Nine Inch Nails - I Can't Give Everything Away (David Bowie cover) live Panorama Festival 2017
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 сер 2017
- "I Can't Give Everything Away" is a song by David Bowie. The song was released as the third and final single from Bowie's twenty-fifth studio album, Blackstar (2016).The track was written by Bowie and produced by Bowie and Tony Visconti.
A reworked version of the song was performed by industrial rock band Nine Inch Nails, who Bowie collaborated and toured with on occasions, during the first show of their I Can't Seem To Wake Up 2017 tour.
Nine Inch Nails Panorama Fest 2017
![David Bowie - ★ (Blackstar) ALBUM REVIEW [R.I.P. BOWIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/AZD9mJ_yGIQ/mqdefault.jpg)
This David Bowie song always makes me cry. I don't know how Trent got through that song.
the 1st 500,000 times or so, when I played Blackstar, I'd go back and listen to the last 2 tracks and just barely not break down in tears. So I get it Jess. I also wonder of Trent gets through easily.
Same. It's the one that broke me I had bought the album only a few days before he died.
He barely did.
can't even hear it without watering my eyes out...
@@nostronico Me too, bought Blackstar the day it came out, and he was gone 2 days later. I still tear up hearing it.
My heart broke when Bowie's voice was played :(
What a spoiler xD
Don’t be sad, be happy! Trent had the opportunity to perform this, and we had the opportunity to hear it. I miss Bowie too, but I’m glad Trent and Atticus got to do this, if even just cathartically.
I was there, for this performance. I don't have the language to convey the emotions I felt, hearing this live.
no one cares
@@CSM100MK2 you can go to hell :)
i can only imagine. i had to come back and watch this having been floored by this performance once before. anyway, the harmonies just kicked in, take care
I was there too
Trent was singing this for his friend and hero who passed. Leave it at that.
Exactly. And you can see and hear Trents hurt from Bowies passing.
@embersoftheabyss yes but both Trent and Bowie are literally the same person, so.
i guess Im quite off topic but does anyone know a good website to stream newly released movies online ?
@Axton Jaxtyn Yea, I have been using flixzone for since march myself =)
@Axton Jaxtyn thanks, signed up and it seems like they got a lot of movies there :D I really appreciate it!
It is nice to hear their voices together once again. When Reznor performed the Downward Spiral, Bowie shared the stage with him performing Hurt. I'm not sure if singing this alongside Bowie's voice triggers that memory for Reznor but I would not be surprised if this was difficult for him
For months after Blackstar was released, after I listened to the whole album, (for what seems like 5,000 listenings) I would reply the last two songs, Dollar Days, and this song. Trent does him justice, this is sublime.
not just Hurt, they were both for Reptile (favorite Bowie song of downward) and for Scary Monsters, Subterraneans and Hallo Spaceboy.
The final song Bowie ever released - there isn’t a more personal, innovative & suitable man to perform this live then Mr. Reznor ❤️
This is so beautiful. The arps at the beginning is like snowflakes falling from the sky
Tears
Him singing together with the recording is kind of like, when you’re alone and you just love the song so much, and you can’t help but sing, even if you don’t necessarily like your own voice (Trent’s voice is beyond sexy, though). It’s kind of like a common nostalgia that continues, and you can revisit with whatever song you like. Do you know what I’m going for?
It kinda feels like a proper "goodbye" from Trent to Bowie
Because when they started being friends they played NIN's Hurt live together, and now that Bowie is gone, Trent is playing one of his songs live while also putting the recording of Bowie's voice to make it seem like they are playing it together, ending it the same way it started i guess
It's like being visited by a ghost, and then the ghost leaves.
loved this comment, exactly how I interpreted the prescence & absence of bowie. Almost like when the giant visited cooper in their dreams (Twin Peaks)
My heart is shattered.
When you fall asleep. You're dreaming. You're in REM. You dream of bits and parts of your life from beginning and until end. That melody is what it makes me feel.
Holly crap, when I heard David's voice over his I just got hit so hard. So beautiful, yet so so sad. Love it.
Simply sad and sublime. Love this cover. NIN did it justice.
I love this version of the song so much, it feels like something off of the downward spiral
Adrift and at peace off the fragile
@@levadura7 Adrift and at peace was from Still wasnt it?
@@tristanraine yes I believed it was a bside, Trent said it's the conclusion to la mer
Aside from this performance, thank your for inspiring “Hearts Filthy Lesson.” As much as genius as David was, there’s no way that song would exists without you.
The composition in this version is so lullaby like, I love it
Simply stunning, you can hear the emotion in Trents voice so hard. You can hear his devastation about bowies death
I had the privilege to hear this live at Aftershock that same year, but it wasn’t the same. This performance is electric.
Great cover! Bowie would be honored!
He is...
heart-renching beautiful version of a gut renching track, which it already is by the great mr. Bowie. they did it proud x
Meu maior império romano é assistir ele cantando hurt com o Bowie todo felizinho e dps vir ver esse cover, penso nisso todo dia
God bless you Trent for doing this. Your still a great musician. i know Bowie was very proud of you and loved you.
The silence at the intro... Pure goosebumps.... and tears today LOVE NIN
still love this.
Wow. Trent just took this to such a personal and emotional place in the best way.
Oh wow, this is hauntingly beautiful.
We don't deserve Trent Reznor
Well that was about more than I could take. Absolutely stunning and heartbreaking and lovely.
RIP Mom. Hope David Bowie is entertaining you the afterlife.
I can't give everything away
Very respectfull and touching homenage. One of the best covers i've heard. Sublime.
Damn...brilliant, moving, ethereal. Wow.
Excellent. Great to watch, hear this. Nice job.
Tears of joy 3am you can hear if you listen to just the music the angles coming down to bring David home and then peacefulness, released from the pain of the body
I wish I could give this the millions of likes it deserves. What an amazing tribute. So much overwhelming emotion. So beautifully sad and so well done. Wow.
Stunning!
this is divine
I miss u David. Miss u a lot.
Such a simply beautiful song
And beautiful version you did here
I love it
WOW!
pure gold
brilliant!
Brilliant !
Niice cover!!
Haunting
This should have been in the Twin Peaks reboot
There’s an idea
Maybe in Season 4 ;)
@@porkwoofles3909 hopefully season 4 happens. I doubt it tho
vladimyr morris If it does then I think it’ll be David Lynch’s final work. His heart isn’t in movies anymore and he is getting older. I don’t think we’ll get any new projects from him in film or tv short of a Twin Peaks 4,
doesnt matter how is their version doing.....he just sings with his heart N respect to A very great friend N mentor to him... can feel his feelings in his tribute
Chilling masterpiece, the friendship they shared was genuine....heartfelt....and kindred. The melody reminds oneself of the soul leaving the body to the next world. No one can escape the cycle...for it is inevitable and true. God bless you both Trent and David
great
Wow 😯 amazing 😻 😢 l❤️❤️❤️❤️ #davidbowie #nin
Pretty epic.
Two genius
i miss Bowie
Мой любимый Дэйф ты всегда будешь рядом с нами в своих песнях 🙃😘💕✊👍✌️🙏😘
I know Trent is a man of word, but still, the music starts at 2:00
Just sublime. Destroyed every time I hear this.
Watching this at 6:11pm and the video is 6 mins and 11 secs…that means something✨🧬✨ thank you
1:48, good job
Devastating
😢
It Hurts
🖤🖤🖤
Missing the Alien 🎵🤘🏻🎵
Fantastic .... Happy Christmas .... I think my youtube Bowie Interpretations might be improving .... less fruit last night and someone clapped ... very slowly, but I'll take it.
4:16 😭
They should have used some delay or reverb on Reznors vox
🕴️💓🎶🌿🏵️🕴️💓🎶🌿🕴️🏵️💓🎶🌿🏵️🕴️💓🎶🕴️💓🎶🌿🏵️
omigod - I was totally expecting him to whine this one out, and be disappointed! But he understood the assignment! however, Bowie deliberately wanted the complexity of that guitar solo to finish this song - which is missing here ...
Охуенное прочтение!
I never liked the original. It was weirdly poppy and upbeat. But this version is legendary.
??? Was the last song on the last album of Bowie... This song is amazing. The "up-beat" was to give contrast.
I liked that it was poppy and upbeat. That was who Bowie was. He could dabble in the dark, but in the end he was the eternal optimist.
@@jessica5497 The song is one of the best Bowie has written, to write off the original is insanity.
@@anabellelei8540 that's what i was saying...like i love trents version, I listen even more than the original, because I identify with the feeling of who singing (trent), even if only a little. But the original is the original.
I thought it was quite sweet that his last ever song to us was... 80s Bowie. It's like he was thumbing his nose, being self-deprecating and waving so long, all at once.
Probably better than the original one
reviloformtamesaws You should listen to the original before you say things like that. Bowie was brilliant!
Cami Castle I like Bowie but this was one carried good too.
reviloformtamesaws....interesting version and I do like it but just the same while subjective IMHO it's far from better than the original . Considering the message Bowie was singing about and the fact it was his last song on the last on the last album he'd ever do.
Johnnywhamo Clearly you don't know anything about the relationship Bowie and Reznor had. This cover is just as good as the original because Bowie himself would have approved of it whole heartedly.
It's called an...OPINION .....as I stated. Have a nice day though.
CRAP
Sorry to hear that's what your Mom said when the pregnancy test came back positive. Must be traumatizing.
Out of tune almost all the time
Stuart Rochabrunt
That's kind of his style a bit y'know
19LapisLazuli No, a good musician or singer will always be on the correct tune, that’s universal, the core of music itsef. That’s not a matter of “style”.
Stuart Rochabrunt piss off back to your chart music, cretin
L B What do you know, ignorant. I’m a musician, and I know what I’m talking about.
Stuart Rochabrunt Right, of course you do. Your self given title of “musician” and probably “artist” surely makes any drivel you spout valid. Forgive my insolence, oh mighty one.
crap
Sorry to hear that's what your Mom said when the pregnancy test came back positive. Must be traumatizing.
@@bigguy1164 copied your answer because it was so good. :)
Rubbish
Love that word
Lame!
Fuck you loser
Sorry to hear that's what your Mom said when the pregnancy test came back positive. Must be traumatizing.
@@robinsalario4372oh, dear... you're the clear proof abortion is way necessary as the world needs no more worthless c u_ nts with bad taste like you.
Más a su estilo IMPOSIBLE ❤️❤️❤️