Phanteks T30-120 Fan Review: Beating the Noctua NF-A12x25 at its Own Game!
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 сер 2024
- Listen up, folks, there's a new ultimate PC fan, and it goes by the name of Phanteks T30-120! Launched August 12, 2021, this is the revolution in fan design I have been hoping for (but maybe not expecting) after years of testing fans and CPU coolers.
Want to support this channel? Leave a Paypal tip! - www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_...
Link to purchase at Amazon:
Phanteks T30-120 Single-Pack ($30): amzn.to/3xFk6TW
Phanteks T30-120 Three-Pack ($85): amzn.to/3fVQk7y
Also available, the new Phanteks Glacier One 240-T30 AIO Cooler, equipped with dual T30 fans and a 38mm rad: amzn.to/3jLB4eG
It's destined to instantly become the best 240mm cooler on the market by a wide margin!
Other recommended lower-cost fans:
1) Arctic P12 PWM PST: amzn.to/3ffR7Py
- Also available in a value 5-pack: amzn.to/2RqhF8H
2) Arctic P12 A-RGB 0dB PWM PST: amzn.to/3bvbvv0
- Also available in a value 3-pack: amzn.to/3yih2Pd
- UPDATE! - Now available in white! - amzn.to/3ycUKPa #ad
3) Thermaltake Toughfan 12: amzn.to/2SKHd0C
- Also available in a value 2-pack: amzn.to/3hVIniQ
Test rig:
CPU Cooler: Corsair Hydro H100i RGB Platinum SE - click.linksynergy.com/deeplin...
CPU: AMD Ryzen 9 3900X - amzn.to/37hj7iM
Motherboard: ASUS X470 ROG Crosshair VII Hero (Wi-Fi) - amzn.to/2OEKD2W
GPU: EVGA GeForce RTX 3080 XC3 - www.evga.com/products/product...
RAM: Corsair 4x8GB Vengeance SL DDR4-3200 White: amzn.to/3r09NIq
Case: be quiet! Silent Base 802 Glass Panel White: click.linksynergy.com/deeplin...
Power Supply: Corsair RM850X White: amzn.to/3wxnLUQ
PSU Cables: Corsair Individually-Sleeved White: amzn.to/3qmyrEN
Using the affiliate links above helps support this channel!
Chapters:
00:00 Introduction
02:17 What makes the T30 different?
07:39 Pricing - It's a Premium Product!
08:29 Test Setup
09:17 Max RPM Benchmarks
10:25 35dBA-normalized Benchmarks
11:19 40dBA-normalized Benchmarks
12:00 45dBA-normalized Benchmarks
12:47 Wait, the T30 at 35dBA can beat other fans at max?!?
13:33 Audio Samples at 35dBA, 40dBA, and Max
14:40 Conclusion: the T30 is the New Reference!
19:53 How My Fan Reviews Moved the Industry Forward - Наука та технологія
![NOCTUA Давай ДО СВИДАНИЯ [ PHANTEKS PH-F120T30 ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/JjYtJi9YJ7s/mqdefault.jpg)
![NOCTUA Давай ДО СВИДАНИЯ [ PHANTEKS PH-F120T30 ]](/img/tr.png)
May the algorithm bless your videos, again, severely underrated
I wish... at this point, my reviews are really just for my subs, as the algorithm doesn't do much for me!
@@TheTechBuyersGuru Thats god damn sad, u make really good deep test videos.. u deserve more...
also high quality actually.
@@TheTechBuyersGuru I'm not a sub! I googled the Fan and this came up! it might be working....for those who specifically google this fan?!...either way...now I'm subbed... :D
The Algorithm must be rounding the corner because I found this and I'm not subscribed..... now I am
@@TheTechBuyersGuru well the algorithm led me to this video and now I'm subbed! Haha stranger things have happened
I need these in 140mm size!
Hopefully the concepts scales similarly
My wallet hopes they don't... I'm already broke
Phantastic review, Ari! Can’t thank you enough for all of your hard work benchmarking fans. It certainly has shed more light on the cooling industry.
I should have titled this video "The Phantastic Phanteks T30"! And thanks for the feedback, I hope you didn't say that just because I begged for positive feedback, LOL!
@@TheTechBuyersGuru Love it! No, I watch nearly all of your videos and truly appreciate the hard work! I have a friend who purchased many of his cooling components based upon your recommendations and he couldn't be happier with his decisions.
I'm hoping this will wake Noctua up and we see more interesting products from the other companies competing in this space
We still need to see the rest of their 2021 roadmap. With Phanteks releasing this first, Noctua may do some trick for their upcoming black NF-A12x25.
One thing is dB og sound pressure another thing is the fan pitch (frequency) at some other channel I was able to listen to the fans and while they may be tested at the same sound pressure in dB the frequencies exhibited by the two fans are very different. In other words the Noctua was far more pleasant to the ears. Also do bear in mind that the phanteks one is thicker, hence it moves more air.
@@Persason That's very subjective and can't be measured tho.
They don't need to be woken up. Phanteks T30 is 30mm thick and its a different fan category than Noctua NF-A12x25. Phanteks could not beat Noctua as Noctua NF-A12x25 is engineered to the last so they went with a 30mm version.
@SmashStomp Inc these fans are usually used with WC radiators. 5mm is a lot in that situation when you also need to consider a rad thickness.
Awesome video thanks for taking the time to test out so many different fans! This Video has really helped me pick out my future fan upgrades for my NRP200
It's so great you have the rep now so much so that companies want you to do release day reviews. You are my go-to person for fan reviews. Keep up the great work. Your review methodology is great!
I appreciate that! I can't promise release-day reviews every time, but I will be focused on the latest releases going forward, including for coolers.
I wish I have seen this channel sooner. Thank you so much for your videos. I have learned a lot about fans and truly appreciate the noise samples.
Welcome to the channel!
Found my way here from your SG13 chassis coverage. Over several videos I saw you refine your methodology, educate on the essential challenges in benchmarking these systems, and giving fair and actionable advice to a buyer in each price range. Really great work!!
Glad you enjoyed that series!
Can`t wait for the case fan and air cooler tests/comparisons with this fan. Great video as always !
You put out the best fan reviews. Thank you so much!!!
Excellent content as always, great job Ari! Really cool to see a company innovating in this somewhat stagnant sector of the PC market and dethroning Noctua.
Couldn't agree more!
Enormously helpful, Ari. It has helped inform several of my purchases over the last year. Much appreciated!
Glad to hear my videos have encouraged you to try out some new gear. Hopefully you like it all!
We NEED your review of the 140mm when it arrives! I trust your fan reviews THE MOST
thank you for covering this niche, fans are really overlooked, and it is practically the only thing you'll be hearing from your PC all the time.
Yeah, it's amazing to me that there wasn't more coverage of this topic, but it is pretty hard to test versus something like GPU framerates.
Especially differentiating between testing as a case fan, a heatsink fan and cooling fan is rare elsewhere. As we've seen from testing here, fans can behave very differently between those use cases.
Wow, i'm sold. Really appreciate the effort you put into these videos.
Thank you!
Thanks for this Ari, glad the YT algorithm decided to post it. I have always used Noctua like yourself. It is great to see another company trying new tech and pushing the boundaries in PC components. Subscribed!
Welcome aboard!
Thanks for all the work you put into these videos. Great information, great advice.
Glad you like them!
Thanks for your amazing work and time dude ! Keep it up
Ok, i watched some of your videos and it was always very instructive and a pleasure to watch ! Your last chapter made me comments, i hope (like others in the comments) that you will find the fame you deserve.
Also very clear voice and no noise around, which is a pleasure to my non-english ears :D.
Props to you for that hard work ! Amazing content ! Love
Wow, thank you! I sometimes wonder if background music would make my videos more popular. But I'm glad to hear that you appreciate that I'm just speaking into the camera without music.
I always take your reviews as base for my future purchases 👍
Awesome review, you include all the numbers one could possibly need. Love reviews of these niche products. This fan seems really great and I want to replace my current fans now.
I'm sure there's more people could want to see, but I'm glad you agree I covered enough to make a decision!
Looks like Noctua. Appreciate the review, most of the cases I've used lately have been Phanteks.
Love your channel too man. You’re very underrated. Bless.
The last part of this video is definitely the best. Spec doesn't matter when it comes to sounds, as in the same dB reading doesn't always equal to how we perceive the tone of the sound. I have Gentle Typhoon @1850 RPM and they're quiet as hell. Other cheap fan in general at that RPM will 'bleed' our ears. This fascinates me as a human being, as we can't always rely on measurement device to make our decision in life.
Again, thanks for the review, Ari! It's definitely an eye (and ear) opener for me! :D
Amazing review Ari, very in depth and answered all my questions
Glad to hear it, tried to cover everything and it was a lot. Felt bad it was over 20 minutes for a single product review, but no one has said it was boring... yet!
Great review and great points at the end, as always.
Glad you made it to the end, it was a long one!
Man I'm so glad I found your channel, definitely underrated, seeing the performance I feared the sound would be terrible, but when I heard the audio samples I was surprised, asking myself if the recording was bad since I felt like the sound was a lot better than the noctua. When you mentioned in the end that this is your opinion as well I almost couldn't believe it, that it would be possible to have a fan with that performance with an even better sound than noctua's.
Thanks so much for the great video, I was afraid I wouldn't be able to find a video that does both noise normalized testing AND play sound samples. That's rare and you're doing a great job!
Thanks for that feedback, so glad to see you found the channel and enjoyed the coverage. I think more folks are doing noise-normalized testing, and a few are providing sound samples, but I was definitely one of the first, and people really responded positively to it!
I might consider getting these fans also thank you sir for reviewing these fans and great job at explaining the whole situation that this company didn't stole this product and such lol everyone is different but with slight same touches, looking forward to these phantek fans
Another great fan review! Thank you.
Thanks for coming back for another review!
You are a godsent, thanks for this early review! Didn't have these on my radar 🤠
Fingers crossed these will be on sale for black friday. Just outfitted my NR200P with five Toughfans after your videos 😂
Glad you enjoyed it, and for now, you are in good shape with the Toughfan 12s. As for discounts, hmmm, I think it's more likely these will be sold out from now until Black Friday!
Excellent work, very nice fans!!!!!, very good review, thanks for the work!!!!
Amazing video on what looks like an amazing fan. Exited to see how it performs as a case fan and as a heatsink fan. Phanteks might be onto something with that 30mm thickness.
Thanks for watching. And I agree, this fan is definitely worth testing again!
@@TheTechBuyersGuru whats the best "case" fan you have tested?
@@user-wv1wg2mp1b 120mm: Scythe Kaze Flex is his favorite case fan. See shootout. ua-cam.com/video/PUdsTiRmuuU/v-deo.html
Best bang for buck: Arctic P12.
Also, it's my opinion that the best 140mm is Silent Wings 3.
Great breakdown in various categories 👌
Thank you very much for all your efforts and laudable intention to supply information to people to help them pick the right fan 👍👌🙏
You are welcome!
Great review again, thanks, glad I subscribe to your channel! Didn't see these fans coming AT ALL, such a great job from Phanteks. We will see what Noctua can come up with, we know they like to be the king. A 30mm 120 and 140mm noctua fan would be awesome.
It will be interesting to see what Noctua can do, but the T30 was in development for 3 years, and Noctua often takes just as long to bring out a new product, so I expect there won't be much direct competition for a while!
Wow! Great job Phanteks! That's a really clever design bringing it to 30mm thickness
Looking forward to seeing your heatsink and case fan tests for it :) Nice job with the tests Ari!
Ive decided not to do heatsink tests as fitment will be challenging with most fan clips, but I may sneak it into an upcoming ARGB case fan shootout... despite the lack of ARGB!
Phanteks T30 is 30mm thick and its a different fan category than Noctua NF-A12x25. Phanteks could not beat Noctua as Noctua NF-A12x25 is engineered to the last so they went with a 30mm version.
This could go well with my P300. Amazing review! Now I could jot down more fans on my list for my new build. I've bought the P12 basically, thanks to your videos, and I love it. I got 5 of it running in my case.
Great to hear! Your 5-pack of P12 fans was probably around the cost of one T30, so you did the right thing!
@@TheTechBuyersGuru And it's all thanks to you. I was actually lost on what fans to buy and I found your videos. It helped me a lot with my decisions. Amazing work!
Your videos make me want to buy a roomful of fans and cases. Great review as always.
Well, at least you'd keep cool!
Thank you for the info. It actually was what I was looking for
Already about to start buying some now !! Great review !!!
Enjoy! If you're in the US, you can use this link: amzn.to/3xKZud0
Not sure if they are widely available worldwide yet.
Best fan channel out there. So underrated.
Thank you, I saw a need, and I did my best to fill it!
I really like the way you wrapped this one up Ari, well said!
Glad you enjoyed it, tried to make this about more than just the T30, but the whole industry!
Wow phanteks finally did it!!! Man to bad these don't fit on my ID-COOOLING SE 207XT Black. Now I can't wait for a case fan and heat sink review.. I keep coming back that's why I sub!! Great work and appreciate everything you do your passion shows it.. From the great state of Florida! 🌄
Glad you liked the review! Good point that it could be a challenge clipping these onto many heatsinks as they will be too big. I should have mentioned that!
Not the p200a but glad for this surprise. Looks great, the specification that does matter here is the 30mm. Just need to be mindful particularly if someone tries to use on a front Rad their gpu clearance will be more limited than before. Thanks for the content enjoyed as always.
Yup, that's another application where it could matter, I mentioned the extra 5mm potentially impacting RAM slot clearance on heatsinks and motherboard clearance on top rads.
Very in depth review no matter what product you review. Always looking foreward to your reviews.
Thanks for the feedback!
FANtastic review! 😁
Another top-notch review, great performance and build quality perfect combination
Thank you as always, Tony Beckett!
Thank you for the video, I appreciated the rigour, I watched nearly the whole thing 🤗
I am loving your videos. Keep up the good work!
Thanks!
Good review, thanks for all you do. Keep em coming.
Thanks, will do!
Thanks Ari. This was great. I'm hoping they come out with a 140mm version.
Thank you for the great review again.
Great to have some meaningful innovation in fans . And Good contents! Thank you for that
Glad you enjoyed it! I agree that it was about time for some innovation in the market. Some people are concerned about the 30mm width, but if it makes that much of a difference, maybe it should become the new standard!
thank you for covering these
Indeed may the algorithm bless you. Googled for the fans in the hope to hear the noise of them and here we are!!!! Have my like and subscription.
Welcome aboard!
Subscribed and liked. Well done my man.
WOW! Now this was very unexpected to put it lightly. I did not think that Phanteks would drop such a monster of a fan. Amazing unbiased review as always my guy! Man, this really is crazy to think that there are fans out there that have rivaled the Noctua A12x25 for a while now at least for radiator applications, but to actually have a fan that beats it is really an accomplishment. Well done to Phanteks and their engineering. So this makes me ask the question Ari, will you be testing these T30-120 Phantek fans on the Nh-U12s heatsink? Or maybe as a case fan application?
I already have so many fan/cooler tests lined up that it's hard for me to immediately turn around a T30 test on the NH-U12S or as case fans. But, my next shootout happens to be an ARGB case fan test... maybe, just maybe, I'll add these as a reference despite not being ARGB...
@@TheTechBuyersGuru get wingboost 3 for argb test
Boom! Great review
Much appreciated! 🙏
Love your reviews, the effort is always obvious! Kinda bummed because I actually just ordered 4 Noctua NFA12x25, but oh well
You can blame me... I named them the best rad fans last month!!! It's really not all that often that fan tech takes a leap like this. It's practically like when a new generation of GPUs arrived... you can't feel too bad that you had the best of what was available the moment before!
Just ordered 10 of them 😊. Great review
Great video, good narrative and details throughout
Thanks as always for your feedback!
Another great review!!!
brilliant review as always. can't wait for the t30 heat sink and case fan follow-ups.
Glad you liked it! Due to compatibility issues with a number of heatsink clip designs, I'm going to hold off on testing on a heatsink, but I will be testing it as a case fan soon!
@@TheTechBuyersGuru good point. we'll leave the heatsink to wonder snail duty.
LOL, you know my videos well! And luckily, the WS is finally in stock! - amzn.to/3yZ4xqW
@@TheTechBuyersGuru no doubt. you're doin the Lord's work
Great review. I think this fan could have amazing potential as a case fan for quiet PC enthusiasts.
Wishing you all the best, Ari. Just subbed. You definitely deserve a lot more.
Thanks for subbing!
Great content, once again. Hope you're doing well!
Thanks! You too!
This is a bloody good review, thanks mate!
Glad you liked it!
Outstanding review
Awesome video 😎👌🏽
Great review and product Ari 🥰🥰🥳🎉 yes I agree that a lot of work goes on behind the scenes with pc product testing including fans, as also a Gamers Nexus subscriber, they have advised it’s going to cost them around $100k+ USD on fan testing equipment in their upcoming testing facility upgrade. I think that’s something that many people don’t realise what actually goes on behind the scenes and to create a standardised test methodology and then run these to test product performance to compare efficacy & efficiency of the items to see real improvements in designs etc or stagnation or worse, regression. Keep up the great work you do. I would love to see more regular uploads, obviously workload etc permitting 🥰🎉🥳👍
LOL, GN does great stuff, and I'm glad he can throw $100K at fan testing, because he will change the industry big time with his results. Unfortunately, I haven't found the ticket to printing money on YT, but I'd like to think I've significantly changed the fan industry with essentially zero budget!
Great review. They’re really nice fans
Great review! Thank you!
Awesome review, benchmark, and concluding thoughts as always. They sure looks like the best radiator fan, but I would also like to see how they stack up to Phanteks' claims of being the best case and heatsink fan before I buy them. The fans going up to 3000rpm, while very loud, is an extremely compelling feature. I enjoy overclocking and a little extra cooling can make the difference between a stable 3dmark run and a crash. Thanks for all you've done for us fan benchmark enthusiasts
Glad you enjoyed it! I agree that the 3000RPM can come in handy under certain circumstances, like competitive benchmark runs.
You really need to test these as case fans!
Thank you for doing this work ! Another good one ...
You're very welcome!
Top notch review as always
Thank you!
Honestly great review.. thanks!
Amazing review of the t30. Would love to see how it performs in heatsinks and case fan situations to see if it truly is the “ultimate fan”
Impressive. It's real nice to see that there is still room for improvement in fans. Progress had been stagnated for a long time. Very much hope we see a 140mm version too.
Beating the A12 is no small feat, since it was already a big leap ahead of the previously best available fans.
I think that most of the performance lead over the A12 probably comes from the extra depth though. A 25mm version of the same fan would probably be very similar in performance.
The really superb bearing noise profile, the neutral colorscheme, and the selectable fan modes with great control range pushes it ahead.
I hope this will catch on and 30mm will become more standard across the market. Designing in 5mm more headroom for fans across should be a non-issue in anything but the smallest ITX cases - and it just seems like such an easy way to increase the ever important performance/noise ratio.
You can still get 5x Arctic P12 or P14 for less than one of these though - so that's still the no-brainer choice for anyone on a budget. They perform really great as long as you are willing to work around the resonance issues they have at certain RPMs, and that's something you can largely mitigate with a little manual tuning of the fan curve.
Couldn't have said it better myself!
I really like your way of testing and just found your channel with your last combined fan test video. Hope you go on with these extensive tests, then otherwise as you said the customer has to buy it's fans blindly which is not really satisfying at the end.
Welcome! Yes, until I started doing these tests, there really wasn't a good way to pick fans. But these reviews take a lot of time!
Super detailed review!! Thanks
Thanks for watching!
Great review
Wow, didn't expect this!
We also need 140mm version, cmon
That application is always going to be a bit more limited, especially for a fan that is mainly for radiators. This might work well as a case fan, but as I mentioned, I can't yet confirm that.
@@TheTechBuyersGuru yeah, this is obviously a fan better suited for coolers and radiators, but you know, marketing
Your videos are great.Watching out for these on a air cooler
I may not do it because of clip incompatibility. The fan will work with some heatsinks that clip to back of fan, but most clip to front of fan.
@@TheTechBuyersGuru Oh, that makes sense. Appreciate that anyway 💪🏾
Great review. Performance and sound profile look very impressive. I'm also partial to gray, so to me that is one great-looking fan. Would be interested in performance as a case fan. Fair to say that $30 is an expensive fan, though.
You like grey and you like great performance? Then this is definitely the fan for you! - amzn.to/2XRKvSv
Great Video!
when i heard the news about these new fans i prayed that you already have and tested em lol
my prayers have been answered lol as always great video.
That is some high praise, glad I could deliver!
really underrated channel!
Fantastic review, thank you
Glad you liked it!
Brilliant review thanks.
Thanks for watching!
damn nice work
thank you very much for educating us all
Solid job
Nice and thorough review as usual. Just want you to know i've bought kaze 140mm for my NR200 side panel fan based on your recommendation and did'nt dissappointed. It's silent and move a lot of air. So you're absolutely contributing good cause for the industry.
For the phanteks, I didn't dig the colors but to each their own. I'm also curious about their claim as best heatsink and best case fan, as not even noctua A12x25 win them all.
Glad that the Scythe 140mm worked for you, it's an amazing case fan. And yes, I will eventually test the T30 as a case fan, just not today!
Could you add the Akasa Apache Silent fan into your reviews which has been a brilliant silent and performance fan not to mention cost. 💛 Great review again.
Great review from truly underrated channel. The only missed thing from my opinion is airflow tests for those who gonna use these fans as case fans. I suggest you buy anemometer or something that can measure cfm
Thanks for that! I'll be testing these as case fans, not with an anemometer, but with a case. ;)
Stay tuned!
i feel like this is a turning point for your channel and the case fan industry in general! Finally someone has solidly beat Noctua at their own game. The case fan industry competition is heating up for the first time in a while.
Do you see any other companies copying the 30mm form factor since it seems to work so well?
I hope you're right that this is a turning point! I asked Phanteks for a comment on potential copies and did not receive a response. I think it could happen, but it doesn't use off the shelf parts. Molding the blade copies would be the easy part...
@@TheTechBuyersGuru ThermalFake *ahem* ThermalTake new product in 3...2...1...
Not noted from many reviewers is that the Arctic P14s also have the increased thickness(thought not the P12s). Might be worth testing against those in a future review.
Looking forward to your case fan usage review of this, and hopefully these aren't sold out again when these end up being in the lead.
Very good point on the P14 thickness. They are 27mm thick. But a bigger deal is that the P120 Bionix ARGB are actually 30mm thick: amzn.to/3yOk11N
That's unfortunately because of the ARGB ring and thicker frame, and not because of anything that would increase performance like larger blades. These fans will be in my case fan shootout, and while they have traditionally been among the very best case fans on the market, it will be interesting to see how they do against the T30.
Nicely done. Comparison to other reviews justifies your focus on noise-normalized cooling testing over airflow numbers, despite this fan rating highly either way.
I hope there will be a review of the Glacier One 240T30 AIO..
I can't believe that Tom's and TPU use wind tunnel testing to tell people how fans work on a PC radiator....
This man in grinding! and one day it’ll rain