his music is so dark, real and easily understood in your darkest moments. There's happy, fake music. Then there's real and cruel music. This is what makes Trent, in my opinion, one of the greatest musicians out there. Though most of his music is dark and tragic, it fits and is so relatable. Life has many dark and tragic moments, it brings comfort listening to an artist who knows exactly what you're going through. Keep it real Trent, you'll always be my favorite.
Some of us feel more comfortable in the not so sunshine lollipops feel. Trent Reznor is a comfortable place to be ok with that. That aside he is an amazing musician as are the people who have worked with him through out the years. Truly magic.
When I was pregnant with my son, the ONLY THING that calmed him, was playing N.I.N. through head phones wrapped around my stomach. He spent the 19 short years of his life IMMERSED in " all things Trent." He died in 2016... 2 days after he turned 19.... from cardiomyopathy. 6 years later, wrapping this song around my ears is the ONLY THING that keeps me from giving up the ghost. I miss you DWE 😭💔 P.s.. Trent ... I still pray for your grandma.... Anyone who understands, knows too much... My heart is for you. 💙 Edited 04.21.24 a couple people have asked, so I will clarify. My son lived with me. He went to bed just like normal on the night of 13 September, 2016. The next morning, I found him in his bed, not moving, not breathing. I called 911. (It took them 45 minutes to get there. ) I tried CPR.... I'm 5 feet 5 inches. My son is six feet. I TRIED I TRIED I TRIED I FAILED. The coroner said he had an enlarged heart. He died from Cardiomyopathy. 19 years and 2 days old. Shortly before my son died, he said he hopes he gets to do ONE thing in his life that really matters because he doesn't deserve to have life as good as he has it. I think his death has shown that compassion and sincere support can be found in the least likely of places. Now that he's gone, I'm always terrified that there's never going to be anyone to remember him with me. But I feel like other NIN fans TRULY DO care. If my son were here today, he would say, look for that one friend of family member, or class mate or Co worker, or whomever it is, that is always on the outside. The person who is never cool or popular the person who never gets invited anywhere. Get to know them. Become their friend. You may just find something that you can't buy for all the material riches in the world.
It’s been an honor to be alive during nin existence. Every album released perfectly fit to what was going on in my life and even today as I’m older and they are older I still feel connected to his music no matter what.
its timeless music. i can still remember sitting in the mall parking lot as a teenager listening to a cassette i just bought....an album titled pretty hate machine....i was blown away by it...that was 1989 i think.
I could listen to Nine Inch Nails all day. They are one of the only bands that I have consistently liked since middle school. I'm 22 now, going on 8 years of being a fan.
I hear you. I bought My first nails CD when i was 11 (1993). Pretty Hate Machine. It had been out for about 4 years at the time. 6 months later The Downward Spiral was released. That album changed my life. Been a fan for over 20 years now. I'm seeing NIN in August and am every bit as excited as when i first saw them in 1996.
I discovered him around 6 years ago when I was 20. Pretty "late" in his career. I can listen to any of Trent's work on a daily basis and never get sick of it. He has so much material and it is all so deep and fulfilling that I'll be enjoying it until the day I die. I just hope he keeps making music for another 20 years. He's as good as ever right now.
XD When I was 14, I made my mom buy The Downward Spiral for me. I used to sit in my room for hours listening. I will be 34 this year and I still love this music. Fuck this just makes me cry...
I was in my teens and beginning to wrap my mind around abuse I experienced as a child. The honest sorrow and anger in Reznor's voice - I could relate that to the disgust and anguish I felt. It changed the way I viewed the world and was a catalyst to feel what I needed to, in order to move on.
I still think Trent is one of the most underrated talents of our time , one of those where when he moves on to that great below , people are going to look at his body of work and just go WOW . What a remarkable talent .
He isn’t underrated, he won big awards, it’s not like he’s this industrial underground artist. His music is the closest to mainstream pop as it gets, i’d call it industrial pop. I don’t mean he’s a bad artist, i like NIN, but they’re easy listening compared to other underground industrial acts who are the real geniuses behind industrial music.
I want to be that guy who would give a paragraph essay on why exactly pain exists...but...this sort of pain, truly does tell us that we're still human and alive. I don't believe that there is a meaning to life, you can make your own of course, but that's subjective. Human emotion. So interesting, isn't it? We can't describe it, but we don't need to. That's the truest connection we have with everyone.
know matter your darkest day theres brighter tomorrow,,without the sad there is no happy , ying and yang* . life will happen with or without anyone person but it wouldnt be the same , we live to die and die inside to live , anything worth doing isnt gonna be easy and thats the point ,,GET BUSY LIVING, OR GET BUSY DYING
I'd listen to the words he'd say But in his voice I heard decay The plastic face forced to portray All the insides left cold and gray There is a place that still remains It eats the fear it eats the pain The sweetest price he'll have to pay The day the whole world went away
This song is about the death of Trent's grandmother Clara, but it's more specifically about her funeral. Trent speaking about priest burying his grandmother/cremating her. On the outside, he looks calm and collected, knowing it's his job. But on the inside, it pains him to have to lay another one to rest. Years of these rituals has made his face plastic.. emotionless in front of death which has left him cold and grey. His mind forces him remain apathetic about having to put someone to rest infront of many loved ones, breaking down. The sweetest price the priest will have to pay? When he has to lay the entire world to rest and the whole world goes away. The song is dedicated The priest and his grandmother.. The person who was calm while everyone else was breaking down..
This is the only song I found in all these years that gives me a little of each feeling. Not the typical sad song that makes you cry, no the best song that gives you nostalgia, not the perfect song that makes you feel joy. It's just a song that gives you a piece of everything, like life is. Is the song of the past, is a song for the present, and for what is yet to come.
It was a grey day and I had just started a fire to get rid of old stuff from my mothers house. She was ill in cancer and had spent her last 4 months at the hospital. I started throwing things on the fire, memories that I had no room for. This song started playing on my iPod and everything felt like a film. First time i heard it. So emotional. I played the last two minutes over and over again till the fire was out. It became the soundtrack of my mother and will always stay with me. Amazing song.
Listened to this song a lot while my dad was dealing with liver cancer from his long abuse of alcohol. It was a short battle and he passed away in the middle of the night. This song perfectly matches the feeling deep down that him and I will never be able to mend our relationship. Just thought I'd share some emotions
The first time I listened to this song I was strugling with pancreatic cancer myself, I called my gf at that time to tell her about this beautiful song but she didn't answer, she was pregnant and was being taken to the hospital for a problem in her cervix. She had an abortion that day. After my parents died of old age, without the opportunity to have a grandson/daughter, I listened to this song for answers, over and over. Then I died of cancer, but fortunately, we got wifi here in hell so I can tell my story. Trent used to say, if there is a hell, I'll see you there, so I'm here, waiting patiently for him.
This version of this song makes me bawl my eyes out. It reminds me of my dad and the months leading up to his suicide. Nine Inch Nails is really good at hitting the mark with my various emotions. All of them.
This song takes me back to the day I lost my daughter. That morning was the happiest I had ever been in my life, because she was entering this world. Nothing could've ruined my happiness, or so I thought. Happiness quickly turned into horror and despair, as we were told she had passed just as she was coming into the world. No warning, no "accident" that could've resulted in her death, and no explanation. That is the day the whole world went away for me, and I went away from the world. I'm a ghost of who I was, and who I was going to be. I'll never get that part of me back. My friends and family can tell, no matter how hard I try to show otherwise.
The day my whole world went away was .09.14.16, when my son died from cardiomyopathy 2 days after turning 19. I grew up listening to N.I.N. I played it for him when he was in my tummy..... Trent was his obsession. R.I.P. D.W.E.
This is one the songs I can see myself listening anytime anywhere in the world... at a funeral, in a train, at night in bed, during end of the world, a distant old memory.
I jammed this constantly during my dads short 3 week battle with cancer. It was too late by the time they caught it and he was in too much pain so he was drugged up those last 3 weeks of his life. My father and I were always at odds with eachother and the worse part was there was so much I wanted to say but was afraid to and he could hardly say anything anyway so I just stayed hiding in my room until he passed.
Trent has always had a song for me, this being one of my favorites. It somehow brings tranquility and peace even when dealing with things that makes everyday so challenging. Family issues are so much harder around the holidays. This is why I wish away this part of the year...no one can love or get along...
One of the best musicians of his generation, the piano fills the void and paints the perfect contrast between low and high pitches and tones, masterpiece
My dog passed away from complications after surgery..he's the 10% that wasnt gonna fully recover...put him to sleep..today..looked him in the eyes and whispered to him as he fell...
Despite the quagmire of pain on the road so many have taken by journeying with Trent Reznor from the beginning, there are times when something so unmistakably beautiful graces my senses that this man pulled from the depth of his mind. Truly, few artists in this world reach such a level. But a handful every century and this man stands among the 20th and 21st century as something to aspire toward in soul moving music.
"Thought he had it all, before they called his bluff. Found out that his skin just wasn't thick enough. Wanted to go back to how it was before. And although he'd lost everything, right then he lost a whole lot more." -Trent Reznor
Still is the best thing Trent Reznor ever made. Seriously, a lot of people cite The Downward Spiral as his peak, for one reason or another and I'm not saying it isn't great- because I fucking love The Downward Spiral. But, I genuinely believe Still is a masterpiece.
2 year old comment, But thank you for your service. We civilians could never understand what you guys went through there. Regardless of the purpose of the war, You laid it down and took care of what Was demanded. Thank you.
Cory Meece not as deep or as well as trent reznor. and reznor uses metaphor that everyone can relate to. rappers are so direct and specific and they lack a lot of metaphor that it's hard to relate to their stuff unless you're an angry black guy living in a similar situation.
Cory Meece Unfortunately rap lacks musical nuance... not that beats aren't sick, they just don't reflect the emotional spectrum required to make an all-consuming song.
Aaaah I see wat u did there they have used nineinchnails forever to movies look at the movie seven at the beginning or man on fire I man on fire list goes on and on
I feel like I relate to most of his songs. The struggle is real. Mine being anxiety and depression caused by panic disorder. Yet when I go through it, I find myself comforted by Trent and his music. The unique sound and style combined with the powerful lyrics are something we can all feel in our bones.
I knew this song (and NIN) from the trailer for Terminator Salvation back in 2009, but I heard this version for the first time in The Bear S2. Amazing piece, every version fits on a different mood and hits perfectly
I’ve luved Trent since the 80’s whether it’s the “darkest moments” or just LIFE in general. He definitely feels or understands the “hurt” many of us know.
I immediately recognized the song being a long time fan.. But even though it already had very emotional meaning to me... Hearing it during the end of the person of interest episode.. it even gave me more chills. I will miss Root. Thanks Trent for your epic music!
MickAri B Once I saw the title of the episode, I knew this song would play, and I knew it was going to be a doozy. I'm pretty mad that I wasn't wrong. That scene with this song and the overall plot line of that show, was the perfect mixture. Easily one of my favorite moments of any form of media. Great artist, great show, great character.
curling up in a ball crying, this song ringing through my mind like the white noise that some parts of life give you. everything seems so fragile and delicate when i hear this song, like your entire life is leading up to one moment of final pain. to all of you out there that feel the same way when you hear this song, i hope that you all can find comfort in realising that your pain is alike to many others, despite the fact you may not believe so. love everyone, and live for those you love (if you dont like other people, then give care and love to yourself).
Born in 84 I grew up listening to nine inch nails and have all the respect for Trent a great artist and in the end this song is part of all of us and we all can relate to it is what brings us all together as brothers and sisters and mothers and fathers..
I'd listen to the words he'd say but in his voice I heard decay the plastic face forced to portray all the insides left cold and gray there is a place that still remains it eats the fear it eats the pain the sweetest price he'll have to pay the day the whole world went away
Cody Osborn The lyrics are saying that "the whole world went away" when Jesus died and Christianity was born. A derogatory message against Christianity. "The plastic face forced to portray" is the Crucifix. "The insides left cold and gray" means he doesn't believe Jesus was Christ, God's son or anything more than any other person on Earth and He didn't resurrect after crucifixion because His insides and organs died, just like everyone else. I'm a Christian, so I'm not saying this because I believe it.
This song helps when you feel you're whole world is going to fall apart. No reason, no explanation: just the feeling of not being where you're supposed to be, doing what you're supposed to do. Not knowing the answers to questions you cannot even come up with. The start is desperate, the ending is stimulating, like a mantra: it helps you level with yourself. I'm not making sense, am I? But then again, neither is the human mind.
One of my Fucking ALL TIMEEEE favorite NIN songs and they used is the Bear?!?!! Whatttt The music supervisor on this show is unreal. Sufjan, Radiohead, and Nine inch Nails all used in season 2.
This song makes me think of my relationship I have with god and the depression I go threw everyday, the build up is the strength to carry threw to the next, Trent’s music has a pain that is easy to relate to
Mine was never opioids or opiates mine was crack cocaine 17 years took thousands and thousands of dollars away from myself and I know what you mean 2 years 2 months sober today
"UHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHAAAAHHHH" - Jesus trent, I'm all in a good mood and with good energy and I just have to stop to comment and appreciate the crazy amount of pressure from this man's mind in how he expresses his music. It feels like more than just music, as if it's a connection from another dimension and not just an onset of simple tones and overtones with frequencies aligning to create a recognizable pattern to illustrate a greater, deeper meaning. I'm happy right now, which is funny because this music is getting me so close to crying from the pain and the past, the realization that we as people, you me are still here; We are gifted with life and it is beautiful even in the sadness that I and many other people have experienced, that the best feeling (I don't value feelings too much as most of mine have been more negative than positive although I have felt amazing many times). At least in my case, I've always been an observer, that has been my greatest flaw and gift at the same time. Just like everyone else, questioning what actually matters to you. Anyways... I figure a lot of the things I type are in the moment sort of things, we are always growing. Expression is beautiful and Trent Reznor fucking nailed it. Like everytime, lol. *bows to him*
How addiction feels literally one minute everything is fine you're social having fun then suddenly you look up and the funs stopped you're on your own and your world does go away replaced with chemical joys and living for the next fix constantly on and off thinking of it like it's the most important thing in your mind
The day my world went away was December 2nd, 2018 when my own Grandmother passed away, you can't talk about it, you have to go through it to experience how debilitating loss really is. This track is more of a mournful elegy that totally captures that personal loss. I thank you Trent and Nine Inch Nails for creating this and helping those who grieve. Rest in Peace, Grandma. You will never be forgotten by those who knew and loved you.
I probably started listening to NIN a little too early. Even then I was amazed by how intricate his music was and how he put emotions directly into music. Gave me chills then, gives me chills now. This is and always will be true music. No matter what Trent does be it happy or otherwise, I'll listen to it a love it.
Questo brano mi fa volare verso un paradossale senso di malinconia riguardo ciò che si lascia e un senso di ottimismo inerente ciò a cui si va incontro... Bellissimo e introspettivo viaggio interiore! 👍
This reminds me of Gramps when he and Granny first visited me on May of 2017. Gramps had only three months left to live. His death was at August 15th, 2017. Rest in peace, old timer. Me and Granny will never forget you.
This remix reminds me of my first steps into Reznors music masterpieces. I love "TDTWWA" and when I've heard this remix for the first time, I was rapt by the music he composed. It sounds silly, but Trent Reznor is my greatest music heroes of all time. It's because of him I started to LISTEN and to FEEL the music. So much beauty inside such a simple sounds. I hope someday I'll have opportunity to thank him for everything, because his music was accompanied me in every moment of my adult life.
i cant thank you enough for this trent, you gave me the words. i thought i was alone all these years, and now i cant deny that i was wrong. you cant live life without death. you cant experience happiness without having been in pain.
my brother died from a brain tumour two years ago and i’ve only recently began to let myself feel it. i put this on the other day and just broke down in tears around the 2:30 mark. trent is a professional
This is my favourite version. This and the solo from To Live is to Die immediately take me to my memories of my parents who have since passed. The music...the music.
his music is so dark, real and easily understood in your darkest moments. There's happy, fake music. Then there's real and cruel music. This is what makes Trent, in my opinion, one of the greatest musicians out there. Though most of his music is dark and tragic, it fits and is so relatable. Life has many dark and tragic moments, it brings comfort listening to an artist who knows exactly what you're going through. Keep it real Trent, you'll always be my favorite.
100% agree. Identifiable. Relatable. It is a mirror. We see ourselves reflected in his Music.
Happy music is not just fake music. There are different emotions you can put into your music, it's real if you put your soul in it.
Some of us feel more comfortable in the not so sunshine lollipops feel. Trent Reznor is a comfortable place to be ok with that. That aside he is an amazing musician as are the people who have worked with him through out the years. Truly magic.
Well said my friend 🙌
Same. My number 1 always!
When I was pregnant with my son, the ONLY THING that calmed him, was playing N.I.N. through head phones wrapped around my stomach.
He spent the 19 short years of his life IMMERSED in " all things Trent."
He died in 2016... 2 days after he turned 19.... from cardiomyopathy.
6 years later, wrapping this song around my ears is the ONLY THING that keeps me from giving up the ghost.
I miss you DWE 😭💔
P.s.. Trent ... I still pray for your grandma.... Anyone who understands, knows too much... My heart is for you. 💙
Edited 04.21.24 a couple people have asked, so I will clarify. My son lived with me. He went to bed just like normal on the night of 13 September, 2016.
The next morning, I found him in his bed, not moving, not breathing. I called 911. (It took them 45 minutes to get there. ) I tried CPR.... I'm 5 feet 5 inches. My son is six feet. I TRIED I TRIED I TRIED I FAILED.
The coroner said he had an enlarged heart. He died from Cardiomyopathy. 19 years and 2 days old.
Shortly before my son died, he said he hopes he gets to do ONE thing in his life that really matters because he doesn't deserve to have life as good as he has it.
I think his death has shown that compassion and sincere support can be found in the least likely of places.
Now that he's gone, I'm always terrified that there's never going to be anyone to remember him with me. But I feel like other NIN fans TRULY DO care.
If my son were here today, he would say, look for that one friend of family member, or class mate or Co worker, or whomever it is, that is always on the outside. The person who is never cool or popular the person who never gets invited anywhere. Get to know them. Become their friend. You may just find something that you can't buy for all the material riches in the world.
Too bad im the only one saying this but I'm sorry
@@santirocks Thank you so much. 🤗
@@lindakay9552 of course!
rad
This just made me cry so hard. Thank you for sharing that.
It’s been an honor to be alive during nin existence. Every album released perfectly fit to what was going on in my life and even today as I’m older and they are older I still feel connected to his music no matter what.
He. Its only Trent in NIN.
His music has hit me in this way also. Every song fits a moment in my life whether happy or sad.
@@vitalixy3578 man u can say they for singular. not tryna be gronky troll but ur not even grammar nazi properly hahaha
its timeless music. i can still remember sitting in the mall parking lot as a teenager listening to a cassette i just bought....an album titled pretty hate machine....i was blown away by it...that was 1989 i think.
I continue to be entranced and moved by his artwork. Thanks you!
I could listen to Nine Inch Nails all day. They are one of the only bands that I have consistently liked since middle school. I'm 22 now, going on 8 years of being a fan.
I hear you. I bought My first nails CD when i was 11 (1993). Pretty Hate Machine. It had been out for about 4 years at the time. 6 months later The Downward Spiral was released. That album changed my life. Been a fan for over 20 years now. I'm seeing NIN in August and am every bit as excited as when i first saw them in 1996.
I discovered him around 6 years ago when I was 20. Pretty "late" in his career. I can listen to any of Trent's work on a daily basis and never get sick of it. He has so much material and it is all so deep and fulfilling that I'll be enjoying it until the day I die. I just hope he keeps making music for another 20 years. He's as good as ever right now.
Dude same...but since 5th grade ..am now 38
XD When I was 14, I made my mom buy The Downward Spiral for me. I used to sit in my room for hours listening. I will be 34 this year and I still love this music. Fuck this just makes me cry...
It's awesome. Been jamming since at least 2004 to them. Great in concert too!!! Top 5 shows I've been too.
Trent Reznor is completely unique artist and hauntingly intelligent, groundbreaking in a way Pink Floyd was...genuine artistry.
atomi62 My 2 favorite bands of all time. Lmao I love it!!
My favorite bands too
Hes underrated in my opinion.
NIN are great and Trent an assett, Pink Floyd? No.
I wholeheartedly and passionately agree. I'd throw Caspian in that category as well.
reminds me of my 7 year heroin addiction....Definitely the soundtrack to that day I had my first hit...5 years clean today
Lyanna Targaryen Nice work that is impressive!
Keep kicking ass!
Lyanna Targaryen A glorious hug from me!
Just try beating Clonazepam and your heroin addiction will seem like a vacation
Kaecilius don't understand the point of this comment trying to 1-up on struggle
I was in my teens and beginning to wrap my mind around abuse I experienced as a child. The honest sorrow and anger in Reznor's voice - I could relate that to the disgust and anguish I felt. It changed the way I viewed the world and was a catalyst to feel what I needed to, in order to move on.
Someone is feeling that way now. You could make it all go away
Me too.
I’ve been there too, friend. The realization that I can do better by someone else was the start of my healing.
GOD
I like this- makes you feel what you need to, then you can move on.
I still think Trent is one of the most underrated talents of our time , one of those where when he moves on to that great below , people are going to look at his body of work and just go WOW . What a remarkable talent .
He's not underrated at all. Those who know it goes without saying.
But I feel ya on the comment
Hall Of Fame career. A tortured genius who overcame his battles.
Wut... underrated? Academy award winner, Golden globe award winner, Emmy award winner....
He isn’t underrated, he won big awards, it’s not like he’s this industrial underground artist. His music is the closest to mainstream pop as it gets, i’d call it industrial pop. I don’t mean he’s a bad artist, i like NIN, but they’re easy listening compared to other underground industrial acts who are the real geniuses behind industrial music.
The darkness in me never stops growing.
I want to be that guy who would give a paragraph essay on why exactly pain exists...but...this sort of pain, truly does tell us that we're still human and alive. I don't believe that there is a meaning to life, you can make your own of course, but that's subjective. Human emotion. So interesting, isn't it? We can't describe it, but we don't need to. That's the truest connection we have with everyone.
Life is meaningless with or without it. It may just appear meaningful with it. It's not
know matter your darkest day theres brighter tomorrow,,without the sad there is no happy , ying and yang* . life will happen with or without anyone person but it wouldnt be the same , we live to die and die inside to live , anything worth doing isnt gonna be easy and thats the point ,,GET BUSY LIVING, OR GET BUSY DYING
Don't look to deep into it bro pain just nerves sending signals to our brain letting us know some things wrong lol
@@RLR313 Shawshank Redemption quote.
I'd listen to the words he'd say
But in his voice I heard decay
The plastic face forced to portray
All the insides left cold and gray
There is a place that still remains
It eats the fear it eats the pain
The sweetest price he'll have to pay
The day the whole world went away
This song is about the death of Trent's grandmother Clara, but it's more specifically about her funeral.
Trent speaking about priest burying his grandmother/cremating her.
On the outside, he looks calm and collected, knowing it's his job. But on the inside, it pains him to have to lay another one to rest. Years of these rituals has made his face plastic.. emotionless in front of death which has left him cold and grey.
His mind forces him remain apathetic about having to put someone to rest infront of many loved ones, breaking down.
The sweetest price the priest will have to pay? When he has to lay the entire world to rest and the whole world goes away.
The song is dedicated The priest and his grandmother.. The person who was calm while everyone else was breaking down..
Amazing!!!!
When did he say this
I hope i die before my parents. They enjoy their lives and i could give a shit about mine
@@junglejarred6366 if your child dies your life sucks though
@@warnerunterbrink9386 that doesn't change my hopes in the least
This is the only song I found in all these years that gives me a little of each feeling. Not the typical sad song that makes you cry, no the best song that gives you nostalgia, not the perfect song that makes you feel joy. It's just a song that gives you a piece of everything, like life is. Is the song of the past, is a song for the present, and for what is yet to come.
Yeah, they’re pretty smart with this RocknRoll stuff. Lots of metaphorical stuff I’ve geeked on since my early teens. Like, how tf did you know?🧐
Pretty sure that what he meant it as plus trying to also say how bad we fucked this planet helps
I am listening to this while writing a script. Your words captured the essence of this song perfectly.
R.i.p the mother of my children, baby we miss you and will never stop loving you
It was a grey day and I had just started a fire to get rid of old stuff from my mothers house. She was ill in cancer and had spent her last 4 months at the hospital. I started throwing things on the fire, memories that I had no room for. This song started playing on my iPod and everything felt like a film. First time i heard it. So emotional. I played the last two minutes over and over again till the fire was out. It became the soundtrack of my mother and will always stay with me. Amazing song.
So sorry about your mother.
stop guys I'm crying already
Listened to this song a lot while my dad was dealing with liver cancer from his long abuse of alcohol. It was a short battle and he passed away in the middle of the night. This song perfectly matches the feeling deep down that him and I will never be able to mend our relationship. Just thought I'd share some emotions
The first time I listened to this song I was strugling with pancreatic cancer myself, I called my gf at that time to tell her about this beautiful song but she didn't answer, she was pregnant and was being taken to the hospital for a problem in her cervix. She had an abortion that day. After my parents died of old age, without the opportunity to have a grandson/daughter, I listened to this song for answers, over and over. Then I died of cancer, but fortunately, we got wifi here in hell so I can tell my story. Trent used to say, if there is a hell, I'll see you there, so I'm here, waiting patiently for him.
When just a song becomes so powerfull, and inmortalizes those powerfull moments. That's just unexplainable
This version of this song makes me bawl my eyes out.
It reminds me of my dad and the months leading up to his suicide.
Nine Inch Nails is really good at hitting the mark with my various emotions. All of them.
I'm sorry about your dad. I'm worried about mine.
Sorry about your loss , stay strong .
Hope it all works out .
god damn that comment almost made me :'(
+mr5elfde5truct my dad worries me too. He's tried
Anyone still here ?
2024 and I'm still here
yes
Never left 😉
2024 yes
This song takes me back to the day I lost my daughter. That morning was the happiest I had ever been in my life, because she was entering this world. Nothing could've ruined my happiness, or so I thought. Happiness quickly turned into horror and despair, as we were told she had passed just as she was coming into the world. No warning, no "accident" that could've resulted in her death, and no explanation. That is the day the whole world went away for me, and I went away from the world. I'm a ghost of who I was, and who I was going to be. I'll never get that part of me back. My friends and family can tell, no matter how hard I try to show otherwise.
So sorry for your loss!
So sorry brother
So sorry, sending a prayer to you. Thank you for sharing.
⚘️⚘️⚘️⚘️⚘️⚘️
I lost my daughter at 21 not sure which would be worse.
Praying for you
I like how Trent can make sad songs sound so hopeful and uplifting. Listening to them only makes me feel good.
IrishDutchman alchemy. Solve et coagula 😈
Catharsis.
Trent is the very definition of the tortured artist. Brilliant and beautiful
Ask any mother, the birthing of new life is full of pain, anxiety and uncertainty, but it's not torture, it's beauty. :)
The day my whole world went away was .09.14.16, when my son died from cardiomyopathy 2 days after turning 19.
I grew up listening to N.I.N.
I played it for him when he was in my tummy.....
Trent was his obsession.
R.I.P. D.W.E.
I'm so sorry for your loss.
I'm so sorry
@@brostoevsky8481 thank you so much. 🤗
نفسو بالسما.
It’s something we say here in Lebanon, it goes something like “he’s in heaven”.
May he rest in peace.
@@Danny-wv8ec thank you. 💙
This is one the songs I can see myself listening anytime anywhere in the world... at a funeral, in a train, at night in bed, during end of the world, a distant old memory.
I jammed this constantly during my dads short 3 week battle with cancer. It was too late by the time they caught it and he was in too much pain so he was drugged up those last 3 weeks of his life. My father and I were always at odds with eachother and the worse part was there was so much I wanted to say but was afraid to and he could hardly say anything anyway so I just stayed hiding in my room until he passed.
Say it now. ❤️❤️
This song restores me.
+Noah Benzing my exact thoughts..
+Noah Benzing a sad song that makes me full of energy again in a bad day, it also restores me.
Noah Benzing to a better time?
Trent has always had a song for me, this being one of my favorites. It somehow brings tranquility and peace even when dealing with things that makes everyday so challenging. Family issues are so much harder around the holidays. This is why I wish away this part of the year...no one can love or get along...
One of the best musicians of his generation, the piano fills the void and paints the perfect contrast between low and high pitches and tones, masterpiece
My dog passed away from complications after surgery..he's the 10% that wasnt gonna fully recover...put him to sleep..today..looked him in the eyes and whispered to him as he fell...
Despite the quagmire of pain on the road so many have taken by journeying with Trent Reznor from the beginning, there are times when something so unmistakably beautiful graces my senses that this man pulled from the depth of his mind. Truly, few artists in this world reach such a level. But a handful every century and this man stands among the 20th and 21st century as something to aspire toward in soul moving music.
"Thought he had it all, before they called his bluff.
Found out that his skin just wasn't thick enough.
Wanted to go back to how it was before.
And although he'd lost everything, right then he lost a whole lot more."
-Trent Reznor
You're right. It's just a tragedy that these days all he seems to care about is dressing like Bono and selling overpriced collector vinyl.
so well said
Phil Thompson yeah he's getting rich off his vinyl editions. I was wondering how he had the opportunity to work on 30 years of composing
Hear! Hear!
Still is the best thing Trent Reznor ever made. Seriously, a lot of people cite The Downward Spiral as his peak, for one reason or another and I'm not saying it isn't great- because I fucking love The Downward Spiral. But, I genuinely believe Still is a masterpiece.
It's the year the whole world went away
2020
imo it went away in 2012
2021lol
and in the end dirt is heavier than your gold always
The beauty of this version of this song is beyond me.
Still is just a masterpiece.
Lady C nin girls are a masterpiece
I used to fall asleep listening to the "Still" album when I was in Iraq.
2 year old comment,
But thank you for your service.
We civilians could never understand what you guys went through there.
Regardless of the purpose of the war,
You laid it down and took care of what
Was demanded. Thank you.
@@br4d048 Purpose of war? Greed and political interest. There's nothing brave about sending innocent people far away just.. for nothing.
For my grandma. You were the light in my life.
Probably one of the best/saddest/most beautiful songs of all time. Period
Yes, probably.
I love how Trent is the only artist that writes exclusively about inner struggle. No artist comes close in my opinion.
Plenty of artists rap about inner struggle .. It's not an uncommon thing
Cory Meece not as deep or as well as trent reznor. and reznor uses metaphor that everyone can relate to. rappers are so direct and specific and they lack a lot of metaphor that it's hard to relate to their stuff unless you're an angry black guy living in a similar situation.
Cory Meece Unfortunately rap lacks musical nuance... not that beats aren't sick, they just don't reflect the emotional spectrum required to make an all-consuming song.
ZombieDeathRace Then you have to listen to Gopher Guts, Daylight or Fumes from Aesop Rock.
Pete Agassi I agree with you. I can relate to his music in so many ways. I can feel what he is saying. Helps me get through hard times.
This is John Conner. If your listening to this...you are the resistance...
oooh yeah :D
Aaaah I see wat u did there they have used nineinchnails forever to movies look at the movie seven at the beginning or man on fire I man on fire list goes on and on
I knew you were real!!!!!
I feel like I relate to most of his songs. The struggle is real. Mine being anxiety and depression caused by panic disorder. Yet when I go through it, I find myself comforted by Trent and his music. The unique sound and style combined with the powerful lyrics are something we can all feel in our bones.
Same here bro...I know the struggle is real but there is always a way.Stay strong champ!
@Alex B. M. oh the troll generation and the need to mock people who put there selves out there. You lack of empathy astounds me
same bro, his music always makes me calm whenever i start stressed out. its just like a cure for me..
Trent makes a single note echo in your soul,and haunt.
I knew this song (and NIN) from the trailer for Terminator Salvation back in 2009, but I heard this version for the first time in The Bear S2. Amazing piece, every version fits on a different mood and hits perfectly
I’ve luved Trent since the 80’s whether it’s the “darkest moments” or just LIFE in general. He definitely feels or understands the “hurt” many of us know.
I immediately recognized the song being a long time fan.. But even though it already had very emotional meaning to me... Hearing it during the end of the person of interest episode.. it even gave me more chills. I will miss Root. Thanks Trent for your epic music!
Right on bro... You read my mind
MickAri B Once I saw the title of the episode, I knew this song would play, and I knew it was going to be a doozy. I'm pretty mad that I wasn't wrong. That scene with this song and the overall plot line of that show, was the perfect mixture. Easily one of my favorite moments of any form of media.
Great artist, great show, great character.
curling up in a ball crying, this song ringing through my mind like the white noise that some parts of life give you. everything seems so fragile and delicate when i hear this song, like your entire life is leading up to one moment of final pain. to all of you out there that feel the same way when you hear this song, i hope that you all can find comfort in realising that your pain is alike to many others, despite the fact you may not believe so. love everyone, and live for those you love (if you dont like other people, then give care and love to yourself).
I want this played at my funeral.
+Phil Krzycki right?
It's so beautiful, somber, and soothing all at the same time.
+Phil Krzycki Hell, I want my funeral played at this!
+Phil Krzycki me to me too
Me too
Whatever it is. Don't let it Win.
chacha leo I give up
Still fighting....
Aye
Thanks man
Im trying...
One of the only NIN songs that end with hope
:)))))))))
~NMB
Rest in peace my sister. Hopefully we'll meet again one day.
I've lost my best friend of 25 years last month. There's no replacement. I've lost people but... we came up together. I'm trying to get better.
Love the use of this in The Bear!
I was there when it came out. The web site was great back than.
This track puts me at peace.
The quality of the comments on this video is above average.
I never expect anything else when true music is involved.
Even more so with songs like this.
Born in 84 I grew up listening to nine inch nails and have all the respect for Trent a great artist and in the end this song is part of all of us and we all can relate to it is what brings us all together as brothers and sisters and mothers and fathers..
I'd listen to the words he'd say
but in his voice I heard decay
the plastic face forced to portray
all the insides left cold and gray
there is a place that still remains
it eats the fear it eats the pain
the sweetest price he'll have to pay
the day the whole world went away
+ART shadow MAKE UP Thank you, Queen Marjorie.
...what does it mean... Do you think?
Cody Osborn The lyrics are saying that "the whole world went away" when Jesus died and Christianity was born. A derogatory message against Christianity. "The plastic face forced to portray" is the Crucifix. "The insides left cold and gray" means he doesn't believe Jesus was Christ, God's son or anything more than any other person on Earth and He didn't resurrect after crucifixion because His insides and organs died, just like everyone else. I'm a Christian, so I'm not saying this because I believe it.
Raining BlackAndBlue Wow, that's powerful. Thanks for the explanation
that's one way, i guess.
there's other ways. See songmeanings.com/songs/view/18604/
3:38 these piano notes kill me all the time
same
Yes
God same. He is amazing with simple piano melodies.
393 people had so many tears in their eyes that they missed the thumbs up button .......
This song helps when you feel you're whole world is going to fall apart. No reason, no explanation: just the feeling of not being where you're supposed to be, doing what you're supposed to do. Not knowing the answers to questions you cannot even come up with. The start is desperate, the ending is stimulating, like a mantra: it helps you level with yourself.
I'm not making sense, am I? But then again, neither is the human mind.
I feel ya ❤
What a year.
i love the weight of the jewels and the dirt ..dirt wins ...then the feather symbolic of the soul floating to heaven
This is the best version. Or maybe I just say that because the piano.. I reeaally like piano.
Dont know where I'd be without music
@trenton moore
Same here
One of my Fucking ALL TIMEEEE favorite NIN songs and they used is the Bear?!?!! Whatttt
The music supervisor on this show is unreal. Sufjan, Radiohead, and Nine inch Nails all used in season 2.
YESSS absolute genius
My God did you feel that your life just flushed before your ears
Sunny summer, 20 years old, headphones, NIN in full blast, shirtless, skating all day long and getting injured. 20 years ago...
One of the most beautiful things I've ever heard, all these years and I could never stop listening.
I would love to sit on a hill top and just watch everything burn & sink to it's demise.
I would like that too.
jasonkingj69 frfr 💯
Me too
I hope trent made this not knowing how many people would die for his music
This song makes me think of my relationship I have with god and the depression I go threw everyday, the build up is the strength to carry threw to the next, Trent’s music has a pain that is easy to relate to
Mine was never opioids or opiates mine was crack cocaine 17 years took thousands and thousands of dollars away from myself and I know what you mean 2 years 2 months sober today
The sweetest price we'll have to pay, the day the whole world goes away...
He wrote this when his Grandmother died.
the one that raised him?
His Grandmother Clara.
@@riotjohndoe bitch what?
@@johnthetampon6940 what tha fuck are you on about?
@@hellohello4438 me too. r.i.p.
The Bear. The fuckin' Bear.
This song makes depression sound audible.
RIP Gramps. Love you buddy
this song is perfection...brings me back
if you shed enough skin, muscle, nerve and bone, will you look behind at what you were, or will you be looked at by what you've lost?
J
Who wrote what you just said..... it's beautiful
@@wadesdead I did.
@@hypocritespun7971 help. I can't see my way out.
RIP Root ! You will live forever in the Machine !
*cries inconsolable*
When i die...
Bury me with this song and NIN discography in cascet.
"UHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHAAAAHHHH" - Jesus trent, I'm all in a good mood and with good energy and I just have to stop to comment and appreciate the crazy amount of pressure from this man's mind in how he expresses his music. It feels like more than just music, as if it's a connection from another dimension and not just an onset of simple tones and overtones with frequencies aligning to create a recognizable pattern to illustrate a greater, deeper meaning. I'm happy right now, which is funny because this music is getting me so close to crying from the pain and the past, the realization that we as people, you me are still here; We are gifted with life and it is beautiful even in the sadness that I and many other people have experienced, that the best feeling (I don't value feelings too much as most of mine have been more negative than positive although I have felt amazing many times). At least in my case, I've always been an observer, that has been my greatest flaw and gift at the same time. Just like everyone else, questioning what actually matters to you. Anyways... I figure a lot of the things I type are in the moment sort of things, we are always growing. Expression is beautiful and Trent Reznor fucking nailed it. Like everytime, lol. *bows to him*
I like his music more now then i did years ago that dont seem that long ago theres truth to it i feel
Terminator salvation trailer music brought me here
I could always identify with nice inch nails music. When I was a teenager I was feeling what he was singing about.
How addiction feels literally one minute everything is fine you're social having fun then suddenly you look up and the funs stopped you're on your own and your world does go away replaced with chemical joys and living for the next fix constantly on and off thinking of it like it's the most important thing in your mind
Same bro
Most beautiful melody i ever heard. Something incredible.
Most perfect comment I ever read. Ya wouldn't wanna be me.
Beautiful imagery to accompany this powerful music. Thank you!
The day my world went away was December 2nd, 2018 when my own Grandmother passed away, you can't talk about it, you have to go through it to experience how debilitating loss really is. This track is more of a mournful elegy that totally captures that personal loss. I thank you Trent and Nine Inch Nails for creating this and helping those who grieve.
Rest in Peace, Grandma. You will never be forgotten by those who knew and loved you.
Ian Oliver , sorry for your loss. I lost my grandmother December 14th, 2018 and my heart is broken forever 💔
One year later, I haven't forgotten, nor stopped honoring your memory any less my precious Grandmother. You will always be in my heart.
I would hope with seven minutes left on my death bed I could listen to this on my way out. I've always felt this was a goodbye.
Exactly !!
I probably started listening to NIN a little too early. Even then I was amazed by how intricate his music was and how he put emotions directly into music. Gave me chills then, gives me chills now. This is and always will be true music. No matter what Trent does be it happy or otherwise, I'll listen to it a love it.
Redemption starts at 2:27 most powerful movement my ears ever heard restored me before pulling the plug on this thing we call a beautiful life.
Salv My favorite part of the song starts there, it sounds so beautiful.
This song never grows old. I always get the emotion in it.. it's just raw on a plate no frills, just it is what it is...and I like it :)
Pain
I know!
one of the best songs ever made( the still acoustic version)
Questo brano mi fa volare verso un paradossale senso di malinconia riguardo ciò che si lascia e un senso di ottimismo inerente ciò a cui si va incontro... Bellissimo e introspettivo viaggio interiore! 👍
This reminds me of Gramps when he and Granny first visited me on May of 2017. Gramps had only three months left to live. His death was at August 15th, 2017.
Rest in peace, old timer. Me and Granny will never forget you.
Came here from Westworld and I'm so thankful for that! Love this masterpiece!🎉
This song continues to age better and better with each listen
This remix reminds me of my first steps into Reznors music masterpieces. I love "TDTWWA" and when I've heard this remix for the first time, I was rapt by the music he composed. It sounds silly, but Trent Reznor is my greatest music heroes of all time. It's because of him I started to LISTEN and to FEEL the music. So much beauty inside such a simple sounds. I hope someday I'll have opportunity to thank him for everything, because his music was accompanied me in every moment of my adult life.
i cant thank you enough for this trent, you gave me the words. i thought i was alone all these years, and now i cant deny that i was wrong.
you cant live life without death. you cant experience happiness without having been in pain.
my brother died from a brain tumour two years ago and i’ve only recently began to let myself feel it. i put this on the other day and just broke down in tears around the 2:30 mark. trent is a professional
@Motodomokun i'm familiar but i appreciate you mentioning it. You can really tell he gets it haha
13 years still so deeply moving
This is my favourite version. This and the solo from To Live is to Die immediately take me to my memories of my parents who have since passed. The music...the music.