Donna's Demise? - Silence In The Library - Doctor Who - BBC

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 747

  • @thehabz4190
    @thehabz4190 3 роки тому +2015

    The phrase "hey who turned out the lights?" Literally haunted me for years. I watched this episode as an 8 year old and couldn't go back to who until I was 18

    • @carmi8034
      @carmi8034 2 роки тому +13

      me word for word

    • @willmarsden7657
      @willmarsden7657 2 роки тому +37

      I'm a bit older - for me it was back in the Eccleston days. The little gas mask kid "are you my mummy?". Eugh, lord that was uncomfortable.

    • @frankiepena4804
      @frankiepena4804 2 роки тому

      Same lmao

    • @masmurdermonkey9233
      @masmurdermonkey9233 2 роки тому +3

      @@willmarsden7657 Yes, same here. Bloody terrifying.

    • @ausguy4385
      @ausguy4385 Рік тому +3

      A ex would loose it worse with
      "Are you my mummy" 😅😂
      I did the right thing and did it 😅

  • @sianjohnson7975
    @sianjohnson7975 10 років тому +972

    Chilling moment when he repeats I'm fine I'm ok I'm fine

    • @SakariWolf13
      @SakariWolf13 4 роки тому +28

      Sounds like me on my worst days.

    • @joshmaddocks1901
      @joshmaddocks1901 4 роки тому +14

      No when Dave starts to walk that's me when I get up in the morning

  • @connorclemmons8698
    @connorclemmons8698 7 років тому +1353

    Fun Fact: I work the night shift and I watched this episode as the sun was rising. I went to bed with a smug grin knowing that I wouldn’t be in the dark. I forgot I wake up after the sun sets and instantly remembered this episode when I woke up in my room in the dark. I can tell you that given the circumstances it’s scarier to wake up in the dark, than it is to actually fall asleep in it.

    • @Enigmatic-v83
      @Enigmatic-v83 Рік тому +7

      agreed

    • @SeriousDragonify
      @SeriousDragonify 7 місяців тому +2

      Be glad youre not born blind.
      They get used to from day one.

    • @HellstreamGames
      @HellstreamGames 3 місяці тому +4

      @@SeriousDragonifybecoming blind would be the worst, me and my brother have a pact where, if one of us gets blind, paralyzed, fall into a coma etc. we would put the other one out of their misery.
      He’s balding at 28 now and I’ve been frequently asking him 😅

    • @debrinamcduffie7071
      @debrinamcduffie7071 18 днів тому

      How is this a fun fact

  • @PMW3
    @PMW3 9 років тому +3752

    could you imagine watching this scene and having your power go out, or a light bulb burn out?

    • @shakibzz
      @shakibzz 9 років тому +24

      PMW3 dude omg

    • @_visualsyt
      @_visualsyt 9 років тому +156

      PMW3 I would just be like, 'Hey, who turned out the lights?'

    • @xxxbanan007
      @xxxbanan007 9 років тому +10

      +Minecraft Visuals XDDD

    • @xavierreichel8254
      @xavierreichel8254 8 років тому +82

      The first time I watched it, it was in the evening. As I got up, I turned around and at the end of the hallway, a light went out. Then the next one, closer to me. Then the next one. The lights slowly turned off, and I freaked out as I imagined the V.N. swarming towards me. The result? Several blown fuses...

    • @_visualsyt
      @_visualsyt 8 років тому +31

      Or was it? That's what they want you to believe, blown fuses...

  • @Tarkus_H
    @Tarkus_H 9 років тому +3177

    I don't know what it is, but there's just something about the looping speaking that's so creepy.

    • @notmyname3487
      @notmyname3487 9 років тому +53

      I know what you mean.

    • @DrizzyGames
      @DrizzyGames 8 років тому +62

      +Iambic Pentameter It is also funny you gotta admit "I can't Why can't I"

    • @digstrememcdingus1463
      @digstrememcdingus1463 8 років тому +44

      it seems like he's still alive

    • @lizzygrizxy
      @lizzygrizxy 7 років тому +45

      I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I I can’t why can’t I

    • @ZaccoOfficial
      @ZaccoOfficial 6 років тому +33

      I'm scared of the words like, that girl saying donna has left the librar its so creepy

  • @lulub517
    @lulub517 4 роки тому +613

    These things scared me more than weeping angels. Having multiple shadows and the enemy being a swarm that looks exactly like shadows, not to mention the repeating words and moving skeleton chasing them slowly.

    • @flargarbason1740
      @flargarbason1740 2 роки тому +21

      No doubt. The weeping angels are kinda lame. The only cool thing about them is them turning to stone when seen. A swarm that disguised itself as a shadow, leaves just a skeleton, slowly creeps into light, controls the suits of dead bodies, can speak through a neural relay (as well as the whole ghosting thing in general). The whole idea of having two shadows being a sign they’re on you is terrifyingly awesome

    • @X3H3X
      @X3H3X 2 роки тому

      and the fact they could kill you before you even scream

    • @themusicboy9766
      @themusicboy9766 2 роки тому +8

      @@flargarbason1740 I think there both cool in there aspects

    • @swostikasharma9647
      @swostikasharma9647 Рік тому +2

      It's the weeping angels for me 😭 They're more scarier to me... When I first watched that episode I thought "THAT'S SUCH A COOL CHARACTER CONCEPT"....I wasn't even scared more like impressed....
      I got nightmares that night about them chasing me . 😂😭

  • @InsanityVirus
    @InsanityVirus 6 років тому +686

    "Donna Noble has left the library. Donna Noble has been Saved." Gives me chills every time

  • @aquawaveseafaring
    @aquawaveseafaring 9 років тому +581

    Just mix a hint of "Hey, who turned out the lights?" and 3/4 lbs of "Donna Noble has left the library. Donna Noble has been saved." and Viola! Instant nightmares!

    • @oabuseer
      @oabuseer 7 років тому +8

      Aqua033 "Viola" 😂

    • @manio_e
      @manio_e 4 роки тому +5

      Aloix voila*

    • @FalonGrey
      @FalonGrey 3 роки тому +7

      "Hey, who turned out the Donna Noble?"

  • @StagBusterSJ05
    @StagBusterSJ05 9 років тому +998

    I think this was the scariest episode of tennant' sera as dr who. Mostly because of the intimidating repetition after their deaths....and skeletons

    • @heatherrockwell9012
      @heatherrockwell9012 8 років тому +20

      Most scary episode ever, on the other hand, was Listen.

    • @StagBusterSJ05
      @StagBusterSJ05 8 років тому +1

      Awesome

    • @mjh-xp2ez
      @mjh-xp2ez 6 років тому +28

      Midnight on par with this

    • @sarahaconley7361
      @sarahaconley7361 5 років тому +27

      Waters of mars scared me so much as a kid 😨😨

    • @ihateeverythingisgood8138
      @ihateeverythingisgood8138 5 років тому +5

      Russel T Davies and Moffat are both brilliant at writing horror but we haven’t seen Chibnall embrace the scary side of doctor who yet

  • @SilveerStarr
    @SilveerStarr 13 років тому +220

    That moment when Donna's face shows up on that statue almost made me cry the first time I saw this.

  • @Domihork
    @Domihork 9 років тому +1655

    Shame that Ten didn't at least ask Eleven "And by the way, how's River?" in the 50th...

    • @kurisutori6186
      @kurisutori6186 9 років тому +22

      +Domihork ooo Right in the gut!

    • @ТимкаПанин
      @ТимкаПанин 8 років тому +64

      maybe, tenth doctor in the 50th anniversary didn't met donna second time? He's 904 in the 50th.

    • @Domihork
      @Domihork 8 років тому +63

      Тимка Панин He's 906 in the 50th and it's most probably right before End of Time, because in the begining of End of Time, he suggests he had something Elisabeth I. on his way to Oods

    • @ТимкаПанин
      @ТимкаПанин 8 років тому +29

      Domihork tenth said in the 50th that he is 904 years old. He said that to the rabbit, when he think that rabbit is disguised zygon. Pardon my bad english.

    • @jonathancollins1075
      @jonathancollins1075 8 років тому +13

      10th doctor is the last doctor river sees

  • @Girly_tbr
    @Girly_tbr 3 роки тому +147

    I love how both River & jack got a chance to use the “squareness gun”

  • @Victor-056
    @Victor-056 3 роки тому +670

    What makes this scene more horrifying is that when Doctor tells Dave to turn around, pay attention to his Life Meter before the violent Spasm.
    It's already at three bars. The Vastha Narada had already started eating Dave even BEFORE they rendered him a skeleton.

    • @RealCoolstriker64
      @RealCoolstriker64 Рік тому +204

      That’s not a “life meter.”
      It doesn’t start going down until you’re ghosting: IE: already dead.
      So the *actual* horrifying reveal was that Dave didn’t turn around.
      *The swarm did.*

    • @rioking4914
      @rioking4914 Рік тому +15

      ​@@RealCoolstriker64Thats even worse 😭

    • @NtoTheM
      @NtoTheM Рік тому +15

      That doesn't really work out. The spasms served a purpose.
      They just made a mistake and had the wrong lights already set before it should've been.

    • @exstacc1886
      @exstacc1886 11 місяців тому +19

      ​@@NtoTheMsee, I'd believe that, but in the prior scene, the camera is maneuvered to avoid showing the bar before he turns around

    • @NtoTheM
      @NtoTheM 11 місяців тому

      I'd agree, but then the spasms would be pointless. The guy was also communicating normally right before and only started acting as the entity would after the spasms, so before that he was fine.
      @@exstacc1886

  • @ggmrgameanddraw
    @ggmrgameanddraw 8 років тому +268

    This episode was so terrifying but yet so amazing. It gave me nightmares and a whole new appreciation for the Doctor's strength and speed.

  • @sarahkessler9657
    @sarahkessler9657 9 років тому +1381

    When the lights go out at your school like a power outage, say hey, who turned out the lights? That's how to spot a whovian.

    • @TheSkully343
      @TheSkully343 7 років тому +65

      Or that the Vashta Nerada's got them.

    • @damienferz2086
      @damienferz2086 7 років тому +45

      Or a bad school if you're constantly having power outages.

    • @giratinagamer5624
      @giratinagamer5624 6 років тому +15

      Clever.

    • @emmahart9166
      @emmahart9166 5 років тому +9

      @@damienferz2086 or Australia, where every single school you go to has at *least* one outage per year

    • @OneBiasedOpinion
      @OneBiasedOpinion 5 років тому +11

      What, by who freaks out and starts bolting for the nearest exit? Poor sods do the same thing when you sneak one of those angel statues from a cemetary into their room...

  • @masterchief272
    @masterchief272 2 роки тому +85

    There’s an easter egg in Fallout New Vegas’ DLC where things called Trauma Override Harness were made to retrieve injured soldiers to their base. However, it was a work in progress and it couldn’t detect if the body was alive or dead. If you have a trait called Wild wasteland and you’re in a specific facility, one of them will yell out “Hey, who turned out the Lights?”

  • @tamakitono
    @tamakitono 10 років тому +335

    River instinct is to hold the doctor´s hand while running from Danger T__T my feels

  • @Willllow
    @Willllow 9 років тому +529

    Vashta Nerada, what a wonderful phrase!

    • @meenakshious
      @meenakshious 9 років тому +80

      Vashta Nerada, ain't no passing craze!

    • @Willllow
      @Willllow 9 років тому +103

      It means no organs, for the rest of your days!

    • @meenakshious
      @meenakshious 9 років тому +88

      It's our flesh-free philosophy! The Vashta Nerada!

    • @shakibzz
      @shakibzz 9 років тому +25

      you guys xD

    • @THEghost13579
      @THEghost13579 9 років тому +13

      +Willmo Rolfe I... can't. Why can't I....

  • @leahwilkins8012
    @leahwilkins8012 7 років тому +139

    I did the "Hey, who turned out the lights?" when the prof hit them to show a clip and I heard some voices go "DON'T YOU START"

  • @physicsimpossible73
    @physicsimpossible73 9 років тому +998

    Why can't Steven Moffat write more episodes like this? This double episode was amazing, I want more! The Vashta Nerada need to return!

    • @rickyray2794
      @rickyray2794 9 років тому +54

      +Epicnerd73 Midnight and The Water of Mars episodes were spooky as hell and awesome.

    • @GammaProtogolin
      @GammaProtogolin 9 років тому +3

      +Ricky Ray I wish there was more episodes on the midnight monster.

    • @ggmrgameanddraw
      @ggmrgameanddraw 8 років тому +5

      Too bad Moffat left the show...

    • @digstrememcdingus1463
      @digstrememcdingus1463 8 років тому +4

      well the next writer can always bring the vashta nerada into an episode like lets say doctor who and the sontarans/daleks make a truce to escape from the vashta nerada or a sciencist captures the alien from knightmare and exposes it to vashta nerada to see what happens to it and both work together to escape and the doctor has to stop them

    • @Heligoland360
      @Heligoland360 7 років тому +5

      I'm glad Moffat left. He fucked up the series.

  • @thestoffelytoff
    @thestoffelytoff Рік тому +102

    This is absolutely terrifying, but donna’s face haphazardly stuck onto the robot at the end just kills me every time 😂😂

  • @azameroski
    @azameroski 5 років тому +41

    Can we just talk about how at about 2:07 River grabs the Doctor's hand as she's saying "Run!"

  • @Blackstaff425
    @Blackstaff425 10 років тому +923

    Why can't Moffat write like this all the time.

  • @jhonnymark7581
    @jhonnymark7581 4 роки тому +24

    0:11 And so, a legend is born.

  • @digitalutopia1
    @digitalutopia1 11 років тому +65

    This.
    While a particular creature can be pretty creepy in itself, it's the setting that really seals the deal. In this case, what really made the Vashta Nerada a threat - was the fact that it was an entire planet filled with books, from the trees they called home - and since it was abandoned, they didn't have any food. Anywhere else, they'd be nothing more scary than the flesh eating termites they normally are. .

  • @cherry.bakewell8973
    @cherry.bakewell8973 9 років тому +25

    I watched this for the first time when I was 11, I couldn't go to sleep with the lights off for months.

  • @Chubs.
    @Chubs. 9 років тому +139

    this was when moffat was good

    • @uscman
      @uscman 5 років тому +3

      When he was restrained a bit when RTD was show runner

    • @galarstar052
      @galarstar052 4 роки тому +5

      @@uscman he was always good. Even as showrunner

    • @hollywark2885
      @hollywark2885 4 роки тому +2

      @@galarstar052 Nah Moffat had good ideas for his era but the execution was terrible

    • @galarstar052
      @galarstar052 4 роки тому +3

      @@hollywark2885 nah, it was executed well.

    • @TheRock-dp3vh
      @TheRock-dp3vh 4 роки тому +2

      @@galarstar052 Series 5 was Moffat’s best series. Series 6 and Series 7 both started strong but went downhill in the second half, S7 especially. Then S8-10 was an inconsistent mess, with a few standout episodes to keep people interested.

  • @necromech_
    @necromech_ 4 роки тому +52

    It still manages to be disturbing, even with the goofiest looking skeleton mask in existence.

  • @FaravusGaming
    @FaravusGaming Рік тому +4

    ...I feel like he thought River might be a future regeneration in that moment, haha

  • @baileyginn1700
    @baileyginn1700 9 років тому +25

    This episode is so sad but the constant repetition of "hey! Who turned out the lights?" Makes it kind of funny.

  • @abraxos2413
    @abraxos2413 3 роки тому +13

    This was the first episode of Who I watched (I was eight years old and was over at a friends for a sleepover) and I couldn’t sleep without the light on for about 4 years after this. It wasn’t until recently that I got up the courage to watch Who again.

  • @zantelrus9211
    @zantelrus9211 3 роки тому +25

    I've seen this episode so many times, it's my favourite Doctor Who stories but I never noticed that little bit where River and the Doctor hold hands

  • @yshrenianknight2516
    @yshrenianknight2516 6 років тому +22

    This episode is one of my favorites. It even has a ton more meaning now that weve been shown the singing towers

  • @cesaragenberg6819
    @cesaragenberg6819 6 років тому +25

    This is the last time River meets the doctor. Time can be a little wobbly.

  • @sypherz2592
    @sypherz2592 9 років тому +53

    Hey who turned out the lights had me dying laughing.

    • @narcissismincarnate9201
      @narcissismincarnate9201 6 років тому

      When I was little it scared the B’jesus out of me.

    • @aSleepyPenguin
      @aSleepyPenguin 6 років тому +1

      I was laughing so hard at the time.
      I was saying "WTH IS THIS XD!!!"

    • @Saznaki
      @Saznaki 3 роки тому

      Its how calm the voice is when saying it 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @mamiedubingo
      @mamiedubingo 3 роки тому

      It's nervous 💀

  • @Cyber_Striker
    @Cyber_Striker 10 років тому +47

    I love the music that starts at 1:54 I just really love it so much. Anyone know if there is a soundtrack for this?

  • @Josh2219
    @Josh2219 9 років тому +682

    Now these were the good Moffat stories. Unlike the trash we get these days.

    • @mellowsign
      @mellowsign 9 років тому +27

      +Josh221
      I think Heaven Sent more than redeemed him.
      (I know your comment is older than that episode)

    • @thatweirdkidstudios930
      @thatweirdkidstudios930 9 років тому +12

      This wasn't Moffatt. Moffatt was introduced with the 11th Doctor.

    • @con8200
      @con8200 9 років тому +75

      +ThatWeirdKid Studios This was Moffat. He wrote a good handful of stories before he became show runner; The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances, The Girl In the Fireplace, Blink and Silence In the Library/Forrest of the Dead.

    • @Spenfen
      @Spenfen 9 років тому +35

      +Josh221 hey, he still writes good individual stories. Case in point: Impossible Astronaut/Day of the Moon, Listen, Dark Water/Death in Heaven, and Heaven Sent. The real problem is with his showrunning. He loves to create massively overcomplicated plot arcs that interweave several stories. But while he's great at doing that when he has 45 or 90 minutes to work with, he gets WAY too excited when he has an entire series to work with. On top of that, he's chosen some less-than-perfect writers for the show (Stephen Thompson and Chris Chibnall) and many of his episodes for series 6 and 7 sucked because they tried too hard to play into the over-arching narrative of the season, and we've seen with those two seasons that this style doesn't work with Doctor Who: as a result, he's returned to the RTD-style plot arcs where something is just mentioned several times throughout the season but it never plays significantly into the plot of the episode until the finale (holy HELL that was a long sentence). And series 8 and 9 proved that Moffat knows how to run the show like this, even if he may have done some extremely divisive things in this past season finale.
      Tl;dr: Moffat still writes good episodes, he's just bad at doing massive, over-complicated series-long plot arcs.

    • @con8200
      @con8200 9 років тому +2

      I still like a few of Moffat's stories, but not many of them as he is too busy trying to put plot arcs and stuff in them that he isn't focused on the individual story. I liked The Impossible Astronaut/Day of the Moon and hated Dark Water/Death In Heaven and Heaven Sent/Hell Bent.

  • @necromech_
    @necromech_ 2 роки тому +9

    from 0:39 onwards, nice little disturbing ost sting they made for this scene, with the bass guitar, perfectly fits the scene

  • @PsionNinja
    @PsionNinja 11 років тому +54

    shit hiding in shadows is far scarier that those lame angels....

    • @MasterViseOMG
      @MasterViseOMG 10 років тому +4

      They dont hide in shadows, they are shadows

    • @dannyboi5887
      @dannyboi5887 9 років тому +10

      MasterViseOMG they aren't. they millions of tiny micro organisms that form shadow like shapes. they themselves live in real shadows

  • @pupseus
    @pupseus 8 місяців тому +3

    This episode scared me so much at 12 yo that I still remember the "hey who turned out the lights" perfectly from this even though I haven't watched this in 8 years

  • @StillJustDreaming
    @StillJustDreaming 6 років тому +10

    Love the look on the Doctor's face when he sees River use her squareness gun.

  • @digitalutopia1
    @digitalutopia1 11 років тому +19

    That theory goes well beyond that - if you pay attention during 11's run, it's possible that they lay out Jacks entire fate, on how he ended up becoming the "Face of Boe".

  • @lissethdesousa9939
    @lissethdesousa9939 Рік тому +3

    "Hey! Who turned out the lights?!"
    Me: It's catchy just listening to it.

  • @dinieland
    @dinieland 10 років тому +65

    Hey, who turned off the light..

  • @ussbased-a7074
    @ussbased-a7074 7 років тому +43

    "Donna Noble has left the library"
    "Donna Noble has been saved"
    "Donna Noble has left the library"
    "Donna Noble has been saved"
    "Donna Noble has left the library"
    "Donna Noble has been saved"
    "Donna Noble has left the library"
    "Donna Noble has been saved"

  • @frenchprint
    @frenchprint 6 років тому +3

    the first doctor who episode I ever saw! nearly 10 years later and a bigger and bigger fan of the show everyday!

  • @SimpleWolfStudios
    @SimpleWolfStudios 6 років тому +4

    This episode scarred me for Years when I was younger, I ran like the bloody wind every time I saw the shadows edge towards me

  • @digitalutopia1
    @digitalutopia1 11 років тому +11

    Basically...Timey Wimey.
    More specifically - Moffat can't tell the future, so at the time he wrote that episode, he assumed that Tennant would still be the Doctor, and thus, still be using the same Sonic Screwdriver, by the time he/they were finished with River's story.
    However, obviously - Matt Smith became the Doctor, complete with a new sonic design. Beyond that though, they kept her dialog vague enough in that episode, and developed her character enough, so that her words still make sense

  • @andybrookes3519
    @andybrookes3519 Місяць тому +2

    “Are you my mummy”
    “Hey, who turned out the lights”
    “My arms are too long”
    Sentences that will haunt you forever 😮

  • @GreenNekoProductions
    @GreenNekoProductions 7 років тому +24

    1:01 Anyone else notice the USB plug?

  • @RenardeBlanche
    @RenardeBlanche 11 років тому +11

    There's a theory that River's gun actually is the gun that Jack had. He didn't have it on him in "Parting of the ways" which means it was on the Tardis, where River could have found and taken it.

    • @MovieMagic515
      @MovieMagic515 4 роки тому +1

      Well he had a Sonic disruptor she had a squareness gun.

  • @CWSSje
    @CWSSje 12 років тому +12

    Wait till you see an episode called "Midnight"

  • @vasp99
    @vasp99 3 роки тому +3

    I know nothing about cinematography but I love the production qualities of this episode , stunning and classic .

  • @jackrogers5308
    @jackrogers5308 4 роки тому +14

    The ending bit is creepy but what I never got was earlier in the episode it's mentioned the faces are "skin graphs" which made me assume they took a physical human face and put it on there. If all of Donna was downloaded into the planet's core, how can her physical face be on the speaker stands?

    • @MovieMagic515
      @MovieMagic515 4 роки тому +1

      Maybe her one was imitated holographically.

  • @MayhemMaker007
    @MayhemMaker007 11 років тому +37

    Does anybody know what that music is that starts at 1:56?

  • @susan6834
    @susan6834 2 роки тому +1

    never turning the lights off now

  • @htmlman1
    @htmlman1 11 років тому +10

    vashta nerada + weeping angels = best. thing. ever.

  • @literallyanangrymoose7717
    @literallyanangrymoose7717 Місяць тому +2

    God above, watching the suit shaking and knowing full well what's happening inside is legitimate nightmare fuel.

  • @casualcraftman1599
    @casualcraftman1599 7 років тому +41

    If the statues have human faces and the Vashta Nerada eat meat, Why don't the Vashta Nerada eat the human faces on the statues?

    • @eeyorepiglet3131
      @eeyorepiglet3131 7 років тому +9

      "Donna Noble has left the library." So her face is a projection I think?

    • @steliosstamatialis8169
      @steliosstamatialis8169 7 років тому +9

      I think it would be like having an entire roast chicken in front of you and eating only the skin; it's not exactly a proper meal!

    • @Blazieth
      @Blazieth 4 роки тому +9

      @@eeyorepiglet3131 Most likely. Donna was still very much alive; she had merely been "saved", mentally within the Library's database, while her body was presumably stored somewhere safe. They wouldn't *literally* take her face off of her body to use here; it's almost certainly just using her likeness.

    • @Spartan11117777
      @Spartan11117777 3 роки тому

      I imagine a bunch of Nanites replicating her face.

    • @Ami-vh7sr
      @Ami-vh7sr 3 роки тому +1

      It's because the faces aren't meat but a recreation using inorganic matter.....

  • @LorenAguilar
    @LorenAguilar 10 років тому +97

    oh no here come the nightmares from fallout new vegas

  • @gregs7519
    @gregs7519 Місяць тому +2

    I have absolutely no idea what any of that was

  • @AstroFalcon_Z
    @AstroFalcon_Z 2 роки тому +1

    This episode was filmed in the building I work at

  • @terrortower666
    @terrortower666 9 років тому +10

    "can't see a ruddy thing" , that made me laught for ages.

  • @r3n3gad33
    @r3n3gad33 8 років тому +6

    Am I the only one who cried when I saw Donna at the end?

  • @PCCphoenix
    @PCCphoenix 5 років тому +5

    "Hey, who turned out the lights?"
    *RUUUUUUUUNNNN!!!!*

  • @Sarah_Sparkles
    @Sarah_Sparkles 11 років тому +5

    a skeleton in a suit being possessed by flesh eating shadows chasing you down at the slowest pace possible.......well if that isnt the creepiest thing besides the weeping angels i ever saw

  • @YellawayHD
    @YellawayHD 6 років тому +1

    This two parter is my favourite in all of new who. Honestly I think this scared me more than blink. The looping speech haunted my dreams for ages

  • @miroslavzima8856
    @miroslavzima8856 7 років тому +2

    Definitely one of the most chilling episodes.

  • @carmody3155
    @carmody3155 4 роки тому +2

    I remember seeing this as a kid and its given me an extreme fear of shadows til today

  • @OfficialMecaton
    @OfficialMecaton Рік тому +1

    This reminds me of the spiderman 3 deleted scene where venom ate eddie and left his bones behind in a deleted scene 😮

  • @ethangomez166
    @ethangomez166 6 років тому +6

    I wish doctor who can be good like this again

  • @hargous
    @hargous Місяць тому +1

    My local tv used to put these episodes around midnight when everybody else is asleep and night is quiet. Like they planned it.

  • @พชรประเสริฐสุข

    Guys who turned out the lights?

  • @skelly1004
    @skelly1004 5 років тому +5

    I thought this was a nightmare I had as a child.

  • @crazymurdav
    @crazymurdav 9 років тому +10

    Why end JUST before the cliffhanger? Extra 20-25 seconds max and they don't show it :/

  • @plonker007
    @plonker007 5 років тому +2

    This episode scared the hell out of me when I was younger. And I miss the actor.

  • @drkreuzer670
    @drkreuzer670 2 роки тому +1

    Damn, he's gone BAD TO THE BONE!

  • @Mango_mahogany
    @Mango_mahogany 5 років тому +2

    0:57 you pause the video but you still hear it

  • @kimdkus
    @kimdkus 12 років тому +1

    AND DON'T BLINK!! DO. NOT. BLINK!!!

  • @djfrozen4534
    @djfrozen4534 8 років тому +7

    This was the most scariest episide ever from doctor who i had nightmares when i was a kid about this episode when it was broadcast live and i still have nightmares till this day all i can think of in my head is those white statue things and the scenarey

  • @LordMoonshadowGaGa
    @LordMoonshadowGaGa 11 років тому +2

    I thought it was just the same gun tech, but since Jack is from a further time period, his gun is more advanced and able to return the matter.

  • @bananasaregood8655
    @bananasaregood8655 3 роки тому +1

    When doctor who could be genuinely unnerving

  • @TERMINATIONBLISS08
    @TERMINATIONBLISS08 4 роки тому

    This is #1 in "Vids that end 10 seconds too soon, and prevent absolute terror"

  • @KayleighNatasha
    @KayleighNatasha 8 років тому +1

    I swear everytime the Vashta Nerada attack Dave or he lays his hands on the doctor's shoulders, I jump out of my skin

  • @Astrithor
    @Astrithor 5 років тому +9

    The revival created some amazing enemies

  • @RoundusMongus
    @RoundusMongus Рік тому +2

    Hypothetically, if you just left the planet abandoned for long enough, wouldn’t they starve to death?

    • @JackRogers-x9e
      @JackRogers-x9e 8 місяців тому +2

      Yes but you’d have to do so for a very, very long time. Judging by how these creatures are portrayed, they don’t seem to need much energy/calories to keep themselves alive. So they could probably last hundreds of thousands if not millions of years, much like bacteria.

    • @skilledarma
      @skilledarma 5 місяців тому

      Considering the library was “empty” for 100 years, I think we can assume they don’t easily starve

  • @minatsuki2575
    @minatsuki2575 2 роки тому +1

    This is my favorite Doctor Who episode.

  • @notaphycologyst6644
    @notaphycologyst6644 Рік тому +1

    Dave really just said 💀

  • @menslady125eif2590
    @menslady125eif2590 9 років тому +12

    SPOOKY, spooky, spooky, spooky!

  • @Enivri
    @Enivri 3 роки тому +1

    0:38 what I tell people when they ask if I’m ok
    0:48 what my brain is saying

  • @projectkepleren
    @projectkepleren 7 років тому +4

    2:00
    the best soundtrack

    • @MovieMagic515
      @MovieMagic515 4 роки тому

      I wish i knew the song's name.

    • @projectkepleren
      @projectkepleren 2 роки тому +1

      @@MovieMagic515 it's the subwave network

    • @evanmcclellan5878
      @evanmcclellan5878 Рік тому

      ​@projectkepleren thank you so much 2 days listening to every official doctor who track from season 1 to four just for this😁😁😁😁

  • @_pestilence____5657
    @_pestilence____5657 3 роки тому +3

    Can anyone please tell me what is the song playing in 1:24 can anyone please tell me.

  • @cdsky3
    @cdsky3 12 років тому +4

    I grew up watching Dr. Who. The only episode that ever gave me nightmares was when the spiders who controlled the people were hanging on the peoples backs. That STILL freaks me out! I wanted to be a Darlek for Halloween so badly when I was kid!

  • @marcusreading3783
    @marcusreading3783 4 роки тому

    Soooo yeah, this very clip was one of the first ever bits of Doctor Who I ever saw back when I was a kid. I was at a friends house and it was on and this tiny bit freaked me out.

  • @Gamemaniac92711
    @Gamemaniac92711 13 років тому +1

    @becketto Two flaws: One, his regeneration takes too long and would merely draw out the pain
    Two: A Regeneration would merely make them more of a target because it's more to eat.
    Three: He has limited amounts of regenerations.

  • @mimilook4347
    @mimilook4347 4 роки тому +1

    The man: *is obviously not ok*
    Doctor: Are you ok?

  • @tobyfrance7520
    @tobyfrance7520 7 років тому +6

    What is the music called that is used when he is chasing them?

  • @merten0083
    @merten0083 Рік тому

    I remember watching this episode on Netflix at like 3AM binging Doctor Who, alone, it scared the hell out of me.

  • @yusaalyssum6761
    @yusaalyssum6761 8 років тому +14

    I was cry when I watch this part

    • @Burgunderwacht
      @Burgunderwacht 8 років тому +1

      ben riverin ölümünde ağladım kim oldugunu bilmedigim halde...

    • @joedjrjd3652
      @joedjrjd3652 5 років тому

      You cant spell bud

    • @Bignfluffy
      @Bignfluffy 5 років тому

      present_yusa I was cry when I see this cringe worthy comment

  • @the_infinexos
    @the_infinexos 7 місяців тому +1

    Scary thing is they had eaten his eyeballs so fast and painlessly he didn't know it was too late

    • @blackqweenmars
      @blackqweenmars 6 місяців тому +4

      I don’t think they ate his eyeballs. I think they swarmed in front of his face so he couldn’t see.