I love how I read the rest of the books and now I watch the movie again and he’s talking about something 2000 years later from this point. I think that’s super dope.
I love how he absolutely nailed the pitch resonance with The Voice on Jessica. She couldn't fault him, he had dialed her number perfectly for total control over her at that moment.
Personally, I think this scene was where Timothee displays the strongest acting. Paul foresees a future that only *HE* causes and a lot of innocent people die because of him and people view him as a messiah for his actions. Paul was just a kid dealt with the poor hand in fate's cruel game.
Well Atreides roughly translates to “descended from Atreus.” Atreus is a heroic but ill-fated house from Greek mythology and it’s claimed that House Atreides are descendents of this line. So that would make sense.
@@walthitchcock thats crazy to think about like theyre descendant of a line tens of thousands of years before these events(im not exactly sure how far in the future dune is set)
That’s literally what the Atreides family is supposed to be in the the Dune universe. Paul’s paternal legacy is traced all the back to his original ancestor, Atreus. Dune goes a lot deeper than you realize…
@@Jaenoe818 I don't know about the books, but I think the films mention it is the year 10,000-something (though, it isn't using AD or CE, so it could be even further in the future with a new calendar system)
Justice? Paul and his mon are trained to master their emotions better than the best monks in history. Why would they get emotional like that? That's so american. Good american actors are the ones who cry all the time.
@@Tanirhum you are literally one witnessing the largest genocides ever imagined caused by you which you have absolutely no control over whilst on hallucinogens that can help people navigate space and time. Fuck me most people would completely lose their mind over the concept of involvement. He holds himself together pretty well
@@Tanirhum Dude he is seeing the Future of his Bloodline, all that leads to the Dictatorship of the God-Emperor. If that dosnet make you emotional that means you are a sociopath
@@zachcreaghcoen2389which you only understand if you read the books. The movie doesnt explain it, its just some drug infused vision, whereas in the books the severity of this moment is made perfectly clear. I just read it, and it changed my whole perception of Paul and of what to expect from this story. I dont understand how can you argue that the movie did this scene justice, when its just a confusing mess, that skimps through a key development moment for the protagonist.
@@mac19999x I haven’t read the books and I understood it pretty well. “Holy War raging across the stars like an unquenchable fire” is a pretty clear giveaway.
That's actually the third worm that pops up. Rewatch from 1:12. Two other worms (that you don't actually see themselves) explode out of the ground before the third one you are referencing.
Just noticed the line near the start of this scene 'there's Spice in the tent' is ADR'd and now it sticks out to me. I think I've watched this scene to many times lol
After reading the book, I think they did very well with this scene. It doesn't follow the dialog in the book in precise, it leaves many things Paul came to realize out too (like his sister's existence, his grandfather), but it still very clearly based on it, and makes it more dramatic/mysterious and intense than the book version.
Paul is truly scared because he knows that a lot of innocents will die because of his Jihad a Jihad he didn’t choose to be associated with him at all That’s his Atreides character showing yet he’s also tempted by the power of being the Padishah Emperor of the Known Universe AND the Kwisatz Haderach a living god
So Paul knew what would happen to the innocent people of the universe and did nothing to stop it? How unbelievably terrifying. I guess in the end, it was always the Harkonnen and the Sardaukar who were the good ones, while the Atreides and the Fremen were the evil ones. 😞
@@costco_pizza the lines between good and evil are blurred in the Dune series, just as they are in real life. Both sides did morally questionable things, and that's why it's important to always question your leaders and to hold them accountable.
A lot of people have been talking about Timothée Chalamet's performance being better in Dune Part 2 than it was in this one. And every time I just have to ask... Did they not watch this scene? His acting in this scene had me glued to the screen. He is the reason that this is the scene I remember the most from Dune Part 1. Ofc, he was still fantastic in Part 2.
Yeah IIRC in the books Chani doesn't rebel against Paul, instead being by his side as his concubine. I think Messiah will more be about a love triangle between Paul, Chani, and Irulan, with the backdrop of the Jihad and Paul giving in to his status as a God-like messiah. Then the threats to his rule.
It also had Paul envisioning the mass suffering caused if he were to travel south through the constant showing of the starved bodies scattered around his mum
Is this possible futures or realities? The scene where they were fighting we see paul but in dune 2 we see shani in that position. Will that be shani by his side or the princess looking down at the soldiers
This was a possible future. The latter part of this vision shows us Caladan and that's from Dune Messiah since the holy war doesn't actually leave Arrakis until after the first book which the first two movies adapt. It hasn't happened yet and we might see that in part three. That part is most likely also a possible future but could be similar to the reality that unfolds in the future since Denis has expressed his concerns about reuniting Chani with Paul in Messiah.
No sé por qué pero no sabéis lo mucho que amo esta vision del futuro de DUNE parte 1, los planos de cámara, la música, lo ágiles y estilo de lucha de los Fremen, siempre que la veo me transmite una sensación de ensoñación épica. Si sabéis como puedo ser parte del equipo de rodaje para ser un Fedaykin extra en la futura tercera parte de DUNE Messiah. Es una de mis top 10 escenas favoritas en el cine, Denis Maestro necesito ser un Fedaykin entre las legiones alzando el estandarte verde y negro del halcón de los Atreides, gracias. Pd: He visto esta escena unas 36 veces o más
I feel this flashback should've been several minutes and had a bit more exposition attached to it. I get that the meanings behind the flashbacks get revealed further on in the books but this scene just lacks the gravitas of the book. The galactic destruction and genocide that follows Pauls Jihad just looks like same random 20 second battle scene on Arrakis
Yeah, I didn’t get that at all. It’s Paul’s reaction to the vision that gave me all the exposition I needed. The worshiping, the burning of the bodies without “harvesting” them, the bloody knife & hand. I saw it in theater and I got the impression without any question that Paul is going to do more than just get revenge on the Emperor for his father. When he says “somebody help me, please”, that’s didn’t sound like someone who was afraid of fighting a random 20 second battle on a desert planet. It sounded like the panic from a young boy who knows he’s going to be Herr Hitler. I imagine we don’t “see” more as an audience, is because Paul is desperately trying hard NOT to see. So we’re only getting his reaction, and not a full record accounting of galactic atrocities.
@@leonwilliams9589I think my issue, is that while Paul is having a visceral and vivid reaction, the scenes reflecting his visions just don't match his reactions which comes across as confusing and takes me out of the movie.
@@Droxal that’s the point. It’s like Anakin’s visions about Padme before his fall. It’s an incomplete cognitive experience jumbled up by the inherent uncertainty of probabilistic outcomes. What actual information makes its way into our frontal lobe is never coherent, but feelings and emotions are excitations (neurochemistry) in the same fields as all other “experience”. Pain, contemplation, sight, love, etc…all happen in the brain. A vision, isn’t just a jumbled up series of visual stimuli but of the experience overall. And emotions aren’t built on detail, they’re built on broad associations. That’s why details in what you “see” never match up to the certainty about the meaning of what you’re seeing. Paul wasn’t just seeing the future, he was experiencing it because it is specifically HIS future he’s seeing.
They put spoiler for 2nd book (3rd movie if it happens) in this movie itself. Haven't read the second book yet but I know 'the blood in channi's knife is Paul's'. And they haven't given the spoiler about the lineage of Paul and his mother. This is really good. But the politics of the book is missing.
IKR? I just finished reading the first part of Dune, and as I read this specific part of the book, when Paul and Jessica's lineage was revealed, I nearly freaked.
3 worms explode into the battlefield, with a slo-mo of the third when Paul removes his face guard. The explosions aren’t bombs going off, it’s worms coming out of the sand
Where is that written? Paul doesn’t control anyone physically, except with the voice. He just finds clear paths to victory using prescience and therefore appears to his enemies as invincible.
This scene is the only real problem I have with the movie. It is the most important scene in the entire book and it’s just really underwhelming. I don’t know anyone who remembered this scene who had not read the book prior to viewing.
I had to go to youtube to watch videos on what Paul was in the book to understand this scene on a second viewing. I think what you pointed out is what a lot of people would have issues with if they never read the book (like myself). I will say that after learning about him more, this scene became more powerful (for me at least).
I found it extremely satisfying in the cinema, but then I've read the book several times. I think it does a good job of packing in the feeling utter crisis within Paul, in the musical tension and the acting. They could have included more explicit and powerful vision-scenes I suppose.
Highly disagree. It was insane in the cinema. Very powerful. The change from Chani smiling and welcoming to the battle and then utter realization of the horrors to come. This is one of my favorite scenes in cinema. The music and editing was fantastic.
I haven't read the book, and I specifically search out this scene whenever I think about this movie. In fact, this scene is the one that's burned into my brain from this movie. I really need to read the books.
Nah man this scene gave me absolute goosebumps, I just had to come back and watch again. I don’t normally get goosebumps when watching something, but Timothée killed it. 👏🏾
“You did this to me” Seems to be enough context. Something she or her people did caused him to be a scary monster. I don’t know much about the movie or the books beyond he’s supposed to be some godlike powerful messiah or something and that seems kinda clear here.
@@zachlewis9751 Or he could be wrong in accusing her. Just because he said “You did this to me,” she didn’t necessarily do “this” to him. Plus, his mother lost her partner just as he lost his father. He would do well to return her sympathy to him.
the film is beautiful, but these battles on ridiculous ceremonial daggers in no way correspond to the high-tech future and spoil the whole impression of the film.
Dunes whole aesthetic is 'ancient future'. Books, human computers, human navigators, ornate ancient and artisinal looking technology is commonplace, while actual technological advance has stagnated or stopped.
The film doesn't explain it perfectly, but the shields they wear can only be penetrated by slower attacks, like those of a melee weapon. The faster something moves towards the shield, the stronger it's deflected. I personally find the medieval sci-fi setting to be very cool and unique.
In the dune verse everyone is invulnerable because of shield technology that can only be penetrated by slow moving object. Thus the age of power ranger melee battlefield
@@lamhuynh7201 not invulnerable - the film didn't explain this, but if a laser weapon hits a shield it creates feedback, causing a nuclear explosion, at some point along the beam length. You could shoot someone with a laser. You just... shouldn't.
@@MrFarlarzia its las gun, technically not laser but the problem why shield won the battlefield is because of the house convention prevent the use of nuclear weapon in the battlefield at the threat of getting nuked by everyone else. Which is basically what the shield-las interaction generated.
A young man of pure heart sees the monster he will become, the horrors done in his name, in his honorable father’s name, and there’s nothing he can do to stop it. “Somebody help me.”
Fun little observation: In this scene, this is the only time you hear "The Voice" being male... aka: its PAUL speaking vs the collective nature of the Bene Gesserit. I know one thing, I peed in that movie theater seat when I heard this LOL!!!
I dont know what you heard. After rewatching the scene a few times - you still hear a distinct "femme/female" inclination when he commands the soldier to "Remove her gag."@@TobiasKolb1
I watched this movie in the theatre (what an experience!) and this scene blew me away, but the true significance of what's going on only really hit me when I read the book. Paul sees a plethora of possible futures, most of which show him his own death or that show him this holy war and he's more terrified of the latter outcome, where a huge army of fanatics wages holy war in his name across the galaxy. From then on, you never quite know what Paul's plan truly is or how he's going to realize it. The second movie is going to be wild, given the events of the second half of the first book, that will be covered.
@@jbird4165 Emperor Leto the 2nd is Paul's son, named after his father Duke Leto the 1st. He's introduced in the second Dune book whereas both movies so far have covered the story of the first book.
After watching Dune part 2, you now understand the most obvious spoiler here. The main difference is that this is an alternative reality of many in the Dune multiverse.
This is, at the same time, one of the best... and worst scenes in the movie. The best is Timothee's acting. He absolutely kills it here, and makes you feel for Paul's horror. The worst is, ironically enough, Villeneuve's directing. Paul's visions are essentially drug induced (for a lack of a better word) hallucinations that are supposed to be both tripping and terrifying. Here, Villeneuve just... shows things in slow motion. And yes, some of Zendaya's shots look like from a perfume commercial, which is NOT what these visions should feel like. This is the one part of the movie Villeneuve dropped the ball in the first movie. Fortunately, the rest is incredible stuff, so it doesn't hurt it too much.
Fun fact: we see the shrine he’s talking about again I think in dune 2 (I might be wrong on which dune) we see a painting of his father with the fremen worshipping the father and bowing with his skull on the shrine.
2:01 almost a population of a foreign world following him as a messiah (willing to do anything for him including genocide), previous emperors beautiful and brilliant daughter as wife, having devoted lover and mother of his children(Chani) by his side, gods power in his eyes and skills to fight like demon. Paul was living litt ⚡⚡⚡
He is clothed in a robe dipped in blood, and the name by which he is called is The Word of God. Revelation 19:13 The dramatic conclusion of the “times of the Gentiles” is described in prophecy as a gigantic world war which is climaxed by the second coming of Christ. This movie has so many spirital aspects its undeniable
Yeah, don't like the grand scale battle fields much myself. They look like in any other Holywood movie. Luckily there are a lot of IRL made background and scenes in this movie. For example most of the indoor shots have been done with real objects and great care for details.
"Holy war spreading across the universe like unquenchable fire"
Such a badass line
"fanatic legions worshiping at the shrine of my fathers skull"
“ A WAR IN MY NAME EVERYONE SHOUTING MY NAME”
@@olcuqap1789 "Paul..."
I love how I read the rest of the books and now I watch the movie again and he’s talking about something 2000 years later from this point. I think that’s super dope.
In the books, Paul referred to it as the Jihad
"You Bene Gesserit made me a freak!"
Just wait until you see what your son does to himself.
😂
Wait until they get a load of his son.
Leto II: oh you think you’re a freak? Hold my water of life
And what would become of Alia...
I love how he absolutely nailed the pitch resonance with The Voice on Jessica. She couldn't fault him, he had dialed her number perfectly for total control over her at that moment.
I see it as his first attempt of breaking free from his mother’s control
Personally, I think this scene was where Timothee displays the strongest acting. Paul foresees a future that only *HE* causes and a lot of innocent people die because of him and people view him as a messiah for his actions. Paul was just a kid dealt with the poor hand in fate's cruel game.
Wait until you see part 2
@@johnwilliams1381 Bitch, I've *ALREADY* seen it!
He does what Anakin should have looked like in prequels I think
@@acenewholland564 At least Anakin's hot. I for one never got into Timothee because THAT MOVIE ruined it for me.
@@wiinterflowers4277 Are you referring to call me by your name? Bruh-
Notice Zendaya’s voice on the word “fear” when Jessica utters it-Paul really is slipping in and out of time.
Indeed! Another small detail in this amazing work of art.
Shit! That’s a great find! Never noticed that till now
Wait I cant hear her voice?? Wdym
@@angelatheangel839 At around 2:14, I think. Jessica asks Paul "what do you fear?" and Chani's voice overlaps on the word "fear."
@@cirrusB612 ooohh thats Chani's voice!? wow good pick up, thought it was jessica's!
Love the scene. Both, the vision of holy war and acting. "A war in my name" line gives me chills every time. Perfection
Who's here after Part Two ? Can't wait for the third film that will show the true horror of Paul's jihad.
I hope there's a part three🤞🏽
i cant imagine that with PG13 rating. Dune 2 was pg13 and alot of violence was shown off screen or off shot.
Part two was amazing, saw it at a dome theater. 🔥🔥
@@kr15711it’s making crazy money it’s assuredly coming
"Send them to paradise" damn that's hard core 😂😁
I mean if you think about it, Paul is somewhat of a character in Dune that emulates Greek Tragedy. My opinion of him at least.
Well Atreides roughly translates to “descended from Atreus.” Atreus is a heroic but ill-fated house from Greek mythology and it’s claimed that House Atreides are descendents of this line. So that would make sense.
@@walthitchcock thats crazy to think about like theyre descendant of a line tens of thousands of years before these events(im not exactly sure how far in the future dune is set)
That’s literally what the Atreides family is supposed to be in the the Dune universe. Paul’s paternal legacy is traced all the back to his original ancestor, Atreus.
Dune goes a lot deeper than you realize…
Paul reminds me in some ways of Eren. Eren knew the unchangeable future too....(Attack on Titan). And they would and could not change it.
@@Jaenoe818 I don't know about the books, but I think the films mention it is the year 10,000-something (though, it isn't using AD or CE, so it could be even further in the future with a new calendar system)
Glad they did this scene justice
Justice? Paul and his mon are trained to master their emotions better than the best monks in history. Why would they get emotional like that? That's so american. Good american actors are the ones who cry all the time.
@@Tanirhum you are literally one witnessing the largest genocides ever imagined caused by you which you have absolutely no control over whilst on hallucinogens that can help people navigate space and time. Fuck me most people would completely lose their mind over the concept of involvement. He holds himself together pretty well
@@Tanirhum
Dude he is seeing the Future of his Bloodline, all that leads to the Dictatorship of the God-Emperor. If that dosnet make you emotional that means you are a sociopath
@@zachcreaghcoen2389which you only understand if you read the books. The movie doesnt explain it, its just some drug infused vision, whereas in the books the severity of this moment is made perfectly clear. I just read it, and it changed my whole perception of Paul and of what to expect from this story. I dont understand how can you argue that the movie did this scene justice, when its just a confusing mess, that skimps through a key development moment for the protagonist.
@@mac19999x I haven’t read the books and I understood it pretty well. “Holy War raging across the stars like an unquenchable fire” is a pretty clear giveaway.
3:08 He sure got the pitch right that time!
3:15 she cries not because she is sad but because she knows what he says is true
everyone calling my name. a war in my name. DEEP
Easily the best scene in the movie in terms of story. Easily.
What about in terms of cgi
@@Dragon.um5tzwhen his helmet opened it was a little bad, but still decent.
@@XanVicious yeah that part was a bit weird but overall it looks great
@@Dragon.um5tzif u look close its the dust over his face that makes it look cgi, but once its full closeup the face and helmet mesh perfectly
Anyone else only just noticed the worm in the background at 1:22?
Yeah, me too , first time I see it :D
Bro i’ve watched this scene so many times and i never noticed it lol
That's actually the third worm that pops up. Rewatch from 1:12. Two other worms (that you don't actually see themselves) explode out of the ground before the third one you are referencing.
@@BiggiifulYEEOOOOO I NEVER NOTICED IM SCREAMING I’m so hyped for genocidal Paul to take over the universe
holy fuck didn't see it before!
Just noticed the line near the start of this scene 'there's Spice in the tent' is ADR'd and now it sticks out to me. I think I've watched this scene to many times lol
Best scene in the movie after Gom Jabbar scene
I wish they did "the sleeper has awakened" as an homage
Maybe in part 2
They end up doing it
He will do that when he drinks the water of life
2:26 Timothee's performance is great
After reading the book, I think they did very well with this scene. It doesn't follow the dialog in the book in precise, it leaves many things Paul came to realize out too (like his sister's existence, his grandfather), but it still very clearly based on it, and makes it more dramatic/mysterious and intense than the book version.
Such a powerful scene that sets up messiah perfectly
The scene on Caladan will definitely be in Messiah. Can't wait.
Paul is truly scared because he knows that a lot of innocents will die because of his Jihad a Jihad he didn’t choose to be associated with him at all
That’s his Atreides character showing yet he’s also tempted by the power of being the Padishah Emperor of the Known Universe AND the Kwisatz Haderach a living god
Over 60 billion according to the books :(
@Desert Power I got it from wikipedia, yeah not a great source but I am assuming it is accurate.
dune.fandom.com/wiki/Muad%27Dib%27s_Jihad
So Paul knew what would happen to the innocent people of the universe and did nothing to stop it? How unbelievably terrifying. I guess in the end, it was always the Harkonnen and the Sardaukar who were the good ones, while the Atreides and the Fremen were the evil ones. 😞
@@costco_pizza tbf Paul pulled a Dr strange and viewed as many timelines as he could and in all of them the jihad occured
@@costco_pizza the lines between good and evil are blurred in the Dune series, just as they are in real life.
Both sides did morally questionable things, and that's why it's important to always question your leaders and to hold them accountable.
Seeing the Fremen worshiping Letos skull in the part 2 gave me goosebumps.
A lot of people have been talking about Timothée Chalamet's performance being better in Dune Part 2 than it was in this one. And every time I just have to ask... Did they not watch this scene? His acting in this scene had me glued to the screen. He is the reason that this is the scene I remember the most from Dune Part 1.
Ofc, he was still fantastic in Part 2.
damn you can see Jamis behind Pual during the scene with the floating ships
This scene shows that Chani will come around and support Paul and the Fremen as they surrender to the Jihad against the Universe.
Yeah IIRC in the books Chani doesn't rebel against Paul, instead being by his side as his concubine.
I think Messiah will more be about a love triangle between Paul, Chani, and Irulan, with the backdrop of the Jihad and Paul giving in to his status as a God-like messiah. Then the threats to his rule.
“Holiest war ever!”
On the winds of time, I ride destiny and prophecy.
2:39 are we gonna talk about timothee chalamets acting tho? 😮💯
Absolutely insane that Part Two didn't have visions or mysticism like this that Part One had. One of the many disappointments of the sequel.
it had the worshipping at the shrine of leto's skull at least
It also had Paul envisioning the mass suffering caused if he were to travel south through the constant showing of the starved bodies scattered around his mum
@@roryanderson9747 Exactly.
Loved Dune Part 2. Visions weren’t as good in P2, but there’s too much to cover to check every box. It was excellent.
Is this possible futures or realities?
The scene where they were fighting we see paul but in dune 2 we see shani in that position.
Will that be shani by his side or the princess looking down at the soldiers
This was a possible future. The latter part of this vision shows us Caladan and that's from Dune Messiah since the holy war doesn't actually leave Arrakis until after the first book which the first two movies adapt. It hasn't happened yet and we might see that in part three. That part is most likely also a possible future but could be similar to the reality that unfolds in the future since Denis has expressed his concerns about reuniting Chani with Paul in Messiah.
Desert power
No sé por qué pero no sabéis lo mucho que amo esta vision del futuro de DUNE parte 1, los planos de cámara, la música, lo ágiles y estilo de lucha de los Fremen, siempre que la veo me transmite una sensación de ensoñación épica. Si sabéis como puedo ser parte del equipo de rodaje para ser un Fedaykin extra en la futura tercera parte de DUNE Messiah. Es una de mis top 10 escenas favoritas en el cine, Denis Maestro necesito ser un Fedaykin entre las legiones alzando el estandarte verde y negro del halcón de los Atreides, gracias.
Pd: He visto esta escena unas 36 veces o más
This doesn't seem to be on the playlist yet.
Also the "Removing dead bodies..." video.
Just wanna help.
Got it! Thanks. :)
Is "in my father's name" actually a reference to Leto II?
I didn't hear him say that exactly? Just "a war in my name".
@@rumighoul something like flying a banner in his father's name at about 2:34
Oh shit, that’s a reference to the golden path. I’m surprised I didn’t catch that till now.
I feel this flashback should've been several minutes and had a bit more exposition attached to it. I get that the meanings behind the flashbacks get revealed further on in the books but this scene just lacks the gravitas of the book. The galactic destruction and genocide that follows Pauls Jihad just looks like same random 20 second battle scene on Arrakis
Bro this movie was like 3 hours long and has so much to cover...
Yeah, I didn’t get that at all. It’s Paul’s reaction to the vision that gave me all the exposition I needed. The worshiping, the burning of the bodies without “harvesting” them, the bloody knife & hand. I saw it in theater and I got the impression without any question that Paul is going to do more than just get revenge on the Emperor for his father.
When he says “somebody help me, please”, that’s didn’t sound like someone who was afraid of fighting a random 20 second battle on a desert planet. It sounded like the panic from a young boy who knows he’s going to be Herr Hitler. I imagine we don’t “see” more as an audience, is because Paul is desperately trying hard NOT to see. So we’re only getting his reaction, and not a full record accounting of galactic atrocities.
@@leonwilliams9589I think my issue, is that while Paul is having a visceral and vivid reaction, the scenes reflecting his visions just don't match his reactions which comes across as confusing and takes me out of the movie.
@@Droxal that’s the point. It’s like Anakin’s visions about Padme before his fall. It’s an incomplete cognitive experience jumbled up by the inherent uncertainty of probabilistic outcomes. What actual information makes its way into our frontal lobe is never coherent, but feelings and emotions are excitations (neurochemistry) in the same fields as all other “experience”. Pain, contemplation, sight, love, etc…all happen in the brain.
A vision, isn’t just a jumbled up series of visual stimuli but of the experience overall. And emotions aren’t built on detail, they’re built on broad associations. That’s why details in what you “see” never match up to the certainty about the meaning of what you’re seeing. Paul wasn’t just seeing the future, he was experiencing it because it is specifically HIS future he’s seeing.
@@leonwilliams9589 The fact we are comparing this to Star Wars Prequels is probably not a good sign.
Remote viewing goes hard
0:48 - “Come and see…”
They put spoiler for 2nd book (3rd movie if it happens) in this movie itself. Haven't read the second book yet but I know 'the blood in channi's knife is Paul's'.
And they haven't given the spoiler about the lineage of Paul and his mother. This is really good. But the politics of the book is missing.
No. wrong. Keep reading. Best is yet to come.
IKR? I just finished reading the first part of Dune, and as I read this specific part of the book, when Paul and Jessica's lineage was revealed, I nearly freaked.
@@nateborie6329do tell
@@JJRichardson_ he is Harkkonen and Atreides
I feel like that war is going to happen Dune Messiah or Dune chapterhouse movies soon
You took too much, Paul. You took too much, too much…
Very awesome
Ephraim had gave it before and not? To beacause too to my name is Yoshua
So whenever people use the Voice in this movie, you hear the voices of other past Reverend Mothers mixed in. 3:08 you don’t hear any of them.
How are they running on the sand without attracting the sand worms
The Fremen are riding worms into battle. When Paul's mask comes up you can see one in the background
3 worms explode into the battlefield, with a slo-mo of the third when Paul removes his face guard. The explosions aren’t bombs going off, it’s worms coming out of the sand
Spoiler
All the warriors are Paul thru manipulation of time and space
He’s single handedly fighting off the warriors
Where is that written? Paul doesn’t control anyone physically, except with the voice. He just finds clear paths to victory using prescience and therefore appears to his enemies as invincible.
2:25
Janis lives = bad future
Isn't it the opposite? That Janis could have guided Paul to freeing arrakis without causing the Fremen to engage on a zealous crusade afterwards?
@@josephtownsend7481 he shows up in the bad future vision 2:20
@@johnnymaximum3828 that "bad future" actually the better one than what about to come
@@rudernshaw9636 his son saves the universe tho
@TheT26E4SuperPershing fuck lol my bad (still an interesting read how he does it tho😅)
Spice is work poop?
This scene is the only real problem I have with the movie. It is the most important scene in the entire book and it’s just really underwhelming. I don’t know anyone who remembered this scene who had not read the book prior to viewing.
I had to go to youtube to watch videos on what Paul was in the book to understand this scene on a second viewing. I think what you pointed out is what a lot of people would have issues with if they never read the book (like myself).
I will say that after learning about him more, this scene became more powerful (for me at least).
I found it extremely satisfying in the cinema, but then I've read the book several times. I think it does a good job of packing in the feeling utter crisis within Paul, in the musical tension and the acting. They could have included more explicit and powerful vision-scenes I suppose.
Highly disagree. It was insane in the cinema. Very powerful. The change from Chani smiling and welcoming to the battle and then utter realization of the horrors to come. This is one of my favorite scenes in cinema. The music and editing was fantastic.
@@Biggiiful the score and visuals in this scen were perfect 👍
I haven't read the book, and I specifically search out this scene whenever I think about this movie. In fact, this scene is the one that's burned into my brain from this movie. I really need to read the books.
do you think his acting is a bit wacky here?
yep. seems to work for most people, but i find his acting jarring in this scene. he does better in part two.
Nah man this scene gave me absolute goosebumps, I just had to come back and watch again. I don’t normally get goosebumps when watching something, but Timothée killed it. 👏🏾
Paul is so mean to his mom for no reason in this scene.
He's reasonably angry, he was bred for this purpose. This wasn't happenstance, it was planned for generations.
Context is key.
“You did this to me”
Seems to be enough context. Something she or her people did caused him to be a scary monster. I don’t know much about the movie or the books beyond he’s supposed to be some godlike powerful messiah or something and that seems kinda clear here.
@@nickrivas6429 What purpose? Waging the jihad?
@@zachlewis9751 Or he could be wrong in accusing her. Just because he said “You did this to me,” she didn’t necessarily do “this” to him. Plus, his mother lost her partner just as he lost his father. He would do well to return her sympathy to him.
the film is beautiful, but these battles on ridiculous ceremonial daggers in no way correspond to the high-tech future and spoil the whole impression of the film.
Dunes whole aesthetic is 'ancient future'.
Books, human computers, human navigators, ornate ancient and artisinal looking technology is commonplace, while actual technological advance has stagnated or stopped.
The film doesn't explain it perfectly, but the shields they wear can only be penetrated by slower attacks, like those of a melee weapon.
The faster something moves towards the shield, the stronger it's deflected.
I personally find the medieval sci-fi setting to be very cool and unique.
In the dune verse everyone is invulnerable because of shield technology that can only be penetrated by slow moving object. Thus the age of power ranger melee battlefield
@@lamhuynh7201 not invulnerable - the film didn't explain this, but if a laser weapon hits a shield it creates feedback, causing a nuclear explosion, at some point along the beam length.
You could shoot someone with a laser. You just... shouldn't.
@@MrFarlarzia its las gun, technically not laser but the problem why shield won the battlefield is because of the house convention prevent the use of nuclear weapon in the battlefield at the threat of getting nuked by everyone else. Which is basically what the shield-las interaction generated.
1:03 your dream as a kid after watching the 95 Power Rangers movie
After seeing dune part two, these visions mean so much more to me and makes me appreciate part one even more.
THE HOLY WAR IS COMING.
A young man of pure heart sees the monster he will become, the horrors done in his name, in his honorable father’s name, and there’s nothing he can do to stop it. “Somebody help me.”
This is not the Holy War you think it is.
those advanced freman suits look so good
I need a clear 360 view of this in concept art somewhere, the fedaykin are badass.
"everyone screaming my name!"
whisper: "paul"
made me crack up
he is still under impression he can change this, thus choosing the name "Muad Dib". Little did he known....
Fun little observation: In this scene, this is the only time you hear "The Voice" being male... aka: its PAUL speaking vs the collective nature of the Bene Gesserit. I know one thing, I peed in that movie theater seat when I heard this LOL!!!
What about when he uses it in the Ornithopter prior to this scene?
I dont know what you heard. After rewatching the scene a few times - you still hear a distinct "femme/female" inclination when he commands the soldier to "Remove her gag."@@TobiasKolb1
It's such a cool detail, actually feels like he's tapping into the 'masculine memories' more and actually becoming the 'place they dare not look.'
Flawless performance!!!! A true Masterpiece!!!!
Maan, this scene is so powerful.... Kudos to Villeneuve
I watched this movie in the theatre (what an experience!) and this scene blew me away, but the true significance of what's going on only really hit me when I read the book.
Paul sees a plethora of possible futures, most of which show him his own death or that show him this holy war and he's more terrified of the latter outcome, where a huge army of fanatics wages holy war in his name across the galaxy.
From then on, you never quite know what Paul's plan truly is or how he's going to realize it.
The second movie is going to be wild, given the events of the second half of the first book, that will be covered.
Did you enjoy the part 2? :D
I just realize Paul is not talking about himself, he's seeing the visions of his son
At this moment he is talking about the muadib jihad. I think they get more into Leto 2 in the next one
Nah this is all of Paul’s arc
This is NOT Leto
@@jbird4165 Emperor Leto the 2nd is Paul's son, named after his father Duke Leto the 1st. He's introduced in the second Dune book whereas both movies so far have covered the story of the first book.
@@matthew55793he clearly says “everyone is screaming my name” this has to do with the jihad not Leto.
After watching Dune part 2, you now understand the most obvious spoiler here. The main difference is that this is an alternative reality of many in the Dune multiverse.
This is, at the same time, one of the best... and worst scenes in the movie.
The best is Timothee's acting. He absolutely kills it here, and makes you feel for Paul's horror.
The worst is, ironically enough, Villeneuve's directing. Paul's visions are essentially drug induced (for a lack of a better word) hallucinations that are supposed to be both tripping and terrifying. Here, Villeneuve just... shows things in slow motion. And yes, some of Zendaya's shots look like from a perfume commercial, which is NOT what these visions should feel like. This is the one part of the movie Villeneuve dropped the ball in the first movie. Fortunately, the rest is incredible stuff, so it doesn't hurt it too much.
1:23 Go Go Power Rangers!
Jihad
Fun fact: we see the shrine he’s talking about again I think in dune 2 (I might be wrong on which dune) we see a painting of his father with the fremen worshipping the father and bowing with his skull on the shrine.
"Paul"
2:01 almost a population of a foreign world following him as a messiah (willing to do anything for him including genocide), previous emperors beautiful and brilliant daughter as wife, having devoted lover and mother of his children(Chani) by his side, gods power in his eyes and skills to fight like demon. Paul was living litt ⚡⚡⚡
“Price! You need to go now!”
Captain Price: 3:08
🧼
SOAP!
I like how in Paul's vision, he mimics Chani's moves almost exactly
He is clothed in a robe dipped in blood, and the name by which he is called is The Word of God. Revelation 19:13 The dramatic conclusion of the “times of the Gentiles” is described in prophecy as a gigantic world war which is climaxed by the second coming of Christ. This movie has so many spirital aspects its undeniable
awful cgi
Yeah, don't like the grand scale battle fields much myself. They look like in any other Holywood movie. Luckily there are a lot of IRL made background and scenes in this movie. For example most of the indoor shots have been done with real objects and great care for details.
How
Wait until you watch the second movie