Lol totally. Except it is a very different musk note. Coming from the Patchouli I believe. Sun Down for example is super animalic. Also the musk in Green Witch is a supporting character as to where with Sun Down is more "front and center". Hope that makes sense, have a good one!
What an awesome location! Thanks for the thorough review! It's so hard to get a decent idea of what a fragrance smells like from a video. However, you do a great job bridging the gap of the unknown! Much appreciated sir!
Thanks Jeff! You're welcome sir! This was a challenge to describe so I decided to break it down the way that I did and I hope it made sense. Have a great week Jeff!
Agreed - Tobin’s descriptions often make many others look like amateurs. As a newbie to the artisanal world, I’ve come to appreciate his descriptions enough that most of my purchases have come after watching his review. I wouldn’t have ever tried HC&C if it weren’t for Tobin but now I have 14 sets, and still don’t have all that I want 😂
@@Lee-deadphishaves😅 I'm with you! I don't buy any set based upon other shave reviewers. I wait for Tobins review. I feel like most others are either just shaving and talking or worse, just SELLING the product. Tobins reviews are thorough AND genuine/honest. And now Im buying Green Witch 😅😅😅
@@stagsandstaples1127 I can honestly say, I don’t have any fragrance(s) that I’ve bought after watching/listening to Tobin’s review, that I don’t like. They’ve all been good to great, with some simply smelling a little better than the others. I think I’m going to have to get a sample from PAA, it sounds like a winner!
Thanks John! Mission Accomplished 😀 I was trying to think of a spot like this one and when this spot dawned on me I was like oh yeah I think it'll be perfect and I was so happy with how the photos and the backdrop turned out. Hope you have a great Sunday
Very good Tobin! It's funny as more and more scents come out, the closer artisans are getting to my wheelhouse. This one sounds the closest so far and maybe a direct hit. The name, the artwork, and maybe the scent too. I might have to check it. I was thinking I might have to look into getting some Z Mac and maybe do some casting. I don't think it would be too hard to do a top cap and bottom plate, duping a Fasan. Like I need another project! That house really is like the old homestead farmhouse. They start out with a one room house and over time, do additions as needed. Eventually you get a house with this look. Have a great weekend bro!
Thanks Lee! I try to put a lot of thought into it and analyze the fragrances and the best part is is actually enjoy it like it's one of my favorite parts of content creation😊 (Shnerd)😊😅
@@Tobins_throwbacks it shows! I can see and hear the genuine interest you have when you’re describing fragrances, such a big part of why I listen/watch to your reviews; I know I can count on you giving it straight up to the viewer 😉
Great review Tobin. I have a sample on order and can't wait to get it. I also have a lot of PAA shampoos and deodorants, I just wish they had some liquid shower soap. I would even volunteer to test them. I also just ordered MacDuff's Autum Cabin. Have a wonderful weekend. 👍🎃
Thanks William! I'm not sure if Douglas and Fran would be willing to do a liquid for a few different reasons. One would be the packaging and materials required to ship and "liquid soaps" aren't actually soap they are actually detergents with additives. Autumn Cabin is the best Cabin Imo. So good! If you remember try to let me know what you think of it after you use it a couple of times. I think after reading your comment that's what I'll use tomorrow 🙏 Have a good one!
Thank you! I love hearing that! I was hoping this spot would be perfect and I was really happy with how the photos and video turned out. Thank you sir I hope you have a great Sunday!
@Tobins_throwbacks So I got the GreenWitch Envy, it reminds me of Stetson, which to me isn't a bad thing. I also got Droid Black, F-Bombs and Red Planet. My kids think Droid smells like fruity pebbles lol, and it does have a fruity scent, but it's very wearable. F-Bombs is soft, not really my favorite, but after the dry down is pleasant. I don't know Tom Ford scents, but the Cowboy Up (Hombre Leather) is still my favorite there. And I had to get Red Planet splash after trying the soap. It has such a clean, masculine barbershop scent. It reminds me of my grandfather's time, where blue collar men always started the day off with a shave no matter what they did for work. Again, can't thank you enough for your reviews. It's introduced me to a whole new world of excellent scents that I otherwise would have never discovered. Keep on rockin brotha!
i’m glad someone who has a bigger voice than mine is also waiting for malbolge. we need it back!! lovely description of the scent, i can’t wait for my sample to get in
I heard you say in one of your previous videos that you used to do boxing and after seeing you try to throw a kick I can confirm that you are a boxer 😂 cheers my friend have a good day
Awesome Halloween location. Green Witch is on order, just waiting for it to arrive. Great Ducks win on Friday 🏈 . My Dores won today as well. I absolutely love your breakdown of the scents. I wish I had that ability. I have the Peligrino and it is one of my favorites. I used Macabre Maestro this morning and while I was unsure how I would like the scent just smelling the soap. It smelled far too forward at the start and too leathery. However, I loved it after smelling the scent all day with the splash and EDP. Have a great rest of the weekend!
Thank you I have a place in mind for clown fruit and I'm hoping to pull it off as well as this one I was very happy with how this place turned out. When it arrives I'd love to hear you're honest thoughts of it. Keep working at it and you'll get there, it took me years of practice to get comfortable with fragrances. The Peregrino feels perfect in the hand and the Roswell fibers are 🔥 Oh man, the games today! I watched the second half of the Tennessee game and can have been more thrilled and then I watched the majority of the Texas v Georgia game and couldn't be happier with those results😊 🦆#1🦆 The dry down of Tuscan Leather is the best part of it imo. I've actually been comparing it with cowboy up all week this week and I must say I think I am leaning towards cowboy/Ombre being my preferred leather fragrance. However, if you ask me next week or a few weeks from now I will have likely changed my mind again😅😅😅. Do you have Cowboy Up? I plan to record my review of the Osprey tomorrow 🙏 Hope you have a great Sunday Andy!
I do not have the Cowboy Up soap but I do have a sample of the EDP. I really like the scent and will need to pick up the soap and splash. Thanks again.
@@Tobins_throwbacksHello Tobin. I hope all is well in the land of tall trees and the #1 team in the nation. I received my haul of GreenWitch Envy today - soap, splash, solid cologne ( I really, really like solid colognes), deodorant, and star jelly. I think the scent is incredible. I try not to just smell the overall scent but the individual ones now. I bought essential oils as you suggested in a video. I can at least know things such as what patchouli smells like 😂. I plan to shave with it tomorrow morning. I like the initial scents of ginger , pepper, and orange - I need to open my spice drawer to recall the cardamom scent. This is a wonderful scent. I have my order in for the EDP. I just forgot to order it in the initial purchase. Thanks again!
@Wittar7090 hey I was thinking about you earlier today. I've got my notes together for my review of the Osprey. That's awesome what all essential oils did you grab? Where did you order them from? I'm hoping a week from tomorrow I can afford to put in an order for all the Greenwich stuff, yesterday I bought the new Oumo St2 knot in a chubby handle I'm looking forward to giving that a go my expectations are low but I'm hoping for the best with it. And life is good in the land of the tall trees and the number one team in the nation looking forward to Saturday's kickoff! Hope you're doing well have a good one Andy!!
Awesome description/review of this scent. You might be the last to review but it was the best. I used your link at the 6 minute mark to order this. I cant wait to smell this one. Awesome location and background for this one. Have a great week
Thanks Mike! Its truly a wonderful and unique fragrance! I couldn't be happier with how the pictures turned out. I had a vision in my mind prior to the shave and was thrilled when i got home and saw the pictures. When im out in the daylight its just too hard to "truly see them". Have a great week!!
Thank you😊 So I'm not positive I would say maybe. If you reach out to Doug or Fran they'd be happy to tell you. I may take you up on that dare😊 Have a great week!
I think you should make SNERD T-shirts. The word snerd has to always be on it, and some kind of shaving gear or whatever accompanying snerd. The first T should have your mug on it! 😂
Excellent review. Nice little B role walk around the property. Ordered this one exactly 4 mins after getting Doug's product drop email. Looking forward to it too. Question for you Tobin. Might you know if Doug is doing a re-run of Clown Fruit? I want the EDP of that one.
@@ChristopherDanielJones Thank you sir. I think it was pretty this time last year, within a day or so, that CF came out. I'm down under and enjoying what PAA, amongst others, is doing.
Thanks Rod!! Curious to know your thoughts of it when it arrives. So yes sir I expect clown fruit to drop between now and Halloween. Douglas hasn't told me that but that's just what I expect. It's probably already Sunday for you, and I hope it's going well!
Right?!??!??!??!?!! It's so good! If I had to guess I would say it's likely the musk note that she mentioned. But I'm only guessing I'm not brave enough to ask 😉😊😜🤐🤫
I love how it feels like your haveing a conversation with us.
That's how I try to approach it🙏 thank you sir!
Simply Wonderful! 👏🎬👏
Thanks Allan!!
Wow! The most intriguing thing about your review of this is that the ladies gave a musky type fragrance a 9 and a 10! That threw me for a loop😂
Lol totally.
Except it is a very different musk note. Coming from the Patchouli I believe.
Sun Down for example is super animalic.
Also the musk in Green Witch is a supporting character as to where with Sun Down is more "front and center".
Hope that makes sense, have a good one!
What an awesome location! Thanks for the thorough review! It's so hard to get a decent idea of what a fragrance smells like from a video. However, you do a great job bridging the gap of the unknown! Much appreciated sir!
Thanks Jeff! You're welcome sir!
This was a challenge to describe so I decided to break it down the way that I did and I hope it made sense.
Have a great week Jeff!
Just ordered it, yet again...great review and PERFECT location for a Halloween themed shave!
Awesome! Thank you!!
Nobody, nobody, nobody does a scent description like you Tobin. Already ordered and on the way. Talk soon my friend!
I couldn't agree more Glenn!
Agreed - Tobin’s descriptions often make many others look like amateurs. As a newbie to the artisanal world, I’ve come to appreciate his descriptions enough that most of my purchases have come after watching his review. I wouldn’t have ever tried HC&C if it weren’t for Tobin but now I have 14 sets, and still don’t have all that I want 😂
@@Lee-deadphishaves😅 I'm with you! I don't buy any set based upon other shave reviewers. I wait for Tobins review.
I feel like most others are either just shaving and talking or worse, just SELLING the product.
Tobins reviews are thorough AND genuine/honest.
And now Im buying Green Witch 😅😅😅
@@stagsandstaples1127 I can honestly say, I don’t have any fragrance(s) that I’ve bought after watching/listening to Tobin’s review, that I don’t like. They’ve all been good to great, with some simply smelling a little better than the others. I think I’m going to have to get a sample from PAA, it sounds like a winner!
You sir are too kind! I think you're going to absolutely love it Glen! I really do! It's SO GOOD!
HOPE YOU AND SUSIE HAVE A GREAT SUNDAY!
Haunting spot. That door was chilling. Great thumbnail and review!
I wondered if I was the only one that noticed! Tobin kinda looked at it😅
Thanks John! Mission Accomplished 😀 I was trying to think of a spot like this one and when this spot dawned on me I was like oh yeah I think it'll be perfect and I was so happy with how the photos and the backdrop turned out.
Hope you have a great Sunday
@@stagsandstaples1127😀😄🙏
At first I thought I was seeing things😅
This location SCREAMS Halloween! And is perfect for that label!
Thank you sir!!
Nobody Does it BETTER!! 🐐
Carly Simon? 😅
Looks like a place that would be spooky at night ... Green Witch does sound great.👌🤠👌
Definitely 😊 lots of critters to spook ya too. Have a great week Lawrie!
Killer job Tobes! Thx man!
You bet, thank you!
Very nice shave Video, Tobin!
Have a great Sunday 😊
Thanks, you too!
I need this one!!
It's so dang good Dave!
Great review, Tobin! I love your descriptions and you shoot from the hip. "You're my anti-stank hero." I love it! 😂😂😂
Thanks Sam!
😅 I still can't believe I said that! I laughed when I was editing the video 😅
Have a great week brother!
@@Tobins_throwbacks You too!
Very good Tobin! It's funny as more and more scents come out, the closer artisans are getting to my wheelhouse. This one sounds the closest so far and maybe a direct hit. The name, the artwork, and maybe the scent too. I might have to check it. I was thinking I might have to look into getting some Z Mac and maybe do some casting. I don't think it would be too hard to do a top cap and bottom plate, duping a Fasan. Like I need another project! That house really is like the old homestead farmhouse. They start out with a one room house and over time, do additions as needed. Eventually you get a house with this look. Have a great weekend bro!
Thanks Ian!
Do it! If anyone can pull off working with Zmac it's you!
Bare minimum if you get a chance grab a sample of this
Have a great week!
One of the best at fragrance descriptions, Tobin shines once again - Nicely done!
Thanks Lee! I try to put a lot of thought into it and analyze the fragrances and the best part is is actually enjoy it like it's one of my favorite parts of content creation😊 (Shnerd)😊😅
@@Tobins_throwbacks it shows! I can see and hear the genuine interest you have when you’re describing fragrances, such a big part of why I listen/watch to your reviews; I know I can count on you giving it straight up to the viewer 😉
The review ive been waiting for 🐐
Thanks man! Hopefully I delivered!
Another absolutely wonderful review and beautiful location Mr. Tobin
Many thanks!
🐐 - banger review location and product as always ❤️🔥❤️🔥
@@alexbotello9612 thank you sir I appreciate you Hope you're having a good one
Great review Tobin. I have a sample on order and can't wait to get it. I also have a lot of PAA shampoos and deodorants, I just wish they had some liquid shower soap. I would even volunteer to test them. I also just ordered MacDuff's Autum Cabin. Have a wonderful weekend. 👍🎃
Thanks William!
I'm not sure if Douglas and Fran would be willing to do a liquid for a few different reasons. One would be the packaging and materials required to ship and "liquid soaps" aren't actually soap they are actually detergents with additives.
Autumn Cabin is the best Cabin Imo. So good! If you remember try to let me know what you think of it after you use it a couple of times.
I think after reading your comment that's what I'll use tomorrow 🙏
Have a good one!
I was waiting to hear a witches screech when I saw the door move. Hehehe. Great shave Tobin and thanks for the shout out
😅😅 A screech would have been perfect!
Have a good one Matt! I'll have a tracking number for ya tomorrow.
Tomorrow is a "chill at home" day. 🙏
@@Tobins_throwbacks sweet! I know you have been busy
I've heard you say that Phoenix makes shaving fun, but I would suggest that you do as well.
Thank you for the wonderful reviews 👏
Thanks you!
Great shave Tobin and again another awesome location! Perfect choice for the Green Witch set.
Thank you! I love hearing that! I was hoping this spot would be perfect and I was really happy with how the photos and video turned out.
Thank you sir I hope you have a great Sunday!
You sold me on it! Great review Tobin! Just ordered the aftershave along with a few others you had previously recommended. Can't wait to get this.
You're going to love it! It's so good!
@Tobins_throwbacks So I got the GreenWitch Envy, it reminds me of Stetson, which to me isn't a bad thing. I also got Droid Black, F-Bombs and Red Planet. My kids think Droid smells like fruity pebbles lol, and it does have a fruity scent, but it's very wearable. F-Bombs is soft, not really my favorite, but after the dry down is pleasant. I don't know Tom Ford scents, but the Cowboy Up (Hombre Leather) is still my favorite there. And I had to get Red Planet splash after trying the soap. It has such a clean, masculine barbershop scent. It reminds me of my grandfather's time, where blue collar men always started the day off with a shave no matter what they did for work. Again, can't thank you enough for your reviews. It's introduced me to a whole new world of excellent scents that I otherwise would have never discovered. Keep on rockin brotha!
i’m glad someone who has a bigger voice than mine is also waiting for malbolge. we need it back!! lovely description of the scent, i can’t wait for my sample to get in
Not sure about a bigger voice 😊
It'll definitely be back sometime this autumn. It comes back every year 🤞
Have a great Sunday!
Saved the 🐐 for last!
😊🤗🙏
Great location for Halloween shave. This smells really great I got a sampler and I was really impressed with it.
@@r55mannyp morning Manny! Thank brother! I love this fragrance!
Have a great Friday brother, it's 4am here and I want to go back to bed lol.
@ lol. What time you get in for work? My kid woke me up at 5am and I felt the same way as you. Have a great Friday!
Epic location for this shave!!!
Thank you sir!
Finally 😊
Sorry brother 😊🙏
I heard you say in one of your previous videos that you used to do boxing and after seeing you try to throw a kick I can confirm that you are a boxer 😂 cheers my friend have a good day
😅😅😅😅 definitely a boxer 😅 thanks Sean!
Have a good one!!
Awesome Halloween location. Green Witch is on order, just waiting for it to arrive. Great Ducks win on Friday 🏈 . My Dores won today as well. I absolutely love your breakdown of the scents. I wish I had that ability. I have the Peligrino and it is one of my favorites. I used Macabre Maestro this morning and while I was unsure how I would like the scent just smelling the soap. It smelled far too forward at the start and too leathery. However, I loved it after smelling the scent all day with the splash and EDP. Have a great rest of the weekend!
Thank you I have a place in mind for clown fruit and I'm hoping to pull it off as well as this one I was very happy with how this place turned out.
When it arrives I'd love to hear you're honest thoughts of it.
Keep working at it and you'll get there, it took me years of practice to get comfortable with fragrances.
The Peregrino feels perfect in the hand and the Roswell fibers are 🔥
Oh man, the games today! I watched the second half of the Tennessee game and can have been more thrilled and then I watched the majority of the Texas v Georgia game and couldn't be happier with those results😊 🦆#1🦆
The dry down of Tuscan Leather is the best part of it imo. I've actually been comparing it with cowboy up all week this week and I must say I think I am leaning towards cowboy/Ombre being my preferred leather fragrance.
However, if you ask me next week or a few weeks from now I will have likely changed my mind again😅😅😅.
Do you have Cowboy Up?
I plan to record my review of the Osprey tomorrow 🙏
Hope you have a great Sunday Andy!
I do not have the Cowboy Up soap but I do have a sample of the EDP. I really like the scent and will need to pick up the soap and splash. Thanks again.
@Wittar7090 good deal. Have a good week Andy!
@@Tobins_throwbacksHello Tobin. I hope all is well in the land of tall trees and the #1 team in the nation. I received my haul of GreenWitch Envy today - soap, splash, solid cologne ( I really, really like solid colognes), deodorant, and star jelly. I think the scent is incredible. I try not to just smell the overall scent but the individual ones now. I bought essential oils as you suggested in a video. I can at least know things such as what patchouli smells like 😂. I plan to shave with it tomorrow morning. I like the initial scents of ginger , pepper, and orange - I need to open my spice drawer to recall the cardamom scent. This is a wonderful scent. I have my order in for the EDP. I just forgot to order it in the initial purchase. Thanks again!
@Wittar7090 hey I was thinking about you earlier today. I've got my notes together for my review of the Osprey.
That's awesome what all essential oils did you grab? Where did you order them from?
I'm hoping a week from tomorrow I can afford to put in an order for all the Greenwich stuff, yesterday I bought the new Oumo St2 knot in a chubby handle I'm looking forward to giving that a go my expectations are low but I'm hoping for the best with it.
And life is good in the land of the tall trees and the number one team in the nation looking forward to Saturday's kickoff!
Hope you're doing well have a good one Andy!!
Awesome description/review of this scent. You might be the last to review but it was the best. I used your link at the 6 minute mark to order this. I cant wait to smell this one. Awesome location and background for this one. Have a great week
Thanks Mike! Its truly a wonderful and unique fragrance!
I couldn't be happier with how the pictures turned out.
I had a vision in my mind prior to the shave and was thrilled when i got home and saw the pictures.
When im out in the daylight its just too hard to "truly see them".
Have a great week!!
Do you know if this is exclusive at PAA or retailers may get as well? Great video, I dare you to do that shave at midnight. 👻
Thank you😊
So I'm not positive I would say maybe. If you reach out to Doug or Fran they'd be happy to tell you.
I may take you up on that dare😊
Have a great week!
I think you should make SNERD T-shirts. The word snerd has to always be on it, and some kind of shaving gear or whatever accompanying snerd. The first T should have your mug on it! 😂
😂😂 Lol thanks for the laugh brother! 🙏
It sounds a really lovely fragrance. Buuuuuuut, what kind of spiciness?
Soft Spicy.
Do you know how similar this is to Swamp Fox from SG?
Negative, wish I did!
Dude...the door...
Right???
😅😅😅😅
If Texas loses this game your Ducks ought to be #1
That's what we're thinking! Sco Ducks!
Tobin? Are there hip bines behind you?
😅😅😅😅 there might actually be a pelvis😅😅😅
@@Tobins_throwbacks it was supposed to say hop bines
Excellent review. Nice little B role walk around the property. Ordered this one exactly 4 mins after getting Doug's product drop email. Looking forward to it too.
Question for you Tobin. Might you know if Doug is doing a re-run of Clown Fruit? I want the EDP of that one.
When it dropped I scrambled to find Tobin's affiliate link 😅 I couldn't order this one fast enough either
I think CF drops every year
@@ChristopherDanielJones Thank you sir. I think it was pretty this time last year, within a day or so, that CF came out. I'm down under and enjoying what PAA, amongst others, is doing.
Thanks Rod!! Curious to know your thoughts of it when it arrives.
So yes sir I expect clown fruit to drop between now and Halloween. Douglas hasn't told me that but that's just what I expect.
It's probably already Sunday for you, and I hope it's going well!
@@ChristopherDanielJonesthanks Chris!
What is it that makes Alexis hold back and give 9, but Emily 10?
Right?!??!??!??!?!! It's so good! If I had to guess I would say it's likely the musk note that she mentioned. But I'm only guessing I'm not brave enough to ask 😉😊😜🤐🤫
@@Tobins_throwbacks but, in my mind, the musk note would turn Emily off, as she has a younger palate
There was/is a bug on you 😅 you were right lol
Yeah lol when I was editing I noticed several
But during the video I thought I was tripping 😆