Quite obviously the point of the scene with tension building in the faces from laughing to a more serious look. Cut to Schindler being taken into custody right after
I agree... I saw this when I was about 12 and I still see Amon goeth everytime I see Ralph f. My mind doesn't separate them into actor and part, only one person. In my opinion he went beyond acting, I have never watched a movie that did that for me. Same with Liam N. And Ben K. These actors were on their A game.
@@annasloan2349 I agree completely. I have a few pictures of Ralph Fiennes (some of when he was portraying Göth) in my photos, but I always feel wrong about it. Because aswell as seeing the face of Ralph, I’m seeing the face of Göth, and although it’s not really him; I can’t help but feel so guilty for it. That’s the effect Fiennes’ extraordinary acting can have on a person, and I really don’t think I’ve seen it anywhere else
I think that Goeth knows exactly what Schindler is doing, he laughs in this scene because to him Schindler is only prolonging the inevitable. To Goeth they are all going to the same place, so it’s amusing to him the great lengths that Schindler goes to care for them. Really superb acting and writing, every time I return to this film I am moved and shocked.
Absolutely not the case, in my opinion. If Göth suspected that Schindler actually cared about Jews, he'd either report him or kill him himself. I read the scene at face value, he thinks that Schindler is having fun, either through giving them false hope or watching them desperately scramble to drink. That's the only reason Göth could think of why a fellow Nazi would do this, but he realizes he was wrong when he sees Schindler going through so much effort to make sure they all get enough. He may not know exactly why Schindler is doing it, but he seems annoyed nonetheless.
@@PaddyRoon7 No, he beginning to see this as strange, he definitely doesn't know for sure. Also, he's still getting rich from him, and that's important to him too.
Schindler was really trying to do a good thing and he had the pschyology there, but he was letting his guard down trying to get them more water and Amon was suspicious. You have to keep playing the part.
I think Amon had suspected it for a long time, he even tried to get Oskar to admit it a few times (in the movie, anyway, I haven’t yet completed the book). But he never did anything about it. I wonder why that is. Did he have that much of a liking or trust in Oskar? Was it his own denial? That is a trait his character held onto throughout the entire film. Göth was a very complex person, I guess we’ll never know
@@vavacadoz he probably envied oskar. Oskar has money, women, some form of political power, swagger, and self control. Plus he has all of that without having to get his hands dirty killing. Many officers would love to be oskar. Just looked how he carried himself at the lunch with all the officers. They all liked him so much for the value he provides them that you would have thought oskar out ranked them all if you didnt know any better.
Schindler was very good at outsmarting nazis by using his businessman skills and kind manners. Here he truly risked to be arrested though. BTW God bless him for what he did..
ClassicFan Angles Charm was something he was a master of and using his power. People had a hard time saying no to him and even if they did he would find another way to make them say yes.
This was a good movie and Liam Nesson was robbed of the oscar and Tom Hanks won instead. Tom Hanks is a good actor and I hope Liam Nesson win's something. This was good movie about what the jews had to go through with the Nazi's and it was sheer hell b/c you didn't know if anyone was on your side and you were a haunted animal 24/ 7 and in the end the head nazis especially Amon Goeth got what he deserved. It was scary for all of those people in Europe and I went to Anne Frank house and it was surreal to see everything and the fact that she died and she would have been 90 yrs old today. War brings out the bad never the good. in people. Thats a fact. Oskar Shindler' is buried in Irsrael. I hope to see it one day. I am being gangstalked and I can understand the fear that jews had b/c you don't know what is going to happen. Your alive one second and dead the next.
I remember reading about the woman who saw him on set and was genuinely terrified. I think if you’re plaguing a villain incredibly well you are deserving of accolades. But when you’re playing a villain who was a real person and truly more horrific than just about any actual movie villain, it’s hard to give the performer an award, especially when they’re so convincing that they seem truly evil like the real person was.
@@stevem2323 They had more in common than just that, but Schindler definitely had the upper hand and Göth looked up to him. But Schindler wouldn't describe Göth as has his dark twin for nothing.
I've always wondered what his strange expression means. You can be right. Especially that the next scene after a long shot on Goeth's face is Schindler's arrest for kissing a Jewish woman. It was Goeth who could denounce him.
I dont think so. I think Goeth is being sarcastic. He realizes that Schindler isnt torturing them, but helping them. This is a turning point in the movie. Goeth will become less trusting of Schindler from this point onward.
Face Off I get it, thats why they don't suspect them and i m sure there are plenty of things he said to reassure the Nazis. After all the movie is only 3 hours long and that lasted wayyyyy longer
These things he did takes real courage and intelligence. He could just turn around and walk away but he didn't. Being in that moment taking these actions, knowing a single error will cost not only your life also your relatives but still keep saving people doing the right thing. A real definition of hero.
Everyone here could display such courage in a parallel path: support Palestinians being treated humanely instead of the constant fascist apartheid of the Israeli state
@@adamguerrero5293Always about Palestinians, eh... Even in the face of constant atrocities against them by their Hamas appointed warriors. Does anybody consider the Israelis at all? Should Israeli Jews pack their things and be gone? What is it you want? Perhaps if living alongside in peace and harmony wasn't rejected then a longer term solution might have been possible long ago.
@@Tube2097 "Living alongside in peace" Only Israel is bulldozing homes, schools, even *olive trees!* Only Israel has illegal colonists, checkpoints that deny freedom of movement, causing miscarriage, etc Israel indefinitely detains children, denies them legal representation, in which they don't know what the charges are or the evidence against them. When Palestinians peacefully protest, *Israel guns them down,* but not only the protestors, journalists & medical workers as well This happens *on a daily basis,* but spoon-fed rage is fed to you, & that's the only thing you know.
Marcus Silverbåge He was in despair on what he was doing at many parts of the movie. Also he was a friend of Schindler so maybe he doesn't want to say anything
Also explains why he (in the movie and reality) was such a heavy drinker. I know through experience, that excessive alcohol consumption is a tell tale sign that a person is under extreme mental stress. Also, feelings of uneasiness weren't uncommon even within the SS. Camp Kommandants and their guards had to see all of the disease, murder, and "Hell" first-hand. High up officials didn't.
I saw this scene as a young man and I WILL NEVER FORGET IT!!!!! They were sitting in hell and all they wanted was water! It was so risky for him but he played it off as a joke. This is a true sign of humanitarianism in the face of danger. I will never forget this scene
you're fully ensconced in propaganda like a good North Korean solider and just like the most effective propaganda you don't even know you've been subjected to it
Amazing film, even the colour of the suits were thought out. Schindler and Julius Madritsch both in white whereas the other members are in dark. Good and evil
Oscar is very upset with what's going on, but he feels like he cannot do anything like he could before the war. 1:45 is a great example of the real feelings between Oscar and Goethe's men. Oscar is doing everything in his power, and he feels helpless in comparison to his position in the 20's and 30's. Stern is another great example of where Oscar is at.
You shouldn't need the promise of rewards in the afterlife in order to be a good person. You should be a good person even if you're going to hell, or if there is no afterlife.
It was just water on the train no harm done thats why they didnt say anything and with all the people oskar knows he could wiggle out of most small things like this
@@HRHooChicken Do you really think that was the case? Who the hell could check on every single killing or officer? Are you for real?? Do you really think Hitler or his close staff was everywhere? In that chaos?? You then must be a naive person.....
@@tiborvisi7438 if you think German soldiers wandered around killing other Germans indiscriminately without consequence then you’re a brainwashed fool. It would’ve been no different to it happening in the UK or USA. They would’ve been tried for murder and shot.
I have 2 different theories here regarding what Goeth is thinking here: i think he's pondering Schindler's motives, but he's guessed that Schindler (who has exquisite tastes in alcohol and suits etc) is trying to keep the workers healthy so they will perform better in his factorys and keep making him more money! He thinks Schindler is obsessed by money, which he really was until he started growing a conscience He cannot comprehend he is doing it as he pitys them, so that's the only possible conclusion is that Schlinder is indeed a money greedy businessman. obsessed in protecting his assets. The other theory, a lot weaker is that Goeth is developing an obsession for the jewish servant girl he has as his personal servant, and the ONLY person who possibly relates to this is Schindler, he feels a strange kinda empathy with a guy he really admires, Schindler too has developed a strange and forbidden bond with the jews. Outing Schindler for it would be outing himself and he's at odds on how to feel and deal with the entire situation
Then comes the Gestapo for Schindler. This scene was really scary. Schindler was arrested 3 times by the Gestapo and if it weren't for his connections that he had with high rank officials in the Abwehr and SS Police he more than likely would have wound up perishing in Auschwitz like those who he saved. What an incredible and good man. Remember Oskar Schindler!!
Goeth is evil and terrifying, so I’m always really scared of him more than Darth Vader or Sauron, because what we see him do really happened. But this scene in particular scares me a lot, because we know of Goeth’s capabilities, and now he realizes who Schindler really is behind that Swastika-marked button. The tension rises making it hard to watch because in the beginning he’s completely oblivious but realizes very slowly what’s happening right in front of him. It beautiful and horrifying at the same time. Ralph Fiennes will always remain the greatest actor for a villain of all time, in my opinion.
‘’I am not saying you will regret it but you might… alright it’s a nice day I’ll go for a drive with you” …3:22…cool knowing he is being arrested by the gestapo . What presence and confidence.
Actually, stuffing them in a hot train and shipping them off to certain death increases their suffering more than a drink of water. I know it's counter-intuitive, but trust me, most people would prefer not to be thirsty in any circumstance.
He smiles and jokes when he turns his head towards the ones in military uniform, but has a face of urgency when he looks to the people in the carts and directs the man to hoes them down with water. Definition of a sheep dog in wolves clothing. Or maybe even a Shepard, so to speak.
What's interesting is that Ralph continually shows through the film that he respects, and even at times emulates Liam. Look at 0:14 how happy he is to see him, then when they sit down, how he is looking at him. Liam takes off his hat, Ralph copies. However, despite this, Ralph never understands him. But is perplexed by him.
This is undoubtedly one of the most important films ever created. But I also wish a film about the gulag archipelago was created detailing events such as this one did with the holocaust with such cinematic intensity.
@@melanie851 And the lessons of both are missed when those same people can become, in real time right before your eyes, just as bad as their own oppressor.
I always found this scene particularly striking for its subtle psychological tension between Goeth and Schindler. Three minutes is enough to figure out their ambitions and even revelations about each other - the initial exchange between them and how Schindler doesn't seem to pay much attention to anything except the cars while Goeth fixates his gaze on Schindler with a hope of establishing himself as an important figure in the eyes of a wealthy, powerful businessman. Schindler is aware of the whole power dynamics and nonchalantly suggests water hoses as a game for the sake of entertainment, indulging in laughing and maintaining joyful atmosphere (especially how he forces the first laugh after 'where's the fire' which followed by Goeth's). The last frames of Goeth's gaze speak for themselves - the growing realization of Schindler's intentions masterfully rendered in a silent close-up.
To someone doesn't know why Schindler did that: The weather was hot, and air was very hot in the train. So many Jews in the train almost couldn't breathe because of the hot air. Schindler just spread the water to them to make them more comfortable.
Spielberg’s magnum opus his swan song his masterwork no one could have made this film except for him , he was born to paint this indescribable canvas of human pain suffering and unimaginable horror . ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
@@nickgurpleez2628 I'm not saying what the SS did wasn't fucked up bc it was. Hitler though using his ideology and having the idea that they were the dominant race led to these men becoming mass murders.
Just noticed one of the officers sat next to amon is "reolheder" from the 1993 stalingrad film. Personally thought that was interesting as I love the film😂
I don’t know how oscar Schindler was throughout, but from the acting by Liam it seemed that this was the actual moment where he transformed into a human being from being a nazi
From the movie, I think that when he first saw the girl in the red coat, was when something started to spark up within him; and then the moment he saw her dead in the cart, he knew something really needed to be done. He made the same face for both scenes. Like you can see the realisation hitting him properly for the first time. In real life, it would’ve been gradual of course. Not that it wasn’t gradual in the film, that’s the whole part of his character development. But it separates each time there’s a change within him, to make it clearer for the audience
1:10 a very subtle dose of irony from Spielberg, one of the Nazis asks "where's the fire." Over his shoulder, a train car is labeled Dresden. Dresden was the site of a significant firebombing in February 1945.
34 “Then the King will say to those on his right, ‘Come, you whom my Father has blessed, take your inheritance, the Kingdom prepared for you from the founding of the world. 35 For I was hungry and you gave me food, I was thirsty and you gave me something to drink, I was a stranger and you made me your guest, 36 I needed clothes and you provided them, I was sick and you took care of me, I was in prison and you visited me.’ 37 Then the people who have done what God wants will reply, ‘Lord, when did we see you hungry and feed you, or thirsty and give you something to drink? 38 When did we see you a stranger and make you our guest, or needing clothes and provide them? 39 When did we see you sick or in prison, and visit you?’ 40 The King will say to them, ‘Yes! I tell you that whenever you did these things for one of the least important of these brothers of mine, you did them for me!’ Matthew 25:35-40
My parent's friends are kids of two of Schindler's kids. They told me about this exactly. Schindler said to the Nazi officers near the train that they smell really bad and they should "wash" them. And that how he got them water.. That is why I assumed that it'll be in the movie. To this day I can't watch this movie. But I am from Israel and was on the poland delegation singing the song from "the girl in red" scene in Yiddish a-capella in a synagog in the Tykocin town. Of you want I can interpret it:)
I have seen this movie once. It is clearly a masterpiece; a work of sublime cinematic and historical artistry. I hope to never see it again. It documents horrors and atrocities that make me ashamed to be a human being. I can't stand it.
I am sorry for all the things jews had to go through.... This is my favourite movie of all time...the things i saw in this movie is soooo sad that i cant bloody explain From a muslim...i hope one day we could get along together
Schindler starts focusing so much on giving them water that he forgets he's supposed to be acting or manipulating.
Jane Doh only just noticed this other day
Quite obviously the point of the scene with tension building in the faces from laughing to a more serious look. Cut to Schindler being taken into custody right after
@@pr0gressd He went to prison for kissing a Jewish girl.
@@noorrougelewis6704 That is what we learn after the scene. We fear something far worse at first glance
@@pr0gressd And Amon defended him to get him released
Imagine trying to mask kindness and empathy as malevolence.
Obviously a man with a very special set of skills.
xelif154 - if you let her go
Kev Shearer i will not look for you,i will not pursue you
But if you don’t, I will look for you, I will find you .. and I will ..
I love this comment section.
The more I watch stuff like this the less and less I understand Nazism and how anyone could partake in this, let alone be so light-hearted about it.
“That is very cruel Oskar” - Amon Göth
Your giving them hope you shouldn't do that that's cruel
Amon goeth
@@jameskirks4332 No arsehole, it IS Göth.
Not English, German....
Göth is his correct name 😊
That cold blooded murderer monster had a sick brain and rotten soul
It's too funny.
Speilburgs decision to shoot the picture in black and white was brilliant!
One of the few movies Liam Neeson does'nt travel on a plane.
dazhibernian how random
Ps Mon the jambos
😂😂😂👍 This comment deserves more hits.
"I ain't gettin on no plane, Hannibal!"
Thumbnail makes it look like a buddy comedy.
This is the movie where Liam Neeson & Ralph Fiennes met and they've been very close friends ever since.
It is
Schindler’s List, that light-hearted comedy
Liam needs a light saber and Ralph needs hus wond and let's see who wins. 😆
1:19
God, the acting was epic.
I agree... I saw this when I was about 12 and I still see Amon goeth everytime I see Ralph f. My mind doesn't separate them into actor and part, only one person.
In my opinion he went beyond acting, I have never watched a movie that did that for me. Same with Liam N. And Ben K. These actors were on their A game.
@@annasloan2349 I agree completely. I have a few pictures of Ralph Fiennes (some of when he was portraying Göth) in my photos, but I always feel wrong about it. Because aswell as seeing the face of Ralph, I’m seeing the face of Göth, and although it’s not really him; I can’t help but feel so guilty for it. That’s the effect Fiennes’ extraordinary acting can have on a person, and I really don’t think I’ve seen it anywhere else
@@annasloan2349 I can't see Hayden Christensen as any other than Anakin Skywalker...
I think that Goeth knows exactly what Schindler is doing, he laughs in this scene because to him Schindler is only prolonging the inevitable. To Goeth they are all going to the same place, so it’s amusing to him the great lengths that Schindler goes to care for them. Really superb acting and writing, every time I return to this film I am moved and shocked.
so true
I don't know about that, i think he kind of refuses to believe that, that Schindler could actually care, pass the money workers could get for him.
Evil cannot comprehend good, they say. @@stevem2323
Absolutely not the case, in my opinion. If Göth suspected that Schindler actually cared about Jews, he'd either report him or kill him himself.
I read the scene at face value, he thinks that Schindler is having fun, either through giving them false hope or watching them desperately scramble to drink.
That's the only reason Göth could think of why a fellow Nazi would do this, but he realizes he was wrong when he sees Schindler going through so much effort to make sure they all get enough. He may not know exactly why Schindler is doing it, but he seems annoyed nonetheless.
@@PaddyRoon7 No, he beginning to see this as strange, he definitely doesn't know for sure. Also, he's still getting rich from him, and that's important to him too.
Schindler was really trying to do a good thing and he had the pschyology there, but he was letting his guard down trying to get them more water and Amon was suspicious. You have to keep playing the part.
I think Amon had suspected it for a long time, he even tried to get Oskar to admit it a few times (in the movie, anyway, I haven’t yet completed the book). But he never did anything about it. I wonder why that is. Did he have that much of a liking or trust in Oskar? Was it his own denial? That is a trait his character held onto throughout the entire film. Göth was a very complex person, I guess we’ll never know
@@vavacadoz he probably envied oskar. Oskar has money, women, some form of political power, swagger, and self control. Plus he has all of that without having to get his hands dirty killing. Many officers would love to be oskar. Just looked how he carried himself at the lunch with all the officers. They all liked him so much for the value he provides them that you would have thought oskar out ranked them all if you didnt know any better.
Who would've screwed that guys, really?
They had the right to shoot you in case of any serious disagreement
@@vavacadoz None of those. Amon was being paid remember?
@@ge2623not at this point no
Schindler was very good at outsmarting nazis by using his businessman skills and kind manners. Here he truly risked to be arrested though. BTW God bless him for what he did..
ClassicFan Angles Charm was something he was a master of and using his power. People had a hard time saying no to him and even if they did he would find another way to make them say yes.
Hispanico //90 This movie is not based on truth.The book itself is fiction.Dont believe me....then go read it....
And his money he gave to the nazi’s
Vegeta Oh! Someone’s never heard of the Wansee conference.
This was a good movie and Liam Nesson was robbed of the oscar and Tom Hanks won instead. Tom Hanks is a good actor and I hope Liam Nesson win's something. This was good movie about what the jews had to go through with the Nazi's and it was sheer hell b/c you didn't know if anyone was on your side and you were a haunted animal 24/ 7 and in the end the head nazis especially Amon Goeth got what he deserved. It was scary for all of those people in Europe and I went to Anne Frank house and it was surreal to see everything and the fact that she died and she would have been 90 yrs old today. War brings out the bad never the good. in people. Thats a fact. Oskar Shindler' is buried in Irsrael. I hope to see it one day. I am being gangstalked and I can understand the fear that jews had b/c you don't know what is going to happen. Your alive one second and dead the next.
How Fiennes did not get an Oscar is an absolute mystery
It’s because somebody else won the Oscar that year
@@martind5487... as is typical with the Oscars, that someone is someone who deserved it less and won it due to a slick marketing campaign
Tommy Lee Jones was better in The Fugutive
I remember reading about the woman who saw him on set and was genuinely terrified. I think if you’re plaguing a villain incredibly well you are deserving of accolades. But when you’re playing a villain who was a real person and truly more horrific than just about any actual movie villain, it’s hard to give the performer an award, especially when they’re so convincing that they seem truly evil like the real person was.
Hollywood wouldn't give it because of who he played . That's the truth of it . Was nearly too real
I love how amon goeth actually likes schindlers a lot, Ralph fienes lights up when he comes around,
Fantastic acting
Schindler was the only one allowed to call Amon his nickname "mony"
He looked up to Schindler, he was in awe of him, the girls, money, businessman.
@@stevem2323 They both bonded are were tall in statue and saw they had similarities. Oskar later described Amon as his dark twin
@@Dom-fx4kt Only thing they had in common was money, but Schindler had upper hand, definitely.
@@stevem2323 They had more in common than just that, but Schindler definitely had the upper hand and Göth looked up to him. But Schindler wouldn't describe Göth as has his dark twin for nothing.
2:45 Amon Goeth starts to realize that maybe Schindler isnt one of us.
I've always wondered what his strange expression means. You can be right. Especially that the next scene after a long shot on Goeth's face is Schindler's arrest for kissing a Jewish woman. It was Goeth who could denounce him.
the interesting thing about this scene is that even the monster Amon Goeth is shocked at the 'cruelty' that Schindler is displaying
I dont think so. I think Goeth is being sarcastic. He realizes that Schindler isnt torturing them, but helping them. This is a turning point in the movie. Goeth will become less trusting of Schindler from this point onward.
I was also wondering how they didn't realize that in fact he was trying to help them hmm
Face Off I get it, thats why they don't suspect them and i m sure there are plenty of things he said to reassure the Nazis. After all the movie is only 3 hours long and that lasted wayyyyy longer
These things he did takes real courage and intelligence. He could just turn around and walk away but he didn't. Being in that moment taking these actions, knowing a single error will cost not only your life also your relatives but still keep saving people doing the right thing. A real definition of hero.
Everyone here could display such courage in a parallel path: support Palestinians being treated humanely instead of the constant fascist apartheid of the Israeli state
@@adamguerrero5293Always about Palestinians, eh... Even in the face of constant atrocities against them by their Hamas appointed warriors. Does anybody consider the Israelis at all? Should Israeli Jews pack their things and be gone? What is it you want? Perhaps if living alongside in peace and harmony wasn't rejected then a longer term solution might have been possible long ago.
@@Tube2097 "does anyone consider the Israelis?"
🙄🤣 only the entire western world establishment & political leadership
Gtfoh 😂🤣
@@Tube2097
"Living alongside in peace"
Only Israel is bulldozing homes, schools, even *olive trees!*
Only Israel has illegal colonists, checkpoints that deny freedom of movement, causing miscarriage, etc
Israel indefinitely detains children, denies them legal representation, in which they don't know what the charges are or the evidence against them.
When Palestinians peacefully protest, *Israel guns them down,* but not only the protestors, journalists & medical workers as well
This happens *on a daily basis,* but spoon-fed rage is fed to you, & that's the only thing you know.
@@adamguerrero5293 Strange, you must think you're a good person...
“That’s so cruel! You’re giving them hope!”
1:10
"Hujar."
"Yes sir?"
"Bring the firehoses."
"Where's the fire?"
LOL
Fire hoses *
I always lmao at that
Liam and Ralph... Genius acting in this. Just superb.
The writing in this scene is excellent, what a tightrope balance. Excellent.
Amon Goeths look in the end....he gets Whats going on. But doesn´t want to believe it?
Marcus Silverbåge He was in despair on what he was doing at many parts of the movie. Also he was a friend of Schindler so maybe he doesn't want to say anything
Also explains why he (in the movie and reality) was such a heavy drinker. I know through experience, that excessive alcohol consumption is a tell tale sign that a person is under extreme mental stress. Also, feelings of uneasiness weren't uncommon even within the SS. Camp Kommandants and their guards had to see all of the disease, murder, and "Hell" first-hand. High up officials didn't.
Don't ever underestimate the power of denial.
Zersetzung Gov. Gang Stalking great input
Or knowing Oskars power and influence he knows he can't do a damn thing about it
I saw this scene as a young man and I WILL NEVER FORGET IT!!!!! They were sitting in hell and all they wanted was water! It was so risky for him but he played it off as a joke. This is a true sign of humanitarianism in the face of danger. I will never forget this scene
you're fully ensconced in propaganda like a good North Korean solider and just like the most effective propaganda you don't even know you've been subjected to it
@@RhinoAg nice schizopost
@@RhinoAg No the korherr reports, Jager reports, and Irving trial already prove this to be true
@@vercot7000 lmaooo
@@RhinoAg Why are you wh*te?
2:58 Amon s face: "i don t like you anymore"
WOW
Amon Goeth’s role is played so well
I know Right
Amazing film, even the colour of the suits were thought out. Schindler and Julius Madritsch both in white whereas the other members are in dark. Good and evil
Yep that’s a good catch.
Great observations
There is no such clear demarcation. Everyone is part good and part evil.
No pedimos que se borre la historia. Pedimos reflexión, colonos abusivos ❗ Liberen a Palestina. 💛🇵🇸
If this really happened, Schindler had balls of steels.
This is just a movie
@@0Mnhrdt3 no this is based off everything Schindler did it’s a true story movie
@@iiMilkyWayRoblox it's based off a fictional book
@@midnightclub7629 no it’s based off a non fictional book that contains actual stuff that happened In real life.
@@midnightclub7629 no this is a true event
Oscar is very upset with what's going on, but he feels like he cannot do anything like he could before the war. 1:45 is a great example of the real feelings between Oscar and Goethe's men. Oscar is doing everything in his power, and he feels helpless in comparison to his position in the 20's and 30's. Stern is another great example of where Oscar is at.
*Oskar
@@--AnonymousUser-- Set my balls on fire..... let me cock rise higher.
"Bless are the merciful because they will receive mercy"---God
You shouldn't need the promise of rewards in the afterlife in order to be a good person. You should be a good person even if you're going to hell, or if there is no afterlife.
@@HRHooChicken ; You don't get it, do you? Chicken.
Hahaha what? God? Who? Was that God sleeping when 6M of them were subjected to a merciless end? Nietzsche was right "God is dead." God is F-in dead!
Amen
@@HRHooChicken you don't understand what it is to be a good person without God's revelations.
They stop laughing........... What a kind man Schindler was
I think they were either thinking "You've got serious OCD issues" or they genuinely thought "Man, you really ARE evil."
He could have gotten killed at this point.. brave man. Not in this lifetime will i ever match this man's bravery.
It was just water on the train no harm done thats why they didnt say anything and with all the people oskar knows he could wiggle out of most small things like this
Not really. They had laws in Germany. Spraying a train with water wasn't a crime. Killing Schindler would have been murder
@@HRHooChicken Do you really think that was the case?
Who the hell could check on every single killing or officer? Are you for real??
Do you really think Hitler or his close staff was everywhere? In that chaos??
You then must be a naive person.....
@@tiborvisi7438 if you think German soldiers wandered around killing other Germans indiscriminately without consequence then you’re a brainwashed fool. It would’ve been no different to it happening in the UK or USA. They would’ve been tried for murder and shot.
"You shouldn't do it, that's cruel"
Me:- "Look who's talking?"
I don’t know what Spielberg was on at his time but this film was peak brilliance.
RIP Oskar Schindler. Save one man you save the world.
"Your cruel"
Me"You'd know about that. Wouldn't you mate"
I have 2 different theories here regarding what Goeth is thinking here:
i think he's pondering Schindler's motives, but he's guessed that Schindler (who has exquisite tastes in alcohol and suits etc) is trying to keep the workers healthy so they will perform better in his factorys and keep making him more money! He thinks Schindler is obsessed by money, which he really was until he started growing a conscience
He cannot comprehend he is doing it as he pitys them, so that's the only possible conclusion is that Schlinder is indeed a money greedy businessman. obsessed in protecting his assets.
The other theory, a lot weaker is that Goeth is developing an obsession for the jewish servant girl he has as his personal servant, and the ONLY person who possibly relates to this is Schindler, he feels a strange kinda empathy with a guy he really admires, Schindler too has developed a strange and forbidden bond with the jews. Outing Schindler for it would be outing himself and he's at odds on how to feel and deal with the entire situation
Amons change of expression, as well as all of the officers, is good.
Not a cell phone in sight...just two guys enjoyng the summer heat
3:13 look at the sign, they knew about e-mail before it existed
Which sign?
Lmao
“Oskar seriously, cut it out, our gas bill is already out of this world, the least we could do is try and clamp down on the water bill a tid bit.“
It's like a meeting of Netanyahu's cabinet :(
Then comes the Gestapo for Schindler. This scene was really scary. Schindler was arrested 3 times by the Gestapo and if it weren't for his connections that he had with high rank officials in the Abwehr and SS Police he more than likely would have wound up perishing in Auschwitz like those who he saved. What an incredible and good man. Remember Oskar Schindler!!
Schindler would have never been sent to a concentration camp or death camp.. but he would have definitely been legally punished by the Nazi Party
I hope people remember that this movie is a historical fiction. Unfortunately some in the comments think this is real.
Goeth is evil and terrifying, so I’m always really scared of him more than Darth Vader or Sauron, because what we see him do really happened. But this scene in particular scares me a lot, because we know of Goeth’s capabilities, and now he realizes who Schindler really is behind that Swastika-marked button. The tension rises making it hard to watch because in the beginning he’s completely oblivious but realizes very slowly what’s happening right in front of him. It beautiful and horrifying at the same time. Ralph Fiennes will always remain the greatest actor for a villain of all time, in my opinion.
‘’I am not saying you will regret it but you might… alright it’s a nice day I’ll go for a drive with you” …3:22…cool knowing he is being arrested by the gestapo . What presence and confidence.
“You’re giving them hope. You shouldn’t do that!”
Don't forget Gaza, no water!!!
What's really creepy about the 'Where's the fire?' line is that all of those people would wind up burning in the end.
Hope is the worst form of evil for it prolongs the suffering of man - Nietzsche
Actually, stuffing them in a hot train and shipping them off to certain death increases their suffering more than a drink of water. I know it's counter-intuitive, but trust me, most people would prefer not to be thirsty in any circumstance.
Hope is a good thing maybe the best of things and no good thing ever dies - andy Dufrence
To be perfectly honest, fuck Nietzsche...
From someone with psoriasis at 24 I can agree with that
And Nietzsche has a heck of a lot to answer for. He tried, but his ethic made him insane. And what did we get?
Liam Neeson acting as Schindler, who acting as a rich factory owner, this movie is perfect
He smiles and jokes when he turns his head towards the ones in military uniform, but has a face of urgency when he looks to the people in the carts and directs the man to hoes them down with water.
Definition of a sheep dog in wolves clothing.
Or maybe even a Shepard, so to speak.
Sheepdog.
a bunch of school bullies that never grew up
Yeah something like that
Every notice Nazis now arent what Nazis are SUPPOSED to look like. They're always in some way kinda unfit or too self indulgent.
@@ciaranward3559 whereas antifa just look like mutants
What's interesting is that Ralph continually shows through the film that he respects, and even at times emulates Liam. Look at 0:14 how happy he is to see him, then when they sit down, how he is looking at him. Liam takes off his hat, Ralph copies.
However, despite this, Ralph never understands him. But is perplexed by him.
This is undoubtedly one of the most important films ever created.
But I also wish a film about the gulag archipelago was created detailing events such as this one did with the holocaust with such cinematic intensity.
The friendship between an angel and a devil.
It takes a very special man to be praised and loved by two opposite sides in such a war, simply amaizing
This is a beautiful dog
Forget the Nazis, look at the beautiful dog in the background.
abhishek sk It's a Great Dane mate.
I love Great Danes. They're so big but so gentle.
A Great Dane! They are majestic no doubt!🐕💪
Hate to burst the beautiful dog picture but that was probably Amon's dog which he trained to rip people apart and attack people.
Beautiful dog
Spielberg directed a masterpiece.
This movie is still one of my favorites.
This ,and " Pianist'
@@melanie851 Pianist is also awesome.
@@melanie851
And the lessons of both are missed when those same people can become, in real time right before your eyes, just as bad as their own oppressor.
@@fredmcelroy2839
What would be awesome is if you demanded those lessons be universally applied
Mine too
Amon's laugh...
I always found this scene particularly striking for its subtle psychological tension between Goeth and Schindler. Three minutes is enough to figure out their ambitions and even revelations about each other - the initial exchange between them and how Schindler doesn't seem to pay much attention to anything except the cars while Goeth fixates his gaze on Schindler with a hope of establishing himself as an important figure in the eyes of a wealthy, powerful businessman. Schindler is aware of the whole power dynamics and nonchalantly suggests water hoses as a game for the sake of entertainment, indulging in laughing and maintaining joyful atmosphere (especially how he forces the first laugh after 'where's the fire' which followed by Goeth's). The last frames of Goeth's gaze speak for themselves - the growing realization of Schindler's intentions masterfully rendered in a silent close-up.
Very good comment..ty
Yeah I saw the scene too
I think they start laughing simultaneously.
quit the yap we know what its about bro thinks its a joke but my mans actually sees humans
goeth was aware? but didn't do anything about it?
I always wonder in this scene whether Goeth is wondering why Schindler is doing this or just realizing what are his real intentions.
Goeth knew the score and fully aware. Ruthless but yet wise enough to know that Schindler was his meal ticket .
To someone doesn't know why Schindler did that:
The weather was hot, and air was very hot in the train. So many Jews in the train almost couldn't breathe because of the hot air. Schindler just spread the water to them to make them more comfortable.
Holy shit I thought this video was about funny cats.
I just thought that Schindler thought that the Train was filthy and wanted to clean it with a garden hose.
You're all wrong. The trains were actually on fire. Even the German who was eating confirms this.
World Difference No shit dude.I thought he did for the lolz
Yes indeed
Spielberg’s magnum opus his swan song his masterwork no one could have made this film except for him , he was born to paint this indescribable canvas of human pain suffering and unimaginable horror . ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Schön das er deutsche als Monster darstellt, was als Jude nicht verwunderlich ist. Und niemand weiß, warum Juden damals nicht gemocht wurden.
I feel like that might have made a worse situation for the prisoners in the long run. Once the water warms up, it'll get incredibly hot _and_ humid.
I agree with Amon, he did give them hope. They had no clue about the horrors to come.
This scene is brilliant
In an hour of such darkness lies such one bright hope of humanity and compassion.
the movie makes it seem like the rail cars are big. But they had one in the holocaust museum and those things were very tiny and cramped.
The nazis are so cold and heartless, even the sight of human compassion is almost alien towards them.
Shows the power of brain washing
@@nathanhursey6779 sociopathy doesn't come from brain washing
*palm rubbing intensifies*
@@nickgurpleez2628 I'm not saying what the SS did wasn't fucked up bc it was. Hitler though using his ideology and having the idea that they were the dominant race led to these men becoming mass murders.
Isn't rich capitalist scum worse?
Goeths haircut is proving to be very popular these days.
Its a great hairstyle. I cut my hair like that sometimes
Just noticed one of the officers sat next to amon is "reolheder" from the 1993 stalingrad film. Personally thought that was interesting as I love the film😂
They stopped laughing when they finally realized what his true intentions were.
Whenever i see it i got Goosebumps tears 😢 at the same time...
Mereka telah meraskan pedihnya pembantaian tapi mengapa mereka lakukan thdp rakyat Palestina
He’s literally using his gift to negotiate and managing to save these people lives with a smile on his face.
It took Goath a few minutes to realize what Oskar was really doing, Humanity
I don’t know how oscar Schindler was throughout, but from the acting by Liam it seemed that this was the actual moment where he transformed into a human being from being a nazi
From the movie, I think that when he first saw the girl in the red coat, was when something started to spark up within him; and then the moment he saw her dead in the cart, he knew something really needed to be done. He made the same face for both scenes. Like you can see the realisation hitting him properly for the first time. In real life, it would’ve been gradual of course. Not that it wasn’t gradual in the film, that’s the whole part of his character development. But it separates each time there’s a change within him, to make it clearer for the audience
0:32 ladies and gents behold, first ever cellphone in the history of hoomans
1:10 a very subtle dose of irony from Spielberg, one of the Nazis asks "where's the fire." Over his shoulder, a train car is labeled Dresden. Dresden was the site of a significant firebombing in February 1945.
One of the best movies I have seen x
"Where's the fire?" Haha. I dig it.
Goethe be like, "there's an imposter among us".
Did you mean "Göth"?
Amog us
Ben Kingsley, realizing that Schindler is saving everybody from the heat is priceless!
Wonderful compassion ❤
One of the best movies based on a novel.
I bet it’s the joo’s fault you’re chubby and poor.
"Where's the fire?'
How was Shindler able to deal with all these college professors and college kids is beyond me
It's love beyond border an unconditional.
34 “Then the King will say to those on his right, ‘Come, you whom my Father has blessed, take your inheritance, the Kingdom prepared for you from the founding of the world. 35 For I was hungry and you gave me food, I was thirsty and you gave me something to drink, I was a stranger and you made me your guest, 36 I needed clothes and you provided them, I was sick and you took care of me, I was in prison and you visited me.’ 37 Then the people who have done what God wants will reply, ‘Lord, when did we see you hungry and feed you, or thirsty and give you something to drink? 38 When did we see you a stranger and make you our guest, or needing clothes and provide them? 39 When did we see you sick or in prison, and visit you?’ 40 The King will say to them, ‘Yes! I tell you that whenever you did these things for one of the least important of these brothers of mine, you did them for me!’ Matthew 25:35-40
Sadly now same situation in Gaza, but reversed
How he kept his cool knowing he was in the lions den, a man of such compassion no wonder the Jews honoured him, would we be the same in his shoes?
My parent's friends are kids of two of Schindler's kids. They told me about this exactly. Schindler said to the Nazi officers near the train that they smell really bad and they should "wash" them. And that how he got them water.. That is why I assumed that it'll be in the movie. To this day I can't watch this movie. But I am from Israel and was on the poland delegation singing the song from "the girl in red" scene in Yiddish a-capella in a synagog in the Tykocin town. Of you want I can interpret it:)
My foster grandfather is a victim of the holacoust
1:14 this was so much better in german... ,,Wo brennt's denn?''
his was such a lighthearted comedy!
Best scene and sad at the same time
That's what u call a human.
Quite a picnic!
I have seen this movie once. It is clearly a masterpiece; a work of sublime cinematic and historical artistry. I hope to never see it again. It documents horrors and atrocities that make me ashamed to be a human being. I can't stand it.
Fassbender would of SMASHED that role of the evil general - I know a little before his time but he could of pulled that laugh off spot on!
I am sorry for all the things jews had to go through.... This is my favourite movie of all time...the things i saw in this movie is soooo sad that i cant bloody explain
From a muslim...i hope one day we could get along together
Wow, we need more people like you❤
But we also need to consider what THEY have put people through over the centuries
I'm glad you feel the same way.