It's really hard to say his impact is huge and if he lived longer it maybe even bigger for me I think he was in negative to the culture but at the same time he was the one who liberated turkey although I don't like him personally I won't say he wasn't bad all along
seems like one of those rare "enlightened despot" types who was able to will things into existence. seems more on par with Washington than Napoleon in that sense.
I think his legacy is complicated. If the rumours are true and the ottomans were prepared to give up Istanbul. Then definitely a net positive after a while lot cultural treachery and inferiority complex and bizarrely racial supremacism
@@HikmaHistory It just so happened that europe modernised first, because it was the most dominant power at the time and still is. Perhaps, modernity would have been a natural progression for other countries too, if they had followed a similar and successful path to world domination if they were so inclined, or if their civilisational development and evolution hadnt been interrupted by european colonial expansion...who knows? Whatever may be the case, the so called 'western' values of democracy, freedom, open society etc, are not the exclusive preserve of one section of humanity. These ideals belong to us all, and are things we should all strive towards as a common heritage of collective human advancement and progress.
@@HikmaHistory what ? no, moderniziation isn't a europeon thing it was lead by europe. Same way the golden age of islam wasnt a golden age of islam. Just colonizers inheriting the already existing knowledge and expanding on it. We are all standing on the shoulders of giants. Praise to the ones before!
@@HikmaHistory modernism is just codeword for colonialism. People in Türkiye dont like mustafa kemal because he brought colonialisr values to Türkiye and sold out Ottoman muslim culture
Religion is not important in Turkey. Most Turks prefer a secular lifestyle. The rise of Erdogan isn't because of religion. It's because of his political charisma. He will eventually be forgotten, but Ataturk will live on as long as the nation does.
Why will Erdogan be forgotten ? He managed Turkey to make a own car TOG. Ataturk saved the righteous. Numerous coups did happen in Turkey after Ataturk. Erdogan survived a coup. He does not misbehave. Did you see how they did put Morsi in jail. Or Imran Khan ? Erdogan won't be forgotten. You will be forgotten. You will die alone and awaken again alone and shall see nothing of this World again a new life. But you shall stay interested in whether Erdogan be forgotten or not. I shall also die and wake up new and I'm also interested like you are.
We Koreans envy Ataturk. He is a great leader like something out of a novel or movie. It's funny how Islamists go out of their way to criticize such a great leader.
Do you know why? It's because he tried getting rid of some fundamental Islamic principles, a few examples being the Arabic azan getting banned, allowing women to wear mini skirts, and the suppression of the Kurdish people and their culture and language.
@@everythingerina9379 kurdish people tried to backstab turks just like arabs did. Check out the treaty of Sevres. Azan wasn't banned, it was translated to turkish since it calls turkish people to prayer. No one was forced to wear miniskirts. You probably are referring to the new dress codes implemented at that time. Which only prohibits all religious attire for government officials. No civillians were forced to change any dress codes. You are classic muslim who gets offended when you can't enforce your pedo-incest bedouin rules on people.
Ataturk is one of the most important geniuses of the last century. Turkish youth is grateful to him. He brought the ruined country on the edge of the abyss to the brink of civilization. Even if we die one day, the names of our heroes like Atatürk will always live on. How happy is the one who says I am a Turk!
father of lies and first fascist dictatorship in history. he was the lowest of the low of the last century. the personality cult of Mustafa Kemal the drunk in uneducated turkey is not taken for a second seriously all around the world.
I'm a Brit, living in Turkey for 7 years, married to a Turk. I've been here through two elections and I would argue that the hero worship of Atatürk (whom I do respect greatly) is actually holding back the Turkish left. It is almost impossible to have a discussion about Atatürk without it being taken very personally. Atatürk is viewed as being almost unquestionably perfect, but at the same time he is presented as being many different things to many different people. Atheists believe that his personal letters show he was an atheist, secular Muslims believe his speeches show he was a secular Muslim and Conservative Muslims believe his actions show that he was a dictator. He has become a myth, and believing a myth, especially one so recent, becomes disempowering. If a myth created the nation, then "we" cannot change the nation and must simply wait for the next mythological character to come along. The Turkish left is obsessed with going back to a past (one that never really existed because Atatürk never truly realised his vision, it was being pulled apart while he still lived and was dead 5 years after his death). I reiterate, Atatürk was a remarkable man, that achieved incredible things that no other did in this period. But, he was human, flawed, complex, and often wrong. If we don't deal with this and still view him as the myth, then we can't move forward. Turkey will never retake it's place as one of the most important pieces of land in the world, unless it starts to look to the future rather than fantasising about the past.
Kemal Ataturk defeated Greece, Armenia, France, Britain and there colonies like French Algeria, British India along with radical Muslims who were funded by Britain. He later created modern Turkey and Turkish people are grateful for all the reforms and his great vision. Kemal inspires us even today.
I need to right a wrong. Ataturk's father was not ethnically Slavic or Albanian. This nonsense is just disinformation created on Wikipedia. Atatürk's father and mother were both Yoruk. Do a search on what Yoruk means.
Only 1 thing is certain, Turks came from Asia, they had clear Asian features, geneticaly this man does not look Asian, most of the people living in Turkey, they dont look Asian, they adopted Turkish culture and they call themselves Turks, but they are not direct descendants of Turks that came from Asia.
He was Macedonian. Plus, the Turkic makeup is near nonexistent in the modern “Turkish” population anyway. The original Turks all looked rather Mongoloid in the surviving paintings from the Byzantine and even Abbasid Empire.
Please don’t mis inform people that he was Jewish. He was of a Türkmen background. He had shut down the Masonic establishments. He believed in Islam and his Turkic culture and was very proud of it. He converted the Kuran into Turkish because his people didn’t speak or understand Arabic so he wanted them to know their wholly book and learn and respect its values. During the Ottoman rule less then 10% of the people knew how to read and write but after him majority knew. He was truly a genius and way ahead of his time. We as Turks were very fortunate and even the descendants of the Sultans admitted that if he had not existed Turkiye would not have existed today.
@@idontexist1155I also do not like him. He killed more than 200.000 of Greeks and Armenians and he is a butcher. To be more exact nobody in greece and armenia likes him.
He really just seems like a self hating apostate and none of them have any idea what their religion is Anderson only assume things about it but none of them actually have understanding. Besides, a religion has things to offer A nationalist apostate has nothing to offer besides material, and even that isn't something they can guarantee
Everyone who doesn't support prostitution, alcohol, the destruction of gender norms and everything that follows it, hates Ataturk. Also those minorities that were persecuted by later Kemalists, like Kurds.
Wow. That was well done. I would imagine a conversation with the Ataturk would be fascinating. With the benefit of hindsight it looks like when the Turks needed a hero they got one.
Simply put, the most complete, greatest human being who ever lived. Unmatched as a military leader, statesman, and a visionary. In the short span of his adult life, defeated every major world power, recovered almost all of the heartland of his nation, and caught up with the hundreds of years of development that the empire had lagged behind, even surpassing the west in many ways. Truly achieving the impossible. We are ever grateful to him for restoring the forgotten dignity of our great nation.
YOU should know simping well. After all you make your living from it. But on the other hand we are grateful to a hero for the freedom we have and the dignity we enjoy. You wouldn’t understand such concepts.
@@sibelshinaishin5170 Your grandfather who died for your country is just as responsible for your dignity as Ataturk was. And Ataturk could not have given you your dignity if God did not give him victory. When was the last time you thanked God for your dignity instead of a man in a coffin?
Atatürk jew or not he never left his country nor his nation nor his people and that is why we love him. He was there when his country and nation needed him,his likes,his nation believed, followed him untill the end, they were Victorious in the end!.
He is not jew idk why he said that but even ottoman papers his mom has konya descent and his that is a turk from albania which his family gpes there under politica of iskan
Resepect to Atatürk Sir from India, Turks are very lucky that they got protected by this wnderful soul. Turks are different from the arabs ethnically. A own culture. Atatürk Sir protected his people from western as well arabic colianilism as they did it with Mother India. We wished we would have had such leaders as Atatürk Sir who protected us angainst Powers. He is selfless and beyond of Gods grace, Jai Atatürk!
Thank you so much for your work. Ataturk has always fascinated me and though obviously not perfect, seemed in a lot of ways like an aspirational beacon for this part of the world, though I'm sure others could and will dispute that. The time period you covered is also so rich in contrasts between the traditional past and oncoming modernity that it never ceases to boggle my mind. Understanding history is so important and your channel is a treasure. Thanks again!
Brother, thank you for making this documentary. I enjoyed how you presented the chronology and transition from the Ottoman Empire to the Turkish Republic. Though I want to elaborate on some "facts" you are presenting about Mustafa Kemal Atatürk that I found utmost disturbing. Have you had dived deeper in the history of the Turks (meaning not only the Ottoman Empire, but also those before, you would have discovered both parents of Mustafa Kemal (the mother more definite than his father) were from Turkish nomadic descent (Yörüks). In the history of Turkish Empires (Ottoman, Seljuks etc.) nomads were primarily moved/located to the edges of the empire, including to the newly conquered grounds. There is a wisdom behind this. Since the Ottoman Empire stretched out and held control over the Balkans and Greece for decades, the likelihood of Atatürk having nomadic roots is higher than having any other ethnic background. The quote on quote "fact" that Atatürk was a crypto-jew (Donmeh) is utterly false and tends to smear, most likely due to your opinion about his politics of seperating religion from the state. As you mention in the documentary, some people hate him because of this reason and find him to be a traitor to the Ottoman Empire and Islam. Then again, in Judaism the religious status (being a Jew) is passed on from generation to generation by mothers and the tribal designation by the father. In neither of these cases, factually, it can be confirmed that Atatürk has been Jewish.
We know his background, it has been made public with documents. His mother’s as well as his father’s. This campaign to make Atatürk a Villain is to conceal the Arab role and their cooperation with the British to bring down the Ottomans. Of course their outright ignorance as well.
@@starcapture3040 Have you ever been to Türkiye, my friend? How can you cross out such a big and divers ethnic group by saying they cannot be white and have blue eyes. I am really sorry to have just read this.
@@KufluPeynir42 to call yourself father of the Turks then who claimed to be as such should be real Turk not Turkified donma Jew from Thessaloniki . real Turk must look like Uzbekistanis and turkmanstanis. blue eyed Turks don't exist. Mustafa Kemal was white so its hard to call him real Turk. actually the young Turk party that claimed to be turkest its majority weren't from Turkish background many jaws and Albanians and other ethnicities were in it. and that show why they had enmity with Islam and destroyed the ottoman state from within.
2:15 his father's descend goes to Kocacık Turkmens which are living in Konya. Most likely, this family settled to macedonia during rise of Ottomans period. 2:34 his mother wanted to send mustafa to "mektep" not "medrese/madrasa". Medrese is islamic high school. Mektep is islamic elementary school. Mustafa was a child in that period so he wouldn't go medrese. 23:49 that's right, he held power by undemocratic ways. Look at this issue from this way: He has big ideals and aims that never achieveble with liberal democracy. 30:47 he left afterwards these exaggerated theories. 32:50 all those rebellions are not concerned about kurdish nationalism or kurdish separatism. They were feudal lords, so they didn't like modern turkish state. They rebelled because of this.
I wouldn't be so sure to blame Kurdish separatism on feudalism. Let's not forget that after the martial law in 80s even the very identity of Kurd was suppressed, Kurdish was banned. Hell even Saddam didn't ban Kurdish. I don't believe in making an ethno-nationalist Kurdish state but the Turkish state has given much reason to the Kurds to revolt in the past.
@@johnxina5126 80 coup is extremely complicated issue. İ am not sure about past, but today, every kurd can use their language in Turkey. İt' s just not using in administrative or official institutions. For example, it's similar that you can't use arabic in French official instutitions or you can't use native american languages in USA. Every political group complains about 80 coup. Communists, islamists, liberals and kurdish separatists, everyone complains. We can' t hear any positive thing about this coup. İn fact, coup at least stopped right-left wing skirmishes and stabilized country until PKK terrorism rises again. And don't forget that kurds in iraq welcomed in Turkey after Saddam's oppressive policies. And additionally, if you hear news like "A Kurdish singer oppressed in Turkey JUST BECAUSE OF HE SANG İN KURDİSH." dont believe them. In fact, it was not wanted to sing in any language. İt' s not about Kurdish or Turkish. Even our people can believe such things.
As a Somali we have been taught by Wahhabi Arab fanatics that Mustafa was an infidel who changed Turkey to a non-muslim country. This documentary is really so informative about the founder of the Turkish nation. I feel ashamed that the arabs spread alot of lies against this man. So much respect for the Turkish people and their leader Mr. MUSTAFA KAMAL. love and respect from Somalia❤❤
We Turks don't care about what other Muslim thinks about us being secular ve love secularism and will continue to love our national hero for centuries to come
He us fascist in modern day language and he put a superiority complex in the head of turks who committed crimes against kurds till this day , anyway the Wahhabist are the same and even worse , nothing will heal the region except going back to our shared culture in the past otherwise wars .
@@sametsamet-sr3nj I am Muslim from India. I love Turkey and love Secularism. Live and let others live is my principle. Turkey is secular and that's why it is prosperous among other Muslim nations ❤ Would love to visit your country Turkey one day 🥰
@@sametsamet-sr3nj Secularism means freedom and freedom is the path to development. Not regressive Theocracies which actually claim religious but are corrupt actually.
In fact, the retention of Istanbul within the boarders of Turkey was almost a miracle accomplished not only by Atatürk's military genius, but by Lenin's secret diplomacy too.
He wasn’t a military guinius as portrayed in the history books written by the Kemalist. For this guy to be able to destroy Turkey from within, the colonial powers had to make this theatrical set up to make a drunk military leader a hero. He did more harm to Turkey afterwards than physical military occupation. Did you ever ask yourself why Greek celebrate him more than the Turks. We will never forget his inferiority and submissiveness to the west and the years of tyranny, coups and poverty that followed fall of the caliphate at the hands of this unknown tyrant.
@@TheTruth-wj7fl he's the pinnacle of anti-colonialism and at the time for most Indian or even German nationalists an inspiration against those powers you mentioned and also being a real general having winning battles on his name for the Ottomans and the nationalist movement. Because of this Turkey had an unique stance during WW2 and the rest of the regional countries had no choice to join the allies or the axis powers because they had no choice in the matter. Furthermore nationalist sentiments or the cry for reforms weren't that uncommon also having coups. This strange backwards made up notion that somehow he's a spy for saving something that others tried to erase on the map is utter nonsense and has a political slander mentality. Also the real spy a real example is Thomas Edward Lawrence who helped the Arab revolt and has full credit in his achievements as well therefore gaining British dominance on the levant region. Not to mention that the Turks brought Islam further expanding it not the other way around as there's no Islamic identity or politcal movement and during the fall of the Ottomans poverty, instability, illiteracy, dividing factions, population decline was very well known and was drastically solved with an iron grip on his behalf wich is a huge feat even gaining respect from other nations on the political stage stopping further invasions into Anatolia. Even religion cannot stand in the way against the state wich is a cultural mindset of the Turks. The Ottomans were a part of the European community and had more interest in the Balkans and makes it also a part of Europe as well like the Greeks who are partly Eastern and Western (based on their history and location).
@@Ghjkoplokkp Did the turks persecuted all the minorities ? The Arabs tried to fix but thr nationalistic egoistic turks wouldn't accept, now wonder everyone around you hate you
@@mreast1000 Arab betrayal now it’s not important for Türkiye republic 10 NATO countries with modern armed forces: 1)United States 2)Turkey 3)France 4)Germany 5)Italy 6)United Kingdom 7)Greece 8)Spain 9)Poland 10)Romania
Some Pakistani tliban minded mulllahs hate Great brave VISIONARY MUSTAFA KAMAL ATATURK,but we common educated MUSLIMS love him, respect him.SECULARISM IS ALWAYS BETTER AS in a country different religious people live, moreover state government should be free from religion
he was likely of Jewish ancestry. I don't think he was a 'crypto Jew', meaning that in private he practiced Judaism, but it undoubtedly affected his belief in a more secular and modernized Turkey. The US/UK/EU enjoy teaching Muslims to entirely reject Judaism b/c they know that it's the opposite of the fanatical/face covering version of Islam that these governments support.
Visited Turkey recently and was really fascinated seeing women behaving exactly like they would in the west. Never knew it was all Attaturk's doing. Great man!
Very important to know that he fought against to Western countries but he admired their education, law and technology. He wanted Turks to remember their own identity, culture and values, forget about Middle Eastern culture, and adopt Western education amd science system. That's why he was genius. Turks adopted Middle Eastern language and culture along with Islamic religion which was wrong. Ataturk had no problem with any religion, he just didn’t want ajy religion in the politics and government establishments which would bring equality.
All your gibberish just proved Turks are dying for western validation or More like Worship West. They have nothing of their own - they want to adopt this or that. Somehow, They think their own faith - ideas - even language is inferior to their superior Western masters. Severe inferiority complex.
This topic for some reason concerns arabs. Idk but some arab states abandoned the ottomans and even fought the ottomans side by side with the britts. The caliph had no meaning in this period of time. The only people who cared were the anatolian people and muslims of east asia. I will never forget them. Many indian,pakistani and bengali muslims got executed by the british empire.
Turkiye without Ataturk is Iraq or Afghanistan Ataturk is an idea, it means the level of contemporary civilizations, it means science, art, human rights instead of bigoted religions and dogmatic religions. Even 100 years ago, Ataturk talked about the problems caused by religions and reactionism, but the Anatolian Turkish people did not understand him and the result was akp and The bigoted Anatolian people still send their children to sects and live far from civilization.!
Turkey without ata turk would be a lot larger than what it is now. Whatever the case, Ata turk is the same type of terrorist as the ayatollahs of iran, except he is a secular terrorist. He has killed a lot more than Khomeini for sure
🤡🤡 ata turk left turkey with a gdp of $20B which is equivalent to the GDP of Afghanistan back in 2020 during a war 🤣 he turned turkey into a garb*ge dump that had nothing better to do than k1ll1ng kurds. He set turkey up for being exploited and couped for decades by foreign powers. Erdogan took this tr*sh that ata turk left behind and turned Turkey into the second most powerful country in NATO after the United States. Now turkey has a GDP well over $900B thanks to Erdogan. Turkey has the largest land army in Europe, larger than the rest of Europe combined excluding Russia. That means turkey makes up over 30% of NATO’s combat power, while the US makes up 55% of NATO’s fire power and the rest of NATO, dozens of countries combined accounts for about 15% 🤣🤣 turkey doesn’t even spend the 2% GDP requirement on its military and yet its military budget is larger than the entire economy of Lithuania. You can talk all the cr*p you want, but numbers are reality and ur secul*r ideological fanaticism is just del*sional.
He is the best leader of the world.He was a soldier , he was a president , he was a teacher , he was a writer . He is the father of the Turks !! He was the savior of the great nation !! YAŞA MUSTAFA KEMAL PAŞA YAŞA ADIN YAZILACAK MÜCEVHER TAŞA !!!!!
ATATÜRK was a genius person with knowledge far ahead of his time. He was a Great Soldier, a Great Leader, a great thinker. Unfortunately, the Turks will not have such a leader again.
I have a lot of love and respect for Ataturk from Pakistan, he was a great military and state leader who lead Türkiye to greatness. I wish my country could have a leader like him. 🇵🇰🩷🇹🇷
@@PakNationalist-xy4in That is the exact reason why you'll never grow like TUrkey nor will u have Ataturk like people. Religion keep u in the dark age.
I admired him, the moderniser he turned the Hagia Sofia into a museum so there would be no arguments. It was after all a Orthodox Christian Cathedral built between 532 snd 537well before Islam started. There was no need for Erdogan to turn it back in to a Mosque. There are over 3000 Mosques in Istanbul. One thing I can say is that no mosques were turned into churches under the British Empire
Ataturk was not Jewish. His father's mother (gradmother) was of Albanian origin, grandfather was a Yoruk Turk. You only inserted the term "Jewish" because you want to make a your propaganda.
At this stage, this channel has covered the same person and the topic for the umpteenth time. Could you please make videos about other region or events? For example, you never covered the Malaysian/Indonesian history or Bengal history. Perhaps Islam in countries like Mali or Mauritania would be interesting to talk about.
@@User38514 That's not a really a good argument, is it? As a viewer, you are supposed to give useful feedbacks, regardless of your capability to create video content or not. If such was the case, people wouldn't even bother enjoying watching videos or content creators simply would make video for other content creators and not for the general audience. Same can be said for criticising films, shows or sport players. One doesn't have to be experienced in these fields just to criticise.
I don't see that as a complaint. It's constructive input and a suggestion which I'm sure any reasonable person would agree with. Not sure why the childish attitude from above commenters. "Do it urself"... what a genius you are.
Wow... This was VERY WELL done. I am going to watch pretty much every video you've posted because of seeing this one. Just gotta say, Thank You for the history lessons. I'm an avid consumer of News and History because it all has relevance to today's geopolitical conflicts and regional sentiments. The Ottomans left a HUGE mark on history. The decisions of European Powers on what to do with the former Empire's territories has had a lasting effect to this day and will continue on for quite a while. Today I was searching for info on the history of Gaza and, of course, one can not escape the massive role of the British/French on the Levant and how their decisions set the stage for the events that just took place in the past 2 days. It's fucking sad that the Israelis basically discount the 1900 or so years of regional history that's occurred since the destruction of Jerusalem by the Romans. The Jews essentially fled the region and their former neighbors moved in. It's been THEIR land for centuries, almost 2 millenia! Talk about selfishness.... I don't believe that there's another example in human history where a group of people returns to their ancestral homeland after hundreds & hundreds of years to then perpetrate upon the local populace the horrors of what they themselves fled... The Israelis are quite forgetful or they're just living in cognitive dissonance to the extreme. Ugh... but back to THIS VIDEO. GREAT JOB! Loved every second of it. You had my devoted attention from the first minute. Lastly, just wanted to say that your outtro was absolutely HILARIOUS.... PEEEEEEEEEEACE!
OMG! broooo you just gave my brain a orgy 😂 im so happy there a people out there that actually have a god damn clue of what they are talking about!!!! Your an absolute legend!!! The name palestine was given by the Romans 😂😂 people are just so ignorant it makes me want to burn the world. We muslims are not antisemitic but for this precise reason you pointed out we hate the israili citizens and government. I can now sleep in peace. Thank you.
i think you might be thinking of esau in the bible. current jews are not the Israelites of the bible. israelites were removed by assyria way before. exciting pieces this mess altogether. recently was an vid on how the arab royals say they are brothers with israel. once again that would be esau and ishmael in the bible. freaking fascinating how its all coming together. hey read act 11:26 if the jews are judah they should be christian. lol also, they mixed there race which upset rebecka esau's mother. europeans are the only ones who fight to keep there blood clean and pure. this is amazing. its called blood poisoning.
Father of the Turks was Greco-Macedonian, with an Arabic first and second name (Mustafa and Kemal/Kamal)*, and an Arabic title, Ghazi. Turkey is a made-up nation, most of the ‘Turks’ are just Anatolians, Levantines, mixed in with HUGE Balkan contribution in the North due to the 7 million Muslim Balkanites who fled to Turkey after the collapse of the Ottoman Empire, and with some Armenian and Kurdish too. The Turkic makeup is near nonexistent in the modern “Turkish” population. It’s why the original Turks looked rather Mongoloid in the surviving paintings from the Abbasid Empire.
“The religion of the Arabs destroyed the Turks” The Turks were a great nation before they accepted the religion of the Arabs. After accepting the Arab religion, the national bonds of the Turkish nation loosened; national feelings and excitement matched. This was very natural. Because the purpose of the religion founded by Muhammad was to be in the politics of an Arab nation, above all nationalities. M. Kemal Source: Marital Information and Atatürk's Manuscripts, Afet Inan, Turkish Historical Society Press, Ankara 1969, pp 364-365
@@blacksheep6174Pakistan is grate cuntry. First Muslim cuntry to have Islamic Atom bomb, ask why Allah blessed only Pakistan with atomic bomb and not Toorki... but Toorki our fraand cuntry, and brather. Erdogan zindabaad, Toorki Zindabad, dont say bad on Pakistan. We have bad time now, but Allah will bring to top again, that time we see .
Indian muslims cared a lot about the caliphate......they cared so much that they rioted against the British when brits destroyed the ottomans.....and than killed fellow Hindus for some reason......like you hate the brits why kill hindus for it?....extremist morons turks didn't give 2 shits about indian muslims
Atatürk was a man so great in his achievements, even today most people fail to fathom what he did for his countrymen, for the women, for turkey's future and independence.
@@starcapture3040 women didnt have any voting rights and even after becoming widows didnt have any rights when becoming widows (regarding the last will). Turkish women got thr right to vote, right to divorce, multiple wifes were forbidden, they werent treated like Cattle anymore
@@bmyt4249 there was no voting rights it was a bloody dictatorship. women as men have had useless vote. RIGHT TO DIVORCE? ok this is faction! under his new copy past constitution From the Swiss Code, a constitution inspired by Christianity, women in Turkey were banned from asking for divorce, along with banning polygamy. Under Islamic law, women have had the right to divorce their men since the 600s AD. If you're going to defend your dictator, you better not create factional history.
@@Sa7biUKI am Turkmen on my father's side and Circassian on my mother's side. In addition, everyone born in this country is Turkish, regardless of their origins. Many of our citizens of Kurdish origin became martyrs for this country.
TÜRKIYE is 98% Muslim, maybe you are that 2% i think. Its no problem that you are not religious, that's your choice, but give some respect for the people that are religious, and don't lie please.
Look up the history of the painting "The Tortoise Trainer". It was meant to be a satire of the futility of reunification of the Ottoman Empire. Wikipedia has the best description.
he is not as a radical as they make him appear, i see where he's coming from after witnessing the stagnation and decline of the ottoman empire and he wanted to form a unified nation but instead it resulted in him creating a racist ideology that places the turks above everyone including europeans that he took as an inspiration
Anyone who has good intentions for TÜRKIYE is important for us TURKS, whether it is ATATÜRK or ERDOĞAN, but there is no place in TÜRKIYE for traitors or terrorists. But 1 thing is the most important for the TURKS in TÜRKIYE and TURKS over all the world and that thing is : ISLAM 🤲🏽 So respect each other and don't judge people based on race, religion or skin color.
"Atatürk and the New Turkey were constant reference points for the Nazis as part of their own biography, AS AN EXAMPLE of the perfect Führer story, and as examples of völkisch “good practice” in a variety of aspects" Ihrig, 2014, p. 145: "Atatürk in the Nazi Imagination - Stefan Ihrig | Harvard University Press".
Ataturk was a great patriot, he loved his country and his people. He spearheaded a nationlist movement which ended and resulted with an independent Turkiye. He modernized Turkiye and its people, he gave us modern education, secularism, national identity, human rights, a place in the modern world. Ataturk haters are all islamic fundamentalists or ethnical separatists. There have always been those traitors who hated Ataturks reforms as they wanted Turkiye remain as a religious , backward country. But the majority of the Turkish nation understands the meaning of those reforms, appreciate the mentality of real Kemalism and know that we own our existance as a sovereign nation to Ataturk and his friends. We will always remember him as the saviour of Turkish people and the creator of the Republic of Turkiye.
Oppression, Dictatorship,Tyranny Forced displacement of the Armenians didn’t he also hang religious figures for not wearing a Jewish hat? Ohhh 😂 he was hay ahead of his time with lgbtq 🏳️🌈 by the way read his wife’s memoir’s
This video was really eye-opening. I live in Europe, and we have a large Turkish minority. Some of them came in the 50's 60's to help with a labour shortage. I knew that there was once the Ottoman empire, and that we now have several nation states on former Ottoman soil. But I never understood the nuances about Turkey, especially about religion; I was always puzzled about the religious and cultural identity of Turkey. This video really made everything click for me!
In spite of the fact that Ataturk may be regarded as a hero by some, the fact of the matter is that when he advocated for western reforms with the Ottomans, such hero worship and reforms on his part appear to have only succeeded in esagerbate further future reactionary movements in the future. There is a truth that is often overlooked, and that is the fact that the Turks did not appear to regard the Arabs as being on an equal footing with them. Instead, they only advocated for western reforms, which ultimately resulted in the creation of competition among themselves. The Palisiltinians were never able to be successfully governed by them throughout the entirety of their history. fascist indealism and fought against ethnic minorities that had been located there prior to the rise of the fascist and radical movements.
Turks came from Asia, they had clear Asian features, geneticaly this man does not look Asian, most of the people living in Turkey, they dont look Asian, they adopted Turkish culture and they call themselves Turks, but they are not direct descendants of Turks that came from Asia.
Sorunun ne? 🤣 Türkiyede milyonlarca Arnavut var. Binlerce de melez. Benim arkadaşımın kayınvalidesi Arnavut. Arkadaşım doğuracak. Arkadaşımda Bulgar türkü.. Çocuk Türk, Bulgar, Arnavut melezi.. Biz takılmıyoruz size ne oluyor. Mehmet Akif in babası Arnavut, annesi özbekti. O en büyük şairlerimizden biri.Pekçok sanatçımızın anne yada babası Arnavut yada Boşnak. Biz karışıp güzellikler doğurmayı seçtik.Örnek İbonun babası Arap, anne Pomak Bulgar.. Emre beyin annesi Türk, baba Arnavut. Barış arduçun baba Arnavut, anne laz.. Kıvanç Arnavut Boşnak, Türk melezi.. Siz güldürüyorsunuz.Başkan Gürcü, hanımı Arap.. Bunlar bizler için boş şeyler. Milletimiz önemli olan.
“The religion of the Arabs destroyed the Turks” The Turks were a great nation before they accepted the religion of the Arabs. After accepting the Arab religion, the national bonds of the Turkish nation loosened; national feelings and excitement matched. This was very natural. Because the purpose of the religion founded by Muhammad was to be in the politics of an Arab nation, above all nationalities. M. Kemal Source: Marital Information and Atatürk's Manuscripts, Afet Inan, Turkish Historical Society Press, Ankara 1969, pp 364-365
If you mean those Turks who worshipped nature which itself is created then definitely not. The nature of nationalism is extreme glorification of ones ancestors. It is something irrational and has no basis in reality. Islam offers guidance to mankind regardless of race, ethnicity, etc Kemalism offers secularism to the Turks.
mentioning the fire in izmir while ignoring greeks countless atrocities, rapes, murders, putting whole innocent villagers in mosques naked and burning it etc. not mentioned. these are known from greek soldiers own letters. but it doesnt matter, we are a proud nation, never cried of any genocide carried out towards us. never gonna happen either. long live turks, rest in peace to our heroic ancestors. we will be united at the precence of allah one day. insallah
City of bilecik where the ottoman empire was founded was burned 3 times by the greeks, city of aydin was totally destroyed and burned down by them and ofcourse izmir.
@@Wonderhorse9006Osmanlı güçlü falan değildi daha kendi mısır valisi Mehmet Ali paşaya 2 kere savaşta kaybeden devletti İngilizler olmasa Osmanlı 1850lerde yikilicakti
@@GrigRP i mean all of humanity. imagine wanting to live in a dictactorship. i pity the muslim because they have to believe in a rotting 7 century religion.just because their ancestor have too also, if this caliphate so good. why no muslim try to revive it? oh i forgot. isis did. the world most famous terrorist group
"Greece and Turkey had realized that the two groups could not longer live together in cooperation" did they? I wonder if the GENOCIDE OF MILLIONS OF ARMENIANS, GREEKS AND OTHER MINORITIES HAD A PART TO PLAY IN THAT REALIZATION
2 Million Balkan Turks were driven out from their home by Balkan Christians during and after the Balkan Wars, and another million were murdered by the same people. That's when we realized Greeks and other Christians wanted nothing else than murdering us. This is exactly why. But of course you'd turn a blind eye when it is our people who were murdered wouldn't you, hypocrite?
It was the turkish sunni tradition that was brought by the republic and atatürk, which carried out pogroms and mass killings. he was also the one who later had the pashas, who were responsible for the armenian genocide, released from prison. by abstracting turkey's bourgeois revolution from its historicity and mythologizing it under the names of particulars, what ideology do you think is responsible for producing the dichotomy between ottoman pasha and republican revolutionary? dont even look at which ideology is the foundational element behind this production....
He was gay & had many young 15 - 21 year old lovers. He liked them very young, virile & that's being a deranged Pedophile. That's why he never married & there's actual facts about his life that prove this. It was a very well known fact among his friends & the wealthy people, families, he socialised with in the palace.
At the end of M. Kemal's speech to the Assembly on November 1, 1937; However, these principles should never be equated with the dogmas of books supposedly descended from heaven. We have taken our inspirations directly from life, not from the sky and the unseen”[1], with lengthy explanations and no objections, in an article we shared before, that what we mean by the expression "books thought to have descended from the sky" is "divine books" like the Qur'an. We have proved it in a way that leaves no room. For this reason, we do not consider it necessary to repeat them all here now. We will only be content to share "additional information" here. After reading this article, those who wish can click on the link we have added to the resource no. [2] in the "Resources" section and read the article in question.
The steel-colored brightness of [his] eyes shines out of the warrior-like, sunburned brown of [his] face with an uncanny, captivating power. Eyes, within which the supple power and the ruthless will of self-assertion of the Turanian grey wolf twin- kles." Be it Aryan, Turanian, or even Mongolian, or, again perhaps obviously, Prussian-when, in the narratives, Atatürk meets the Kai- ser, Hindenburg, and Ludendorff in 1917-what his appearance and actions reaffirmed was the awakening and the "triumph of race." Schopen concluded: He is nothing less than the incarnation of all warrior-like na- tions. The Turk is, in his moral qualities, one of the best sol- diers of the world. For him the victorious military Führer stands above everything else. And Mustafa Kemal, mathematician and carrier of soldier blood from his father's line, was a genius of the strategic idea."7 For most of these texts, Atatürk was the ultimate warrior-"battle was his nature."+ Froembgen described him as "a thunderstorm turned man." Melzig said in his Atatürk biography: "In him a he- roic spirit rose to the light from the depth of thousands of years." Froembgen also stressed, "He is a soldier the like of which seldom comes along." Atatürk's prowess in battle was stressed time and again: "The soldiers hesitated to throw themselves into the rain of death. Mustafa Kemal knows, here no order will be enough, here one needs to be a role model, to be a Führer."52 The Führer as a role model for everybody-in battle, for the Turkish farmer with his model farm, but also for the ordinary Turk, when it comes to demeanor, dress, and indeed everything-was a constant theme of these texts.53 Descriptions of Atatürk's aura elevated him to messianistic levels. With his deeds at Gallipoli during World War I, Atatürk emerges in these narratives not only as the imminent savior of Constantino- ple but as a transcendental "savior." Indeed, the formula "savior and Führer" was frequently put forward by some texts. Some stressed that one could feel a special aura, "a magic circle," in his presence he was "the chosen one."
Ataturk rolling on his grave while erdogan undoing great things he did for turkey. From 1st world to 3rd world country its amazing in less than a decade.😂
🤡🤡 ata turk left turkey with a gdp of $20B which is equivalent to the GDP of Afghanistan back in 2020 during a war 🤣 he turned turkey into a garbage dump that had nothing better to do than killing kurds. He set turkey up for being exploited and couped for decades by foreign powers. Erdogan took this trash that ata turk left behind and turned Turkey into the second most powerful country in NATO after the United States. Now turkey has a GDP well over $900B thanks to Erdogan. Turkey has the largest land army in Europe, larger than the rest of Europe combined excluding Russia. That means turkey makes up over 30% of NATO’s combat power, while the US makes up 55% of NATO’s fire power and the rest of NATO, dozens of countries combined accounts for about 15% 🤣🤣 turkey doesn’t even spend the 2% GDP requirement on its military and yet its military budget is larger than the entire economy of Lithuania. You can talk all the crap you want, but numbers are reality and ur secular ideological fanaticism is just delusional.
🤡🤡 ata turk left turkey with a gdp of $20B which is equivalent to the GDP of Afghanistan back in 2020 during a war 🤣 he turned turkey into a garb*ge dump that had nothing better to do than k1ll1ng kurds. He set turkey up for being exploited and couped for decades by foreign powers. Erdogan took this tr*sh that ata turk left behind and turned Turkey into the second most powerful country in NATO after the United States. Now turkey has a GDP well over $900B thanks to Erdogan. Turkey has the largest land army in Europe, larger than the rest of Europe combined excluding Russia. That means turkey makes up over 30% of NATO’s combat power, while the US makes up 55% of NATO’s fire power and the rest of NATO, dozens of countries combined accounts for about 15% 🤣🤣 turkey doesn’t even spend the 2% GDP requirement on its military and yet its military budget is larger than the entire economy of Lithuania. You can talk all the cr*p you want, but numbers are reality and ur secul*r ideological fanaticism is just del*sional.
He is the only one leader in the World faught 5 Wars against 7 nations and managed importent reforms of a whole country maked him immortel. Even his Enemies treatet him with respect and recognition
Ataturk is ome of my favorite figures and definately favorite politician. If it wasn't for him, Turkey would now be something like Afganistan or other sad Muslim countries. I hope that Erdogan is not able to undo all of that
🤡🤡 ata turk left turkey with a gdp of $20B which is equivalent to the GDP of Afghanistan back in 2020 during a war 🤣 he turned turkey into a garb*ge dump that had nothing better to do than k1ll1ng kurds. He set turkey up for being exploited and couped for decades by foreign powers. Erdogan took this tr*sh that ata turk left behind and turned Turkey into the second most powerful country in NATO after the United States. Now turkey has a GDP well over $900B thanks to Erdogan. Turkey has the largest land army in Europe, larger than the rest of Europe combined excluding Russia. That means turkey makes up over 30% of NATO’s combat power, while the US makes up 55% of NATO’s fire power and the rest of NATO, dozens of countries combined accounts for about 15% 🤣🤣 turkey doesn’t even spend the 2% GDP requirement on its military and yet its military budget is larger than the entire economy of Lithuania. You can talk all the cr*p you want, but numbers are reality and ur secul*r ideological fanaticism is just del*sional.
I am a believing muslim (may Allah accept my deeds) and also very fond of Atatürk who saved and shaped a whole nation. So, you can be both imo.. Whoever is against him is a traitor, which, many are. Unfortunetaly...
Âl-i İmrân / 33. Ayet meali اِنَّ اللّٰهَ اصْطَفٰٓى اٰدَمَ وَنُوحًا وَاٰلَ اِبْرٰه۪يمَ وَاٰلَ عِمْرٰنَ عَلَى الْعَالَم۪ينَۙ Muhakkak ki Allah Âdem’i, Nûh’u, İbrâhim âilesini ve İmrân âilesini tertemiz bir hülâsa hâlinde seçip bütün insanlık üzerine üstün kılmıştır. Bakara / 119. Ayet اِنَّٓا اَرْسَلْنَاكَ بِالْحَقِّ بَش۪يرًا وَنَذ۪يرًاۙ وَلَا تُسْـَٔلُ عَنْ اَصْحَابِ الْجَح۪يمِ Rasûlüm! Biz seni, insanları hem müjdelemen hem de uyarman için hak din ile gönderdik. Sen vazîfeni hakkıyle yapıyorsun; dolayısıyla cehennemlik olanlardan sorumlu tutulacak değilsin! Bakara / 281. Ayet وَاتَّقُوا يَوْماً تُرْجَعُونَ فٖيهِ اِلَى اللّٰهِ ثُمَّ تُوَفّٰى كُلُّ نَفْسٍ مَا كَسَبَتْ وَهُمْ لَا يُظْلَمُونَࣖ ﴿٢٨١﴾ Bir günden sakının ki, onda Allah’a döndürüleceksiniz, sonra herkese hak ettiği tam olarak verilecek ve onlara haksızlık edilmeyecektir. En'âm / 21. Ayet وَمَنْ اَظْلَمُ مِمَّنِ افْتَرٰى عَلَى اللّٰهِ كَذِبًا اَوْ كَذَّبَ بِاٰيَاتِه۪ۜ اِنَّهُ لَا يُفْلِحُ الظَّالِمُونَ Allah hakkında yalan uyduran veya O’nun âyetlerini yalanlayandan daha zâlim kim olabilir? Şüphe yok ki zâlimler kurtuluşa eremezler. ua-cam.com/video/RfEQkWTnmDM/v-deo.html
Do you think Ataturk was a net positive or a net negative for Turkey?
For more modern history: ua-cam.com/play/PLiPhmAD3I2Jz6goEJlQ1zh6KkbeBWZ2pP.html
Ataturk was great
@@plataoplomo9096 only for evicting the Europeans
It's really hard to say his impact is huge and if he lived longer it maybe even bigger for me I think he was in negative to the culture but at the same time he was the one who liberated turkey although I don't like him personally I won't say he wasn't bad all along
seems like one of those rare "enlightened despot" types who was able to will things into existence. seems more on par with Washington than Napoleon in that sense.
I think his legacy is complicated. If the rumours are true and the ottomans were prepared to give up Istanbul. Then definitely a net positive after a while lot cultural treachery and inferiority complex and bizarrely racial supremacism
He didn’t embraced western values he embraced modernism which came from collective human civilization
Kinda difficult to separate modernism from its context (Europe), regardless of its homogenising implications.
@@HikmaHistory It just so happened that europe modernised first, because it was the most dominant power at the time and still is. Perhaps, modernity would have been a natural progression for other countries too, if they had followed a similar and successful path to world domination if they were so inclined, or if their civilisational development and evolution hadnt been interrupted by european colonial expansion...who knows? Whatever may be the case, the so called 'western' values of democracy, freedom, open society etc, are not the exclusive preserve of one section of humanity. These ideals belong to us all, and are things we should all strive towards as a common heritage of collective human advancement and progress.
@@HikmaHistory what ? no, moderniziation isn't a europeon thing it was lead by europe.
Same way the golden age of islam wasnt a golden age of islam. Just colonizers inheriting the already existing knowledge and expanding on it. We are all standing on the shoulders of giants.
Praise to the ones before!
You're funny! 😂
@@HikmaHistory modernism is just codeword for colonialism. People in Türkiye dont like mustafa kemal because he brought colonialisr values to Türkiye and sold out Ottoman muslim culture
Religion is not important in Turkey. Most Turks prefer a secular lifestyle. The rise of Erdogan isn't because of religion. It's because of his political charisma. He will eventually be forgotten, but Ataturk will live on as long as the nation does.
Secularism is ❤ good for all countries.
Exactly.!
Why will Erdogan be forgotten ?
He managed Turkey to make a own car TOG.
Ataturk saved the righteous.
Numerous coups did happen in Turkey after Ataturk.
Erdogan survived a coup.
He does not misbehave.
Did you see how they did put Morsi in jail.
Or Imran Khan ?
Erdogan won't be forgotten.
You will be forgotten.
You will die alone and awaken again alone and shall see nothing of this World again a new life.
But you shall stay interested in whether Erdogan be forgotten or not.
I shall also die and wake up new and I'm also interested like you are.
Pan ISLAMISIM ☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️.
@@umaraziz8274f. Ck your Islam
We Koreans envy Ataturk.
He is a great leader like something out of a novel or movie.
It's funny how Islamists go out of their way to criticize such a great leader.
Thank you brother. Love korea❤
We love Korea, our ancient allies against the chinese.
Islamists believe in a religion with a pedo and incest prophet. Their words mean nothing
Do you know why? It's because he tried getting rid of some fundamental Islamic principles, a few examples being the Arabic azan getting banned, allowing women to wear mini skirts, and the suppression of the Kurdish people and their culture and language.
@@everythingerina9379 kurdish people tried to backstab turks just like arabs did. Check out the treaty of Sevres. Azan wasn't banned, it was translated to turkish since it calls turkish people to prayer. No one was forced to wear miniskirts. You probably are referring to the new dress codes implemented at that time. Which only prohibits all religious attire for government officials. No civillians were forced to change any dress codes.
You are classic muslim who gets offended when you can't enforce your pedo-incest bedouin rules on people.
He was a genoicidal pest, you Koreans love slavery and had one of the longest slave practices, ofcourse you would love Ataturk
Ataturk is one of the most important geniuses of the last century. Turkish youth is grateful to him. He brought the ruined country on the edge of the abyss to the brink of civilization. Even if we die one day, the names of our heroes like Atatürk will always live on. How happy is the one who says I am a Turk!
senin Allahina kurban Berat kardes.
father of lies and first fascist dictatorship in history. he was the lowest of the low of the last century. the personality cult of Mustafa Kemal the drunk in uneducated turkey is not taken for a second seriously all around the world.
I FULL HEARTEDLY AGREE WITH YOUR STATEMENT.
Me also Mustafa Kemal Ataturk 4 ever
I'm a Brit, living in Turkey for 7 years, married to a Turk. I've been here through two elections and I would argue that the hero worship of Atatürk (whom I do respect greatly) is actually holding back the Turkish left.
It is almost impossible to have a discussion about Atatürk without it being taken very personally. Atatürk is viewed as being almost unquestionably perfect, but at the same time he is presented as being many different things to many different people. Atheists believe that his personal letters show he was an atheist, secular Muslims believe his speeches show he was a secular Muslim and Conservative Muslims believe his actions show that he was a dictator. He has become a myth, and believing a myth, especially one so recent, becomes disempowering. If a myth created the nation, then "we" cannot change the nation and must simply wait for the next mythological character to come along.
The Turkish left is obsessed with going back to a past (one that never really existed because Atatürk never truly realised his vision, it was being pulled apart while he still lived and was dead 5 years after his death).
I reiterate, Atatürk was a remarkable man, that achieved incredible things that no other did in this period. But, he was human, flawed, complex, and often wrong. If we don't deal with this and still view him as the myth, then we can't move forward. Turkey will never retake it's place as one of the most important pieces of land in the world, unless it starts to look to the future rather than fantasising about the past.
Kemal Ataturk defeated Greece, Armenia, France, Britain and there colonies like French Algeria, British India along with radical Muslims who were funded by Britain. He later created modern Turkey and Turkish people are grateful for all the reforms and his great vision. Kemal inspires us even today.
Chp propaganda
@@starcapture3040This is not CHP propaganda, this is Arab Bedouin. This is history and everyone knows it, Arabs don't because you are Arabs.
EXCELLENT SUMMARY OF ATATURK
@@sibelshinaishin5170 ataput must be hated and so all bloody dictators. i don't cherry-pick like you.
@@starcapture3040 greek haha
I need to right a wrong. Ataturk's father was not ethnically Slavic or Albanian. This nonsense is just disinformation created on Wikipedia. Atatürk's father and mother were both Yoruk. Do a search on what Yoruk means.
Thats true 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Ok then what was his grand parents name ?
@@m.mozdemir Ne diyosun pampa? Ne saçmalıyorsun. Annenesi ve dedesinin ismini ne yapıcaksın?
Only 1 thing is certain, Turks came from Asia, they had clear Asian features, geneticaly this man does not look Asian, most of the people living in Turkey, they dont look Asian, they adopted Turkish culture and they call themselves Turks, but they are not direct descendants of Turks that came from Asia.
He was Macedonian. Plus, the Turkic makeup is near nonexistent in the modern “Turkish” population anyway. The original Turks all looked rather Mongoloid in the surviving paintings from the Byzantine and even Abbasid Empire.
So many negative comments about Ataturk by Turks in here but they seem to forget that Turkey would not exist without him.
Most Turks like him
The turks that do hate him are religious zealots who hate to think.
@@hasinabegum1038no we dont
Yes we do and feel we owe him.
@@yusufardagures5490fikirlerin kimsenin umrunda değil sik kırığı.
Kabul et ya da etme ülkenin büyük çoğunluğu Atatürk'ü sever.
Please don’t mis inform people that he was Jewish. He was of a Türkmen background. He had shut down the Masonic establishments. He believed in Islam and his Turkic culture and was very proud of it. He converted the Kuran into Turkish because his people didn’t speak or understand Arabic so he wanted them to know their wholly book and learn and respect its values. During the Ottoman rule less then 10% of the people knew how to read and write but after him majority knew. He was truly a genius and way ahead of his time. We as Turks were very fortunate and even the descendants of the Sultans admitted that if he had not existed Turkiye would not have existed today.
He was not Jewish. He was a full blooded Türk.
What the f. How can someone be so falsely informed bro
@@meltemOz65 arablar beğenmedikleri herkese yahudi diyorlar. Bunu da bilerek yapıyorlar.
adamı şikayet etmeliyiz ya bunun bütün videolarında böyle!
@@B13.B13 Arkadaş ya benim yorumlarım niye siliniyor. Bu arapların geneli böyle düşünüyor.
Atatürk was a great mind weak minds could not understand❤
Check those who disrespect Atatürk on the comments. All of them has Arabic names.
Islamists hate this guy just because he protected the turkish culture and didn't arabize it.
many people like me hate him because he contributed to the millions of greeks, armenians and assyrians murdered
@@idontexist1155facts
@@idontexist1155I also do not like him. He killed more than 200.000 of Greeks and Armenians and he is a butcher. To be more exact nobody in greece and armenia likes him.
@@idontexist1155Muslims*
He is a visionary and far ahead of his time
🤘🐺
Ataturk was an alpha leader. Regards from the USA
i've been studying the Ottomans for over a year now. this was excellent. thanks so much
Glad it was helpful!
He was the opposite of an Ottoman
The only ones who dislike him are butthurt islamists (most who happen to not even be Turkish), thats how you know he did something right.
That or they were victims of his oppression(Armenians)
He really just seems like a self hating apostate and none of them have any idea what their religion is Anderson only assume things about it but none of them actually have understanding.
Besides, a religion has things to offer
A nationalist apostate has nothing to offer besides material, and even that isn't something they can guarantee
Everyone who doesn't support prostitution, alcohol, the destruction of gender norms and everything that follows it, hates Ataturk. Also those minorities that were persecuted by later Kemalists, like Kurds.
@@potassium3550Armenians were the oppresors
@@potassium3550lol he had nothing to do with armenian massacres you obviously don't have a clue of the period or what he did. 😂
Wow. That was well done. I would imagine a conversation with the Ataturk would be fascinating. With the benefit of hindsight it looks like when the Turks needed a hero they got one.
Thank you! What I'd give to have a convo with Ataturk!
Thanks, you are more perceptive than many.
Simply put, the most complete, greatest human being who ever lived. Unmatched as a military leader, statesman, and a visionary. In the short span of his adult life, defeated every major world power, recovered almost all of the heartland of his nation, and caught up with the hundreds of years of development that the empire had lagged behind, even surpassing the west in many ways. Truly achieving the impossible. We are ever grateful to him for restoring the forgotten dignity of our great nation.
Well said brother, Ne Mutlu Türküm Diyene!
Exactly.
Lmao absolutely shameless simping for a man who’s been dead for 100 years
YOU should know simping well. After all you make your living from it. But on the other hand we are grateful to a hero for the freedom we have and the dignity we enjoy. You wouldn’t understand such concepts.
@@sibelshinaishin5170 Your grandfather who died for your country is just as responsible for your dignity as Ataturk was. And Ataturk could not have given you your dignity if God did not give him victory. When was the last time you thanked God for your dignity instead of a man in a coffin?
Atatürk jew or not he never left his country nor his nation nor his people and that is why we love him. He was there when his country and nation needed him,his likes,his nation believed, followed him untill the end, they were Victorious in the end!.
He betrayed the country and destroyed islamic identity and abolished caliphate and forced WESTERN THOUGHT AND LIBERAL IDEALS ON TURKEY
Atatürk ve yahudilik ne alaka kardeşim yaptığın yoruma sokayım. Hayır ben yahudileri seven bir Türk olarak soruyorum. Ne alaka?
He is not jew idk why he said that but even ottoman papers his mom has konya descent and his that is a turk from albania which his family gpes there under politica of iskan
he fled the syrains front and then fled to Bulgaria lol had had no country he was British agent.
@starcapture3040 he was put Incharge of battle of gallipoli
Show me another leader in the world as great as Ataturk?
NE MUTLU TÜRK'ÜM DİYENE 🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷 BAŞBUĞ MUSTAFA KEMAL ATATÜRK 🙏🏻
erdogan
Mehmet, Sulaiman Murad mehmet 1, selim 1. All ottomans before 17s
Jesus Christ
Resepect to Atatürk Sir from India, Turks are very lucky that they got protected by this wnderful soul. Turks are different from the arabs ethnically. A own culture. Atatürk Sir protected his people from western as well arabic colianilism as they did it with Mother India. We wished we would have had such leaders as Atatürk Sir who protected us angainst Powers. He is selfless and beyond of Gods grace, Jai Atatürk!
Thank you so much for your work. Ataturk has always fascinated me and though obviously not perfect, seemed in a lot of ways like an aspirational beacon for this part of the world, though I'm sure others could and will dispute that. The time period you covered is also so rich in contrasts between the traditional past and oncoming modernity that it never ceases to boggle my mind. Understanding history is so important and your channel is a treasure. Thanks again!
Thank you for the lovely words!
he's just either a greek christian or a jew
Atascheiss was an animal
Fascists were also fascinated by Ataturk and Ataturk was pals with them, his genoicidal policies inspired fascists
@@seganteUp yours Traitor
Brother, thank you for making this documentary. I enjoyed how you presented the chronology and transition from the Ottoman Empire to the Turkish Republic. Though I want to elaborate on some "facts" you are presenting about Mustafa Kemal Atatürk that I found utmost disturbing. Have you had dived deeper in the history of the Turks (meaning not only the Ottoman Empire, but also those before, you would have discovered both parents of Mustafa Kemal (the mother more definite than his father) were from Turkish nomadic descent (Yörüks). In the history of Turkish Empires (Ottoman, Seljuks etc.) nomads were primarily moved/located to the edges of the empire, including to the newly conquered grounds. There is a wisdom behind this. Since the Ottoman Empire stretched out and held control over the Balkans and Greece for decades, the likelihood of Atatürk having nomadic roots is higher than having any other ethnic background. The quote on quote "fact" that Atatürk was a crypto-jew (Donmeh) is utterly false and tends to smear, most likely due to your opinion about his politics of seperating religion from the state. As you mention in the documentary, some people hate him because of this reason and find him to be a traitor to the Ottoman Empire and Islam. Then again, in Judaism the religious status (being a Jew) is passed on from generation to generation by mothers and the tribal designation by the father. In neither of these cases, factually, it can be confirmed that Atatürk has been Jewish.
We know his background, it has been made public with documents. His mother’s as well as his father’s. This campaign to make Atatürk a Villain is to conceal the Arab role and their cooperation with the British to bring down the Ottomans. Of course their outright ignorance as well.
This is all CHP Propaganda. he was no Turk at all. Turks could never have blue eyes and be white. if so then they wer Turkified not real Turks.
@@starcapture3040 Have you ever been to Türkiye, my friend? How can you cross out such a big and divers ethnic group by saying they cannot be white and have blue eyes. I am really sorry to have just read this.
@@KufluPeynir42 to call yourself father of the Turks then who claimed to be as such should be real Turk not Turkified donma Jew from Thessaloniki . real Turk must look like Uzbekistanis and turkmanstanis. blue eyed Turks don't exist. Mustafa Kemal was white so its hard to call him real Turk. actually the young Turk party that claimed to be turkest its majority weren't from Turkish background many jaws and Albanians and other ethnicities were in it. and that show why they had enmity with Islam and destroyed the ottoman state from within.
YOU ARE SO IGNORANT I AM SORRY WE RESPONDED TO YOU. LET ME FINISH WITH A TURKISH SAYING. IT URUR KERVAN YURUR.
2:15
his father's descend goes to Kocacık Turkmens which are living in Konya. Most likely, this family settled to macedonia during rise of Ottomans period.
2:34 his mother wanted to send mustafa to "mektep" not "medrese/madrasa". Medrese is islamic high school. Mektep is islamic elementary school. Mustafa was a child in that period so he wouldn't go medrese.
23:49 that's right, he held power by undemocratic ways. Look at this issue from this way: He has big ideals and aims that never achieveble with liberal democracy.
30:47 he left afterwards these exaggerated theories.
32:50 all those rebellions are not concerned about kurdish nationalism or kurdish separatism. They were feudal lords, so they didn't like modern turkish state. They rebelled because of this.
To be honest, one can be a feudal lord, an islamists and a Kurdish nationalist at the same time. A conflict has many roots.
I wouldn't be so sure to blame Kurdish separatism on feudalism. Let's not forget that after the martial law in 80s even the very identity of Kurd was suppressed, Kurdish was banned. Hell even Saddam didn't ban Kurdish. I don't believe in making an ethno-nationalist Kurdish state but the Turkish state has given much reason to the Kurds to revolt in the past.
@@johnxina5126 80 coup is extremely complicated issue. İ am not sure about past, but today, every kurd can use their language in Turkey. İt' s just not using in administrative or official institutions. For example, it's similar that you can't use arabic in French official instutitions or you can't use native american languages in USA. Every political group complains about 80 coup. Communists, islamists, liberals and kurdish separatists, everyone complains. We can' t hear any positive thing about this coup. İn fact, coup at least stopped right-left wing skirmishes and stabilized country until PKK terrorism rises again. And don't forget that kurds in iraq welcomed in Turkey after Saddam's oppressive policies. And additionally, if you hear news like "A Kurdish singer oppressed in Turkey JUST BECAUSE OF HE SANG İN KURDİSH." dont believe them. In fact, it was not wanted to sing in any language. İt' s not about Kurdish or Turkish. Even our people can believe such things.
@@hgkghkhgkgh8378 maybe yes but we are still not sure about are they really a kurdish nationalist.
Erdogan has big ideals and aims that never achievable with liberal democracy? it can work too.
As a Somali we have been taught by Wahhabi Arab fanatics that Mustafa was an infidel who changed Turkey to a non-muslim country. This documentary is really so informative about the founder of the Turkish nation. I feel ashamed that the arabs spread alot of lies against this man.
So much respect for the Turkish people and their leader Mr. MUSTAFA KAMAL. love and respect from Somalia❤❤
We Turks don't care about what other Muslim thinks about us being secular ve love secularism and will continue to love our national hero for centuries to come
Hopefully one day Somalia will get their own Ataturk and bring peace and prosperity to Somalia. Regards
He us fascist in modern day language and he put a superiority complex in the head of turks who committed crimes against kurds till this day , anyway the Wahhabist are the same and even worse , nothing will heal the region except going back to our shared culture in the past otherwise wars .
@@sametsamet-sr3nj
I am Muslim from India. I love Turkey and love Secularism. Live and let others live is my principle. Turkey is secular and that's why it is prosperous among other Muslim nations ❤
Would love to visit your country Turkey one day 🥰
@@sametsamet-sr3nj
Secularism means freedom and freedom is the path to development. Not regressive Theocracies which actually claim religious but are corrupt actually.
In fact, the retention of Istanbul within the boarders of Turkey was almost a miracle accomplished not only by Atatürk's military genius, but by Lenin's secret diplomacy too.
He wasn’t a military guinius as portrayed in the history books written by the Kemalist. For this guy to be able to destroy Turkey from within, the colonial powers had to make this theatrical set up to make a drunk military leader a hero. He did more harm to Turkey afterwards than physical military occupation. Did you ever ask yourself why Greek celebrate him more than the Turks. We will never forget his inferiority and submissiveness to the west and the years of tyranny, coups and poverty that followed fall of the caliphate at the hands of this unknown tyrant.
@@TheTruth-wj7fl he's the pinnacle of anti-colonialism and at the time for most Indian or even German nationalists an inspiration against those powers you mentioned and also being a real general having winning battles on his name for the Ottomans and the nationalist movement. Because of this Turkey had an unique stance during WW2 and the rest of the regional countries had no choice to join the allies or the axis powers because they had no choice in the matter. Furthermore nationalist sentiments or the cry for reforms weren't that uncommon also having coups. This strange backwards made up notion that somehow he's a spy for saving something that others tried to erase on the map is utter nonsense and has a political slander mentality. Also the real spy a real example is Thomas Edward Lawrence who helped the Arab revolt and has full credit in his achievements as well therefore gaining British dominance on the levant region. Not to mention that the Turks brought Islam further expanding it not the other way around as there's no Islamic identity or politcal movement and during the fall of the Ottomans poverty, instability, illiteracy, dividing factions, population decline was very well known and was drastically solved with an iron grip on his behalf wich is a huge feat even gaining respect from other nations on the political stage stopping further invasions into Anatolia. Even religion cannot stand in the way against the state wich is a cultural mindset of the Turks. The Ottomans were a part of the European community and had more interest in the Balkans and makes it also a part of Europe as well like the Greeks who are partly Eastern and Western (based on their history and location).
@@Lawliet_____ ultra-based :)
@@Ghjkoplokkp
Did the turks persecuted all the minorities ? The Arabs tried to fix but thr nationalistic egoistic turks wouldn't accept, now wonder everyone around you hate you
@@TheTruth-wj7flArabic ass pain’s talking 😁😎😁😎😆😆😆
ATATURK IS A GREAT LIDER !!!
Glider
@@mreast1000 Arab betrayal now it’s not important for Türkiye republic
10 NATO countries with modern armed forces:
1)United States
2)Turkey
3)France
4)Germany
5)Italy
6)United Kingdom
7)Greece
8)Spain
9)Poland
10)Romania
@@мишар8128yeah that second spot on the list is thanks to erdogan
Hey Hikma, could you provide a link to the sources you used for the video? I would love to learn more about this period of Turkish history
I would recommend the book Ataturk by Andrew Mango.
Gray Wolf book is the best in English
Ben Türküm ve Atatürk benim atam değildir! Atatürk Türk değildir. Benim atam Abdülhamid han 🇹🇷
Do you like turkish
As someone whose native language is Turkish (Azerbaijani), I can say that Ataturk is the most perfect man who ever lived in Türkiye.
Im glad i found your channel.
Always coming out with some 🔥 history lessons
More to come!
Some Pakistani tliban minded mulllahs hate Great brave VISIONARY MUSTAFA KAMAL ATATURK,but we common educated MUSLIMS love him, respect him.SECULARISM IS ALWAYS BETTER AS in a country different religious people live, moreover state government should be free from religion
he was likely of Jewish ancestry. I don't think he was a 'crypto Jew', meaning that in private he practiced Judaism, but it undoubtedly affected his belief in a more secular and modernized Turkey. The US/UK/EU enjoy teaching Muslims to entirely reject Judaism b/c they know that it's the opposite of the fanatical/face covering version of Islam that these governments support.
😂😂😂
Erdogan is more loved in beggar Pakistan than Turkey itself anyway
Go back to Mongolia buddy
Visited Turkey recently and was really fascinated seeing women behaving exactly like they would in the west. Never knew it was all Attaturk's doing. Great man!
Very important to know that he fought against to Western countries but he admired their education, law and technology. He wanted Turks to remember their own identity, culture and values, forget about Middle Eastern culture, and adopt Western education amd science system. That's why he was genius. Turks adopted Middle Eastern language and culture along with Islamic religion which was wrong. Ataturk had no problem with any religion, he just didn’t want ajy religion in the politics and government establishments which would bring equality.
Turks rules over Muslim world.
All your gibberish just proved Turks are dying for western validation or More like Worship West. They have nothing of their own - they want to adopt this or that. Somehow, They think their own faith - ideas - even language is inferior to their superior Western masters. Severe inferiority complex.
This topic for some reason concerns arabs. Idk but some arab states abandoned the ottomans and even fought the ottomans side by side with the britts. The caliph had no meaning in this period of time. The only people who cared were the anatolian people and muslims of east asia. I will never forget them. Many indian,pakistani and bengali muslims got executed by the british empire.
Turkiye without Ataturk is Iraq or Afghanistan Ataturk is an idea, it means the level of contemporary civilizations, it means science, art, human rights instead of bigoted religions and dogmatic religions. Even 100 years ago, Ataturk talked about the problems caused by religions and reactionism, but the Anatolian Turkish people did not understand him and the result was akp and The bigoted Anatolian people still send their children to sects and live far from civilization.!
❤❤❤
I hope your country can recover from islamism. I read that the Turkish youth are increasingly atheist. Hope that stays that way.
😂😂 kaffir
Turkey without ata turk would be a lot larger than what it is now. Whatever the case, Ata turk is the same type of terrorist as the ayatollahs of iran, except he is a secular terrorist. He has killed a lot more than Khomeini for sure
🤡🤡 ata turk left turkey with a gdp of $20B which is equivalent to the GDP of Afghanistan back in 2020 during a war 🤣 he turned turkey into a garb*ge dump that had nothing better to do than k1ll1ng kurds. He set turkey up for being exploited and couped for decades by foreign powers. Erdogan took this tr*sh that ata turk left behind and turned Turkey into the second most powerful country in NATO after the United States. Now turkey has a GDP well over $900B thanks to Erdogan. Turkey has the largest land army in Europe, larger than the rest of Europe combined excluding Russia. That means turkey makes up over 30% of NATO’s combat power, while the US makes up 55% of NATO’s fire power and the rest of NATO, dozens of countries combined accounts for about 15% 🤣🤣 turkey doesn’t even spend the 2% GDP requirement on its military and yet its military budget is larger than the entire economy of Lithuania. You can talk all the cr*p you want, but numbers are reality and ur secul*r ideological fanaticism is just del*sional.
Imagine what he would say today's Erdogan's Turkey.🤯
Of course, he would follow leader Erdogan❤
Excellent documentary 👋👋
Many thanks!
damn so many people hating on the man who literally made their nation
Turkish people love Ataturk,its the brainwshd ,tlibn minded Pakistani mulllahs who hate Great brave Mustafa Kamal
They are not a part of our nation, they are crypto-Arabs.
Funny how people are more keen on their temporary lives then their eternal ones after their deaths
Atam❤♾️
Ne mütlü Türküm diyene
He is the best leader of the world.He was a soldier , he was a president , he was a teacher , he was a writer . He is the father of the Turks !! He was the savior of the great nation !! YAŞA MUSTAFA KEMAL PAŞA YAŞA ADIN YAZILACAK MÜCEVHER TAŞA !!!!!
He was a Dönme Jew, he betrayed Islam. He was the devil, that‘s why they built two statues of him in Israel.
He was a Jew from Salonik
ATATÜRK was a genius person with knowledge far ahead of his time. He was a Great Soldier, a Great Leader, a great thinker. Unfortunately, the Turks will not have such a leader again.
I have a lot of love and respect for Ataturk from Pakistan, he was a great military and state leader who lead Türkiye to greatness. I wish my country could have a leader like him.
🇵🇰🩷🇹🇷
@user-lz9vl8mo1y I also prefer Islam over Pakistan. Religion comes first
@@PakNationalist-xy4innation over religion. Alwayd
@@PakNationalist-xy4in That is the exact reason why you'll never grow like TUrkey nor will u have Ataturk like people. Religion keep u in the dark age.
I admired him, the moderniser he turned the Hagia Sofia into a museum so there would be no arguments. It was after all a Orthodox Christian Cathedral built between 532 snd 537well before Islam started. There was no need for Erdogan to turn it back in to a Mosque. There are over 3000 Mosques in Istanbul. One thing I can say is that no mosques were turned into churches under the British Empire
Muslims love the old desecration, appropriation and conversion of other people's holy sites, churches and temples into mosques!
Ataturk was not Jewish. His father's mother (gradmother) was of Albanian origin, grandfather was a Yoruk Turk. You only inserted the term "Jewish" because you want to make a your propaganda.
I get why you are mad that he tell on Ataturk that he was a Jew, what is your opinion on actual Jews tho?
Bro he is as Jew as they get plain and simple we all know he was a jew
@@DhhSbsh-i3nIt's not jew bro stop spreading some islamist propaganda😂
At this stage, this channel has covered the same person and the topic for the umpteenth time. Could you please make videos about other region or events? For example, you never covered the Malaysian/Indonesian history or Bengal history. Perhaps Islam in countries like Mali or Mauritania would be interesting to talk about.
Why dont you do it urself?
@@User38514 That's not a really a good argument, is it? As a viewer, you are supposed to give useful feedbacks, regardless of your capability to create video content or not. If such was the case, people wouldn't even bother enjoying watching videos or content creators simply would make video for other content creators and not for the general audience. Same can be said for criticising films, shows or sport players. One doesn't have to be experienced in these fields just to criticise.
@@nabilalhami1681 yes
Why do you complain when you get to watch it for free?
I don't see that as a complaint. It's constructive input and a suggestion which I'm sure any reasonable person would agree with. Not sure why the childish attitude from above commenters. "Do it urself"... what a genius you are.
I prefer this longer and more detailed format. More like this please! 👏
You got it!
There are about 6hrs but in Turkish 😁
atatürk had already shelved the solar language theory after a few years. it is absurd to keep talking about it.
Wow... This was VERY WELL done. I am going to watch pretty much every video you've posted because of seeing this one. Just gotta say, Thank You for the history lessons. I'm an avid consumer of News and History because it all has relevance to today's geopolitical conflicts and regional sentiments. The Ottomans left a HUGE mark on history. The decisions of European Powers on what to do with the former Empire's territories has had a lasting effect to this day and will continue on for quite a while. Today I was searching for info on the history of Gaza and, of course, one can not escape the massive role of the British/French on the Levant and how their decisions set the stage for the events that just took place in the past 2 days.
It's fucking sad that the Israelis basically discount the 1900 or so years of regional history that's occurred since the destruction of Jerusalem by the Romans. The Jews essentially fled the region and their former neighbors moved in. It's been THEIR land for centuries, almost 2 millenia! Talk about selfishness.... I don't believe that there's another example in human history where a group of people returns to their ancestral homeland after hundreds & hundreds of years to then perpetrate upon the local populace the horrors of what they themselves fled... The Israelis are quite forgetful or they're just living in cognitive dissonance to the extreme. Ugh... but back to THIS VIDEO. GREAT JOB! Loved every second of it. You had my devoted attention from the first minute. Lastly, just wanted to say that your outtro was absolutely HILARIOUS....
PEEEEEEEEEEACE!
OMG! broooo you just gave my brain a orgy 😂 im so happy there a people out there that actually have a god damn clue of what they are talking about!!!! Your an absolute legend!!! The name palestine was given by the Romans 😂😂 people are just so ignorant it makes me want to burn the world. We muslims are not antisemitic but for this precise reason you pointed out we hate the israili citizens and government. I can now sleep in peace. Thank you.
i think you might be thinking of esau in the bible. current jews are not the Israelites of the bible. israelites were removed by assyria way before. exciting pieces this mess altogether. recently was an vid on how the arab royals say they are brothers with israel. once again that would be esau and ishmael in the bible. freaking fascinating how its all coming together. hey read act 11:26 if the jews are judah they should be christian. lol also, they mixed there race which upset rebecka esau's mother. europeans are the only ones who fight to keep there blood clean and pure. this is amazing. its called blood poisoning.
hikma history dropped and farid basharat won today it’s a good day
Eyyy! Appreciate the support
Father of the Turks was Greco-Macedonian, with an Arabic first and second name (Mustafa and Kemal/Kamal)*, and an Arabic title, Ghazi. Turkey is a made-up nation, most of the ‘Turks’ are just Anatolians, Levantines, mixed in with HUGE Balkan contribution in the North due to the 7 million Muslim Balkanites who fled to Turkey after the collapse of the Ottoman Empire, and with some Armenian and Kurdish too. The Turkic makeup is near nonexistent in the modern “Turkish” population. It’s why the original Turks looked rather Mongoloid in the surviving paintings from the Abbasid Empire.
As a Pakistani, I support six arrows and it must be implemented at all costs to survive.
First implement basic human right , common sense and civil in your country
“The religion of the Arabs destroyed the Turks”
The Turks were a great nation before they accepted the religion of the Arabs. After accepting the Arab religion, the national bonds of the Turkish nation loosened; national feelings and excitement matched. This was very natural. Because the purpose of the religion founded by Muhammad was to be in the politics of an Arab nation, above all nationalities. M. Kemal
Source: Marital Information and Atatürk's Manuscripts, Afet Inan, Turkish Historical Society Press, Ankara 1969, pp 364-365
@@yakupdemir5016
This is all nonsense they say but they can never explain why a Muslim is a brother of muslim
You should be worried about your country . Your army is commiting crimes against nation
@@blacksheep6174Pakistan is grate cuntry. First Muslim cuntry to have Islamic Atom bomb, ask why Allah blessed only Pakistan with atomic bomb and not Toorki... but Toorki our fraand cuntry, and brather. Erdogan zindabaad, Toorki Zindabad, dont say bad on Pakistan. We have bad time now, but Allah will bring to top again, that time we see .
Thanks for making this. I enjoy your work and I am grateful for it.
Glad you enjoy it!
Ataturk abolished the Ottoman Empire and proclaimed republic of turkey in 1924
No, it is 1923. You may be confusing it with the abolition of the caliphate.
@@numanbaran8607 made a mistake sorry 😔
@@muhammedjaseemshajeef6781 Bro it's all good we are all students of history
Indian muslims cared a lot about the caliphate......they cared so much that they rioted against the British when brits destroyed the ottomans.....and than killed fellow Hindus for some reason......like you hate the brits why kill hindus for it?....extremist morons turks didn't give 2 shits about indian muslims
Atatürk was a man so great in his achievements, even today most people fail to fathom what he did for his countrymen, for the women, for turkey's future and independence.
what did he do for women?
@@starcapture3040 women didnt have any voting rights and even after becoming widows didnt have any rights when becoming widows (regarding the last will).
Turkish women got thr right to vote, right to divorce, multiple wifes were forbidden, they werent treated like Cattle anymore
@@bmyt4249 there was no voting rights it was a bloody dictatorship. women as men have had useless vote. RIGHT TO DIVORCE? ok this is faction! under his new copy past constitution From the Swiss Code, a constitution inspired by Christianity, women in Turkey were banned from asking for divorce, along with banning polygamy. Under Islamic law, women have had the right to divorce their men since the 600s AD. If you're going to defend your dictator, you better not create factional history.
@@bmyt4249 How does the right to vote matter when you could only vote for Ataturk?
@@AttaBek1422 you are a very smart fella. Is presidency the only thing anyone can vote for?
Most of us are not even Muslims, I don't care about religion, the only important thing for me is Turkishness.
Says the guy with Pontic Greek, Armenian and Kurdish DNA
@@Sa7biUKTurkic≠Turkish
@@Sa7biUKI am Turkmen on my father's side and Circassian on my mother's side. In addition, everyone born in this country is Turkish, regardless of their origins. Many of our citizens of Kurdish origin became martyrs for this country.
TÜRKIYE is 98% Muslim, maybe you are that 2% i think.
Its no problem that you are not religious, that's your choice, but give some respect for the people that are religious, and don't lie please.
@@g-maestro45398% muslim background, not practising religion.
Superb documentary, clearly written and an excellent examination of Kemalism, wonderful video footage too!
Many thanks!
Look up the history of the painting "The Tortoise Trainer". It was meant to be a satire of the futility of reunification of the Ottoman Empire. Wikipedia has the best description.
I love that painting and its significance!
Incredible documentary.
Glad you liked it!
Atatürk ❤ 😊i am Bosnian American Muslim and I admire Atatük
he is not as a radical as they make him appear, i see where he's coming from after witnessing the stagnation and decline of the ottoman empire and he wanted to form a unified nation but instead it resulted in him creating a racist ideology that places the turks above everyone including europeans that he took as an inspiration
Not radical after massacring Kurds and banning their language lmao
Excellent summary at the end!
Thank you my man!
Anyone who has good intentions for TÜRKIYE is important for us TURKS, whether it is ATATÜRK or ERDOĞAN, but there is no place in TÜRKIYE for traitors or terrorists.
But 1 thing is the most important for the TURKS in TÜRKIYE and TURKS over all the world and that thing is :
ISLAM 🤲🏽
So respect each other and don't judge people based on race, religion or skin color.
Hate nationalist terror Turks who are traitors of Islam. Love Islamic Turks who are defenders of Islam.😊
"Atatürk and the New Turkey were constant reference points for the Nazis as part of their own biography, AS AN EXAMPLE of the perfect Führer story, and as examples of völkisch “good practice” in a variety of aspects"
Ihrig, 2014, p. 145: "Atatürk in the Nazi Imagination - Stefan Ihrig | Harvard University Press".
El CiD biography please make video
Ataturk was a great patriot, he loved his country and his people. He spearheaded a nationlist movement which ended and resulted with an independent Turkiye. He modernized Turkiye and its people, he gave us modern education, secularism, national identity, human rights, a place in the modern world. Ataturk haters are all islamic fundamentalists or ethnical separatists. There have always been those traitors who hated Ataturks reforms as they wanted Turkiye remain as a religious , backward country. But the majority of the Turkish nation understands the meaning of those reforms, appreciate the mentality of real Kemalism and know that we own our existance as a sovereign nation to Ataturk and his friends. We will always remember him as the saviour of Turkish people and the creator of the Republic of Turkiye.
One of the greatest men of the twentieth century , with much love and respect from Australia.
Oppression, Dictatorship,Tyranny Forced displacement of the Armenians didn’t he also hang religious figures for not wearing a Jewish hat? Ohhh 😂 he was hay ahead of his time with lgbtq 🏳️🌈 by the way read his wife’s memoir’s
This video was really eye-opening. I live in Europe, and we have a large Turkish minority. Some of them came in the 50's 60's to help with a labour shortage. I knew that there was once the Ottoman empire, and that we now have several nation states on former Ottoman soil. But I never understood the nuances about Turkey, especially about religion; I was always puzzled about the religious and cultural identity of Turkey. This video really made everything click for me!
Gran politico, puso a Turquía a la Altura de Europa. ❤
In spite of the fact that Ataturk may be regarded as a hero by some, the fact of the matter is that when he advocated for western reforms with the Ottomans, such hero worship and reforms on his part appear to have only succeeded in esagerbate further future reactionary movements in the future. There is a truth that is often overlooked, and that is the fact that the Turks did not appear to regard the Arabs as being on an equal footing with them. Instead, they only advocated for western reforms, which ultimately resulted in the creation of competition among themselves. The Palisiltinians were never able to be successfully governed by them throughout the entirety of their history. fascist indealism and fought against ethnic minorities that had been located there prior to the rise of the fascist and radical movements.
Incredible top notch content... Deserves more views
Turks came from Asia, they had clear Asian features, geneticaly this man does not look Asian, most of the people living in Turkey, they dont look Asian, they adopted Turkish culture and they call themselves Turks, but they are not direct descendants of Turks that came from Asia.
And I love him sooo much!! CUZZ hi was our daddy In turkey!! And I live in Denmark
But hi is still my lovely daddy !!
I mean our daddy !!!
Keep it up Hikma!
Thank you, will do!
El CiD Spain knight biography please make video
Albanian Father of Turks.
Sorunun ne? 🤣 Türkiyede milyonlarca Arnavut var. Binlerce de melez. Benim arkadaşımın kayınvalidesi Arnavut. Arkadaşım doğuracak. Arkadaşımda Bulgar türkü.. Çocuk Türk, Bulgar, Arnavut melezi.. Biz takılmıyoruz size ne oluyor. Mehmet Akif in babası Arnavut, annesi özbekti. O en büyük şairlerimizden biri.Pekçok sanatçımızın anne yada babası Arnavut yada Boşnak. Biz karışıp güzellikler doğurmayı seçtik.Örnek İbonun babası Arap, anne Pomak Bulgar.. Emre beyin annesi Türk, baba Arnavut. Barış arduçun baba Arnavut, anne laz.. Kıvanç Arnavut Boşnak, Türk melezi.. Siz güldürüyorsunuz.Başkan Gürcü, hanımı Arap.. Bunlar bizler için boş şeyler. Milletimiz önemli olan.
Genius, smart, honest and humanist...My beloved: ATATÜRK
w to ataturk. as a turkish muslim, we love him
“The religion of the Arabs destroyed the Turks”
The Turks were a great nation before they accepted the religion of the Arabs. After accepting the Arab religion, the national bonds of the Turkish nation loosened; national feelings and excitement matched. This was very natural. Because the purpose of the religion founded by Muhammad was to be in the politics of an Arab nation, above all nationalities. M. Kemal
Source: Marital Information and Atatürk's Manuscripts, Afet Inan, Turkish Historical Society Press, Ankara 1969, pp 364-365
That's why we defy him like many other Islamic Turks.
If you mean those Turks who worshipped nature which itself is created then definitely not.
The nature of nationalism is extreme glorification of ones ancestors. It is something irrational and has no basis in reality.
Islam offers guidance to mankind regardless of race, ethnicity, etc
Kemalism offers secularism to the Turks.
look at you now... converting churches into mosques. violating human rights. you guys got yourselfes the title of REZIL TURKLER
@@potassium3550well had it not been for kemamlism Turkey would be just another egypt
@@leaveme3559they were now things are change isn't it.?
mentioning the fire in izmir while ignoring greeks countless atrocities, rapes, murders, putting whole innocent villagers in mosques naked and burning it etc. not mentioned. these are known from greek soldiers own letters. but it doesnt matter, we are a proud nation, never cried of any genocide carried out towards us. never gonna happen either. long live turks, rest in peace to our heroic ancestors. we will be united at the precence of allah one day. insallah
WELL SAID.👏🏻
City of bilecik where the ottoman empire was founded was burned 3 times by the greeks, city of aydin was totally destroyed and burned down by them and ofcourse izmir.
You never cried because you knew it'd be shameless to whine over a slaughter your ancestors started.
Few visionaries have done as much for their country as Ataturk. As an American I find him unparalleled and extraordinary.
May the rise of the Ottoman Empire rule again.
We Turks have a saying, had the dog’s prayer been accepted there would be bones coming down the skies instead of the rain,i hope you get the idea.
@@sibelshinaishin5170Erdogan is making dogs out of kemalists. We will see who will cry for bones.
Amin
Im Turk, I wish Ottoman came back, we were the strongest Muslim empire in the world
@@Wonderhorse9006Osmanlı güçlü falan değildi daha kendi mısır valisi Mehmet Ali paşaya 2 kere savaşta kaybeden devletti İngilizler olmasa Osmanlı 1850lerde yikilicakti
13:55 are those on the right janissaries?
nope, by that time they were long gone history
If Ataturk would not exist, the Turks would have ended up like the Palestinians.
This is just attaturk book biography simplified
GIGACHAD ATATURK
he is a role model for us all.
and cringe caliphate. good for us all it didnt exist anymore
By "us" you mean "us paajeets" right?
@@GrigRP i mean all of humanity. imagine wanting to live in a dictactorship. i pity the muslim because they have to believe in a rotting 7 century religion.just because their ancestor have too
also, if this caliphate so good. why no muslim try to revive it?
oh i forgot. isis did. the world most famous terrorist group
Using cringe unironically is cringe
@@user-op8fg3ny3j the ottoman is more cringe here.
imagine losing all your territory and have to be save by a murtad
You're cringe
Why don't you also mention that he was a crypto jew from greece as well as a prominent freemason?
"Greece and Turkey had realized that the two groups could not longer live together in cooperation" did they? I wonder if the GENOCIDE OF MILLIONS OF ARMENIANS, GREEKS AND OTHER MINORITIES HAD A PART TO PLAY IN THAT REALIZATION
10 yılda 5 milyon türk yok oldu , katledildi . Kime karşı soykırım yapıldı tatrışalım
2 Million Balkan Turks were driven out from their home by Balkan Christians during and after the Balkan Wars, and another million were murdered by the same people. That's when we realized Greeks and other Christians wanted nothing else than murdering us. This is exactly why. But of course you'd turn a blind eye when it is our people who were murdered wouldn't you, hypocrite?
It was the turkish sunni tradition that was brought by the republic and atatürk, which carried out pogroms and mass killings. he was also the one who later had the pashas, who were responsible for the armenian genocide, released from prison. by abstracting turkey's bourgeois revolution from its historicity and mythologizing it under the names of particulars, what ideology do you think is responsible for producing the dichotomy between ottoman pasha and republican revolutionary? dont even look at which ideology is the foundational element behind this production....
in Türkiye we fuck allah everyday
As an American, when i look at a picture of Ataturk i always think "there was a great man".
ATATURK WAS GREAT MAN.
He was gay & had many young 15 - 21 year old lovers. He liked them very young, virile & that's being a deranged Pedophile. That's why he never married & there's actual facts about his life that prove this. It was a very well known fact among his friends & the wealthy people, families, he socialised with in the palace.
At the end of M. Kemal's speech to the Assembly on November 1, 1937;
However, these principles should never be equated with the dogmas of books supposedly descended from heaven. We have taken our inspirations directly from life, not from the sky and the unseen”[1], with lengthy explanations and no objections, in an article we shared before, that what we mean by the expression "books thought to have descended from the sky" is "divine books" like the Qur'an. We have proved it in a way that leaves no room. For this reason, we do not consider it necessary to repeat them all here now. We will only be content to share "additional information" here. After reading this article, those who wish can click on the link we have added to the resource no. [2] in the "Resources" section and read the article in question.
your point?
And sultan was really nice and sooo strong!!
The steel-colored brightness of [his] eyes shines out of the warrior-like, sunburned brown of [his] face with an uncanny, captivating power. Eyes, within which the supple power and the ruthless will of self-assertion of the Turanian grey wolf twin- kles." Be it Aryan, Turanian, or even Mongolian, or, again perhaps obviously, Prussian-when, in the narratives, Atatürk meets the Kai- ser, Hindenburg, and Ludendorff in 1917-what his appearance and actions reaffirmed was the awakening and the "triumph of race." Schopen concluded:
He is nothing less than the incarnation of all warrior-like na- tions. The Turk is, in his moral qualities, one of the best sol- diers of the world. For him the victorious military Führer stands above everything else. And Mustafa Kemal, mathematician and carrier of soldier blood from his father's line, was a genius of the strategic idea."7
For most of these texts, Atatürk was the ultimate warrior-"battle was his nature."+ Froembgen described him as "a thunderstorm turned man." Melzig said in his Atatürk biography: "In him a he- roic spirit rose to the light from the depth of thousands of years." Froembgen also stressed, "He is a soldier the like of which seldom comes along." Atatürk's prowess in battle was stressed time and again: "The soldiers hesitated to throw themselves into the rain of death. Mustafa Kemal knows, here no order will be enough, here one needs to be a role model, to be a Führer."52 The Führer as a role model for everybody-in battle, for the Turkish farmer with his model farm, but also for the ordinary Turk, when it comes to demeanor, dress, and indeed everything-was a constant theme of these texts.53
Descriptions of Atatürk's aura elevated him to messianistic levels. With his deeds at Gallipoli during World War I, Atatürk emerges in these narratives not only as the imminent savior of Constantino- ple but as a transcendental "savior." Indeed, the formula "savior and Führer" was frequently put forward by some texts. Some stressed that one could feel a special aura, "a magic circle," in his presence he was "the chosen one."
Cringe
@@GrigRPextremely
The meat glazing is crazy
We miss him dearly❤❤❤❤
Amazing Leader and also a Handsome one!
Ataturk rolling on his grave while erdogan undoing great things he did for turkey. From 1st world to 3rd world country its amazing in less than a decade.😂
Just like islamized europe 😂😂😂😂
🤡🤡 ata turk left turkey with a gdp of $20B which is equivalent to the GDP of Afghanistan back in 2020 during a war 🤣 he turned turkey into a garbage dump that had nothing better to do than killing kurds. He set turkey up for being exploited and couped for decades by foreign powers. Erdogan took this trash that ata turk left behind and turned Turkey into the second most powerful country in NATO after the United States. Now turkey has a GDP well over $900B thanks to Erdogan. Turkey has the largest land army in Europe, larger than the rest of Europe combined excluding Russia. That means turkey makes up over 30% of NATO’s combat power, while the US makes up 55% of NATO’s fire power and the rest of NATO, dozens of countries combined accounts for about 15% 🤣🤣 turkey doesn’t even spend the 2% GDP requirement on its military and yet its military budget is larger than the entire economy of Lithuania. You can talk all the crap you want, but numbers are reality and ur secular ideological fanaticism is just delusional.
🤡🤡 ata turk left turkey with a gdp of $20B which is equivalent to the GDP of Afghanistan back in 2020 during a war 🤣 he turned turkey into a garb*ge dump that had nothing better to do than k1ll1ng kurds. He set turkey up for being exploited and couped for decades by foreign powers. Erdogan took this tr*sh that ata turk left behind and turned Turkey into the second most powerful country in NATO after the United States. Now turkey has a GDP well over $900B thanks to Erdogan. Turkey has the largest land army in Europe, larger than the rest of Europe combined excluding Russia. That means turkey makes up over 30% of NATO’s combat power, while the US makes up 55% of NATO’s fire power and the rest of NATO, dozens of countries combined accounts for about 15% 🤣🤣 turkey doesn’t even spend the 2% GDP requirement on its military and yet its military budget is larger than the entire economy of Lithuania. You can talk all the cr*p you want, but numbers are reality and ur secul*r ideological fanaticism is just del*sional.
He is the only one leader in the World faught 5 Wars against 7 nations and managed importent reforms of a whole country maked him immortel. Even his Enemies treatet him with respect and recognition
Ataturk is ome of my favorite figures and definately favorite politician. If it wasn't for him, Turkey would now be something like Afganistan or other sad Muslim countries. I hope that Erdogan is not able to undo all of that
🤡🤡 ata turk left turkey with a gdp of $20B which is equivalent to the GDP of Afghanistan back in 2020 during a war 🤣 he turned turkey into a garb*ge dump that had nothing better to do than k1ll1ng kurds. He set turkey up for being exploited and couped for decades by foreign powers. Erdogan took this tr*sh that ata turk left behind and turned Turkey into the second most powerful country in NATO after the United States. Now turkey has a GDP well over $900B thanks to Erdogan. Turkey has the largest land army in Europe, larger than the rest of Europe combined excluding Russia. That means turkey makes up over 30% of NATO’s combat power, while the US makes up 55% of NATO’s fire power and the rest of NATO, dozens of countries combined accounts for about 15% 🤣🤣 turkey doesn’t even spend the 2% GDP requirement on its military and yet its military budget is larger than the entire economy of Lithuania. You can talk all the cr*p you want, but numbers are reality and ur secul*r ideological fanaticism is just del*sional.
I am a believing muslim (may Allah accept my deeds) and also very fond of Atatürk who saved and shaped a whole nation. So, you can be both imo.. Whoever is against him is a traitor, which, many are. Unfortunetaly...
Whoever is with him and agrees with his ideas is a kaffir.
Your a believing Muslim but you support a dude who single handedly wiped out islam from turkey and killed kurds
The great leader of modern Turkey Ataturk,only insane people will critise the great man.❤
Âl-i İmrân / 33. Ayet meali اِنَّ اللّٰهَ اصْطَفٰٓى اٰدَمَ وَنُوحًا وَاٰلَ اِبْرٰه۪يمَ وَاٰلَ عِمْرٰنَ عَلَى الْعَالَم۪ينَۙ
Muhakkak ki Allah Âdem’i, Nûh’u, İbrâhim âilesini ve İmrân âilesini tertemiz bir hülâsa hâlinde seçip bütün insanlık üzerine üstün kılmıştır.
Bakara / 119. Ayet اِنَّٓا اَرْسَلْنَاكَ بِالْحَقِّ بَش۪يرًا وَنَذ۪يرًاۙ وَلَا تُسْـَٔلُ عَنْ اَصْحَابِ الْجَح۪يمِ
Rasûlüm! Biz seni, insanları hem müjdelemen hem de uyarman için hak din ile gönderdik. Sen vazîfeni hakkıyle yapıyorsun; dolayısıyla cehennemlik olanlardan sorumlu tutulacak değilsin!
Bakara / 281. Ayet وَاتَّقُوا يَوْماً تُرْجَعُونَ فٖيهِ اِلَى اللّٰهِ ثُمَّ تُوَفّٰى كُلُّ نَفْسٍ مَا كَسَبَتْ وَهُمْ لَا يُظْلَمُونَࣖ ﴿٢٨١﴾
Bir günden sakının ki, onda Allah’a döndürüleceksiniz, sonra herkese hak ettiği tam olarak verilecek ve onlara haksızlık edilmeyecektir.
En'âm / 21. Ayet وَمَنْ اَظْلَمُ مِمَّنِ افْتَرٰى عَلَى اللّٰهِ كَذِبًا اَوْ كَذَّبَ بِاٰيَاتِه۪ۜ اِنَّهُ لَا يُفْلِحُ الظَّالِمُونَ
Allah hakkında yalan uyduran veya O’nun âyetlerini yalanlayandan daha zâlim kim olabilir? Şüphe yok ki zâlimler kurtuluşa eremezler.
ua-cam.com/video/RfEQkWTnmDM/v-deo.html