I carry the Sig Sauer P365X with the shorter barrel and longer 12 rd grip module, but I switched mine out for the Wilson Combat grip module and it makes a world of difference to me. It's a much better fit in my hand and the texture is a lot better than the factory texture. I have the Holosun 407k mounted and I've also found out to be very reliable and a very good fit for the Sig optic cut. I am absolutely impressed with this combo and for me it's my most "perfect" carry gun to date.
Yup, I have been waffling on what slide to get for the P365 slide and WC XL grip module combo. I don't want to sit around without the pistol while the slide gets milled, and some of the best slides seem to be permanently OOS fue to yhe popularity of the pistol. Might just go woth a factory P365X slide.
Working on the P365 slide,Icuras a.c.e pro xl grip and Parker Mountain Machine comp/barrel combo. Can’t wait. I wanted the spectra comp but couldn’t find one!
I have this pistol and absolutely love it. I feel the slide porting instead of a traditional comp is a worthy trade off, especially on such a small pistol. It's an "oh shit" gun not a duty gun and I'd rather lose some barrel length than deal with a comp that can come lose and/or throw shrapnel at my face through the ports. If you throw a Zev oversized mag release you'll be good to go! Thanks Aaron
I liked your video. The idea behind the P365 built in comp is that it's built in and it doesn't have the many problems that add on comps have. The P365 Spectre comp ( I have one) execution is very good and everyone that shoots it can feel the difference ( I also have a P365XL) Now going forward can Mfg's make improvements on built in comps, I'm sure they will make advancements but for now Sig did a very good job.
I EDC the P365Xl w/ a Romeo Zero... Been considering the Spectre Comp just as a nice treat/upgrade and swaping the crap Romeo out for a Swampfox. This is just the revie wI've been searching for! Thanks brother!!
If you want the trigger flatter aftermarket will bring the creep less and put it more near the wall which will keep your trigger flat to begin with. Tactical Trigger makes an excellent upgrade while retaining OEM parts and safeties.
Great review Aaron. In my opinion you should also review the S&W performance center M&P shield plus 4” ported model, either by itself, or in a heads up against the Sig Spectre comp. There aren’t many models of different compensated or ported carry guns that come straight from the factory like that, so I think it would be a great comparison. I know you don’t like comparing apples to apples in terms of which one you personally like better, but seeing as how one model is compensated and the other is ported, I think it could be an interesting conversation between the two methods and seeing which one is more effective. I am curious what you would think about that.
You mentioned the desire for a flatter trigger at the end... I had the same complaint about the XL flat triggers and have found the curved trigger from the original 365 to be a significant improvement. It's 20 bucks, and it makes the travel distance feel much more reasonable. Thanks for reviewing the Spectre comp, I was interested to see if that slide/barrel design had any efficacy.desire
The side view footage comparing muzzle rise/return, to my eye, appears to show the ported version moves about 75% as far, and returns quicker (of course).
Great vid and God Bless you for not calling it the Sig Speck-Tray comp. Theres about a half million other gun tubers that appear to be illiterate out here.
💡🙏😳. Thank you Aaron for that review 🤔 I had a feeling that it would NOT compensate muzzle flip as well as an actual comp would and I agree that the barrel should have Been ported and full length 🙏 Great review you confirmed what my gut was telling me
I do think the trigger pull and design is a safety feature being probably the gun without a trigger shoe safety carrying it everyday and knowing how reliable it’s been for me and so many others and knowing the trigger I’m sure it’s a safety feature that being said I’ve just falling in love with Sig triggers because of it. Mainly over that flat feel with out of the box and they change their pulls on guns depending on what they are for in the 320 lineup legions trigger is much different then a X Tac
I have one of the Spector comp slides on the way to compare to the 365x + PMM JTTC slide combo I already have. I just want Holosun to release the EPS already.
Ive put over 4000 rounds through my 365xl at various training courses and it keeps up well with compact and fullsize guns. Gets smoked by staccatos but theyre a different animal. I use a 507k, Wilson grip w/ weights, tlr7 sub and dpm recoil system (long plug med/short spring). Mcarbo spring kit and Tactical trigger kit. It runs fast and flat and i trust it with my life. Its hard to belive this version is worth the money. 🤙🏼🍻
This is pretty much my exact setup minus the mcarbo and dpm. I'm a little nervous about modifying the trigger system but I'm interested in the dpm. Are you happy with it? Had any issues?
@@zacharyread5303 Not one hiccup. Runs like butter and with the right combo of spring and plug the felt recoil is pretty much gone and the dot settles back on target with very minimal dip. Changes the recoil impluse for the better. The Tactical Trigger kit is fantastic. No screws to adjust anything so nothing to come loose on ya. Took pretravel down to 1/8” and just enough overtravel to make it run right. All safeties still intact.
Maybe I was over expecting from the DPM solution, but I don't feel it did a thing on my SIG 365XL. I can't say I did a back and forth test, but then again, somebody would have to help me with a double blind test there.
The thing you said at the end about preferring a flat trigger that's closer to 90 degrees. I think Sig makes their triggers that way because the break is at 90 degrees and they think that's optimal for whatever reason. I haven't shot a flat trigger on a P365 but it looks very similar to the one on my P320 and I don't mind it and I do like it better than the curved trigger it had originally.
Was always curious about this gun but I went with an Icarus aluminum frame, custom works FCU, Zev 365xl slide, 407k 6 moa, DPM recoil spring, and custom Bar-Sto triple ported barrel.
@@stevenlee2780 I actually never shot with the original spring, since it was like 50$ anyway and I was able to get the DPM relatively cheap, I went straight to it. Side effect of using the custom works FCU and not starting with a complete gun
I would check out Icarus Precision… killer Aluminum and weighted EVO comp grip module options. Changed my P365 night and day! Along with P320 options! Many have commented on the PPM micro comp
I’d like to see an application of the Sage / Agency compensator for the Glock 43x. It is a more elegant, and more livable, solution when compared to the Parker Mountain Machine JTTC comp.
Not a fan of the 43x now that the p365xl exists.... the gun is better in every way. Sig really has something with these FCU units even Agency comped, the 365XL has less recoil in my hands and in my opinion.
Sage is 100% correct. I have a Parker Mountain JTTC on my p365 and have also had the slide and barrel ported by Magnaport. It is hands down the softest shooting and accurate sub compact I have ever fired. I highly recommend Magnaporting in conjunction with a comp on this platform. Just my two cents..........
Best combo is the original P365 slide with the P365XL grip module and magazines. The only thing I may change is to buy the AL frame made by Icarus to add a bit more weight to the pistol... It's a fantastic gun!!.
I run a PMM Comp/Barrel on a P365X. I am a fan of compensated carry guns. Shot it and a Range Buds Spectre Comp side by side on several drills. The true, compensated gun was more efficient at lessening muzzle rise/"felt recoil"- shot flatter, than the ported slide Spectre Comp model amongst 3 shooters. A subjective eval granted, but results were unanimous.
My glock19 is as small as I would absolutely consider going on a handgun, my next will be full size for sure, and that about getting a 19L slide for it and porting the slide & and maybe an extra barrel I have to go with it after seeing this, or do you think since they are threaded barrels that would get better results with a barrel mounted comp? Or a ported barrel and/or slide?
I have the P356XL with a Holosun 407K and the TLR7. The only thing I added was a hogue grip for a palm swell. Its my daily carry and its been a good gun. The spectre comp seems really cool but not worth it for me at this time because mine works for my needs.
I guess the comp is cooler than the normal spectre, but I continue to be mind boggled by pricing of all the spectre line up. Love my Xcompact and X5 legion.
I think the percieved negation in recoil between the two pistols is better attributed to the LXG grip module giving you better control over the gun, rather than the slide porting.
There’s a UA-cam video out by a popular guntuber, Honest Outlaw maybe, that switched the grip modules to test that. He found the LXG grip had nothing to do with the recoil, the comp actually works.
I have large hands and have a problem with the magazine dropping free. Did you experience the same issue? I have to completely release my grip on the pistol. Thanks
Using the short barrel instead of porting seems to me to be cost saving for Sig because it allows them to use the same barrel as the regular 365 (just TiN instead of nitron coated) which if im paying $600 more over a regular 365xl than i would expect to get more than just slide cuts and a 365 barrel.
I am hoping that Agency brings out a replacement trigger for the P365 platform like the trigger they already make for the P320. That has a less extreme angle and is one of the only complaints I have about the 365 series.
I'm with you on the trigger. Does anyone else make an aftermarket trigger that has more of that 90° starting position? I saw that Tactical Triggers makes a kit that reduces trigger pull travel, as well as reset distance...yet it still utilizes that same stock, oddly angled trigger.
Aaron, it sounds like for the minimal amount of recoil mitigation you are better off just getting the P365XL and having the benefits of a longer barrel and sight radius while saving a few hundred dollars to use on a 507K is that a reasonable perspective?
As someone who's had the standard XL for about a year, I'd rather keep what I got than go with a shorter barrel with slight "compensation". To me, the extra barrel length is necessary for a vast majority of defensive rounds to expand properly and be more effective overall. Sure, compensation is nice but at the end of the day, the standard XL is not a snappy G43, it handles well as it is. Maybe if Sig decides to release a proper XL barrel length that's ported and comp'ed, I'll pick one up.
The better test would be to shoot a 365 vs the XL spectre comp. Weigh the difference and add a weight to the light rail to keep the guns at dead even bbl length and velocity and recoil impulse and dead even total weight. Then test the recoil.
I do not like that forward swept trigger.. But I've heard and u can see that when u pull it after the break it stops at a perfect 90 degrees. (straight) benificial good bad???? Up to u lol
I bought the same nra xl with 507k and no kidding like 2 weeks later this model came out and I had extreme buyers remorse and after gbrs and mike glover praised it, made my remorse worse but just sucked it up and shot it and around 500 rounds got very consistent out to 25 yards with. No malfunctions or issues at 1,000. Psa has ran a great deal on the comp’d version for I believe $899 or $999. Keep watch in their emails. Thank you for your opinion as always. Made me feel better!
Gave thumbs up,nice video, the trigger breaks at 90 degrees..if /may have done shooting this model you would know..fyi just observed as your last comment..
I bought a spectre comp and have a 365 and 365x. Also have PMM micro comp installed on 365. The spectre comp seems a little softer in recoil while PMM micro comp just won’t stay on with rocksett and red locktite….
@@ItzAlex626 yeah, I want to know what the trick is… I’ve reinstalled it 3x and each time I cleaned w acetone and brush and scraped off the remnants on the threads. I use new shims so it gets correct tension, use red locktite and rocksett and they still backs off…
@@pittwm I'm not sure what the correct way is. I bought the Moshi block and followed thier video too. I redid this week with different shims and rockset. Let it sit for 3 days so maybe the thread locker will have time to set? It's seems to stay on now. I can't get it loose with just my fingers now. I'll shoot it and see if it flys off or not. Best of luck to you
Maybe this is going to sound weird ,but , how do you fire from 25 yards? from a bench...supported...standing...no support...one eye or both eyes opened?
Having shot all models of the sig 365 the comp is softer on the muzzle flip. It's not as much as sig says but it is an improvement. Money wise it's not worth it. But the better cut for the optic and a few other improvements make it nice if you own one.
I had the P365 before the P365XL, and I felt the XL was more accurate, perhaps due to the longer barrel? How does the Spectre's shorter barrel affect accuracy of groups at say 30 or 40 yards?
I carry the XL ($645 total) with a Wilson Grip Module($70), a True Precision 4.3” threaded barrel($190) and Herrington comp($90) Holosun 507K green dot. It shoots noticeably flatter. I like the longer barrel, and feel it’s more accurate than the 3.1 or 3.7 Sig barrels. So I think my combination is on par with the XL Spectre Comp. I’ve included the prices paid as a comparison.
@@juniperburton7693 It adds up when you try to improve on the design. With my astigmatism, I need a circle dot optic. A red dot only or iron sights don’t work well for me. So the extra expense for the Holosun was needed. I will keep my Wilson grip module, it fits better in my hand than the factory one. It’s a little fatter and allows better trigger placement for my finger. The nice thing about a threaded barrel and comp (or suppressor), you can always remove them and go back to factory condition.
Great video! Love your opinion on all things that go bang! Question, when speaking about premium ammunition, "HST, Gold Dot", through barrels 4.5" +, is there any reason to ever use the 124g +P or is it best to stick with standard pressure loadings? I've been using and practicing when I can with 147g HST & Gold dots for a few years now but I'm constantly wondering if added velocity would gain more positive than negative drawbacks through longer barrels.
I wonder how this porting would compare with the single chamber comp from parker mountain machine for the p365xl head to head. It's expensive at $360, but I'm willing to bet it's a better experience
Really appreciate the head-to-head in front of the horizontal lines to show the effect of the compensator
Thanks
Best review out on this handgun by far. The background with lines while watching recoil was a nice touch.
I carry the Sig Sauer P365X with the shorter barrel and longer 12 rd grip module, but I switched mine out for the Wilson Combat grip module and it makes a world of difference to me. It's a much better fit in my hand and the texture is a lot better than the factory texture. I have the Holosun 407k mounted and I've also found out to be very reliable and a very good fit for the Sig optic cut. I am absolutely impressed with this combo and for me it's my most "perfect" carry gun to date.
Yup, I have been waffling on what slide to get for the P365 slide and WC XL grip module combo. I don't want to sit around without the pistol while the slide gets milled, and some of the best slides seem to be permanently OOS fue to yhe popularity of the pistol. Might just go woth a factory P365X slide.
Wow… do you have a picture of this? Social media anything? I would love to see what this looks like…
I have the XL slide on a Wilson XL grip module, and I couldn't agree more. It's awesome. No issues with holster compatibility with the Wilson grip.
I have the X and just got the XL. I’ve been looking at the WC grip and now I definitely want it. Thanks for your input 👊🏼
Working on the P365 slide,Icuras a.c.e pro xl grip and Parker Mountain Machine comp/barrel combo. Can’t wait. I wanted the spectra comp but couldn’t find one!
You are the best. Thank you for your awesome reviews
This exact setup is my EDC. Love it.
Always quality analysis, thank you
I have this pistol and absolutely love it. I feel the slide porting instead of a traditional comp is a worthy trade off, especially on such a small pistol. It's an "oh shit" gun not a duty gun and I'd rather lose some barrel length than deal with a comp that can come lose and/or throw shrapnel at my face through the ports. If you throw a Zev oversized mag release you'll be good to go! Thanks Aaron
Great review and agree with all your observations/critiques. Keep it up Aaron. 👍
I liked your video. The idea behind the P365 built in comp is that it's built in and it doesn't have the many problems that add on comps have. The P365 Spectre comp ( I have one) execution is very good and everyone that shoots it can feel the difference ( I also have a P365XL) Now going forward can Mfg's make improvements on built in comps, I'm sure they will make advancements but for now Sig did a very good job.
the review we've been waiting for
Glad to see another gun review
Great review. Thorough and concise.
Thank you for a very well done and informative video.
Great review as usual. Best gun and gear review channel on youtube.
I EDC the P365Xl w/ a Romeo Zero... Been considering the Spectre Comp just as a nice treat/upgrade and swaping the crap Romeo out for a Swampfox. This is just the revie wI've been searching for! Thanks brother!!
Been waiting for this one
This is an outstanding review. Thank you.
Great video as always 👊🏻
Loved this review!
If you want the trigger flatter aftermarket will bring the creep less and put it more near the wall which will keep your trigger flat to begin with. Tactical Trigger makes an excellent upgrade while retaining OEM parts and safeties.
Definitely getting one! Hopefully a review of the new Romeo Zero Elite is coming soon 🙏
I’ve been waiting for this forever.
Great review Aaron. In my opinion you should also review the S&W performance center M&P shield plus 4” ported model, either by itself, or in a heads up against the Sig Spectre comp. There aren’t many models of different compensated or ported carry guns that come straight from the factory like that, so I think it would be a great comparison.
I know you don’t like comparing apples to apples in terms of which one you personally like better, but seeing as how one model is compensated and the other is ported, I think it could be an interesting conversation between the two methods and seeing which one is more effective.
I am curious what you would think about that.
I have been searching for that test. I need one of them.
You mentioned the desire for a flatter trigger at the end... I had the same complaint about the XL flat triggers and have found the curved trigger from the original 365 to be a significant improvement. It's 20 bucks, and it makes the travel distance feel much more reasonable. Thanks for reviewing the Spectre comp, I was interested to see if that slide/barrel design had any efficacy.desire
Is the flat trigger from sig or after market?
My Spector comp has a 3,6" barrel.. I love it.
The side view footage comparing muzzle rise/return, to my eye, appears to show the ported version moves about 75% as far, and returns quicker (of course).
Thank you for the great review Aaron. I don’t need one of these.
I have the 365xl and I put on a copper magwell to help give a little more heft and help with snappiness
The p365 with 507k is my EDC. Just can’t bring myself to carry a full size gun except on special occasions.
Great vid and God Bless you for not calling it the Sig Speck-Tray comp. Theres about a half million other gun tubers that appear to be illiterate out here.
great review
💡🙏😳. Thank you Aaron for that review 🤔 I had a feeling that it would NOT compensate muzzle flip as well as an actual comp would and I agree that the barrel should have Been ported and full length 🙏 Great review you confirmed what my gut was telling me
Very good review thanks
I do think the trigger pull and design is a safety feature being probably the gun without a trigger shoe safety carrying it everyday and knowing how reliable it’s been for me and so many others and knowing the trigger I’m sure it’s a safety feature that being said I’ve just falling in love with Sig triggers because of it. Mainly over that flat feel with out of the box and they change their pulls on guns depending on what they are for in the 320 lineup legions trigger is much different then a X Tac
I have one of the Spector comp slides on the way to compare to the 365x + PMM JTTC slide combo I already have. I just want Holosun to release the EPS already.
The PMM is definitely superior.
Ive put over 4000 rounds through my 365xl at various training courses and it keeps up well with compact and fullsize guns. Gets smoked by staccatos but theyre a different animal. I use a 507k, Wilson grip w/ weights, tlr7 sub and dpm recoil system (long plug med/short spring). Mcarbo spring kit and Tactical trigger kit. It runs fast and flat and i trust it with my life. Its hard to belive this version is worth the money. 🤙🏼🍻
This is pretty much my exact setup minus the mcarbo and dpm. I'm a little nervous about modifying the trigger system but I'm interested in the dpm. Are you happy with it? Had any issues?
Interesting setup.
@@zacharyread5303 Not one hiccup. Runs like butter and with the right combo of spring and plug the felt recoil is pretty much gone and the dot settles back on target with very minimal dip. Changes the recoil impluse for the better. The Tactical Trigger kit is fantastic. No screws to adjust anything so nothing to come loose on ya. Took pretravel down to 1/8” and just enough overtravel to make it run right. All safeties still intact.
@@Osprey1994 Shes a keeper 👊🏼
Maybe I was over expecting from the DPM solution, but I don't feel it did a thing on my SIG 365XL. I can't say I did a back and forth test, but then again, somebody would have to help me with a double blind test there.
Comment for channel positivity and thanks for the review
The thing you said at the end about preferring a flat trigger that's closer to 90 degrees. I think Sig makes their triggers that way because the break is at 90 degrees and they think that's optimal for whatever reason. I haven't shot a flat trigger on a P365 but it looks very similar to the one on my P320 and I don't mind it and I do like it better than the curved trigger it had originally.
Was always curious about this gun but I went with an Icarus aluminum frame, custom works FCU, Zev 365xl slide, 407k 6 moa, DPM recoil spring, and custom Bar-Sto triple ported barrel.
Do you feel the DPM recoil spring makes a difference than the standard recoil spring assembly in the P365 setup?
@@stevenlee2780 I actually never shot with the original spring, since it was like 50$ anyway and I was able to get the DPM relatively cheap, I went straight to it.
Side effect of using the custom works FCU and not starting with a complete gun
I would check out Icarus Precision… killer Aluminum and weighted EVO comp grip module options. Changed my P365 night and day! Along with P320 options!
Many have commented on the PPM micro comp
PMM’s comps are awesome 🙌
Currently building mine now. Waiting for background on p365x. Use fcu and slide, sell the rest.
I wonder if agency arms will make a p365 trigger like their p320 one.
You can just buy the slide now if you like.
Thanks Aaron
Kinda want... have an early p365 that I've enjoyed for years for discrete use. An optic ready and comped version is certainly interesting to me.
I’d like to see an application of the Sage / Agency compensator for the Glock 43x. It is a more elegant, and more livable, solution when compared to the Parker Mountain Machine JTTC comp.
Not a fan of the 43x now that the p365xl exists.... the gun is better in every way. Sig really has something with these FCU units even Agency comped, the 365XL has less recoil in my hands and in my opinion.
Sage is 100% correct. I have a Parker Mountain JTTC on my p365 and have also had the slide and barrel ported by Magnaport. It is hands down the softest shooting and accurate sub compact I have ever fired. I highly recommend Magnaporting in conjunction with a comp on this platform. Just my two cents..........
Why would you need both? Honest question
You could probably buy the barrel that is as long as the slide and have it ported. Vulcan Machine Werks does porting like that.
You're able to not blink while firing. impressive :D
Best combo is the original P365 slide with the P365XL grip module and magazines. The only thing I may change is to buy the AL frame made by Icarus to add a bit more weight to the pistol... It's a fantastic gun!!.
You could just buy the Wilson Combat grip module and drop in their tungsten weights.
@@Osprey1994 I have the Icarus and the Wilson Combat grip module with the Tungsten weights and the Icarus feels much better.
this guy is awesome 😃
I run a PMM Comp/Barrel on a P365X. I am a fan of compensated carry guns.
Shot it and a Range Buds Spectre Comp side by side on several drills. The true, compensated gun was more efficient at lessening muzzle rise/"felt recoil"- shot flatter, than the ported slide Spectre Comp model amongst 3 shooters.
A subjective eval granted, but results were unanimous.
I ran through 100 rounds last weekend and enjoyed the SC more than my G43 and G48.
My glock19 is as small as I would absolutely consider going on a handgun, my next will be full size for sure, and that about getting a 19L slide for it and porting the slide & and maybe an extra barrel I have to go with it after seeing this, or do you think since they are threaded barrels that would get better results with a barrel mounted comp? Or a ported barrel and/or slide?
This is a long shot but does the 507kx2 have a lower 1/5 cowitness with the stock sights? I like to have the smallest cowitness.
(Edited after watching again) I wish they would make a sub compact with a 4.25" barrel. It's the grip for the most part that could print.
Would be interesting to see an aftermarket barrel made with ports
I think this is gonna be my new Back up
Lmao back up
Would love to see Aaron test the S&W Shield Plus PC Ported.
Agreed
I have the P356XL with a Holosun 407K and the TLR7. The only thing I added was a hogue grip for a palm swell. Its my daily carry and its been a good gun. The spectre comp seems really cool but not worth it for me at this time because mine works for my needs.
We all know the romeo zero suck, but I just got the Romeo Zero Elite. It absolutely rocks the Holosun 407 and 507….at least so far.
I guess the comp is cooler than the normal spectre, but I continue to be mind boggled by pricing of all the spectre line up. Love my Xcompact and X5 legion.
What appendix carry holster do you use that fits your light and sight on it for the specter comp
I think the percieved negation in recoil between the two pistols is better attributed to the LXG grip module giving you better control over the gun, rather than the slide porting.
There’s a UA-cam video out by a popular guntuber, Honest Outlaw maybe, that switched the grip modules to test that. He found the LXG grip had nothing to do with the recoil, the comp actually works.
Comp does work, and it doesn't seem to have the reliability problems that a standard comp can cause.
Could you take a 365 XL barrel and put matching ports in the barrel to line up with the slide cuts and it be more effective 🤔
Good stuff
I have an XL and paid half of what this model costs thanks to LE pricing. I’ll stick with the basic model.
I have large hands and have a problem with the magazine dropping free. Did you experience the same issue? I have to completely release my grip on the pistol. Thanks
Would you be so kind as to tell me how much I have to tighten the streamlight to avoid damaging the frame? thank you
Made it boys
I have this gun and it's sweet! In my opionion gets back on target quickly and shoots flatter than the standard 365 XL
How is the gold barrel as far as wear and tear goes, does the finish hold up?
Same here!
Using the short barrel instead of porting seems to me to be cost saving for Sig because it allows them to use the same barrel as the regular 365 (just TiN instead of nitron coated) which if im paying $600 more over a regular 365xl than i would expect to get more than just slide cuts and a 365 barrel.
I am hoping that Agency brings out a replacement trigger for the P365 platform like the trigger they already make for the P320. That has a less extreme angle and is one of the only complaints I have about the 365 series.
I'm with you on the trigger. Does anyone else make an aftermarket trigger that has more of that 90° starting position?
I saw that Tactical Triggers makes a kit that reduces trigger pull travel, as well as reset distance...yet it still utilizes that same stock, oddly angled trigger.
mcarbo has a trigger with pretravel adjustment
Aaron, it sounds like for the minimal amount of recoil mitigation you are better off just getting the P365XL and having the benefits of a longer barrel and sight radius while saving a few hundred dollars to use on a 507K is that a reasonable perspective?
I have a zev oz9 hypercomp and don’t notice the flash when I shoot it .
Can you please do a review on the p320 spectre comp
As someone who's had the standard XL for about a year, I'd rather keep what I got than go with a shorter barrel with slight "compensation". To me, the extra barrel length is necessary for a vast majority of defensive rounds to expand properly and be more effective overall. Sure, compensation is nice but at the end of the day, the standard XL is not a snappy G43, it handles well as it is. Maybe if Sig decides to release a proper XL barrel length that's ported and comp'ed, I'll pick one up.
A surprise to be sure.
The better test would be to shoot a 365 vs the XL spectre comp. Weigh the difference and add a weight to the light rail to keep the guns at dead even bbl length and velocity and recoil impulse and dead even total weight. Then test the recoil.
Any suggestions for a newbie that’s looking to buy a red dot holosun to zero in?
Throw a tactical dev pro ledge on it and you'll fall in love with it
I literally just looked at that, how you liking the little gas pedal? And does it affect your holster comparability?
I do not like that forward swept trigger.. But I've heard and u can see that when u pull it after the break it stops at a perfect 90 degrees. (straight) benificial good bad???? Up to u lol
I bought the same nra xl with 507k and no kidding like 2 weeks later this model came out and I had extreme buyers remorse and after gbrs and mike glover praised it, made my remorse worse but just sucked it up and shot it and around 500 rounds got very consistent out to 25 yards with. No malfunctions or issues at 1,000. Psa has ran a great deal on the comp’d version for I believe $899 or $999. Keep watch in their emails. Thank you for your opinion as always. Made me feel better!
I bought it when it came out for 1200. It wasn’t worth it in my opinion and I traded it.
Nice! Just picked up the same nra Xl. No optic yet, but it seems a nice swap from a Glock 19, especially in this heat.
They get paid from sig, sig is their sponsor
Gave thumbs up,nice video, the trigger breaks at 90 degrees..if /may have done shooting this model you would know..fyi just observed as your last comment..
What holster were you running with this? Been looking for a holster that works with the placement of the optic cut and the light for this pistol
I’m using A and R design.
holosun eps/eps carry review coming in the near future?
I bought a spectre comp and have a 365 and 365x. Also have PMM micro comp installed on 365. The spectre comp seems a little softer in recoil while PMM micro comp just won’t stay on with rocksett and red locktite….
I'm having the same issue with mine on a Glock 19. Even got their own barrel and tried different shims.
@@ItzAlex626 yeah, I want to know what the trick is… I’ve reinstalled it 3x and each time I cleaned w acetone and brush and scraped off the remnants on the threads. I use new shims so it gets correct tension, use red locktite and rocksett and they still backs off…
@@pittwm I'm not sure what the correct way is. I bought the Moshi block and followed thier video too. I redid this week with different shims and rockset. Let it sit for 3 days so maybe the thread locker will have time to set?
It's seems to stay on now. I can't get it loose with just my fingers now. I'll shoot it and see if it flys off or not. Best of luck to you
@@ItzAlex626 yeah I redid mine a couple weeks back…. I smothered the thread with red locktite and let it sat in also… I havent shot it…
Maybe this is going to sound weird ,but , how do you fire from 25 yards? from a bench...supported...standing...no support...one eye or both eyes opened?
Just got the P365 macro. I wanted the Spectre, but it is a little much for my budget at the moment.
Having shot all models of the sig 365 the comp is softer on the muzzle flip. It's not as much as sig says but it is an improvement. Money wise it's not worth it. But the better cut for the optic and a few other improvements make it nice if you own one.
Having said that I love mine. It's just overpriced.
I need a review on a .50 AE desert eagle please
I'd say from the slo mo vid it definitely looks like a bit of reduction and, well a lil less Violent.
I agree, the trigger is swept way too far forward - I impulse-purchased a P365XL and got rid of it for that very reason.
Does this include screws to mount the 507k?
I had the P365 before the P365XL, and I felt the XL was more accurate, perhaps due to the longer barrel?
How does the Spectre's shorter barrel affect accuracy of groups at say 30 or 40 yards?
It probably has more to do with the xl’s larger grip
I carry the XL ($645 total) with a Wilson Grip Module($70), a True Precision 4.3” threaded barrel($190) and Herrington comp($90) Holosun 507K green dot. It shoots noticeably flatter. I like the longer barrel, and feel it’s more accurate than the 3.1 or 3.7 Sig barrels. So I think my combination is on par with the XL Spectre Comp. I’ve included the prices paid as a comparison.
That's an expensive pistol!
@@juniperburton7693
It adds up when you try to improve on the design. With my astigmatism, I need a circle dot optic. A red dot only or iron sights don’t work well for me. So the extra expense for the Holosun was needed. I will keep my Wilson grip module, it fits better in my hand than the factory one. It’s a little fatter and allows better trigger placement for my finger. The nice thing about a threaded barrel and comp (or suppressor), you can always remove them and go back to factory condition.
I put a eps carry 6 moa on mine, or rather tried to. Screws from holosun are too long optic rattles, any advice anyone?
Great video! Love your opinion on all things that go bang! Question, when speaking about premium ammunition, "HST, Gold Dot", through barrels 4.5" +, is there any reason to ever use the 124g +P or is it best to stick with standard pressure loadings? I've been using and practicing when I can with 147g HST & Gold dots for a few years now but I'm constantly wondering if added velocity would gain more positive than negative drawbacks through longer barrels.
I’ve not seen significant enough performance of the +P across the board to make the additional recoil worth it, personally.
I wonder how this porting would compare with the single chamber comp from parker mountain machine for the p365xl head to head. It's expensive at $360, but I'm willing to bet it's a better experience
This set up feeds and runs any ammo , with a comp that's not always the case . For that reason I'm buying the spectre comp slide .
If they come down in price I’d consider one or trade my way to one with a good deal 😂 Otherwise compact size G19 is about perfect as far as CCW