Been a Roses, Ian Brown fan since 1990. What a remarkable talent it is to be able to miss every note in a song in one take. The legendary frontman of a generation persona that he once effortlessly carried has more of sleeping amongst the binbags around the back of ASDA's vibe about it now.
@@nickyn4076 Correct. I was, I don’t follow anyone blindly. If an artist short changes me I have the freewill to register it and decide accordingly. I’ll continue to listen to the early solo and Roses stuff, but his recent output and performances are not to the same standard.
Whatever anyone is saying about Ian. The man has more balls than just about anyone in the entertainment business, he speaks his mind and treads his own path. If you polish go see Elton Joan’s
He's one of very few well known people if you like that have spoken out over the bs we've been subjected to the last 2 1/2 years and he's always been very outspoken and rightly so. Without having to go into detail cause we'll be here til the cows come home, you must know deep down that something is very wrong with this world, much love Ian Brown x
I'm really sad I found and watched this.. Absolutely loved the Roses, the first album was one of the all time UK classics and I was there at Spike Island. But jesus this was like a homeless man finding a microphone 😢
I can understand the financial implications of not wanting to tour with a band, but he should at least re-record the backing tracks to a key he can sing in these days
Shit hot. Now I get it. Standing on the shoulders of the great Jamaican toasters and those roots travelling sound systems, the MCs at the parties giving birth to Hip Hop... I get it. Love this man x
@@royblackman8778 yeah, I’ve never rated him. A mate of mine once tried telling me he was better than Richard Ashcroft. It was that moment I realised my mate was a retard!
Love Brownie huge fan saw him live loads of times but shame hes doing this letting himself the song and his fans down needs a band behind him song is a masterpiece.
Always a big fan of the roses and at various times, Brown could sing a bit better or a bit worse, always masked by a tight live band, without that distraction you purely focus on the vocal and it's dreadful
Ian Brown is one of the very real rock rebels. While all the masked morons were shuffling around like robotic idiots he was one of the VERY few who had the guts to express the Truth. The reaction against him puts a black mark on British history.
People can slag him off all they want but his solo work is the bollocks prefer it to the Roses. Hope he makes a new album and sorts this out hes better than this. His solo work is so underrated its a shame to see him like this legend.
No one knows his financial status, he doesn't look like he's got too much left in the tank so guessing this is his retirement fund... you can't blame him, surely he's earned the right to a cash grab at the end of his career? Besides tickets were cheap tbf
It's funny alls you lot slaggin ian off and I bet half of yas a) wouldn't have the balls to say to his face b) have the balls to even get up on stage ya selves! Bare in mind he's older , voices change man. After decades of singing at massive venues not just in a massive band that also reunited and a solo career I'd think his voice would of changed. The guys nearly 60. Legend!
Obviously with his stature as a Manchester rock icon he thought after splitting with the band again he could do a tour on his own.I agree with the criticisms but he probably thought it was less effort and much easier doing it on his own.I think 40 quid is ok though,you are seeing the man singing and the music is good
FFS! That has to be the worst, out of tune, vocal I have ever heard in my life. Excruciating. It’s tragic because the album is excellent. Let’s face it; he can’t sing in tune. The bad singers in the crowd are more in tune.😢
look, take the covid & conspiracy theories and focus on the music, he was never a brilliant vocalist but he got the job done back in the 90s and early 2000s but now hes just completely lost it. compare this tragedy to what noel gallagher is doing at about his same age, noel arguably sounds BETTER AT 55 THAN WHEN HE WAS IN HIS MID TWENTIES. thats saying something.
I seriously fancied him for years and he was absolutely gorgeous in the FEAR video. Here he looks like someone you’d cross the road to avoid whilst avoiding eye contact and holding your bag with both hands. Very sad.
The band are tight - sound just like the record!
Backing track not a musician in site.. Ian needs to stop his voice is shit beyond flat
@@MrSandalwood lol
Never thought I’d say that but it would have been better if he sung from playback
Been a Roses, Ian Brown fan since 1990. What a remarkable talent it is to be able to miss every note in a song in one take. The legendary frontman of a generation persona that he once effortlessly carried has more of sleeping amongst the binbags around the back of ASDA's vibe about it now.
@@nickyn4076 Correct. I was, I don’t follow anyone blindly. If an artist short changes me I have the freewill to register it and decide accordingly. I’ll continue to listen to the early solo and Roses stuff, but his recent output and performances are not to the same standard.
Its called aging mate.
@@nextinline777it's called too many years of abusing drugs and this is the end result
@@andy_xtr3861 Still, he must have a few quid in the bank from this tour.
@@nextinline777 Plenty of artists older than him can still sing.
For. Everyone. A. Refund.
😆😆😆
Best comment, apart from the sleeping in the bins round the back of ASDA vibe.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂 dying mate
Find Exit And Run
Funding Elderly Age Retirement
Find Earrape Annoying Really
You just cant sugar coat this....
Millions could sing well, only few could write songs millions love
Is he serious, using a backing track and his singing is awful?
Can sombody please inform Mr Brown that one of the cleaners Is fucking about with his microphone
Whatever anyone is saying about Ian. The man has more balls than just about anyone in the entertainment business, he speaks his mind and treads his own path. If you polish go see Elton Joan’s
There's being original and them theres masking being shit as original.. unfortunately Brown here is a sad parody
He's drugged out, he probably just does this 'cause he needs drug money.
The man bun/ponytail combo only adds to the misery.
I brought my two sons with me to that gig, we travelled over from Dublin to see him, Legend he is!!
Is that you Yoda?
Mmm
yet after all that he was as shit as you knew he would be - right? I bet your kids thanked you for it... ffs...
I saw this guy outside cash converters with a can of tennents super
Same ere
Yeah, and we can hear the result of that. Dire, shambolic, out of tune karaoke!😢
How cool was that
Haha me too!
Write a song like this pal,and you won't be outside CashConverters...you Uneducated fool....
We can say that at least he knew the lyrics
Karaoke board was probably behind the camera
I was at this gig & he was absolutely brilliant he got the whole crowd up on his own without a band respect Mr brown
I've got some magic beans for sale 🤡
He had the crowd up because there were no seats
Why pay a band when you have a laptop out back
This is unbelievably sad. He should have left it where it was. This is a money grab and a ruined reputation. Gutted.
He's one of very few well known people if you like that have spoken out over the bs we've been subjected to the last 2 1/2 years and he's always been very outspoken and rightly so. Without having to go into detail cause we'll be here til the cows come home, you must know deep down that something is very wrong with this world, much love Ian Brown x
Oh aye, those 150K dead must’ve been really pleased he was calling it all bullshit
The legend is in danger of becoming a myth……..😔
I'm really sad I found and watched this.. Absolutely loved the Roses, the first album was one of the all time UK classics and I was there at Spike Island. But jesus this was like a homeless man finding a microphone 😢
What do they say about nothing good to say🫢
This wasn't the stone roses it was Ian brown . Stop living in the past
man that is unintentional praise, working class hero, the whole point
“Fantastic expectations” oh the irony
Reminds me of all the drunk lads at the bar during karaoke night.
I can understand the financial implications of not wanting to tour with a band, but he should at least re-record the backing tracks to a key he can sing in these days
Nothing to do with keys. That was tone deaf.
I was at rock city on Thursday. Best 40 quid I've ever spent
Nottingham was a very good night.
He's like a "mad as fk" Uncle pissed up at a wedding Dad dancing LOL.
Lol exactly what I was thinking. What a legend!
You just don’t get it do you
Laughing all the way to the bank
Hardly. There's like 50 people there.
Laughing all the way to Mc donands
Mc Donald’s my bad
Brown is a embarrassment 😳
@@MrSandalwood to you and the rest of the middle class.
Legend
Bloody beautiful ! ❤❤❤❤ Top Man x
Shit hot. Now I get it. Standing on the shoulders of the great Jamaican toasters and those roots travelling sound systems, the MCs at the parties giving birth to Hip Hop...
I get it. Love this man x
Like my Grampa on karaoke down the local 😆😆😆
Only not as good.😂
@@mcfabb absolutely! 🤣
Saw him at v2000 and he was shite then!
@@royblackman8778 yeah, I’ve never rated him. A mate of mine once tried telling me he was better than Richard Ashcroft. It was that moment I realised my mate was a retard!
Go and watch Ed sheeran then and take your emojis with ya
Love Brownie huge fan saw him live loads of times but shame hes doing this letting himself the song and his fans down needs a band behind him song is a masterpiece.
He’s not singing in key it’s awfull
He’s never sang in key!!! ✌️👍✌️
Always a big fan of the roses and at various times, Brown could sing a bit better or a bit worse, always masked by a tight live band, without that distraction you purely focus on the vocal and it's dreadful
Exactly brown is tacking the piss out of his fan.. backing tracks and shit vocals.. it's embarrassing 😳
It was never about the voice
It was about the music..oh wait, there's no music..
Ian Brown is one of the very real rock rebels. While all the masked morons were shuffling around like robotic idiots he was one of the VERY few who had the guts to express the Truth. The reaction against him puts a black mark on British history.
Christ that looks and sounds bad
Looks like the bloke who’d dance in the bus station if you gave him 20p
Bore off
😂😂😂😂
Anything to do with Covid?
A pound. But so what?
@@alexgroushko3142 Stay safe hehehe
Its really sad to see what hard drugs do to a person if they live long enough to end up like this.
He does look stoned
People can slag him off all they want but his solo work is the bollocks prefer it to the Roses. Hope he makes a new album and sorts this out hes better than this. His solo work is so underrated its a shame to see him like this legend.
Did he give a reason why he didn’t have a band on tour with him?
Obviously money
Sometimes I fantasise where the stage is cold and lonely and the punters are stung below me
I love the Stone Roses but this is a rip off
This song aged well
Such a shame. What an incredible vocalist, this was painful.
YEA IAN BROWN SICK AS FUCK ONE OF THE BOYS TRUST ME
Embarrassing! Mugging your own fans of with a karaoke. Surprised he didn't have a monitor with the words rolling down.
Some easy money for the retirement fund.
Easy money but hard listening.
so basically people are paying for a karaoke show... wtf?
Stone Roses legend
Spettacolare non azzecca una nota, ma lo amo cosi ❤️
Lyrics don't alter tune beat still remains.message no different what are folk moaning for
Agree if they don’t like it then switch off 🤬🤬
No one knows his financial status, he doesn't look like he's got too much left in the tank so guessing this is his retirement fund... you can't blame him, surely he's earned the right to a cash grab at the end of his career? Besides tickets were cheap tbf
Who gives a F*** it’s Ian brown still love the song. I wouldn’t kick him out of bed as far as I’m concerned still love the man
Wheres the band?
Seriously ?
Great gig and was on form...sounded and looked better up by the mixing desk
Where was it? Ten miles away? The best mix would’ve been muted vocals.
Lol everyone complaining in the comments why watch it then 😂 stick to listening to liam gallagher
Sick gig! 🔥
Great atmosphere. 🙌
#stellify
#monkeymagic
#stonerosesriseagain2025
It's funny alls you lot slaggin ian off and I bet half of yas a) wouldn't have the balls to say to his face b) have the balls to even get up on stage ya selves! Bare in mind he's older , voices change man. After decades of singing at massive venues not just in a massive band that also reunited and a solo career I'd think his voice would of changed. The guys nearly 60. Legend!
You can't even spell, lol.
IB - Incredible brave. Word!!!
It’s a fine line though😂
Sounds terrible sorry
You don’t get it go somewhere else
@@timcomley5948 get what
Free. Earplugs. All. Round
You don't have to be able sing to be absolutely fucking brilliant.
If your known as a singer...Then singing is quite important...You sound like a proper fan boy...Give your head a shake you muppet...
No band equals much more money..keep it real Ian
Who cares about the haters 🤔
Agree
Love him but it's gone
Dress him in Mongolian armour and he could be Mounted a Mongolian steed 0:31 flinging arrows across the plains.
He’s taking the piss here.
Really needs a band supporting
He really doesn't. Did you see him live on this tour ?
The man is going naked on stage spreading the old modern words and fans are crying for a band? Enjoy while you can!
Wish he had been naked
Should have at least told his fans he was preforming without a band before selling the tickets.
Why's he doing this... He used to have a great backing band. Strange.
Shite
I was there, £40 to watch a fuckin karaoke.
Obviously with his stature as a Manchester rock icon he thought after splitting with the band again he could do a tour on his own.I agree with the criticisms but he probably thought it was less effort and much easier doing it on his own.I think 40 quid is ok though,you are seeing the man singing and the music is good
FFS! That has to be the worst, out of tune, vocal I have ever heard in my life. Excruciating. It’s tragic because the album is excellent. Let’s face it; he can’t sing in tune. The bad singers in the crowd are more in tune.😢
even wearing his own merch..this is beyond tragic... like a charity version of stars in their eyes
Lol, maybe he likes is own merch?
He always wore his own merch
Marc Bolan also wore his own t-shirts.
Mick Jagger take note.
Wow that’s bad..
he looks more like my nan than my nan does
😂😂😂😂
Now shares the same look as Bruce Dickinson
Good luck Ian, you’re being judged on your opinions not your ability.
Absolute shite Ian.
Ger to the back of the dole que.
he looks like my lesbian aunty
That is fuckin awful
Put your earplugs in then! Simples
P.L.O.P. Murdered
What happened dude?
God awful .
Tragic
look, take the covid & conspiracy theories and focus on the music, he was never a brilliant vocalist but he got the job done back in the 90s and early 2000s but now hes just completely lost it. compare this tragedy to what noel gallagher is doing at about his same age, noel arguably sounds BETTER AT 55 THAN WHEN HE WAS IN HIS MID TWENTIES. thats saying something.
Kareoke king 🤦♂️
Legend but he's deffo bin on bag
Hahaha
Fantastically excremental and ridiculous
This is awful
This is very, very sad.
Karaoke 🎤 car crash
actually think this is legit mad
Depressing
soft lad
it's a no from me. shame tho. huge respect for the albums
...you guys paid money for this ?
Aww Ian.. come on lad, what happened here, that was not an acceptable performance, love ya but play this back 2 yourself...
Total embarrassment, from a man I grew up idolising.
I seriously fancied him for years and he was absolutely gorgeous in the FEAR video. Here he looks like someone you’d cross the road to avoid whilst avoiding eye contact and holding your bag with both hands. Very sad.
I think he’s still gorgeous
Jesus
He must need money for drugs...
You know this for a fact do you? Where’s your proof? Or is it just supposition
The only singer who sounds worse live