Electoral Bond Debate: Sitharaman Vs Chidambaram
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 бер 2024
- #nirmalasitharaman #pchidambaram #electoralbond #indiatodayconclave2024
In this riveting India Today Conclave 2024 session, Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman dismantles assumptions surrounding electoral bonds. She dissects the links between probe agency raids and these financial instruments, challenging prevailing narratives. Sitharaman candidly acknowledges imperfections in the system while defending its role in transparent party funding. Meanwhile, P. Chidambaram, Former Finance Minister, counters with allegations of “legalized bribery.” Witness this high-stakes face-off as two political heavyweights clash over electoral bonds’ legitimacy and accountability.
-----------------------
Thank You for watching! Do not forget to Like | Comment | Share
-----------------------
About the channel
Watch us for the best news and views on business, stock markets, crypto currencies, consumer technology, the world of real estate, bullion, automobiles, start-ups and unicorns and personal finance. Business Today TV will also bring you all you need to know about mutual funds, insurance, loans and pension plans among others.
Follow us at:
Website: www.businesstoday.in
WhatsApp: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va4Hd309hXFCqY62yD2I
Facebook: / businesstoday
twitter: / business_today
Instagram: / business_today
As all know.. Nirmala sita raman is the biggest shameless person ever😂😂😂
P. Chidambaram is most corrupt politician
True and never respect others arrogant agitated and admant all the time.
Shameless homeless
Shameless is an understatement
She and her party take the country to be a bunch of idiots. Their arrogance is unbecoming of a democratic government.
Never ever seen such cheat and liar like Nirmala Sitharaman
Hapta osuli bhai modi .hapta nikal 🤣
She is know for Mother of lies.😅
So without electrical bond we get more transparency..what a cheap and stupid thinking.. atleast electroral bond more transparent then previous one ,we know who donated the parties..
ముగ్గు గ్ బుట్టకు తెలివి ఎక్కువే!
👌👌👌👌👌
To the person who was vocal in saying "NO" in the audience: Salute bro, our country needs people like you. Jai Hind!
There is no assumption, there are dates when ED raided and when donation was given
Then show that raids were before donations if you want to cast accusations.
@@pskk7371
New Delhi: Hyderabad-based businessman P. Sarath Chandra Reddy’s company, Aurobindo Pharma Limited - which was linked to the Delhi liquor policy case in which chief minister Arvind Kejriwal was arrested on Thursday (March 21) - 👉👉donated electoral bonds worth Rs 5 crore to the 👉👉Bharatiya Janata Party in November 2022, just five days after he was arrested in the case by the Enforcement Directorate.
This information was first revealed by reporter Jahnavi Reddy and Project Electoral Bond, after the Election Commission released the unique numbers associated with each electoral bond on Thursday.
Aurobindo Pharma Limited was founded by Sarath Reddy’s father P.V. Ram Prasad Reddy, and Sarath Reddy is one of its directors.
When Sarath Reddy’s case came up for bail in the Delhi high court, the👉👉 Enforcement Directorate 👉👉did not oppose bail. In May 2023, the court granted him bail on medical grounds.
In June 2023, Sarath Reddy turned approver in the case. Two months later, the pharma company donated another👉👉 Rs 25 crore to the BJP.
Before Sarath Reddy’s arrest, the company had donated money to the Bharat Rashtra Samithi and Telugu Desam Party through electoral bonds.
Opposition leaders including 👉👉Delhi deputy chief minister Manish Sisodia and👉👉 BRS MLC K. Kavitha have been previously arrested in the case. Opposition parties have accused the Union government of using central agencies to stifle all dissent and political opposition in the country.
@@pskk7371why a political party need fund????
@@bharamurayar3025 this you should ask every political party that has taken funds.
@@pskk7371 Are you a political party???
How shameless bjp people,they are proving it is true 😢..
Biggest corrupt prime minister. If ED and CBI were neutral, modi would be in jail. Modi is using ED and CBI to blackmail companies and forcing them to buy electroral bond. This is one corruption but modi has done several corruption regarding PMO care fund, CAG report of corruption, Rafael corruption, Adani corruption.
You must realise while you’re voting. Please don’t vote for BJP.
@@arumugaswamyp9512 lol u guys do not have the brains.
How shameless ?? Can you explain ??
@@jayakishore565just watch video😅
one of a shameless soul in our country - Nirma!
what an idiotic n cheeky logic! She has indirectly contributed to the rechristening of SBI as Swindler's Bank of India.........
No her soul is fine, it's your you should worry about.. you can fool people but god is watching your nonsense..
@@sanjana4713 hey andbhakt! the bonds have been bought by Hub Power Coy of Pakistan at the time of Pulwama terror atttack. Chinese companies have also bought the bonds. now u will say tht bonds were given to Communist Party of India......
@@123rocker0071987 so you mean to say communist china want BJP to be on power🤣.. do you ever use your brian or its dead like your logic?🤣
Under the BJP, china is suffering a lot. And you want to say china want BJP..
Now who is andhbhakt? I guess you are andhbhakt of believing whatever nonsense you want too because reality hurts your belief.
Congress, fake liberal and anti nationals have zero understanding about china.
First understand china then you comment the nonsense.
झूट बोला है तो क़ाएम भी रहो उस बात पर,
आदमी को साहब-ए-किरदार होना चाहिए ।
It feels ashamed for a citizen of India that Indias FM is arguing like a school kid
Papers speak itself, No lies will be tolerated
Either she thinks the voters are fools or she is the biggest fool
She thinks we all are fool 😅
But she's not wrong....voters are fools
In every country it has same rule to reveal electoral bonds to public, now ruling party has revealed it to them. Finally, it wouldn't effect in Lok Sabha elections, because people will vote for good regime, development and security of country, not with electoral bonds effects.
@@bhargavrajput9019 do you know how other countries uses this money.
Let me give you example Germany collected 1 billion usd , so they used those money for school tutuion free.
After this student are not paying fees govt are paying through electoral bond, how our govt is using they give project to those who buy electoral bond, save income tax criminal, murderer, kidnapper, liquor scam
You should know how other countries are using against how we are using, first check facts then write
@@manishinte
Not only she but we all think so
How come this lady became FM??? She is a great actor...
Ask yourself for voting based on religion
Yes agreed . You may knock at their door again Madam, just to say what you have given is not enough ⁉️
Absolutely😂😂😂
Main culprit was Arun Jetli who institutionalise the most corrupt system of shameless collecting corrupt election fund. Maha chori
The ED, IT or any of the BJP's other agencies will do it on their behalf!😂😂😂
Ye chora chidambaram kya bolega, sab jante hain ruling party ko jyada Chanda milega, judiciary bekar ke kaam kar raha hai, janata ka paisa barbaad kar raha hai
Very true. Knocking to give the next invoice
Nirmala ji make no sense. Making ful of us like we can't understand a think.
She says when ever a company donated the opposition party SBI alerted us and we went and raided them. Which is even worse. 😀
If you have sense of logic..you would surelt understand..😅
India deserves an educated PM
Why accept money if you have to knock their door???!!! You ACCEPTED IT OR DID YOU RETURN IT. Will you return it
Knock the door and collect in cash in suitcases as per Congress formula and clean funding
EC courts how many they punished for last 20 years in election spending cases?
PM, HM and FM have forgotten that their own God knows the truth and will reward them.
அரசன் அன்று கொல்லும், தெய்வம் நின்று கொல்லும். PM, HM and FM are accountable to GOD and RAM.
Deivam Ninru Kollum.
These days , deivam inrea Kollum .. SC
God knows nothing. Actually the educated peoples know.
Yes , they beg for food and water yeh poor people ka shaap hai bjp ko
Vote for the right person u think in 2024 election. Every vote matters.
Don't vote as evm machine will vote . Hope you understand 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@shares961logic🤡🤡🤡
All parties are corrupted! You can't live with clean hands
Even if u r not going to say that's what everyone is going to do 😂
Chidambaram sir is truly genius and great personality.
Yes of course, that's why he was inside jail for long, he is not only corrupt but also a crook
Chidambaram sir 🎉 awesome ,We need educated people to run the country economy.
Educated? Sure. This man was part of one of the biggest scam 😂
@@user-ey2ym7cj5n😅😊😂.
Real shameless ppl.... even a kid can tell what happened
So basically you think cash transactions are better than electoral bonds 😂😂😂😂😂
IQ = -100
yes kids can tell because they lack understanding
u mean Rahul Gandhi 😂
@@chetanjethwa3823 Gujju saving Gujju
@@chetanjethwa3823Tu sayad se gobarbhakt hai
Chidambaram sir is a genius
Biggest joke of the decade😂😂😂😂😂
Have you forgotten the role he played in one of the biggest scam. 😂. So true that Indians have short memory and forget all scams
FM is speaking in condescending tone like we don't have brains. Madam, please open yourself up to an unbiased investigation which differentiates between good donation and bad money. Find the givers and takers of bad money and prosecute them, don't make an assumption that you are holier than thou.
Because Nirmala Sitaraman.... you don't have sense.... you are talking unconsciously that's why people are laughing at your statement
No you did not make sense Madam. I think there comes a point when we should shut up.
The country already knows the chronology Madam...
Sir you speak the truth God bless you sir save our nation
Shameless FM of India never deserved to have this useless FM .
Nirmala needs SC to summon her and get the truth out.
Correct
She will talk the same way to Chief justice also.that her nature.pickle lady.
She is the same FM told that dollar is increasing against rupees.....not rupees 😂
Haha 😅😅 shameless FM
But it was and it is the truth. Check other currencies.
Yes compared to dollar rupee depreciated but compared to others it was very stable and for some countries in value also grown. Have some knowledge before mentioning.
But that is truth right . Bcoz interest rates are increased dollar will go back . So it’s not rupee descended dollar increased against all currencies . She told truth oly . What’s ur education dude ??
IT WAS ABSOLUTELY RIGHT . EVEN THE EURO VALUE WAS DECREASING ON THOSE TIME.
This lady is so shameless
Blame Pt. Nehru, Nirmala Ji, problem solved.
People of India has awaken.....
Oh! That's why the SBI has not disclosed the full details. To make this excuse. We will have to wait till 18th March.
Ms.FM, This is a great shame! You are the best among the worst FMs of India for the last 75 years. What a bad moment for our nation? Time will let feel it for sure!!
How can she best, drinking people hard earned money in the form of taxes and no control over inflation. U know individual tax paid is more than corporates who earns in crores.
Thx Rahul for those 2 fantastic questions and probably ED is coming to INDIA TODAY soon
All the best to those who still wants to continue with this govt
Interviewer Rahul had no answer to FM's questions. If he wants to argue, he should have matched dates of all raids and dates of each fund of the top 14 donors to prove that every fund to BJP was connected to raid. And if Congress was AGAINST bonds, why they also received funds through bonds??? They should have banned it in their party! Useless defence by Chidambaram.
Sir chidambaram is well educated and intelligent personality. No doubt. ❤
That's y he wants to paste posters and who will clean it !
Chiddu is the no.1 corrupt FM India ever had. I sometimes wonder how forgetful we are as a people.
Lol😂😂😂 Thats why Congress redeemed 1000 crore bonds
@@venkatesh4715 dont forget manish sahu 550 corer gholtala of khangress
Int person was in jail on charges of corruption, is it right?
Madamji....try to accept the truth
what is the truth
@@SatyanarayanaNaik scam on Electoral bond
After all she a bhakth
Calling this shameless woman “Madam” is an insult to proper ladies .... and adding a “JI” to that? Respect for this woman?
She is definition of shameless along with cylinderlla 😂
There was a moment of pause from the audience when NS poses the question to the audience...and if anyone from the audience says YES...then we all know that the BJP government would send a raid the next day 😂
THE EYES OF FINANCE MINISTER IS COMPLETELY SHOWING THAT BOND IS A BIG BLUNDER .
Qwik Suply chain contributed 10 times its profit & Keventer group 100 times its profit via electoral bonds. It is illegal for a listed company to donate 100 times its profit. They are accountable to shareholders.
They donated via bank account that is listed in the name of QSC. They simply must've moved to one companies bank account the money from various other businesses.
And why did they do that? @@luvraj006
Is Qwik supply chain and Keventer a listed company?
It's Govt's job to prove the allegations are wrong.
To remove the assumptions, BJP and govt should release it's donor's list and show them have not taken donation from those 14 companies where ED had made raids
SBI itself has confirmed that and where's the need for proof?
Nirmala sounds exactly like a teacher who when faced with an intelligent question by a student tries to use her authority to shut the student up and then tries to convince the class that the student is asking a stupid question 🤣🤣🤣
What a cleaver answer from finance minister cool maam. Keep it up
Mami on fire without knowing proper answer😂
She just said do i make sense , audience Said no 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Audience went blank. Like how should we react now?
Mamies bottom is on fire 🔥 wonderful 🎉😂😅
Wah....even a kid can connect the dots...😂
But not the hon’ble FM of the day. She pretends.
Yes Madam. U r right. We are fools.
Nirmal Sitharaman has always been an angry school teacher in news debates and in Parliament. Her arguments have never made sense.
Shameless person
For the common man jugglery of words
They think people are fools.
How she humility the journalist.😅😅
When bonds are illegal/unconstitutional why the money is not returned by political parties. The donors have availed 80GG for charity. This is Indian politics.
Worthless answer by the FM, miserable state of affairs
Sir,
Don't call this madam for this discussion, please call PM or HM.
PM Modi never spoke in media interview questions publicaly, in a decade since he is a PM. He just talks in National media and through his cabinet members.
Haha😂😂 pm then it’s a script, this time orange.
Yes Call PM to answer these questions
Really.
Are we really joking !
@@jack-in6yd
Madam finance minster all the funding happend after raid only. After raid with in a week these companies purchased bonds. Its on record . And how come companies will fund for state governments when the central agencies are in raid.
She thought truth will not come out.
sitaraman ko jnu degree kaise de diya?although i know in jnu there are various d grade course which are not demandable course.
Person after vote by evm must check vvpat receipt to check authenticate his choosed party then put in box
Evm count and vvpat receipt count must be matched
Yes is required aa you said
Useless & Foolish Finance Minister Nirmala Tai 😂😂😂
I wish they had knocked doors of Adani in case of Hindenburg thing.. No Ed or Cbi raids there.. inko lgta hai janta pagal hi rhegi hamesha.. Such disgusting creatures.. Common sense still prevails.. we can make out ourselves and match the incidents..
Good english, we are impressed, thank you so much for your kind words..... #FM
Its true that companies have been funding all the political parties from many years and now with regards to electoral bonds we need to wait till we know complete details about which company has donated to which party and has that company got any benifits post donation before blaming any political party..we should never come to conclusion based on short term data...
When politicians dont get out much and they think normal citizens are dumb, you make such comments. No strong reply for accusations shows their guilt.
Madam , Truth is very hard but need to accept,
Then why the hell did Scamgress got 1800cr through electoral bond 😂😂
@@fudalog1561aa Gaya ek character. Bhai faltu dimaag mat laga. Congress ki scheme nahi hai ye . And funding bhi check kr le kitni hai
@@diggidiggiable IT WAS DONE IN LEGAL WAY NOT ILLEGAL WAY . NOW SUPREME COURT SAID THAT THE SCHEME IS ILLEGAL IS DIFFERENT MATTER.
@@debapratimmandal3295 It has violated the RTI Act, which makes it illegal from the beginning. Come on, man, it's high time; now, stop defending the biggest liar in the history of mankind.
@@debapratimmandal3295hahha..nice logic brother...legalized bribe money 😂😂😂. There is God above who's watching all this tamasha and now the time has come to step down gracefully
All anti-nationals coming together and Nirmalaji is there ❤
BJP government threatened corporates with central agencies and let them buy bonds for security . FM why angry at question?
One of the most irritating person I have come across
anyone remember finance Minister's dialogue "...Yes...we are not corrupt..." and Electrol Bond scam has come out to disclose party's real nature😂
and
Now, she is saying "We still raided after Donation..."😅 Reason is the company has Purchased less number of Bonds and to purchase/give more money they have raided... that's the tactics Dear😅😂
That's how Party works 😂🤣
Even her husband don't relate with what she is saying.
Honourable FM, show us a single example where any company has funded BJP and after that ED has knocked their door.
But vice-versa there are cases where,
ED has knocked the doors and that company has funded BJP and ED has showed gratitude through showing soft corner for them.
chidambaram Sir,right, Jai Congress
Lol 2012 Congress raised 2000 crores through anonymous bonds and they didnt even reveal the donors. Now same Congress is questionning a more transperant Electoral Bond scheme. The SC that was silent then is suddenly now woken up 🤣🤣 Agenda is clear.
@@thiruvettiIam giving 10k crores to congress to wipe out BJP 🎉
@@TruthGeneral I am giving my vote to BJP to put the final nail in the coffin to have Congress mukt India. Jai Hind
Similar like a roadside thief who does burglary by threatening with knife chor become chowkidhar
I had gone through the comments. SHAMELESS LADY was the majority comments😂😂
Nirmala can not accept the truth, she is always out to defend her party by all means. Wish good luck in the days to come
Step 2-Once the SC get the unique identification number.
Step 3-SC should investigate the accounts of 14 top corporates and audit each company profit per year and the fund they given to political parties.
Why don't you the government release the complete data. Then there won't be need for assumptions. It is blatantly obvious that there was some kind unethical stuff going.
Roka kisne hein BJP to bola Jo data lene hein le lo
ITS SBI
@@sohandas4096gadha
@@debapratimmandal3295 congress thode hein koi record nahi hoga pura transperant process bein
Classic potrayal of 4 mins of Common Sense vs a minute of Non-Sense😂
To curtail the cost BEST thing is to bring different party minister on one stage on the same day. Let have debates live with people.
How long PM and FM will propagate that electoral bonds are transparent?
EB is transparent in the sense that there's a record for the first time ever of donation(via SBI) to political party on balance sheet of the buyer, that is traceable. Before EB it was all suitcases full of cash directly to political parties. With EB accountability has existed for the first time in 75 years. Now compare the corruption.
@@luvraj006 and you still do not need to pay tax on the money you spent buying the bond. So, earlier, at least, it was black money. Now, you made the same money white while the ruling party also kept track of other parties' donations. Wow nice no corruption 🤷
@@luvraj006 Taking bribe is illegal, in any manner.. No one can give justification to that.. it's illegal.. that's it..
@luvraj006 Bribe has to be termed as bribe, be it in brief case or electoral bond..
@@tarunkhapra7211then why even western countries use same method.
They are corrupt too?
Please let me know that do you guys really think cash transactions are better than bonds.
If yes then may God save you. 😂😂😂
*❤BJP and BRS OUT this time.✅💯Great Analysis on valuable information 👌🇮🇳 What the Supreme court said is 💯 perfect. This is complete corporate management of political parties and Governments in India. Like this there are several false bills and amendments that the BJP party and NDA government did and several politicians have been demolished and witnesses destroyed in the last 10-20 years by Modi wherever he is in power along with Amit Shah. Please go ahead and thoroughly inquire after the government falls down. See politicians have become religious culprits since then.. Jaibhim Jaibharat India 🇮🇳 RESPECT ALL ❤*
One simple way. Bring a bill in Loksabha and declare that all amendments to various laws, particularly tax laws, Evidence act etc, ( make no exception) made in the last 10 years stand withdrawn and the pre2014 levels restored. Will be very difficult to amend every law cl. by cl. They have butchered so much.
My vote will always be for BJP. They are the only solution to India;s development.
@@thiruvettiwhat development ? 😂😂😂😂
@@ambrosepravin2072 The development that Congress could never achieve 🤣🤣
@@thiruvetti what corruption in the name of electoral bonds and PM care funds and legalised the corruption by making new laws and giving free bees to corporate.... ?
Lol Congress raised 2000 crores in 2012 through anonymous donors and when SC questionned it didnt even disclose any details.
Now same Congress is questionning a more transperant Electoral Bond structure. Hypocrisy ki bhi seema hothi hai
What all said happened
Election is NOT. TAMASHA. MAKING
I am SURPRISED at this kind of statement
Sad What can I have expected that's why nothing happened in the past
You make raid after raid because you are greedy
Naive..madam...Ed is centre driven agency....
GOOD QUESTIONS RAHUL JI. Shameless Nirmala
Rise above religion and caste. Save democracy, save India 🙏
Madam Finance minister, if taking your point in argument, then if someone funded, and then ED knock their door, if means something wrong to those people, so why not those funds returned or why not formulas a committee to investigate,?
Shame on bjp
Sir Chidambaram the most experienced with a deep and strongest experienced and very well matured is an like a standard. Any party coming new can follow this standard but cannot upgrade it.
Selectively raiding the company/party by the help of SBI through electoral bond information to the ruling party , by letting them know who bought the bonds and how much. Such a manipulative way of money handling with no transparency process.
Amount obtained by BJP through electoral bonds is peanuts and is given as pocket money for party cadres.
A and A company gifts will be in PM CARES Fund ;the biggest scandal on earth collected using PM name and through ministry circulars which was later declared as not official scheme. Government and public sector employees were forced to give one day salary and I was fooled as well.
Was PM cares fund routed to BJP party😂
What about 1.4k crore for TMC. And 1.2k crore for Congress
PM CARE FUND IS GOVT FUND NOT PARTY FUND EDIOT.
Well how can fraud be considered threw check. Now everything will be done in cash. 😂😂😂
@@Fukranhm what about 6500 cr for BJP, look at the rat in your plate, rather for a fly in others
Big blunder 2024 bye bye bjp
GHANTA
@@debapratimmandal3295 let's see what happens, 10 years people of India watch very carefully and they will now in different mood for 2024 general election vote castings.
Always remember why I should be always perspective for political parties we will try to do better by changing power every 10 years
Ayega toh modi hee dekhna ... Hamara evm machine baneyega useh pm . Jai modi 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@shares961 Everyone has right to choice of political ideology, but this time people of do not go with Liars
@@sch2405 countries like Japan and Germany who produce robots believe evm machines can be easily hacked but Modiji will use it to win . You and me can't do anything. Don't even vote as evm will do the work . Eccentric but bitter truth.
Dollar is more strong and not rupee is weak . . .
Does it make any sense?
Again No 😂😂😂😂
Nirmalaji is always gives a question as the answer for a question! Great talent. Jai Shree Sitaram!!!
Kudos to BJP for implementing "GST" in the corruption stage of a business/service ..!
No bribes (to local leaders) required to get things done. Instead, pay big to the Big, then the project is DONE...!😁
Valid point 💯
Modi ED electoral bonds scam. Biggest in independent India. 44000 Crore project given away in return to bind donations
Chidambaram sir ❤
Electoral bonds are unconstitutional. Gifting a note printing machine to enemy camp is constitutional perhaps!
Ed can be endorsed as well
See how media defends bjp .
Shameless
All these bonds should band and closed and give to poor persons
Madam made perfect sense , they got the money and got back coz it was not enough.
So clear!
04:39 "NO"