“No Relation Between Donations And ED Raids”, Says FM Nirmala Sitharaman
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 бер 2024
- #indiatodayconclave #nirmalasitharaman #financeminister #edraid #electoralbond
Join us at the India Today Conclave 2024 as Nirmala Sitharaman, Union Minister of Finance and Corporate Affairs, delivers the first government response on electoral bonds. Sitharaman challenges assumptions surrounding electoral bonds data, questioning the narrative and highlighting the imperfections of the previous system. She asserts that electoral bonds contribute to transparent party funding, emphasizing their role in making the process more accountable and legitimate.
-----------------------
Thank You for watching! Do not forget to Like | Comment | Share
-----------------------
About the channel
Watch us for the best news and views on business, stock markets, crypto currencies, consumer technology, the world of real estate, bullion, automobiles, start-ups and unicorns and personal finance. Business Today TV will also bring you all you need to know about mutual funds, insurance, loans and pension plans among others.
Follow us at:
Website: www.businesstoday.in
WhatsApp: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va4Hd309hXFCqY62yD2I
Facebook: / businesstoday
twitter: / business_today
Instagram: / business_today
She has no answer clearly.😂😂
No perfect solution has established either
She never does. No one in their party gives proper answers to whats asked.
First learn to understand English.
@@liv4nation781lol. Learn law😂
You should learn english first
White money corruption😅😅
Prove it in court bachha … and
@@santhoshs9810it cells at full time work 😄
@@santhoshs9810court is already doing it's work.....usi ki vajah se hame pata chala hai
@@santhoshs9810 40 पैसा कामगार..😂😂😂😂
There is an clever arrogant thief who steals everything from ppl and challenges them to prove it in court….. here I am not talking abt ppl and BJP….
Why does honourable FM sound like a parent who just got caught doing something wrong. 😅
Lots of BJP leaders will go to jail if they lose this election.
Only in dreams
LOSE 😂😂😂😂😂
Even deaf and dumb will tell you bjp will win.
@@gumnaamhubhai4063 exactly iske nasley nikal jaaenge par logon ka BJP ke upar se bharosa nahi jaaega 🤣🤣🤣. He thinks people are that dumb to bring the most corrupt party in human history to power ? Just because BJP got white money in a completely transparent and fair way ?
@@gumnaamhubhai4063yes BJP will win but we r the once who will be at loss
"Main onion nahi khati" - type answer.
Companies with 100 crore net profit is buying 400 crore bonds...waaahhhh....This is another level scam
Imagine how much this 100 crore company make in reality
Police is asking to thieves that did you theft or not.. 😂😂😂
Ok, what about congress, TMC and other parties who got the electoral bond. Understand the root cause. U take free rashan... I can say u r looting the farmers and tax payers money.
Here issue is Guard himself is thief hiding his notorious character.
If ED AND CBI forced to companies for donating money to parties, why companies do not go supreme court.
@@gobindadas99it is easy to give money and get rid of cases and will have freedom to work. So they will give money and try to be safe that's called legal bribary
How plainly Nirmala is lying while she won't be able to face questions after a few days when everything gets revealed.
If ED AND CBI forced to companies for donating money to parties, why companies do not go supreme court.
@@gobindadas99😂😂
@@gobindadas99 Supreme court will take up the issue after 5 years and by that time the company will be ruined by the political party.
Very flimsy answer by FM! Not the same confidence! 😂
i think its clear. But we should watch data and dates. Hope your politics wont come in the way
@@mcprasanth76Forget abt data and dates….. 67% received by BJP…. 14 out of 31 donors have had ED/IT raid….. No brainer actually
VERY True
That's how one speaks when they are corrupt. This lady in particular has been a big disgrace, from BJP and for India as a whole.
@@Siva1477 These 14 could also given to other parties.
The three godi anchors sitting in front of the MADAM FINANCE MISTER reminds me of the most obedient students in my 5th standard.
Not convincing FM. Anchors seem scared to ask. Nation wants to know
Finance Minister never failed to exhibit the arrogance at every stance
From her side, her party has been blamed for corruption with assumptions. An electoral bond is given to all the parties. Most Kolkata-based companies gave it to TMC, the same with BRS. If I'm an entrepreneur with capacity, I, too, will donate; it's the essential thing. You vote for Congress; I can ask you why you are voting for Congress; you are biased towards Congress. I, as an entrepreneur, want my country to progress, so I will spend and do whatever is possible to the best of my capabilities for the party to meet that objective.
Would you donate 1000% more than what your company is making in profits?
@@liv4nation781 hello mr deshbhakt please tell me 1) why is india 111th country out of 125 countries on global hunger index
2) why is the unemployment rate so high
3) why is the cost of basic needs getting higher
please do answer these question as our finance , home , and prime minister's health gets worse by the second when these question are mentioned so we cant risk asking them
also mister entrepreneur i am certainly not at the level of of our respectable finance minister but a advice none the less " you have clearly invested in the wrong places for the development of the nation "
also its not just accused , no company would donate the amounts mentioned here
Future Gaming located in Tamilnadu. Operates in Tamilnadu and Kerala.
Haldia located in West Bengal.
Megha engineering got clearance from BRS in Telangana.
Yashomati hospital located in Hyderabad,Telangana.
It's All DMK, TMC, BRS ruled states. Where is BJP in this?
I think SC should order total disclosure to make people aware of how everyone got money and from whom they got it. It will expose reality of TMC, Congress, DMK and BRS...these parties got unprecedented amount of money despite being regional parties.
@@liv4nation781 you are a true BJP supporter, you will get a MP seat in next election
This is what you call lying through the teeth.
Didn't know that Indian companies are so benevolent ......😅struggling with profitability but eager to serve the political masters........
The Audacity to say "how can you say it went to BJP?" just wait till monday for SBI to release the Bond Numbers.
Update: On Monday SC asked SBI to release by 21st i.e. Thursday along with an affidavit that no data is withheld.
Lot of BJP's drama to be seen before SBI is allowed to share complete data on electoral bonds. Some how Mo D has come to believe that except him all Indians are fool. Credit of this fake belief goes to Mo D's jumalebaji and dramebaji looking real to his voters.
You are already crying when Adani didn't fund... Now new narrative brought to satisfy your sadistic mentality on Monday....poor sadist 😂
Everyone gives to winning party, why do they give to losers like Pappu ? 😂
This is not audacity..here they got the money through a legal system still.. the real audacity is people forgetting the scams that congress did.."SCAMS" Which is not legal. Bjp has got 600pcr in from 2019 till 2024 through a legal way and congress 2012 coal scam alone amounts around 1.9 lakh crores. Now if we sum up their just any 5 years scam amount, Bjp donot even come to 1 % of their scammed money..and people want congress back
THE BJP NOT ONLY GET THE BENEFIT.
A disgrace to the country. A disgrace to Tamilnadu.
The question is why these companies are giving such a huge amount to any party? not only BJP other parties also?
our entire election is run on the basis of quid pro quo, and has been since the beginning....we've to take steps to stop crony capitalism from overtaking the democracy and turning it into oligarchy
Other parties because they want an end of BJP
@@dinakarandavidso BJP because BJP wants to end other parties, so dumb argument
After winning election govt will give liberal rules and regulations, give tenders to those companies to make profit
What huge amounts, why can't companies give huge donations. Remember the size of our country and number of political parties. For a corporate, if environment is favourable or not may decide who they give donation to. And its in there interest to fund democracy in a way. Happens in all democracies. The donation BJP has received is roughly 300 crore per state that they are ruling at present. This is decent as hosting a single rally of PM might cost crores. This average is high for regional parties.
And there is no ideal state to be in. Definitely the donations made by MEIL and Future gaming are suspicious. Quiq pro quo possibility.
Electroal scam bjp 11000 crores 😂😂😂
A company in Coimbatore "Future Gaming" (Martin lottery) was raided and accused for 409Crores money laundering, even ED attached their assets..... After which this company buys 1368 Crs worth bonds and ED drops the case....it's been three years.....
• Reportedly all cases dropped against Future Gaming.
If ED AND CBI forced to companies for donating money to parties, why companies do not go supreme court.
@@gobindadas99
When a company like "Megha Engineering" bags 14400 corers worth twin tunnel project acting its gives 100crs in the form of bonds, why will they even think of going SC.... In the same way, Future gaming gave 1368Crs and they would have received atleast 10times more of our money.....
When journalists ask her tough questions she calls it lazy journalism. Why were they hesitating to declare it till today.
Well she gave a practical, honest answer and addressed the problems with implementation. Instead of making false promises and idealism.
@@Srikrishnakarthik 😂who is implementing. can't understand the mindset of people still supporting these corrupt ones.
What is funny is that everyone sitting in that hall, including the FM, knows that this system is intentionally introduced for this particular purpose, but caught by the SC, and she has no other option but to give alternative narratives. However, sadly, these things will have zero effect on this election because ordinary Indians are more interested in some petty matters.
Exactly said
She means to say after Company gave money’s they still raided Company means the money given was less and needs to give more
Assumptions assumptions
Well buying MLAs and toppling governments weren't cheap. 😂
@@lonerider6175 "for sale” MLA’s are available only with the opposition parties?
@@kechi_kechi I guess the opp isn’t trying to buy MLAs as much as bjp is doing. Any idiot who argues with this is blind. How many governments were toppled by bjp? You srsly can’t think that it’s happening naturally
@@soultune908 opposition parties are clueless about their MLAs…yet they cry on bjp for poaching?
Look at her eyes!! She is blinking uneven..unrhythmic the. ..so lying!!😅
If those companies come forward and say that "yes, we had to donate after the raid", will her answer be different?
Madam Finance Minister, the SBI was 'forced' to provide the data by SC. They didn't follow the orders.😂😂
I JUST CAN'T JOIN POLITICS!
How can someone lie so easily?
A JNU educated Finance Minister has to stoop so low, and do it with a facade of confidence. I would die of shame. 😢
how are you saying that though?
@@ramber1021 I can say what I feel. You write down your objection, if you have any.
@@myhonestcomments sure yes , you are entitled to your opinion, but I just wonder how would i feel about calling some person a liar without evidence to back it up, don’t think I’d want to do that.
@@ramber1021Good question.
1. She is saying raids may have been conducted even after the donations were made. The fact is that many dates have been found for raids before donation. Why isn't the news channel cross-questioning? For now, it's circumstantial, which is why the unique numbers of the bonds is required urgently.
2. She says they need to look into how loss making firms shouldn't donate. But why did they (BJP) amend the rules to allow it? This wasn't there in the old system.
3. She says the earlier system was imperfect and the electoral bonds were better. It is clear that the system needed to change, but BJP has taken advantage of this need to bring a system that gives all powers to the ruling party. Zero transparency to others. They were the ones targeting the donors to the opposition, when AAP was declaring donors on their website and had to stop it because of the targeting by BJP.
BJP is the crook that the system needs to protect democracy from, and they are the ones making a new system. It is the same tactic as using Pegasus against opposing voices rather than on terrorists.
@@ramber1021 Good question and an obvious one.
1. She is saying raids may have been conducted even after the donations were made. The fact is that many dates have been found for raids before donation. Why isn't the news channel cross-questioning?
2. She says they need to look into how loss making firms shouldn't donate, but why did they (BJP) amend the rules to allow it? This wasn't there in the old system.
3. She says the earlier system was imperfect and the electoral bonds were better. It is clear that the system needs to change, but BJP has taken advantage of the need to bring a system that gives all powers to the ruling party. Zero transparency to others. They were the ones targeting the donors to the opposition, when AAP was declaring donors on their website and had to stop it because of the targeting.
BJP is the crook that the system needs to protect democracy from, and they are the ones creating the new system. What an irony!
She just defends, not giving proper answer.
Wait & watch Monday .... 😂😂
Nothing to watch...since no Adani opposition broken 😂
ED raids, companies pay, no relation, just pure love
Not satisfactory answer . she is trying to coverup .which is not good
FM's reply is not satisfatory. Jately was smart enough to consider all that she is proposing to consider in future legislation on electoral bonds. Jetaley has deliverately kept the intrasparency in Electoral Bonds and BJP has immensely benefited from it.
FM why the hell your sbi requested three month time to submit the details to Supream court?
Ask sbi
@@nithinkt5373 sBI is under the Finance ministry control . She should bow down and resign getput from.ministry. or atleast she should have taken action agent sbi chairman. We would have appreciated
@@jothip6673 who need your appreciation... Sbi is an independent entity with government and other holding shares....sbi can always speak from their angle...
@@nithinkt5373digital india modi ki guarantee 😂
@@Arjun-di7bi 2g pappu ka guarantee 😆
First of all , FM and. BJP ruling accepted that the act amendments in IT , Finance, PR act Corporate act are unconstitutional as said by Supreme court of India.
Now she says, new scheme will be firmed with more transperancy. All foolish. Bjp got major fund out of electoral bond and no need. Only aim to come to power.
She was replying like anger going out of control.
Rahul Kanwar asks such a stupid question! This is like a bowler giving a loose ball to a Virat Kohli
he is paid for that. it is match fixing
I am glad that people's eyes r opening
It is shocking to know that parties have got amount from Pakistan through electoral bonds. Coimbatore based Lottery company have given huge amount to parties. During corona time pharmaceutical companies have given money to political parties through electoral bonds. After ED, CBI raid companies have given money to political parties through electoral bonds.
What a joke, pakistan funding for electoral bonds as it is in deep financial crises. Electoral bonds are sold only in bank with proper kyc through for account only. Congress government has sold money printing machines to Pakistan, how stupid Congress is. People are making all sorts of assumptions, we have to wait for the verdict as all the transactions with EB were legitimate, completely white money.
😂😂😂😂we are human will understand you the govt doing raid with RD and raising money for your party and Monday will see how many numeric serial numbers hidden by sbi for saving other big parties and bjp
Qwik Suply chain contributed 10 times its profit & Keventer group 100 times its profit via electoral bonds. It is illegal for a listed company to donate 100 times its profit. They are accountable to shareholders.
The party that was fighting black money through demonetization was actually white washing it. 😂
EBs from Pakistan have been given to BJP during Pulwama.Nirmala should explain this ássumption' 👿👿👿👿👿
for the expense in taking dead bodies across country and cry for votes ??modiji and sanghi mommies and buties
It is too early to invite FM.After few days FM will not be able to answer these kind of questions.If it was all legal why they had to keep secret about who funded whom ?
Bhai, agara tera bank, transactions aur bank balance sabko public me batha de including your account numbers, will that make sense. Murli u go get a degree and earn some money.
Is it required to 3 more months for SBI for showing the transactions...?? Why???
the question is not about system... question is about why these corporates donated??
The dates of buying bond and the dates of ed raids can be easoly confirmed from data.and it is done for megha engineering
As arrogant as Nirmala
This is feminism
FM we understand n ur body language says, u r scared.
Your face is frightened Nimmi.
Bhai Ambani ki kichidi kaisi thi. 😂😂😂
Future Gaming located in Tamilnadu. Operates in Tamilnadu and Kerala.
Haldia located in West Bengal.
Megha engineering got clearance from BRS in Telangana.
Yashomati hospital located in Hyderabad,Telangana.
It's All DMK, TMC, BRS ruled states. Where is BJP in this?
I think SC should order total disclosure to make people aware of how everyone got money and from whom they got it. It will expose reality of TMC, Congress, DMK and BRS...these parties got unprecedented amount of money despite being regional parties.
Can't believe these politicians.
At 1:38 the FM says "we" went knoocking at tbeir doors. Who are we in this? I thought tbe ED was an independent organization Madam FM?
Knock came first money came later😂MLA and MP came later
Who is the authority of state owned bank ?
Why would a company making 200cr profit give approx 1000 cr donation?
When it is transferred to your account, why is delay in giving the data? Including bond number etc.
That is the smart question
see slowly media stalwarts are changing.. strong questions getting posed..
Yeah exactly!
Media is also a beneficiary in this.
Janta ko aap bewkoof samjhna band kijiye.. She didn't give amswer.. Only blaming other party... Lakhs of crore were there.. Madam..
Will Supreme Court appoint a SIT to investigate companies & the political parties about quid pro quo, extrotion using ED/CBI followed by electrol
bonds and cases dropped, shell companies
companies paying more than their revenuescompanies pay more than 100% of their profits, are these companies paying willingly and why? will ED & CBI investgate BJP on fast track? Will
the BJP leadership be booked under PMLA for money laundering, extrotion, round triping, etc People want to know. Or will Modi come back to power and all this will be sweeped under carpet?
Dear FM who instruct SBI not disclose details before june 2024
FM Not with that much confidence btw 😅
What will happen to the electoral bonds if not redeemed by the party?
Who will become the beneficiary?
It goes to the PM CARES FUND
@@gmdriyazNot the PM CARES but the PM National Relief Fund
FM: Iam i making sense.
Audience:No better you start eating Onions.
There is a ceiling on how much a Company donate by bonds, based on their profits.
rightly said this visibility made by BJP era... earlier it was not transparent..
Now caught red handed by CJI
If she days NO means it is YES
As per FM's version even after taking the bond if ED had still gone knocking at the doors it could even be asking g for more money.😅
It’s Ram Rajya . She is having sense 😂😂❤❤❤
अडाणी अंबानी इनका नाम नही आने से बहुत सारे लोग सदमे में हैं 😢😂
Aree bhai..."shell company" ke bare kabhi suna hai kya..???
QWIK Supply chain PVT LTD ke bare me search kro...Samz jaoge...
Sadma....Toh SBI ki Puri Report aane ke baad Pta chalega
Why Supreme court not taking any action against anti social element like drug maffia
Seetharama why central govt is not working against drug mafia.
Sc st obc reservation is bad 😂.but brahmin bania EWS quota is good😂😂😂
Gujrat mein sabse zyada international drugs aate hai, vo bhi BJP ke sabse bade donor adani port se 😏
What for you have given your Vote to Mo D?
Andh Bhakt can't see that people have not elected Mo D as PM for doing 24x 7 hours jumalebaji and dramebaji.
Mo D works for 18 hours a day but all of these 18 hours he work for the party. Who is running central gov?
Tu supreme court se jyada janta hai kya, sala khud nashe karke comment type krrha tha sayad. Bade aye supreme court ko questions puchne wale😂
You mean Adhani's Mundra port?
The simple question is if these companies are funding the party then are they getting something in return? The answer is YES. All or most of these companies are under investigation prior to they funding the party through electoral bonds. The timeline of events proves that. It's clear like day light that these shell companies and companies who were corrupt and evaded tax has got themselves free by paying money to BJP. You cannot say that yo run the country the party had to do such illicit acts. This is absolutely a scam and one of the biggest.
FM means to say supreme court judgement is wrong of electoral bonds being unconstitutional????
rubbish answers from a FM
How long can you justyfy electorel bond of bjp when the suprem court of india has sead it is unconstitutuional. And you are compairing or rating with the previous system.😅😅
Police .. Chor se he pooch rahe hi.. Chori ki hi ki nahi
Because of chanda it's people have to pay more for whatsoever you buy from these companies.
Amazing Finance minster... dare to answer good IQ reporters
Then I am Batman.
Why didnt you ask the same thing to the PM?
Cleaner? 😂😂😂
Why did they(BJP) tried to hide the electoral bonds in the first place?
Rahul Kanwal have no option but to ask questions on electoral bond.... Jhumla party's game have come to end... Results are 0 ,,,, but reply the given by FM is arrogant😂
One nation one election one tax...abolish all taxes, abolish all denomination over Rs50...
Only bank transaction tax..
Then polticians will not bother people...
Do you mean that Mo D will loose the opportunity to show his face after every one minute on TV?
When white is coming into account, why there is no transperancy
Is there a pool proof method under this law that money received by parties will be spent in white and accounted for scuririny. Probably there should be a separate AG to audit all party account in par to their IT filling.
Godi media finally forced to asked the questions to their masters. 😂 power of indian supreme court
What else can she says when her boss himself is not educated in this field
Is pappu an MIT graduate he is the most illiterate one in the country,when I saw his knowledge about AI😅😅😅
Picture abhi baaki mrs. Finance minister.. Today u r saved as sbi has not given the full information to supreme court..
What happens when all the information is out ..
Loss making companies, companies who were being investigated, lottery and gaming companies, shell companies, individual with no net worth donating to political parties, what does this show...
Why all these years, the validity of this scheme was not challenged or checked? Today a Marathi paper has stated that some regional parties have given very dubious statements about how they got the money.
This lady is too arrogant, i don't think she deserves to be a minister, as a minister you should be humble you're not the owner of this country learn being humble you're just a servant of the people of this country.
Exactly. She thinks if she raised her voice and manipulates words , and makes stupid statement and rolls her eyes when she can't answer questions.
Its not an assumption but BJP just went behind corporates even after donations is because the donation was not just enough for BJP. Infact BJP wanted more
Appreciate her acting skills, should be nominated for Oscars
Eloctoral Bond:Leagal anonymous bribe.....😂😂
BjP and TMC is now exposed.
How
Even Congress also 😂
@@KaranKunwar-uu9kf no
@@KaranKunwar-uu9kfevery single political party in India
😂😂😂 Paap ka Ghada jaldi bhar raha hai
Party in power, power to lobby.. but, using govt entities... funny ppl..
so for example x company gives Electoral bonds to Congress, the Finance Ministry will know and can send ED to those companies and ask them to pay BJP too isnt ?
Why not E. D, C. B. I, I. T on nirmalaji ji door? Thats?? She wont win? 2024
Cheapo is acting as if she does not have the data!
It is Congress cheapoo who will be getting exposed and cheapoo like you doing propoanda
Turning Dark into Light she admits 😅what a Great FM Indians are having showering limelight into all pockets😅😅
Simply court judgment for EB as 'unconstitutional' is hardly going to stop mouth of FM, unless a severe punishment is awarded for core contributor who has introduced it. Rahul is so ashamed of questioning that always trying to prove that it is not his question but question from audience. Q is if EB is better system, why it is called unconstitutional and scrapped? Either court is wrong or Govt. Both can't be correct or right. Who is right and who is wrong? Why can't your advocate convince Judges if it was better system even after 02 years? Why is it better system? Who has the capacity to know about donors details? These people are so shameless! Nobody is raising question, how SBI was found as liar to court. Once saying, it needs months to get data, again later able to submit data within next day.
How loss making company give donation in election? From where money come when you are a loss making company? If you have money enough why you are in loss? So absurd. Obviously, something is wrong.
Total fake Govt
Jumla fm
.... of Jumla PM
@@prohindbetter than finger licking pappu
FM should say how can a compnay with profit of Rs.250 Cr buying EBs for Rs 1653 Cr rupees woth.
Company with profit of Rs 1.8 Cr buying EBs for Rs 185 Cr.
FM should explain.
How can this happen?
Supreme court says it is totally unconstitutional, what do you say on it...when will ED take actions on this issue..
FM herself have the money 😂