Ranking Classic Doctor Who From Worst To Best: Part 1 (131-158)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 24

  • @randallmilessmith5705
    @randallmilessmith5705 8 місяців тому

    With you liking the daleks colour version have you seen peter cushings adaptations of the two hartnells? How do you compare hartnells version to cushings please

    • @AnotherScifiGuy
      @AnotherScifiGuy  8 місяців тому +1

      I have seen them, a subscriber sent them both to me! I enjoy them, I like the Cushing version of the Daleks better but prefer the hartnell version of invasion to earth better.

  • @suttercane6
    @suttercane6 8 місяців тому

    Warriors of the Deep (starring Ingrid Pitt) needs its own chapter stop 😂

  • @KennyBacchus-yg3uv
    @KennyBacchus-yg3uv 8 місяців тому

    Ranking. Classic. Doctor who. From. Worst. To. Best. Part. 1. (. 31. 158. )

  • @lenlooksback7981
    @lenlooksback7981 8 місяців тому +1

    I'd say you could actually have lumped the entirety of season 23 at the bottom of the list. Trial is truly terrible. Yeah: dear Ingrid's demise in Warriors IS appalling, also. At least it's good for a good laugh: as you so ably demonstrated! Um....think the Space Museum is a touch worse than The Chase/The Web Planet, however. Overall, great video!

    • @AnotherScifiGuy
      @AnotherScifiGuy  8 місяців тому

      Many thanks! The first episode of space museum is amazing, the rest are not as good, but still fine imo.

    • @BernardJKD
      @BernardJKD 8 місяців тому +1

      Disagree

    • @rnw2739
      @rnw2739 8 місяців тому

      Insanity. Trial is one of the best seasons of Classic Who ever. How you can cite it as 'terrible' is utterly mind-blowing. I will just assume you haven't seen it and are one of those fools that listen to the mental Colin Baker haters who become noticeably silent when you ask them for reasons - other than the pathetic stock answer of the 2 second Peri strangling scene which they refuse to acknowledge is down to post regenerative trauma.

    • @lenlooksback7981
      @lenlooksback7981 8 місяців тому

      @@rnw2739 Own the season 22 bluray set and have ZERO problem with Twin Dilemma....so there! The Trial (and most everything that followed it) still STINKS.

    • @AnotherScifiGuy
      @AnotherScifiGuy  8 місяців тому

      @@rnw2739 I have trial many times, as I have almost all of classic who and modern who, I’ve been watching the show seen I was three or four years old back in the 80s.

  • @BernardJKD
    @BernardJKD 8 місяців тому +1

    There like 6 maybe 7 bad classic stories. Bit harsh on Mindwarp.

    • @AnotherScifiGuy
      @AnotherScifiGuy  8 місяців тому +1

      Just my personal least favorite of classic who, still miles better than the worst of modern who.

    • @rnw2739
      @rnw2739 8 місяців тому

      Mindwarp is excellent and has one of the most disturbing and shocking endings of all Doctor Who.

    • @AnotherScifiGuy
      @AnotherScifiGuy  8 місяців тому

      @@rnw2739 so glad that was retconned.

  • @alisticious
    @alisticious 8 місяців тому

    Things I learned: I like Kroll even less than the guy who's known for disliking kroll 🤣

  • @rnw2739
    @rnw2739 8 місяців тому

    Mate, are you ok? Your descent into phoney, hysterical laughter over Ingrid Pitts death was more cringeworthy than the ludicrous scene itself.
    No sane person who still has alll their faculties could EVER place 'The Awakening' beneath 'Delta and the Bannermen'. I urge your family members to have you certified ASAP for their own protection.

    • @AnotherScifiGuy
      @AnotherScifiGuy  8 місяців тому

      Oh I assure you, I was trying to stop laughing, it was literally making my face turn red. The awakening has a decent first part, but part 2 was totally disappointing, both it and delta are bad stories by classic who standards, though they are better than some of modern who like kill the moon, fear her, and the caretaker.

  • @the_flyattractor8656
    @the_flyattractor8656 8 місяців тому

    So many of the stories mentioned and the first thing that comes to mind is "The Target Book Does it Better!" And You Put Them in STORAGE!!!!!!!!!???????????????? Dropping back down to Jodie leve on Patreon and SOOOOO Hittig the Down Thumb button...Gonna make a ton of Fake accounts and hit it SEVERAL TIMES!!!!!!!!!!!😠....😉

    • @AnotherScifiGuy
      @AnotherScifiGuy  8 місяців тому

      Ah! But I am reading one of those target novels right now! I mentioned to you I was about to get to another one. 😁

    • @AnotherScifiGuy
      @AnotherScifiGuy  8 місяців тому

      Actually I have realized I have most (if not all of the books) at home with me as I found the book with them in it while searching for a super 7 Thundercats figure.