Different Size Winter Tires and Rims

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 вер 2024
  • Can you use different size tires and rims for the winter?

КОМЕНТАРІ • 101

  • @bobbydigital8243
    @bobbydigital8243 17 днів тому +1

    Thank you for this information for years. I’ve been driving the same size winter tires to my summer tires and every winter I’ve always got stuck in the snow.

  • @marimavu
    @marimavu Рік тому

    Thanks big fella u just saved me lots of hustle! I have 17 for my Malibu, found 16’ steelies on Marketplace, will fit it with studded winter tires and hopefully survive this Saskatoon winters

  • @PreludeSon
    @PreludeSon 6 років тому +6

    Excellent! This is what I'm hoping to see. Thanks for the post my friend.

  • @gdstruthers
    @gdstruthers 5 років тому +2

    Rob thanks for taking the time to post the video!

  • @Dupedupedean
    @Dupedupedean Рік тому

    Thanks for this video. I have been looking for someone addressing downsizing for the winter tire. I have 20 inch all season and the dealership advised that I go for the 18 inch for the winter tire. I wasn't sure what to make of it, until I stumbled across your video. Thanks a lot!

  • @billseiler4952
    @billseiler4952 3 роки тому +1

    Many people will laugh at snow tires but they are great in the winter. Thanks for sharing

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  3 роки тому

      Yes they make a huge difference! Thanks for your comment!
      Cheers!
      Rob

  • @richardpc7097
    @richardpc7097 3 роки тому +1

    Hello, it seems I’m a little late to the discussion but your spot on. I have a Honda Accord Sport 2014 and with a good deal I’m looking at over $800 for a set of snow tires not including rims (235/45R18). I bought snow tires with a smaller rim and they work great (205/65R16). I tried to order tires from Costco and they won’t put them on since they aren’t what’s on there now. I’ll probably just have my mechanic order some and have him swap out old snow tires with new since it’s time for a change. Helpful video. Thank you!

  • @trevorstolz8580
    @trevorstolz8580 2 роки тому +2

    There is another reason steel rims are far superior to "performance rims". I live in northern Canada where we can get six inches of snow overnight. What happens with alloy rims is that you get a spoonful of snow in the rim and this unbalances the tire. The part of the rim that covers the interior space between the sides of the tire is parallel to the road. Centrifugal force just makes the snow, ice and/or mud more and more compact. If it gets above freezing, the ice melts and the mud remains. The whole car shakes and the only solution is to go to a car wash or try and scrape the mud out of the rim.
    The steel rims are somewhat more bowl shaped. Centrifugal force throws the snow out of the rim constantly. The wheel doesn't get unbalanced. I put the best winter tires on my vehicle that money can buy so even with a front wheel drive, I can drive through almost anything. However, when the wheel gets unbalanced because the depth of the snow is deep than the height of the side of the tire, it gets in the rim. I ONLY use steel rims for winter tires. They are far better "performance" rims.

  • @johngaudet6316
    @johngaudet6316 6 років тому

    Yes your so right about the price savings down sizing winter tires and rims, another plus is that a higher profile tire in winter is better going over frost heaves or really bumpy roads less chance of rim and tire damage. I down size from low profiles to studded winters. Its amazing the difference !

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  6 років тому

      You are totally right! Unfortunately studded tires are illegal in Ontario. Sad but true. Thanks for your comment!
      Cheers!
      Rob

  • @rulinghabs
    @rulinghabs 4 роки тому

    I have a 2019 Honda Accord Touring 2.0 with 19 inch rims. I live in Vancouver and thought I could live on all seasons. No chance. It snowed the other day and my car is useless. I am glad I saw this. I have no problem downsizing to save money.

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  4 роки тому

      Exactly! How do you like the Accord? It's a nice looking car and that 2L Turbo must Rock!

    • @rulinghabs
      @rulinghabs 4 роки тому

      Rob's Garage Woodworking car has a ton of bells and whistles. Very happy with it. I would say it is more quick than fast. Does have a noticeable lag unless it is in sports mode. Great car though. Had an Acura before.

  • @jakegerrior7066
    @jakegerrior7066 Рік тому +1

    My mum has the same thing with the 2015 civic touring and she had 17 inch rims for summer and for winter she had 15 inch

  • @serious_in_seattle6917
    @serious_in_seattle6917 2 роки тому +1

    Thanks. This is good information. I just bought a gently used 2021 Corolla XSE with low profile tires. A lot of people simply pay to have their regular tires swapped with winter tires on the same rims each fall and spring. here in the Seattle area. I prefer to buy winter tires already mounted on rims so I can switch them easily myself. Since TPMS sensors are required that increases the cost substantially, unfortunately. Anyway, I need to find steel rims in 15 or 16 inch sizes that fit properly on my Corolla and get winter tires next fall that provide a near identical total diameter. I suspected that what you suggest was possible but it has been difficult finding the information. It seems that tire stores want people to come back twice each year to have tires mounted. That’s a pain in the butt.

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  2 роки тому +1

      Yeah it's next to impossible to get help from tire places. Try to find a young guy starting out of his garage or off a farm. I use tire size calculators for reference all the time. Here is a link to one. www.calculator.net/tire-size-calculator.html

    • @serious_in_seattle6917
      @serious_in_seattle6917 2 роки тому

      @@robsgaragewoodworkin thanks for the calculator link.

    • @HONDAKING1000
      @HONDAKING1000 Рік тому

      Im The same boat with my corolla XSE, Curious what tires and rims you ended up getting for the winter ? Any Info would be much appreciated !:)

  • @diegoeleazar9154
    @diegoeleazar9154 5 років тому +2

    Automotive industries always try to grab your money. Thanks for advice!

  • @youtubehand
    @youtubehand 4 роки тому +1

    Bob, thanks for the video! I leased a suv with 275 35 R22 performance summer tires. The lease will end by December next year. I think it's still a good idea to install winter tires in Vancouver for safety reason and to purchase mint condition second hand winter tires makes more financial sense.
    I am torn between two options in the secondhand market: #1. 275 40 R22 winter tires set for $1200. #2. 20inch Rims +275 35 R20 winter tires set for $1800. (All listing prices). These options are still rather expensive. I also notice the first option will make the diameter of the vehicle 3.7% larger.
    My thoughts are: The first option will save me rim money in the short run, but may be difficult to resale when the lease ends. The second option is convinient and may be easier to resale, but cost more up front.
    I wonder what would you suggest? Observations and advices are welcome! Thank you Bob.

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  4 роки тому

      Sorry for the late reply. Both are Crazy Expensive! I'm a big fan of tires on rims. That way you can change them yourself in the driveway in 1/2 hour vs. waiting for an appointment in the height of "tire season" and maybe weeks later than you wanted to wait. Or even worse, driving an expensive SUV on performance summer tires and ending up in the ditch. Hoping you find a great deal! Good Luck!
      Rob

  • @sunilgodson298
    @sunilgodson298 3 роки тому

    2155017 stock and for winter - 20565r15. 17 is for performance and 15 rim you will get more tire grip which is good for winter life and grip.. Good point.

  • @davidviner4932
    @davidviner4932 5 років тому

    I am having winter tyres fitted to my BMW convertible on Saturday, I’ve acquired a matching set of M Sport alloys for the new tyres so the car will look the same but drive ok under 7 degrees centigrade, I don’t want steel wheels with narrower tyres when I can keep it looking the way it should and the grip will still be excellent

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  5 років тому +2

      Wider tires tend to float in the snow and slush. But if you don't have too much of that in the winter where you are then I'd buy the sexy alloys too!
      Cheers!
      Rob

  • @RoomiesGarage
    @RoomiesGarage 6 років тому +2

    in this case..... seize does matter...cheers

  • @jinyu6514
    @jinyu6514 2 роки тому

    yeah it’s true, but if your driving on the highway 100+mph without snow, it’s too bouncy becaused of the height.. i prefer 205/55/16 or 215/55/16

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  2 роки тому

      Yeah they aren't quite performance handling but they perform much better in the snow.

  • @The_real_Toddington
    @The_real_Toddington 4 роки тому +1

    My 2011 civic takes 195 65 15, yesterday I bought snow tires that are 205 65 15. Hoping they aren't too big

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  4 роки тому

      LOL! That's pretty close though! Was that a mistake or a good deal?

    • @The_real_Toddington
      @The_real_Toddington 4 роки тому

      @@robsgaragewoodworkin yeah it was a mistake on my part, I bought second hand (almost new) so a little late to return. If it's too close I'll possibly sell. Thanks for the insight

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  4 роки тому +1

      @@The_real_Toddington Looked it up on tiresize.com/calculator/ and the circumference is 78.4in Vs 80in and width is 7.7in vs 8.1in so your speedometer might be off a bit but they will fit no problem.

    • @The_real_Toddington
      @The_real_Toddington 4 роки тому

      @@robsgaragewoodworkin Good to hear Appreciate you looking up the math!

  • @cheezblood10
    @cheezblood10 16 днів тому

    Thanks for the info
    Downsize from 20" to 17?
    That too much of a difference

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  16 днів тому

      @@cheezblood10 no you can totally do that. Get the same overall height the same with a smaller rim. Look up a tire calculator to find the equivalent size.

    • @cheezblood10
      @cheezblood10 16 днів тому

      @@robsgaragewoodworkin
      Thanks again,u take care

  • @danielj9932
    @danielj9932 Рік тому

    Thank you❤

  • @rogerhudson9732
    @rogerhudson9732 5 років тому

    And don't drive as fast in winter.
    Don't forget the TPMS system needs to be set on the new steel rims.

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  5 років тому

      You are absolutely right! Many first generation TPMS cars needed wheel sensors but now most operate with the wheel speed sensors in the ABS system to monitor tire pressure. (they compare rotation speeds between tires)
      Thanks for your comment!
      Cheers!
      Rob

    • @hermaj33
      @hermaj33 4 роки тому

      How do you reset your TPMS system? Just put winter tires in Honda Accord 2014. Thanks and thanks for the explanation and the video

  • @Goatizgone
    @Goatizgone Рік тому

    As per books in need 235/40/19,please recommend me different size for my car

  • @tysondaniels6001
    @tysondaniels6001 3 роки тому

    Hi Rob, I was looking into winter tires for my wife’s suv with p255/65R 18 and found some nice winter’s on rims with the size 235/55 R17’s
    Was wondering if you think that’ll work for her vehicle? And thanks for sharing ur knowledge and definitely subscribed 👍🏾

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  3 роки тому

      So you just have to make sure the rims have the same bolt pattern and size and that the rims clear the brake caliper assembly. The size can be off a bit and it's best if you can get tires with the overall diameter the same so your speedometer is accurate. Here is a tire calculator and I have checked your tire sizes. They claim the difference in height is "dangerous". It's probably OK but it's a pretty big height difference. Your call. Good Luck on your search!
      tire-calc.com/#

  • @EduardoGac
    @EduardoGac 3 роки тому

    Excelent!
    I have a AWD Toyota Highlander
    Can I do that ?
    My current summer Rims are 19”
    Could I get a 17” rims with winter tires?

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  3 роки тому

      Yes. Just make sure the rims clear the brake assemblies. Look at tire sizes for the old highlanders or lower models. Chances are they will have 17" rim/tire combo with the same diameter as your new highlander's tires. Good Luck!
      Rob

  • @adamdj3271
    @adamdj3271 2 роки тому +1

    Hello Rob, Thank you for sharing. Just wanted to ask. I recently bought a 2nd hand 205/65/16's winter tires for my honda civic 2012. would it be suitable for this car because the one I'm currently using is 205/55/16's Thank you in advance!

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  2 роки тому

      Those are a little taller but they "should" be fine. Here is a link for further info. tiresize.com/comparison/

  • @Italianborn
    @Italianborn Рік тому

    I found 4 used rims with tire i want to buy, 225/60/r 18 …I’m not sure if they would fit ?!

  • @ziawalizada3184
    @ziawalizada3184 Рік тому

    Hello sir I have 3 the same shape tyre and one different shape but same size does it effect my car performs

  • @gpaz2439
    @gpaz2439 10 місяців тому

    Hello sir. i have 2017 highlander 2455519 tires with 19 inch rims. im looking for rims and tires for the winter but dont know what size. i need help

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  10 місяців тому +1

      Inside the driver door is the sticker with the recommended tire size. Also printed on the side of the tire. Here is a good website for further info
      www.calculator.net/tire-size-calculator.html

  • @manuelsalgado8510
    @manuelsalgado8510 Рік тому

    I have a utility trailer with 215/70R14 I’m having a hard time finding them, what Zia’s can I go to that would be easy to find in the future?

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  Рік тому

      I would go to a place that sold trailer tires and wheels and just swap the set. Or you could find a similar set of tires on rims in Kijiji or marketplace.

  • @patrickbass3118
    @patrickbass3118 2 роки тому

    Thanks for the info.
    Would it be ok to run a winter tire that ends up being around a half inch bigger/smaller overall?

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  2 роки тому

      Yes but it will make a slight difference in your actual speed vs what the speedometer says. Also depending on how your car checks tire pressure it can cause the tire pressure monitor system light to be on all the time.

  • @foff159
    @foff159 2 роки тому

    Is it ok to use those Honda rims you took off and add winter tires to them, Would they get damaged?

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  2 роки тому

      Yes, but it will cost more because they are a larger rim size and they are low profile tire. The new tire machines are much better and are far less likely to damage rims.

  • @randomrazr
    @randomrazr 3 роки тому

    is it worth getting alloys over steel rims

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  3 роки тому

      Up to you. Depends on how you want your car to look. I have winter steelies and my parents had to have stock alloys. If I had the money I'd get nice summer alloys and run stock alloys in the winter.
      Cheers!
      Rob

  • @greeneking77
    @greeneking77 3 роки тому

    Hi I have a civic 2010 that came w/ 16 " rims and 205 55 16 tires. I want to go down to 15" rims and 185 narrow tires for better fuel economy. I know my speedo will be off but would there be any other problems? Also what aspect ratio would I need on the 185s or does it matter? thanks for the video

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  3 роки тому

      I really don't think you will get better fuel economy but if you look at the tire and rim size for the older civics they all fit the newer civics and the overall height is very similar. Here is a link that can help you out. tiresize.com/calculator/

  • @McHughFilmCompany
    @McHughFilmCompany 4 роки тому

    Hey rob! Would 195/65R15 be too small for my 2016 civic? They came off a 2015 civic and was wondering if its possible to do that so I could save a few bucks.. Thanks!

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  4 роки тому

      Those are the same height and the rims will fit perfectly! Don't forget to get some Honda hubcaps to go with them...
      Cheers!
      Rob

    • @McHughFilmCompany
      @McHughFilmCompany 4 роки тому

      @@robsgaragewoodworkin Perfect! I just wanted to make sure it's safe to use since the only difference between mine and yours is the 10mm in width. Thanks again.

  • @muhammadkhan9773
    @muhammadkhan9773 10 місяців тому

    Hey need your advice
    I have civic 2019 with 215-55-16 inch rim
    Can I put 215-50-17 winter tire and 17”rims
    Please reply

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  10 місяців тому

      You can’t put a 17” tire on a 16” rim

    • @muhammadkhan9773
      @muhammadkhan9773 10 місяців тому

      @@robsgaragewoodworkin original size is 215/55/16
      So I want to change with 215/50/17
      Can I do that

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  10 місяців тому

      @@muhammadkhan9773 oh sorry I guess I read that wrong. Should be fine. Here is a tire calculator site to give you more details.
      tiresize.com/calculator/

    • @muhammadkhan9773
      @muhammadkhan9773 10 місяців тому

      @@robsgaragewoodworkin honestly just watched your video and though you are the right guy who can answer my question
      16 to 17 no issue right
      Some one says your car alignment get issue coz car set on 16” and you putting 17’’
      But you said no issue I can upgrade
      215/55/16 to 215/50/17
      Thank you 😊

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  10 місяців тому

      @@muhammadkhan9773 yeah it should be fine. The idea is to keep the aspect ratio the same or close. Use the tire calculator to compare.

  • @falconeye577
    @falconeye577 5 років тому

    Question
    I want to change the WHEELS and Tires on my 2017 F-150
    it came with 17 in factory wheels
    I want to put 20 or even 22 wheels on the rear, but keep the 17 in wheels on the front
    My Question is will the truck have any issues with this setup

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  5 років тому

      That's old school! If you change wheel size make sure they won't rub or bottom out on the box when fully loaded. This may change your speedometer reading. This was VERY popular in the 60's, 70's and early 80's.
      Have Fun!
      Cheers!
      Rob

    • @falconeye577
      @falconeye577 5 років тому

      Old School, Yup. I got my first car, a 66 Mustang, in the mid 70s, guess what I did to it
      I take it your telling me it will not have a major effect on the truck other than looks

  • @photoMorg
    @photoMorg 4 роки тому

    Hi Rob thanks for the video. I have a 2007 Honda Civic Coupe Rims 16x6.5 Tires P205/55R16 any suggestion on steel rims and wheel size I can get away with to save money. Thanks Paul

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  4 роки тому

      You can use the ones off the previous generation civics. 195/65R15 or even 185/75R14 *note* some tire shops will only sell you rims and tires size based on the cert. label on frame inside drivers door. Here is a tire calc. link tiresize.com/calculator/

  • @123danks
    @123danks 3 роки тому

    I’m thinking going down 2” on my rav 4.

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  3 роки тому

      You can use this website to find the right overall dimensions of the tire to keep your speedometer accurate tire-calc.com

    • @123danks
      @123danks 3 роки тому

      Rob's Garage Woodworking thanks

  • @m.m1048
    @m.m1048 5 років тому

    It dont come with 215/55/16?

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  5 років тому

      Stock tires are 215 50 R17 and the snow tire package from the dealer is 205 65 R15 on steel rims
      Cheers!
      Rob

  • @huzaifaq123
    @huzaifaq123 4 роки тому

    Hi Rob
    I have a Honda Civic Sport 2020 that are 235/40R18. Can I downsize for the winters to 215/50R17? I’ll be saving $300 Canadian . Will there be any issues?

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  4 роки тому +1

      The winter tire package that the dealer gave me was 15" steel rims and a tire size of 205/65R15. This gave me the same height as the stock performance summer tire but slightly narrower. It has higher sidewalls too. The smaller the rim the cheaper the tire generally. You will need new wheels if you get 215/50R17. I suggest always getting winter tires permanently mounted on their own rims so you can change your tires/wheels whenever you want free of charge. It's also much better for the tires not to be put on and taken off the rims every 6 months and you can save the look of your alloy rims for the summer. Your Civic will accept 205/65/R15 on 15" rims (circumference 80 width 8.1) as your stock tires have a circumference of 79.8 and width of 9.3. It's a 10th gen civic just like mine. Plus you save money on the tire/rim package and save money not having the tires removed and mounted every 6 months. The downfall is a slight performance decrease in cornering but huge performance increase in snow. Here is a tire calculator link tiresize.com/calculator/
      Happy Shopping!
      Rob

    • @huzaifaq123
      @huzaifaq123 4 роки тому

      Hi rob thanks for the response. I ended up buying 215/50R17 for my winter tires . I brought the Michelin X-Ice Xi3 For 542.92 from Canadian tire.It was on sale. I also brought steel rims for 247.92. My local tire shop can install for 80 plus tax.

  • @brendanH2O
    @brendanH2O 6 років тому

    Hey, thinking of getting downsized winter tires for my 2015 Genesis Sedan... they usually run all seasons 245/45/18. Would I be able to go to a smaller rim/tire package and it not effect the larger breaks the Genesis has 345mm? Thanks!

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  6 років тому +1

      You just have to clear the brakes with the inside of the rim. You should be able to go to a 15 or 16 inch rim. Just check the rim before you put tires on. Then get the same overall height of tire - a good tire shop can do this for you, or you can check online.
      Good Luck!
      Rob

    • @brendanH2O
      @brendanH2O 6 років тому

      Thanks :)

  • @micheleacegamer7730
    @micheleacegamer7730 5 років тому

    1000 $ for tiers?! Wtf are you driving a formula 1? That's way too much here in Europe you can get a really Good winter set tires for 1/4 of that

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  5 років тому +3

      Costs vary per country but I'll break it down for you.
      Tires $137.50 X 4 = $550
      Steel rims $60 X 4 = $240
      Installation $15 X 4 = 60
      Sub total $ 850
      X 13% tax = $960.50 TOTAL
      This is the Canadian cost. It's a better idea to permanently mount tires on rims for longer tire life, cost savings and convenience.

    • @micheleacegamer7730
      @micheleacegamer7730 5 років тому

      @@robsgaragewoodworkin well those numbers make more sense.
      2000$ for rims and tires seemed too much

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  5 років тому

      If you bought another set of the 17" factory rims they would be around $1000. If you bought the factory rim size snow tires (215 50 R17) the same brand tire is $205.00 each + $15 installation X 4 = $880 + tax = $994.00

  • @detmer87
    @detmer87 6 років тому

    @1:58
    1000 dollars for the tires?! that can't be in dollars, euro's or pounds :P

    • @robsgaragewoodworkin
      @robsgaragewoodworkin  6 років тому +2

      Canadian Channel = Canadian prices. 215 50 R17 for mid grade winter tire=$175 each, mounting cost=$15 each X 4 wheels X taxes = $858. For 205 65 R15 mid grade tire=$140, mounting=$15, steel winter wheel=$50 X4 X taxes =$926
      When you change tires 2X per year the cost is $135.60
      So if you use stock 215 50 R17 your first year price is $933.60 (initial tire price and install plus spring changeover back to summers) and every year after is 135.60 for tire changeover(2X per year)
      Yep, it's expensive here...
      Cheers!
      Rob