The Recognition of Taiwan Since 1949
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 бер 2022
- The video shows the recognition of the state of Taiwan (Republic of China) since 1949 when the People's Republic of China formed. In 2022, there are currently 181 countries recognize the People's Republic of China while only 14 countries recognize the Republic of China (Taiwan).
Twitter: / wawamustats
Facebook: wawamustats
Subscribe here: ua-cam.com/users/wawamustats?s...
Bhutan is the real OG here
BHUTAN BE LIKE WHAT THE NORTH IS NOT OCEAN NOT REAL MAN WHAT?
@@Random_Chinese_Person Bhutan believes it is not landlocked
@@aaryanbhatia4939 I SAID IT
Aryan?🧐
Bhutan only recognize qing dynasty in china
And see ROC and PRC isnt china
Countries who recognize neither: My goals are beyond your understanding.
Bhutan
@@imweird3363 No doubt India's vassal
nowadays, only bhutan because bhutan's foreign relations are controlled by india.
I believe it'd be better to use ROC rather than "Taiwan", at least in this video. Because It's comparing two regimes representing the same nation "China". It's just the matter of recognizing which regime. Using plain "Taiwan" might very likely cause some confusion to people who aren't so clear on the history.
As a Taiwanese,I don't agree
@@goodmanyoung3393 Elaborate, is Taiwan not Republic of China (1912-present)?
@@goodmanyoung3393 If you don't agree, overthrow the Nanking government of China, which rules Taiwan Province! Instead of disapproving online! Taiwan Province doesn't even have its own government ~
goodman young If you do not agree, you can amend the constitution, which is stipulated in your constitution. Of course, Taiwanese people have no concept of law, and everyone from the president to ordinary people violates the Constitution all the time.
@@goodmanyoung3393 You don't agree, but ROC's constitution agree
Up to today, 181 UN members recognize PRC as the sole legal government of China including Taiwan island. 14 UN members still recognize the pre-1972 ROC. 0 UN member recognizes ROT
What is ROT?
Republic of taiwan
Taiwan without china
Island taiwan
@@ryukaze. Republic of Taiwan that Taiwan die-hard Separatists want to set up encouraged and protected by the US and Australia
Recognize "Republic of China"(ROC) is NOT equal to recognizing "Taiwan independence", Republic of China is a Chinese regime established in 1912 who used to legally represent entire China, not just Taiwan, Taiwan is merely an island of China and one of few lands still controll by ROC after KMT defeated by CCP in 1949, Republic of China exists long before KMT relocate to Taiwan in 1949. "Taiwan independence", AKA Taiwan separatism, is an Anti-Chinese movement aiming for creating a new country solely based on Taiwan island(such as "Republic of Taiwan") to overthrow ROC and completely detach from Chinese ethnic identity and separate from China forever.
the funny thing is they try to call the language chinese into Taiwanese,and they say Chinese doctor is Taiwanese doctor
A self proclaimed sovereign floater, they don't seem to like it.
Bhutan: There is no China
Has the part attached to the Chinese Empire been deleted from the Constitution of Bhutan?😅
bhutan: I don't have independent diplomacy
Bhutan: We're not landlocked, the only thing on the north of me is glorious sea
Republic of China VS the People's Republic of China
The title is wrong. Taiwan is a geographical name, and the regime that governs it is called the Republic of China. The correct title is recognizing the roc government as representing China or the PRC government as representing China.
Or it can also refer to the island as Formosa
SanExpreso Excuse me, this is the name of the republic of China under the Constitution. Not just kindergarteners who can pick names
@@user-qg1tp7ib5r 現在也沒人承認中華民國了 以後就是台灣了
frm jerry 我们大陆人非常期待那一天到来，希望你们赶快修宪，让我们解放军师出有名，而不得天天嘴炮台独。
@@user-qg1tp7ib5r 笑死，你們的廁所門裝了沒
India was one of the first countries to recognise PRC as "China"
Due to that Nehru, he had sympathy for China.
Because china and inda at the time has a similiar conditon, that why india recognize mainland china for a sole legal govt
I guess India was the first democratic nation to do it
For India, PRC & RoC is still at war. RoC is not just Taiwan but Taiwan is a part of RoC. For Taiwan to be independent, they have to sacrifice the title of "ROC" . You can't have two China, when you both are fighting to regain the entirety of China.
@@dharmapersona2084 no
Soviets helped india they didn't recognised taiwan because of soviets
Ans soviets and PRC are good friends
Don't blame everything to Nehru
Bhutan being a chad and never recognizing PRC or ROC despite bordering PRC.
The "The Recognition of Taiwan" title is extremely misleading:
Despite ROC's territorial shrinkage to Taiwan and nearby islands by 1950 after it lost the Chinese Civil War, *the KMT government in Taipei had been most persistently and tenaciously holding unto its claim as the sole legitimate government of all China from 1950 all the way up to Taiwan's democratization in the 1990s.* During these decades, (known in Taiwan as the "Martial Law Era"), equating ROC with "Taiwan" was considered the most grievous faux pas, as it implied that ROC was merely a "Taiwanese government" as opposed to China's legitimate central government - an attitude ROC had absolutely zero tolerance of. Such faux pas was known as "ziwo aihua" ("self-dwarfing" or "self-demeaning") - something that could cause an editor or publisher to lose his job at very least. During these years, "Taiwanese Nativism" (the ideology that perceives Taiwan as a nation of its own, separate and distinct from China) was deemed as dangerous as Communism, and was subjected to the most ruthless persecution. In fact the majority of the dissidents, who were revered today as the forefathers of Taiwan's democracy, had been jailed at some points in the 60s and 70s on "national security" related charges, the severity of which were attributable less to their alleged political seditions than their endorsement of "secession"(i.e. promoting a distinct Taiwanese Identity and calling for Taiwanese self-determination), as the latter was seen as a far worse crime than criticizing the government in the eyes of ROC.
On the diplomacy front, ROC broke off relationship with anyone who recognized the "Bandit Regime" on the mainland. It was also unrelenting in its resistance to the American proposal of "double recognition" regarding China's seat in the UN. (With more countries recognizing PRC as China's legitimate government, ROC's holding of China's seat in the UN became increasingly tenuous from 1960 onward. To avoid ROC being kicked out of UN outright, the US tried to charter a "mid-course", whereby two "Chinas" would both be recognized with China's veto power in UN security council being passed on to PRC and ROC retaining its membership). Despite the continuous lobbying from the US, ROC remained unwavering in its position that there was only one China, of which Taiwan was a province and itself the sole central government. (ROC eventually relented and begrudgingly came onboard the "double recognition" proposal in 1971. However, it was too late. In the same year the UN switched recognition to PRC and expelled ROC.)
Only with Taiwan's democratization in the 1990s, the previously whispered Taiwanese Nativism became legalized and subsequently crept into the mainstream social discourse. It finally blossomed into full-fledged Taiwanese Nationalism in 2000s. During the process ROC itself transitioned from a Chinese-Government-in-Exile into a genuine Taiwanese government, elected by local Taiwanese and embracing the locals' Taiwan-centric values, attitudes, and identities.
Notwithstanding all of these, even today, a largely "Taiwanized" ROC is still Republic of China, not Republic of Taiwan. ROC still in legal & diplomatic terms presents itself as the government of China. For example, in 2017, when Panama switched its diplomatic recognition of China from ROC to PRC, ROC's foreign ministry released a harshly worded announcement, which criticized Panama for turning its back on "108 year's relationship". The year count mentioned there was intriguing - Panama established diplomatic relation with the Empire of China under Qing dynasty in 1909, precisely 108 years before. (In 1909, Taiwan was a Japanese colony.) It's just another case-in-point of ROC's abiding diplomatic position - it sees itself as a direct successor of Imperial China, whose last emperor abdicated his sovereignty to the Republic on Feb 12th, 1912. ROC has been constitutionally taking on Qing Dynasty's mantle ever since as the latest & current China. It still remains so today in ROC's official posturing.
Therefore, even today, there isn't really a "recognition of Taiwan" anywhere on the planet - even ROC itself doesn't officially recognize a country called "Taiwan", leave alone any other countries in the world.
As for the Cold War era before Taiwan's democratization, such labeling is even more misleading - *the dispute then was 100% a dispute over "Who is the legitimate government of China".* In fact, If, during these years, someone living in Taiwan had the indiscretion of making such a video, in which ROC was presented as simply "Taiwan", he would soon have ROC's own secret police knocking at his door, interrogating his suspected involvement with "secessionism".
Had no idea of Taiwan's persistence of being the government of China, or the cold era version of the dispute. Cool.
@@aaryanbhatia4939 It was once one of the five permanent members of the United Nations and one of the five most powerful governments in the world.
Taiwan is its last afterglow.
You don’t have to explain too much here. WawamuStats is like a Chinese propaganda channel. Go check out it’s previous videos. They are all about showing off China.
I would use the official name Republic of China to replace Taiwan so people would know better about the relationship between the two or people would fell confused about what the relationship between China and Taiwan and why you make this comparison. You wouldn't make such kind of comparison between Vietnam and Thailand right? Don't assume that everybody would know their relationship.
Correct John, once they use Taiwan, it mean Taiwan is an independent country, and no relation to China anymore, but they compare the recognition? Mhmm… not sure, but it’s real weird.
@@miyahwang26 why using taiwan means taiwan is an independent country instead of a province of China, but the civil war doesn't come to an end? Is calling California,a state of the US California makes California independent? I didn't quite get your logic.
@@petercui5464 fake account
@@miyahwang26 what does fake account mean?你要是说不好英语，你可以说中文，我可以原谅你的没事，弯弯的井底之蛙是这样的
@@petercui5464 Taiwan is a country, it's a fact, you've been brainwashed by China 台湾是个国家 这是事实 你被中国洗脑了
Honduras, Guatemala, Haiti, and Paraguay: “Look at us, Hey! Look at us, look at us, who would have thought? Not me!”
We recognize both. 🖕war
Listing how many countries "recognize Taiwan independence" vs "recognize Taiwan as part of China" is very misleading, since both the PRC and ROC officially recognize Taiwan as part of China and not as independent. There IS a movement to revoke the ROC's claim on China, Mongolia, etc., and declare it an independant republic of Taiwan (ROT, I guess), but this is unpopular, since it wouldn't actually change anything and the PRC bizarrely enough considers this a red flag and thus might invade if such a statement was made. For some reason the PRC prefers it when the ROC claims all of the PRC's territory, apparently because they think this somehow improves the chances of the de facto separate countries reunifying.
Greetings! Great video ✨
Love it
Taiwan is literally recognized by 95% of the UN as part of China but they keep sending supplies and weapons to them.
They? Maybe use “USA”
And buy Taiwanese stuff like TSMC chips and ASUS
Sorry, no. Most countries acknowledge China’s claim, but do not recognize Taiwan as being a part of China. Imagine a guy that says he is the king of the moon, you acknowledge that he keeps saying “I’m king of the moon!” or you can recognize him as king of the moon and ask him to bring you to his moon castle.
@@curtf6714 Sorry, no. Taiwan is always a part of China, the problem here is would you recognize PRC or ROC to have control over it (and the whole mainland, because you can't separate two of them, one China policy get it?).
It is such a chad move that Bhutan still doesn’t recognise either.
The background music is well chosen, especially the musical instruments, It sounds like an ancient Chinese style
And Taiwan is a de facto independent country separated from China.
Wuhan-19 chirona virus host style ??
Who knows the name of BGM? Thanks .
@@jacktam7673 no chinnes civil isnt end
So both PRC and ROC arent a countries until this civil war end
@@jacktam7673 927comments on this channel?! How much is CIA paying you? Holy shit
The world : which one do you recognize ? ROC or PRC ?
Bhutan : no
Bro The ROC is older then PRC then ROC would be real China.
then why doesn't your country establish diplomatic relations with ROC?
Actually, some of the Taiwanese don't even know their country is ROC.
They think their country is "Taiwan".
(Our president even said she is the president of Taiwan in some diplomatic occasion）
Is that true? It would be Such a Shame if they dont even know about their own history. Poor Jiang Jie Shi spent his last life time wasted to keep Republic of China alive.
@@lotrlmao1648 ROC's life base on cold war,this is why they survive until now
Aquel que no conoce su historia está condenado a repetirla.
In their constitution, the mainland is still their land and Taiwan is just a province. They even claim Mongolia as their land.
@@lotrlmao1648 yes, dpp is an evil authoritarian regime
OneChina 👏👏🇰🇷
Paraguay, uno de los pocos que reconoce a ROC.
Igual que Guatemala.
Lacayos de EUA.
@@cesarixu9804 Paraguay reconoce a Taiwan porque ha sido un aliado por décadas, además de que hay miles de taiwaneses viviendo en Paraguay no sabes nada de Paraguay Cesar, de seguro quieres que sean lacayos de China.
@@pedroblasdejesustoralesper9252 Taiwán pertenece a China desde el 232 A.C.
Así lo dictaminó la ONU, incluyendo EUA.
Inglaterra y Japón han invandido la isla desde el siglo XIX, y desde entonces han querido separarla de China.
Y a pesar de los movimientos separatistas financiados por EUA y Japón desde 1945, en la actualidad la mitad de la población (los obreros) quiere la reunificación con China continental, para acceder a los derechos laborales y programas sociales que la oligarquía taiwanesa les niega.
En Taiwán los obreros siguen estando en una condición de semi-esclavitud, a pesar de la "apertura democratica" que sólo ha beneficiado a muy pocos.
Por eso los taiwaneses de clase baja huyen de Taiwán cuando pueden.
En México también hay una gran comunidad de taiwaneses, aunque ellos se hacen llamar orgullosamente "chinos".
Pero lo repito, Paraguay y Guatemala apoyan la independencia de Taiwán, porque creen que así obtendran algunas croquetas de la Casa Blanca.
@@cesarixu9804 Paraguay apoya a Taiwan porque 1- ha recibido millones de dólares en préstamos no reembolsables de Taiwán 2- Miles de estudiantes paraguayos están becados en universidades Taiwanesas 3- Paraguay tiene una comunidad Taiwanesa bastante grande, además el presidente de Taiwán visita regularmente Paraguay, y por si fuera poco la mayoría de la población apoya que se mantengan los lazos, tu afirmación bastante simplista y basada en la ignorancia de que Paraguay solo lo apoya por recibir migajas de EEUU es absurda, no sabes nada de Paraguay.
@@zhiro_3 Osea, Paraguay apoya la independencia de Taiwán por motivos económicos ¿no?
Creo que eso todos lo sabemos.
2 Chinas like 2 Germanies before
The Recognition of Taiwan × The Recognition of ROC ✔
World to Bhutan: What is China?
Bhutan: I don't know what is China.
@ＯＦＡＲＡ Bhutan still recognised Qing empire as China, However no more Qing.
I love the background music 😍🎶 please tell me the name wawamustats
wow its sad seeing everyone turn red
Do you want make with friend with poor or rich? The rich one gives you wealth and development.
@@gamgster5257 it’s not rich and poor, it’s 1.3b people or 23m people who represent more…
@@gamgster5257 Taiwan is richer than China in per capital and IDH
@Angel whiss Yes.They can just get more benefit from mainland China.😂
@@gamgster5257 both, you just need to form United States of China.
The funniest part is, since some countries agreed there is only one China and PRC is the only representative of China, why are they still making trouble with this issue, especially recent year, this is so obvious what do they want
easy to response: a divided china is in their best interests, they do not genuinely care about taiwan
The U.S. wants a divided China so it can’t take its throne as the worlds no.1 superpower in the near future.
Most countries only don’t recognise Taiwan because China throws a tantrum if they do
@@TheTheTheTheTheTheOh, so why can't they just recognise ROC and break diplomatic tie with PRC, things solve, isn't it? Since China has their most hated political system 🤔
And don't forget, ROC's map is even bigger than PRC version, including 11 dashed lines, Mongolia...
@@cerberus3671 This is US not British Empire turd
Thailand recognized Republic of China due to the Foreign Policy as part of the US ally during the early phase of Cold War. By the way, Thailand started to have a contact with People's Republic of China in the 1950s via "The Secret Diplomacy" with the idea that China is a big and important country in Asia which cannot be overlooked. Started with the Bandung Conference in 1955, Thailand and China had a contact in secret for many times until it was stopped during the 1960s - 1970s due to the political climate in both country. After US shift the policy to China, Thailand resumed the contact with China and established the Diplomatic Relations in 1975. Even Thailand had to cut the Diplomatic Relations with Republic of China or Taiwan, Thailand and Taiwan still maintian the unofficial relation via The Taipei Economic and Culture Office in Bangkok and Thailand Trade and Economic Office in Taipei.
反复小人
music: The Ancestors - Jakub Pietras
My Respect to the countries in Blue 📈📈📈📈📈📈📈📈📈
Fact: Taiwan still claims arunanchal pradesh, sikkim, ladakh, some parts of kashmir, of india also the whole bhutan and whole mongolia country as a part of republic of china(Taiwan)
Fact: We Taiwan don't claim any territory outside Taiwan's teorritory.
False its all china
China claiming not Taiwan
@@kakashiar But taiwan constitution says otherwise, being indian i absolutely know that you are not taiwanese
@Aoun Muhammad lol, first up all search in google, their constitution says otherwise
I like the bgm~~ it's so awesome!
republic of china(taiwan) VS people republic of china
Bhutan: what are you arguing about
They need Tibet back.
No country recognizes the existence of Taiwan as a country name. This video shows the process of the People's Republic of China replacing the Republic of China.
Love Taiwan 🇹🇼 from Paraguay 🇵🇾
love your mon...you are loser
@@TV-it6gs you don't have a mom
Cheve avei 🇵🇾🇹🇼
@@TV-it6gs love your dictatorship and contamination
Legitimate: exist
Me to Taiwan: You're more senior
This title should be ROC and PRC
This is a video about the recognition of Republic of China rather than Taiwan. 🤔 Those who do/did simply don’t/didn’t have diplomatic relations with People’s Republic of China.
Doing so before 1971 means something really very different than today (before it meant recognizing national government of ROC in Taiwan as the only legitimate government of the entire China)
Yup, basically not a single country recognize Taiwan as an independent country as of today. Those 14 countries are recognize Republic Of China in Taiwan as the legitimate government of the entire China, include Mainland and Taiwan island. And the rest of 181 countries are recognize People's republic of China is the legitimate government of the entire China and of course it is include the Mainland and Taiwan island. Take a look at ROC's constitution then you will know what I mean. If the Republic of China in Taiwan's current leader decide to be an independent country, first thing he/she should do is to change its constitution, otherwise their constitution just a joke and its leader should go to jail for that. However, if he/she decided to divide China, it will break the law of the current legitimate government of China(PRC). One and half billion Chinese won't allow that to happen for sure as well.
And the ROC and PRC still in civil war right now. They never signed any peace agreement yet.
Bhutan: I’m just happy to be here
I think it is the longest war but the weirdest thing is nobody win
Really weird title.. The ROC does not just include Taiwan and Penghu, it also includes Kinmen, Matsu islands, and some isles on South China Sea.
🇯🇵❤️🇹🇼
In the context of Taiwan independence, it is about creating a new Republic of Taiwan, not about recognizing the RO.China.
I think most of Taiwaneses want to independent from Republic of China
Republic of China is not belong to people's Republic of China
PRC have independented from ROC since 1949
@@goodmanyoung3393 yes, but it never came true even at this moment, the reality is that the government in Taiwan is a Chinese government called Republic of China.
Well it's not about Taiwan independence, and plenty of people in Taiwan oppose the separatists too.
@@sakura7431 I don't agree part of yours.Many Taiwanese still work hard for having a new country
@@goodmanyoung3393 what you said is exactly what I said.
you have a mistake in this video:the reconization of tw(ROC) doesn't mean taiwan is idependent from china,but means that ROC government is the only government that represent china.
Tiwan exists:
China: Is that for me👉👈
Well yeah, Taiwan was and still is Chinese territory, current regime who rules Taiwan is literally called Republic of "China".
Very interesting. The situations with most African countries in 1950s were "N/A" because they were not independent yet.
Eran colonias britanicas y franceses
Solo egipto y sudafrica ya era pais independiente
Bhutan: there is no china, only thunder dragon empire!
Bhutan submitted to the 5-claw dragon flag of the Chinese Empire. After all, the national flags are all 3-claw dragons!
Bhutan still recognised Qing empire as China, However no more Qing.
TWN is a nice place in Asia if you have visited.
Thank you for telling that Madagascar was already independent before 1960 ! Malagasy here !
Taiwanese:
We're the step son of Japan
the step-grandson of Usa
😅😅😅
Usa and Japan:
You are part of china🤡🤡🤡
fun fact: although China established diplomatic relations with so many countries, Chinese still have to deal with visa if they want to go to these countries and Chinese passport is just like 💩
@@jacktam7673 But that passport can take their people out from warzone even now in Ukraine. How is yours?
@@jacktam7673 the whole Ukraine is now a no-plane zone but Chinese embassy can still get a plane for evacuation of Chinese people in Ukraine. When Taiwanese runs into problem, the Chinese embassy is always the right place to go. How about yours?
@@jacktam7673 fun fact: In their constitution, the mainland is still their land and Taiwan is just a province. They even claim Mongolia as their land.
Whether PRC or ROC, Taiwan is just a province.
Taiwan has no seat in the UN, no embassy, no national anthem, no flag, and you call a place like that a country?
Lol
@@user-ow7tl1zo1q there are 30 countries similar as Taiwan
Taiwan is Chinese too
If you like the New Year countdown, you must love to countdown our allies count.
Shouldve started before 1949 to show the full picture
You should name this "Rejection of Taiwan since 1949" or "Recognition of People's Republic of China since 1949"
I remember in the last century, Mainland China gave Taiwan the most generous offer ever: governments from both sides would build a new China together, with a new flag. Even the name of the country could be negotiated.
Taiwan rejected.
When was that and what was the proposal's official name?
source? sounds fake
@@op9764 source - trust me bro
@@ProCelestialEmpire Originally proposal by Deng Xiaoping in 1979. He even let Taiwan retain its own armed forces.
@@op9764In case you dont know, there is a thing called Google.
I thought France recognized the PRC before Britain, and South Korea did before Japan.
The greens have just got into the chad club and lost 5000000000000000000000000000000000 social credit
It really doesn't matter. PRC or ROC. Life is short, live happy :)
I mean i would say roc since you can't really live happy when you're in a labor camp.
@@GoogleAccount-pi9ct Look at the Indians, do you think they are live happy？
I miss Wawamustats trolls. They are so funny !
Specially indian , Pakistani, Chinese
Yeah they are so funny 😆
It's now 13 with Nicaragua being the latest to drop Taiwan
isn't there a small country in Europe i don't remember the name, Slovenia maybe, that recently recognize Taiwan as a country?
Vatican
Cant wait for the 50 cent army to flood the comments
Yeah, I like to make fun of these 50 cent army, they are childish and brainwashed by western media and don't have their own mindset.
@@johnyankee6999 yeah I like to make fun of you kind of people deeply brainwashed by western media, or just CIA troll~
let us witness the reunification
Question: will that reunification be peaceful or bloody?
@@commanderiosifstalin4938 as long as the island does not claim independence, it would be peaceful for sure. War does not benefit Chinese.
It's about two different governments of china. Btw back in 1940s China also had more than one or two governments. Truman intervened another country's civil war by deploying the 7th fleet in taiwan strait in 1950. Can americanos try imagine what's it going to be like if the europeans intervened their own civil war in the 1860s?
yes,theres the Chinese soviet republic in 1930s,and some places are controlled by ccp,but still there's only a china
Imagine in 1860there is two America
Background music name?
Bhutan does not recognize any permanent members of the UN Security Council due to Indian influences.
Bhutan was a vassal state of Tibet in a theocratic fashion, and Tibet was under Qing Empire, tho Bhutan was not Qing’s vassal. In modern days they underplay the cultural origin of the dragon flag, which can often be interpreted as a symbol for being part of Qing China’s imperial order tho it was formally adopted much later on and potentially only took inspiration from it.
Bhutan did however become a vassal state of British Raj and then republic of India until 1992. But india still has immersive amount of influence over Bhutan and is responsible for their national defense.
Because they are scared of Chinese expansion and instead they trust India.
I love both 🇯🇵❤️🇨🇳❤️🇹🇼
@@ge_ming_wu_zui Russia is European
Only 28 million ppl live in Siberia
Hey Ben, Is Taiwan is a country?
What's the music name?
Me is disappointed with Canada for recognizing Taiwan as a part of China.
But why?
Also another question, do you recognise Crimea and Donbass region Ukranian? Because by your logic, they’re independent from Ukraine. It’s the international law, sovereignty is indisputable.
@@mdza Because China is not a good country and doesn't treat its people really well. It's also communist, too, and I want Taiwan to gain independence and stay free from China.
@@mdza Sadly I don't know about Donbass, but I do know that Crimea was annexed by Russia back in 2014. So I don't recognize Crimea as an independent nation, but I do prefer for Crimea to be either a part of Ukraine, or to be independent.
@@Shonade_Malik trust me, Chinese government treat people a lot better than current Taiwan province government. You don’t have to worry
@@Shonade_Malik Oh right sorry, China bad, free Taiwan, Ukraine good, Crimea and Donbass are Ukraine, who cares about international law am I right?
Honestly had it not been for other nations most likely Taiwan and China would have united too just like Vietnam one side would win a war and unite both.
It doesn't matter what borders divide the people, at the end of the day they are still the same people.
True. There’s even less reason for the U.S. to intervene when even the U.S. itself recognizes Taiwan as a part of China.
At least Ukraine is an actual, independent nation.
@@cerberus3671 US recognized Taiwan in all but name lmao
2022－1949＝73 years.
Background music name ??????????
Taiwan has never claimed independence
👍👍👍👍👍
+ 1000000000000 social credit
@@user-gongaesa 🕳🐸
I have no idea why some countries still only recognize ROC
1. ROC has been defeated and has to move to a small island (Taiwan), so what about the big mainland
2. Due to the One-China System
3. PRC has many friends and enemies, what does those countries think about that conflict
4. PRC has been recognized by most of UN members, what would those countries think about their governments
5. What if those countries were invaded by PRC, did they actually get defeated
actually they're grinding money from China and USA
These countries all are small countries that want to get more money from Taiwan.
They are countries that don't give a shit about China's threat and recognise which China they want.
From a philosophical standpoint, the size of partial territory or population that you are governing over doesn't decide whether you are the lawful representative.
For all intents and purposes, the ROC and the PRC have the same claim to mainland China plus Taiwan, maybe the ROC even more since they were the government that first represented China in the UN, and the PRC never legally took over China or had a real democratic mandate from the people living there.
In the end, it's all splitting hairs. China and Taiwan are nowadays de facto separate countries, and while we may never not see full mutual recognition in our lifetime, I do very much hope that they will let each other be, because that is frankly the best possible result for all Chinese people. A little bit of friendly competition has never hurt anyone.
@@jiandongzhuang5636 u mean USA?
Ultra chad Angola and Honduras. Didnt recognize either of them until the 80's
chad Bhutan recognizing neither
Why did Saudi Arabia delay in recognizing China until 1989? Just 3 decades ago? At that time, even the United States, the archenemy of China, recognized it!
Because China and Saudi Arabia only began to establish diplomatic relations in 1990.
🇺🇸 wasn't their enemy back then. Infact , 🇨🇳 were a kind of ally to counter USSR.
Japan was 🇺🇸's economic rival
USSR was 🇺🇸's militaristic rival.
🇺🇸 is trying to play the same , this time USSR= 🇨🇳, 🇨🇳=🇮🇳. In future, they will antagonize 🇮🇳, this is how 🇺🇸 maintain their influence on world
China and the United States were allies against the Soviet Union in the 1980s.
China was not the US's archenemy in the 80's.
Game over, wife is Taiwanese and she says she is Chinese...
Your wife should teach the taiwanese young generation a lesson. Ungrateful little shits keep forgetting about their home country and their history. Pathetic.
@@petercui5464 I'm 19, I still think I'm a Chinese, but aslo a Taiwanese (Republic of China, Taiwan 🇹🇼) not a prc Chinese sorry
@@hugok3340 我觉得很好啊，我们都是中国人，台湾确实是中华民国，民族认同不能丢啊，“中肯”换成“台肯”，中医换成“台医”云云，才是分裂主义，才是让我们唾弃的
Don’t forget Cyrenaica was different to Libya between 1949 and 1951
I sense some social credit
The vast majority of Chinese recognize PRC as the only legitimate China. This is the most important thing.
Taiwan is free. And you mad that Taiwan is not yours ahhaaha suck it Winnie Pooh
Ah yes, just like how 'vast majority' of Russians recognizing Ukraine as being theirs is the most important thing
@@Frostenheim LMAO. Wrong example. All countries recognize Ukraine as a country and have diplomatic relations with it, but no countries recognize "Taiwan" as a country
@@user-cd6py6ee1zChina communist and the Taiwan the old e true nationalist chineses.
As an italian i reconize taiwan as the true china democracys must support eachother
True China? A loser who take refuge in Japan 🤔
Italy ？🤣 Whoever Italy supports will be in trouble
@@user-gq4fy6fh7z i support your mother 😎
ITALA DEDSPARRCE...un enano geopolitico😂
i think Latvia briefly recognized Taiwan in 1992
Never thought I could say it but based Paraguay
Thanks for the video and big greetings from russia🇷🇺
🐻🐻🐻🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺vs🦅🦅🦅🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
Russia is like our brother 🇮🇳❤🇷🇺
@@user-jc2wc9nu3e 🐻❄️ not 🐻
Respect to Russia from Chile 💪🔴🔵
And pasol nx from 🇱🇹
I love Taiwan from Japan🇹🇼❤️🇯🇵
Thank you
I think most of Taiwaneses love Japan,too
Love Southern Kuriles （part of Russia） from China.
Love Southern Kuriles （part of Russia） from China.
@@user-so1rf1fb1x Of course, and don't forget Taiwan and china are different countries!
of course you love Taiwan, A father always love his son
You should use ROC vs PRC instead of Taiwan vs China
Bhutan: I'm the real China🤪
I'm from the Philippines, Philippines is the nearest country in Taiwan except china , Taiwan and Philippines have a standoff of water territory and Taiwan have own military forces , for me Taiwan is not a country but also not controlled by mainland china . It is independent land and people and constitution
yeah, and their constitution even say Taiwan belongs to China.
Yes, I'm from Singapore, and I don't think Taiwan is a country. There are only two regimes in one country, and the civil war is not over yet. Moreover, Taiwan is not recognized by the United Nations and most countries. Although in fact it is not controlled by mainland China, Taiwan is not legally independent.
@大时代中華民國憲法僅記載中國之「固有疆域」而不是實際掌控的領土，兩者不一樣，在撰寫憲法的同時台灣還在被日本統治，但中華民國一樣把台灣納了進去
@大时代 because Taiwan is the real china , taiwanese constitution have china historical constitution, the mainland china or CCP is new country
@@edgardobaldomar8825 ROC lost the civil war so PRC is the true China
I wish Taiwan was recognised by all the countries
Cope
In your dream 😇
god bless you
ni zai xiang pi chi
its ROC and PRC, Taiwan independence thing is whole diff issue.
Sad ending
yeah... Taiwan is just a common province of PRC since the liberation war of China by PLA.🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳
As Indian, We Hate Your Government, But We are The Largest Economy From 0001 -1500 , If we Work Together, We will Be largest Economy Again!!!! .
Republic of China🇹🇼 is in People's republic of China🇨🇳
@@mrjay76 sure "Indian"
@@mrityunjaigupta2325 They are still at war.
RoC= PRC - same govt
RoC =/= Taiwan
If Taiwan wants to be independent, it has to lose the title of ROC
@@jirachi-wishmaker9242 Yes Indian🇮🇳👳🇮🇳👳🇮🇳👳
I recognize all.
Bhutan
Never changes
Bhutan is the most loyal servant of the Chinese Empire ~
Earth :- There are 5 Oceans on Earth!
Bhutan 🇧🇹 :- NO! there is also a 6th Ocean, CHINESE OCEAN!
Earth:- *wtf*....
excuse me？I think only 4