Was I Wrong about 1792 Full Proof Bourbon? What's On The Shelf Wednesday

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 170

  • @TheMashandDrum
    @TheMashandDrum  5 місяців тому +2

    Use my code MASH to get $5 off your delicious, high protein Magic Spoon cereal by clicking this link: sponsr.is/magicspoon_mash_0624

  • @richardsneed1255
    @richardsneed1255 5 місяців тому +40

    Gotta respect a guy that can admit he may be wrong and revisit the subject.

  • @Janoy_Cresva
    @Janoy_Cresva 5 місяців тому +43

    1792 FP at $50 is one of the best values around

    • @Tranzekno
      @Tranzekno 5 місяців тому +2

      *Benchmark FP has entered the chat* 👀

    • @0529mpb
      @0529mpb 5 місяців тому +1

      ​@Tranzekno Benchmark FP is a mixer, so is OGD 114. They are amazing in cocktails.

    • @Tranzekno
      @Tranzekno 5 місяців тому

      @@0529mpb I like both neat but yeah perfect for mixers too. Still some of the best value whiskeys you can find

    • @maddevil7474
      @maddevil7474 5 місяців тому +1

      This Pakistani tater store tried to convince me that 1792 FP was a $100 bottle.

    • @XoXoVENOMoXo
      @XoXoVENOMoXo 5 місяців тому +3

      Green river full proof for 49 is good as well

  • @gjlowe
    @gjlowe 5 місяців тому +14

    This bottle is so much better than regular 1792. Good call on the viscosity.

    • @BigDdreaming
      @BigDdreaming 5 місяців тому +1

      Yeah, wasn’t impressed with the small batch. Just found another bottle of the Full Proof. Very excited

  • @bigdave2952
    @bigdave2952 5 місяців тому +16

    I like the entire line up of 1792. Full proof is great!

  • @jasonwatson
    @jasonwatson 5 місяців тому +15

    I was one of the defenders from your last video…I think I was mostly just shocked because my palate generally is in line with yours 100%. On a side note why haven’t you made it to 100k yet, better content than some that are already there.

  • @djohnson3583
    @djohnson3583 5 місяців тому +7

    “Yea I know. I’m super Italian” 😂😂😂

  • @djbeacon6895
    @djbeacon6895 5 місяців тому +6

    Had 2 great SPs of the FP. Both were very good. The first one 4 years ago was Top 10 for me that year.

  • @jameswallace6227
    @jameswallace6227 5 місяців тому +1

    Store picks are really where this one shines. The regular bottles are still good but I’ve had two picks that were just excellent in every way.

  • @stuartrollings602
    @stuartrollings602 5 місяців тому +1

    Howdy and glad you enjoyed this batch! Been collecting all of the 1792s and especially the full proof! Saddle up!

  • @JR-KKAS0819
    @JR-KKAS0819 5 місяців тому +1

    Yes!!!, thank Goodness you revisit this, incredible Bourbon great value Store picks are amazing.

  • @Jack-kt8bs
    @Jack-kt8bs 26 днів тому

    I have a bottle on the shelf. It is next to be given a good try out. looking forward to it.

  • @nickmerkerson5401
    @nickmerkerson5401 5 місяців тому +1

    1792 FP is a favorite. I have only had store picks and always a great pour. Cheers and good pouring.

  • @DaveH8905
    @DaveH8905 5 місяців тому +5

    1792 Full Proof legit may be the best overall bourbon readily available on shelves. (It’s readily available for me, anyway). It has an awesome price point, a beautiful bottle, and the flavor profile tastes like a blend of all the different legacy distilleries into one bottle, and is so well balanced, like you said. It’s Goldilocks. Does it blow me away like a C923? No, but I don’t think it needs to.

  • @coreysstillbarking
    @coreysstillbarking 5 місяців тому +1

    Glad to hear it Jason. I love these picks and they only get better with time. I was very surprised when it made the video, so I’m glad you revisited it.

  • @fredbaker6315
    @fredbaker6315 4 місяці тому

    I have been able to get 1792 Full Proof regularly for about 40 bucks. I grab a bottle whenever I come across one and find it awesome. I can only imagine how a store pick would match up with what I’m finding on the shelf. It’s still one of my go to bottles for the price! Cheers

  • @nickp5511
    @nickp5511 5 місяців тому +1

    Nice review! I really enjoy the 1792 SB, 12yr, and Full Proof! I just picked up a store pick the other day and it’s even nicer! Cheers!

  • @connerneal286
    @connerneal286 5 місяців тому +1

    I bought a 1792 FP SP from a reputable store in KS. It's probably a top 40 bottle. My buddy got a different store pic in the same town, and it's a top 5 all time bottle. Wild how much the 1792 FP differ from one another.

    • @motohead077
      @motohead077 3 місяці тому

      Cpl days ago had my 1st 1792 ever & it's a SiB Pick $45. It's really good, but have no other 1792 to compare it to. Though it is probably the best (or tied) $45 bottle I ever had. As good or better than 2 ECBP batches. Better than the JD BP barrel I have.
      No banana, but beautiful sweet vanilla on this.
      Thinking of getting a cpl more bottles, as who knows if/when I'll be able to find any pick at $45.

  • @DiegoG.whiskey
    @DiegoG.whiskey 5 місяців тому +1

    I have a store pick from a small store in Portales NM, it's a full proof 1792, it's really good, nice bouquet of flavors and gets better as it sits!!

  • @nateduncan7089
    @nateduncan7089 5 місяців тому +1

    The 1792 Full Proof is my favorite in the series followed closely by the 12 year.

  • @WhiskeyTemple
    @WhiskeyTemple 5 місяців тому

    Have this bottle. Agree 100%. Originally from Columbus, OH and moved to Largo, FL. 10 years ago. Sunshine, Corona, Star and my favorite 1St Ave Liquors always have some great store picks!!! Keep up the great content.

  • @eugenenassif
    @eugenenassif 5 місяців тому +1

    Indie bottlers like Calumet have proved that Barton liquid can be some of the best bourbon out there. Unfortunately, cask variation is massive. I've had 1792 picks that I would buy again and again and ones with a sip out of them sitting on my shelf for years. Huge variation.

  • @c.j.miller2665
    @c.j.miller2665 5 місяців тому

    Dude! I respected you before, but I even respect you more for saying you were wrong! But I agree that 1792 is usually hot. But happy you enjoyed it again. Cheers!

  • @gabeballinger375
    @gabeballinger375 5 місяців тому

    Let is rest 30 minutes and try again. Helps reduce alcohol burn. Great Video!

  • @uwrossl
    @uwrossl 5 місяців тому +1

    Hahaha....Literally just poured one and opened up the computer. I've got a local store pick as well as one from the total wine here and both are excellent. Thought you were crazy on that vid where you were dogging it. Great to see the update and give it time. The ethanol totally balances out on everyone I've had. Cherry, chocolate, tobacco, leather are prominent on both of mine. My wife where's Lost Cherry perfume from Tom Ford and every time she puts it on I want a pour of 1792 Full Proof.

  • @TheUMIA
    @TheUMIA 5 місяців тому +12

    1792 FP is great for $50. Even better when your local stores have store picks. Cheers.

  • @chrisb5986
    @chrisb5986 5 місяців тому +4

    Finally, a bottle I can find and afford.

  • @stevenwilson6941
    @stevenwilson6941 5 місяців тому

    Glad you liked it. I get them from time to time and really like the flavor but usually drinks really hot. May seek out a store pick

  • @peterb.3278
    @peterb.3278 5 місяців тому

    I am so glad you finally got a good 1792 full proof - yes there still some that run hot but a good barrel pick can be so good!

  • @remander3873
    @remander3873 5 місяців тому +1

    Barton actually has one of my favorite overall profiles. I love it. You'll find it in some other brands that source from Barton, like Calumet Farms and Sam Houston, IIRC.

    • @DPTX
      @DPTX 5 місяців тому +1

      Same here! Buckner’s 13 and Lucky Seven 14 are amazing and both sourced from Barton.

  • @vincentsimon4037
    @vincentsimon4037 4 місяці тому

    Just picked up a bottle last weekend in Ashland KY from Good Spirits. Paid $69.99 but it's the 1st time I've ever seen it outside of their crap small batch. I'll likely go back to get the B&Bond to add to my collection. Thanks for the great review fellow drummer!

  • @brandonedwards9001
    @brandonedwards9001 5 місяців тому

    Haven't had a pick myself, hell got my first full proof this year but dollar for dollar i find that full proof bottle to be great. At $50 it's well worth it imo. Definitely will by a pick when i come across one. Cheers!

  • @ericwhelan4433
    @ericwhelan4433 5 місяців тому

    Just got a local pick of this, and it’s right on the heels of a recent Stagg I had this weekend. Stellar bottle for the price.

  • @DumptruckDAV3
    @DumptruckDAV3 5 місяців тому

    So many people sleep on 1792 FP. Its got proof, its got flavor, its a great value for the money. I have several store picks in my bar at home from various states and I will usually buy one whenever I see them.

  • @TheJohnbortle
    @TheJohnbortle 5 місяців тому

    I'm always impressed by it when I grab a store pick after I haven't had it for a while.

  • @andrettski8686
    @andrettski8686 5 місяців тому +1

    A friend had the shelfer that I tried and liked. Came across a store pick and WOW, just phenomenal, it drinks more like 115-118 proof to me.

  • @josephclites6971
    @josephclites6971 5 місяців тому

    Love the whole 1792 lineup. Haven't had SW, PF, or HR, but the others are incredible. And when you can get a store pick, they generally are even better. I have a SB store pick that is out of this world for a 98 proofer.

  • @teofilstevenson
    @teofilstevenson 5 місяців тому

    Nice review Jason. If I can find a 1792 Store Pick I grab them and typically love them. The Single Barrel prolly my fav with Full, Proof coming in second.

  • @IG-wp9hw
    @IG-wp9hw 5 місяців тому +1

    I love your what’s on the shelf Wednesdays!!!!

  • @JD0124
    @JD0124 5 місяців тому +1

    I think this is the first time I was the first to comment! Woot!!! Now, time to check it out....
    I've had the Full Proof some time ago, but I don't recall what I thought.

  • @rfitz4233
    @rfitz4233 5 місяців тому

    My single barrel store pick was disjointed and too hot at first, but after only a few days it smoothed out and lengthened with a lot of great high proof flavors. Glad you liked yours. Cheers!

  • @dougpearson3934
    @dougpearson3934 5 місяців тому

    So glad to see you onboard now…. such a bargain, it’s hard to beat if you’re looking for that proof punch…. I have been seeing tons of these in the past 6 months or so in the Houston area… store picks usually around $49.99. Great review Jason. 👍

  • @jeffwinbush5039
    @jeffwinbush5039 5 місяців тому

    Well, well, well. I appreciate your timing as I'm heading down to Louisville this week, so I'm gonna add this 1792 to my "buy it if I see it" list. Thanks, Jason! 👍

  • @teddyballgame25
    @teddyballgame25 5 місяців тому +1

    I’m sure it’s capable of being very good. My pick from PA is just a small step above Bulleit CS.

  • @Blinc32
    @Blinc32 5 місяців тому

    I think these are underrated for sure. I got a regular FP recently that was a real banger. Plus I have a few picks and one I think is like rich and fruity more like Stagg and one is more nutty like a good KC 120 proof bourbon pick. And at 50 ish bucks I think they're a great value.

  • @Gatorblitz69
    @Gatorblitz69 5 місяців тому

    One of my favorite pours, I have about 12 different store picks at the moment! Cheers

  • @salata95
    @salata95 5 місяців тому

    I knew I wasn’t crazy it is freaking great
    And for 50-55 bucks it just makes me smile
    Been seeing tons of of store picks all over from small stores to Total Wine definitely one of my favorites 👍
    Glad you enjoyed it 🥃cheers

  • @dgsutube01
    @dgsutube01 5 місяців тому

    I don't see them often where I live, but whenever I'm travelling and spot a store pick I'll usually grab it. I haven't been disappointed yet. Thanks for giving it another shot!

  • @timmorton2307
    @timmorton2307 3 місяці тому

    I just bought one today on a whim, i am not a barrel proof guy, but this is damn tasty!! As i was about to write Stagg like, you said it outloud. This is a good one,

  • @bobbocontreras5240
    @bobbocontreras5240 5 місяців тому

    I got a beautiful oak note. Viscous and some great tasting notes. Love that bottle

  • @OutsideTheStar
    @OutsideTheStar 5 місяців тому +1

    A couple good suggestions for WOTSW. Pikesville Rye, Sagamore Double oak’d, Rye, I don’t think you’ve done Four Roses Small batch select & Dragons Milk Origins. ( I know it’s not everywhere but it’s super underrated)

  • @danieldean2096
    @danieldean2096 5 місяців тому

    Picked up the 1792 FP for $45 in PA. Looking forward to opening and comparing to the SB. Cheers

  • @billyeksi9553
    @billyeksi9553 5 місяців тому

    I never tried 1792 now you got me curious especially after you admit that you were wrong about it I respect that

  • @doughency8408
    @doughency8408 5 місяців тому

    Lavergne beverage in Tennessee had a store pick of this and I bought Two bottles it was so good and have already finished the first

  • @mladjoRiChi
    @mladjoRiChi 5 місяців тому +1

    After this review I revisited 1792 FPSP from Warehouse Liquors in Chicago, and it was absolutely delicious! But then I added about 20% of 1792 12y to my that pour, and I enjoyed it tremendously! 😋🥃
    It made it even more complex and less proofy. A pour I’d like to present to any bourbon lover whenever we do flights! Should blend as much of it I can, and have it as a benchmark to what enjoyable pour should taste! 😅😋😋🥃🥃

  • @motohead077
    @motohead077 3 місяці тому

    Jason, you weren't wrong. The prior bottle of 1792 you had a pour from was not to your liking. Now you have different whiskey in the same bottle & you like it much more..
    Thanks for the reviews though, you saved me from taking a chance on a 1792 shelfer at $50-60 & just got a SiB $45 from a very well respected picker/group & it's great!
    Good things come to those who wait & put in research time

  • @jacquelineanthony1080
    @jacquelineanthony1080 5 місяців тому

    I have some at my Salute Liquor store in Austin Texas!! It's a good pour and I am happy you are reviewing it !! awesome

  • @mgrego2
    @mgrego2 5 місяців тому +1

    I’m with you. I haven’t liked any 1792 because the alcohol burn messes with the flavor and the experience. In the last few months, I’ve picked up two store picks that I really liked.

    • @andrettski8686
      @andrettski8686 5 місяців тому +1

      Yes, the store pick I got didn't drink hot at all, more like 115-118 proof. And that was at 1st crack.

    • @Best_Served_Neat_On_Ice
      @Best_Served_Neat_On_Ice 5 місяців тому +1

      @@andrettski8686,
      I've had two Full Proof store picks that drank like 115 at the first crack. The regular non-store pick drank like 130 at the first crack!

  • @Speciarii
    @Speciarii 5 місяців тому

    Rarely find these on the shelf, let alone a store pick, in my area. Cheers 🥃

  • @ttiger9780
    @ttiger9780 5 місяців тому

    I bought one of these a few years ago and loved it. Haven't seen any since.

  • @a68freak
    @a68freak 5 місяців тому +1

    Glad I’m not crazy, I get the same thing from 1792 Full Proof. Viscous, intense flavor, but lots of heat. Interested if someone I trusted picked one. I only find them at big box stores. Thanks Jason C.

  • @CharleyCarey
    @CharleyCarey 5 місяців тому

    I found this, as a store pick, 3 weeks in a row this spring. I haven't seen it since. I was a big fan.

  • @huntermcdougal5013
    @huntermcdougal5013 5 місяців тому

    1792 single barrel and full picks are straight honey. Also love the 12 year

  • @BigDdreaming
    @BigDdreaming 5 місяців тому

    One of my favorites. Strong but flavorful

  • @jonathansantana6239
    @jonathansantana6239 5 місяців тому

    1792 fp store picks are tasty to me. To each their own. I'm not crazy about WT products, and I'm sure that is an unpopular opinion. Who cares. Drink what you like and how you like. Cheers. That being said, glad you came around. Those are the tasting notes I get on mine.

  • @christopherryan7654
    @christopherryan7654 5 місяців тому +2

    One of my favorites.

  • @Jrdeck88
    @Jrdeck88 5 місяців тому

    I got my first 1792 12yr a few months ago for pretty close to MSRP…it is my favorite bourbon so far…gonna have to find a full proof

  • @codyking1001
    @codyking1001 5 місяців тому

    The single barrels are soooo much better than the standard release

  • @stuffandwhiskey
    @stuffandwhiskey 5 місяців тому

    I wonder if there’s a subtle shift in the Barton profile happening much like Turkey, but it seems to be getting less banana-y and more dark and rich. We did a 1792FP and we didn’t get banana in a single barrel in the bunch. It was kinda shocking. In talks with people who have picked there recently, they said next to no banana either. If Barton starts to shift toward this darker profile then I’m all for it!

  • @reudevad
    @reudevad 4 місяці тому

    Our local small shop got a case of this and put it on the shelf at $45. I just bought two

  • @RodneyHenderson357
    @RodneyHenderson357 5 місяців тому

    Gotta keep the 1792 offering in rotation. The small batch and Asw fiddler were my gateway juice in my bourbon journey. The store pick full proof are butterscotch and maple bombs. Trick is letting it breathe for at least a week. After opens that's when the magic happens......

  • @andrewswanson7485
    @andrewswanson7485 5 місяців тому

    Love this bottle, one of my favorites. If you want to have a very great old fashioned try it with 1792 full proof and thank me later...

  • @dustinrose3
    @dustinrose3 5 місяців тому

    Don’t give away all the secrets!
    Love these hopefully they stay available and somewhat affordable.

  • @davidhopkins3120
    @davidhopkins3120 5 місяців тому

    Hi Jason, well I'm glad for the controversy on 1792 Full Proof and sorry you were wrong, budda bing! Yah I really like the full proof and I admit I haven't seen your "scathing" review so I don't have a lot to say except that I appreciate your humble apology, haha...Cheers!

  • @BuffaloBourbonEnthusiasts
    @BuffaloBourbonEnthusiasts 5 місяців тому

    We did a blind of 4 1792 Full Proof picks and after the video I said, I don’t need to ever buy another. Well, then a 1792 FP crushed all the competition in my bottle share. Phenomenal.

    • @iansammons2730
      @iansammons2730 5 місяців тому +1

      1792 FP holds up incredibly well against other high proofers. Its bold with nice easy to pick out fruit characteristics and enough oak to let you know it means business. Its 45 bucks in pa right now, and beats bottles twice its price.

    • @BuffaloBourbonEnthusiasts
      @BuffaloBourbonEnthusiasts 5 місяців тому

      @@iansammons2730 If you're in Western PA and you happen to travel up to Buffalo, then grab Key Liquors store pick. It is unlike any other 1792 FP. Cheers!

  • @Whiskey_Sippers
    @Whiskey_Sippers 5 місяців тому

    I have a 1792 full proof pick that is amazing. Has a green apple note like a jolly rancher, it's a pick from John O's.

  • @eddavison1961
    @eddavison1961 5 місяців тому

    Just saw a bunch on the shelf in Philly for 45. Bought one, obviously.

  • @philb6409
    @philb6409 5 місяців тому

    Nice review; glad you are doing these again.

  • @DPTX
    @DPTX 5 місяців тому

    I got a 9 year pick last year that is ridiculously good, noticeably darker than a standard FP too.

  • @krischaney9034
    @krischaney9034 5 місяців тому

    Give it a couple weeks. I've never had a bottle open up like a 1792 FP. Cheers!

  • @319_Fishing
    @319_Fishing 5 місяців тому

    I haven’t had a bad 1792 Fp store pick! The regular FP isnt bad but the store picks are incredibly better

  • @craigvanderhoff1208
    @craigvanderhoff1208 5 місяців тому

    Finally pulled the trigger on this bottle recently and just popped it open after your review! For the money really good! Definitely get the brown sugar and banana note. I really enjoy that banana note!

  • @peterjanetatos7061
    @peterjanetatos7061 5 місяців тому

    I paid$49.99 today and I think it’s awesome!!

  • @mikey82sy
    @mikey82sy 5 місяців тому

    “Yeah, I know. I’m super Italian” 😂🥃😂🥃

  • @RVWhiskey
    @RVWhiskey 5 місяців тому

    This one also always drank hot for me. Maybe it does need a touch of water. I’ve actually started to add 2-3 drops of water to most of my whiskey JUST to see if it gets better or worse. I think that most of us bourbon drinkers tend to write off adding water all together, but I’m finding that some whiskies really do benefit from a hint of water.

  • @trevorforever1
    @trevorforever1 5 місяців тому

    I like my regular 1792 FP but I also happen to know the store that picked that bottle and they have some PHENOMENAL store picks. Can’t wait to crack my EHT SiB they picked recently

  • @stephenfitt5633
    @stephenfitt5633 5 місяців тому +1

    Not been able find a store pick (I’m in U.K.) but wasn’t a fan of the regular full proof, it drank so so hot.

  • @curetiamhices289
    @curetiamhices289 5 місяців тому +1

    I’m finally seeing 1792 offerings other than small batch where I am. I’m a big fan of the Full Proof, but I don’t see any store picks, unfortunately.

  • @ikkiwikki
    @ikkiwikki 5 місяців тому

    Nice to see you can admit that you were wrong. Even the standard 1792 FP is a solid bottle for people that don’t want to hunt. Have only had one store pick and it was significantly better. Cheers!

  • @numanuma20
    @numanuma20 5 місяців тому

    You had to mention Sunshine up in Palm Harbor! They have two locations.

  • @jj18057
    @jj18057 5 місяців тому +1

    I enjoy the sweet wheat offering.

  • @michaelcriger6359
    @michaelcriger6359 5 місяців тому

    Never see them throughout most of the mid-west that I travel in, but just managed to get one on a trip to Texas! Picked up a BIB, too!

  • @ceottolino
    @ceottolino 5 місяців тому

    1st experience when it won awards a few years back i thought it drank hot , this year I too have tried to store picks and both were amazing pours 1792 store picks in 2023-24 are way better than what I had 3 or 4 years ago

  • @jtblackford
    @jtblackford 5 місяців тому

    Sunshine Liquors is a great store, they have great barrel picks

  • @inkynate9372
    @inkynate9372 5 місяців тому

    I like Barton/1792/Calumet in general, but the FP pick I have open atm is an absolute banger. Stupid good for $50. Stores locally have also been flooded with FP and the bib over the past couple of months.

  • @jonathanhackett9180
    @jonathanhackett9180 5 місяців тому

    I bought 3 bottles when Jim Murray rated it as his world whiskey of the year 2020..still have one left. Bought a store pick last year and a new standard release this year and I'd say both have more alcohol punch then the 2020 batch but they all have good aspects. Benchmark full proof is a good comparison but I've preferred the 1792s blind

  • @ryanschroeder560
    @ryanschroeder560 5 місяців тому +1

    You gotta figure out how to get a batched full proof and do a comparison. I have only had a single barrel and it was a complete hitter. From my experience outside of regular 1792, I’ve only seen Barton products on the coasts. I’d imagine that they are still catching up from the warehouse falling apart.

  • @UncleSpam1350
    @UncleSpam1350 5 місяців тому

    7/8 In Bloomington, MN, may still have some of these on hand. I was chatting up the folks there about how they do their picks, though, and they said Barton very recently just started sending the bottles without giving them any chance to sample and choose a barrel themselves. Kind of a shame, since I really trust their palates.

  • @toddtipton2857
    @toddtipton2857 5 місяців тому

    Love those bottles

  • @whiskeybidness
    @whiskeybidness 5 місяців тому

    Living in Virginia as an ABC control state these don’t pop up often but they do find their into allocated drops 3-4 times a year as SB picks. I always have 1 plus a backup on hand because they simply SLAP!