarly discourses of the sect in question before making definitive judgments about their beliefs.Engaging in comprehensive research and dialogue with scholars from different sects can help foster a more accurate understanding of their beliefs and practices. This approach ensures a fair and nuanced assessment of diverse religious perspectives while avoiding misconceptions or misrepresentations.
فرقہ واریت کینسر ہے اور کینسر لاعلاج ہے.
اس سب کے باوجود اگر ہم مسلمان ہیں تو یہ الله - خالق کا خاص احسان ہے.
دل سے الله اور رسول کو مانیں یہی اسلام ہے یہی ایمان ہے (کسی فرقے اور کسی شخصیت کا شکار نہ بنیں.)
All the best👍
Indeed.
You can't apply the rules of book from 1400 yrs ago it's common sense ya respect is there for prophet but many ideas are outdated just pick which are amazing and leave the rest!! That's how society evolve with time !! And i hope it changes with time!! I can see hope in middle East let's see what happen to Pakistan
The glorious period of Islamic science and philosophy occurred in lands where there were greek and roman colonies. It was natural to fear "infection" from these defeated civilizations and take steps to prevent it.
Can Islamic countries in Africa and in Southeast Asia justifiably claim credit for the thoughts of the Mu’tazilites? It would be like catholics in India feeling proud of the Sistine Chapel or the great cathedrals of Europe or its great universities.
Grt video
Ap par bhi fatwa aane waala kuch dino mein, naala bandh lein :D
Jokes aside, quite an enlightening message, thanks for sharing.
Why we are so backward is very clear…… we have made unimportant things very important and very important things unimportant….. like modern logical education….😢
You r right sir
If I'm not wrong
The four school of thoughts
Hanfi,Shafi,hanbali,Maliki accept each other and these make the clear majority of ummah
Shia are also a considerable amount. Fiqh e Jaffaria.
Do not tell lies regarding lynching in India. Very few cases was there justice is there to take care of it. Now it is informed to police.
Aulad-e-Rasool (SAWW) k sath jo hua kash ap is baat ka bhi zikr karte...Khud Rasoolullah (SAWW) ko zehr dia gaya aur phir 11 naslon tak qatal kia jata raha...aur phir ye silsila aaj bhi jari hai...
Baqi in mein se boht aise hain jinho ne khud doosron per fatway lagaye thay aur baaz to genocide mein involve bhi rahe hain...
Proud to be Muslim & Pakistani No Firqawariat!
I agree with most of your ideas Dr. Sahab and I like that you're trying to inculcate critical thinking and reasoning among the masses through your work. However, I disagree with your black and white comparison of science and theology, science being accepting and evolving while theology being frozen in time. If u look deeply into how theology develops and how different sects emerge, you'll see that it's very much rooted in the historical context and a product of its time. It's not like someday someone gets up and just comes up with a new sect or a different theology. Theology is very dynamic and evolves with time too. I'm sure you understand that already but I disagree with the way you did the comparison.
Peace.
Theology's claim about itself is that it is a given. A fixed solution valid for all times.
In most cases yes but I'd be a little hesitant to make a generalization. In many cases People/communities are very accepting and understanding of the idea of evolution of theology and having multiple interpretations. You would find people and communities who think it's necessary for theology to evolve according to the time and context so that it can be relevant and provides updated guidance. I think your idea fits/represents a certain fundamentalist thinking among many religions around the world who think theology is frozen in time and try to apply certain things from the past to the present anachronisticicallly. But I think I do understand what you're trying to say.
Peace.
@@nvd_ub Taimur is right. Read the book, it starts with "this is the final word and a word from the god". At this point it's just question of interepetation. And often interpretation done by those in power will be accepted or gets accepted! A brittle material (one who has decided the only state it would live in) cant bend and form into something else. Thats the case here. The only way is to melt it totally and create a new alloy.
@@Taimur_LaalYou can't apply the rules of book from 1400 yrs ago it's common sense ya respect is there for prophet but many ideas are outdated just pick which are amazing and leave the rest!! That's how society evolve with time !! And i hope it changes with time!! I can see hope in middle East let's see what happen to Pakistan
That’s why I stay away from religion… it’s your personal choice and believe whatever you want to believe in BUT please keep it to yourself……for God’s sake……🙏
❤❤❤
M Ali Mirza burger version
By the way, respect from Russia
True. 💯
Sir, you should check out Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza.
Agree
Sir hmaray dilo ma sy rusool or rab ki sach i mohabbat khatm kr k in firqo ki dali gae h jis din nabi pak SAW or Allah ki haqeeqi muhabat paida hoge hm seedhy rasty py aa jain gay or isi k sth hm nature sy sawal kr sakain gy that is adoption of scientific approach
As long as there is supposed to be one truth and only one muslims will keep fighting to prove that their version is true. It's never gonna end.
You can't apply the rules of book from 1400 yrs ago it's common sense ya respect is there for prophet but many ideas are outdated just pick which are amazing and leave the rest!! That's how society evolve with time !! And i hope it changes with time!! I can see hope in middle East let's see what happen to Pakistan
Well these all ideas if approached in its true essence it has such flexibility to apply any dimensions and in any field. 2ndly I just pointed on the sects system that subcontinent scholars has made more than sunnah nd quran
I think, there is a way to achieve peace in the world... if, we could get all the mullahs from the world and add them to a committee and keep sending them bizarre questions to issue fatwas on... like can mickey mouse marry olive oyl from popeye's or should teletubbies grow beardd and wear hats, etc. and when each of them had expressed their opinions and issued their fatwas... you get it printed and show it to them and then take it away and throw it down the well... and repeat...
ua-cam.com/video/o0-1-wA8ANk/v-deo.html
Mufti fazal hamdard on Deeni Engineering
Never ever talk about religion in Pakistan as if you're talking to educated people, people that are tolerant. In fact, never give your point of you and give disclaimers after and before each statement you make.
Bada tang hai nazeriya, deen nahee sambalata humsay,
Kitab to padee, par samza khak kuch nahee,
Akharat ke chinta youn huyee, dushman samaz liya insan ko,
Khoon ke youn lage talab, uppar wala ko khoonee banadiya,
Youn padee kitab ke munnfic ban gaya,
Abb bharta hu daam deen ka,
Jaisa janta hu sab kuch paygambaro say jiyada....
Allah bless you
These Fatwas are so funny 😂 😂😂
Main tu level of depth par heran ho k kis kis chez par itna ghaur kia gaya hay or fatwa lagaya gaya hay
I am not part of any sect but we know that ahle hadees were launched to destroy ottoman empire and barelvi sect was established to spread hatred about freedom fighters and deobandi was a freedom movement but after sometime america changed thier direction and used them as a weapon against Soviet Union
This is an interesting perspective that requires further exploration.
Muslim had best past bcoz that time no internet to expose them... 😂 today we get to know every thing
Every religion had same History
Even Hindus exist who think Raavan was right
Extremist hindus specially in India are famous for doing some very....... u know😄
By the way this Guy is an athiest and Many of the historic facts he told are wrong.
He is a kind of guy who speak Half Truth. He will speak some facts and impress the listener and then some distorted history in between
I accept that there is extremism in Pak which is unacceptable but I also think India is in front of us in this regard;
نہ میں وہابی، نہ میں بابی
میں ہوں مسلم علمی کتابی۔
Litterate ya illiterate ho India ke bare me pakio knowledge [information] bahut kam hai....🙏🙏🙏🙏
Din rat shalman sahrukh Amir ka movie dekhte hai fir bhi muslim ka India me genocide ho raha hai....🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
You can't apply the rules of book from 1400 yrs ago it's common sense ya respect is there for prophet but many ideas are outdated just pick which are amazing and leave the rest!! That's how society evolve with time !! And i hope it changes with time!! I can see hope in middle East let's see what happen to Pakistan
Bilkul vesay hi Jesay Indians ko Lagta ha K Saara Terrorism Pak ker raha ha
@@soundofsuccess7152 TTP, Taliban and Afghani to Jwab de raha hai.....
@@Sk-cr2bl
RSS
Or even Modi at national level Terrorism ker rhay hain Muslims or Sikho even Christians k Khilaaf
TTP Taliban Vagera America ki trf se bnaye gaye Brain wasjed Group hain
Inhay kon theek kehta ha?
O yaar konsa ap taraki kr gay ho jo apko fikar lag gai hai k agar islami nizam walay aye to ye ho ga vo ga... Ab to ap log ho na kr lo taraki
Islam and science......🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂
Comparing religious book with science is like comparing hitler to jesus😂😂😂
Assalam o alikum Sir,
Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza ki videos ko dekna shoro karian.
Tamam firqon ki dukany band kardi hai.
you sound like engr ali mirza
❤❤❤😂
Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza ki tarah bol rahy ho ap bhi
sir please do not discuss these topics. If you want to see the result, have a look at engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza sab.
nicely said
this is ure best presentation ever
Sir jee, you are venturing into treacherous territory. Please exercise caution and be mindful of the risks involved.