Doctor Who: EVERY Version Of The Doctor Explained

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 тра 2024
  • The Doctor has lived many lives - many more than you might've realised.
    For more awesome content, check out: whatculture.com/topic/doctor-who
    Follow us on Instagram: / whoculture
    Catch us on Twitter: / whoculture
    #DoctorWho #TheDoctor #Explained
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 531

  • @benpecto.benpecillton
    @benpecto.benpecillton Місяць тому +391

    Crazy how the 2nd Doctor regenerated so hard that the world gained color

    • @Donnagata1409
      @Donnagata1409 Місяць тому +9

      Yes, incredible...

    • @igorschmidlapp6987
      @igorschmidlapp6987 Місяць тому +16

      Maybe he regenerated from Kansas to Oz? ;-P

    • @medafan53
      @medafan53 Місяць тому +15

      I believe a novel, possibly Day of the Doctor or Twice Upon a Time, implied that the first two Doctors were colourblind.

    • @Avantall05
      @Avantall05 Місяць тому +8

      ​@@medafan53YES, I'm reading Day of the Doctor, and it does say that about those two

    • @Melina_Evarblume_Seelie
      @Melina_Evarblume_Seelie Місяць тому

      It's not quite how colourblindness works, but that is such a cool and creative theory. My guy regenerated his eyesight ​@@medafan53

  • @lulu480
    @lulu480 Місяць тому +310

    I am shocked the story of Doctor Moon completely escaped me. I’ve watched Riversong’s story arc so many times and that never occurred to me.

    • @scottfromspace
      @scottfromspace Місяць тому +31

      Found this on the wiki: "Moffat explained that River Song was in fact the Doctor's widow, and had witnessed the death of the 45th Doctor on a battlefield before she began having adventures with his younger selves."

    • @Reginald425
      @Reginald425 Місяць тому +29

      It’s not like it’s canon or even hinted at that much, more of a head cannon that’s nice to have, but not something to be necessarily picked up on

    • @boiwifeyasmr4U
      @boiwifeyasmr4U Місяць тому +15

      @@Reginald425 A headcanon of the writer of the episode. I am not sure the term headcanon means anything when talking about the author of a work. Unless we are playing death of the author

    • @katrose5179
      @katrose5179 Місяць тому +10

      @@boiwifeyasmr4UIf it’s not explicitly there, it’s not canon.

    • @evagrius13
      @evagrius13 Місяць тому +7

      Canon in Doctor Who... 😅😂

  • @findtheblue
    @findtheblue Місяць тому +173

    "you didn't expect that one did you" he is in the thumbnail

  • @Logotu
    @Logotu Місяць тому +54

    Don’t forget Merlin is an incarnation of the Doctor as seen in Battlefield! (Coincidentally, in legend Merlin is half human on his mother’s side!)

    • @patrickpablo217
      @patrickpablo217 Місяць тому

      True but we never see that incarnation, right?

    • @JohnSmith-hh6hg
      @JohnSmith-hh6hg Місяць тому +2

      ​@@patrickpablo217I would say not yet

    • @geocachingwomble
      @geocachingwomble 24 дні тому

      @@JohnSmith-hh6hgI would think it was the 7th doctor because of how he was recognised as Merlin during battlefield

    • @frankshailes3205
      @frankshailes3205 20 днів тому

      @@geocachingwomble Ancelyn specifically says he doesn't recognise his face, but knows he has had many faces. The novelisation says he had red hair as Merlin, though Ten complains he has never been ginger yet. So it's a future incarnation, or perhaps an alternative universe one.
      ANCELYN: Oh, he has many faces, but in my reckoning, he is Merlin.
      DOCTOR: You recognise my face, then?
      ANCELYN: No, not your aspect, but your manner that betrays you. Do you not ride the ship of time? Does it not deceive the senses being larger within than out?

    • @stuff2227
      @stuff2227 19 днів тому +1

      @@frankshailes3205 this video explained that the Doctor had many incarnations before the "1st Doctor" and based on the fugitive Doctor he doesn't remember them or at least some of them. maybe merlin is one of those

  • @RetroBonesMA
    @RetroBonesMA Місяць тому +110

    OMG it just dawned on me… the Curator is a retired Doctor that’s done adventuring. 14 being worn out and needing to chill, now living with Donna. 14 BECOMES THE CURATOR 😭😭

    • @brendan.coyle2
      @brendan.coyle2 Місяць тому +8

      ooh that’s an interesting theory

    • @BlakeGamer-qy6ve
      @BlakeGamer-qy6ve Місяць тому +4

      Good guess but actually no, kinda? I mean yes but 15 also does, 14 regenerates into 15.

    • @RetroBonesMA
      @RetroBonesMA Місяць тому +14

      @@BlakeGamer-qy6ve 14 bi-generates to 15. 14 retires while 15 goes off to adventure.

    • @BlakeGamer-qy6ve
      @BlakeGamer-qy6ve Місяць тому +8

      @@RetroBonesMA yes, when 14 dies I presume he gets plucked from time back to the bi-generation as 15.

    • @RetroBonesMA
      @RetroBonesMA Місяць тому +3

      @@BlakeGamer-qy6ve that makes no sense

  • @maldaror7097
    @maldaror7097 Місяць тому +75

    Sacha Dhawan got a mention but does deserver his own title, he was the Doctor for a hot minute.

    • @dylanziesing6122
      @dylanziesing6122 Місяць тому +7

      The Master Doctor yeah.

    • @Daikon_Micucci
      @Daikon_Micucci 29 днів тому +1

      Isn't he also of the Timeless Child's unknown race, or was that only because he became the Doctor for a moment?

    • @matthewparker5277
      @matthewparker5277 25 днів тому +3

      ​@Daikon_Micucci no he's just a regular gallifreyan and he's pissed because his regeneration power comes from the doctor and not naturally occurring like they were told

  • @j.rileyindependentproductions
    @j.rileyindependentproductions Місяць тому +21

    The way I headcanon the Vaelyard is actually due to Matt Smith's original 11th Doctor that still exists OUTSIDE of the Universe. See, when he restarted the Universe, The Doctor that appeared in THAT Universe was THAT Universe's Doctor, the one Amy "recreated" because she remembered him. She was able to remember into existence, not pull from outside. That leaves the previous one outside, forgotten. The Doctor, always afraid of death, yet also seeing the bad parts of his personality growing in his isolation (plus dealing with all his guilt as he'd not helped the War Doctor in this timeline), would experiment to separate those feelings, unknowingly creating The Valeyard.
    We could even suggest that what the 14th Doctor did at the edge of the universe was what allowed the Valeyard back in. Also possible even the previous 11th Doctor squeezed back in, who, through experimentation may not have been able to fully regenerate, but had reverse-engineered Degeneration, eventually becoming the Curator.

  • @AC3handle
    @AC3handle Місяць тому +18

    I'm a little disappointed that you didn't mention about how Capaldi's Doctor was having issues with his face, until he remembered that it was his 10th incarnation who saved the man and his family, from Pompeii who he would end up looking like.
    Also of note is the 10th DOctor is also the most unforgiving Doctor, to where he punished each member of the Family of Blood.

    • @frankshailes3205
      @frankshailes3205 20 днів тому +1

      I wonder why the first Doctor didn't angst about being identical to the Abbot of Amboise, and the second didn't have an identity crisis over Salamander? Let alone the fifth worrying about looking exactly like his antagonist, Commander Maxil.

    • @TheClarksonFan
      @TheClarksonFan 2 дні тому

      Have to say I’m disappointed they didn’t acknowledge John Frobisher from Torchwood Children of Earth regarding the 12th Doctor, as someone who would/should have been saved if the Doctor was there like he was meant to be, as another reminder.

  • @GoranNewsum
    @GoranNewsum Місяць тому +72

    Still dealing with the loss of Lynda (with a Y)

    • @MichaelHeide
      @MichaelHeide Місяць тому +5

      The AI-generated subtitles refer to her as "Linda with a Why", by the way.

    • @Imogen_V
      @Imogen_V Місяць тому +11

      Not Linda with an i, she got evicted for damaging property

    • @frankshailes3205
      @frankshailes3205 20 днів тому

      @@Imogen_V This Linda has two eyes.

  • @markosborne7776
    @markosborne7776 Місяць тому +18

    The cause of death in the 7th doctor..”a lack of gun control and America’s health care system.” 😂

    • @ShinySephiroth1
      @ShinySephiroth1 Місяць тому +4

      TBF the data shows the *quality* of US healthcare, when one can get access to it, is top notch... it's just that, had he survived, the Doctor would've been in debt for life! 😂

    • @Verge63
      @Verge63 23 дні тому

      6th was the Joe Besser of drs

  • @josephcooter5763
    @josephcooter5763 Місяць тому +33

    This just in. Breaking News Tecteun has been named Galifrey's Mother of the Year.

  • @chrisbellon3739
    @chrisbellon3739 Місяць тому +19

    You forgot about the Richard e grant version of 9th doctor for early 2000's web cartoons made by bbc

    • @samanthab1923
      @samanthab1923 Місяць тому +3

      I love him. He was great in LOKI 😂

    • @marionbaggins
      @marionbaggins Місяць тому +1

      @@samanthab1923 Amen. Classic Loki was the GOAT!!!

  • @olirothers
    @olirothers 18 днів тому +2

    Seeing Doctor Moon on this list would’ve been the biggest plot twist in WhoCulture history if they hadn’t put him on the thumbnail

  • @mikemullen8174
    @mikemullen8174 Місяць тому +11

    The Sixth Doctor's regeneration was so bad that the BBC greenlit Big Finish to retcon it.

  • @ftumschk
    @ftumschk Місяць тому +20

    4:10 the Morbius Doctors are only notorious in retrospect. I watched the episode at the time of transmission, and I and my fellow Doctor Who fans at home and at school found the idea of pre-Hartnell Doctors incredibly exciting.

  • @diannholland
    @diannholland Місяць тому +41

    I am SO excited for this new era. LOVE Dr Who. The Doctor Moon story was FANTASTIC! and I SO want to see more of him now that we all know!

    • @kuggacouragegx6093
      @kuggacouragegx6093 Місяць тому +5

      Now let's see the fake fans complain about Dr moon

    • @carloszarzoso1724
      @carloszarzoso1724 Місяць тому +2

      ​@@kuggacouragegx6093 who is gonna moan that makes sense. I don't like this new doctor and the p
      Splitting which makes two and time line has changed so there is two now from the start so when the child of time crap was happening they would of split again cus the toy maker changed everything so the new splits when they pass they split. And then there are the division doctors so they split now so that makes thousands of doctors million in my eyes damaged it. All I do is watch doctor who disney and woke killed it. And this singing 😢

    • @kuggacouragegx6093
      @kuggacouragegx6093 Місяць тому

      @@carloszarzoso1724 omg stfu. The doctor fused with a version of himself from an alternative future when he regenerated.
      The doctor literally made the Meta crisis yet u clowns aren't crying.
      He grew back his hand and that was a new ability they made up for the revival.
      Stupid u dint like the new doctor just cause he is black. Not a reason, that is u being racist.
      Stupid it is a time travelling show, the time lines have always been changing u idoot.
      Also the doctor is everywhere in the universe and time. Like what the 11th and 12th doctor did and howbthe doctor always met themselves many times.
      Stfu cause how tf that is even an issue.
      Also stupid, the timeless child isn't bad nor bs, it literally answers the question and explored the lore.
      U can't even get the name right.
      It isn't child of time.
      Also the timeless child didn't split anything so wtf u are talking about🤦‍♂️.
      Dude stfu.
      Wtf u are even talking about. All u been doing is just saying split multiple times.
      Stupid the bi generation only happened cause of the toymaker u idiot.
      Stfu and stop reaching.
      Also stfu cause no one is splitting.
      Also dummy. There are infinite incarnations, meaning infinite doctors.
      Infinite versions of themselves.
      Stop reaching
      Stupid how tf diseny and woke have to do with this? When there is not a single thing Disney nor woke about what happened at all u idiot.
      Also no, u don't watch doctor who.
      U can't even get basic names right nor how the show works.

  • @ofskittlez
    @ofskittlez Місяць тому +24

    I love how care-free the 15th Doctor seems. I like to say, he left his trauma at Donna's house.

    • @gilgameshofuruk4060
      @gilgameshofuruk4060 Місяць тому +9

      Give it time. Call me sceptical, but it seems to me that no modern drama can go for long without finding that the central character has a dark secret, hidden pain, blah, blah.
      I do hope I'm wrong here, though.

    • @ofskittlez
      @ofskittlez Місяць тому +11

      @@gilgameshofuruk4060 No you're quite right. We've already seen 15 grappling with having been abandoned/adopted. I've said this before, I was no fan of the Timeless Child plot, but I appreciate the commitment to it. I'm glad RTD isn't simply sweeping it under the rug.

  • @captainmanic
    @captainmanic 26 днів тому +3

    Matt Smith played the doctor twice. On the planet Christmas he regenerated, but he keeps the same face. This is in addition to getting the life extension mentioned.

  • @owenyowenface
    @owenyowenface Місяць тому +6

    And now,over to Strax to explain the whole thing again with added chin,hair and ear references 😂❤

  • @leeci33
    @leeci33 Місяць тому +15

    Omg. You said “the toymaker” and I immediately in my head heard “ha ha ha Ha Ha ha ha” 👀

  • @whophd
    @whophd Місяць тому +3

    I think the choices in this video were good as defined: Doctors who exist in-universe. A great companion video will be actors-based, covering all the obvious inclusions (Five Doctors, Twice Upon A Time), as well as the less obvious ones (stunt doubles in the original production, stunt doubles in the Blu-rays like Logopolis). Then you’ve got Ty Tennant (being another “First Doctor” presumably), Peter Cushing (ditto?) and all the comedy doctors outside of canon - if you list the Curse of Fatal Death, where does it end? Anyone who impersonated Tom Baker with a scarf in a TV sketch? Voice actors impersonating for computer games? Those rotating heads in Dimensions in Time? Well if we cut out comedy sketches what if we include charity specials: Then one inclusion I just rediscovered yesterday is Arabella Weir, who around the 40th anniversary (2003) played “the first female Doctor” on audio. I guess diving into Big Finish is necessary.
    The best source of information on this is a Doctor Who Magazine article a few years ago, and it lists “actors who played the Doctor” with a score for how official their contribution was. Obviously Tom Baker, David Tenannt and so on get full points.

  • @chrisandersen5635
    @chrisandersen5635 Місяць тому +6

    That! Was surprisingly well done!👍 I’ve been watching since early 1980’s, and I often just shake my head in confusion at the turns and twists of this silly show. Well, I guess I still do, but this overview is pretty succinct. Well done WhoCulture.

    • @Donnagata1409
      @Donnagata1409 Місяць тому +1

      You say "silly show" as it was something bad...🤣🤣

  • @HeatherKirksey-ls6gk
    @HeatherKirksey-ls6gk Місяць тому +2

    I know they're very much not canon, but a fun coda to this episode could perhaps include Rowan Atkinson, Joanna Lumley, Peter Cushing, and Richard E. Grant, if for no other reason than they're such brilliant performers in their own way that have touched the fandom . Maybe a Top 10 non-Doctor canon Doctors? I remember my mind being blown when I found out quite late in my own fandom that Grand Moff Tarkin had once played the Doctor, even if the films were money grabs and not exactly great examples of storytelling. I felt as though my little nerd mind had been blown to smithereens.

  • @cairneoleander8130
    @cairneoleander8130 Місяць тому +3

    I had absolutely no idea that any form of reality television existed as early as 1985 to be commented upon at all. Doctor Who FTW giving me sparkling tidbits to go research and lessen my own ignorance yet again. Never lets me down

    • @ShinySephiroth1
      @ShinySephiroth1 Місяць тому

      I thought the same

    • @botsly4u
      @botsly4u 7 днів тому

      Reality tv? I got my first Desktop Computer in 1986 from University of Central Florida with Air Force Classification documents on it, nothing interesting except for documents explaining how to deal with classified documents and on a reality flight simulator. Didn't get any info on it other than it's existence. Operated on DOS 4.01 which I learned by typing the executible programs and watching what happened. Reformatted my hd 5 times.
      prior to that it was the commodore 64 as in bytes not mega or even kilo but single bytes.
      Between the two I started with Atari type reality games, hockey, Handball, Soccer. With the computer I logged on to Bulletin Board Systems and played Trade wars and other text-based turn-based games. Most only had 1 phone line But a Pirate site in NY, Rusty and Eddies BBS had 23 phone lines and it was free you just had to hack in to become a member and the upload pirated software to remain one. Yes, software games were like the Caldron, Ultima 1-7 prior to Ultima Online which still exists now. There was a really cool game call Starflight that had you dealing with aliens in space with distinct personalities like the one that was set up as a corporation and if you were fired you would be killed as a trespasser, or the Spemin who would be timid when alone but try to take you out when they thought they out massed you. Stargate 2 came out 2023 and it is fanbased and it sucks but then the developers mever worked full time on it and since weren't paid didn't last long and it took forever to get a finished program, I think they just gave up and released a crappy version of it. then there was Compuserve, also in mid 80's. which had a lot of phone lines but charged 12.95 an hour. I would sit in front of the computer and handwrite the keyboard commands I would use, only needed the first Letter I believe, so that when I logged on I could get the most for my money. I got all my school papers from it, ie company news PRs would be released and not published in most newspapers. And my teacher with her newfangled Plagiarist program would never catch me. i would play a text-based RPG on it limiting myself to an hour. All online games were text based but you could buy reality games and load them through your 5.25" floppy drive, each one could hold 512 kilobytes. Took 40 to back up my 20 mb hd. When I got that I thought no way in hell would I ever fill that up having been used to the commodore 64's tape drive.
      There was online porn too in the form of JPG's and GIF's. Took several hours, sometimes to download one and could be printed out by my full color dot matrix printer. Just a picture. One Gif I remember is an animation of Snow White and the 7 Dwarves. Sleepy got the job of doing the deed. Or was it Sneezy?
      Then the 90's had DnD, Car Wars, Paranoia, Nech Warrior, etc. All book imagination board games without the board. Or Moral decay a game with 23 simultaneous logons allowed, on a mainframe. you play a DnD type character, but it had businesses. Completely text based. You kill a corpse it would hold the same as your pc ie Player Character could hold as it was built on the same model, 2 corpses. I figured out how to use some of the 13 macros you could create. I created a series that allowed me to indefinitely stack them. each corpse can hold 2 corpses then the corpses it was carrying could carry the same items indefinitely or until they started rotting on I think 20 or 30 minutes. then a drop all command in the front room of my corpse plant which would flood the room with all the loot those corpses were carrying, including the loot on the rotted corpses. And then shortcuts to process them in the plant into food which paid me the set fee, which I lowered to 5 silver pieces since I owned the plant. the food we sold to distilleries who turned it into beer and sold to bars which sold drinks that healed you but caused clerics to not be able to cast spells. we would make the purchases using checks so they wouldn't get confused or used as player currency. Any how a Mage i.e. developer discovered my use of the bug and one time caused the corpses to blow up when I went to stacking them and when you died in this game you came back naked and had to spend 2 hours, for me, to work your way up to the good shit. Anyhow I used a monk in my guild to spy on other business owners and when they went to hand over a check to another business owner I would, as thief, sneak in and pickpocket the check then deposit it in my business before they could kill me using pre-typed direction keys in a macro because with only 23 players it wasn't too hard to figure out who was the thief and thieve s were paperweights even back then.
      Sorry, all I got left is stories to tell and I go on too long.

  • @elzoof
    @elzoof Місяць тому +5

    I still think they missed a trick not calling the Fugitive the Ruthless Doctor.

  • @carld5329
    @carld5329 Місяць тому +2

    There are others you could have discussed as well... The movie Doctor, played by Peter Cushing, from the 60s films. Also, Rowan Atkinson (and others), from The Curse of the Fatal Death.

  • @soundgal_sine_qua_non
    @soundgal_sine_qua_non Місяць тому +16

    I'm still waiting for an episode where we see the beginnings of the Library and Dr. Moon being established so that the Doctor spending eternity in the database with their wife can be canon 😭

    • @JohnSmith-hh6hg
      @JohnSmith-hh6hg Місяць тому

      The problem is the actor who played dr. Moon and also showed up in the John wick movies died last year so we need someone who looks like him and can age in the library

    • @brewster_4
      @brewster_4 26 днів тому

      @@JohnSmith-hh6hg You're thinking of the wrong actor. The actor who played Doctor Moon in Colin Salmon. He's still alive. The actor in John Wick was Lance Reddick.

    • @botsly4u
      @botsly4u 7 днів тому

      um, wasn't there one where the dr was degenerated to pure energy form to live forever, that one where he saw his own death?

  • @michaeltortorice9876
    @michaeltortorice9876 Місяць тому +4

    If you listen carefully, and I always do, you can hear which ones are Ellie's favorites.
    If I had a gun to my head, I feel sure I could rate them in her estimation.
    But since I don't have a gun to my head, I'm not going to.
    Fun list. Hope you feel better soon.

  • @tks9119
    @tks9119 Місяць тому +1

    Another cool incarnation of the doctor is the one written by Michael Moorecock where he is the eternal champion. Loved that series and character and it felt like a natural inclusion into who lore.

  • @davidponseigo8811
    @davidponseigo8811 Місяць тому +3

    When I think of the Doctor I still think of the 4th Doctor in the classic series and the 10th in the current series.

    • @joeblow2426
      @joeblow2426 Місяць тому +1

      Commonly thought of as the two best Doctors, I believe.

  • @gilgameshofuruk4060
    @gilgameshofuruk4060 Місяць тому +1

    15 actors. Don't forget Richard Hurndall's brilliant impersonation of William Hartnell in The Five Doctors.
    And yes, I am forgetting David Bradley in that Peter Capaldi episode.

  • @noahjackson8174
    @noahjackson8174 Місяць тому +1

    i didn't know about the doctor moon theory. you forgot about richard hurndall who played the first doctor for the five doctors special, richard e grant for the time between the eight and ninth doctors, peter cushing and his two movies, david bradley for the current first doctor, micheal jones for the kid doctor in listen, and evan mccabe as brendan the previous doctor to hartnell.

  • @Vim-Wolf
    @Vim-Wolf Місяць тому +2

    Colin Salmon as the Doctor? Hell yeah.

  • @lulu480
    @lulu480 Місяць тому +19

    I don’t know how old you are but you couldn’t possibly old enough to grow up with all of classic Who. And yet you knowledge of the entire Who universe is remarkable. I’m glad I discovered WhoCulture!

    • @AmberMetallicScorpion
      @AmberMetallicScorpion Місяць тому

      as a heads up. all of classic who was available on britbox for a few years, and as of about october or november last year, it became available for free on bbc iplayer, meaning that elli had more than enough time to watch the entirety of the main series

    • @GemJam73
      @GemJam73 Місяць тому +5

      All this information is online. It's presented well though.

    • @nicko1710
      @nicko1710 Місяць тому +3

      I'm only 19 but I've seen about 70% of the entire series.

    • @lulu480
      @lulu480 Місяць тому +2

      @@GemJam73 nice not having to look it up though….

    • @lulu480
      @lulu480 Місяць тому +1

      @@nicko1710 I’m so old I’ve seen them all… 😏

  • @MrCuddy2977
    @MrCuddy2977 Місяць тому +2

    The Doctor did burn the original Mona Lisa: he burnt ONE of the original Mona Lisas!

  • @bentbliley
    @bentbliley Місяць тому +3

    i was hoping to see some non canon doctors like peter cushing and richard e grant but this was still a nice video

  • @alpinehouse9980
    @alpinehouse9980 Місяць тому +6

    it's my personal headcanon that 12 was the Doctor and the Valeyard, and that's what the Hybrid was originally meant to be about

  • @crowcoregames1785
    @crowcoregames1785 24 дні тому +1

    my headcannon is that the dreamlord is the Val yard

  • @Ro-po2ej
    @Ro-po2ej 15 днів тому +1

    Honestly I always thought that the morbius doctors were actually the past incarnations of morbius before he’s just a brain

    • @michaelschwartzmike4christ246
      @michaelschwartzmike4christ246 14 днів тому +1

      I agree so the "first appearance" of the doctor wasn't his first incarnation he had at least a full cycle of 13 lives prior because Mobius was amazed just how many lives the doctor had also if it is true that the doctor is the timeless child the he sure did live more lives many more before

  • @JohnSmith-hh6hg
    @JohnSmith-hh6hg Місяць тому +1

    You forgot to mention why the "12" Doctor (Peter Capaldi) choose this face , to remind him of someone/something
    It was the face of one man he save from Pompeji while he was the 10th doctor

  • @gregorybetters4386
    @gregorybetters4386 25 днів тому +1

    I know he was never in a TV episode but Peter Cushing deserved a mention.

    • @michealschrum6076
      @michealschrum6076 День тому

      Peter Cushing's Doctor was not connected to the Who continuity. He was a human human being and not related to the Doctor in any way.

  • @captainmanic
    @captainmanic 26 днів тому +1

    Rowen Atkinson also played the Doctor once. As did Joanna Lumley. Don't forget them!

  • @iamhungry4000
    @iamhungry4000 18 днів тому

    The Doctors didn't rewrite time when they saved Galifrey.
    It always happened, but because of the memory loss suffered from three Doctors in such close proximity, the War Doctor remembered, but when he regenerated into Christopher Eccleston's Doctor, almost immediately, the memories were lost (as stated in Day of the Doctor), so he believed he had done it. Before they leave the museum at the end they clearly state they won't remember saving Galifrey. It's literally stated in the episode in the scene where John Hurt asks which TARDIS is his.
    Time wasn't rewritten. It was such a big event involving so much time travel, energy, destruction, alteration of two universe's, AND the fact that it was the past in the Doctor's own timeline (which would result in a paradox btw), means it would have been a fixed point in time, something we know the Doctor can't change despite his best efforts.
    The fact that he regenerated into 9, then found Rose shows this was always the way events occurred even if the Doctor himself didn't know it.
    It ALWAYS happened that way, he just didn't know it from the beginning of 9 till the end of 11.

  • @XDeserak
    @XDeserak Місяць тому +1

    They could easily have meta-crisis doc return as the Valyard
    With the war doc retcon and the regeneration without changing, he could technically be said to have come into existence after the 12 incarnation of the doc.
    Was already shown to play out the doctors dark side, which is why main doc left him with rose to become a better person
    If she failed at that, or if something happened to rose and pushed him over the edge, he could easily wind up thinking the "real" doctor is too soft to get the job done, steal a tardis and go evil.
    Plus, it's not like David Tennant is in a hurry to retire from the show, and we know he can play evil characters well.
    Would make an interesting way to keep him around.

  • @chrisbailey1966
    @chrisbailey1966 Місяць тому +13

    What about Brendan the Irish police man, seen by many as an unreal Doctor now and plot device for the Timeless Children. The Timeless Children has many plot holes, should always have been a Master origin story and the fall out of it leading to Division. Then Division could have used a pre-Hartnell Doctor/s and when he found out he escapes. A much neater story arc, let's see if RTD2 tries to fix this and other problems or just says "a wizard did it".

    • @gilgameshofuruk4060
      @gilgameshofuruk4060 Місяць тому +1

      RTD has already "fixed" it. The Toymaker said "I've made a jigsaw of your life". RTD went on to say in an interview that now writers are free to come up with anything they like about the Doctor's past.
      I suppose one day we'll have some daring individual do a 'Buffy "Normal Again"' and imply the whole series has been the delusion of a mentally ill patient in hospital.

  • @slayerdemin
    @slayerdemin Місяць тому +2

    i've got one more Doctor to watch, then i'll have watched them all. Until the new season or whatever it's called.

  • @carolineskipper6976
    @carolineskipper6976 Місяць тому +2

    An excellent sprint through 60 years+ of history.....
    Heaven help anyone who comes to this as a potential new viewer in the hopes of understanding the Whoniverse though. 🤣🤣

  • @Legendary3Dgamer
    @Legendary3Dgamer Місяць тому +10

    In the thumbnail I saw dr moon and I’ve said that in comments that he’s a version of the Doctor same with the dream lord but no one believed me and finally someone gets me in as Ellie in this video 😅

    • @Melissa.Garrett
      @Melissa.Garrett Місяць тому +4

      Didn’t the Doctor actually say in the episode that the Dream Lord was an aspect of him? How could anyone not get that?

    • @Legendary3Dgamer
      @Legendary3Dgamer Місяць тому +1

      ​@@Melissa.Garrett no i don't think it was and yh i agree

    • @Melissa.Garrett
      @Melissa.Garrett Місяць тому +4

      @@Legendary3Dgamer I watched it last week, the Doctor definitely said it. 😊 I always thought the Dream Lord was a concept worth exploring again, but alas.

    • @kuggacouragegx6093
      @kuggacouragegx6093 Місяць тому +1

      Yes and no. He is one of the incarnation in his future, so it is both yes a version but he is the doctor

  • @ZoranBlackRose
    @ZoranBlackRose 20 днів тому

    Taking the timeless children and the flash back of lives from the one doctor that showed regenerations before the first matt smith was way beyond the thirteenth reincarnation lol

  • @Flytrap
    @Flytrap Місяць тому +1

    This was excellent!

  • @CalebHopkins
    @CalebHopkins Місяць тому +1

    Hearing what you said about the Curator it made me think of David Tenants 14th Doctor... I wonder if they're the same character just the 14th is the start of him eventually growing to become the Curator. 🤔

    • @ShinySephiroth1
      @ShinySephiroth1 Місяць тому +4

      I like how someone here said their headcanon is the 14th Doctor degenerates every time he dies so, by the time we see The Curator, 14 has degenerated down to 4.

    • @CalebHopkins
      @CalebHopkins Місяць тому +1

      @@ShinySephiroth1 that would actually be pretty cool 😂 and it'd back up my theory too haha

  • @Chayira1
    @Chayira1 5 днів тому +1

    Wait can The Watcher be relevant to the most recent DW episode (73 Yards)? I can feel a theory cooking in the back of my head, but I don't know yet

  • @babytails1879
    @babytails1879 28 днів тому +1

    15:41 the Doctor looks like a Ghostbuster lol

  • @ruairih100
    @ruairih100 8 днів тому

    I would have given the doctordonna (donnas version) their own spot and also the master doctor from POTD his own spot as he was officially a regeneration.
    I would have done a special mention segment with the Curse of Fatal Death doctors and the scream of the shalka doctor as , at the time of each of their broadcasts , they were canon

  • @michaeldemarco9950
    @michaeldemarco9950 18 днів тому

    “Between the Doctor’s twelfth and final incarnation” would be as David Tennent’s Doctor reluctantly regenerated into Matt Smith’s Doctor.

  • @gshaunsweeney
    @gshaunsweeney Місяць тому +2

    Can we get a video like this but of the Master?

  • @doro626
    @doro626 3 дні тому

    Thanks Who Culture. I needed that!

  • @ChrisEllorris
    @ChrisEllorris Місяць тому

    I did in fact see a Doctor Moon explanation coming because you put him in the thumbnail to make me watch the video 😂

  • @amadeuscrossing7061
    @amadeuscrossing7061 4 дні тому

    We couldn’t get enough of the 10th doctor. So much so we gave rose and Donna their own personal copies 😂

  • @penbucket
    @penbucket Місяць тому

    I am so excited for the new series!!!!!!

  • @LlorDrei
    @LlorDrei 28 днів тому

    The ordering is a bit off, for the basic Doctors.
    1 = William Hartnell
    2 = Patrick Troughton
    3 = Jon Pertwee
    4 = Tom Baker
    5 = Peter Davison
    6 = Colin Baker
    7 = Sylvester McCoy
    8 = Paul McGann
    9 = John Hurt
    10 = Christopher Eccleston
    11 = David Tennant
    12 = David Tennant (Made canon by BBC immediately after the episode aired where he was shot by a dalek blast, and regenerated into himself)
    13 = Matt Smith
    14 = Peter Capaldi
    15 = Jodie Whittaker
    16 = Ncuti Gatwa

  • @coyoteink
    @coyoteink 12 днів тому

    I’ve watched “the lost” episodes of doctor who as a kid…dr who was on two channels on was pbs which came from spokane Washington and the other was a canadian public tv station. So maybe somewhere in a warehouse in spokane Washington the lost episodes are stashed away in a box some place…if it was the canadian station, then there is someone in Alberta Canada that has the lost episodes on them. Maybe they passed on and in there family’s basement is a case of vhs tapes with the lost episodes.

    • @coyoteink
      @coyoteink 12 днів тому

      Id also like to point out to the writers of the tenth doctors regen…timelords are immune to radiation

  • @mauriziopuddu4734
    @mauriziopuddu4734 26 днів тому

    About the Valeyard origin, you mustang hear the Big Finish Doctor Who audio story called Trial Of The Valeyard.

  • @jedhood6986
    @jedhood6986 Місяць тому +1

    I’ve always wanted to have some more Paul McGann. I loved the movie.

  • @kingzaynsmyname3634
    @kingzaynsmyname3634 Місяць тому +21

    Lets find out why Doctor Moon is there 😮😮

  • @bobbylon5
    @bobbylon5 Місяць тому +2

    "Vintage" Ellie! 😁

  • @pstevenson5157
    @pstevenson5157 6 днів тому +1

    The war doctor was the 9 th doctor but he refused to come back to play the doctor at that time that’s y we get someone else

  • @AaronBallvideos
    @AaronBallvideos Місяць тому

    "He was one of the only doctors to have a companion die on his watch"
    Katarina and sarah kingdom want a word

  • @tomm7505
    @tomm7505 День тому

    Sweety, you forgot Peter Cushing and the two Doctor Who movies that he made: Doctor Who and the Daleks (1965) and Invasion Earth: 2150 A.D. (1966).

    • @michealschrum6076
      @michealschrum6076 День тому

      Peter Cushing is not canon to the Who universe. He was a human being who invented an time and space machine. His movies did not take place as far as the Whoniverse is concerned.

    • @tomm7505
      @tomm7505 22 години тому +1

      @@michealschrum6076 Well, the new "Doctor" is not "canon" in my view, so there we are.

    • @michealschrum6076
      @michealschrum6076 15 годин тому

      @@tomm7505 Well, he is.... but I'm right there with you. Changing the actor and attitude is par for the course with the Doctor, but changing the fundamental nature of any lead character and then screaming hatred at the very fanbase who you expect to watch your show when they are alienated by it.... not the way to run a show. At least not when you want me to watch it. Capaldi was the last one I watched.

  • @ourphilosophyis9119
    @ourphilosophyis9119 Місяць тому +1

    It’s astonishing to me how I’ve come to accept the new regeneration cycle retcon, the Time War retcon, bigeneration, and the War Doctor, and yet, I still dislike the timeless child change just as strongly as the day it aired.

  • @EXPERTISE
    @EXPERTISE 24 дні тому

    Patrick Troughton is my all time favorite! But so many others are on the list! 4, 9,10,11,12 are my top 5!

  • @cooldudefran
    @cooldudefran Місяць тому +1

    It's laughable how Hartnell was considered old at 57 roughly the same age as Capaldi

    • @AaronBallvideos
      @AaronBallvideos Місяць тому

      People back then just looked alot older let's be fair compared to today

    • @stuartpinel3621
      @stuartpinel3621 Місяць тому

      @@AaronBallvideos "I am younger!"

  • @magnumlad1001
    @magnumlad1001 Місяць тому +4

    I think the curator is the fourteenth doctor, the one that’s still around at the same time as 15, after a few regenerations. It is sort of like he’s retired after all so I think it makes sense.

  • @kevinclark8880
    @kevinclark8880 12 днів тому

    Patrick Troughton faced the Daleks 'many times'. Or, as most of us know it, twice.

  • @Benjiesbeenbetter.
    @Benjiesbeenbetter. 25 днів тому

    15 actors. Richard Hurndall played the First Doctor in The Five Doctors.

  • @theoneyouhatetolove2310
    @theoneyouhatetolove2310 6 днів тому

    Without having to watch one single episode i am greatful to learn how glad i didnt even start. I prefer the show sliders

  • @anubhab.r
    @anubhab.r 16 днів тому

    You missed the 10th doctor's copy that stayed back with Rose

  • @josilver2690
    @josilver2690 Місяць тому +6

    Honorable mentions...Scream of the Shalka doctor and Peter cushing doctor

    • @charlestownsend9280
      @charlestownsend9280 Місяць тому +1

      And the second curator and the fatal death doctors and the 6 unbound doctors.

    • @pennywisethedancingclown2246
      @pennywisethedancingclown2246 Місяць тому

      Hehe yeah. There's even a Spiderverse style (Doctor-verse?) Doctor Who comic where the Ninth Doctor encounters Peter Cushing Dr. Who, The Shalka Doctor AND Rowan Atkinson Doctor. It's called Doctor Whoah! (DWM 376 comic story).

    • @charlestownsend9280
      @charlestownsend9280 Місяць тому

      @pennywisethedancingclown2246 there's also a story in the 60th big finish where 9 meets one of the unbound doctor's (an alternate 3rd doctor who arrives in 1999 rather than the 70s and ends up taking a retired brigadier as a companion. Who then later leaves after they visit skaro, in one of the most weirdest dalek stories ever, one where at one point the doctor brainwashs a dalek into thinking it's the second coming of davros and basically starts a religious war between daleks. He later has bernice summerfield as a companion after she gets trapped in his universe) and they also team up with the good incarnation of the master (who like the doctor is also jumping around different incarnations after being hit with a deregeneration weapon 8n the time war).
      It's weird that it's 9 who keeps having adventures with alternate doctors.

  • @alisonsmith4436
    @alisonsmith4436 Місяць тому

    Thank you ☺️

  • @matthewbray764
    @matthewbray764 Місяць тому +1

    Another doctor that the coments has not mentioned is the unbound doctor from an alternate universe originating from big finish

    • @DavidHHH99
      @DavidHHH99 Місяць тому +1

      Which one? There were five of them. And if we're counting Big Finish, Colin not only played an alternate 5th Doctor in the two Doctor of War Unbound boxsets, but also another incarnation of The Curator.

    • @matthewbray764
      @matthewbray764 Місяць тому

      @@DavidHHH99 I was referring to the David Warner one as I have listened to Once and Future

  • @michaelpuglia2407
    @michaelpuglia2407 22 години тому

    Isn't it great how there is so much to work with- what about one about missing or rogue timelords? (not doctors!)

    • @michaelpuglia2407
      @michaelpuglia2407 22 години тому

      always under the impression that some of the morbuis Dr.s, are some incarnations of Morbius not all dr whos

  • @ColinHoad
    @ColinHoad Місяць тому

    The Dream Lord was the best part of 11's entire era. We need more Dream Lord.

  • @AzurePastel007
    @AzurePastel007 Місяць тому +1

    If we are counting The Timeless Child arc, Their is one question. Did the Doctor get ALL of their Timeless Child regenerations back from the Timelords in The Time of the Doctor? Or Just a new 12 Regeneration Cycle? If it was just a new Cycle. Whenever we get to the end of it, which isn't too far away, there's going to have to be some more Timelord stuff. We're already on the 4th incarnation of the cycle. And that's not even wondering if the Master forcing the Doctor to Regenerate counts as a Regeneration. Technically it was a regeneration even though it was reversed? Idk what do you think?

    • @michaelbeadle5156
      @michaelbeadle5156 Місяць тому +3

      Rassilon says "How many regenerations did we grant you?" in Hell Bent
      This implies a limited number was granted.
      Personally I feel like a new 12 makes the most sense in my head, but who knows
      Could it be possible that the doctor has always had his unlimited timeless child regenerations, but didn't regenerate from 11->12 because he didn't think he could? Again, who knows

    • @patrickpablo217
      @patrickpablo217 Місяць тому +1

      The way I understand the situation now is that the Doctor has always had infinite regenerations but didn't know it, and the only people who might've known didn't want the Doctor to know so they kept pretending it was only the limited set. As far as 11 into 12, i think he didn't regenerate because no one killed him and getting the extra regeneration energy from the Time Lords triggered a regeneration directly or else the shock of it gave the old man a heart attack and that triggered the regeneration. Or possibly 11 had completed what he set out to do on Trenzalore and could finally "rest in peace" by allowing himself to die and regenerate into 12. That's the general way I think about it anyway.

    • @mrwittyone
      @mrwittyone Місяць тому +1

      @@patrickpablo217 Exactly. The Doctor has an unlimited amount of lives but that information was kept from them.

    • @Hal-Blue
      @Hal-Blue 4 дні тому

      They explained during Capaldi era the doctor had a incalculable number of regenerations.

  • @casual_bill8749
    @casual_bill8749 19 днів тому

    When you introduced the 6th doctor you forgot to say The Best Doctor

  • @ds222
    @ds222 21 день тому

    The Curator’s Gallery was the Tardis. Look at the walls for the clue.

  • @Prowler323
    @Prowler323 14 днів тому

    Why is it that just hearing Sarah Jane's name and seeing her face makes me tear up? I'm a grown man, dammit!

  • @spencerwelchii573
    @spencerwelchii573 Місяць тому

    You forgot to mention thar two other actors portrayed the first Doctor after William Hartnell's death.

  • @Travis_D_Travesty
    @Travis_D_Travesty Місяць тому +1

    So Rowan Atkinson, Robert E. Grant, Jim Broadbent, Hugh Grant and Joanna Lumley don't count? Nor does Peter Cushing? I know there was at least one more, but he must not matter either, right?

    • @marionbaggins
      @marionbaggins Місяць тому

      Joanna is the True First Female, and I won't take No for an Answer!!!

    • @pennywisethedancingclown2246
      @pennywisethedancingclown2246 Місяць тому +1

      Hehe yeah. There's even a Spiderverse style (Doctor-verse?) Doctor Who comic where the Ninth Doctor encounters Peter Cushing Dr. Who, The Shalka Doctor AND Rowan Atkinson Doctor. It's called Doctor Whoah! (DWM 376 comic story).

  • @grahamcann1761
    @grahamcann1761 Місяць тому +3

    You included Doctor Moon! I'm so excited; I've been commenting about him for some time! That said, there are a few you didn't include (probably for good reason):
    • Peter Cushing as The Movie Doctor.
    • Ty Tennant as the young Doctors legs ("Listen")
    • The Doctor's of "The Curse of the Fatal Death": Rowan Atkinson, Richard E. Grant, Jim Broadbent, Hugh Grant, and Joanna Lumley.
    • Honorable Mentions: As the first Doctor Richard Hurndall and David Bradley.
    As always thank you all so very much for the videos.
    • And the two Doctors who weren't the Doctor, but called themselves The Doctor: David Morrissey (Jackson Lake) and Michelle Gomez (Missy).

  • @AlDuke14
    @AlDuke14 Місяць тому

    Wouldn't it be interesting if the 14th Doctor (David Tennant) re-generated into Dr Moon once he dies of old age... Calling it now

  • @Legendary3Dgamer
    @Legendary3Dgamer Місяць тому +10

    Please do this for the master!

  • @wolfielps4411
    @wolfielps4411 Місяць тому

    Hi Ellie please read this PLEASE I've seen a lot of articles about an interview with Matt Smith about returning as the doctor, he replied it's not just a cameo appearance but he's coming home as the 16th doctor after ncuti leaves.
    You have contacts and would know more if this was true or not?

    • @TooAZY
      @TooAZY Місяць тому +2

      It was an April Fools joke

  • @wolfpredator5226
    @wolfpredator5226 День тому

    Chuti might just end up dethroning Matt as my fav doctor if all goes well

  • @L0g0Z0g0
    @L0g0Z0g0 Місяць тому

    I think some are still missing, although they are from extended media (Welp I clicked the video fir them in fact)

  • @joelmavity1467
    @joelmavity1467 Місяць тому

    Despite what some people say about him the 6th is one of my favorites.

  • @bobsimon8547
    @bobsimon8547 13 днів тому

    Idk who does the break down chapter titles but he's the Meta-Crisis Doctor not the Mecha Crisis Doctor

  • @WhoooooNerd
    @WhoooooNerd Місяць тому +1

    get well soon ellie! 😄

  • @Thehappyhammockhiker
    @Thehappyhammockhiker 5 днів тому

    Don't forget Mary Poppins and the guy from Paddington

  • @Jeddstevens
    @Jeddstevens Місяць тому +1

    Where is the Peter Cushing doctor

  • @Atlas.23
    @Atlas.23 Місяць тому

    I was expecting to see the cyberplanner doctor, I like him he's funny