I've probably typed this a half dozen times but I'll gladly say it again, this channel is the most mesmerizing, beautiful, and intricately written collection of intelligent entertainment on UA-cam. Just awesome work! Thank you for making me and countless others just a little bit wiser and cultured. Amazing job!
Right?!? The power comes from the points of view that are represented, new POV’s to those we learn of in traditional learning situations. The plan is to engage us with stories of people like us, regular people who are generally forgotten in time. It’s impact is far greater than if we’re given the usual history lecture, show etc. I’m so thankful for this new kind of history lesson. I believe it even lowers my blood pressure, mind and body are better off from the experience even though it can be devastating.
And that will be the fate of us all as Climate change removes the homes we knew throughout the planet, and we have been too passive or corrupt to stop it. A city can be rebuilt, but not the gift of a liveable planet, once ruined.
"The dead are gone and with them we cannot converse. The living are here and ought to have our love." I think that particular verse is something we should all reflect on more often - especially in this particular day and age when we don't know how long our loved ones will be here.
@@paulhallett1452 Why? Plenty of my loved ones wouldn't even be in heaven according to Christianity. Why would I want to spend "eternity" away from the ppl I love? Also, it was a reference to Covid, genius.
That poem at the end was so moving. It's one thing to read stuff like that without a sense of the loss that people were feeling. With the benefit of time, we can be callous to the fact that these people's lives were upturned. They would have thought the world had come to an end, where we just look back and see the next civilization starting to take it's place. "I want to go back. There is no road back." That moved me way more than it would have without the context gleaned from the episode.
The poem is actually an integration of several short poems, which are all from a collection called 《昭明文选》or mostly known as 《古诗十九首》（19 ancient poems）. The writers of these poems had been unknown for a long time.
Last year in tenth grade and for much of the school before that, I despised history to the point that I almost failed once. And now for some weird reason, I'm taking time out of the busy academic schedule to watch these, even when I don't have history as a subject anymore. Says something about the quality of these documentaries. Hats off.
I swear school curriculums go out of their way to make their subjects as awful and uninteresting as possible - usually while obscuring the subject and leaving students with false impressions (especially when the subjects concern subjects that have political implications). And history is one of those subjects where you can just about ignore everything you learned in K-12 cuz it's probably wrong.
Remember, friend, whenever you learn something about human culture, human history, you also gain a better understanding of yourself. To get to know yourself better, it helps to learn how mankind has operated and acted and reacted and resurrected down the millennia. Never stop learning. It is the gift that never stops giving back to you. Peace to you.
" ..but there's no road back!" Moved to some tears. Thank you so much Paul! You are a true artist of historical documentary. I share your videos everywhere.
You are setting the example of historical representation with your details, sources, and complete honesty. I'm sure you're aware of the many channels that are nothing but speculative garbage. They draw so much attention, it's a really disappointing trend. You are much appreciated by those of us who aren't interested in fake history. Great work!
I like how the narrator includes deep geological history in this video. It is like about finding The First Cause and how everything is interconnected, especially geology and geography, which have been shaping the fates of many empires and societies.
The BBC spends hundreds of thousands, if not millions of pounds per hour to produce TV programmes, I am guessing your budget is a percentage or two of theirs, yet I find your work far more engaging. Thank you for your content.
That's because they don't think anyone will watch it unless you have a known person presenting on a big fee with their own production company producing it rather than someone with skill and passion. Hence next week, Danny Dyer on Diocletian!
@@cosuinofdeath The Summer Palace and other historic buildings were not destroyed by the Communists, but by Western colonizers (They did the same in Iraqi museums)
Can you recommend more documentaries like this one? They can be in putongyu as well. I'm a Chinese descended American and I want to learn more about the country of my ancestors
I can't even imagine how long this series took to create. Astounding work, mate. I've watched every episode, many of them more than once. Thank you for these videos, they are fantastic.
@bastiat You generally acuse the whole podcast as garbage... This is just ridiculous. Argumenting that history disagrees is even more weak. So what exactly you are talking about. It looks like that we agree to disagree...
@bastiat @bastiat You are changing topics and start to accuse me as well... That's rude and unprecise. The podcast is bad... Now it's some kind of weird 'argument' (it's literally not an argument, but just one word..) about human systems in general and media. Speak thoroughly to prove your point. I think, education needs different perspectives and presentations to reveal layers of 'truth' and 'knowledge'. Again, you say the whole podcast is bad. I totally disagree. It's made by a person that cares about this world and tries to combine many aspects of education and uses a modern form of presentation. The podcast informs about very important times, societies, personalities and civilizations around the world. I can't think of anything that is more useful in our time. The podcast tries to show 'us' (in a globaliized world) how fragile societies and systems can be. Furthermore, if you look at episode 8 for example it informs about key aspects of human civilization in general. Ex oriente lux!
Excellent channel. I also strongly recommend Stefan Milo channel and David Reichs book as an short introduction to properly understood history of humanity
Again exhaustively researched, elegantly written, and beautifully presented. I have now watched about half a dozen of these documentaries, and I have been immensely impressed by each one of them. Who said "history doesn't repeat itself, but it rhymes"? One can't help but feel that there are lessons to learnt for us as our own civilization lurches from one crisis to another.
@ritasjourney it is the people that follow the psychopaths and grant them power who are the ones who don't learn from history. Power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely.
@@SeanHiruki I am surprised it wasn't mentioned, but the first diplomatic contact between China and Rome occurred in Lingdi's reign (186-190 CE somewhere around there), with an envoy sent by Marcus Aurelius.
@@SeanHiruki The supposed connection between the Romans and the Chinese was tenuous at best. The Chinese were vaguely aware there was some important barbarian city somewhere to the west where Chinese goods may haven eventually made their way to, and that was it. The Romans, for their part, knew nothing of China.
@@webeskimo The Romans and the Han (indeed, all Chinese imperial dynasties) are strikingly different. For instance, the Roman Empire survived the rise and fall of many dynasties, even within a single year, whereas the Chinese empire collapses with the fall of the ruling dynasty, often descending into protracted periods of internecine war until a new dynasty comes out on top and rebuilds the empire.
I have to admit that I almost passed up on watching any of your videos because your channel name, Fall of Civilizations, brought to mind the kind of overly dramatic documentaries that only focus on spectacle that now populate the cable history/documentary channels. I'm so glad I decided to try, because despite the name, you start from the formation of the geography, millennia before there were even any humans, and go into exquisite detail on each of your topics. Every time, I am amazed at how much research you have done, and how much information is actually known about each civilization. Thank you for what you do, and you have had me hooked ever since.
These are as wonderfully relaxing as they are full of eventual slow doom. They fit my 2020 zeitgeist perfectly. So well researched, full of detail, and so moving. Please never stop!
All of these episodes are masterpieces. national geographic can't hold a candle to These productions. The cinematography, audio & Presentation are all very well done. Very thorough research as well. All of these factors combined with very clear And pleasing to the ear Narration equals Documentary excellence.
Like Mathew said. It's a lot of stock videos. In the first 4 minutes of the video, not a single shot was of Luoyang, an ancient inland city. There was 15 seconds of CGI, 3 minutes of a abandoned village on a small fishing island, and some fillers. You can't really call this a documentary.
Nat Geo is overrated. Lots of competition nowadays. I only stick to UA-cam and Netflix. I dont even know why i have a tv. Serengeti is amazing, though.
The description of Emperor Ling doing market role-playing with his women is hilarious @2:04:00, even your voice actor gives a hint. Doing this while the empire goes bankrupt and burns. What great history.
After spending 3 months in China, one thing I have learned was that China has a long and complicated past, possibly longer than many other civilizations. I found this documentary most intriguing and historically accurate. A superior production. Thank you.
Every segment of this series is as thorough, well-researched, incredibly beautiful and heart-wrenching as the next. The Fall of Civilizations is the best ancient civilizations series ever made.
What I took from this series is that the worst place to be in a rebellion is in the library. Temples and palaces are bad too, but nothing comes close to the fire hazard in libraries.
What would us history nerds have done without you Paul. You have created not one but multiple master pieces and all I can do is thank you for it. Never stop please.
My take to anyone who has not yet watched it: This 3 hour video is one of the best investments of time you will ever make. Team Video Han Dynasty, thank you so much for this gem. I really appreciate your effort and research as much as your empathy and respect for a dynasty and era that I would say is not only a jewel in Chinese history but also in world history.
The piece at the end is gorgeous. It speaks of utter devastation, and of the turning of the pages of history. May our own downfall be so beautifully memorialized.
The piano intro gets me every time. I had to learn it for myself just to hear a full version. Your series is gaining the recognition it deserves and these are getting so much better each time!! Absolutely love it
@@FallofCivilizations You should do Soviet Union one day. ;) It's a joke of course but only half so. It was a unique civilization in a way, which is not more.
@@ascadorcern6106 On one hand, you are right, the SU is still continuation of Russia. On the other, it is a unique culture and civilization on its own. So, it it limited in time in this sense. But anyway, I was joking.
@@manichaean1888 I actually do rather like the idea... Even if it doesn't really work, the reasons for its collapse are still in debate and interesting, but maybe a bit too modern. You'd get a lot of arguments in the comments.
I am so glad youtube randomly suggested this series! I'm completely hooked! There are so many scary parallels with current world events in these videos... I have a feeling we might be living through a future episode
I am not being sarcastic with what I am about to write. Of course you see parallels between Han era China; sadly, no, depressingly, there are very few true variations in history. Details may vary, but overall, history just repeats itself, millennia after millennia, in every country, in every culture. Out of periods of chaos and upheaval, civilizations emerge, struggle to a peak, even a flowering, then decadence and decay set in, then fall and the process starts all over. Sometimes the process is measured in centuries, at other times, far less. When I was in school, one teacher, the wife of a Southern Baptist preacher, spent more time going on about parallels between the fall of Rome and the USA in the early 1970s, and pointing out that a sign of "the second coming" was that there would be wars and rumors of wars; a braver classmate pointed out that there had always been wars and rumors of wars. Of course that was not well received, but as unfit as that teacher was, the worst was the geography teacher who was, 20 years later, an unreformed McCarthyite, and how terrifying life was in Soviet Russia and how, Ft. Benning, a first strike target for atomic war, was only 30 miles away. As dysfunctional as this was, I am sure that it has been repeated for millennia - Babylonian teachers terrifying their students with tales of the evil Assyrians, Chinese scholars railing about the evil Mongols. We humans never truly, completely learn.
@@jeraldbaxter3532 Unfortunately, scaring children has been a powerful mind control method that leads to an intoxicating feeling of great power to the people in charge and mass compliance in the populace. It requires a bit of head shaking to clear the mind and violent revolt from time to time to reset for the next round,. We have nothing to fear but fear itself is true to a point. Fear puts you in shackles. Power corrupts, and you have to hide the corruption or you're out of your job. The Catholics taught us all that very clearly and it's pretty much a universal truth when all the checks and balances collapse or are done away with.
Completely concur with Dragan. Incredibly detailed information & background, all presented without hype or fanfare, laid out in a wonderfully logical & chronological sequence with diversions to other times &/or characters where appropriate. Cannot recommend this video highly enough. MANY thanks for all of your hard work & efforts. joe in buenos aires
This was just a fantastic episode. I love that you dedicated such a long time to properly explain how the history went down, made sure to use proper pronunciation, and holy cow I can't imagine how long it took to get the footage for these 3 hours. It honestly felt like I was listening to a condensed version of Game of Thrones-like story set in China.
The opening poem written by Chao Zhi (曹植) in July, 211 ACE. Original text below: 步登北邙阪，遙望洛陽山。 洛陽何寂寞，宮室盡燒焚。 垣牆皆頓擗，荆棘上參天。 不見舊耆老，但睹新少年。 側足無行徑，荒疇不復田。 遊子久不歸，不識陌與阡。 中野何蕭條，千里無人煙。 念我平常居，氣結不能言。
You do impressive work in a open way that allows even the most novice to understand and digest. You are a true teacher / organic documentary illustrator sir. 100% on point congrats
This is absolutely fascinating! In the West, we don't hear nearly enough about Chinese and other Asian history. Very enlightening and fascinating, particularly the contrast, if you keep in mind the progress of the Greeks and Romans at the time.
I love the music in this podcast. It sounds both sad and inspiring, at different times. Mr. Cooper provides greater insights into Chinese history than I learned in both 7th and 10 grades. History was one of my fave subjects in HS, and no wonder: I practically excelled in the subject and even carried that love into college for my first two years. History remains a favorite subject of learning even after college, grad school and B-school, b/c I read about various period in outside reading sources--both nonfiction and fiction.
I found my education regarding Chinese history and culture to be very lacking in my US high school curriculum. I was in a small town so very possible ours did not provide the best curriculum and/or it depended on the time period in which we went to high school. I did learn more in college, but I was not a history major, so it was limited. That's why I so appreciate these wonderful podcasts to educate me further. They really are like historical documentaries that could definitely be used in classrooms.
Your reference "coalesced like beads of mercury on a table" - wow that brought up memories of playing with beads of mercury from a bottle of it that my brother and I had as kids in the late forties. Kids don't have the joy and fascination of such amusements any more but that reference sure brought back memories. I still have that vial of mercury pilfered from my father's home medical office.
@@spshea I teach children. They still have that fascination. You have no idea the bizarre things I catch children playing with in my classroom, in addition to their smartphones and laptops. Haven't caught mercury yet, but I wouldn't be surprised. LOL. Kids are still kids.
I love watching these videos at night. Often I fall asleep, so I have to watch them again the next night. But these videos bring peace to the end of my day, and I’m actually excited to get to bed. I guess what I’m trying to say is thank you. I’ll keep liking and watching if you keep making them. Please keep making them!
Same here. The documentaries are my bedtime stories. I often drift to sleep while half listening. His voice is sooo soothing. In the morning i have to replay again to confirm if i really heard everything.
Mr. Cooper, it is difficult to add anything that has not already been said about your work. You are a master of the narrative arts, an artist of cinematography, a giant of historical context and knowledge, and a brilliant alchemist in combining all of these individual elements into truly compelling, cohesive unions of scholarly production. I can hardly wait to see episodes 12 through 100.
worth the binge for all episode.. Love this podcast as I am learning and got mesmerized about the ancient civilization. better than what netflix and other streaming platform can provide..
Such an amazing Podcast, to you and everyone who created this, thank you! So brilliant, chilling, exciting, and heartbreaking at the same time. The last few minutes got me for sure, watching what is going on now and thinking back when I was growing up, gave me chills for sure! History is such a fascinating mirror, with the hope that it doesn't turn with the same results with a different date in time! Thank you again!!!!
There was a famous saying from Tang empire Li Shining to his advisor: one can learn his dressing from a mirror, the rise and fall of dynasties from history, and the right and wrongs from other people.
I WISH you were teaching me history as a child. I used to hate history growing up and even as an adult, my recurring nightmare is that I’m climbing up the stairs of my old school building and I realize that I have a history exam. I wake up in a panic from my own racing heartbeat. I began watching your stuff because I have been having a sneaking suspicion since 2017/18 that this “US Empire” is going to come tumbling down like the Roman Empire and since I know / remember nothing of history, your channel has been teaching me far more than my textbooks in school. So THANK YOU! 🙏🏼
Dear Paul, I watched this one twice. The beginning is very gripping and emotional, comparing this to a slow car crash is so accurate. Love your narration an d voice. Excellent documentary. Thank you for sharing your gift with all of us. ❤
One of the few things I have to look forward to the past few months are these videos. Thanks for the great content, UA-cam living up to its potential through your work.
These are the BEST historical videos, right there with Rare Earth for impact and no peer in empire histories, that opening piece of music is so perfect
An amazing compilation of early chinese dynastic history that is the Han Dynasty. Rich and well researched content. Beautiful landscape videography! My only minor gripe is that some imagery that supposedly portray the Han Emperor and it’s court officials included inaccurate images of the Qing Emperor and its officials wearing the famous pigtail hairstyle of the Qing Dynasty - the last dynasty of china were descended from the Manchurians from Northeast China. This in no way detracts from the immense work that went into making this highly educational documentary on Han China.
I woke up to the Sumerian video and I watched like 3 more videos in a row after. History is one of my FAVORTE things. Thank you for all the hard work and for filling my brain with knowledge in the most pleasant way possible :p
I doubt that. The main difference between any class and UA-cam is that you decide what you watch. If this interests you, you will listen to it. Any class has the disadvantage that no matter how interesting it tries to be, if you don't care about the topic you won't pay attention. I think it would be best if we could have mood based learning. Imagine schools would let you choose what to learn after a certain degree of basics completely by yourself. Or let's say you have a set amount of classes you have to attend each year, but you get to decide daily what you feel like learning. Sure, this is a very broad generalization. But I could imagine it would cause people to actually pay attention
@@eccomi21 well yes and no.. The self selecting nature of UA-cam does matter, but investigation into the matter has confirmed that test-based curriculum makes it far less likely that children, especially boys, will pay attention in class. Presentation to purpose, like this, does wonders in restoring attention. When students can see why it matters and why it is important AS they learn, it makes a huge difference. Even if students are exposed to this learning style outside matters they care about, they pay more attention and are more engaged.
Splendid, just splendid. The sensations of life of these eras bringing history to life, your writing poetic. Incredible production. Better than any I've seen that were made with many dozens of camera teams, producers, writers, researchers, voice talent, editors, etc. And conceptually, made with something even more rare, vision.
The podcasts were excellent. The video addition is beyond excellent. I don't know how you do this without the corporate / network support. Your work has been very inspiring to me. Thank you!
A truly amazing series on history so well done they deserve to on TV. This is my favourite episode I love China and it’s history and learning about that history is one of my greatest interests.
They say timing is everything, I just randomly caught the poem at the end of this by chance and it hit me like a sledgehammer, due to personal reasons happening in my life right now, as much tears as it has brought to me, I really needed to hear it, THANK YOU!
I have listen to them all several times. because there's so much to learn. the way the story is told is, to me, far more exciting than anything that has come out of Hollywood.. EVER.. can't make these stories up, they are so exciting with tragedies , thrills etc.. the first few times, i’ll listen intently to the story, then and often after he's in the background if I'm working and if I'm having a restless night sleep. then ill put a long episode on loop and go to sleep. to get to relive the story again . i call this type of amazing story telling a compact, university degree. it deserves listening to it in many settings. THANK YOU so much for doing what you do .. i am excited to see that i am not the only one that loves this podcast. and it also gives me so much hope to see people want to know our collective history and even better, that you and your team are doing all that you do so that we can appreciate our past.
Amazing not only in terms of quality of the historical narrative, but also in terms of linguistic quality. I love listening to British English of the high level and here we also hear some Chinese. I do not speak Chinese at all , but it is so cool to hear some Chinese words/ poems ! I just SUBSCRIBED !
Again, yet another masterful documentary production that eclipses any other productions seen before, save those of the same origin. Entirely enjoyable in every aspect, but most especially visually.
Thank you so much! This is fantastic! Thank you for speaking slowly enough that I can actually take in what is being said. Thank you for making the study of history thoroughly enjoyable! -Mike T., Los Angeles 🌞❤️
I have seen about half or more of these visual podcasts by now and I'm blown away by your craftsmanship and dedication. you should be praised a thousand times over for these. I don't know what else to say except for just, thank you for making these 🙏
These documentaries are the best thing I have seen on youtube. Well organized, very professional in referring to sources very critically yet still managing to make these stories human and engaging with only very brief relation to our world today. You cannot help but be transported there anyway. In that regard this series haunts me.
Awesome Awesome documentary! I think this is my favourite of these works and I would have never thought a documentary about China and not a Sumerian or Assyrian documentary would normally be at the top of my list. Also, what a beautifully gorgeous country! My mouth was gaping throughout in complete shock and awe!❤
I love this channel. As great as Dan Carlin is. FOC is high art and getting better with every episode! Thanks for the hard work and excellence. Cheers from Vancouver B.C.
I'm learning about my own country of my birth ancient history although I'm an American citizen and army veteran, I have studied ancient history of China while on vacation back at my native Daiwan village now at age 93 after many traveling around the world I'm watching UA-cam history of China again!
I had a four hour drive to listen to this in its entirety and I loved this from beginning to end. But the highlights for me were when you talked about the regions of China, how they came to be geographically, and the different peoples that inhabited every corner of the continent. Not only did you lay out the history of this Dynasty in precise chapters, you explained the importance of the terrain and how it affected Chinese history as a whole. Also, bonus points for citing first hand accounts from ancient historians and political figures for exposition. The time and effort that must have gone into this video must have been insane. One of the best history pieces I've ever heard by far.
I feel like I can listen the narrator talk forever. I wished he would continue on with what happened after the fall of Han. Such an interesting and moving history lesson.
Listened to all your podcasts on this channel and no other history channel on UA-cam has actual history presented in such a solid perspective. Phenomenal work from you and your team!
Your writing and presentation skills are impressive and appreciated. So many documentaries are sterile and strictly factual, which diminishes one's connection to (and retention of) the content. The degree of empathy that you encode into these "podcasts" brings these ancient civilizations to life.
I scrolled for a bit and didn’t see a comment about it. I absolutely love this series in general and this episode in particular. I grew up playing the Dynasty Warriors video game series and knew that the games were taken off a book(?) that was called the romance of the three kingdoms. It was based loosely around the end of this time period. Connecting the dots before Cao Cao, Liu Bei, and Sun Jiang was super interesting! Keep up the good work!
Most history professors and experts specialize in one culture, civilization, or epoch. Joseph Campbell specialized in biblical history, Ken Burns American history. Paul has created such a diverse portfolio of expertise to span so many different eras, cultures, and civilizations. He tells stories spanning the globe, spanning every era of written human history, and all causes of the end of civilizations. External invasions in the Easter Island episode, internal rot in the Han dynasty episode, climate change refuges in the Bronze Age episode. He tells stories founded on Chinese classical poetry, Aztec codex, and scholarly research in the Byzantium episodes. Paul has created a true masterpiece to rival those of the Iliad he references in his works. One day when they write the story of the downfall of our civilization, I hope they find a suitable voice to speak Paul's commentary on our times.
I can't imagine this not being so award worthy...Emmy? Oscar? The British equivalent?? Paul Cooper is doing some of the best deep-dive history work in the entire field, & I could watch these visually stunning, deeply researched pieces forever.
You do some of the greatest work of history on the internet. Thank you for weaving together so eloquent all these historical stories and details and even including great poetry. Appreciation
These are, indeed, exquisite! Thank you! I look forward to future episodes, especially I would like to see some about India. (I love India.) Also, I'd love to see some concerning Japan. And more China. I don't think Westerners know nearly enough about the East.
And Korea! Westerners often mention China and Japan while skipping right over Korea, whose dynasties were very stable indeed, and who conducted broad trading.
Your production quality is breathtaking the way your narration seamlessly tie a history lesson into thrilling storytelling and a humbling experience and reminder our time our beautiful civilization will too pass into the pages of time... Cheers from Salt zlake City!!
As is so often the case.. The research and diligence that went behind this episode is simply astonishing. A comment like this is not the first time that a viewer of your channel has expressed such gratitude. And as we will soon learn.. it will be far from the last...
I'm so enjoying this! It's a wonderful presentation, full of details that bring the whole scene to life. I learned more from listening to this than many other such-type documentaries together. And the scenery you include is just wonderful, and the owls and horses, and the poetry. Some of that was just amazing. Thanks so much, great work! Subscribing.
This was so informative. I had only the vaguest idea of Chinese history and this helped flesh out at least part of it. I was moved to tears at the end, to think of so much lost.
Who else has to keep rewatching these because they're super interesting but his voice is so relaxing that it puts you to sleep?
I cant sleep watching these, I'm too interested lol
This is like my asmr when I sleep. The only jarring part is the poem at the beginning.
This series is how I go to sleep every night
It took me one week to finish one episode. I always fell asleep.
I thought it was just me lol
I've probably typed this a half dozen times but I'll gladly say it again, this channel is the most mesmerizing, beautiful, and intricately written collection of intelligent entertainment on UA-cam. Just awesome work! Thank you for making me and countless others just a little bit wiser and cultured. Amazing job!
Thank you for this.
The poem at the end … “I want to go home but there’s no road back”, that line is devastating.
Right?!? The power comes from the points of view that are represented, new POV’s to those we learn of in traditional learning situations.
The plan is to engage us with stories of people like us, regular people who are generally forgotten in time.
It’s impact is far greater than if we’re given the usual history lecture, show etc.
I’m so thankful for this new kind of history lesson. I believe it even lowers my blood pressure, mind and body are better off from the experience even though it can be devastating.
It's tragically beutiful because it shows these people were jist like us normal people who just wanted thier stable lives back.
That hurt me more than I thought it would
And that will be the fate of us all as Climate change removes the homes we knew throughout the planet, and we have been too passive or corrupt to stop it. A city can be rebuilt, but not the gift of a liveable planet, once ruined.
Zap 😊lp mmm
"The dead are gone and with them we cannot converse. The living are here and ought to have our love." I think that particular verse is something we should all reflect on more often - especially in this particular day and age when we don't know how long our loved ones will be here.
In most days and ages people know when they’ll lose their loved ones? Nah. Repent.
@@paulhallett1452 Why? Plenty of my loved ones wouldn't even be in heaven according to Christianity. Why would I want to spend "eternity" away from the ppl I love?
Also, it was a reference to Covid, genius.
@@paulhallett1452 Repent yourself.
@@paulhallett1452 Go away.
I interpret it more like we should be nicer to each other and love the living that are here, learn from the past and all...
In my 80's and this is the most enjoyable history lesson ever. Cheers
😨
@@harishthethird why make a face? I hope I still have a love of learning and her age
@@richarddavis8863 no it's supposed to convey astonishment xd
This makes me so happy to see the older generation able to utilize new technologies to continue to learn more! Love this
@@Winteramen .
That poem at the end was so moving. It's one thing to read stuff like that without a sense of the loss that people were feeling. With the benefit of time, we can be callous to the fact that these people's lives were upturned. They would have thought the world had come to an end, where we just look back and see the next civilization starting to take it's place.
"I want to go back. There is no road back." That moved me way more than it would have without the context gleaned from the episode.
The poem is actually an integration of several short poems, which are all from a collection called 《昭明文选》or mostly known as 《古诗十九首》（19 ancient poems）. The writers of these poems had been unknown for a long time.
One interesting thing: this kind of poems in Han dynasty were more like lyrics. They are used to be sung in some specific tunes.
@@salazar3494 in fact ancient Chinese poems are probably read like songs, old Chinese does not sounds like modern Chinese at all.
Well said.
Last year in tenth grade and for much of the school before that, I despised history to the point that I almost failed once. And now for some weird reason, I'm taking time out of the busy academic schedule to watch these, even when I don't have history as a subject anymore. Says something about the quality of these documentaries. Hats off.
Says something about the quality of many teachers.
@@MrHanderson91 more so the quality of the curriculum
I swear school curriculums go out of their way to make their subjects as awful and uninteresting as possible - usually while obscuring the subject and leaving students with false impressions (especially when the subjects concern subjects that have political implications). And history is one of those subjects where you can just about ignore everything you learned in K-12 cuz it's probably wrong.
Remember, friend, whenever you learn something about human culture, human history, you also gain a better understanding of yourself. To get to know yourself better, it helps to learn how mankind has operated and acted and reacted and resurrected down the millennia. Never stop learning. It is the gift that never stops giving back to you.
Peace to you.
" ..but there's no road back!" Moved to some tears. Thank you so much Paul! You are a true artist of historical documentary. I share your videos everywhere.
I reached the end of this doc and had tears in my eyes. No one does it like you, Cooper. I'm stunned and I feel like a changed man after seeing this.
You are setting the example of historical representation with your details, sources, and complete honesty.
I'm sure you're aware of the many channels that are nothing but speculative garbage.
They draw so much attention, it's a really disappointing trend.
You are much appreciated by those of us who aren't interested in fake history.
Great work!
Thanks Bryan, much appreciated.
My face
Wise Words
I like how the narrator includes deep geological history in this video. It is like about finding The First Cause and how everything is interconnected, especially geology and geography, which have been shaping the fates of many empires and societies.
And climate!
Read Guns, Germs, and Steel
@@MattGrovesFTW Yes, a real eye opening book, or UA-cam video. Ronn
“Guns, Germs & Steel” is an excellent read!
.7
The BBC spends hundreds of thousands, if not millions of pounds per hour to produce TV programmes, I am guessing your budget is a percentage or two of theirs, yet I find your work far more engaging. Thank you for your content.
Thanks Charles, much appreciated!
The BBC used to produce things like this but now they go for visuals and looks rather than substance and content
That's because they don't think anyone will watch it unless you have a known person presenting on a big fee with their own production company producing it rather than someone with skill and passion. Hence next week, Danny Dyer on Diocletian!
@@justme-hh4vp "Diocletian was a right proper geeza, he was top dog son"
I believe you mean kilograms per hour
I just finished watching and ... I don't know what to say. China's beauty, story of Han, music, poetry - I'm speechless. Thank you so much!
All gone now they destroyed their own history
@@cosuinofdeath like how?
@@cosuinofdeath The Summer Palace and other historic buildings were not destroyed by the Communists, but by Western colonizers (They did the same in Iraqi museums)
@@cosuinofdeath troll spotted
They destroyed them to survive, or what is the point of a Christian, English speaking China?
Thanks!This is a superb series -- I've learned so much. Especially liked the episode on Vijayanagara which is little known.
I'm an old Chinese man who fines this history story of Ancient China very interesting indeed about the history of Imperial China!
Can you recommend more documentaries like this one? They can be in putongyu as well. I'm a Chinese descended American and I want to learn more about the country of my ancestors
《中国通史》《从秦始皇到汉武帝》《楚国八百年》《帝陵》《丝绸之路》《张骞通西域》
Malaysian Chinese here, there is many historical documentary about ancient China make by mainland itself @@PatrickLongblkwhtrbbt
Who finds
Study about your Manchurian masters
I can't even imagine how long this series took to create. Astounding work, mate. I've watched every episode, many of them more than once. Thank you for these videos, they are fantastic.
@bastiat I rather think not!
@bastiat You generally acuse the whole podcast as garbage... This is just ridiculous. Argumenting that history disagrees is even more weak. So what exactly you are talking about. It looks like that we agree to disagree...
@bastiat @bastiat You are changing topics and start to accuse me as well... That's rude and unprecise. The podcast is bad... Now it's some kind of weird 'argument' (it's literally not an argument, but just one word..) about human systems in general and media. Speak thoroughly to prove your point. I think, education needs different perspectives and presentations to reveal layers of 'truth' and 'knowledge'. Again, you say the whole podcast is bad. I totally disagree. It's made by a person that cares about this world and tries to combine many aspects of education and uses a modern form of presentation. The podcast informs about very important times, societies, personalities and civilizations around the world. I can't think of anything that is more useful in our time. The podcast tries to show 'us' (in a globaliized world) how fragile societies and systems can be. Furthermore, if you look at episode 8 for example it informs about key aspects of human civilization in general. Ex oriente lux!
Excellent channel. I also strongly recommend Stefan Milo channel and David Reichs book as an short introduction to properly understood history of humanity
Again exhaustively researched, elegantly written, and beautifully presented. I have now watched about half a dozen of these documentaries, and I have been immensely impressed by each one of them. Who said "history doesn't repeat itself, but it rhymes"? One can't help but feel that there are lessons to learnt for us as our own civilization lurches from one crisis to another.
Mark Twain.
Beautifully commented. I so agree with you.
Unfortunately, psychopaths with out of control desires for money and power do NOT learn.
@ritasjourney it is the people that follow the psychopaths and grant them power who are the ones who don't learn from history.
Power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely.
I think the quote ( it doesn't appear in his books) is "History may not repeat itself, but it often rhymes."
A surprising number of parallels between Rome and Han. And as I had that thought, you carried us right down that path. Brilliant work.
Rome and The Han were contemporaries and had a trading relationship. In China Rome was called “Da Qin”
@@SeanHiruki I am surprised it wasn't mentioned, but the first diplomatic contact between China and Rome occurred in Lingdi's reign (186-190 CE somewhere around there), with an envoy sent by Marcus Aurelius.
where do you see paralels between han and rome? Besides the usual things in any empire/ clan etc. etc
@@SeanHiruki The supposed connection between the Romans and the Chinese was tenuous at best. The Chinese were vaguely aware there was some important barbarian city somewhere to the west where Chinese goods may haven eventually made their way to, and that was it. The Romans, for their part, knew nothing of China.
@@webeskimo The Romans and the Han (indeed, all Chinese imperial dynasties) are strikingly different. For instance, the Roman Empire survived the rise and fall of many dynasties, even within a single year, whereas the Chinese empire collapses with the fall of the ruling dynasty, often descending into protracted periods of internecine war until a new dynasty comes out on top and rebuilds the empire.
I have to admit that I almost passed up on watching any of your videos because your channel name, Fall of Civilizations, brought to mind the kind of overly dramatic documentaries that only focus on spectacle that now populate the cable history/documentary channels. I'm so glad I decided to try, because despite the name, you start from the formation of the geography, millennia before there were even any humans, and go into exquisite detail on each of your topics. Every time, I am amazed at how much research you have done, and how much information is actually known about each civilization. Thank you for what you do, and you have had me hooked ever since.
The story is very engaging and informative
The photography is fabulous
The voice of narrator is clear and very engaging
Nothing like is comparable
ty😅😉😉😜😘
f😉😘
It is all very evocative and engaging
Junior or senior? A jackelope Aunt Jackie would be fun probably.
Sleep pandies
These are as wonderfully relaxing as they are full of eventual slow doom. They fit my 2020 zeitgeist perfectly. So well researched, full of detail, and so moving. Please never stop!
Mmm
Not real history, Anglo-Saxon conspiracy
@@戚文玮 How so?
Slow doom. Yeah great way to describe the series. Heartbreaking but yeah very well done.
This is literally one of the best documentaries I have ever seen
All of these episodes are masterpieces. national geographic can't hold a candle to These productions. The cinematography, audio & Presentation are all very well done. Very thorough research as well. All of these factors combined with very clear And pleasing to the ear Narration equals
Documentary excellence.
Ditto, but adding, "Excellent and Superb!"
Alot of it is just smart use of stock footage I believe
Like Mathew said. It's a lot of stock videos. In the first 4 minutes of the video, not a single shot was of Luoyang, an ancient inland city. There was 15 seconds of CGI, 3 minutes of a abandoned village on a small fishing island, and some fillers. You can't really call this a documentary.
Nat Geo is overrated. Lots of competition nowadays. I only stick to UA-cam and Netflix. I dont even know why i have a tv. Serengeti is amazing, though.
@@jayt3972 thanks, I'm wary of long videos because adhd
The description of Emperor Ling doing market role-playing with his women is hilarious @2:04:00, even your voice actor gives a hint. Doing this while the empire goes bankrupt and burns. What great history.
I noticed the voice actor too!
I Love that he included that lol
After spending 3 months in China, one thing I have learned was that China has a long and complicated past, possibly longer than many other civilizations. I found this documentary most intriguing and historically accurate. A superior production. Thank you.
That goes for every ancient civilization. Always complex and above all... Corrupt.
Not surprising considering China is one of the cradles of civilization.
Every segment of this series is as thorough, well-researched, incredibly beautiful and heart-wrenching as the next. The Fall of Civilizations is the best ancient civilizations series ever made.
What I took from this series is that the worst place to be in a rebellion is in the library. Temples and palaces are bad too, but nothing comes close to the fire hazard in libraries.
The arid climate of the Zhongyuan plains and the dryness of bamboo and paper makes for a very flammable environment.
What would us history nerds have done without you Paul. You have created not one but multiple master pieces and all I can do is thank you for it. Never stop please.
I can feel the sadness inside me when I understand the depth meaning of that poem written from a broken heart of a broken hope. Beautiful Poem.
My take to anyone who has not yet watched it: This 3 hour video is one of the best investments of time you will ever make. Team Video Han Dynasty, thank you so much for this gem. I really appreciate your effort and research as much as your empathy and respect for a dynasty and era that I would say is not only a jewel in Chinese history but also in world history.
Thanks my friend, very kind of you.
you are encouraging me to watch this video 6:26
The piece at the end is gorgeous. It speaks of utter devastation, and of the turning of the pages of history. May our own downfall be so beautifully memorialized.
The piano intro gets me every time. I had to learn it for myself just to hear a full version. Your series is gaining the recognition it deserves and these are getting so much better each time!! Absolutely love it
It's called Home at Last by John Bartmann! He'd probably get a kick out of hearing your version.
@@FallofCivilizations A John Bartmann - EDM remix would be great
@@tommole645 No. Just, no.
The 4K is great, thanks for your work, as a history teacher this is like going to the movies to see your subjects play out in the big screen.
Thank you, I'm glad you like it!
@@FallofCivilizations You should do Soviet Union one day. ;)
It's a joke of course but only half so. It was a unique civilization in a way, which is not more.
@@manichaean1888 i'm not sure if you can do the soviet union without the russian empire . so i think it would be a great episode and i second this
@@ascadorcern6106 On one hand, you are right, the SU is still continuation of Russia. On the other, it is a unique culture and civilization on its own.
So, it it limited in time in this sense.
But anyway, I was joking.
@@manichaean1888 I actually do rather like the idea... Even if it doesn't really work, the reasons for its collapse are still in debate and interesting, but maybe a bit too modern. You'd get a lot of arguments in the comments.
I am so glad youtube randomly suggested this series! I'm completely hooked! There are so many scary parallels with current world events in these videos... I have a feeling we might be living through a future episode
I am not being sarcastic with what I am about to write. Of course you see parallels between Han era China; sadly, no, depressingly, there are very few true variations in history. Details may vary, but overall, history just repeats itself, millennia after millennia, in every country, in every culture. Out of periods of chaos and upheaval, civilizations emerge, struggle to a peak, even a flowering, then decadence and decay set in, then fall and the process starts all over. Sometimes the process is measured in centuries, at other times, far less. When I was in school, one teacher, the wife of a Southern Baptist preacher, spent more time going on about parallels between the fall of Rome and the USA in the early 1970s, and pointing out that a sign of "the second coming" was that there would be wars and rumors of wars; a braver classmate pointed out that there had always been wars and rumors of wars. Of course that was not well received, but as unfit as that teacher was, the worst was the geography teacher who was, 20 years later, an unreformed McCarthyite, and how terrifying life was in Soviet Russia and how, Ft. Benning, a first strike target for atomic war, was only 30 miles away. As dysfunctional as this was, I am sure that it has been repeated for millennia - Babylonian teachers terrifying their students with tales of the evil Assyrians, Chinese scholars railing about the evil Mongols. We humans never truly, completely learn.
@@jeraldbaxter3532 Unfortunately, scaring children has been a powerful mind control method that leads to an intoxicating feeling of great power to the people in charge and mass compliance in the populace. It requires a bit of head shaking to clear the mind and violent revolt from time to time to reset for the next round,. We have nothing to fear but fear itself is true to a point. Fear puts you in shackles. Power corrupts, and you have to hide the corruption or you're out of your job. The Catholics taught us all that very clearly and it's pretty much a universal truth when all the checks and balances collapse or are done away with.
I discovered this channel 2 days ago and have already listened to 10 episodes. You've made my night shifts more bearable. Thank you
One of my favorites is the Khmer Empire.
This is the only channel I will not unsubscribe from. Thank you for all the hard work.
Why would you unsubscribe from other channels? Why did you subscribe in the first place?
@@culwin i don't really get what OP meant either 😅
This is the only comment reply I won't delete
Don’t listen to ‘em, Nora. I get the sentiment.a.x
This entire series of fallen civilisations should be watched by everyone on the planet. Amazing.
Paul, You are creating masterpiece. So well researched, so informative and so vividly presented. Sincere congratulations for Your work and thank You.
What awards can we submit him for?
Apparently China had morals at one point, death of a dynasty. China is now enemy #1
@ because Americans can't get richer anymore exploiting them? You are the enemy!
Completely concur with Dragan. Incredibly detailed information & background, all presented without hype or fanfare, laid out in a wonderfully logical & chronological sequence with diversions to other times &/or characters where appropriate. Cannot recommend this video highly enough. MANY thanks for all of your hard work & efforts.
joe in buenos aires
@@joebuenosaires3539 Thank You Joe. Sincere regards to You too.
This was just a fantastic episode. I love that you dedicated such a long time to properly explain how the history went down, made sure to use proper pronunciation, and holy cow I can't imagine how long it took to get the footage for these 3 hours. It honestly felt like I was listening to a condensed version of Game of Thrones-like story set in China.
I've watched this one over 20 times. It's absolutely incredible and also soothing when trying to rest.
The saddest part of all these series is the book burning every civilization has a book Burner 😢
How do you feel about the term "erased from the historical record"? When you think about it... this is really scary.
@@georgehenry76 Have a day off.
@@LordZama Take your own advice.
@@sgswaney You got a point, luv?
We have Amazon. They just banned Clarence Thomas's book
This guy is proof that passion and dedication will lead to success. These videos are incredible.
You are, with no doubt, the greatest documentarian I’ve ever heard. You are an amazing talent.
This whole series should be named “Lament”.
The opening poem written by Chao Zhi (曹植) in July, 211 ACE. Original text below:
步登北邙阪，遙望洛陽山。
洛陽何寂寞，宮室盡燒焚。
垣牆皆頓擗，荆棘上參天。
不見舊耆老，但睹新少年。
側足無行徑，荒疇不復田。
遊子久不歸，不識陌與阡。
中野何蕭條，千里無人煙。
念我平常居，氣結不能言。
Wonderful material, fabulous voice. Still very hard to adequately comprehend the durability and long life of these civilizations.
You do impressive work in a open way that allows even the most novice to understand and digest.
You are a true teacher / organic documentary illustrator sir.
100% on point congrats
It is very difficult to overstate the quality of this work. All aspects so meticulously taken care of. A documentary work of art. Historical poetry.
This is absolutely fascinating! In the West, we don't hear nearly enough about Chinese and other Asian history. Very enlightening and fascinating, particularly the contrast, if you keep in mind the progress of the Greeks and Romans at the time.
I love the music in this podcast. It sounds both sad and inspiring, at different times. Mr. Cooper provides greater insights into Chinese history than I learned in both 7th and 10 grades. History was one of my fave subjects in HS, and no wonder: I practically excelled in the subject and even carried that love into college for my first two years. History remains a favorite subject of learning even after college, grad school and B-school, b/c I read about various period in outside reading sources--both nonfiction and fiction.
I found my education regarding Chinese history and culture to be very lacking in my US high school curriculum. I was in a small town so very possible ours did not provide the best curriculum and/or it depended on the time period in which we went to high school. I did learn more in college, but I was not a history major, so it was limited. That's why I so appreciate these wonderful podcasts to educate me further. They really are like historical documentaries that could definitely be used in classrooms.
The chills down my spine when that last poem was read... How Amazing this trip was
wow I never noticed now much the background music is authentically from the region under discussion until now...amazing production!
Your reference "coalesced like beads of mercury on a table" - wow that brought up memories of playing with beads of mercury from a bottle of it that my brother and I had as kids in the late forties. Kids don't have the joy and fascination of such amusements any more but that reference sure brought back memories. I still have that vial of mercury pilfered from my father's home medical office.
@@spshea I teach children. They still have that fascination. You have no idea the bizarre things I catch children playing with in my classroom, in addition to their smartphones and laptops. Haven't caught mercury yet, but I wouldn't be surprised. LOL. Kids are still kids.
I love watching these videos at night. Often I fall asleep, so I have to watch them again the next night. But these videos bring peace to the end of my day, and I’m actually excited to get to bed. I guess what I’m trying to say is thank you. I’ll keep liking and watching if you keep making them. Please keep making them!
Same here. The documentaries are my bedtime stories. I often drift to sleep while half listening. His voice is sooo soothing. In the morning i have to replay again to confirm if i really heard everything.
Thought I was the only one :D
Mr. Cooper, it is difficult to add anything that has not already been said about your work. You are a master of the narrative arts, an artist of cinematography, a giant of historical context and knowledge, and a brilliant alchemist in combining all of these individual elements into truly compelling, cohesive unions of scholarly production. I can hardly wait to see episodes 12 through 100.
p
worth the binge for all episode.. Love this podcast as I am learning and got mesmerized about the ancient civilization. better than what netflix and other streaming platform can provide..
The Khmer Empire episode is my personal favorite.
Such an amazing Podcast, to you and everyone who created this, thank you! So brilliant, chilling, exciting, and heartbreaking at the same time. The last few minutes got me for sure, watching what is going on now and thinking back when I was growing up, gave me chills for sure! History is such a fascinating mirror, with the hope that it doesn't turn with the same results with a different date in time! Thank you again!!!!
There was a famous saying from Tang empire Li Shining to his advisor: one can learn his dressing from a mirror, the rise and fall of dynasties from history, and the right and wrongs from other people.
I WISH you were teaching me history as a child. I used to hate history growing up and even as an adult, my recurring nightmare is that I’m climbing up the stairs of my old school building and I realize that I have a history exam. I wake up in a panic from my own racing heartbeat. I began watching your stuff because I have been having a sneaking suspicion since 2017/18 that this “US Empire” is going to come tumbling down like the Roman Empire and since I know / remember nothing of history, your channel has been teaching me far more than my textbooks in school. So THANK YOU! 🙏🏼
Dear Paul, I watched this one twice. The beginning is very gripping and emotional, comparing this to a slow car crash is so accurate. Love your narration an d voice.
Excellent documentary. Thank you for sharing your gift with all of us. ❤
One of the few things I have to look forward to the past few months are these videos. Thanks for the great content, UA-cam living up to its potential through your work.
These are the BEST historical videos, right there with Rare Earth for impact and no peer in empire histories, that opening piece of music is so perfect
An amazing compilation of early chinese dynastic history that is the Han Dynasty. Rich and well researched content. Beautiful landscape videography! My only minor gripe is that some imagery that supposedly portray the Han Emperor and it’s court officials included inaccurate images of the Qing Emperor and its officials wearing the famous pigtail hairstyle of the Qing Dynasty - the last dynasty of china were descended from the Manchurians from Northeast China.
This in no way detracts from the immense work that went into making this highly educational documentary on Han China.
I woke up to the Sumerian video and I watched like 3 more videos in a row after. History is one of my FAVORTE things. Thank you for all the hard work and for filling my brain with knowledge in the most pleasant way possible :p
Maaaaaan if high-school history classes were taught in this manner, I'd have been much MUCH more attentive.
This is how history should be taught! Not by textbooks.!
I doubt that. The main difference between any class and UA-cam is that you decide what you watch.
If this interests you, you will listen to it. Any class has the disadvantage that no matter how interesting it tries to be, if you don't care about the topic you won't pay attention.
I think it would be best if we could have mood based learning. Imagine schools would let you choose what to learn after a certain degree of basics completely by yourself. Or let's say you have a set amount of classes you have to attend each year, but you get to decide daily what you feel like learning. Sure, this is a very broad generalization. But I could imagine it would cause people to actually pay attention
These shows make me look back and wish I would have become a history teacher
@@eccomi21 well yes and no..
The self selecting nature of UA-cam does matter, but investigation into the matter has confirmed that test-based curriculum makes it far less likely that children, especially boys, will pay attention in class. Presentation to purpose, like this, does wonders in restoring attention. When students can see why it matters and why it is important AS they learn, it makes a huge difference.
Even if students are exposed to this learning style outside matters they care about, they pay more attention and are more engaged.
I hated all history classes in school. Now here I am in adulthood. Haha
Splendid, just splendid. The sensations of life of these eras bringing history to life, your writing poetic.
Incredible production. Better than any I've seen that were made with many dozens of camera teams, producers, writers, researchers, voice talent, editors, etc.
And conceptually, made with something even more rare, vision.
The podcasts were excellent. The video addition is beyond excellent. I don't know how you do this without the corporate / network support. Your work has been very inspiring to me. Thank you!
A truly amazing series on history so well done they deserve to on TV. This is my favourite episode I love China and it’s history and learning about that history is one of my greatest interests.
Such a beautiful summary of the Han Dynasty! The poems, visuals, geographical info, historical personalities, etc...
If Kongming himself gives such praise you know it is quality content
Fall of Civilizations isThe best historical documentaries ever!
The highway t
They say timing is everything, I just randomly caught the poem at the end of this by chance and it hit me like a sledgehammer, due to personal reasons happening in my life right now, as much tears as it has brought to me, I really needed to hear it, THANK YOU!
I’ve watched most of the videos on this channel, but this is the first one that has made me cry. The closing poem is so deeply, deeply sad
I have listen to them all several times. because there's so much to learn. the way the story is told is, to me, far more exciting than anything that has come out of Hollywood.. EVER.. can't make these stories up, they are so exciting with tragedies , thrills etc..
the first few times, i’ll listen intently to the story, then and often after he's in the background if I'm working and if I'm having a restless night sleep. then ill put a long episode on loop and go to sleep. to get to relive the story again .
i call this type of amazing story telling a compact, university degree. it deserves listening to it in many settings.
THANK YOU so much for doing what you do .. i am excited to see that i am not the only one that loves this podcast. and it also gives me so much hope to see people want to know our collective history and even better, that you and your team are doing all that you do so that we can appreciate our past.
Amazing not only in terms of quality of the historical narrative, but also in terms of linguistic quality. I love listening to British English of the high level and here we also hear some Chinese. I do not speak Chinese at all , but it is so cool to hear some Chinese words/ poems ! I just SUBSCRIBED !
This is simply gorgeous to watch after listening to this many times. Beautiful cinematography
Again, yet another masterful documentary production that eclipses any other productions seen before, save those of the same origin.
Entirely enjoyable in every aspect, but most especially visually.
The amount of work you put into these, and the high quality of them, is greatly appreciated.
These episodes have captivated my family. My youngest doesn’t travel well so it’s a lovely way to experience history without travel.
Thank you so much! This is fantastic! Thank you for speaking slowly enough that I can actually take in what is being said. Thank you for making the study of history thoroughly enjoyable! -Mike T., Los Angeles 🌞❤️
Mr. Cooper is a genius. Best historical podcast I have ever listened too. Thanks Paul!
I have seen about half or more of these visual podcasts by now and I'm blown away by your craftsmanship and dedication. you should be praised a thousand times over for these.
I don't know what else to say except for just, thank you for making these 🙏
Thanks my friend, very kind!
These documentaries are the best thing I have seen on youtube. Well organized, very professional in referring to sources very critically yet still managing to make these stories human and engaging with only very brief relation to our world today. You cannot help but be transported there anyway. In that regard this series haunts me.
Awesome Awesome documentary! I think this is my favourite of these works and I would have never thought a documentary about China and not a Sumerian or Assyrian documentary would normally be at the top of my list.
Also, what a beautifully gorgeous country! My mouth was gaping throughout in complete shock and awe!❤
Wow just wow. I’m speechless and love the 3 kingdoms and all the lure of Chinese history.
I love this channel. As great as Dan Carlin is. FOC is high art and getting better with every episode! Thanks for the hard work and excellence. Cheers from Vancouver B.C.
I'm learning about my own country of my birth ancient history although I'm an American citizen and army veteran, I have studied ancient history of China while on vacation back at my native Daiwan village now at age 93 after many traveling around the world I'm watching UA-cam history of China again!
I had a four hour drive to listen to this in its entirety and I loved this from beginning to end. But the highlights for me were when you talked about the regions of China, how they came to be geographically, and the different peoples that inhabited every corner of the continent. Not only did you lay out the history of this Dynasty in precise chapters, you explained the importance of the terrain and how it affected Chinese history as a whole. Also, bonus points for citing first hand accounts from ancient historians and political figures for exposition. The time and effort that must have gone into this video must have been insane. One of the best history pieces I've ever heard by far.
I feel like I can listen the narrator talk forever. I wished he would continue on with what happened after the fall of Han. Such an interesting and moving history lesson.
Listened to all your podcasts on this channel and no other history channel on UA-cam has actual history presented in such a solid perspective. Phenomenal work from you and your team!
This was absolutely outstanding!! Can't believe these quality programs are here to watch.
Your writing and presentation skills are impressive and appreciated. So many documentaries are sterile and strictly factual, which diminishes one's connection to (and retention of) the content. The degree of empathy that you encode into these "podcasts" brings these ancient civilizations to life.
I scrolled for a bit and didn’t see a comment about it. I absolutely love this series in general and this episode in particular. I grew up playing the Dynasty Warriors video game series and knew that the games were taken off a book(?) that was called the romance of the three kingdoms. It was based loosely around the end of this time period. Connecting the dots before Cao Cao, Liu Bei, and Sun Jiang was super interesting! Keep up the good work!
Was hoping to find a fellow Dw/Three Kingdoms Fan.
Most history professors and experts specialize in one culture, civilization, or epoch. Joseph Campbell specialized in biblical history, Ken Burns American history. Paul has created such a diverse portfolio of expertise to span so many different eras, cultures, and civilizations. He tells stories spanning the globe, spanning every era of written human history, and all causes of the end of civilizations. External invasions in the Easter Island episode, internal rot in the Han dynasty episode, climate change refuges in the Bronze Age episode. He tells stories founded on Chinese classical poetry, Aztec codex, and scholarly research in the Byzantium episodes. Paul has created a true masterpiece to rival those of the Iliad he references in his works. One day when they write the story of the downfall of our civilization, I hope they find a suitable voice to speak Paul's commentary on our times.
Brilliant writing, visuals and editing. This makes for a very immersive, escapist atmosphere. Quality podcasts like these do UA-cam much honor.
I can't imagine this not being so award worthy...Emmy? Oscar? The British equivalent?? Paul Cooper is doing some of the best deep-dive history work in the entire field, & I could watch these visually stunning, deeply researched pieces forever.
You do some of the greatest work of history on the internet. Thank you for weaving together so eloquent all these historical stories and details and even including great poetry. Appreciation
How can learning about the death of civilizations be so relaxing?
there's peace of mind in realizing how little of what we do will have lasting effects.
@@busTedOaS ...might be wishful thinking at this point, but I hear you
It really is captivating yet relaxing, it’s probably why this particular podcast has such a loyal following and great success.
@@busTedOaS wonderful reply
The title does not suit the narrative. But the story line is quite apt
These are, indeed, exquisite! Thank you! I look forward to future episodes, especially I would like to see some about India. (I love India.) Also, I'd love to see some concerning Japan. And more China. I don't think Westerners know nearly enough about the East.
And Korea! Westerners often mention China and Japan while skipping right over Korea, whose dynasties were very stable indeed, and who conducted broad trading.
Your production quality is breathtaking the way your narration seamlessly tie a history lesson into thrilling storytelling and a humbling experience and reminder our time our beautiful civilization will too pass into the pages of time... Cheers from Salt zlake City!!
this is such spectacularly poetic storytelling, i am in awe
As is so often the case..
The research and diligence that went behind this episode is simply astonishing.
A comment like this is not the first time that a viewer of your channel has expressed such gratitude.
And as we will soon learn.. it will be far from the last...
I'm so enjoying this! It's a wonderful presentation, full of details that bring the whole scene to life. I learned more from listening to this than many other such-type documentaries together. And the scenery you include is just wonderful, and the owls and horses, and the poetry. Some of that was just amazing. Thanks so much, great work! Subscribing.
Glad you enjoyed it!
This was so informative. I had only the vaguest idea of Chinese history and this helped flesh out at least part of it. I was moved to tears at the end, to think of so much lost.