the Curse of the house of Braganza, and the fall of the Portuguese Monarchy

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 64

  • @nunocbnunocb5875
    @nunocbnunocb5875 3 роки тому +30

    1910, the disgrace.

    • @josealmeida76
      @josealmeida76 2 роки тому +1

      Foi mesmo, de 1910 a 1926. E os socialistas-comunistas-marxistas desde 25-4-1974 fazem semelhante...

    • @manelhuehue3271
      @manelhuehue3271 10 місяців тому +3

      1889 for Brazil :(

  • @miguellemos4669
    @miguellemos4669 3 роки тому +34

    Btw in Portuguese Bragança sounds like Braganssa. The ç never sounds like z. That would be Spanish maybe.
    In Portuguese there's no such name as Alfonso. It's Afonso without the L.

    • @Igor_054
      @Igor_054 2 роки тому +1

      O espanhol não tem o som de "z". Eles pronunciam casa como caça, ou então com a língua presa, tipo "catha", dependendo do sotaque.
      A mudança de ç para z em Bragança em algumas línguas seria para ajudar a pronunciar esse "ç", porque em espanhol o z seria exatamente o som de ç. Mas, ironicamente, essa mudança faz o pessoal pronunciar errado mesmo assim.

    • @vieiradosreismariadelurdes9105
      @vieiradosreismariadelurdes9105 Рік тому

      ​@@Igor_054
      Itália 👇
      É onde a letra "z" é igual a "s".

  • @RadioAraujo
    @RadioAraujo 2 роки тому +6

    it's not impossible to have democracy within the monarchy... I'm a Portuguese monarchist and parliamentarian so meh

    • @lusitanus.
      @lusitanus. 11 місяців тому

      Tu és um estólido liberal.

  • @Rotebuehl1
    @Rotebuehl1 Рік тому +4

    If You don't understand I'll explain:
    In Portuguese the name is 'Afonso'
    In Castillian it is 'Alfonso'
    Not difficult to know...

    • @NAU-invideoveritas
      @NAU-invideoveritas 5 місяців тому

      He also doesn't get "Augusto", with a hard "G", as in English and even in Latin, where the name comes from... 🤔

  • @andypham1636
    @andypham1636 Рік тому +1

    the Kohary branch of the house of sale coburg-gotha ruled in Bulgaria also, but not the UK

    • @MikeB071
      @MikeB071 11 місяців тому

      Tsar Ferdinand.

  • @markballard9942
    @markballard9942 2 роки тому +2

    Interesting video. The last few minutes are difficult to hear because the music gets fairly loud.

  • @ange7679
    @ange7679 5 місяців тому +1

    the long ahh name is the most real Portuguese thing I've seen

  • @davidsousalopes2391
    @davidsousalopes2391 2 роки тому +6

    "Spain became a democracy and then a kingdom again." As if the two are not possible at the same time lol

    • @andyt8216
      @andyt8216 Рік тому +5

      Exactly, why do some think the two are exclusive? The most democratic country in the world is the Kingdom of Norway.

  • @Dharmarenee
    @Dharmarenee 3 роки тому +5

    The music made it hard to hear you.🤦🏽‍♀️

  • @honorladone8682
    @honorladone8682 3 роки тому +1

    Thanks for your time and consideration. Philadelphia USA

  • @gecko5892
    @gecko5892 2 роки тому +4

    Ave monarchia!!🇬🇷☦️👑❤️🇵🇹✝️👑

    • @JohnPaul-mu5sx
      @JohnPaul-mu5sx 3 місяці тому

      That will be a reality these days.💙🩵

  • @philipdeutsch9716
    @philipdeutsch9716 Рік тому

    very interesting. thanks for sharing!

  • @aussieoma0418
    @aussieoma0418 3 роки тому +2

    Quite the music when your talking.

  • @lj5801
    @lj5801 3 роки тому +5

    While the video is very interesting and well made, when it got to the current claimant, the music overtook your narration.

  • @bewareofpigeons
    @bewareofpigeons 2 роки тому +8

    Your pronunciation of Portuguese names could do with some attention: they are not that difficult to master. I have never heard, for example, Augusto, which has a hard 'g', being pronounced 'Aojusto': think of the English month August, or the name Augustus.

  • @motherlandchronicles
    @motherlandchronicles 3 роки тому +1

    Interesting video, liked the way you covered the story

  • @thunderbolt1964
    @thunderbolt1964 3 роки тому +5

    The monarchy should be restored

    • @andyt8216
      @andyt8216 Рік тому +3

      And the previous beautiful flag. 💙🤍

    • @epic8923
      @epic8923 Рік тому +1

      why

  • @Dunsapie
    @Dunsapie 3 роки тому +4

    The music is very off-putting.

  • @andrereis_12
    @andrereis_12 Рік тому +3

    Congratulations on the video and thank you for making a video about our loving Nation. The only thing I didn't like was how bad your pronunciation of portuguese words was. Portuguese and spanish are two very different languages, trying to pronounce portuguese words, especially portuguese names, with a Spanish point of view is not the best course of action. Try to put those names on google translator to see what I'm talking about. I know it's hard to pronounce portuguese words but if you can make an effort to pronounce spanish words, you can do the same with portuguese words. Thank you.

    • @FrancisTheBerd
      @FrancisTheBerd 10 місяців тому +1

      Not worth it to go to the translator as it's in brazilian

  • @reginaromsey
    @reginaromsey 3 роки тому +2

    I have never known where the House of Braganza had its foundations.

    • @tugadmundo
      @tugadmundo 3 роки тому +1

      it is rather a long story but quite interesting .

    • @andypham1636
      @andypham1636 Рік тому

      from an illegitimate son of John I, the first king of Portugal of the house of braganza

  • @hlpwithalfonso4135
    @hlpwithalfonso4135  3 роки тому +3

    Let me know which topics you guys want me to cover next.

    • @thunderbolt1964
      @thunderbolt1964 3 роки тому +1

      Also when the king was deposed it was a constitutional monarchy and therefore a democracy

  • @jaidoni.vincent6773
    @jaidoni.vincent6773 3 роки тому +3

    5:24
    1860 flashbacks

  • @FrancisTheBerd
    @FrancisTheBerd 10 місяців тому +1

    "Or in portuguese Joo-ó"

  • @mariajason3547
    @mariajason3547 3 роки тому

    The music literally ate you voice at the end
    Why is it so loud?

  • @dynadushi
    @dynadushi 3 місяці тому

    2:37 i'm dead 😭😭😭😭 lolll

  • @grantie7
    @grantie7 2 місяці тому

    I'm a descendent of the 8th princess (ignacia francisca of bragandza) of peter ii the pacific Duke of braganca King of portugal. Does that give me any claims?

  • @miltonmiles6324
    @miltonmiles6324 3 роки тому

    what’s the song at the end of the video?

  • @andypham1636
    @andypham1636 Рік тому

    Luis Filipe, Prince Royal was never king since in Portugal, you had to be proclaimed king (or queen) by the Portuguese cortes.

  • @danielledegeorge2129
    @danielledegeorge2129 3 роки тому +1

    Why is it that every monarch that didn't abdicate or give up their throne was called "mad"?

    • @joaoluisesquivel2810
      @joaoluisesquivel2810 2 роки тому +2

      Queen Maria the 1st, born 1734, became queen in 1777 but had dementia from 1792 on and his son, Prince Regent John, rulled for his mother for the next 18 years becomming King John VI upon his mothers death. Queen Maria the 1st died in Brazil aged 81.

  • @davidjsouth231
    @davidjsouth231 3 роки тому +1

    Oooh! Very bad! At least before the EU. Don’t ever say Portugal and Spain are similar. Spent 14 wonderful years in Portugal. 79-93

    • @m11071997r
      @m11071997r 2 роки тому +1

      Genetically there is no difference between Portuguese and Spanish on the west-north. Both people belong to the same Iberian substrate population. Monarchs and aristocrats divided people only because of a matter of power and ambition.

    • @joaoluisesquivel2810
      @joaoluisesquivel2810 2 роки тому

      @@m11071997r Of course there are genetic differences. Spanish European rule by Charles V brought all the netherlandish and italian blood into the pool in such numbers never compared with Portugal. Besides they have the French heritage of Calalunia and the unique Basque blood Portugal doesn't have. If a similitude could be found with be with Galicia. Even the presence of Rome was not that deep, nor the Celts. Even pre Roman tribes existing in the south of Portugal were completely different like the Lusitanos.

    • @m11071997r
      @m11071997r 2 роки тому +1

      @@joaoluisesquivel2810 The Lusitanian tribes roamed in areas currently belonging to Spain and Portugal, Lusitanian people does not belong uniquely to Portuguese ancestry. When the Umayyad caliphate invaded the peninsula, their warriors displaced every Cristian inhabiting in the peninsula, including the roman-celto-iberian population of the south of Portugal. So everyone mixed for almost 784 years in the north, while the different Islamic kingdoms controlled and populated lands of current Spain and Portugal. The reason why Portuguese and Galician were back in time the same language is because the ancestors of most of the people who are currently living in Portugal can be traced back to Galicia.

    • @m11071997r
      @m11071997r 2 роки тому +1

      @@joaoluisesquivel2810 Spain is not a ethnogenetic union, neither is Portugal (mirandes people) nor other countries as France (occitane) which is normal all the countries in the world and explain the diversity and richness that land and the history provided during times. What is undeniable is that Portuguese people share common ancestors with people living north west(Galicia) and partially west Spain.

    • @joaoluisesquivel2810
      @joaoluisesquivel2810 2 роки тому

      Ok. Conii, Turdetani (Algarve to Cadiz), Celtici (Alentejo), Turdetani Oppida (Beira litoral), Lusitani (Beira interior). Look it up. On the Spanish East side of Lusitani there were the Vettones (Extremadura Española). North of Douro river is another matter. Have a very nice weekend.

  • @greggmaclean6036
    @greggmaclean6036 3 роки тому

    Not bad ...except at the end the music drowns out your voice.

  • @davidsantos1630
    @davidsantos1630 2 роки тому

    Radical Repúblicano que alteração da história

  • @tugadmundo
    @tugadmundo 3 роки тому +1

    What do you not understand about the name " Afonso ",the fact that you are called "Alfonso " has any significance in this matter ?Do you not know of different spellings for the same name in different languages ?

  • @davidsantos1630
    @davidsantos1630 2 роки тому

    Só uma colonia de Roma mas um dia a Lusitânia vai renascer

  • @Almagesto25
    @Almagesto25 Рік тому

    "They became a kingdom, then became a democracy" - just by hearing this I concluded that I should not continue watching your video haha... sorry.

  • @pbohearn
    @pbohearn 2 роки тому +1

    Europe is entirely preoccupied with bloodlines and lines of succession. It’s a sick preoccupation on the “what ifs” list, especially for countries who have long cast off the feudal yoke of monarchy. To paraphraseBette Davis’s cutting confrontation RE: Crawfords ( Blanche’s) wishful thinking to change an unwanted reality: “ But you aren’t, Blanca, you aren’t a monarchy, and it’s a cold day in hell when the monarchy is restored.” For those distant relatives of deposed kings, it’s a boorish kind of status climbing. Blue bloodlines is a most destructive kind of elitism that led to inbred mongrels.

  • @sofiakatelyn
    @sofiakatelyn Рік тому

    No he is not. Never been, never will 😂

  • @mathiaslill3386
    @mathiaslill3386 2 роки тому +1

    HOBBIT JOURNEY 2022

  • @thunderbolt1964
    @thunderbolt1964 3 роки тому +13

    The monarchy should be restored