Cliff Burton [VS] Jason Newsted [VS] Robert Trujillo (For Whom The Bell Tolls)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 січ 2020
  • Cliff Burton [VS] Jason Newsted [VS] Robert Trujillo (For Whom The Bell Tolls)
    😎 SUBSCRIBE for NEW videos! - bit.ly/DonghunSubscribe
    ⌚️ Previous Video - • Fleeing As Optimus Pri...
    ⚡️ Social Media ⚡️
    🔧 Roblox - www.roblox.com/users/69304747...
    ⛏ Planet Minecraft - www.planetminecraft.com/membe...
    Don’t forget to subscribe for NEW videos!
    This is just the start of another new series on my channel. There seem to be so many new series coming. Anyways, here’s a comparison of 3 of Metallica’s bassists on For Whom The Bell Tolls live performances. Yes Ron McGovney was Metallica’s original bassist but he stayed for a very short period and was never involved in Metallica’s songs. Anyways, hope you enjoyed!

КОМЕНТАРІ • 6 тис.

  • @KoreoBace
    @KoreoBace  3 роки тому +1054

    Thanks for the all the views and subs and making this my new most viewed and liked video! Let’s rock on!🤘🤘
    HELLYEAH! 1M+ VIEWS 🔥

    • @thomastasoulas5847
      @thomastasoulas5847 3 роки тому +11

      CLIFF EM ALL RUUUUUULES YEAH.

    • @apktluaj9222
      @apktluaj9222 3 роки тому +9

      Cliff 👍

    • @anupamtheboss4536
      @anupamtheboss4536 3 роки тому +6

      When you are a SLAYER fan, Metallica Seems to be So BORING & SLOW

    • @fishernick2447
      @fishernick2447 3 роки тому +10

      Anupam THE BOSS .... disagree with ya bud, go mosh at a Metallica concert and say it’s slow.

    • @michaelws6247
      @michaelws6247 3 роки тому +8

      I think if the bus accident never happened and Cliff never died I really don’t know if Metallica would still be around. Just my .02 but here goes. Cliff had a huge influence on the sound we all know this. When the time came for 90\91 black album & working with bob rock... I think Cliff would of said Fock off and not do it. James would of probably followed & Lars n Kirk. The old stuff.... we all love it with out a doubt but the 90s were weird. Pantera’s sound was soaring but I’m not convinced Metallica could have continued like that.. the evolution of sound with Metallica is what it is because it adapted to the time, producers & bassist’s. Regardless of that cliff is my favorite bassist of all time hands down. And to the dude about slayer being faster... listen to creeping death or seek & destroy

  • @davidnissim589
    @davidnissim589 3 роки тому +3063

    Cliff - Technicality
    Jason - Vocals
    Rob - 🦀🦀🦀

    • @rotblodd
      @rotblodd 3 роки тому +1

      WHDHHQQJDHIWWNFJ

    • @Samford_
      @Samford_ 3 роки тому +11

      @@rotblodd what

    • @byron3201
      @byron3201 3 роки тому +5

      JAJAJAJAJA

    • @maximwinner5326
      @maximwinner5326 2 роки тому +22

      Jason - ENERGY

    • @a-ice
      @a-ice 2 роки тому +5

      ​@@Samford_ she probably didn't know tapping the keyboard randomly is particular for Turkish people. cehalet

  • @SantaLuka
    @SantaLuka 3 роки тому +6219

    No matter who plays the bass, Hetfield is always like hey,hey, hey, hey...

    • @nuxgod6297
      @nuxgod6297 3 роки тому +208

      And Lars playin faster and faster🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @SantaLuka
      @SantaLuka 3 роки тому +84

      @@nuxgod6297 Right, man. That's thrash metal, faster means better. 😁

    • @nuxgod6297
      @nuxgod6297 3 роки тому +31

      @@SantaLuka but its looks like untechnical music. My friend who studied in conservatory can make a better😅😅(sry for my English. I'm just Russian🤣🤣)

    • @mariocarvajal6176
      @mariocarvajal6176 3 роки тому +3

      🤣🤣🤣

    • @CaseSet236
      @CaseSet236 3 роки тому +7

      YEAH,YEAH

  • @kevinstone7735
    @kevinstone7735 9 місяців тому +526

    Can we just agree all three are phenomenal bass players?

    • @katemcgee1984
      @katemcgee1984 6 місяців тому +17

      Yup! Just here because I find it cool to see the different styles side by side.

    • @Asmallcorneroftheinternet
      @Asmallcorneroftheinternet 5 місяців тому +3

      I mean, yeah, that went without saying.

    • @firefly44220
      @firefly44220 4 місяці тому +2

      No

    • @londonmadeeasy6676
      @londonmadeeasy6676 3 місяці тому +4

      No, Jason is appalling

    • @14stg44
      @14stg44 3 місяці тому +2

      Only one does his job well - its jason.

  • @napoleonbechard9114
    @napoleonbechard9114 8 місяців тому +46

    Cliff’s hair : ↖️↙️⬅️⬆️◀️⬅️⬇️🔼⬆️↖️⬅️

    • @goldenwolf8081
      @goldenwolf8081 4 дні тому

      His fingers: ⬆️⬆️➡️⬇️🔀⬅️⤵️🔃↔️↕️↔️⤴️↪️🔁⤴️↙️🔁

  • @cadeblackout
    @cadeblackout 4 роки тому +9221

    *_Best Solos:_* Cliff Burton
    *_Best Vocals:_* Jason Newsted
    *_Best Crab Walk:_* Robert Trujillo

    • @leopardsammy1306
      @leopardsammy1306 4 роки тому +91

      Cade Blackout omg pls no im gonna laugh all day even when im sleeping 😂

    • @cadeblackout
      @cadeblackout 4 роки тому +35

      Leopard Sammy
      Oh you’d better 😉🤣

    • @ysinvangulik1004
      @ysinvangulik1004 3 роки тому +90

      When he stillhad his long hair, Jason could do an awesome 'windmill'.

    • @orionorion328
      @orionorion328 3 роки тому +172

      Trujillo is a great musician but he looks like he's trying to go to the bathroom all the time

    • @azriazis1085
      @azriazis1085 3 роки тому +43

      Robert trojillo is some kind of monters

  • @Arak_Drakoniz
    @Arak_Drakoniz 3 роки тому +5877

    Cliff - pure creativity
    Jason - sticks to Metallica’s style
    Robert - pure love for bass

    • @2nd100k
      @2nd100k 3 роки тому +36

      @General Pershing the AJFJs versions the only one you should listen to

    • @zakkrick
      @zakkrick 3 роки тому +86

      Jason sticks to what he hears on the CD

    • @fordprefect7710
      @fordprefect7710 3 роки тому +14

      Yes. This.
      So much this.

    • @Arak_Drakoniz
      @Arak_Drakoniz 3 роки тому +46

      @@marioalexanderski9598 hope you kept the receipt for that opinion.

    • @furtivegold8727
      @furtivegold8727 3 роки тому +10

      @@marioalexanderski9598 Its either a shitty joke or you're out of you're fuckin mind!

  • @grahamhannah2108
    @grahamhannah2108 10 місяців тому +406

    I saw Cliff play in 86 when Metallica opened for Ozzy.
    It was freaking awesome!
    RIP Cliff!😢

    • @squintspalladorous9119
      @squintspalladorous9119 9 місяців тому +5

      Master of Puppets/Ultimate Sin Tour. Long Beach Ca. 86 was my first concert. 11 yrs old.

    • @pauld6222
      @pauld6222 9 місяців тому +3

      I saw Cliff play on their Ride the Lightning tour. The opening acts were Armored Saint, who just came out with their March of the Saint album, and a band who just had their debut album out called WASP. Id say there were only 200-300 people at the show. There were no big fancy light shows, stage props, or even a big stage. It was just 3 of the best metal bands in the business all coming together for one of the best concerts I have ever seen to date. I'm glad I got to see Metallica before their turned into a radio metal band.

    • @user-fp8fs5fj7t
      @user-fp8fs5fj7t 9 місяців тому +2

      if only you knew much much I envy you

    • @jonny1one634
      @jonny1one634 8 місяців тому +1

      dudeeeeee what a lucky !

    • @keithwoolley8448
      @keithwoolley8448 4 місяці тому +2

      86 indy

  • @JuFraCerVi
    @JuFraCerVi 9 місяців тому +304

    Jason's bass is the entire sound of Metallica in 90's

    • @JoaoMata
      @JoaoMata 7 місяців тому +18

      But not in the late 80's... 😏

    • @michaelmccutchen7278
      @michaelmccutchen7278 6 місяців тому +7

      Cliff Burton 100% easy pick!!!

    • @tb2324
      @tb2324 6 місяців тому +8

      @@JoaoMatahe specially said 90s. So your comment was silly.

    • @JoaoMata
      @JoaoMata 6 місяців тому +1

      @@tb2324 I wrote it as a joke, so yes, it may be silly. 😘

    • @notsobigcheese
      @notsobigcheese 4 місяці тому +6

      not gonna lie tho, the way jason started that bass in the video just sounds menacing

  • @theruley
    @theruley 3 роки тому +3365

    “I don’t care who you are, you are not as good as cliff”
    -Jason Newstead

    • @mlody969
      @mlody969 3 роки тому +48

      NewstED !!!

    • @ohalistair
      @ohalistair 3 роки тому +147

      Rob Trujillo has entered the chat.
      Rob is the best bassist they've had, and it's not even close.

    • @nikifromschool
      @nikifromschool 3 роки тому +243

      @@ohalistair really dude ...

    • @user-mz8ib7oi4c
      @user-mz8ib7oi4c 3 роки тому +148

      @@ohalistair just no

    • @ohalistair
      @ohalistair 3 роки тому +64

      You can disagree all you like but if you had actually listened to any of his work besides Metallica, you'd know he makes Burton look like Newsted, and Newsted look like Sid Vicious.

  • @ekmekarascigkofte5792
    @ekmekarascigkofte5792 3 роки тому +1281

    James: Hi Cliff, how you doin?
    Cliff: *hits bass aggressively*

  • @larry902
    @larry902 6 місяців тому +132

    I always felt Jason had the most booming bass sound,and he was the best vocalist as well

    • @hedjester7006
      @hedjester7006 4 місяці тому

      Oh, the irony

    • @br.m
      @br.m 4 місяці тому +5

      Agreed. He should have replaced James at lead vocals. His solo work is awesome.

    • @eusebipujoltorradeflot2084
      @eusebipujoltorradeflot2084 2 місяці тому

      And also the best drummer!😂

  • @arian13
    @arian13 29 днів тому +3

    Jason was just phenomenal in the whole cunning stunts gig. The bell tolls, the solo in to live is to die, sanitarium, misery. He was just so so good. Miss that guy 🤘🏻

  • @randyman22
    @randyman22 3 роки тому +3031

    Cliff Burton was insane! He literally could play a bass like a lead guitar.

    • @SniffHeinkel
      @SniffHeinkel 3 роки тому +62

      His bass playing is god tier.

    • @HectorRivera-kh9no
      @HectorRivera-kh9no 3 роки тому +136

      Cliff Burton was definitely the best of all three.

    • @claudiovallese40
      @claudiovallese40 3 роки тому +51

      Indeed he came up from bein’ a guitar player, even if fingerstyle
      Conversely Jason, who also plays some guitar on his own, always been a bass player, startin’ fingerstyle (same was on doomsday for the deceiver, where he almost mimicked steve harris) then switchin’ to picks tipswise
      Rob is a fullyfledged bass player

    • @lisajohnson521
      @lisajohnson521 3 роки тому +45

      @@HectorRivera-kh9no LOL Jason and Rob look like it hurt them to play it. Cliff looked like it was a breeze. I wonder if it's really difficult to play.

    • @HectorRivera-kh9no
      @HectorRivera-kh9no 3 роки тому +21

      @@lisajohnson521 Lol... right? Cliff was a natural.

  • @tremorchristlester4688
    @tremorchristlester4688 3 роки тому +1459

    I believe all 3 are great but if I had to say one word about each..
    Cliff: Skilled
    Jason: Aggression
    Robert: Funky

    • @vincentreysen3288
      @vincentreysen3288 2 роки тому +83

      Finally a comment about them other than crabs

    • @creaturex5705
      @creaturex5705 2 роки тому +54

      @@vincentreysen3288 Robert: Crab

    • @protectyourneck3042
      @protectyourneck3042 2 роки тому +6

      That's probably the best way to put it

    • @TesterOfProducts
      @TesterOfProducts 2 роки тому +19

      Robert was definitely funky when he was playing with Suicidal Tendencies and Infectious Grooves

    • @Homielander229
      @Homielander229 2 роки тому +10

      You can feel the funkiness in his solos

  • @fernboy61
    @fernboy61 8 місяців тому +77

    I've seen them 30 times, Cliff was a god at playing bass, he created those songs and paved the way for the rest. His influence is all over Justice. Jason came in at the right time to lift the band and make them what they are today, his singing of Whiplash and Creeping death are legendary and he made them rockstars. The timing just wasn't good on the human side for him, the first boyfriend after a divorce or a sudden loss rarely lasts long. Rob came in when the band was ready to welcome someone else and let him play his style. He cemented the band and greatly helped them become the megastars that they are today. All 3 are geniuses of the instrument with their own style and personna. Metallica wouldn't be Metallica today without those 3. They were blessed to have the right bass player at the right time, all the time. If one of the 3 had fail, the band would have imploded.

  • @ederbigger6397
    @ederbigger6397 6 місяців тому +110

    In my opinion and many others Cliff is the best metal bassist of all time.

  • @thorandmoljnir
    @thorandmoljnir 2 роки тому +1135

    I can't believe how awesome Burton was. He played like he was lead guitarist.

    • @randomrecipes5007
      @randomrecipes5007 Рік тому +52

      Absolutely insane, guitarists would've feared playing with him.

    • @laurendonlon2480
      @laurendonlon2480 Рік тому +7

      I know right!

    • @MelodicsRareMusicVid
      @MelodicsRareMusicVid Рік тому +6

      he was a beast, but his earlier versions of that bass solo when he was in his previous band wasnt as polished. i think he had a decent amount of time to perfect it and then throw some twists in with it at every show. i often wonder if he could of kept making great hits like that or if he was one of those people who got lucky early and then never would of did anything good again after.

    • @Thesaurcery4U2C
      @Thesaurcery4U2C Рік тому +2

      @@randomrecipes5007
      Not necessarily...
      A6 string guitar is much easier to play licks on
      String size is huge on a bass in comparison
      and the distance between the frets, just makes more of a stretch
      difficult for your fingers to reach.
      That's the cool thing about cliffs playing
      It's out front being the lead in a few songs
      I'm just realizing how many songs of his I learned on guitar
      Because they are leads.

    • @Griimmyyy
      @Griimmyyy Рік тому +12

      ​@@MelodicsRareMusicVidif he was still alive I'd say we'd be considering him one of the greatest bassists alive

  • @dakgeut
    @dakgeut 3 роки тому +890

    No competition. Cliff got Orion, Fade to black, Call of Ktulu, For whom the bell tolls and Master of Puppets under his belt and achieved this with just two albums. R.i.p.

  • @johnhelms8226
    @johnhelms8226 9 місяців тому +49

    Jasonic will always be one of my favorite metal bass players.

  • @michaeljung5395
    @michaeljung5395 10 місяців тому +77

    I like all 3! Cliff was an absolute virtuoso and Robert was really cool! But for me, Jason was THE bassit for Metallica! Visually and in voice. He was perfect and a fan magnet!

    • @SuperBC10
      @SuperBC10 2 місяці тому +3

      They definitely had a very different, more heavier vibe with Newsted I think.

  • @BerserkerNick
    @BerserkerNick 3 роки тому +1062

    This isn't a fair comparison, lars had Jason's amp turned off the entire time

    • @beeftractor875
      @beeftractor875 3 роки тому +29

      Berserker Nick lol idk why he did that on and justice for all

    • @RealAmericanSanta
      @RealAmericanSanta 3 роки тому +67

      For justice it was purely hazing and a bunch of guys not coping with grief for 29 more years. But fuck can jason pick a bass. He definitely lent a darker and heavier vocal tone to the band as well

    • @MrChopsticktech
      @MrChopsticktech 3 роки тому +13

      @@beeftractor875 l saw a documentary and they said James was afraid he didn't play well enough on the album so they buried him in tje mix.

    • @ChopperOutdoors
      @ChopperOutdoors 3 роки тому +6

      Just like the And Justice For All album.

    • @anthonycarr9118
      @anthonycarr9118 3 роки тому +5

      who really ever hears the bass at at live show lol

  • @diogopizzicato720
    @diogopizzicato720 3 роки тому +1459

    Cliff- god of bass
    Jason- a good bassist
    Robert- the father of all crabs

    • @baraslim
      @baraslim 3 роки тому +4

      Haha

    • @antoniocenteno1483
      @antoniocenteno1483 3 роки тому +56

      Jason and Robert are actually better bass players than Cliff, i mean, is unfair to compare the one that died at age 24 to the guys that lived longer and obivously became much better. "BuT Thy nEvEr Be liKE Cliff!" I guess

    • @marioalexanderski9598
      @marioalexanderski9598 3 роки тому +8

      @@antoniocenteno1483
      Agreed, but Jason is better than both.

    • @miguelesquivel7752
      @miguelesquivel7752 3 роки тому +3

      @@antoniocenteno1483 grasoso de mierda usaste "but"

    • @randomraisins7954
      @randomraisins7954 3 роки тому +5

      @@antoniocenteno1483 You do have a point but I still think Cliff is the best regardless. Never changing my mind. RIP

  • @nicks2716
    @nicks2716 9 місяців тому +58

    What I love scrolling through some of the comments? That all three are getting the respect and admiration they deserve. What a freaking awesome trio of bass players for one band to have!

    • @scatterwave
      @scatterwave Місяць тому

      All the comments about rob r : Crab king, or God of crabs or something to do with crabs 😭😭

  • @milostopic1514
    @milostopic1514 3 роки тому +508

    They all have 2 things in common: 1) they are all brilliant musicians 2) they had to play with Lars for years

    • @caseysmith5740
      @caseysmith5740 3 роки тому +8

      ¡Wisest comment on UA-cam!🤘

    • @iamnaitsirk3091
      @iamnaitsirk3091 3 роки тому +15

      Second hurts the most.

    • @anastasiosgraikos7135
      @anastasiosgraikos7135 3 роки тому +3

      You made my day buddy :)

    • @davidtaylor4975
      @davidtaylor4975 3 роки тому +13

      Worse that playing with Lars would be listening to Lars!

    • @jacobwilson7030
      @jacobwilson7030 3 роки тому +13

      At least when Cliff was playing with him when he was still trying to be a good drummer lol

  • @ggmaster86
    @ggmaster86 3 роки тому +1661

    Cliff - Creativity
    Jason - Demonic Vocals & Uplifting Stage Presence
    Robert: The only man who could play the bass sitting down while standing up at the same time
    Love 'em all

    • @maderastudio8493
      @maderastudio8493 3 роки тому +26

      Dude that killed me!!!! 😂 “sitting down while standing up at the same time.” Kinda creepy, but he can play that bass. Each made it there own. 🤘

    • @ggmaster86
      @ggmaster86 3 роки тому +12

      @@maderastudio8493 yes and he does play it really well 🤘, saw them in 2017 and watching Rob on stage was very entertaining, his vocals got a lot better too!

    • @theklippet
      @theklippet 3 роки тому +10

      Cliff: Impressive
      Jason: Energetic
      Rob: Entertaining

    • @brian_mfr
      @brian_mfr 3 роки тому +1

      🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @damnasonora4685
      @damnasonora4685 3 роки тому +1

      A ver, VS JOHN MYUNG !.. esos son unos pendejitos para la prole... pff

  • @gerhardjasongeick4229
    @gerhardjasongeick4229 8 місяців тому +21

    Jason was duplicating the sound on the album which is what they told him to do and he executed it perfectly. Cliff's intro was boss. Robert's intro came out of left field, as if he didn't know what song was next so he just good off for sixty seconds. He gets the job done but Jason will alwas be my favorite Metallica bassist, and without him I don't think they would have lasted as long as tbey have.

  • @agitator1310
    @agitator1310 9 місяців тому +31

    What we see hear is respect. Cliff Burton wrote this base riff. So once the line starts Jason and Robert don’t change it. However, when Cliff played it live, he went all over the place with it.

  • @carlosdcf8268
    @carlosdcf8268 3 роки тому +580

    Cliff: the solos
    Jason: the attitude
    Rob: the groove

  • @wodenmetal5908
    @wodenmetal5908 3 роки тому +1024

    I think Jason using a little too much wah, I blame Kirk

    • @SniffHeinkel
      @SniffHeinkel 3 роки тому +35

      Kirk Wahmpster.

    • @g3nar023
      @g3nar023 3 роки тому +15

      I’m sure Kirk abused all of them with the wah pedal 😂

    • @johnreeadena1371
      @johnreeadena1371 3 роки тому +1

      Barracuda

    • @espman01
      @espman01 3 роки тому +3

      Kirk Whammett

    • @sgtpeppers67
      @sgtpeppers67 3 роки тому +6

      Kirk is using too much wah, I blame Cliff

  • @piercingcrescendo5150
    @piercingcrescendo5150 11 місяців тому +38

    God I just love the funky play style Rob has.

  • @adammccraw4815
    @adammccraw4815 11 місяців тому +19

    Can’t help but love Jason . He’s the one I grew up with, but can’t deny cliff being the origin, and Robert bringing the omega

  • @a.t.3192
    @a.t.3192 3 роки тому +626

    Regardless of who you think is best, you gotta love Rob's passion. What an awesome dude.

    • @dompennypacker4491
      @dompennypacker4491 Рік тому +23

      Best stage presence I think.

    • @tommyaleks100
      @tommyaleks100 Рік тому

      @@dompennypacker4491 Walks like a crab looks stupid to me.

    • @ij_misir1965
      @ij_misir1965 Рік тому +15

      and he is an absolutely fantastic bassist

    • @didakeepa
      @didakeepa Рік тому

      @@dompennypacker4491 you must be on rocks

    • @dompennypacker4491
      @dompennypacker4491 Рік тому +9

      @@didakeepa I feel honored, to have you reply to my comment out of all of them. Thank you for your time!

  • @V3RTiGo7
    @V3RTiGo7 3 роки тому +320

    Cliff: For Whom?
    Jason: The Bell??
    Robert: Tolls!!!

  • @tuckerbatson3098
    @tuckerbatson3098 10 місяців тому +50

    Cliff was the Innovator that was ahead of his time.
    Jason was the fan, full of aggression and passion (and my god the stage presence).
    Rob is the funkmaster with grimy tone and may be the most technically sound bass player they’ve ever had.

    • @user-my9rh7tx1l
      @user-my9rh7tx1l 9 місяців тому

      agree 100%

    • @alanela6761
      @alanela6761 9 місяців тому +2

      I don't know.... cliff accomplished everything he did without making it to age 25... so very impressive

  • @gustavmetal
    @gustavmetal 10 місяців тому +12

    I grew up with Jason's Metallica so I'm biased towards him (besides, his stage presence and being able to take the frontman seat was a plus in his favor), but can recognize the creationist force behind Cliff.
    While I don't dismiss Trujillo's talent, the thing made me not able to connect with him is that he became part of Metallica when they already lost me as a die hard fan. I checked their new albums, and always end up returning to their older stuff.

  • @shalashaska6658
    @shalashaska6658 3 роки тому +649

    To sum up the comments:
    Cliff: Very good
    Jason: Good
    Robert: Crab

    • @deathbypotato5030
      @deathbypotato5030 3 роки тому +9

      crab

    • @mamuanpuia
      @mamuanpuia 3 роки тому +1

      😀

    • @dustinarcher4396
      @dustinarcher4396 3 роки тому +6

      I would really like to know what crab means because if it means newstead is better than Trujillo then I'll literally be at a loss for words. Oh and cliff wasn't just very good he was the alpha and the omega, astonishing.

    • @shalashaska6658
      @shalashaska6658 3 роки тому +5

      @@dustinarcher4396
      Chill lmao, crab is just a reference to Rob’s iconic crab walk during Metallica live shows
      And yes, Cliff Burton was the best at what he did

    • @manuelmonarrez359
      @manuelmonarrez359 3 роки тому

      Crab people, crab people, crab people

  • @patagon1974
    @patagon1974 3 роки тому +355

    Cliff: The god of bass
    Jason: The metal bass
    Robert: The funk

  • @sillysausage72
    @sillysausage72 3 місяці тому +1

    Loved all 3 man! 🤘

  • @Mina-M-M
    @Mina-M-M 9 місяців тому +9

    You chose a Jason’s riff that cannot be heard! Anyway, Jason beyond technical details, gave soul to the band ! And of course the best back vocals!!

  • @wijtzeheinvanderveen
    @wijtzeheinvanderveen 3 роки тому +120

    *Jason plays perfectly good solo*
    -James: “I can’t hear you!” 1:52
    Well, that would be Lars’ doing then, probably.

  • @NorCalGuy
    @NorCalGuy 2 роки тому +739

    Cliff was such a creative bassist
    Jason is just METAL through and through
    Robert is another level....
    All of them are great in their own rights and all added something to to the band. I would take any version of the band any day all day.

    • @paulpiatt5610
      @paulpiatt5610 2 роки тому +11

      Well said. My thoughts exactly.

    • @stonecold5373
      @stonecold5373 Рік тому +9

      God, I miss Jason. Thank you for all three.

    • @ShallBeMine
      @ShallBeMine Рік тому +4

      being metal is hard. jason is metal in every sense imaginable.

    • @bassjoe69
      @bassjoe69 Рік тому +1

      Jason sucked on the albums, probably James' doing, he was a beast live tho.

    • @austinevans7024
      @austinevans7024 Рік тому +2

      @@bassjoe69 you can’t even say that cause you could hardly hear his bass for most of the time

  • @Sage.the.red_fox
    @Sage.the.red_fox 4 місяці тому +7

    In my opinion.. Cliff was Metallica’s best bassist. He paved the way for the next ahead of him (Jason and Rob) without knowing it.. and also inspired MANY people in the process.

  • @terryreese663
    @terryreese663 Рік тому +247

    Jason's solo's were great in concert. He added a lot to the band. Excellent trio of talent.

  • @DamionJR4923
    @DamionJR4923 3 роки тому +1486

    Jason is underrated cause he isn’t Cliff.

    • @lemans_enjoyer
      @lemans_enjoyer 3 роки тому +86

      Big facts. Jason actually influenced me to start bass. I've fallen in love with his style, and his lines. He's just overshadowed by cliff.

    • @DamionJR4923
      @DamionJR4923 3 роки тому +26

      @@lemans_enjoyer yes no disrespect for Cliff

    • @unknownassassin2212
      @unknownassassin2212 3 роки тому +44

      Jason came into the picture at a dark time the band really was devastated after the loss of cliff and diddent really give Jason his props he was a fantastic bassist forever one of my favorites right up there with Cliff he is gifted with the groove

    • @badjuju2612
      @badjuju2612 3 роки тому +17

      I love Cliff, have always been a fan. I think Cliff was more influential by far, but Jason is a better technical player.

    • @mjoutdoors3662
      @mjoutdoors3662 3 роки тому +1

      Lmao

  • @johnknight9150
    @johnknight9150 11 місяців тому +75

    Cliff was the best at solos, Jason was the best at monstrous backing vocals, Rob is the best at, well... playing bass.

    • @guilhermecarvalho3673
      @guilhermecarvalho3673 11 місяців тому +5

      Bass is easy... until knowing the instrument.

    • @johnknight9150
      @johnknight9150 11 місяців тому +1

      @@guilhermecarvalho3673 ??

    • @Auriflamme
      @Auriflamme 10 місяців тому +3

      @@johnknight9150 I think he means that it's easy to play bass at a simple level just keeping things tight and marking time, but hard when you actually get into playing expressively and exploring the full potential.

    • @johnknight9150
      @johnknight9150 10 місяців тому +2

      @@Auriflamme So is he complimenting or insulting Rob?

    • @_PuppetMaster86
      @_PuppetMaster86 10 місяців тому +3

      It seems Cliff wanted to do something more with the bass and Rob knows the bass top to bottom and has always used proficiency and skill with mastering it.

  • @brianpriestorg548
    @brianpriestorg548 8 місяців тому +1

    Cliff passed away. Jason was the man. He fit that position perfectly. They screwed up losing Jason.

  • @komandoarshad8086
    @komandoarshad8086 3 роки тому +656

    Don't make a comparison between them. Each of them own their signature, skills, & talent and each of them has their era and fans. Respect them.

    • @timorean320
      @timorean320 3 роки тому +28

      Finally, somebody with a brain, and reason. Instead of comparing, just appreciate which each individual brings musically. Cheers!

    • @cheomic2447
      @cheomic2447 3 роки тому +8

      The only thing Cliff has the vote because he arranged/composed the riff..

    • @acommonspat5253
      @acommonspat5253 3 роки тому +4

      To me it's an evolution from one to the other.

    • @mrkremko1
      @mrkremko1 3 роки тому +4

      I agree. Though in this case, cliff’s version of for whom the bell tolls is the best

    • @TheMithrilmza
      @TheMithrilmza 3 роки тому +1

      This is the most intelligent comment in the post.

  • @davidcoomes4944
    @davidcoomes4944 4 роки тому +673

    The thing many ppl forget is Cliff was playing like this and writing a lot of the bass portions of the music and he was only 24 when he died. Hell a lot of 24 year olds now a days are still living at home with mommy and daddy. You also lok at him and he is playing his parts flawlessly while just headbanging at a whole other level where as many that try to pull off the same notes have to be giving it all their attention. Cliff and Dimebag their instrument was just an extension of themselves.

    • @TheChatteh
      @TheChatteh 4 роки тому +11

      David Coomes my sister is 27 this year and still living with my parents lmao

    • @davidcoomes4944
      @davidcoomes4944 4 роки тому +2

      @@TheChatteh point proven I was out of the house at 18 went into the army at 20 had to go back home for a bit after I got out cause stoploss screwed up my plans for getting out.

    • @TheChatteh
      @TheChatteh 4 роки тому +3

      David Coomes well my sister is driving a Range Rover while still living with my mum and dad lmao she got her priorities all wrong. Most of her friends I imagine are married with kids and have a mortgage smh

    • @MikoPellas
      @MikoPellas 3 роки тому +38

      @@davidcoomes4944 ok boomer

    • @liamwatson6789
      @liamwatson6789 3 роки тому +31

      Cliff was living with parents at the time of his death.

  • @georgewashington6464
    @georgewashington6464 9 місяців тому +5

    Cliff was amazing.
    Rob isn't too bad.
    Jason was an animal on stage that gets the crowd riled up.

  • @fanssolperez3430
    @fanssolperez3430 7 місяців тому +1

    «Blackened» (…And Justice for All) (James Hetfield, Jason Newsted, Lars Ulrich)
    «My Friend of Misery» (Metallica) (Hetfield, Newsted, Ulrich)
    «Bass/Guitar Solo» (Live Shit: Binge and Purge) (Kirk Hammett, Newsted)
    «Where the Wild Things Are» (ReLoad) (Hetfield, Newsted, Ulrich)
    «Bass/Guitar Doodle» (Cunning Stunts) (Hetfield, Ulrich, Hammett, Newsted)

  • @GibsonVienna
    @GibsonVienna 3 роки тому +304

    Cliff: I used a Hairconditioner
    Jason: They said, cut your Hair off
    Robert: I use my Hair as the 6th String

  • @badcat-jg6cd
    @badcat-jg6cd 3 роки тому +246

    Cliff is just Cliff no need for words
    Jason has the Vocals
    Robert has the Feel

    • @bintangizzanthariqi4558
      @bintangizzanthariqi4558 3 роки тому +13

      Robert has techniques

    • @BigChungus37_
      @BigChungus37_ 3 роки тому +3

      Rob has the crab walk

    • @xjosex5657
      @xjosex5657 3 роки тому +1

      @@bintangizzanthariqi4558 what's technique if almost all rob plays was written for cliff and Jason?

    • @emeraldcitystoner3596
      @emeraldcitystoner3596 3 роки тому +1

      @@BigChungus37_ Nah, he just walking like that from all the smoke Lars blew up his ass.

  • @TheDukeofhazzard86
    @TheDukeofhazzard86 8 місяців тому +1

    Jason doesn’t get enough credit for stepping into Cliffs shoes as the band was probably still mourning his death. Jason came in played the parts, and didn’t really change anything Cliff wrote. I think he knew that if he tried to rewrite cliffs lines the rest of the band wouldn’t be able to handle it.

  • @fanssolperez3430
    @fanssolperez3430 7 місяців тому +3

    Jason has the support of many Metallica fans. As an old follower of the band, I think the same. He was a great contribution musically with his voice and in the human aspect after Cliff's death.

  • @chrisoutdoors333
    @chrisoutdoors333 3 роки тому +294

    Cliff...legendary pioneer.
    Jason....great bass player. Still had his volume turned down, even live. They never gave him a chance.
    Robert....rawest, truest sound (no distortion or wha effects to cover mistakes) (not that cliff or Jason ever made any) Most soulful bass player of the three. Robert had gigantic shoes to fill so he doesn’t hold back. No pressure. Haha.

    • @emeraldcitystoner3596
      @emeraldcitystoner3596 3 роки тому +5

      That's Lars and his napoleonic complex.

    • @ohalistair
      @ohalistair 3 роки тому +14

      Rob has filled those shoes and then some. Dude is far too talented for this band.

    • @InsidiousOne
      @InsidiousOne 2 роки тому +4

      What do you mean - "No distortion?" He uses distortion even in this video.

    • @DaEpicTable
      @DaEpicTable Рік тому

      @@InsidiousOne I mean for whom the bell tolls is usually played with distortion

  • @ryanglobe416
    @ryanglobe416 9 місяців тому +28

    Metallica really has been blessed to have 3 outstanding bass players.

  • @stormsmack69
    @stormsmack69 3 роки тому +71

    Cliff was a musical genius. There's no replacing him...

  • @michaelstephen819
    @michaelstephen819 11 місяців тому +6

    The first and last time I saw them live was on the Master of Puppets tour in 85. Cliff (and the others) killed it, despite James having an arm in plaster. Oh, and I lost most of my hearing, but it was worth it. That's the way I want to remember them.

  • @mortis5150
    @mortis5150 9 місяців тому +1

    I didn’t know it at the time…but I have been blessed to see all 3 bassists live! 85, 88, & 20!

  • @CharlieBoy360
    @CharlieBoy360 3 роки тому +41

    God that Cliff intro gives me CHILLS. He plays like a seasoned guitarist.

  • @mickureta4507
    @mickureta4507 3 роки тому +230

    Trujillo and Newsted will someday be known as two of the great bassists. It's just unfortunate that they were unfairly compared to a bass guitar wizard with skills beyond the capacity of a human being. Those who criticize the two bassists better show whatever skills they have or just shut up.

    • @GMan-cv9ig
      @GMan-cv9ig Рік тому +5

      Hear Hear!!! We all love METAL!!!!

    • @koningklootzak7788
      @koningklootzak7788 Рік тому

      Huh? Robert is better than Cliff as a bad player for sure.

  • @ricardorico9487
    @ricardorico9487 11 місяців тому +14

    Nunca deram ao Jason liberdade e oportunidade pra mostrar quem é Jason Newsted!
    Acredito que poderíamos ter visto muito mais talento deste baixista se não tivessem sido tão covardes com ele.
    Cliff é eterno, mas Jason equilibrou a química criativa pra o METALLICA de sua fase existir.
    Ou vocês acreditam que se Trujillo estivesse em Black Álbum, ou nos outros com o Jason teríamos o mesmo resultado?

  • @encikmuhammad8260
    @encikmuhammad8260 9 місяців тому +41

    no one can beat the cliff for bass playing..
    no one can beat Jason for high note vocals.
    no one can walk like trujilo walking crab.
    By the way all bassists from meltallica are totally awesome!!!
    ROCK ON!!

  • @fats8051
    @fats8051 Рік тому +519

    Cliff's perfomance is legendary, Jason's is Thrashy and Robert's is Monstrous.

    • @user-hu8wl2fp1y
      @user-hu8wl2fp1y Рік тому

      Mistery***

    • @fats8051
      @fats8051 Рік тому

      @@user-hu8wl2fp1y Mistery for whom?

    • @fats8051
      @fats8051 Рік тому

      (Ok, who is going for a for whom the bell tolls joke. I mean, we are literaly in a FWTBT contents comment section.)

    • @scottgillespie2690
      @scottgillespie2690 Рік тому +1

      No he means monsterious.
      Monsterious - adj. - unexplainably frightening; enigmatic and scary.

    • @fats8051
      @fats8051 Рік тому

      @@scottgillespie2690 I don't understand what is 'mistery'.

  • @iagopm_
    @iagopm_ 4 роки тому +641

    I came here only for watch to robert walking like a crab

    • @benstons6197
      @benstons6197 3 роки тому +2

      Monkey rob..

    • @mg10gold94
      @mg10gold94 3 роки тому +3

      Hang pandai

    • @C-R-Y
      @C-R-Y 3 роки тому +2

      And here we can see a wild rob distracting predators.

    • @mg10gold94
      @mg10gold94 3 роки тому

      @@C-R-Y apa hang dok mengarut ni

    • @creativescreenname
      @creativescreenname 3 роки тому

      Yeah wtf was that 🤣

  • @imienazvvisko
    @imienazvvisko 8 місяців тому +1

    Why this poor mans version of John Entwistle (Cliff) is fan favourite is one of biggest mysteries this universe has to offer.

  • @lawrencelarryhoudashelt7785
    @lawrencelarryhoudashelt7785 3 місяці тому +1

    I've seen all three at different times. It was young whenever I saw Cliff, but I also saw Jason newstead the most and I've seen Trujillo when he was with Ozzy and with Metallica I think Jason was the best but he was also the only one who could have replaced. Cliff, they didn't give him the notariety or the props that he deserved. I seen Jason whenever whenever the lead singer got hurt and was unable to play, seen him take over and do the concert with the help of all the other people at the concert. The lead singer from Slayer, the lead singer from Korn kid Rock and the lead singer from powerman 5000 all came out to sing with him and he did an amazing job

  • @totalflow8734
    @totalflow8734 Рік тому +134

    Cliff wrote a lot of unforgettable songs for Metallica.
    He's unique and on another level

  • @edgardopineda886
    @edgardopineda886 3 роки тому +29

    3:53 Robert crabjillo

  • @alexei095
    @alexei095 3 місяці тому +1

    Jason, miss you so much. Alex from Moscow

  • @stuart207
    @stuart207 9 місяців тому +2

    I like the way Rob throws the rules out the window and just funks it all up 😂

  • @monkeysezbegood
    @monkeysezbegood 3 роки тому +61

    Jason was so hard on stage. Those late 80s early 90s tours... damn.

  • @Silver1137
    @Silver1137 2 роки тому +156

    Jason did a masterful job of filling those shoes. Not sure how many could have done it so successfully

    • @Meatball2022
      @Meatball2022 Рік тому +11

      Agreed. He got a raw deal

    • @joshparsons7631
      @joshparsons7631 Рік тому +8

      ​@@Meatball2022 he was the bassist I grew up with. Still can't believe they parted ways

    • @Meatball2022
      @Meatball2022 Рік тому +6

      @@joshparsons7631 and the band shits on him for no reason that I’m aware of. It sucks. Dont know why. If u see some of his solo stuff, dude is a talent. So is Trujillo, to be fair, but I really don’t know why people shit on Jason the way they do

    • @albertorivera4485
      @albertorivera4485 11 місяців тому +6

      @@Meatball2022 The problem was that they were so in love with Cliff that instead of seeing him as: "Jason is here, to help us continue what we've done so far with Cliff, and make it bigger" (which is what really happened, but they didn't notice), they saw him as: "ah, he's Cliff's replacement, boo, you'll never be like him!"; they almost always saw him as the cause of Cliff's death (yep, so stupid).

    • @Meatball2022
      @Meatball2022 11 місяців тому +2

      @@albertorivera4485 seems as they have gotten older they have more appreciation for him than they did. It’s a shame how all that worked out. Difficult situation for all of them.

  • @gallegosvhf70
    @gallegosvhf70 2 місяці тому

    I saw Robert with Infectious Grooves. MIND BLOWING 😳..All of them kick ass..

  • @vickrise99
    @vickrise99 8 місяців тому +5

    Rob’s groove on that intro is just pure 🔥

  • @argonunya1543
    @argonunya1543 3 роки тому +49

    If it comes down to personal style and skill, I’ve gotta give my vote to Trujillo. I like a bass that’s low and rumbling. His fretwork is fucking crazy.

  • @LuanGCarlos
    @LuanGCarlos 3 роки тому +560

    No matter who plays better, Cliff written it.

  • @D1ofAquavibe
    @D1ofAquavibe 9 місяців тому +1

    Love all three - each different but all legends 🤘

  • @steviehodge6159
    @steviehodge6159 8 місяців тому +3

    That’s a no brained. The best bassist ever goes to Cliff Burton. 2nd to none! Legendary Status. I can’t even imagine what Metallica would be like today had his life not been cut so short.
    🤘🏻R.I.P. Cliff🤘

  • @baron1855
    @baron1855 3 роки тому +44

    Cliff - Skill and mastery over the bass
    Jason: Energy and passion for his playing
    Trujillo: Spirit and Love for the bass

  • @kingstring853
    @kingstring853 3 роки тому +421

    i really dont understand why so many people hate rob he is amazing

    • @jimmysauron
      @jimmysauron 2 роки тому +108

      no one hates him really, they just won’t let the bassist shine cause “he isn’t cliff”

    • @smarkmalark
      @smarkmalark 2 роки тому +63

      I seriously think Rob is one of the best bassists in existence. Not sure why he barely gets recognition though he just puts his whole soul into the instrument and messes around a ton, I’d say he’s just as good if not better in some cases than cliff was. Jason was amazing to and his style really fit the band but he kept it real simple which is a great thing in most cases but for Metallica he just felt a little weak on occasion. All amazing musicians in their own right

    • @UserName________
      @UserName________ Рік тому +8

      I don’t see anyone hating on him

    • @beauxhodges
      @beauxhodges Рік тому +1

      He’s not cliff

    • @kingstring853
      @kingstring853 Рік тому +25

      @@beauxhodges that doesnt mean anything

  • @KnoxCarbon
    @KnoxCarbon Місяць тому +1

    Cliff: the creative genius
    Jason: the energetic showman
    Rob: the dedicated professional
    All of them bring their own energy to the table, all of them are the true heart and soul of Metallica.

  • @kplgraphics
    @kplgraphics 9 місяців тому

    Seems fitting that James shouts “I can’t hear you” during Jason’s solo.

  • @kylesmith261
    @kylesmith261 3 роки тому +161

    Cliff: the solos
    jason: Attitude
    Robert: The Stank

  • @srincident
    @srincident Рік тому +154

    How blessed can one ban be to have such three awesome bassists?

    • @domagojpuksec6897
      @domagojpuksec6897 6 місяців тому +8

      Ye but the price of that is having lars as your drummer

  • @spicychicknballz
    @spicychicknballz 3 місяці тому +1

    Cliff is the GOAT and Rob was already a legend in his own right before he even joined Metallica but I think it’s safe to say Metallica wouldn’t have survived the 90s as a band without Jason.

  • @DarrelWilley-eo9py
    @DarrelWilley-eo9py 8 місяців тому

    Bet I’m one of the few who have seen them all live. Sadly, I saw them in January of 1984 prior to the release of For Whom the Bell Tolls.

  • @IIgrandmasterhdclipsII
    @IIgrandmasterhdclipsII 3 роки тому +76

    Cliff Burton- The Talented Child
    Jason Newsted -The Angry Teenager
    Rob Trujillo -The Funny Kid

  • @Ace_2979
    @Ace_2979 Рік тому +770

    Cliff Burton: The only man who could make a bass sound like a guitar

    • @kiltropablinho79
      @kiltropablinho79 11 місяців тому +7

      Thats right🤘🏼

    • @slasherfilms399
      @slasherfilms399 11 місяців тому +74

      And Lemmy from Motörhead

    • @AndreasHolmgren85
      @AndreasHolmgren85 11 місяців тому +31

      Make it sound? It’s a setting 😂

    • @joedlx
      @joedlx 11 місяців тому +23

      @@slasherfilms399 Cliff and Lemmy share the same bass (Rickenbacker)

    • @NickSena
      @NickSena 11 місяців тому +26

      Royal Blood has entered the chat

  • @aravgarg8859
    @aravgarg8859 3 місяці тому +1

    Cliff: Best bass player
    Jason: best vocals
    Robert: CRABWALK
    James: HEY HEY HEY HEY!

  • @pribilovian4709
    @pribilovian4709 11 місяців тому +3

    I always have respect for cliff but i grew up with Jason and always loved his basses...gotta say he's my favorite of the 3

  • @dimitrijpartner5253
    @dimitrijpartner5253 3 роки тому +196

    Best Solos: Cliff Burton
    Best Riffs/Basslines: Jason Newsted
    Best Moves: Robert Trujillo

  • @thomasconwayDrums
    @thomasconwayDrums Рік тому +490

    Like always...Jason's bass is turned down way quieter than everyone else! 🤣

    • @megabike67
      @megabike67 11 місяців тому

      Yep, because he was a twat that no one liked..

    • @aaroneschenburg4018
      @aaroneschenburg4018 11 місяців тому +37

      Sadly

    • @drformori
      @drformori 10 місяців тому +43

      @@aaroneschenburg4018 but true

    • @botman234langer6
      @botman234langer6 10 місяців тому

      Poor fucking Jason always being treated like crap from James and Lars except for kirk

    • @therealbaglady
      @therealbaglady 9 місяців тому +1

      @aaroneschenburg4018 yes, sadly.

  • @chadogle1198
    @chadogle1198 6 місяців тому +1

    Gave me the chills! Great video!

  • @GangsterBoogieInc
    @GangsterBoogieInc 7 місяців тому

    I have seen Metallica 12 times in concert and the first time was with Cliff back during Master Of Puppets when they were opening for Ozzy. I was there to see Ozzy and this band I had only heard a few days before for the first time was opening for him and I was hooked! And then I went to see the Van Halen Monsters of Rock tour when Metallica was on tour with them. The Justice For All LP. And I first heard and saw Jason. I saw them a bunch of times with Jason over the years. And a couple now with Robert. I love them all and all three are great but watching this just now reminded me how great Cliff was. He was one of a kind and I don't think we'll ever see another bass player like Cliff again. But I take nothing from Jason or Robert. Love them both and very thankful they both came along when they did to save the band. All three fit into the band and have made their mark on Metallica. Thanks for the video good stuff! Long Live Metallica And Cliff Em' All! 😎🤘

  • @jshreves7488
    @jshreves7488 8 місяців тому

    First came across Robert Trujillo when he was bassist for Suicidal Tendencies and Mike Muir's side project Infectious Grooves. Always thought he was an awesome bassist!
    Something about his demeanor here reminds me of a wolf pack. Rob's an "omega" trying to get in so he slinks low, basically exposing his belly. If you've ever watched animal documentaries, watch from 3:49 to 4:06 to see he's basically supplicating before the pack alpha's (Hetfield and Hammett) who then launch into an aggressive stance (dominance) above the newest and lowliest pack member.

  • @edkri07
    @edkri07 3 роки тому +87

    Cliff Burton: All ‘bout dat hair
    Jason Newsted: All ‘bout dat bass
    Robert Trujilo: All ‘bout dat crab walk

    • @dnray2092
      @dnray2092 2 роки тому +1

      No Cliff Burton is a skilled bassist

  • @jtcorey7681
    @jtcorey7681 3 роки тому +45

    Trujillo is amazing. Great performer. +1

    • @randomrecipes5007
      @randomrecipes5007 Рік тому

      Great Crab Walker****
      lol JK he's all around great, great bass player, great performer, and great human being.. Love the guy.

    • @pliniomarquesjunior4039
      @pliniomarquesjunior4039 Рік тому +1

      Of course. Trujillo is number one. Burton is second.

  • @elenee4031
    @elenee4031 9 місяців тому

    I thought people were joking when they said that Cliff made bass sound like a guitar 😲