@ nguyen bao long - Adolf Hitler came from almost nothing and dirt level poverty anyone can rise to greatness, your statement only exposes how much of a lazy communist bum you are if you are at the bottom it's only cus you want to be
@@joryadamson7854 Dagmar of Denmark - fled on HMS Marlborough from the Crimean peninsula shortly after the execution of her som and his family. An execution she never accepted. Moved to Copenhagen, where her lavish lifestyle earned her the disatisfaction of king Christian X. Lived her days out with queen Alexandra after her return from GB.
I see many people inaccurately saying that the Bolsheviks kept the traditions of the Imperial Russian Army, this is completely false. The military traditions of the Imperial Russian Army were eventually and completely destroyed by the Bolsheviks after the Great October Socialist Revolution. The formation of the Workers and Peasants Red Army marked a new era in the history of the historical armies of Russia. The Bolsheviks only kept the Budenovka, a very unpopular and rarely used hat in the Imperial Russian Army. It eventually became the iconic hat of the Red Army during the civil war, and was in the shape of a Bogatyr's helmet (an ancient Russian warrior of Rus) and the early uniforms of the RKKA were reminiscent of the uniforms of the Streltsy . Apart from that, everything else was pretty much abandoned, most importantly, Russian Army shoulder boards and epaulets were abolished. Military orders, decorations, and medals of Imperial Russia were also banned from use. The famous ribbon of Saint George was one of these military relics that were banned from use. The Red Army also abolished the table of ranks of the Imperial Russian Army. New ranks and formations were made, and non of them followed any of the historical traditions of the Russian Army. However, this was not the end of Tsarist/Russian military traditions. They were thankfully revived when Nazi Germany invaded the USSR in the summer of 1941. The soviet government became very pragmatic and knew they had to revive East Slavic patriotism in order to keep the Red Army's morale high. A news paper by Pravda declared the name of the war as the "Great Patriotic War." (This is the name of the war in Soviet Historiography) and is solely based on the name of the War between France and the Russian Empire in 1812. In Imperial Russian historiography, this was was known as the "Patriotic War." Do you see how identical the name is? The word "great" is meant to emphasize the shear importance of the German invasion of the USSR, and recalls the patriotic message of their ancestors who had to fight in the same scenario, but by a different country. Around 1942-43 the shoulder boards of the Imperial Russian Army were revived, the Ribbon of Saint George (previously banned) was reintroduced as the "Guards Ribbon" but had the same context and design. Many Tsarist/Imperial Russian marches and songs were revived, but under different lyrics depending on the context of the original song. Some of these marches include "farewell of Slavianka" a tsarist march that was later used by the Red Army during the 1941 October Revolution parade in Moscow. Many military orders of the Red Army began to use the faces & names of famous Imperial Russian generals and Ukrainian cossacks. These include Field Marshall Mikhail Kutuzov, Admiral Fyodor Ushakov , Generalissimo of the Imperial Russian Army Alexander Suvorov , Russian warrior Alexander Nevsky, and Ukrainian leader Bohdan Khmelnytsky .
Down with all kings, leaders and Stalinist dictatorship! Down with all oppressing and distortions! Down with all elitist privileges bureaucrats! Down with all aggressive and wars! Down with all dogmatic religions and traditions! Down with all greedy bourgeois monopolist dictatorship! We have no thing to loose but our chains. Liberty or Death!?! With the International, humanity will rise up!
@@northwesternfenian3436 how many people USA lost during the war? What about battles on American land? Can't remember any? Learn history, lad, before making such conclusions ;)
Steven Yatsuta how many? I am sure that’s not more than 11 million leastly and “officially proved by russian army”. Unlike you stupid fucks rised in all goods, we study hard in russia to just migrate from this hell
Необращал, на все это, раньше, внимание. Спасибо автору канала, подсказал куда посмотреть! Михалков показал красоту традиции принятия в юнкера. Всё в мелчайших деталям показано... Браво режисёр, браво!
@@karmaoo3865 책에서 우연히 봐보았는데 니콜라이 2세는 아버지 알렉산드르 3세의 영향을 받아 철권 통치를 이어갔다고 합니다. 니콜라이 2세와 알렉산드르 3세를 거쳐서 철권 통치는 더욱더 심해졌다고 하는데 정말 말씀처럼 후계자 교육을 잘 시켰으면 그나마 나았지 않을까 생각합니다
The czarist state was the most terrific racist antisemitic and white supremacy based totalitarian regime at the time, reflected the Kkk in the US. That why horrible virulent anti-indigenous racism, violence against minority groups, and crazy conspiracy theories like the protocols of zion , 'll generated from late 19th century Russia.
Late Russian empire was like the Qanon in the US, tolerance declined, the society degenerated violent pogroms made up of cold-blooded antisemites, clownish antiscience conspiracy theorists, or racists, 'll signs of a declining country. That why we should stop the rightwing terrors now to save America.
@@Joshua_Nguyen0630 Bolseviks and leftist killed more russians than Hitler did during WW2...Gulags,punishment,killings..those the things that leftist brought during revolution...Tsarist Russia will evolutiate during years( parlament, elections and many more)...Always evolution, never revolution.
@@panamarcina Alexander III was pretty average as far as late 19th-early 20th century monarchs go. He wanted a pure ethnostate and persecuted jews, like literally everyone else in Europe. Nicholas II was mainly terrible because he inherited the throne before he was fully trained to govern the empire.
I can see many comments of people absolutely unfamilliar with Russian history telling "bolsheviks kept the tradition". Bolsheviks didn't keep any of those traditions, they destroyed everything that resembles imperial army. The vast majority of the imperial officers were killed or expelled from Russia in the first years after revolution and the very word "officer" became an insult. They were tortured by carving out the "shoulder boards" on their shoulder skin - the main insignia in Tsar army. They were brought back as well as all other attributes of Russian army ONLY in the year of 1943.
Вы сильно ошибаетесь, очень большой процент офицеров Русской Армии участвовали в гражданской войне на стороне красных, Весь так называемый цвет русского офицерства, в большинстве своем полег на полях первой мировой, к 1917 году основная часть офицеров младшего и среднего звена была выходцами из городской интеллигенции, робочего и крестьянского сословия которые и сформировали командный состав красной армии, в белой армии, на самом деле был серьезный дефицит в командном составе.
@@MakhachSultanov ошибаетесь вы. Очень большой это какой? Основная часть офицеров действительно была выходцами из простого народа, повышенного в годы ПМВ, и их так же бессовестно расстреливали как "эксплуататоров". Дефицит командного состава белых, у которых офицеры служили рядовыми - это из какой-то больной фантазии, или может быть из 21-го и 22-го годов, когда все уже давно было кончено для белых? Нет, конечно, мизерная часть офицеров разделяла идеи красных, другая была карьеристами, не хотевшими идти рядовыми в добровольческие армии, и шедшая на командные должности к большевикам, но подавляющая масса была на стороне белых, а само слово "офицер", если вы не знаете, было оскорблением в революционной среде.
His Imperial Highness, Grand Duke Mikhail Alexandrovich Romanov is the young boy with Alexander III... It is said that "Misha" was the most like in mind and temperament to that of his father, the Tsar.🕯🕊☦👑🇷🇺👑☦🕊🕯
What, he still played kiss chase when 25. The issue with the Romanovs, like most of the European monarchy at this time, was inbreeding. Because of it, you had people of low intellect running countries. The Czar, The Kaiser and George the V. The luck for the English was George the V thought he ran the country but didn't. The czar took control of the Russian war effort but was infantile in his aims and objectives and lost a country. The Kaiser was basically a childish idiot and allowed his whims by Hindendorth and Ludendorff, but no real power. And George the V was allowed to walk around and pretend he was in charge but all of the UK establishment knew he wasn't. I await my firestorm far saying the 'truth to power'
@@texan4548 that was how the Imperial family of Russia was addressed. They were addressed by title and name unless you were intimately acquainted with them and were permitted to address them by name. I might suggest that you learn something of the customs and formalities of the court.
@@walterweiss7124 Mikhail Alexandrovich was Alexander III's favorite. I'm sure if he could've, Alexander would've named Mikhail as Tsarevich instead of Nikolai. Alexander didn't allow his oldest son and heir to participate in cabinet meetings or bother to really instruct him in the business of being Tsar. Nikolai upon assuming the throne, was heard to say: "I come to the throne too young... I know nothing of the business of ruling".
You can see how the Prussian/German military tradition was connected with the Russian military tradition. It stems from the 18th and 19th centuries. Some elements have even been preserved up to the time of the Bundeswehr. Unfortunately far too little
Yeah it’s very sad that many traditions in the German military are gone. The most obvious one is that the German military doesn’t goosestep anymore. They also don’t preserve any of their old dress from 1918 and before for parades. Instead they have the dumb berets for dress caps.
@@wilhelmvonberghoff175 Yes, of course you're right. But who broke the Germans' back? If the Germans lift their heads out of the mud just a little, there is a shitstorm in the international media. This and the re-education has broken the neck of the Germans. Now Germany is finally being ruined by the Greens and the left - a pity, but that is fate.
@@0plp0 Tsar Alexander I was a loyal ally of Prussia. Since that time, the Prussian-German uniform system has been strongly influenced by Russia. This is still clearly visible today in the military music and many insignia. Every historically conscious German must be proud of this. I appreciate and respect Russia and its great history. Russia is an inseparable part of Europe
@@kitzbuheltv So what. Look from where they came. Grandmother of Alexander was Catherine the Great that is a German Origin, born in Stettin. Spouse of Catherine was Peter III half german half russian. Godfathers of Alexander I was Joseph II Holly Roman Emperor and Frederick the Great King of Prussia. Since Catherine the Great Russian rullers was Origin German.
Вот так вот смотришь и задумываешься.: "Сколько же тебе ещё матушка-Россия придется перенести тягот и лишений, а сколько сыновей и дочерей своих ты окутаешь в земляную плоть свою... Что о грустном то я!? А сколько потом возродиться сыновей и дочерей русских, да на русской то земле! Слава Руси, слава России!
Russians are RUSSIANS. They are Majestic, Famous, Divine, Magnificent. Thank you O GREAT GOD for creating this beautiful race in spirit and in appearance, in skill and in performance. Slavic Russians are a precious stone and perhaps the most precious stone in the crown of all the peoples of the World. GREAT GOD protect and bless Russia and the Russians and in general all the Slavs in the life of lives everywhere and anytime! 😀😀😘😘🥰🥰🥰🤩🤩🤩💔💔💕💕💞💞💓💓💗💗💖💖💘💘💝💝💟💟🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩
Russians can claim magnificent achievements in the arts and sciences, though not out of proportion to their numbers. They have also been plagued over the centuries with xenophobia, antisemitism, reflexive hostility to "the West," quasi-mystical anti-intellectualism, and among their leaders a sense that they are entitled to dominate other Slavic peoples--being of Polish descent, I know. Lenin's hastily assembled Red Army tried to overrun Eastern Europe in 1920 and was soundly defeated by an alliance led by a gifted amateur strategist, Jozef Pilsudski, and at the end of it Moscow and Smolensk stood undefended. This left Poland, Lithuania, and other nations in the region free to develop economically, free of the stifling control of Bolshevism, until after World War II. Many Russians emigrated to those regions during the Soviet era because the economy was stronger there. The Putin era has shown that Russians have little talent for democratic self-rule, though I see there is a growing movement for that. And to close on a positive note, all my grandparents came from Polish-speaking areas that were under Imperial Russian domination. In those areas the Russian authorities set up free public schools, something the Polish authorities seemed not to bother about. No doubt the purpose was to Russify the population, because instruction was in Russian--but it was a no-cost education. My maternal grandfather, as a boy, chose to attend, though he did so in spite of a threat of excommunication by the local Catholic priest. He became literate in Russian and Polish, and could read enough English to become a US citizen.
@@yuriidarakchiev2942 I can't speak for him, but I would have, if my ancestors had been allowed to stay in their homes, instead of being chased out on the whim of the tsar.
@@thehungrylittlenihilist Karl, if he doesn't speak Russian, which I suspect is the case, he doesn't understand the Russian culture, mentality etc. in plain English he is clueless. Lots of words, little sense.
@@vladoldpub эм... Совок был запатентован Томасом МакНейлом из Филадельфии в 1858 году, так что, он уже более чем 150 лет существует, а избавляться от него не вижу смысла, порой он крайне удобен для уборки всякого мусора и швали, чтобы был порядок и была чистота. Лепота, одним словом.
Очень примечательно, я впервые посмотрел этот фильм, будучи в Корее, в 2003 году зимой. Ох как я смотрел этот фииильмм, ммм. Полностью на русском языке! По телеканалу Action
Digression alert! The black uniforms were a trigger. When Peter Kropotkin, who was from an aristocratic family, graduated from the Imperial Russian military academy, he joined the Siberian regiment because in it he would be posted to areas he wanted to explore as a geographer. When he joined, none of his friends and family seemed familiar with the black uniform. Siberia was not a popular place with his class! Kropotkin renounced his title of prince because of his democratic and socialistic leanings and became an anarchist revolutionary. He soon came to believe that nonviolent methods would best achieve revolutionary goals. When the Russian Revolution succeeded, he hoped that the people would set up a democratic republic. Other anarchists disagreed with him, and the Bolsheviks had other plans, so his hopes, as we know, were not realized. In the 1970s I met an old New York anarchist of Russian descent who remembered the revolution. He disagreed with Kropotkin at the time, but when I spoke with him he said that in the end Kropotkin was right.
I have to confess that I am not happy about the Grand Duke's orders - he should have been wearing the Order of St Andrew. Still: with "The Cadet's Cap" and "God preserve the Tsar" (the tune has an interesting history), the music is very good. This is a film clip which I enjoy
You are right. I belived Misha to be Grand Duke (who he was). The sons of the emperor were awarded the Order of St. Andrew and the lower orders after baptism. The Cavalier of the highest Order doesn't wear its insignia. Rather strange if not serious service wromgdoing.
Costumiers, eh? In the film "Mayerling" the future Edward VII was shown wearing the Order of Maria Theresa which had strict requirements of military leadership which Edward did not meet. Not even the Emperor Ferdinand received it! A little more detailed research avoids irritation to guardians of outdated information, like me!
Not costumiers, but producer, conductor, painters, military consultants. In 1885 cadets have Mosin-Nagants rifles, 10 years before the rifle was invented. The budget of the film is more than $40 mln, they could hire profs or amateurs of any level and order either dummy or real replicas of Berdan or Krnka rifles. Though those faults see barely tens of millions...
What is striking is that the 19th century Tsars were reluctant rulers. From Alexander I to the last Tsar Nicholas II, none of them wanted the position.
@@SuperCosty2010 From history. Let's start with Tsar Alexander I. He ascended to the throne on the murder of his father, Tsar Paul I. During his whole reign, he was haunted with guilt over this. There is a legend that he didn't really die in 1825; but, faked his death and became a monk, Feodor Kuzmich. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feodor_Kuzmich
@@1236612 actually, if you're to become a tsar and you don't want to rule, you deny the whole thing, like Konstantin did for example :) Pavel the First had 10 kids with Maria, somebody would find himself. As for old man Fedor, it's of course nothing more than a conspiracy theory
@@1236612 and after Alexander I don't know too what you're talking about. Nicolas I was reluctant at first though, what didn't keep him in the end from accepting the throne and killing over 1000 people on his first day. Shot them by cannons, aiming on civilians first. After him, only Alexander III was not prepared to rule at first, since he was not the oldest son. But his brother died young enough, so he accepted not only papa's inheritance but the brother's bride also.
@@SuperCosty2010 I wouldn't just dismiss the legend of Feordor Kuzmich outright. Later on, much evidence of him was destroyed by Pobedonostsev, later tutor to Alexander III and Nicholas II. Tsar Alexander I was perhaps the most powerful man on earth, yet, in ways he was somewhat helpless to influence events. At the Congress of Vienna, he was instrumental in establishing democracy in Europe, albeit constitutional monarchies, yet, he was powerless to do the same in his own country.. What I find fascinating are the lives of two contemporaries: Tsar Alexander I and Thomas Jefferson. Both men were democrats in their beliefs, yet, both men had to contend with two evils: serfdom and slavery. They both believed that these institutions were evil., yet, they had to live with this reality to keep support from the ruling elites. Rather than expend the political capital to confront these evils, both men chose to leave it to a future generation to address.
@@7АВТ 뭔 개소리 ㅋㅋㅋ 어딘가 결여되어있고 극단적인 면모가 있던 사람들이 공산주의를 한거지 그게 순수와 헌신이냐? ㅋㅋㅋ 그런 사람들이 사람들 선동하고 내전 일으켜서 사람들을 서로 싸우게 만드니? ㅋㅋㅋ 정상적인 사람들은 절대 그런짓 안한다. 피해의식에 쩔어있고 분노에 가득찬 인간들이나 그런짓을 하지.
Assuming this is accurate the soviets kept a LOT of tsarist military traditions Yelling URA for example after the person inspecting the troops gives a kind of speech
The Soviets originally destroyed most, if not all, Tsarist traditions after the Revolution. It wasn't until the invasion of the USSR by Nazi Germany that many Russian/Tsarist traditions were revived. For example, the name of WW2 in Soviet Historiography was called the "Great Patriotic War." This name was actually based off of the "Patriotic War" when Russia was being invaded by France in 1812. So they decided to add the word "great" to emphasize the importance of the Nazi invasion and connect it to the French Invasion of the Russian Empire.
Никита Сергеевич Михалков Александр Александрович Романов Александр 3 Миротворец В фильме Режиссёра Никиты Сергеевича Михалкова Сибирскiй ЦИРЮЛЬНИКЪ 1998 год
He would have to live at least till 1914 to prevent Russia from entering the dumb war Russia neaded the least. Also his health was certainly weakened by the infamous train accident. And there are leads pointing towards it wasn't exactly an accident. The Brits needed him gone.
It was Alexander III who made a secret military union with France against Germany in 1893. It made inevitable WWI and subsequent collapse of the Russian Empire (along with German, Austro-Hungarian and Turkish empires).
@@viewer6271 Yeah, sure a treaty from 20 years before the war made it inecvitable. Just no. The last things good politicians do is staying true to alliances no matter waht. Alexander understood the intricacies of politics and the goals Russia had to keep in mind. Unlike his son.
@@LongVu-lh9el Vietnamese nationalists are mentally ills. Nationalism is a reactionary and stupid form of bourgeoisie ideal to motivate the people to believe in the authoritarian elitist government, support a dictator and its finance capital, while spread hatred and lies against the innocent Chinese and Asian people & the oppressed minorities, blam Chinese for your internal problems and your corrupted system. Further more, today the Vietnamese nationalists are urging that Vietnam should be become a one-ethnostate supremacist dictatorship. I am full 100 percent Vietnamese but against Vietnamese nationalism and all kinds of nationalism!
@@LongVu-lh9el normal for anyone? the only norm is classical liberalism and a puppet monarchy on the facade. modernism can only lead the planet to hell
@@hermannboyen5392 I am not Khmer Rouge to suggest such drastic measures. But if I could feed myself in our northern forests, I would go there without a second doubt. Because the infomania which modern people breathe is calmly compensated by books
Как сказал Иван Грозный - Россия третий Рим и четвертому не бывать . Хотя и первый Рим наши предки Этрусски построили 🤣. Русский след везде . История России самая скрываемая тайна в мире 😉.
The guys that will 20-30 years later get their asses kicked by Japan, Germany and their own mutinous troops (in that order). I do like a subtle hint of the underlying problem at the beginning when the whole well rehearsed spectacle is nearly derailed by one late priest.
Has nothing to do with the priest. At the begining of the film a terror act is shown where the soldiers are attacked by some anarchists. Is don't know exactly if it was a thing in the Alexander III times.
The Bolsheviks didn't keep the traditions, shortly after the October Revolution and the Russian Civil war, the Bolsheviks destroyed and omitted all Tsarist/Russian military traditions. It wasn't until the break out of WW2 when Nazi Germany invaded the USSR that many Tsarist traditions were revived to boost the morale of the Red Army. Those were pragmatic times within the USSR, because there was a huge emphasis on Russian/East Slavic patriotism during the invasion. Recall the name of the war in Soviet Historiography, which was called the "great patriotic war." This was based on the French invasion of the Russian Empire in 1812 (which in Russian Historiography was called the "Patriotic War")
@@ricksanchez7192 А щас как будто их нет. Да и вообще отрицать то, что во все времена и во всех странах, есть в той или иной степени, более или менее выраженное рабство, было бы лицемерием. Царская Россия пусть и медленно все же, старалась выпутать людей из этой паутины, не везде - это невозможно, но на некоторых заводах были закреплены 9 часов рабочей смены, бесплатная медстраховка и ЛИЧНАЯ больница у рабочих, школы для их детей. И Смотря на то, что у нас есть сейчас в Убогой ФЕДерации, то лучше Царское рабство, чем такая федеративная свобода.
Pardon my ignorance, but what film is this from and what is being depicted in this scene? It’s beautifully shot and very high quality. Is there a version of it available in English?
Ага, а особенно - казахи, горцы, чеченцы, аварцы, грузины, кабардинцы, абхазцы, осетины, лезгины, черкесы, кумыки, поляки, эстонцы, литовцы, латвийцы, финны... настолько сильно все хотели под крыло русского императора, что сдавались почти без боя
@@strangenaut4765 Вот грузины как раз очень и просились!!! Грузинские князья более ста(!) лет просили защиты у русских царей от персов и турок... И еще сто лет продлилась Кавказская война, которая России не нужна была СОВСЕМ! На начало войны, грузин, как этноса, оставалось менее 70 000; через несколько лет их было уже около 300 000!, и это при том, что шла война... А уже в 20х годах 20го века захотели отделиться(меньшевитский мятеж); набрали силу, да и закончился период русско- турецких войн. Сколько русских воинов полегло, что бы сохранить грузин как НАРОД??? Облагодарили знатно уже в 21 веке. PS. Кстати, грузин в Грузии меньшинство, не без помощи России покорили соседние народы - сваны, кахетинцы, аджарцы- очень, очень много... Грузия на Кавказе, как Польша в Европе, гиена.
@@timofejzivoderoff7682 А биритаецы хорошо были когда туалеты у караулных не было и они на людей торгующих какали и писяли в России не только кремтияны были - так же мастера рахные а больше половына царской армии были крестияны ... А при иване грозном много завидени ученые уткрили так же медицинские учреждения а королева англи в это время на лево и на право десятки тысяч убивала а корол Франции за одну ночь 40 тысяч людей убил в бартолемейскую ночь - или это другое и вашим богам Европе все можно ? Если в Европе и США женщины за права боролись то в Китае и персы всегда на уровне были с мужчинами можно посмотреть видео на женщин ирана при шахе да и теперь в правительстве много ....
Old Regimental names being restored by Putin to raise pride and moral in his new military. This includes flags and music. He was respected Tsar but had his enemies all the same. Tried to make Russia modern.
@@pnduarte4696 Yeah, for some people for sure. Although even under Gorbachov, let's say, from 1987 on even Soviet books became very objective and the government even financed films like "The Dog's Heart" by Bulgakov to show how rich and progressive (for its time) the Russian Empire was. So those who judge the pre-Soviet Russian history by reading Soviet books published earlier than 1987, well, those people have mental problems.
they acting was so good I swear I started understanding them about halfway through when he was talking to his wife...
it's the WEIRDEST thing...
the tzarina was of British and german ascendance
Because of these greedy luxurious leaders and capitalists pig, we working class and humanity all die for the war!
@ nguyen bao long - Adolf Hitler came from almost nothing and dirt level poverty
anyone can rise to greatness, your statement only exposes how much of a lazy communist bum you are
if you are at the bottom it's only cus you want to be
@@MisteroZodiac The Empress of Russia in 1885 was of Danish descent being the daughter of Christian IX of Denmark
@@joryadamson7854 Dagmar of Denmark - fled on HMS Marlborough from the Crimean peninsula shortly after the execution of her som and his family. An execution she never accepted. Moved to Copenhagen, where her lavish lifestyle earned her the disatisfaction of king Christian X. Lived her days out with queen Alexandra after her return from GB.
대학때 방에서 이 영화 보고있는데 사고뭉치 룸메가 옆에서 가만히 같이 보더니 며칠뒤 ROTC 지원하고 지금은 대위임ㅋㅋㅋ
인생의 귀인 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@mrcha0501 저보다는 영화속 생도학교 중대장이 귀인입니다. 룸메가 중대장이 그렇게 멋있다고ㅋㅋㅋ
@@dcjj344 정말 이상적인 중대장이었죠!! 부하들을 신뢰하고 사랑으로 품는 상관 ㅎㅎㅎ
@@kmyung 검술대결 커버 쳐준거랑 호송열차 떠날때 경례 해주는건 진짜 멋졌죠
한창 실망하고 계시겠네요
For anyone wondering the first song played is "March of the Preobrazhensky Regiment" the second is march of the Saratov Regiment
Thanks from Russia!
1:45 ~ 2:25 Марш Лейб-гвардии Преображенского полка (March of Life Guards Preobrazhensky Regiment)(프레오브라젠스키 근위연대 행진곡)
3:09 ~ 3:23 Егерский марш (Jaeger March)(엽병 행진곡)
4:01 ~ 5:03 Марш 108-го Саратовского пехотного полка (March of 108th Saratov Infantry Regiment
)(제108 사라토브 보병연대 행진곡)
6:06 ~ 6:53 Боже, Царя храни (God save the Tzar)(주여, 차르를 지켜주소서)
전승절 사열에 자주 나오는 곡들이네요
Старо-егерский, по сборнику Дерфельда)
why prussian jager and russian jaeger is same march music and the tone?
엽병행진곡 소련 시절에도 쓰였죠.
А как фильм называется?
Strange seeing them carrying Mosin Nagants 6 years before they were invented.
Probably not enough Berdan II's around to equip that many extras.
More like Abyssinia never.
pretty sharp !
and marching like soviets
@@someguycold8566 это марш Преображенского Полка. На то время ему было почти 200 лет.
I see many people inaccurately saying that the Bolsheviks kept the traditions of the Imperial Russian Army, this is completely false. The military traditions of the Imperial Russian Army were eventually and completely destroyed by the Bolsheviks after the Great October Socialist Revolution. The formation of the Workers and Peasants Red Army marked a new era in the history of the historical armies of Russia. The Bolsheviks only kept the Budenovka, a very unpopular and rarely used hat in the Imperial Russian Army. It eventually became the iconic hat of the Red Army during the civil war, and was in the shape of a Bogatyr's helmet (an ancient Russian warrior of Rus) and the early uniforms of the RKKA were reminiscent of the uniforms of the Streltsy
. Apart from that, everything else was pretty much abandoned, most importantly, Russian Army shoulder boards and epaulets were abolished. Military orders, decorations, and medals of Imperial Russia were also banned from use. The famous ribbon of Saint George was one of these military relics that were banned from use. The Red Army also abolished the table of ranks of the Imperial Russian Army. New ranks and formations were made, and non of them followed any of the historical traditions of the Russian Army.
However, this was not the end of Tsarist/Russian military traditions. They were thankfully revived when Nazi Germany invaded the USSR in the summer of 1941. The soviet government became very pragmatic and knew they had to revive East Slavic patriotism in order to keep the Red Army's morale high. A news paper by Pravda declared the name of the war as the "Great Patriotic War." (This is the name of the war in Soviet Historiography) and is solely based on the name of the War between France and the Russian Empire in 1812. In Imperial Russian historiography, this was was known as the "Patriotic War." Do you see how identical the name is? The word "great" is meant to emphasize the shear importance of the German invasion of the USSR, and recalls the patriotic message of their ancestors who had to fight in the same scenario, but by a different country. Around 1942-43 the shoulder boards of the Imperial Russian Army were revived, the Ribbon of Saint George (previously banned) was reintroduced as the "Guards Ribbon" but had the same context and design. Many Tsarist/Imperial Russian marches and songs were revived, but under different lyrics depending on the context of the original song. Some of these marches include "farewell of Slavianka" a tsarist march that was later used by the Red Army during the 1941 October Revolution parade in Moscow. Many military orders of the Red Army began to use the faces & names of famous Imperial Russian generals and Ukrainian cossacks. These include Field Marshall Mikhail Kutuzov, Admiral Fyodor Ushakov
, Generalissimo
of the Imperial Russian Army Alexander Suvorov
, Russian warrior Alexander Nevsky, and Ukrainian leader Bohdan Khmelnytsky
.
Down with all kings, leaders and Stalinist dictatorship!
Down with all oppressing and distortions!
Down with all elitist privileges bureaucrats!
Down with all aggressive and wars!
Down with all dogmatic religions and traditions!
Down with all greedy bourgeois monopolist dictatorship!
We have no thing to loose but our chains.
Liberty or Death!?!
With the International, humanity will rise up!
@@northwesternfenian3436 how many people USA lost during the war? What about battles on American land? Can't remember any? Learn history, lad, before making such conclusions ;)
Steven Yatsuta how many? I am sure that’s not more than 11 million leastly and “officially proved by russian army”. Unlike you stupid fucks rised in all goods, we study hard in russia to just migrate from this hell
@@stepanastashenkov4659 Only one who needs to learn history is the one saying comparing American losses to Soviet losses.
Ben Lundquist The Red Army didn’t suck In the war. The only humiliating loss was when Finland fought the USSR in the winter war.
어린시절 영상을 접하고 군인들의 모습이 너무 멋져서 몇 번이고 다시 돌려봤던 기억이 납니다.
영상을 올려주셔서 정말 고맙습니다. 행복이 가득하시길 진심으로 기원합니다.
Необращал, на все это, раньше, внимание. Спасибо автору канала, подсказал куда посмотреть! Михалков показал красоту традиции принятия в юнкера. Всё в мелчайших деталям показано... Браво режисёр, браво!
*принятие в унтер-офицеры
Такая ту..ф..та
@@AntiFash-какая ты ,,,Тарас туфта
Какая гордость за Отечество , нашу армию и Государя..! Браво..
Россия, которую мы потеряли... Но! Должны возродить с Божией помощью!!! 🙏
Надоублюдкаказнить
My Russian was pretty good for about 30 seconds,
Gave it 10 minutes. I thought it was very bad. TL:cnf.
God save the Tsar !🙏🏼❤️Thanks for sharing this scene with tsar Alexander 3 of Russia 🇩🇰
Nikolai 2
allah is greatest
@@badar_9bfamily31 it's not
Nikolai II-Николай II
@@mochithecat2727 It is him....Whom this actor is playing, so you are wrong....
알렉산도르 3세(1845~1894/재위:1881~1894)는 알렉산도르 2세의 차남으로 키가 193으로 장대한 키를 가졌으며 사격술에 능했다고하며 장남 니콜라이 황태자(니콜라이 2세)를 포함한 자녀들에게 다정다감한 아버지였다고 합니다
알렉산드로 3세가 황태자에게 어렸을때부터 후계자 교육을 시켰으면 러시아 제국이 무너지지 않았을겁니다.
니콜라이 2세가 즉위했을때 전혀 후계자 교육을 받지 않았고 스스로도 황제에 오를 준비가 되지 않았다고 했죠
@@karmaoo3865 책에서 우연히 봐보았는데 니콜라이 2세는 아버지 알렉산드르 3세의 영향을 받아 철권 통치를 이어갔다고 합니다. 니콜라이 2세와 알렉산드르 3세를 거쳐서 철권 통치는 더욱더 심해졌다고 하는데 정말 말씀처럼 후계자 교육을 잘 시켰으면 그나마 나았지 않을까 생각합니다
@@nujeel8239 전제군주면 카리스마 있게 밀어붙이는 스타일이었으면 몰라도 니콜라이 2세는 유약하면서 우유부단해서 귀족들과 국민들에게 신통치 않다는 평가를 받다가 라스푸틴을 신임하면서 몰락의 길을 가고 말았죠
откуда все знаете китайцы ,вы историю россии изучаете?
@@olegfavorit это корейцы.
Знают они лишь верхушечки.
The Barber of Siberia; I guess the boy is Grand Duke Michail, the Tsar's youngest son
Что бы не говорили,но вот это...ща,иии раз....и сомкнутые мизинцы и всё... Слезы сами текут...
дура что ли?
Надоказнитьказла
이 영화 고증 잘 하기로 유명함.
I love the editing of this part of the film.
What's the name of this film
@@majcoycomd8064 Nikita Mikhalkov's "The Barber Of Siberia"
I’m not Korean or Russian, but long live Russia
I'm South Korean, I like Russian empire but hate USSR and Russian federation.
The czarist state was the most terrific racist antisemitic and white supremacy based totalitarian regime at the time, reflected the Kkk in the US. That why horrible virulent anti-indigenous racism, violence against minority groups, and crazy conspiracy theories like the protocols of zion , 'll generated from late 19th century Russia.
Late Russian empire was like the Qanon in the US, tolerance declined, the society degenerated violent pogroms made up of cold-blooded antisemites, clownish antiscience conspiracy theorists, or racists, 'll signs of a declining country. That why we should stop the rightwing terrors now to save America.
you don't have to be Russian, you just have to be a good person, like Russians.
@@Joshua_Nguyen0630 Bolseviks and leftist killed more russians than Hitler did during WW2...Gulags,punishment,killings..those the things that leftist brought during revolution...Tsarist Russia will evolutiate during years( parlament, elections and many more)...Always evolution, never revolution.
Don’t be sad that it is gone, be happy that it happened, and that at least some of it was good, if not all.
Tsar Alexander the Third, last real Autocrat of all the Russias.
He was one of the dumbiest tsars, in foolishly only his son surpassed him - that's why they lose their power and the Bolsheviks came to power.
@@panamarcina He was a stupid bigoted person
@@panamarcina Alexander III was pretty average as far as late 19th-early 20th century monarchs go. He wanted a pure ethnostate and persecuted jews, like literally everyone else in Europe. Nicholas II was mainly terrible because he inherited the throne before he was fully trained to govern the empire.
@@DPRK_Best_Korea >persecuted jews. That's problem?
Nikolai was like his papa, or tried at least
러브 오브 시베리아...
과거 여친이랑 꽁냥꽁냥 하러
디브디방 가서 아무거나 대충 골랐던
영화였는데... 둘다 영화에 몰입해서 정말 영화만 보고 나오게 만든 작품.
지금도 교제하시나요?
답 없는거보니까 헤어진듯😂😂
I like to know about other history, love from Malaysia 🇲🇾
Hadirr
Same
Saya pun orang Malaysia 🙋🏻♂️
@@syawalhamidi allah itu babi
@@mochithecat2727
Kau ni dah kenapa?
I can see many comments of people absolutely unfamilliar with Russian history telling "bolsheviks kept the tradition". Bolsheviks didn't keep any of those traditions, they destroyed everything that resembles imperial army. The vast majority of the imperial officers were killed or expelled from Russia in the first years after revolution and the very word "officer" became an insult. They were tortured by carving out the "shoulder boards" on their shoulder skin - the main insignia in Tsar army. They were brought back as well as all other attributes of Russian army ONLY in the year of 1943.
Вы сильно ошибаетесь, очень большой процент офицеров Русской Армии участвовали в гражданской войне на стороне красных, Весь так называемый цвет русского офицерства, в большинстве своем полег на полях первой мировой, к 1917 году основная часть офицеров младшего и среднего звена была выходцами из городской интеллигенции, робочего и крестьянского сословия которые и сформировали командный состав красной армии, в белой армии, на самом деле был серьезный дефицит в командном составе.
@@MakhachSultanov ошибаетесь вы. Очень большой это какой? Основная часть офицеров действительно была выходцами из простого народа, повышенного в годы ПМВ, и их так же бессовестно расстреливали как "эксплуататоров". Дефицит командного состава белых, у которых офицеры служили рядовыми - это из какой-то больной фантазии, или может быть из 21-го и 22-го годов, когда все уже давно было кончено для белых?
Нет, конечно, мизерная часть офицеров разделяла идеи красных, другая была карьеристами, не хотевшими идти рядовыми в добровольческие армии, и шедшая на командные должности к большевикам, но подавляющая масса была на стороне белых, а само слово "офицер", если вы не знаете, было оскорблением в революционной среде.
Михалков сыграл Михалкова.
А мне нравится, его царь. Отлично сыграл!
@@ЕленаК-з4д запятая лишняя
Пошлость
Звенящая пошлость...
@@ЕленаК-з4д да вы что?!!! Александр Третий был очень благородным человеком в отличие от этого прихвостня... куда ему играть такие роли?!!!
Radziwill что за фильм?
Браво Михалков душу маслом
Ich war sehr beeindruckt von den wertvollen Bildern. Vielen Dank für die Veröffentlichung.
Didn't seem too bad for those who survived childhood....
His Imperial Highness, Grand Duke Mikhail Alexandrovich Romanov is the young boy with Alexander III... It is said that "Misha" was the most like in mind and temperament to that of his father, the Tsar.🕯🕊☦👑🇷🇺👑☦🕊🕯
What, he still played kiss chase when 25. The issue with the Romanovs, like most of the European monarchy at this time, was inbreeding. Because of it, you had people of low intellect running countries. The Czar, The Kaiser and George the V. The luck for the English was George the V thought he ran the country but didn't. The czar took control of the Russian war effort but was infantile in his aims and objectives and lost a country. The Kaiser was basically a childish idiot and allowed his whims by Hindendorth and Ludendorff, but no real power. And George the V was allowed to walk around and pretend he was in charge but all of the UK establishment knew he wasn't.
I await my firestorm far saying the 'truth to power'
thought so, because Nikolai was almost adult at that time
You like fancy titles, don't you?
@@texan4548 that was how the Imperial family of Russia was addressed. They were addressed by title and name unless you were intimately acquainted with them and were permitted to address them by name. I might suggest that you learn something of the customs and formalities of the court.
@@walterweiss7124 Mikhail Alexandrovich was Alexander III's favorite. I'm sure if he could've, Alexander would've named Mikhail as Tsarevich instead of Nikolai. Alexander didn't allow his oldest son and heir to participate in cabinet meetings or bother to really instruct him in the business of being Tsar. Nikolai upon assuming the throne, was heard to say: "I come to the throne too young... I know nothing of the business of ruling".
Горжусь, что ношу на груди Георгиевский крест. Есть и другие награды, но этим горжусь особливо ..Награжден в 2008 году.
You can see how the Prussian/German military tradition was connected with the Russian military tradition. It stems from the 18th and 19th centuries. Some elements have even been preserved up to the time of the Bundeswehr. Unfortunately far too little
Yeah it’s very sad that many traditions in the German military are gone. The most obvious one is that the German military doesn’t goosestep anymore. They also don’t preserve any of their old dress from 1918 and before for parades. Instead they have the dumb berets for dress caps.
@@wilhelmvonberghoff175 Yes, of course you're right. But who broke the Germans' back?
If the Germans lift their heads out of the mud just a little, there is a shitstorm in the international media. This and the re-education has broken the neck of the Germans.
Now Germany is finally being ruined by the Greens and the left - a pity, but that is fate.
Connected becouse the Russians rullers since Katarina the Great was German Origin.
@@0plp0 Tsar Alexander I was a loyal ally of Prussia. Since that time, the Prussian-German uniform system has been strongly influenced by Russia. This is still clearly visible today in the military music and many insignia. Every historically conscious German must be proud of this. I appreciate and respect Russia and its great history. Russia is an inseparable part of Europe
@@kitzbuheltv So what. Look from where they came. Grandmother of Alexander was Catherine the Great that is a German Origin, born in Stettin. Spouse of Catherine was Peter III half german half russian. Godfathers of Alexander I was Joseph II Holly Roman Emperor and Frederick the Great King of Prussia. Since Catherine the Great Russian rullers was Origin German.
During official occasion they're displaying unnoficial flag of country, wonder why...
Oh, that's because CURRENTLY russian official flag is tricolor.
Or maybe you are bad at russian history and flags.
@@gogaonzhezhora8640 I can't understand Piotre Czluchowski's comment. Unofficial flag?
@@nachkellottobitbod Thanks!😊
@@nachkellottobitbod
1667 - white-blue-red is a trade flag.
1705 - officially
1883 -1887 white-blue-red
1887-1896 black-yellow-white
1896-1917 white-blue-red
1991-now white-blue-red
in movie - 1885
2:55 Putin when he was young
🤣
Putin time travelling again
😂😂😂
wow he old
Вот так вот смотришь и задумываешься.: "Сколько же тебе ещё матушка-Россия придется перенести тягот и лишений, а сколько сыновей и дочерей своих ты окутаешь в земляную плоть свою...
Что о грустном то я!?
А сколько потом возродиться сыновей и дочерей русских, да на русской то земле!
Слава Руси, слава России!
В сказки веришь?
Russians are RUSSIANS. They are Majestic, Famous, Divine, Magnificent. Thank you O GREAT GOD for creating this beautiful race in spirit and in appearance, in skill and in performance. Slavic Russians are a precious stone and perhaps the most precious stone in the crown of all the peoples of the World. GREAT GOD protect and bless Russia and the Russians and in general all the Slavs in the life of lives everywhere and anytime! 😀😀😘😘🥰🥰🥰🤩🤩🤩💔💔💕💕💞💞💓💓💗💗💖💖💘💘💝💝💟💟🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩
so well said,
Russians can claim magnificent achievements in the arts and sciences, though not out of proportion to their numbers. They have also been plagued over the centuries with xenophobia, antisemitism, reflexive hostility to "the West," quasi-mystical anti-intellectualism, and among their leaders a sense that they are entitled to dominate other Slavic peoples--being of Polish descent, I know. Lenin's hastily assembled Red Army tried to overrun Eastern Europe in 1920 and was soundly defeated by an alliance led by a gifted amateur strategist, Jozef Pilsudski, and at the end of it Moscow and Smolensk stood undefended. This left Poland, Lithuania, and other nations in the region free to develop economically, free of the stifling control of Bolshevism, until after World War II. Many Russians emigrated to those regions during the Soviet era because the economy was stronger there. The Putin era has shown that Russians have little talent for democratic self-rule, though I see there is a growing movement for that. And to close on a positive note, all my grandparents came from Polish-speaking areas that were under Imperial Russian domination. In those areas the Russian authorities set up free public schools, something the Polish authorities seemed not to bother about. No doubt the purpose was to Russify the population, because instruction was in Russian--but it was a no-cost education. My maternal grandfather, as a boy, chose to attend, though he did so in spite of a threat of excommunication by the local Catholic priest. He became literate in Russian and Polish, and could read enough English to become a US citizen.
@@Vurbanowicz do you speak Russian?
@@yuriidarakchiev2942 I can't speak for him, but I would have, if my ancestors had been allowed to stay in their homes, instead of being chased out on the whim of the tsar.
@@thehungrylittlenihilist Karl, if he doesn't speak Russian, which I suspect is the case, he doesn't understand the Russian culture, mentality etc. in plain English he is clueless. Lots of words, little sense.
The old Hym is fantastic
Красиво,блин!!! В лучших традициях! И теперешнее время мы ничего из этого не растеряли!!!
Еще как растеряли.
Чего вы не растеряли? Сраный совок в России! Еще хуже чем до 93-го года!
Наоборот, ещё гавна набежало тогда хоть вид культурных людей изображали, а сейчас терроризмом занимаются и на камеру не стесняясь позируют
@@vladoldpub эм... Совок был запатентован Томасом МакНейлом из Филадельфии в 1858 году, так что, он уже более чем 150 лет существует, а избавляться от него не вижу смысла, порой он крайне удобен для уборки всякого мусора и швали, чтобы был порядок и была чистота. Лепота, одним словом.
@@ОттофонШтирлиц-б6щ под "совком", остроумный мой, я понимаю все самое плохое что могли взять из Советского союза.
Очень примечательно, я впервые посмотрел этот фильм, будучи в Корее, в 2003 году зимой. Ох как я смотрел этот фииильмм, ммм. Полностью на русском языке! По телеканалу Action
А как фильм называется?
@@kalamarisplokamias2683 В названии же все написано
Digression alert! The black uniforms were a trigger.
When Peter Kropotkin, who was from an aristocratic family, graduated from the Imperial Russian military academy, he joined the Siberian regiment because in it he would be posted to areas he wanted to explore as a geographer. When he joined, none of his friends and family seemed familiar with the black uniform. Siberia was not a popular place with his class! Kropotkin renounced his title of prince because of his democratic and socialistic leanings and became an anarchist revolutionary. He soon came to believe that nonviolent methods would best achieve revolutionary goals. When the Russian Revolution succeeded, he hoped that the people would set up a democratic republic. Other anarchists disagreed with him, and the Bolsheviks had other plans, so his hopes, as we know, were not realized. In the 1970s I met an old New York anarchist of Russian descent who remembered the revolution. He disagreed with Kropotkin at the time, but when I spoke with him he said that in the end Kropotkin was right.
That's super cool!
5:50 I must say this is the Chaddest military parade ever B|
Spectacular, thank you.
So you’re into anthems too? Nice
5:58 술 마시고 깨트리는거가 뭐라고 간지나냐
Ура! Ура! Ура!
러시아 전통 ㅋㅋ
Put on the English subtitles - you'll love it!
Made no sense
@@zdravkoleski2375 Right! Gibberish when they finally did appear!
이 영화 며칠전에 봤는데 너무 슬펐습니다. 사랑이 뭐기에 ㅠㅠ
Как это оказалось у меня в рекомендациях?
Я тож не знаю
Zoriuszka Krasnoe что за фильм?
Zoriuszka Krasnoe это воля Божья
@@thatguyfromtv6477 Это база.
@@Knyaz_Bog_Groma Ура! Ура! Ура!
I have to confess that I am not happy about the Grand Duke's orders - he should have been wearing the Order of St Andrew. Still: with "The Cadet's Cap" and "God preserve the Tsar" (the tune has an interesting history), the music is very good. This is a film clip which I enjoy
Grand Duke is wearing St Andrew - that is the blue ribbon like the Tsar wears.
I don't think so: the Tsarevitch is wearing blue (St Andrew) but the Grand Duke is wearing red (probably Alexander Nevsky)
You are right. I belived Misha to be Grand Duke (who he was). The sons of the emperor were awarded the Order of St. Andrew and the lower orders after baptism. The Cavalier of the highest Order doesn't wear its insignia. Rather strange if not serious service wromgdoing.
Costumiers, eh? In the film "Mayerling" the future Edward VII was shown wearing the Order of Maria Theresa which had strict requirements of military leadership which Edward did not meet. Not even the Emperor Ferdinand received it! A little more detailed research avoids irritation to guardians of outdated information, like me!
Not costumiers, but producer, conductor, painters, military consultants. In 1885 cadets have Mosin-Nagants rifles, 10 years before the rifle was invented. The budget of the film is more than $40 mln, they could hire profs or amateurs of any level and order either dummy or real replicas of Berdan or Krnka rifles.
Though those faults see barely tens of millions...
The Barber of Siberia
Vladimir Putin 2:55 !
Putin is a time traveler confirmed.
That comment is dumb
lol Putin sit!
Nonsense Vlad worked for the KGB ....It was his great grandfather Ivan Petrovich Putin...
@Muchen Tuchen LMAO
2:55 He was an Imperial Guard before being a KGB agent and President
@Monovik Bonk
Oh yes he is. He has been alive in 1885 and is now more than 150 years old.
@@individuum4494 He keeps looking young by lifting weights and wrestling with bears.
@@individuum4494 Really! I don't think he looks a day older than 125!
@AbsolutelyAmerican Take out the "t" and you've got it . . . .
Какую империю потеряли! Вот она была мощь!
Ничего, всё вернём, ибо русские всегда приходят за своим.
это где 80 % в лаптях ходили и почти все неграмотны, да уж мощь)
@@yhooo22 а в европе все крестьяне холили грамотные ,чистые и в глянцевах сапожках)
@@ИванБогданов-ч6п представь себе в процентном отношении гораздо лучше.
@@yhooo22 в том , что у них крепостное право отменили раньше , только из этого, крепостное право было везде ,кроме Скандинавских стран
何時の時代もロシアは格好良いな。
Она развалилась в 1917 году, потом СССР в 1991 году и наверное тоже скоро
Аж дух захватывает!
Мощно! Блеск! Слава!
What is striking is that the 19th century Tsars were reluctant rulers. From Alexander I to the last Tsar Nicholas II, none of them wanted the position.
where do you have this information from?
@@SuperCosty2010 From history. Let's start with Tsar Alexander I. He ascended to the throne on the murder of his father, Tsar Paul I. During his whole reign, he was haunted with guilt over this. There is a legend that he didn't really die in 1825; but, faked his death and became a monk, Feodor Kuzmich. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feodor_Kuzmich
@@1236612 actually, if you're to become a tsar and you don't want to rule, you deny the whole thing, like Konstantin did for example :) Pavel the First had 10 kids with Maria, somebody would find himself. As for old man Fedor, it's of course nothing more than a conspiracy theory
@@1236612 and after Alexander I don't know too what you're talking about. Nicolas I was reluctant at first though, what didn't keep him in the end from accepting the throne and killing over 1000 people on his first day. Shot them by cannons, aiming on civilians first. After him, only Alexander III was not prepared to rule at first, since he was not the oldest son. But his brother died young enough, so he accepted not only papa's inheritance but the brother's bride also.
@@SuperCosty2010 I wouldn't just dismiss the legend of Feordor Kuzmich outright. Later on, much evidence of him was destroyed by Pobedonostsev, later tutor to Alexander III and Nicholas II. Tsar Alexander I was perhaps the most powerful man on earth, yet, in ways he was somewhat helpless to influence events. At the Congress of Vienna, he was instrumental in establishing democracy in Europe, albeit constitutional monarchies, yet, he was powerless to do the same in his own country.. What I find fascinating are the lives of two contemporaries: Tsar Alexander I and Thomas Jefferson. Both men were democrats in their beliefs, yet, both men had to contend with two evils: serfdom and slavery. They both believed that these institutions were evil., yet, they had to live with this reality to keep support from the ruling elites. Rather than expend the political capital to confront these evils, both men chose to leave it to a future generation to address.
황제여 만수무강 하소서 하느님 황태자를 지켜주소서 러시아에 영광을 우라
김정은에게 당신이 사라진 군주제의 팬이라고 말씀드리겠습니다. 😊
@@erayulusoy3577 ^^;;;;;
I feel bad for that monk's ears.
😂 Maybe his used to it
Не злите русского солдата! С уважением из Казахстана.
Американцам можно) В Сирии они это показали, уничтожив отряд Вагнер из русских военных залпом ракет. Россия даже не пискнула)
Гавнюки эти русские солдаты
EveryVR
>5 unit Wagner Group
АнглоВики
Наёмники. НЕ Армия России. И не факт присутствия гражданства РФ у них.
Теперь открывай рот.
Не злите боливийского солдата! С уважением из Сьера-Леоне.
@@crazysapertonight это наёмники.На наёмников всех пох
Can someone put up an English translation. I & probably many others haven't got a clue what on earth is going on or being said.
Please 🙏
Long live grate Russian people 🗽❤️🙏🏼🙏🏿 you
Спасибо
솔직히 케렌스키의 입헌군주제+토지개혁만 했어도 러시아 왕가가 유지될 가능성이 컸는데 니콜라이가 개씹어서,,,,,, 좋은 사람이었지만 나쁜 왕이었음...
아니 우리애미가 집 나가서 없는건 인정하는데 하기사 공산주의가 해가갈수록 고여썩어서문제지 혁명초반 대다수 공산주의자의 순수한 혁명적 열망과 헌신은 대단하긴했음.
@@7АВТ 뭔 개소리 ㅋㅋㅋ 어딘가 결여되어있고 극단적인 면모가 있던 사람들이 공산주의를 한거지 그게 순수와 헌신이냐? ㅋㅋㅋ 그런 사람들이 사람들 선동하고 내전 일으켜서 사람들을 서로 싸우게 만드니? ㅋㅋㅋ 정상적인 사람들은 절대 그런짓 안한다. 피해의식에 쩔어있고 분노에 가득찬 인간들이나 그런짓을 하지.
니콜라이 2세 성격은 유약하고 선량하고 교양있는 사람이였는데
정치적으론 독단적인 전제군주였죠
그렇다고 밑에 사람들이 일 잘할 수 있게 힘써준 것도 아니고
@@북한산고추부락리 러시아는 서유럽에 비하면 낙후된 국가라서
1차 세계대전 이후 제국이 유지되었어도
2차 세계대전때 마왕 히틀러에게 먹혔을 듯
니콜라이가 만약 영국의 왕이었다면 훌륭한 왕이었을테지만 실상은 절대왕권국가인 러시아..
Assuming this is accurate the soviets kept a LOT of tsarist military traditions
Yelling URA for example after the person inspecting the troops gives a kind of speech
It is a battle cry. People shout "ave cesar" "valhalla" "banzai" since the beggining of history
The Soviets originally destroyed most, if not all, Tsarist traditions after the Revolution. It wasn't until the invasion of the USSR by Nazi Germany that many Russian/Tsarist traditions were revived. For example, the name of WW2 in Soviet Historiography was called the "Great Patriotic War." This name was actually based off of the "Patriotic War" when Russia was being invaded by France in 1812. So they decided to add the word "great" to emphasize the importance of the Nazi invasion and connect it to the French Invasion of the Russian Empire.
Shouting hurray would naturally carry on.
Yes, also they kept this tradition of starving their own people
@@ricardo7308 this one was invented by the bolsheviks themselves
Никита Сергеевич Михалков
Александр Александрович Романов Александр 3 Миротворец
В фильме Режиссёра Никиты Сергеевича Михалкова Сибирскiй ЦИРЮЛЬНИКЪ 1998 год
If only Alexander III had lived at least another decade.
True
History would be different
He would have to live at least till 1914 to prevent Russia from entering the dumb war Russia neaded the least. Also his health was certainly weakened by the infamous train accident. And there are leads pointing towards it wasn't exactly an accident. The Brits needed him gone.
It was Alexander III who made a secret military union with France against Germany in 1893. It made inevitable WWI and subsequent collapse of the Russian Empire (along with German, Austro-Hungarian and Turkish empires).
@@viewer6271 Yeah, sure a treaty from 20 years before the war made it inecvitable. Just no. The last things good politicians do is staying true to alliances no matter waht. Alexander understood the intricacies of politics and the goals Russia had to keep in mind. Unlike his son.
6:05 Bozhe,Tsarya khrani!
Филипп Ворона 1:52 March of the Preobrazenskiy Regiment. :)
Прямо слышу хруст французской булки.
대한제국이 러시아 군복 예복을 가지고 똑같이 입고 .고종이 제정러시아 힘 읻고 대한제국선포함..나중러시아에게 개털리고 도망쳤지만..이것이 허접 조선말기의 역사임..반성해야함.
Best time of the history. Without fem-nazi and sjw
Believe me. You will never want to become normal Russian in that era.
@@LongVu-lh9el Vietnamese nationalists are mentally ills. Nationalism is a reactionary and stupid form of bourgeoisie ideal to motivate the people to believe in the authoritarian elitist government, support a dictator and its finance capital, while spread hatred and lies against the innocent Chinese and Asian people & the oppressed minorities, blam Chinese for your internal problems and your corrupted system. Further more, today the Vietnamese nationalists are urging that Vietnam should be become a one-ethnostate supremacist dictatorship.
I am full 100 percent Vietnamese but against Vietnamese nationalism and all kinds of nationalism!
@@LongVu-lh9el normal for anyone? the only norm is classical liberalism and a puppet monarchy on the facade. modernism can only lead the planet to hell
@@johnconst648 stop use all stuff, give up your current life and go to the jungle now.
@@hermannboyen5392
I am not Khmer Rouge to suggest such drastic measures. But if I could feed myself in our northern forests, I would go there without a second doubt. Because the infomania which modern people breathe is calmly compensated by books
낭만의 제정 러시아
Как сказал Иван Грозный - Россия третий Рим и четвертому не бывать . Хотя и первый Рим наши предки Этрусски построили 🤣. Русский след везде . История России самая скрываемая тайна в мире 😉.
수많은 농노들이 굶어가며 떠받친 로시아
@@전산정보팀 리얼팩트!
@@전산정보팀 А англию тех лет эксплотация рабочих, прочитайте житье содержанки Маркса К. в Лондоне
Long live RUSSIA 🇷🇺🙏💙
Сколько лет прошло, а ничего не изменилось.
Ибо Империя! Россия - империя, и это круто!
The guys that will 20-30 years later get their asses kicked by Japan, Germany and their own mutinous troops (in that order). I do like a subtle hint of the underlying problem at the beginning when the whole well rehearsed spectacle is nearly derailed by one late priest.
you lie
You don’t seem to remember how the fascist asses were kicked away by them all the way to Europe later 😂
He wasn’t a priest. He was a non-ordained monk.
Has nothing to do with the priest. At the begining of the film a terror act is shown where the soldiers are attacked by some anarchists. Is don't know exactly if it was a thing in the Alexander III times.
I want Putin to transform Russia into a Russian Empire.
But I do not want Putin to turn Russia into the Soviet Union.
Funny thing how the Bolsheviks keep this Tsarist tradition
They are the Bolsheviks .. after many many years, what is wrong..???
Soviets basically are monarchists who really liked red colour , so no wonder
The Bolsheviks didn't keep the traditions, shortly after the October Revolution and the Russian Civil war, the Bolsheviks destroyed and omitted all Tsarist/Russian military traditions. It wasn't until the break out of WW2 when Nazi Germany invaded the USSR that many Tsarist traditions were revived to boost the morale of the Red Army. Those were pragmatic times within the USSR, because there was a huge emphasis on Russian/East Slavic patriotism during the invasion. Recall the name of the war in Soviet Historiography, which was called the "great patriotic war." This was based on the French invasion of the Russian Empire in 1812 (which in Russian Historiography was called the "Patriotic War")
@@alexesin5001 No, they are not.
No, not in any way.
That poor bellringer
why?
Не сейчас, не в советской армии не было, такого что в царской армии, желали душевно, счастья и долгой жизни
В царской России были рабы,никто там никому ничего хорошего не желали.
@@ricksanchez7192 А щас как будто их нет. Да и вообще отрицать то, что во все времена и во всех странах, есть в той или иной степени, более или менее выраженное рабство, было бы лицемерием. Царская Россия пусть и медленно все же, старалась выпутать людей из этой паутины, не везде - это невозможно, но на некоторых заводах были закреплены 9 часов рабочей смены, бесплатная медстраховка и ЛИЧНАЯ больница у рабочих, школы для их детей. И Смотря на то, что у нас есть сейчас в Убогой ФЕДерации, то лучше Царское рабство, чем такая федеративная свобода.
Не является ли этот царь сумасшедшим петро?
2:54 아니 ㅅㅂ 어떻게 이렇게 푸틴하고 닮을수가 있냐
Pardon my ignorance, but what film is this from and what is being depicted in this scene? It’s beautifully shot and very high quality. Is there a version of it available in English?
The Barber of Siberia 1998 film and the scene depicting the commission ceremony of the cadets of the Russian Empire
@@GETNAKD Thanks!
러브 오브 시베리아 추억의영화
Were these officer cadets graduating?
Yes. They are newly-graduated cadets.
yes
In Kremlin yard
저 막강한? 군대가 일본제국 육군 과 독일제국군대에 연전 연패하다 마침내
자기 상관까지 잡아먹었지!
지금 그 용기가 다시 한번 필요하다
6:05 God save the Tsar ~
The son of Alexander III should have 17 years old, but he see him as a of 8 years old, or can be Miguel Romanov?
Yes, this is Mikhail.
It is Mikhail Alexandrovich.
Боже, Россию храни!
Россию сохранит только человек. Если его не сожрут окончательно.
Под защиту этой "Империи " народы просились на коленях...
Ага, а особенно - казахи, горцы, чеченцы, аварцы, грузины, кабардинцы, абхазцы, осетины, лезгины, черкесы, кумыки, поляки, эстонцы, литовцы, латвийцы, финны... настолько сильно все хотели под крыло русского императора, что сдавались почти без боя
@@strangenaut4765 Вот грузины как раз очень и просились!!! Грузинские князья более ста(!) лет просили защиты у русских царей от персов и турок... И еще сто лет продлилась Кавказская война, которая России не нужна была СОВСЕМ! На начало войны, грузин, как этноса, оставалось менее 70 000; через несколько лет их было уже около 300 000!, и это при том, что шла война... А уже в 20х годах 20го века захотели отделиться(меньшевитский мятеж); набрали силу, да и закончился период русско- турецких войн. Сколько русских воинов полегло, что бы сохранить грузин как НАРОД??? Облагодарили знатно уже в 21 веке. PS. Кстати, грузин в Грузии меньшинство, не без помощи России покорили соседние народы - сваны, кахетинцы, аджарцы- очень, очень много...
Грузия на Кавказе, как Польша в Европе, гиена.
Под защиту советской империи тоже, и сильно больше народов. И что?
1:45서부터 2:20까지 BGM 러시아 전승기념일 사열곡으로 쓰임
정확히는 러시아 국방장관 입장곡으로 대조국전쟁 전승기념일 행사때 제병지휘관한테 사열 받으러 갈 때 연주됨
Любите и берегите!
참고로 저 니콜라이 황제 역을 한사람이 이 영화의 감독이래요
1885년이라고나온걸보면 알렉산드르3세같습니다
알렉산드르3세고 실제로도 190정도로 덩치가 컸던걸로. 고증에 맞게 표현한거죠.
반면 아들인 니콜라이2세는 170정도로 아버지에 비해 많이 작았죠.
long live Holly Russia
Yakovlev, where do you live?
Russia
So why do you have a problem then?
So others can understand. Answer my question
Ты наркоман? Ты про какую то империю начал писать, хотя речь о ней шла. Так что нормальному человеку тебя не понятно.
I would have love to an An American Tail version of this.
What is the Name of this film, looks good.
@1 2 A late work by Rossini . . . .
소련 열병식 러시아열병식이랑 많이비슷하네요 저기서 유래했나보네요
열병식 제식동작은 빠르면 18세기 초, 늦어도 19세기 중후반에 정립된게 지금까지 유지되는중. 어차피 인류가 총이라는걸 쓰는이상 크게 바뀔일 없을거
i feel bad for the bell ringers ears that was too close with the bells it so hazardous job at that time i think
I agree
Конечно Никита Михалков тоже русский царь. И почему он кому-то может помешать? 😘😍🤩😇
идеализированное преставление о жизни тех времён. Никто не снимает о жизни крестьян. Всё больше про дворянство. Этим-то всегда хорошо было на руси
Потому что Ленин изнасиловал всех их матерей.
@@timofejzivoderoff7682 А биритаецы хорошо были когда туалеты у караулных не было и они на людей торгующих какали и писяли в России не только кремтияны были - так же мастера рахные а больше половына царской армии были крестияны ... А при иване грозном много завидени ученые уткрили так же медицинские учреждения а королева англи в это время на лево и на право десятки тысяч убивала а корол Франции за одну ночь 40 тысяч людей убил в бартолемейскую ночь - или это другое и вашим богам Европе все можно ? Если в Европе и США женщины за права боролись то в Китае и персы всегда на уровне были с мужчинами можно посмотреть видео на женщин ирана при шахе да и теперь в правительстве много ....
Фильм михалкова чужой среди своих свой среди чужих хороший фильм из саветской России ....
Very sad to say that the Russian's Army between the period of 1600's- 1914 are very ineffective.
Yes. Conquered 1/6 of the Earth surface. Captured Berlin in 1760 and Paris in 1814. Very ineffective indeed…
The actual mighty tsar
장교 임관식에 황제가 참석하네 ?
우리나라도 사관학교 졸업식에 대통령이 참석합니다.
저때까지만해도 유럽에서 장교될라믄 다들 한자리씩 하는 집
아들들이어야하지 않나요
Здорова юнкера
Здравия желаем ваше Императорское величество
Здорова юнкера
Здравия желаем ваше имераторское высочество
Old Regimental names being restored by Putin to raise pride and moral in his new military. This includes flags and music. He was respected Tsar but had his enemies all the same. Tried to make Russia modern.
It was the Soviets who moderated Russia. It was America that broke up the Soviets.
Спасибо автору канала!
Супер!
Like the good ol days.
@Hoàng Nguyên You've read too many Soviet books about the pre-Soviet Russia. Forget them.
@@michaelwild7560 yes, history books are now "soviet books".
@Hoàng Nguyên Ooh, the liberal tore up
@@pnduarte4696 Yeah, for some people for sure. Although even under Gorbachov, let's say, from 1987 on even Soviet books became very objective and the government even financed films like "The Dog's Heart" by Bulgakov to show how rich and progressive (for its time) the Russian Empire was. So those who judge the pre-Soviet Russian history by reading Soviet books published earlier than 1987, well, those people have mental problems.
@@michaelwild7560 yes, the russian Empire was great thats why it ended with a revolt.
Looked like Larry Fine ( 3 stooges ) Driving the carriage at the end ?
Знали бы они чё будет в 17-м году..🌚
Мультик про пони завершат
@@EazyGodfrey хм.
Да в том же самом фильме в начале они подверглись нападению террористов. Все они представляли себе, особенно с таким царем-батюшкой