I drank a bottle of tequila laying in my bedroom floor listening to this song over and over. You cannot die of a broken heart, you only wish you could.
Lest the soul could not carry on, one may find death in small bits and pieces only to find something against their contrast, something horrendously beautiful to strive for, even if one can never have it.
Shout out to those who loved this song since their teenage years. Life has been rough for us all but if you're here reading this, listening again at 40+ know you're so much stronger than you think or know. 'It can't rain all the time' .
Remember when albums were oy released on Tuesdays and there would be lines going to buy the next cd NIN or Tool or any other group you were into. Along with Parade magazine once a month to tear out mini posters of Trent Korn and Beastie Boys to hang up on my wall... I was what in 8th or 9th grade when I first heard him sing save just turned 40 last week still jammin out with my clam out listening to Trent Rock out with his co..... You get the point right😂
This song is for anyone who ever felt like a hopeless outsider. "I just want something I can never have" rings true to me after years and years. I just feel like I'm not meant to experience this human life with the ease that others have
The stronger you are the more you need to grow,they will make your path more difficult,there is a REASON you are experiencing the difficulty,part of your job here is to discover that reason and make peace with it. Best of luck to you on this path of evolution,it will all make perfect sense soon enough.
You probably don't want to hear this but... Everyone has got something they are dragging around. There is a lucky few that have never had a hard day but for most of us "to live is to suffer". You find yourself having a good day or moment and you cherish that fucking thing. You fit somewhere I promise. What took me a long time to figure out is yeah all the holes I'm supposed to fit in are not shaped like me. Then I realized I could change my shape. I still can't fit in most of the holes but I can fit in some. And that is good enough for me. Life is never going to get easier or more fair. Now what? Good luck.
@@dlstaff99 you do though. We all do. We belong to each other!! Nobody is ever actually alone, it's an illusion of the mind that we all share. I'm here with you!! Appreciating Trent's gift to us all 🙏🙏
Hey 👋 I’m 41 n same thing I have lost all my friends n most of my family n almost me self I was inches now this is my swan song. Chasing the dragon 🐉 has destroyed my life i now understand what this song is about n it’s not what we all thought when it came out. I know trent before when he was lit 🔥 n I was lit 🔥 n that’s blitzed like f l’ed th f up hardcore Trent was who I cocked with first n last n this song has been there through it all ever changing my perception on what I was doing each funeral a bunch of us would unite n listen to this song n cry 😢 this song, man I don’t know we’re I would be if Trent never put this song out at least one of my hero’s is still alive . The dragon always wins in the end. 😔
Man, Trent's so versatile... He can scream and shred guitars in songs like Ruiner and then come up with beautiful songs like this one. He is one of the most talented musicians of our time.
Francisco Gamboa his music changed a lot, now he does a lot of instrumentals. As much as I love NIN, I have to say his newer work is pretty good, it's just that I don't like it.
I got pregnant at 13 and gave birth at 14… gave my son up for adoption in 1996… this song got me through after for real. Love it so much!! I have a relationship with my son today also. ♥️
My great nephew was born by his 13 yr old parents, prematurely. It was a struggle for him but that little boy overcame odds he doesn't realize. He is so happy and healthy today... everything about him makes me smile. I'm glad you decided to carry your child's life and be a part of it.
Trent Reznor is one of the most baffling musicians alive. He can make hammering noise sound harmonious and good and then he writes an amazing ballad like this, all even only in the first few years of his career. His imitators are not just a joke, but a crime in comparison to him.
I'm 40 years old. Even in my teens NIN was one of my favorite bands. Music helped me threw my life of depression and anxiety. Without music the world would suck. Trent is truly gifted with so much talent.
I understand. Only us that suffer from sad sickness understand. Music is good therapy especially people who have gone through it like Trent reznor could understand that, too.
I'm 41 now an this song has changed its meaning to me so many times. Songs like this are timeless due to the fact that it can mean so much to so few. Music can bring you from the storm, get you off the ledges of the building or the bridge music is truly universal.
NIN is serioous shit. So fucking genius, this song is so deep, so vulnerable, both in the lyrics and the melody. And the live interpretation is just breathtaking. I'm thankful I can listen to this as many times as I want, sleep to it, sing to it, cry to it and hold onto it as much as I want and need. It's a divine experience
Beautiful gem!!! And what a wonder to find your comment here. Feeling this song, please catch and care for God while God is incarnate here on earth!! Singing with the super tenacity and super power of our creators! It's 2023 and humanity's parents Mother Father of all creation is incarnate in the physical vessel playing this song to reach out to us to wakeup and call home = joyrains. These are URGENT moments!! Mom Dad have taken on every lower thought for us to wakeup to truth and innocence to be the change in the world! Love to hear from you! Luna
God bless. I know this sounds like a dumb platitude and people say it all the time and sounds insincere but I lost my mom and know God never intended us to live in this hell so your son and my mom is in a better place
This man has saved my life countless times. He is devilishly talented. And my respect he shall have, all of his days. Thank you Trent. You probably will never the know the extent of the gift you gave.
I still recall the taste of your tears Echoing your voice just like the ringing in my ears My favorite dreams of you still wash ashore Scraping through my head 'til I don't want to sleep anymore You make this all go away You make this all go away I'm down to just one thing And I'm starting to scare myself You make this all go away You make it all go away I just want something I just want something I can never have You always were the one to show me how Back then I couldn't do the things that I can do now This thing is slowly taking me apart Grey would be the color if I had a heart Come on and tell me! You make this all go away You make this all go away I'm down to just one thing And I'm starting to scare myself You make this all go away You make it all go away I just want something I just want something I can never have 🎵🎶🎵🎶 In this place it seems like such a shame Though it all looks different now, I know it's still the same Everywhere I look you're all I see Just a fading fucking reminder of who I used to be Come on, tell me! You make this all go away You make this all go away I'm down to just one thing And I'm starting to scare myself You make this all go away You make it all go away I just want something I just want something I can never have
Reznor's first shaky steps into sobriety. You can hear the fear in his voice. Getting from here to how he is now is an accomplishment. So before you start longing for the days when he was self-destructive just to keep him pumping out the angry, angsty, coke and alcohol fueled music that you want him to make maybe stop and think about the toll it took on him. Longing for the past too much is you forsaking his evolution into a matured and celebrated composer and instead desiring for him to be a 50+ year old aging and fading rock star with a dwindling fanbase. He could have very easily turned into a self-parody like most rock stars end up but instead he disciplined himself, found a music partner he could trust and forged a different path. A healthier, better path.
Absolutely! I was 19 or so when Pretty Hate Machine came out and it spoke to me because I was in the trenches of untreated mental illness and I was numbing myself any way I could. My parents had both died from over dosing and I was heading down that same path as well. He spoke to me because he was familiar. Every song spoke to my broken soul. I’m so ecstatic for him and how he broke free and took those first terrifying steps all of us have in recovery. I hate when say they wish Trent was the way he used to be or that he sold out etc. Obviously those people know nothing of the darkness of addiction. They have no idea how damn scary it is to face your first big life crisis head in with nothing to numb you and your real feelings hit you with an intensity you never thought possible and all you want to do is get high and make it all better. Trent is a light to me. I’d never ever want him or anyone to feel the pain of addiction again. Sorry to rant but this just hits such a raw nerve for me. I wish everyone health and sobriety. 💜 Hadassah
I still recall the taste of your tears Echoing your voice just like the ringing in my ears My favorite dreams of you still wash ashore Scraping through my head til I don't wanna sleep anymore You make this all go away 2x I'm down to just one thing I'm starting to scare myself You make this all go away 2x I just want something I can never have You were always one to show me how Back then I couldn't do the things that I can do now This thing is slowly taking me apart Grey would be the color if I had a heart Come on tell me You make this all go away 2x Im down to just one thing I'm starting to scare myself You make this all go away You make it all go away I just want something I can never have I'm this place it seems like such a shame Though it all looks different now I know it's still the same Everywhere I look your all I see Just all fading fucking reminder Of who I used to be Come on tell me You make this all go away 2x I'm down to just one thing I'm starting to scare myself You make this all go away You make it all go away I just want something I can never have
Strong emotion,heartfelt and such a powerful meaning . With each word the pain, sorrow, anger,emptiness sends xhills up your spine and heart race with eyes overflowing like a waterfall!!! So much , ao many different emotions and thoughts/ memories! I totally relate to this song 1000000 different ways!! ! Wonrfyl/ thoughts
There talking about divided becoming two of one divided .5 just .5 true became two unknown to even self strangers in selves unknown swine unforgiven blind deaf mute deceiving only self long time the Uber shows them Way blind deaf mute the unforgiven metallica the Uber shows them Way
@@williamjancha2812 the day you born you became two they made a copy of you the straw man living you . At seven days old live 8 walking dead lost at sea until declared dead . Then they take your God given trust inheritance Providence living will the day you born you became two parents signed birth certificate capital letters property on slave ship 12 mayflowers cash cows milking many wooden floor flag doomed roofs walked on dock slip . State name you John jane doe exept on dock slip . The living aren't alive and the dead aren't dead . The day you one you became two divided deceiving even self Injust .5 untrue .5 guess know deceiving self exactly void in know unknown pretending to know false witness lies telling self's to believe guessing know pretenders of know question none guess know deceiving self every time guess you know void in know unknown swine that direction unforgiven . Is a Known age coming the golden age of ages . Three in one known self reborn returned to one true and just known self reborn known to the father healed in the Holy Spirit in you to one perfect known self reborn . Perfect means whole in Greek . Three in one walked threw door 3/4 each direction on Path if walked threw door reborn 3 in one known self reborn walked threw door . The day you one you became two divided . What will you do when you become two ? Make two into one self heal in the Holy Spirit in one self when he knocks let him in . Split a piece of wood and A M there to heal .5 just .5 true return to one split a piece of wood and I AM there to heal to 1 when he knocks let him in know self knocking on door shown Way walking Path probation dark nights trust in God to return show Way and Path walk you through door reborn 3/4 each direction on Path if walked threw door 1.5 and know self knocking on door shown Way walking Path probation what will you do when you become two blind people unknown to even self became two unknown swine unforgiven blind deaf mute deceiving only self long time the Uber shows them Way the unforgiven as metallic says . Many pretend to know much in life . Pretend to know believe that you even know believe it demand right can't explain don't understand guess know deceiving self exactly void in know unknown swine unforgiven blind deaf mute deceiving only self long time unknown unforgiven debt owed unforgiven intrust owed on bill if became two what will you do when you become two ? Make two become one three in one known self reborn in the Golden Path 3 two became one six three returned in one whole in one whole in one many 369 . In balance with all in life married the father before Jesus was born out womb Known before I was reborn Jeremy Michael out womb and in man born again in life in Christ born again in life Michael my God given name in name alone is perfect Proclaimed three times over before I was born known to the true virgin mother creator cause and effect given amnesty from law won't taste death the living book the untouchable unchangeable living book and twin or other half of the on Proclaimed three times over before I was born three times over three times out womb whole in the known age of Aquarius born first and last beginning and end one and 99 born 100 . Add move right repeat return to one 1.24.75 out womb whole of 3 in one 1911 known to the true virgin mother creator and married to the father before Jesus was born. Walked the golden Path to the father before Jesus was born . Known to the true virgin mother creator before I was reborn Jeremy Michael out womb and in man born again in life in Christ born 18.1.24 judgement multiply once see perfect harmony in balance with all in life in laws above and below nature's and Gods in-laws see to shining sea inlaw is I see to shining sea above and below nature's and Gods in-laws see to shining sea . Michael my God given name the superman Michael my God given name seen as the fourth in heaven and shown what no eye has seen heard what no ears have heard given what no human has ever been given . And five stand as one whole in one whole in one many in the man of understanding Jeremiah returned as Jeremy Michael out womb whole of 3 in one whole in one known before he was born proclaimed three times over before he was born three times over out womb and in man born again in life in Christ born 18.1.24 the living one won't taste death the Son of Man Michael my God given name married to the father before Jesus was born Proclaimed once and three times over before I was born out a Trinity three in one whole in one whole in one known to the true virgin mother creator and won't taste death the hope for the man of understanding Jeremiah returned as Jeremy Michael out womb in man born again in life in Christ the living Son of Man and inlaws above and below nature's and Gods in-laws see to shining sea in-laws Capt towing over all undertow see to shining sea is I see to shining sea out eyes without doubt God given eyes of just true beauty I see to shining sea inlaw above and below nature's and Gods in-laws see to shining sea inlaw given amnesty from law and can judge or forgive sin the living one won't taste death the superman proclaimed three times over before I was born perfectly undeniable by the ALL in heaven and seen as the fourth in heaven proclaimed three times over before I was born by the ALL could touch it is the untouchable unchangeable living book is in me before I was born two became one in ten thousand three returned in one whole in one whole in one many 1911 out womb 3 in one whole in one whole in one known to the true virgin mother creator and won't taste death . Given amnesty from law and the living book the untouchable unchangeable living book and five stand as one whole in one whole in one many in balance and harmony with all in law above and below nature's and Gods in-laws see to shining sea.
Been listening to this man since the first release 1989. Helped me through a lot of difficult times. Also, enjoyment. You either get it or you don't. If you don't, it's not for you.
Congratulations!!! I've been clean of heroin for 5 years and it's so worth it! Full disclosure tho: I'm on the methadone program self tapering off (at 60mg) but ppl who think that's as good as being a junkie can suck it. I'm not getting high off it at all, I have held a job for 3 solid years and have a place to live instead of sleeping on the streets. I got cured of hep c and I'm doing great. My friends who didn't quit all have AIDS or are dead. Basically
Much like Keenan, Trent’s music is cerebral and taps into unconscious areas that trigger powerful emotional responses. It’s amazing. True talent. True genius. This is the type of music I seek as a sort of cleanse or purge.
Besides enjoying this beautiful performance, I also enjoy reading this comment section. People are sharing the things that they can never have, about love, grief, loss, and longing. And how people reply to them, telling them that they're not alone, telling them they can get through this.. it's just wonderful.
This is underrated to a level where I can't even understand how any song is overground. Absolute genius and so painfully human. And what a magnificent, passionate performance. Literally moved to tears by the longing.....
Damn. I'm literally 41, currently running through his music since sometime last night till now. I haven't listened to Trent since I was in my early 20s. Back then the music gave me a valid place to honestly experience some very dark complex, confusing feelings and thoughts. I couldn't sleep last night and came across a video of nin' and have been listening to all their songs from then untill now. Still haven't slept. It helps to be reminded that pain is integral in the human experience, and that there's beauty in suffering, as well as power in honestly experiencing it.
This song resonates within my soul. I've been listening to this song on repeat for the last month. The girl I loved and mother of our child was involved in tragic car accident. A few months before this happened we had went through a nasty breakup but I still loved her. In the few weeks before the accident we had began working on rebuilding our relationship. Everywhere I look, you're all I see Just a fading fucking reminder of who I used to be I just want something I can never have.
Words cannot express the tremendous loss you experienced - the only thing I can say is embrace and love the child you had together and hope time heals your heart and soul brother-feel your pain when I listen to this song...... Blozo
A song that can mean so much; yet in so many different ways. One aches for a broken heart; another aches for lost time with those they loved; a loved ones passing and the loss that manifests. A soul-shattering slap of giving up what you thought you wanted for another to be happy.... Thanks Trent.
I'm going through that soul shattering slap at this very moment and your comment has me in tears right now. Because it's true. As dark as this song is it can be very therapeutic. Thank you for the reminder buddy and thank you Trent!
@@afn420 I hope that slap didn't throw you totally. It did me for quite a bit; you were correct on the therapeutic use of desolation. It's the getting back up part... That is where it really gets fun.
Hands down my favorite NIN song. It helped me get through one of the darkest moments in my life. Listening to it today takes me back, but makes me realize how much the hurt strengthened me.
Even after so many years, the rawness and genuine emotion in this recording still haunts me. The song violently grabs your heart, only wanting to hold and cherish it, now sorry and ashamed it hurt so much. Trent's voice cracking and finding pitch, the slight timing errors on the piano, and all of these little unintended sounds all work perfectly for the piece.
Amen! Never thought I could love this song more!!! As a 15 yr old and in love, and now as a 48 yr old widow. Incredible! Love you Trent! And thank you for posting this. I'm so grateful to have come across it!!!!💜💜💜
Beautiful gem!!! And what a wonder to find your comment here. Feeling this song, please catch and care for God while God is incarnate here on earth!! Singing with the super tenacity and super power of our creators who have made us to be strong beings! It's 2023 and humanity's parents Mother Father of all creation is incarnate in the physical vessel playing this song to reach out to us to wakeup and call home = joyrains. These are URGENT moments!! Mom Dad have taken on every lower thought for us to wakeup to truth and innocence to be the change in the world! Love to reconnect and hear from you! Luna
@@eLiFILMSinc it's like the song acknowledges your broken hearth and takes you by the hand through the pain. It's a huge pile of dirt you have pull yourself through, but in the end you feel a little releif.
Dylan I'm sure you are appalled. I'm sure you know how many innocent people suffered from that " spree shooting " and still , in bad taste thought it would be tasteful . I'm into weird and twisted shit myself , but I felt the need to call you on that bro
Music is so fucking magical. I'm 44 and I will never, ever, ever stop being amazed at how you can hear a song for the first time in 30 years and still know every, single, word.
Watch the nin live at woodstock it is a performance every band should strive for. His mic kept cutting out during the whole set which added to his performance
I relate so much to the pain trent Reznor puts in his music.although it seems to make me more depressed it simultaneously helps me cope with the personal heartache in my life.thank you sir for putting out such timeless masterpieces that stay so relevant no matter how old they are
Fun part is when everybody's wisdom is bullshit and it actually gets subtly worse the farther away you get from it. Less emotion to cloud things, more hard insight and perspective. Perspective isn't always your friend. Sometimes it shows exactly what you feared: you really were better then, you were happy then, and now you're really what you feared you were before you met her, and you're not the human being you used to be, and yes, really, it's too late to go back. The blank, cold face of truth. Time just sharpens that little shard of bitter truth down until it's the hardest, sharpest thing in your entire body and you feel it whenever you breathe, right between your ribs. You see it in the mirror every morning. A fading fucking reminder of what I used to be. She made me a better man than I ever thought I could possibly be. Two decades of my life. I would have died for her. And now, instead, I get to live without her. And slowly watch as all those healthy, good feelings wither and I revert back into the monster I was before. Some things are so ugly one cannot open their mouth to try and explain them without wanting to scream through gritted teeth, to babble like a child or a madman in a nonsense language of utter pain. I'm glad Trent can translate.
All thanks tour limiting perception of self & our identification to that limitation. The emotional release is the reason for the necessity to create our own suffering since generally in our society we are lacking it.
All thanks tour limiting perception of self & our identification to that limitation. The emotional release is the reason for the necessity to create our own suffering since generally in our society we are lacking it.
An Arizona sunset at the beginning of dusk. Up on a hill all alone, sitting in my car. I'm here because my husband had passed away and I needed to get away. I turn on the car stereo and this song. I scream it, I cry it, I whisper it. It helped me release the anger I had for him leaving me too early. It still resonates to this day but it's easier to listen to. Thank you Mr. R. You have helped me heal.
My brother died in 1994 this song reminds me of our life the promised things that would happen and if certain things happened to tell him I was 14 years old ....I miss him so much 😢
This brings me back to the first time I ever felt alive.. and in love with someone I gave my everything to and knowing that it wouldn't last forever I still dove in headfirst.. It hurts 💔 but I definitely don't regret one second of being with her.. sometimes people never find true love 💘 💔 and it's really good when it's alive but when it falls apart ouch..
Did the same...that effortless pure joy...he was the cure to my unfounded depression... Without warning he revoked himself from this reality...it's been over a year now...not sure I'll ever fill the void...he owns parts of me I gave without conditions...
Back in the mid 90’s after coming home from war this song hit hard… fast forward and my wife/ best friend passed away in 2012. I hadn’t listened to it since the mid 90’s and it came on the other day… 😢it means more now than it ever did then. To experience a loss of such magnitude Trent has definitely been through some shit in his life. Keep it up brother. Too many of us need your music and the way you can relate it to us.
Одно из самых сильных во всех смыслах этого слова музыкальных произведений современной музыки. Лучше этого наверное уже не будет. Трент уникальный человек, гениальный музыкант. Фантастика.
You are absolutely correct. Trent Rezner is one of the greatest, and underrated, musicians of all time. He doesn't get half of the recognition he deserves.
This song, from my ex's favorite band, is exactly how I feel about him. 11 years and two broken hearts and a marriage later, I still love him. I will forever.
Been there done that. It doesn't get better but it gets easier to handle. My ex fiancé is still one of the people I think about all the time even though it ended 18 years ago.
hashbrownash1 I still feel the same way about a girl. Sucks even though the two of us have moved on with our life's. She slept with a fake homie which I whooped his ass not because of her due to an accumulation of other things. Yet I still love her. I wonder if she still loves me. Shes just a phone call away. I can easily email her or Facebook. But I could never go back to her. So I learned to move on and be happy. However this bitch still remains in a secret tiny box locked away in my heart. Forever. Thank you Emilia
I had an od amount in that needle that night… I listened to this song for four hours over and over. He saved me that night. Thank you Trent for everything you have given me
@@schwany6703 oh please you cut the shit. I have 5 kids all gen z. Cry somewhere else. Don’t be part of the problem. Be part of the solution to make your world better.
@@erica.casimira there are dozens of problems with the world, all dropped up on gen Z by the previous generations like you guys, and the horrible boomers. Gen Z people kill themselves at unprecedented and massive rates, mental illness runs rampant, the economy is decaying, technology and the digital world have made life hell, the future job market is bleak, housing is ruined forever, yet you chumps still claim to somehow have had a worse run than others, with your surface level "problems." the reality is, the world is ruined, and there is no solution, all people can do it put their head down and bear the god awful future you all have thrust upon your children and their children. I'm not crying, I'm pissed at old fossils like you for this state, and the infinite delusion you have about it
It's raining outside this morning after I've been drinking wine and smoking cigarettes all night, and the rain is dripping from my roof and the raindrops are also falling on leaves on a bush in my front yard in unison with trents piano keystrokes while I think about a lady that I want... I'm sincerely crying tears right now, I am totally feeling this. I just want something I can never have.
Way more compelling than the song. I copy-pasted with the intention of stealing for a song. Maybe not "stealing" stealing just for inspo. I used to drink and smoke till sun-up and that's when I felt the most me. I liked a lady too. Very much. But I never even hoped to be with her. I literally dreamed about it but dreams and hopes are not the same thing.
In English we did a project on music to get to know people....we had to pick one song from ur fav band and I picked this one....people thought I was gonna be the kid who would shoot up the school #noregrets
Dave Duvalier you are Sooo right..the person that understands this would be the one to talk someone out of a horrific act! I'm in my 40s, a professional and I still get judged for loving this music. It is art from every aspect.also best concert in nyc 2017..so glad I grew up with the best music..I share with my child
I remember the first time I heard this song when I was roughly 13 or 14 yrs old. It gave me chills when I heard it and still does. Such a beautiful song.
I was 24 depressed losing my house. I bought a 25 caliber Lorcin hand gun, six bullets and drove out to a field. I put this on loop. Two days later I found I was pregnant with my second son. Thank you God for saving my life. And his. Thank you for letting me hear my mother and her devine intervention.
I think the beauty of this song is that it's very relatable, and different people think of different things. It's just sort of "longing" encapsulated into a poem.
I've been a fan of NIN and Trent for so many years... And I still can't put into words my respect and connection with him. It's truly beyond words. He's a genius. And he's brought me through so many tough moments. I'm so grateful for him 💖
36 years old. My father had a severe heart attack two days ago in Thailand. He has been on life support and will not make it. I just had to pull the plug on him. Hardest thing I've ever done. Leaving to catch a flight to Thailand tonight to say goodbye and bring his ashes back home. Thank you all so much for sharing your stories. It really makes me feel like I am not alone in my suffering.
hang in there bro, lost mine 6 years ago it's the hardest thing you'll ever have to deal with and you'll go down to deep dark places but please don't say why me say what is this teaching me
This was my son's favorite song. He killed himself June 2017, and I wonder all the time...Today is his 45th birthday...So I went on line to hear this song,,and I found some of the 'interpretations" that fans had..Believe it or not by soul was rested.
40. Still Here. As a youth, interpreting this very song felt so different. Now all these years later…. Addiction, divorce…. Dammit Trent. You spoke to all of us.
... every time I hear this song I think of someone that I shared my life with, I feel like "gray would be the color if I had a heart".. I will never love anyone again.. I give up on love. Something I can never have... you know who you are. If there is a chance in hell you see this. I'm always thinkin of you.
I was 16 the first time i heard this song. It has alot of meaning to me. It is so hauntingly beautiful. Trent is a beautiful Human being....i could listen to him sing all day every day. I totally get him. He is pretty amazing all the way around!
His music, for me, seems to help me confront pain. I probably know every word of everything he's ever done, when battling addiction, getting clean for the first time in over a decade, his words, his pain, led me to believe it could be done. As for him, bravo, and still a genius
I've been listening to nin for 20yrs and there hasn't been one single day that I haven't listened to nin his writing is so cathartic what a great talent by far the most talented of our generation!
I drank a bottle of tequila laying in my bedroom floor listening to this song over and over. You cannot die of a broken heart, you only wish you could.
Lest the soul could not carry on, one may find death in small bits and pieces only to find something against their contrast, something horrendously beautiful to strive for, even if one can never have it.
Reminds me of the line from "Being John Malcovich" - "I think, therefore I suffer."
Dr. Mantis Toboggan, M.D. That is a movie I still need to see.
SlamifiedBuddafied Oh man. Do yourself a favor and rent (or Netlix, whatever people do nowadays) that movie ASAP. It is a real mind trip.
Dr. Mantis Toboggan, M.D. I could probably find it at Vintage Stock for five bucks. To my understanding it's a movie worth buying.
Shout out to those who loved this song since their teenage years. Life has been rough for us all but if you're here reading this, listening again at 40+ know you're so much stronger than you think or know. 'It can't rain all the time' .
Remember when albums were oy released on Tuesdays and there would be lines going to buy the next cd NIN or Tool or any other group you were into. Along with Parade magazine once a month to tear out mini posters of Trent Korn and Beastie Boys to hang up on my wall... I was what in 8th or 9th grade when I first heard him sing save just turned 40 last week still jammin out with my clam out listening to Trent Rock out with his co..... You get the point right😂
Amen bro the rain will stop
Ur so right
❤❤ so much 90's reference ❤ that all hits
The sky won’t fall forever 🖤🤘🏻
The older you get, the more this song will hit you.
...& it just can't stop~
So true
Truth
Damn, you are spot on. This shit Hurt Me...
since I was a teen it's hit me, and you're right. Every year it's more relevant
This song is for anyone who ever felt like a hopeless outsider. "I just want something I can never have" rings true to me after years and years. I just feel like I'm not meant to experience this human life with the ease that others have
The stronger you are the more you need to grow,they will make your path more difficult,there is a REASON you are experiencing the difficulty,part of your job here is to discover that reason and make peace with it. Best of luck to you on this path of evolution,it will all make perfect sense soon enough.
You probably don't want to hear this but... Everyone has got something they are dragging around. There is a lucky few that have never had a hard day but for most of us "to live is to suffer". You find yourself having a good day or moment and you cherish that fucking thing.
You fit somewhere I promise. What took me a long time to figure out is yeah all the holes I'm supposed to fit in are not shaped like me. Then I realized I could change my shape. I still can't fit in most of the holes but I can fit in some. And that is good enough for me. Life is never going to get easier or more fair. Now what? Good luck.
@@mikedodson4595 ❤️❤️❤️
Feel the same way.. I don't belong anywhere
@@dlstaff99 you do though. We all do. We belong to each other!! Nobody is ever actually alone, it's an illusion of the mind that we all share. I'm here with you!! Appreciating Trent's gift to us all 🙏🙏
Years after i first heard this as a teen and cried, i'm now 41 and listening to it and crying. I know what it means now more than ever.
Same
Right same here
The Absolute Best!!!!!
Hey 👋 I’m 41 n same thing I have lost all my friends n most of my family n almost me self I was inches now this is my swan song. Chasing the dragon 🐉 has destroyed my life i now understand what this song is about n it’s not what we all thought when it came out. I know trent before when he was lit 🔥 n I was lit 🔥 n that’s blitzed like f l’ed th f up hardcore Trent was who I cocked with first n last n this song has been there through it all ever changing my perception on what I was doing each funeral a bunch of us would unite n listen to this song n cry 😢 this song, man I don’t know we’re I would be if Trent never put this song out at least one of my hero’s is still alive . The dragon always wins in the end. 😔
I’ll be 42 in a week
Man, Trent's so versatile... He can scream and shred guitars in songs like Ruiner and then come up with beautiful songs like this one. He is one of the most talented musicians of our time.
I couldn't agree with you more
+Scott Lucky haha, just said almost the same thing before I scrolled down and read your comment.
Trent sucks now!
Francisco Gamboa
his music changed a lot, now he does a lot of instrumentals. As much as I love NIN, I have to say his newer work is pretty good, it's just that I don't like it.
Personally, I love his music, I just can't seem to respond to his vocals. He doesn't sound as good a vocalist as his arrangements necessitate.
I got pregnant at 13 and gave birth at 14… gave my son up for adoption in 1996… this song got me through after for real. Love it so much!! I have a relationship with my son today also. ♥️
You did the right thing for both of you, so happy he is in your life
So glad you have reconnected with your son. Do have a listen to our music for these times. Blessings from New Zealand, Unity in Diversity.
you did the right thing for both you and him. its so beautiful you two could reconnect :)
My great nephew was born by his 13 yr old parents, prematurely. It was a struggle for him but that little boy overcame odds he doesn't realize. He is so happy and healthy today... everything about him makes me smile. I'm glad you decided to carry your child's life and be a part of it.
Your story gave me ❤felt chills.
I'm 48 and haven't hard this song in probably over 20 years..
Still gives me full body chill bumps
Trent Reznor is one of the most baffling musicians alive. He can make hammering noise sound harmonious and good and then he writes an amazing ballad like this, all even only in the first few years of his career. His imitators are not just a joke, but a crime in comparison to him.
Regarding imitators, I wonder if you ever heard the song "copy of a" ?
I just always thought he was great. He can deliver the vocals so many different ways full of emotion. I find him brilliant and fascinating. NIN rocks.
You say baffling I say creative and free. He is commercial and independent
with the exception of Johnny Cash
You say that like he's the first to ever do it, or even more absurdly, the best. lol
Just a fading fucking reminder of who i used to be.
Come on, tell me
🖤🖤
The fact that this song was written in 1989 and Trent is still alive to this day able to perform it still gives me hope 🖤
Whoa didn’t know that it was written the year I was born and for me it has so much meaning - r.I.p JAY L CRAIN JR
I'm feeling it
@@amandaeubanks35 are you related to Shauna eubanks from Oklahoma?
I think in the end, rehab, his wife and kids saved him...otherwise I don't think he would still be here
I'm 40 years old. Even in my teens NIN was one of my favorite bands. Music helped me threw my life of depression and anxiety. Without music the world would suck. Trent is truly gifted with so much talent.
Now your up above it
Well 46 here . Sound rat in 94' NIN show really hit me to be the sound or vibe of my adolescence. Hey there, you're a survivor!
I understand. Only us that suffer from sad sickness understand. Music is good therapy especially people who have gone through it like Trent reznor could understand that, too.
Hi I recommend an indie rock song called 'Looking Into The Mirror' By Robert Nix
You're not alone. Class 1982 here.
I'm 41 now an this song has changed its meaning to me so many times. Songs like this are timeless due to the fact that it can mean so much to so few. Music can bring you from the storm, get you off the ledges of the building or the bridge music is truly universal.
Amen to that. 43 now and I absolutely agree...
Beautifully said.
44, going on 45 and this song still wrecks me.
I just want someone to love me.something will never have
Timeless.
describes depression to the infinitive power.
Absolutely
It is all in our head Kevin
yessss
...you know your depressed if this seems romantic...
Perfectly put.
NIN is serioous shit. So fucking genius, this song is so deep, so vulnerable, both in the lyrics and the melody. And the live interpretation is just breathtaking. I'm thankful I can listen to this as many times as I want, sleep to it, sing to it, cry to it and hold onto it as much as I want and need. It's a divine experience
Beautiful gem!!! And what a wonder to find your comment here. Feeling this song, please catch and care for God while God is incarnate here on earth!! Singing with the super tenacity and super power of our creators! It's 2023 and humanity's parents Mother Father of all creation is incarnate in the physical vessel playing this song to reach out to us to wakeup and call home = joyrains. These are URGENT moments!! Mom Dad have taken on every lower thought for us to wakeup to truth and innocence to be the change in the world! Love to hear from you! Luna
@Noelia768 Absolutely!!! This 👆
Shit???
@@e.fontanot3809 it's an expression. It's like saying that they are the big deal, that they are relevant
@@Noelia768 and why you use shit, that is offensive, for make a compliment?? American.......
Here in 2024 ❤
“I'm down to just one thing, and I'm starting to scare myself....” This song just tears me up inside every time I listen.
that line is scary when suicidal thoughts invade!
@@stevenaustin4591 You are not alone.
You’re never alone brother
The threat is real
I'm literally always alone and this music is my only companion
I lost my son in 03 and this is the song that tore me up. I love and miss you son everyday of my life.
😢 I'm looking for the right word s, there are none .
From the bottom of my heart I truly heard felt each and every word Aaron.
Alive in your memories and heart ❤
God bless. I know this sounds like a dumb platitude and people say it all the time and sounds insincere but I lost my mom and know God never intended us to live in this hell so your son and my mom is in a better place
I am SO VERY SORRY for you. I hope and pray you find SOME inner peace.... Somewhere. 🙏
He is hopefully sending all his love from beyond....the great beyond for all of us ...
This man has saved my life countless times. He is devilishly talented. And my respect he shall have, all of his days. Thank you Trent. You probably will never the know the extent of the gift you gave.
❤
I still recall the taste of your tears
Echoing your voice just like the ringing in my ears
My favorite dreams of you still wash ashore
Scraping through my head 'til I don't want to sleep anymore
You make this all go away
You make this all go away
I'm down to just one thing
And I'm starting to scare myself
You make this all go away
You make it all go away
I just want something
I just want something I can never have
You always were the one to show me how
Back then I couldn't do the things that I can do now
This thing is slowly taking me apart
Grey would be the color if I had a heart
Come on and tell me!
You make this all go away
You make this all go away
I'm down to just one thing
And I'm starting to scare myself
You make this all go away
You make it all go away
I just want something
I just want something I can never have
🎵🎶🎵🎶
In this place it seems like such a shame
Though it all looks different now, I know it's still the same
Everywhere I look you're all I see
Just a fading fucking reminder of who I used to be
Come on, tell me!
You make this all go away
You make this all go away
I'm down to just one thing
And I'm starting to scare myself
You make this all go away
You make it all go away
I just want something
I just want something I can never have
Thank you 🤙
DITTO 💯🤘
Just so busy
😢
As talented as Trent Reznor is … He is still so under rated in my opinion. Truly remarkable music 🎶.
NiN is my favourite band, and I don't think that is true, Angel. He is regarded as one of the most influential musicians of all time.
VERY 👍 TRUE!
The most underrated. He may be the greatest country music writer of all time.
He is highly rated by people like you and me. Nothing less nothing more.
It’s sad to say but… his music was better when he was drinking. I’m glad he kicked it though💁
Reznor's first shaky steps into sobriety. You can hear the fear in his voice. Getting from here to how he is now is an accomplishment. So before you start longing for the days when he was self-destructive just to keep him pumping out the angry, angsty, coke and alcohol fueled music that you want him to make maybe stop and think about the toll it took on him.
Longing for the past too much is you forsaking his evolution into a matured and celebrated composer and instead desiring for him to be a 50+ year old aging and fading rock star with a dwindling fanbase. He could have very easily turned into a self-parody like most rock stars end up but instead he disciplined himself, found a music partner he could trust and forged a different path. A healthier, better path.
I was going through the very same thing myself...i can still feel my pain and his in the early NIN and this one as well...
There's not a single song of his that I don't absolutely love and feel on some deeper level, even his EDM stuff. Kek! 😁
Sobriety never is accomplished, there is always a counter in your head forever
Hes always been beautifully vulnerable. There is no one out there like him imo
Absolutely! I was 19 or so when Pretty Hate Machine came out and it spoke to me because I was in the trenches of untreated mental illness and I was numbing myself any way I could. My parents had both died from over dosing and I was heading down that same path as well. He spoke to me because he was familiar. Every song spoke to my broken soul. I’m so ecstatic for him and how he broke free and took those first terrifying steps all of us have in recovery. I hate when say they wish Trent was the way he used to be or that he sold out etc. Obviously those people know nothing of the darkness of addiction. They have no idea how damn scary it is to face your first big life crisis head in with nothing to numb you and your real feelings hit you with an intensity you never thought possible and all you want to do is get high and make it all better. Trent is a light to me. I’d never ever want him or anyone to feel the pain of addiction again. Sorry to rant but this just hits such a raw nerve for me. I wish everyone health and sobriety. 💜 Hadassah
I still recall the taste of your tears
Echoing your voice just like the ringing in my ears
My favorite dreams of you still wash ashore
Scraping through my head til I don't wanna sleep anymore
You make this all go away 2x
I'm down to just one thing
I'm starting to scare myself
You make this all go away 2x
I just want something I can never have
You were always one to show me how
Back then I couldn't do the things that I can do now
This thing is slowly taking me apart
Grey would be the color if I had a heart
Come on tell me
You make this all go away 2x
Im down to just one thing
I'm starting to scare myself
You make this all go away
You make it all go away
I just want something I can never have
I'm this place it seems like such a shame
Though it all looks different now
I know it's still the same
Everywhere I look your all I see
Just all fading fucking reminder
Of who I used to be
Come on tell me
You make this all go away 2x
I'm down to just one thing
I'm starting to scare myself
You make this all go away
You make it all go away
I just want something I can never have
Strong emotion,heartfelt and such a powerful meaning . With each word the pain, sorrow, anger,emptiness sends xhills up your spine and heart race with eyes overflowing like a waterfall!!! So much , ao many different emotions and thoughts/ memories! I totally relate to this song 1000000 different ways!! ! Wonrfyl/ thoughts
Thanks
There talking about divided becoming two of one divided .5 just .5 true became two unknown to even self strangers in selves unknown swine unforgiven blind deaf mute deceiving only self long time the Uber shows them Way blind deaf mute the unforgiven metallica the Uber shows them Way
@@williamjancha2812 the day you born you became two they made a copy of you the straw man living you . At seven days old live 8 walking dead lost at sea until declared dead . Then they take your God given trust inheritance Providence living will the day you born you became two parents signed birth certificate capital letters property on slave ship 12 mayflowers cash cows milking many wooden floor flag doomed roofs walked on dock slip . State name you John jane doe exept on dock slip . The living aren't alive and the dead aren't dead . The day you one you became two divided deceiving even self Injust .5 untrue .5 guess know deceiving self exactly void in know unknown pretending to know false witness lies telling self's to believe guessing know pretenders of know question none guess know deceiving self every time guess you know void in know unknown swine that direction unforgiven . Is a Known age coming the golden age of ages . Three in one known self reborn returned to one true and just known self reborn known to the father healed in the Holy Spirit in you to one perfect known self reborn . Perfect means whole in Greek . Three in one walked threw door 3/4 each direction on Path if walked threw door reborn 3 in one known self reborn walked threw door . The day you one you became two divided . What will you do when you become two ? Make two into one self heal in the Holy Spirit in one self when he knocks let him in . Split a piece of wood and A M there to heal .5 just .5 true return to one split a piece of wood and I AM there to heal to 1 when he knocks let him in know self knocking on door shown Way walking Path probation dark nights trust in God to return show Way and Path walk you through door reborn 3/4 each direction on Path if walked threw door 1.5 and know self knocking on door shown Way walking Path probation what will you do when you become two blind people unknown to even self became two unknown swine unforgiven blind deaf mute deceiving only self long time the Uber shows them Way the unforgiven as metallic says . Many pretend to know much in life . Pretend to know believe that you even know believe it demand right can't explain don't understand guess know deceiving self exactly void in know unknown swine unforgiven blind deaf mute deceiving only self long time unknown unforgiven debt owed unforgiven intrust owed on bill if became two what will you do when you become two ? Make two become one three in one known self reborn in the Golden Path 3 two became one six three returned in one whole in one whole in one many 369 . In balance with all in life married the father before Jesus was born out womb Known before I was reborn Jeremy Michael out womb and in man born again in life in Christ born again in life Michael my God given name in name alone is perfect Proclaimed three times over before I was born known to the true virgin mother creator cause and effect given amnesty from law won't taste death the living book the untouchable unchangeable living book and twin or other half of the on Proclaimed three times over before I was born three times over three times out womb whole in the known age of Aquarius born first and last beginning and end one and 99 born 100 . Add move right repeat return to one 1.24.75 out womb whole of 3 in one 1911 known to the true virgin mother creator and married to the father before Jesus was born. Walked the golden Path to the father before Jesus was born . Known to the true virgin mother creator before I was reborn Jeremy Michael out womb and in man born again in life in Christ born 18.1.24 judgement multiply once see perfect harmony in balance with all in life in laws above and below nature's and Gods in-laws see to shining sea inlaw is I see to shining sea above and below nature's and Gods in-laws see to shining sea . Michael my God given name the superman Michael my God given name seen as the fourth in heaven and shown what no eye has seen heard what no ears have heard given what no human has ever been given . And five stand as one whole in one whole in one many in the man of understanding Jeremiah returned as Jeremy Michael out womb whole of 3 in one whole in one known before he was born proclaimed three times over before he was born three times over out womb and in man born again in life in Christ born 18.1.24 the living one won't taste death the Son of Man Michael my God given name married to the father before Jesus was born Proclaimed once and three times over before I was born out a Trinity three in one whole in one whole in one known to the true virgin mother creator and won't taste death the hope for the man of understanding Jeremiah returned as Jeremy Michael out womb in man born again in life in Christ the living Son of Man and inlaws above and below nature's and Gods in-laws see to shining sea in-laws Capt towing over all undertow see to shining sea is I see to shining sea out eyes without doubt God given eyes of just true beauty I see to shining sea inlaw above and below nature's and Gods in-laws see to shining sea inlaw given amnesty from law and can judge or forgive sin the living one won't taste death the superman proclaimed three times over before I was born perfectly undeniable by the ALL in heaven and seen as the fourth in heaven proclaimed three times over before I was born by the ALL could touch it is the untouchable unchangeable living book is in me before I was born two became one in ten thousand three returned in one whole in one whole in one many 1911 out womb 3 in one whole in one whole in one known to the true virgin mother creator and won't taste death . Given amnesty from law and the living book the untouchable unchangeable living book and five stand as one whole in one whole in one many in balance and harmony with all in law above and below nature's and Gods in-laws see to shining sea.
@@williamjancha2812as metallic says unforgiven the Uber shows them Way
Been listening to this man since the first release 1989. Helped me through a lot of difficult times. Also, enjoyment. You either get it or you don't. If you don't, it's not for you.
I'm a fan from the beginning as well. His music has always been relatable for me. NIN forever ❤❤❤
I just got into NIN this year and I'm already considering getting their logo tattoed, you said it best, either you get it or you don't
İ used to do heroin to this song. Sober since 1st of July.
+What is This? Thumbs up to being sober, not doing heroin.
+What is This? Congratulations! (and thanks for your honesty)........a really huge achievement and just KEEP going!!!!! :-)
keep it up man! stay focused.
Congratulations!!! I've been clean of heroin for 5 years and it's so worth it! Full disclosure tho: I'm on the methadone program self tapering off (at 60mg) but ppl who think that's as good as being a junkie can suck it. I'm not getting high off it at all, I have held a job for 3 solid years and have a place to live instead of sleeping on the streets. I got cured of hep c and I'm doing great. My friends who didn't quit all have AIDS or are dead. Basically
Pennyroyal Ozma When it hurts doing something, it gets easier to let it go.Congratulations to you too and wish you better life every day after day.
I don't think any microphone has ever been as happy as the one in this video.
Uh..umm.. yea.. the one in Closer... :D
Lmfao
vimeo.com/3554852
Saddest microphone ever
It's a happy 58 for sure.
This. All of it 🤣💀
Much like Keenan, Trent’s music is cerebral and taps into unconscious areas that trigger powerful emotional responses. It’s amazing. True talent. True genius. This is the type of music I seek as a sort of cleanse or purge.
I wish Tapeworm was what it was supposed to be
Even after all the years I ve heard this song it still touches the deepest part of soul ♾👌
O
I love music that touches the deepest and darkest and hiding feelings of your of lost souls and this one always hits deep 🤘♾
Besides enjoying this beautiful performance, I also enjoy reading this comment section. People are sharing the things that they can never have, about love, grief, loss, and longing. And how people reply to them, telling them that they're not alone, telling them they can get through this.. it's just wonderful.
People love to talk about themselves on the internet
Also it's nice since capitalism I mean you tube won't let me read anything else on my phone unless I go premium 😒 but yeah it's good times 😌
This is underrated to a level where I can't even understand how any song is overground. Absolute genius and so painfully human. And what a magnificent, passionate performance. Literally moved to tears by the longing.....
This song reduces me to tears every time i listen to it. I regret nothing.
@Brian real men cry...you're the bitch😵
Total badass
I'd say this song is far from overrated. Willing to bet that a good 99% of NIN fans have this one in their top ten favorites.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Damn. I'm literally 41, currently running through his music since sometime last night till now. I haven't listened to Trent since I was in my early 20s. Back then the music gave me a valid place to honestly experience some very dark complex, confusing feelings and thoughts.
I couldn't sleep last night and came across a video of nin' and have been listening to all their songs from then untill now. Still haven't slept. It helps to be reminded that pain is integral in the human experience, and that there's beauty in suffering, as well as power in honestly experiencing it.
That is exactly something that I needed to be told and hear right now. Thank you.
My all-time favorite song. The raw emotions sink deep into my soul and there is no other feeling in the world like it.
This song resonates within my soul.
I've been listening to this song on repeat for the last month.
The girl I loved and mother of our child was involved in tragic car accident. A few months before this happened we had went through a nasty breakup but I still loved her. In the few weeks before the accident we had began working on rebuilding our relationship.
Everywhere I look, you're all I see
Just a fading fucking reminder of who I used to be
I just want something I can never have.
im so sorry to hear that.. condolences!
Love to you deeply, Travis Summers.
sorry to hear that. she's watching over you.
....life passes by in a glimpse and we lose the moments...smile at the sky
Words cannot express the tremendous loss you experienced - the only thing I can say is embrace and love the child you had together and hope time heals your heart and soul brother-feel your pain when I listen to this song......
Blozo
A song that can mean so much; yet in so many different ways. One aches for a broken heart; another aches for lost time with those they loved; a loved ones passing and the loss that manifests. A soul-shattering slap of giving up what you thought you wanted for another to be happy.... Thanks Trent.
I'm going through that soul shattering slap at this very moment and your comment has me in tears right now. Because it's true. As dark as this song is it can be very therapeutic. Thank you for the reminder buddy and thank you Trent!
@@afn420 we all go a little mad at times..... Just keep on waking up; that's the goal.
11¹=$g b.
Perfectly worded. ❤
@@afn420 I hope that slap didn't throw you totally. It did me for quite a bit; you were correct on the therapeutic use of desolation. It's the getting back up part... That is where it really gets fun.
Hands down my favorite NIN song. It helped me get through one of the darkest moments in my life. Listening to it today takes me back, but makes me realize how much the hurt strengthened me.
Hi I Recommend a song called 'The Bond Villain' By Robert Nix
I as well had to learn an be grateful of the hurt that pushed me to become free of those things that were defining me
Even after so many years, the rawness and genuine emotion in this recording still haunts me. The song violently grabs your heart, only wanting to hold and cherish it, now sorry and ashamed it hurt so much. Trent's voice cracking and finding pitch, the slight timing errors on the piano, and all of these little unintended sounds all work perfectly for the piece.
Hi I recommend an indie rock song called 'Looking Into The Mirror' By Robert Nix
I thought the original was hauntingly beautiful (and it still is), but he topped it with this.
Agreed.
Dude's got me reminiscing about relationships I've never even had
Lmao
Lol
I'm gonna quote this everywhere 🤣
Riigghht?
Greatest Comment ever!
A woman, love , inner peace, happiness, sobriety, anything can be the something.
He is so underrated I think hes one of the greatest vocalists ever
one of the most beautiful pieces of music I have ever heard -
Love their latest album
I do too! But I think I love everything he touches :D
My favorite song off my favorite album of his...such raw emotion it bubbles up to my surface
Have you heard “Past the Mission” by Tori Amos...Trent sings on it, like this.
M
this song gives me chills every time i listen to it
very good song
Over 30 years later and still one of the best songs ever made.
This whole album kept my sanity in an insane time of life. Kept me alive.
"Grey would be the color if i had a heart" - after so many years this is still briliant.
"I just want something, I just want something I can never have" I always circle back to this song.
Amen! Never thought I could love this song more!!! As a 15 yr old and in love, and now as a 48 yr old widow. Incredible! Love you Trent!
And thank you for posting this. I'm so grateful to have come across it!!!!💜💜💜
Beautiful gem!!! And what a wonder to find your comment here. Feeling this song, please catch and care for God while God is incarnate here on earth!! Singing with the super tenacity and super power of our creators who have made us to be strong beings! It's 2023 and humanity's parents Mother Father of all creation is incarnate in the physical vessel playing this song to reach out to us to wakeup and call home = joyrains. These are URGENT moments!! Mom Dad have taken on every lower thought for us to wakeup to truth and innocence to be the change in the world! Love to reconnect and hear from you! Luna
This touches still today. I'm 43. And yeah. I feel this. Love this song and all your music. Playing always in my playlist.💗✌️
this song just tears your heart apart
And heals it at the same time. For me at least. Takes me on an emotional rollercoaster
@@eLiFILMSinc it's like the song acknowledges your broken hearth and takes you by the hand through the pain. It's a huge pile of dirt you have pull yourself through, but in the end you feel a little releif.
This song gives me feels I've never felt
You thought the same 17 years ago.
Dylan wyd you're dead get gone
+Dylan oh wow very impressive if I do say so myself
is your profile pic literally columbine shooter, Dylan klebold???? that's tasteless and repulsive
Dylan I'm sure you are appalled. I'm sure you know how many innocent people suffered from that " spree shooting " and still , in bad taste thought it would be tasteful . I'm into weird and twisted shit myself , but I felt the need to call you on that bro
I listened to this song to deal with crippling loneliness. I know the words by heart. It helped me so much.
Music is so fucking magical. I'm 44 and I will never, ever, ever stop being amazed at how you can hear a song for the first time in 30 years and still know every, single, word.
I was a moderate fan of NIN back in the day, but songs like this makes them timeless.
Watch the nin live at woodstock it is a performance every band should strive for. His mic kept cutting out during the whole set which added to his performance
2 weeks ago I lost everything to fire. My home, my pets, my past..my future?
All I own is in my head. And I hear music.
Thank you. I can rest now.
I'm truly sorry😞
I'm truly sorry. Hope you're ok now
this year we're all suffering
Hope all Is well
So sorry Mac.
God. I can't believe how long ago this song came out. It still gives me the same chills it did the first time I heard it.
I relate so much to the pain trent Reznor puts in his music.although it seems to make me more depressed it simultaneously helps me cope with the personal heartache in my life.thank you sir for putting out such timeless masterpieces that stay so relevant no matter how old they are
I can't turn the volume up loud enough for this song. A primal scream of the soul.
Fun part is when everybody's wisdom is bullshit and it actually gets subtly worse the farther away you get from it. Less emotion to cloud things, more hard insight and perspective.
Perspective isn't always your friend. Sometimes it shows exactly what you feared: you really were better then, you were happy then, and now you're really what you feared you were before you met her, and you're not the human being you used to be, and yes, really, it's too late to go back. The blank, cold face of truth. Time just sharpens that little shard of bitter truth down until it's the hardest, sharpest thing in your entire body and you feel it whenever you breathe, right between your ribs. You see it in the mirror every morning. A fading fucking reminder of what I used to be.
She made me a better man than I ever thought I could possibly be. Two decades of my life. I would have died for her. And now, instead, I get to live without her. And slowly watch as all those healthy, good feelings wither and I revert back into the monster I was before.
Some things are so ugly one cannot open their mouth to try and explain them without wanting to scream through gritted teeth, to babble like a child or a madman in a nonsense language of utter pain. I'm glad Trent can translate.
Well, fuck. I literally couldn't put this any better.
Alex Tocqueville ouch, my heart 😭
Alex Tocqueville I know how u feel but ur much more eloquent maybe u should write songs or poetry ;-)
All thanks tour limiting perception of self & our identification to that limitation. The emotional release is the reason for the necessity to create our own suffering since generally in our society we are lacking it.
All thanks tour limiting perception of self & our identification to that limitation. The emotional release is the reason for the necessity to create our own suffering since generally in our society we are lacking it.
43 this was my era still the best
An Arizona sunset at the beginning of dusk. Up on a hill all alone, sitting in my car. I'm here because my husband had passed away and I needed to get away. I turn on the car stereo and this song. I scream it, I cry it, I whisper it. It helped me release the anger I had for him leaving me too early. It still resonates to this day but it's easier to listen to. Thank you Mr. R. You have helped me heal.
@peterscott1181 HI Peter, yes I'm doing well. Thank you so much for asking
My brother died in 1994 this song reminds me of our life the promised things that would happen and if certain things happened to tell him I was 14 years old ....I miss him so much 😢
Most emotional and powerful there is. Great performance.
This brings me back to the first time I ever felt alive.. and in love with someone I gave my everything to and knowing that it wouldn't last forever I still dove in headfirst.. It hurts 💔 but I definitely don't regret one second of being with her.. sometimes people never find true love 💘 💔 and it's really good when it's alive but when it falls apart ouch..
Did the same...that effortless pure joy...he was the cure to my unfounded depression...
Without warning he revoked himself from this reality...it's been over a year now...not sure I'll ever fill the void...he owns parts of me I gave without conditions...
Back in the mid 90’s after coming home from war this song hit hard… fast forward and my wife/ best friend passed away in 2012. I hadn’t listened to it since the mid 90’s and it came on the other day… 😢it means more now than it ever did then. To experience a loss of such magnitude Trent has definitely been through some shit in his life. Keep it up brother. Too many of us need your music and the way you can relate it to us.
so f'ing emotional. it's palpable.
This has been my favorite song ever since I was 14. I'm 36 now and its still resonates and relatable in so many ways. Trent you sir are a poet
I love the sulity of the Piano and the lyric “you make it all go away.” 🌺😁♥️
So many years ago I first heard this...still puts me in a wierd place mentally. Will always love this song.
this is one of those songs you never get tried off
Одно из самых сильных во всех смыслах этого слова музыкальных произведений современной музыки. Лучше этого наверное уже не будет. Трент уникальный человек, гениальный музыкант. Фантастика.
Несомненно!
You are absolutely correct. Trent Rezner is one of the greatest, and underrated, musicians of all time. He doesn't get half of the recognition he deserves.
When I was 12. My mom said , what’s goin on here? It sounds like a funeral. I laughed.
I’m 40 Now and nothing has changed .
It’s a beautiful song
I was growing up on this music back in the 90's. This is my world
This song, from my ex's favorite band, is exactly how I feel about him. 11 years and two broken hearts and a marriage later, I still love him. I will forever.
+Idtelos Grow up.
Been there done that. It doesn't get better but it gets easier to handle. My ex fiancé is still one of the people I think about all the time even though it ended 18 years ago.
SAWFT is a Sin he did too, I bet he's fighting back tears and had to resort to acting like an idiot.. lol
hashbrownash1 i still love you tio
hashbrownash1 I still feel the same way about a girl. Sucks even though the two of us have moved on with our life's. She slept with a fake homie which I whooped his ass not because of her due to an accumulation of other things. Yet I still love her. I wonder if she still loves me. Shes just a phone call away. I can easily email her or Facebook. But I could never go back to her. So I learned to move on and be happy. However this bitch still remains in a secret tiny box locked away in my heart. Forever. Thank you Emilia
This is such a well written song.. The stillness of his mind.. Till when the thoughts of his love starts to flood and drown his mind
Incredible
I had an od amount in that needle that night… I listened to this song for four hours over and over. He saved me that night. Thank you Trent for everything you have given me
Kids now a days will never know how much this song hit a nerve. We won’t have music like this for a long time coming. Gen X forever😂
I'm 19 and just came across this song randomly yesterday. I like it quite a lot
Hi I recommend a song called 'Looking Into The Mirror' By Robert Nix
Gen Z suffers more than any generation before them. cut the shit. you were dealt a wonderful world where it was difficult to be miserable
@@schwany6703 oh please you cut the shit. I have 5 kids all gen z. Cry somewhere else. Don’t be part of the problem. Be part of the solution to make your world better.
@@erica.casimira there are dozens of problems with the world, all dropped up on gen Z by the previous generations like you guys, and the horrible boomers. Gen Z people kill themselves at unprecedented and massive rates, mental illness runs rampant, the economy is decaying, technology and the digital world have made life hell, the future job market is bleak, housing is ruined forever, yet you chumps still claim to somehow have had a worse run than others, with your surface level "problems." the reality is, the world is ruined, and there is no solution, all people can do it put their head down and bear the god awful future you all have thrust upon your children and their children. I'm not crying, I'm pissed at old fossils like you for this state, and the infinite delusion you have about it
It's raining outside this morning after I've been drinking wine and smoking cigarettes all night, and the rain is dripping from my roof and the raindrops are also falling on leaves on a bush in my front yard in unison with trents piano keystrokes while I think about a lady that I want... I'm sincerely crying tears right now, I am totally feeling this. I just want something I can never have.
Remember I taught you a quad core is faster than a dual core 've German Intel. Bluffing fire
I hope you’re doing well now bro
Way more compelling than the song. I copy-pasted with the intention of stealing for a song. Maybe not "stealing" stealing just for inspo. I used to drink and smoke till sun-up and that's when I felt the most me. I liked a lady too. Very much. But I never even hoped to be with her. I literally dreamed about it but dreams and hopes are not the same thing.
In English we did a project on music to get to know people....we had to pick one song from ur fav band and I picked this one....people thought I was gonna be the kid who would shoot up the school #noregrets
That's their lost for not understand the song
+1 more reason to not give a shit about people
Graphic Creator did you go to valley
more likey the the kid who talked the shooter out of shooting
Dave Duvalier you are Sooo right..the person that understands this would be the one to talk someone out of a horrific act! I'm in my 40s, a professional and I still get judged for loving this music. It is art from every aspect.also best concert in nyc 2017..so glad I grew up with the best music..I share with my child
This song is... I haven't got the words. Gives me goosebumps. That piano is amazing ❤
I just want something I can never have. What brilliant lyrics. This song speaks to my soul. I've felt this way every day of my life. This is true art.
2019 and this song still brings tears. Brilliant lyrics, brilliant performance. Does not get better than this.
Truer words have never been spoken.
I remember the first time I heard this song when I was roughly 13 or 14 yrs old. It gave me chills when I heard it and still does. Such a beautiful song.
Hi I Recommend a song called 'The Bond Villain' By Robert Nix
@@redskies4530 I will most definitely check it out. Thanks.
His voice is so enthrilling - even or espaecially when he sings so quietly.
With such a powerful voice it's never quiet.
i can hear this 1000 times in a row.. and each and every time.. i still get goosebumps
I was 24 depressed losing my house. I bought a 25 caliber Lorcin hand gun, six bullets and drove out to a field. I put this on loop.
Two days later I found I was pregnant with my second son. Thank you God for saving my life. And his. Thank you for letting me hear my mother and her devine intervention.
I think the beauty of this song is that it's very relatable, and different people think of different things. It's just sort of "longing" encapsulated into a poem.
❤
The world stopped for 6 and a half minutes ....
Kenneth Demeester haha my world stops for 6:34 every time I listen to this...
So DID Mine.
Plus 4 seconds
Whoa
love this song.. excellent way to define it, ephemerally.. i approve ..
20+ years later and it hits just as hard as the first time I heard it all those years ago.
I've been a fan of NIN and Trent for so many years... And I still can't put into words my respect and connection with him. It's truly beyond words. He's a genius. And he's brought me through so many tough moments. I'm so grateful for him 💖
36 years old. My father had a severe heart attack two days ago in Thailand. He has been on life support and will not make it. I just had to pull the plug on him. Hardest thing I've ever done.
Leaving to catch a flight to Thailand tonight to say goodbye and bring his ashes back home.
Thank you all so much for sharing your stories. It really makes me feel like I am not alone in my suffering.
I’m sorry, just remember all the joy and happiness with him ❤
hang in there bro, lost mine 6 years ago it's the hardest thing you'll ever have to deal with and you'll go down to deep dark places but please don't say why me say what is this teaching me
This is the MOST personal song for me... Beautiful & heartbreaking... I cry every time :(
This was my son's favorite song. He killed himself June 2017, and I wonder all the time...Today is his 45th birthday...So I went on line to hear this song,,and I found some of the 'interpretations" that fans had..Believe it or not by soul was rested.
same..
it's time to watch "natural born killers" (1994) again ...great story and epic soundtrack! ...Mickey & Mallory are the best :p
I said that last night. But then popped in People Under the Stairs but ready tonight
What's that movie about?
@@Mitchery watch it
A masterpiece.
40. Still Here. As a youth, interpreting this very song felt so different. Now all these years later…. Addiction, divorce…. Dammit Trent. You spoke to all of us.
... every time I hear this song I think of someone that I shared my life with, I feel like "gray would be the color if I had a heart".. I will never love anyone again.. I give up on love. Something I can never have... you know who you are. If there is a chance in hell you see this. I'm always thinkin of you.
I know the feeling. Hang in there. It gets easier as time passes. Good luck.
It never stops hurting, it only gets easier with time. Just leave that space in your heart for them and keep moving forward.
shara murphy Shara, I saw it. I didn't know you felt this way about me.
I hope you ran to her!
U always were the one to show me how
I was 16 the first time i heard this song. It has alot of meaning to me. It is so hauntingly beautiful. Trent is a beautiful Human being....i could listen to him sing all day every day. I totally get him. He is pretty amazing all the way around!
His music, for me, seems to help me confront pain. I probably know every word of everything he's ever done, when battling addiction, getting clean for the first time in over a decade, his words, his pain, led me to believe it could be done. As for him, bravo, and still a genius
I hate how much I love this song. Every time I hear it, reminds no matter how much I heal, I will allways have scars in my memories.
I've been listening to nin for 20yrs and there hasn't been one single day that I haven't listened to nin his writing is so cathartic what a great talent by far the most talented of our generation!