It has a unstable and weak government so it cannot exert control and historically there has been military coups with limited consequences to the plotters which emboldens the military and intelligence to do what they wish.
Since Pakistan passively aided and abetted the Taliban in their efforts to retake Afghanistan, they've really got no one but themselves to blame for the current conflict.
@@cyberverse9141 You must really be not following the region lol, Pakistan has been the key supporter to the Taliban ever since the soviet times. 1996-2001 and during the IR Afghanistan and NATO era. must of the Taliban grew up there. studied there and still have families living there. Specially the Haqqanis which were always in Pakistan. why do you think the resentment of afghans towards Pakistan comes from? Not to mention ISI which has aided them with Intelligence. and most importantly Imran Khan which has been very vocal about his Taliban stance. His words not mine.
I saw an opinion post "calling out" the west for not supporting NGOs in Afghanistan, the next day the taliban started banning all NGOs that hire women.
No surprise. A lot of the opinion pieces decrying the West for not doing this or that tend to be made out of personal ideological biases, not good state policy.
People rlly so slow😂. The Taliban was never funded or supported by Pakistan. It was founded in the late 80s by a village cleric named Mullah Omar. His intended plans were never to capture all of Afghanistan, But just his province Kandahar. He gained lots of support and other Mujahideen groups dissolved and joined him to take over the whole of Afghanistan. The TBan declared Pakistan an Enemy since the early 2000s. The TTP were created by the TBan to do operations within Pakistan and cause them as much harm as possible for being an ally of America
Lmao and this is the so-called "Shariah Law" that's governing the state even though there is evidence of women in influential positions during the early days of Islam. The Taliban haven't been consistent in a single thing they done but there are still people sympathising with their bullshit.
no. Afghanistan is the graveyard of empires. Afghans defeated the British, the Soviets and the US+nato. Afghanistan is peaceful and beautiful now since the US left
Afghanistan is the playground of empires, only 500 ish of last 2000 years were ruled by native afghans. Reality is any middle power could come in, achieve what they want and leave. Afghnistan has no power wxcept being a thorn in everybodys ass. The mistake america made was making a democracy there, like making a house in the sand. Calling it the grAvEyArD oF eMpIrEs is western cope.
USA to Pakistan since 2001: "Stop supporting the Taliban. They are not your friends! Pakistan to USA: "They are our brothers in arms, and we will support them to the end of days!". USA to Pakistan since 2021: "How's that working out for you so far?!?!".
@@arnodorian2967 Border treaty? Afghanistan sold KPK to the British in the 1800s because the tribes there were seen as being unloyal to the nation and now all of a sudden after seeing them become more successful than Afghanistan they suddenly want them back, it’s pathetic.
If Taliban supports Pakistan, no need to watch what they’re doing If taliban supports India and/or is against Pakistan, you need to watch what they’re doing That’s the balance
They are American and their propaganda, pakistan and usa are responsible for every terror organisation and terror activities in South Asia and now both are blaming each other.
If india invades Pakistan, and Pakistan gets the afghans on their side, Pakistan is functionally no longer a long and thin country, but then a wide country, which makes encirclements more difficult, and pakistani logistics stronger.
Saudi Arabia is an Islamic state and you don't see this, I blame it on them being South Asians, because they all make failed States and drive off intellectuals
the pro-Taliban government was overthrown in 2022, and things have not been going good since then. That's why, know what you are talking about before saying random filth.
@@khizarhayatkhan-uq1qm nah nah I’m Pakistani and Muslim but Pakistan is a corrupt puppet country of non Muslims (USA, China). And it creates extremists (it didn’t create Taliban though)
Pakistan has been learning this lesson since the mid 2000s. You can't coddle or support groups who want to destabilize nation states on ideological lines and expect no violent repercussions that undermine your own national sovereignty.
They don't care, pak military thrive in this, their power increases as they are needed to fight terrorism, and their biz makes them richer. They are exploiting the country fully, and once broke enough, they'll just use their foreign passports to enjoy the riches in developed countries.
@@overlord3481 Terrorism isn't some value judgement that can be quantified. The United States and Pakistan are states that support terror, as are most major world powers. Terrorism and destabilization has been the key political weapon since WW2.
@@Pehount before calling names do check about 26/11 , taj hotel , parliament attack and then look up who claimed responsibility for all those incidents , and then check where do they live
pakistan has problem with iran they have problem with india they have problem with afghanistan and they have probelm internally with balochistan and the pashtun reigon? wtf are they even doing?
Important clarification, the Taliban were not part of the Mujahedeen. The Taliban were created by Pakistani ISI well after the Soviet-Afghan War. ISI recognised the benefits of an allied Islamic state in Afghanistan and so trained young Afghan men being taught at religious schools in Pakistan and Kandahar. They were formed in 1994, 2 years after the Soviet-Afgan War was already over and began fighting Mujahedeen groups who had been fighting against the Soviets and were attempting to form a new government. There were some Mujahedeen fighters who later joined the Taliban, but it is completely historically inaccurate to say that the Taliban were Mujahedeen, it's usually done to criticise the Americans however they never supported the Taliban. The Mujahedeen who received US support became the Northern Alliance and later the government of the Afghan Republic.
@@jahangirashraf4128 Wrong. Taliban were formes in pakistan by afghans. The US supported the mujahedeen groups. After the soviet retreat they began fighting amongst themselves, which led to the capture of Kabul by the taliban in 1996. The mujahedeen kept fighting the taliban backed by the US until 2001.
@jahangirashraf4128 no they weren't, the Taliban did not fight the Soviets because they didn't exist in Afghanistan until after the Soviet withdrawal. The US worked with the Mujahedeen groups, some of which had similar ideologies to the Taliban, but they were not the Taliban, nor was the Taliban created from the Mujahedeen.
Didn’t the leader of the Northern Alliance try to warn America about the dangers posed by AQ and the Taliban before 9/11 and was assassinated shortly after. What was his name again?
the US heavily supported the "Peshawar Seven", which is to say Mujahedeen situated in Pakistan, and the US does in fact have a long history of providing support for Pakistan. trying to divorce the US from its funding of islamist jihadis in the region by trying to neatly divide Mujahedeen from Taliban is like trying to claim an arsonist only tried to burn down a single apartment, not the whole building.
Taliban need an external enemy to keep their hold on Afghanistan. They refuse to dismantle the TTP because many of the TTP fighters moonlight between both “branches” of the Taliban and they fear cracking down on TTP will lead to TTP fighters joining ISIS-K (an enemy of the Taliban). The Afghan Taliban also lay claim to Pakistani lands which has always been the case since the inception of Pakistan no matter who ruled Kabul at the time. Afghanistan was the only country that fought against allowing an independent Pakistan into the UN. Now there is talk in Pakistan about Pakistan not accepting the same border and seizing the strategic Wakhan corridor if the Taliban do not change course. Long story short, things may get hotter soon.
I mean it makes sense as to why the afghans wouldn't accept the border. As Pakistan is a state which was artificially created. and most of its people dont need to look far back to trace their afghan routes
@ozone1894 It is shocking to me how some useful idiots advocate for joining Afghanstan. Why would you want to be ruled by these extremist terrorists? I'm so glad I don't have to live in Afghanistan, and I would much rather that it remains that way.
@ozone1894 Not considering the fact that twice as many Pashtuns live in Pakistan than the total population of Afghanistan. Plus Afghanistan tried retaking the provinces in 1961 and the local did not want to join Afghanistan at all. If anything it should be the other way around, Pakistan should absorb the Pashtun elements of Afghanistan.
@ozone1894 actually no, that border was the condition for Afghans being free of direct invasion by the British. Their Emir of the time accepted it in exchange for full diplomatic recognition as an independent country. So without the durand line and the treaty of rawalpindi then Afghan would not exist as a sovereign recognized state. Mind you the Afghans started the third Afghan British war, so them trying to do away with the results of said war now can also mean that Afghans very statehood can be rejected by Pakistan.
Yes Muslim Punjabi’s are currently a majority of the population of Pakistan 🇵🇰 so its unsurprising that they have most senior Pakistani Military officers are of that ethnicity and the British Raj has a direct responsibility of borders were made by their colonial government hence the Pashtun, Balochi and Kashmir peoples borders now across two or three countries. What a nightmare caused by the collapsed British colonial rule who ran away from their collective colonialism administration after World War 2 this is major reason why these two Muslim countries are now at the Brink of war as badly run colonial administrations can’t be fixed by creating new problems.
Hello , My Friend I am from India so i can tell you what's happening in my neighborhood First some context you need to know the previous elected government led by Sheikh Hasina has some problem with Americans now you wonder what's the problem with Americans they want's a navel base in Indian Ocean so they put pressure on Hasina but she don't bow down So mr Biden give green light to CIA to do something so they did what they are doing since there birth toppling democratic elected governments now you are wondering but how they CIA did it so in bangledesh there is reservation in government job for people who family members flights against Pakistan in the liberation of Bangladesh so there is a massive protest and CIA with help some Islamist organisation launch a coup in disguise of civil uprising. As always CIA loss control over them they start having havoc around attacking Hindus shops targeting Hindu women's and committing atrocities on other minorities you know classic Islamist Jihadi Now what's happening now so after sleep joe losses the election i mean get thrown out of race new Trump administration is not so happy with current care taking prime minister Md yunsh bcz his anti India and pro china stance untill now bangledesh army was on stand by but now entire country becoming a wild west and despite months the violence is not ending maybe make a move so without no Americans support or army support there is chance yunus will run away and military will take over I hope now your update with current situation if not you can ask me anything
The Taliban were NOT a faction of the mujahedeen. This is a common misconception. The Taliban formed after the Soviet-Afghan war, made up largely of refugees of the soviet-afghan war returning after being educated in Pakistani Madrasas.
Wait, wth, lol. So not true. Pakistan didn't churn out Taliban mate. Funny how a country efficient at nothing did something like this. Way to put the blame of the idiots in the west and the corrupt officers of the east solely on Pakistan Madrassas.
Pakistan & Bangladesh exist because Indian Muslims from Punjab, Bengal, Gujarat, Bihar, Lucknow/Hyderabadi etc didn't want to live with the Indian Hindus & Sikhs & Jains & Buddhists etc. These are the fruits of their hatred for the Kafirs.
Pakistan will split into four countries in future. Balochistan and Sindh for sure. They mind in India's business too much that they forgot how their own mechanism is functioning.
@aarthirajaraman7453 you guys have been saying stuff like that for 80 years now and been wrong every time 😂 the truth is, China will free Assam soon, and we will free Kashmir The rest will happen on its own
@@cuteorpyarahamza ah but Pakistan is still in the Indian sphere of influence no. We still exert great cultural influence. And we could've had political influence too if it weren't for the nukes. Honestly wait a few decades till another Subhas or Indira comes to power and then you'll see what spheres I'm talking about
Pakistan seems to have learnt nothing from recent history: you do NOT invade Afghanistan. Two major military powers tried, and both got kicked out in shame.
Actually Pakistan is the only one to win against Afghanistan in recent history, during the time Afghanistan invaded in the early 60s, No you do invade Afghanistan, what you dont do it occupy it for multiple decades and accept surrender by you enemy when you can. Both russia and the US had refused t cut their loses early and this is what it resulted in
Pak army would fare much better at an Afghani invasion tbh. They have fairly similar weather and landscapes, much better for the soldiers to endure, whereas soviets and the US military were from another continent, different climate and landscape.
Pakistan thought that their former ally would come together again but that backfired. They were warned not to support the group but ignored, now they reap what they sowed.
Pakistan complaining that the Taliban are providing safe harbor for terrorist is one of the greatest instances of sweet irony that i have ever heard of.
Pakistan when a british line gives india kashmir: REEEEE BRITISH COLONIALISM ARBITRARY LINES Pakistan when a british drawn line gives pakistan pashtun land: this is good
@@djokonole-j6vthe king that lost most of Kashmir to its people and had no legitimacy whatsoever? That agreement holds as much weight as salt holds water.
What are Brits doing in Asia?? oh wait you're telling me they are also in Africa? and the middle east? why don't you stay in Europe and leave the rest of the world in peace?
@@shujah9746 really ? if he had lost the people, then when pakistan's forces went into kashmir to supposedly "liberate" them, why did they start supporting the sikh regiment ? just one regiment of india pushed back pak's forces aswell as majority of kashmir population. right, makes absolute sense. 😅 btw not only the king, but sheikh abdullah also, who was the main opposition also supported india. I have no idea who these so called 'people' are who you talk about. folklore maybe ?
Rudyard Kipling once wrote a poem “the Ballad of East and West” about this area of the Pakistan/Afghanistan border (back then Pakistan was part of British India). It’s one of my favorite poems…
To all those saying Pakistan should have not supported Taliban are vastly underestimating the situation.Pakistan's biggest mistake was not supporting the Taliban but supporting the US in 2001 and allowing them to attack Afganistan due to this many of the Taliban fled towards Kyber region of Pakistan and found refuge but not from Pakistan but from the mountains .You see unlike the US which could use drones to safely fight the Taliban Pakistan could not do this and a ground fight with the Taliban and growing insurgents was deadly and as a result fight against insurgents was intially slow it took Pakistan more than a decade to drive out the insurgents from the Kyber region. Now I will admit Pakistan did support the Taliban to some extent but the comment section is acting like the taliban had full support from Pakistan which they did not. I urge you all to learn and study this conflict deeply and see both perspectives of the war. Pakistan should never have supported America and this war destroyed Pakistan more than it benefitted it.America recived full support from Pakistan in this war they allowed American troops a passage into afganistan and often allowed them to fire ballistic missiles into afganistan off which many would fall into Pakistani areas and hurt the local people.
Nah that's a joke. The US doesn't have casus belli against Greenland and an annexation will be almost universally condemned. So ain't ever happening unless the US actually becomes a dictatorship. Remember such an action will even be unpopular among Americans
It’s not an invasion… he literally offered to buy Greenland and it’s ultimately up to them to decide if they want to break away from Denmark and join with the U.S. an invasion will result military action which there’s none
@@tacossergiobella8736for people to care you must have value or important strategic position . Pakistan and Afghanistan,regardless of how poor or messed up they are both have that . Those poor african countries doesn't have that ,it is that simple ,unless they have resources , that's the only thing they have that majority of the world is intersted in .
02:40 Demographics - If Ethnicities like Sindh, Balochistan and Pashtunustan reject Pakistan, and Brown is Punjabis, than means only half of Brown on the left of India is actual Pakistan.
Hasn't there been a civil war going on in Burma for decades? It looks like the Burmese government has enough trouble keeping control over Burmese territory.
The Taliban were not part of the war against the Soviet Union. They were the refugee children from the nearly 20 year civil war that followed. They grew up in Pakistan and were educated in the Madrasas. They didn’t exist until nearly 20 years after war with the Soviet Union.
Doesn't change anything. They were influenced by the Soviet war, thus became refugees. The US has always been at fault, be it the middle east or South Asia
Shame really, Pakistans biggest motivator for its involvement in all 4 wars in Afghanistan was to convince them to just accept the border, but yet we're still at square one
"Pakistan and Afghanistan might be going to war over each other" 👍 *_India liked this._* EDIT: Joke's on the angry pakistanis in the replies; this was meant to make fun of everyone, even India. 🙃
@@cunningfox1798bhaijan, economy ... If Afghanistan brother wants aid, take it... If want medication help, take it ... We will take our land peacefully with no war ?.?
@@cunningfox1798 india is friendly with taliban and was friendly with last government too . India also give food aid to Afghanistan so India have not much to lose only way india be threatened if pakistan take kabul and somehow install another government who is anti india . And chances of that are ..
Most of Pakistan's land is the traditional lands of Iranic tribes who are essentially ruled by Muslim Indians in the southeast of the country. Afghanistan, Iran, and India should work together to liberate the Iranic tribal lands. Its a big win for everyone.
One of the biggest problems here was that Western powers drew the borders 100 years ago without considering the ethnic and religious roots of the region, and today these problems are not only occurring between Pakistan and Afghanistan. The same scenario exists throughout the Middle East.
Well, if the had considered the ethnic and religious factors, they would have had to divide the Middle East into hundreds of states, some of which not bigger than a single village. I am sure that would not have made it more peaceful.
Natural boarders are built on geography, the colonials didn’t build it based on geography. As an example at 2:40 in the video all the ethnic groups want to seperate apart from the brown coloured one. Compare that to the geographic landscape. The seperate ethnic groups Pink/Yellow/Green are naturally divided by mountains and desert but the brown coloured part has direct access to places like Kashmir/india and thus similar culture. This was not followed, causing the issue. Same stuff in india where you have things like Khalistan and eastern/southern part considering themselves distinct from the northern part
@@cuddlywuddlybear "Natural boarders are built on geography," Not always, not even in Europe. The Pyrenees are for instance a geographic boundary between Spain and France, but there is no such border between Spain and Portugal. And you could drive all the way from Amsterdam to Moscow without encountering natural borders.
Not about muslims. Pakistan and Afghanistan have never gotten along. not during the Secular afghan kingdom and governments or Islamic. If it was a muslim problem how come just across the Persian gulf there are Muslim countries more modern and successful at the current times then most secular states?
ME has a serious case of “splitters“, different factions fighting amongst each other. Not surprising, given the religious and resource circumstances. They may all be “Muslim“, but it‘s not difficult to find a faction that claims it‘s “true“ Islam, while other Muslim factions are not true to Islam. Remember, a heretic is someone who *almost* shares the same beliefs as you do! :/
@IAjayMukhiya Rubbish. You can't expect them to know how to pronounce every single place name on the planet. I live in Australia and the vast majority of English speaking videos mispronounce our capital. But that doesn't automatically mean the underlying information in the vid is wrong.
@ unfortunately common man in Pakistan is suffering from very high inflation, poverty, unemployment but Pakistan is buying 5 th generation jets from china…
What the occupying part was the easy part. The forming a modern centralized government was the impossible part. Afghanistan has never had a strong central government even back when it was a kingdom. I don’t know why the us and ussr though they could impose something that never existed in that area.
@@beuyhs1000 Hmm. Looking in, it seems like the Taliban are popular enough... as for competency, I suppose it takes time to build institutions for good governance..
@@RedSoloCupppppthey're unpopular bcz of food security in Afghanistan ever since USA invasion population of Afghanistan is ballooned it's virtually impossible to feed all of them without some high tech agri like Israel or china use or buy it from outside but to buy u need foreign cash reserves or foreign aid and taliban is isolated. Bad situation really
In a proper, conventional war Pakistan would win. However, Taliban won't fight conventionally, as they take advantage of mountainous terrain and fight guerilla style. Pakistan will, most likely, attack key objectives of Taliban and retreat, taking advantage of their clear air superiority. Hard to imagine either side winning a decisive victory in this war
Why would Taliban fight in a fashion that limits their chance of victory? Most probable case imo is a wide scale revolt in Pakistan's Pashtun region. They are not great fan of Islamabad government any way.
@@puneetmishra4726 Because that can back fire too, one reason for their hostility towards Pakistan is that would unite most of the non Pashtun population who dont like the Taliban, but a unconventional war on both sides would lead them to revolt just like the Taliban once did Also one must keep in mind that most Pashtuns love Pakistan, they dont like the current goverment there is a difference and with Pakistani Pashtuns alone being more than Afghani pashtuns, that says something
i remember when they used to support the Taliban against the usa .... now they are fighting each other i see this as a huge w for all 2 Islamist states doing everyone a favor by decreasing each other. hope the best of the beluch .
@isaacjude91 pakistan is probably the best example for Deep State. And almost every corrupt official in every country is a national, so what's the point?
The Pakistani military IS the Pakistani state. They decide who to go to war with, what businesses will be allowed to run, who the prime minister will be. Everything. Pakistanis call their army the "establishment", because it's the only stable establishment or organisation in that country.
@@isaacjude91 Pakistan is probably the best example for the deep state. Being a national doesn't make you obey your authorities, if that's new to you. You need a chain or faith in authority to hold your supposed subordinates. Plus, corruption is a good way for nothing to work properly.
'You can't keep snakes in your backyard and expect them only to bite your neighbors'
Try and be original, these are Hillary Clinton's words
They did help defeat the USSR... No one was thinking very far into the future when those problems were being solved.
The Taliban never liked Pakistan nor did Pakistan ever support the TBan, Only a false claim to make their loss look more realistic
@@Leto2ndAtreidesthey didbt. Ur confusing mujahedin with taliban - not the same.
@ajmulsharifipak did in fact protect taliban and even bin laden - facts
The fact that the pakistani state has no control over its strong military and intelligence services always baffles me
It has a unstable and weak government so it cannot exert control and historically there has been military coups with limited consequences to the plotters which emboldens the military and intelligence to do what they wish.
So the Pakistan state doesn't even know who it supports? That doesn't sound like a point that helps Pakistan at all.
@@krishnachaitanyagv5065 no, the state supports the military, because the military controls the state.
it is said that the pakistan military has a state, not that the state has a military lol
Not that surprising as the civilian Pakistani government is receiving coups from its military almost every decade.
Since Pakistan passively aided and abetted the Taliban in their efforts to retake Afghanistan, they've really got no one but themselves to blame for the current conflict.
Lol how did they support them? Literally how?
@@cyberverse9141 You must really be not following the region lol, Pakistan has been the key supporter to the Taliban ever since the soviet times. 1996-2001 and during the IR Afghanistan and NATO era. must of the Taliban grew up there. studied there and still have families living there. Specially the Haqqanis which were always in Pakistan. why do you think the resentment of afghans towards Pakistan comes from? Not to mention ISI which has aided them with Intelligence. and most importantly Imran Khan which has been very vocal about his Taliban stance. His words not mine.
I'm from Pakistan and I can say that the decision to support these people (Taliban) was from military the state and people has nothing to do with this
@@Ahmed-ww8od Then you should have not supported the military
@@Ahmed-ww8odare you sure about that?
Play stupid games, win stupid prizes
oh this would be funny. The Soviets tried, the Americans tried, and old empires tried. Batter up, Pakistan and hop on the silly ride.
like you?
@@anywaytechreviewwhy u got triggered 😂 lol
kraut video?
Are u slow by chance?
Reaping what they sowed.
Tell me you’re ignorant without telling me you are
@@harlowidaPakistan literally funded talibs lol
@@harlowida Tell me you’re ignorant without telling me you are
This childish comment section sums up the geopolitics of the region
Can you guys reap some toilets?
As a Pakistani, all pakistan does is make me cry
Thank you Jinnah ♥️🇮🇳
😆🤣😝😆😂
It's okay there are many countries that offer citizenship. Pakistan is a sinking ship that has so much potential yet no leadership
@@Patriarchy_69We aren't doing very well either. Our economic growth is poor and we are surrounded by nemesis.
@@Patriarchy_69yes we can thank him for not making Pakistan the same as india
Get A napkin 😅
I saw an opinion post "calling out" the west for not supporting NGOs in Afghanistan, the next day the taliban started banning all NGOs that hire women.
No surprise. A lot of the opinion pieces decrying the West for not doing this or that tend to be made out of personal ideological biases, not good state policy.
People rlly so slow😂. The Taliban was never funded or supported by Pakistan. It was founded in the late 80s by a village cleric named Mullah Omar. His intended plans were never to capture all of Afghanistan, But just his province Kandahar. He gained lots of support and other Mujahideen groups dissolved and joined him to take over the whole of Afghanistan. The TBan declared Pakistan an Enemy since the early 2000s. The TTP were created by the TBan to do operations within Pakistan and cause them as much harm as possible for being an ally of America
Lmao and this is the so-called "Shariah Law" that's governing the state even though there is evidence of women in influential positions during the early days of Islam. The Taliban haven't been consistent in a single thing they done but there are still people sympathising with their bullshit.
Let me guess….. Reddit?
Pakistan is govern by corrupted army generals. They only care for their own pocket
Afghanistan is called graveyard of empires but reality is Afghanistan itself is a graveyard.
no. Afghanistan is the graveyard of empires. Afghans defeated the British, the Soviets and the US+nato. Afghanistan is peaceful and beautiful now since the US left
@SafaM-ne8zmwhat about the women?
Afghanistan is the playground of empires, only 500 ish of last 2000 years were ruled by native afghans.
Reality is any middle power could come in, achieve what they want and leave.
Afghnistan has no power wxcept being a thorn in everybodys ass. The mistake america made was making a democracy there, like making a house in the sand. Calling it the grAvEyArD oF eMpIrEs is western cope.
@SafaM-ne8zm yes they defeated but with the help of Pakistan
@SafaM-ne8zm ...as long as you're a mullah who supports the Taliban. A Shia, a Hazarah, a woman...perhaps not.
USA to Pakistan since 2001: "Stop supporting the Taliban. They are not your friends!
Pakistan to USA: "They are our brothers in arms, and we will support them to the end of days!".
USA to Pakistan since 2021: "How's that working out for you so far?!?!".
Like USA is any better lol
Pakistan always knew that the Taliban hated them; they supported them anyway because they hate a strong Afghanistan even more.
usa spent 2 trillion dollars to replace taliban with taliban, i think we know we can decide what to do ourselves
USA: OOPS hehehe i left 2 million helicopters in the hands of afghani taliban! i'm just a girl!
Pakistan supported USA invasion. They were using Pakistan for supply routes and using their air bases
Pakistan: Is this... *THE CONSEQUENCES OF MY OWN ACTIONS!?!?!?!?*
Uhh are we just gonna ignore the fact that Afghanistan has been doing this since the 60s…
@حارس_شاہ Are we gonna ignore that Afghanistan made moves border against Pakistan when Pakistan violated the border treaty
@@arnodorian2967 Border treaty? Afghanistan sold KPK to the British in the 1800s because the tribes there were seen as being unloyal to the nation and now all of a sudden after seeing them become more successful than Afghanistan they suddenly want them back, it’s pathetic.
Pakistan is govern by corrupted army generals. They only care for their own pocket
It's the consequence of US meddling. The Taliban was literally a guerilla group trained by the CIA.
Didn’t understand how taliban, which has no border or conflict with India is a counter balance to it?
It’s all about "strategic depth".
If Taliban supports Pakistan, no need to watch what they’re doing
If taliban supports India and/or is against Pakistan, you need to watch what they’re doing
That’s the balance
They are American and their propaganda, pakistan and usa are responsible for every terror organisation and terror activities in South Asia and now both are blaming each other.
Taliban = Islamic group = Muslim brothers = "Friendly with us and not India" 😂 At least that is their belief if I have to assume
If india invades Pakistan, and Pakistan gets the afghans on their side, Pakistan is functionally no longer a long and thin country, but then a wide country, which makes encirclements more difficult, and pakistani logistics stronger.
As a pakistani, I beg these people to stop. the Pak Studies syllabus is already too much
Don't worry, Objective truth was never included in pak studies syllabus to begin with.
YES PLEASE AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH
You guys only have a few years of history to read. Come on have more
Don't worry Pakistan won't cease to exist for long.
as if they teach us any truth in it
"Pakistan is a living testament to the bankrupt idea of an Islamic State." - Tarek Fatah 🇵🇰🇨🇦
Pakistan isn't an Islamic state
They follow nor use any of the fundamentals that an "Islamic state". Do research instead of quoting restarted people on the internet
There has never been a single islamic party that ruled Pakistan in its history…
Saudi Arabia is an Islamic state and you don't see this, I blame it on them being South Asians, because they all make failed States and drive off intellectuals
Muslims are not able to govern their own countries
They are just enforcing peace on each other.
😂😂
smartest human
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
The problem is that they don't claim to be for peace so this cringe joke doesn't work.
@@Narrator_of_Tarikh07 come bro, grow up 🤣
Pakistan should have known supporting the Taliban would have backfired on them
the pro-Taliban government was overthrown in 2022, and things have not been going good since then.
That's why, know what you are talking about before saying random filth.
I don't know whether it's good or bad that the terrorists are fighting with the state sponsors of terrorism.
Tell that to the army
They were warned but ignored.
@@omerarfan Pakistan aided the Taliban throughout the entire conflict.
oh no, when I supported leopards, I didn't expect leopards to eat MY face.
im from Pakistan and your example should be about "snakes" lol. still true though
@@muzammilmughal6311nothing mughal about Pakistan
Yet Afghanistan has been doing that to Pakistan since the 60s and isn’t seen as a problem…
@حارس_شاہ only after your violation of the border treaty
@حارس_شاہ not to mention, the Doha agreement as well.
We got Pakistan blaming terrorism before GTA6
😭
😂😂
@@khizarhayatkhan-uq1qm nah nah I’m Pakistani and Muslim but Pakistan is a corrupt puppet country of non Muslims (USA, China). And it creates extremists (it didn’t create Taliban though)
@@khizarhayatkhan-uq1qm thats your best comeback?
@@khizarhayatkhan-uq1qmyou post videos of you eating bugs in lahore
Such a chaotic region
Britain heading same way😂
WW2 and WW1 shows how Christianity causes world wars. Such a chaotic religion
blame Britian.
Religion*
@@myguybrulmao @ you bringing up nearly 100 year old conflicts, especially when they weren't about religion
Pakistan has been learning this lesson since the mid 2000s. You can't coddle or support groups who want to destabilize nation states on ideological lines and expect no violent repercussions that undermine your own national sovereignty.
Same could be said about Afghanistan who first supported militants in Pakistan starting up from the 60s
The Taliban never received support from Pakistan, Y’all slow af if that what you believe
They don't care, pak military thrive in this, their power increases as they are needed to fight terrorism, and their biz makes them richer.
They are exploiting the country fully, and once broke enough, they'll just use their foreign passports to enjoy the riches in developed countries.
Pakistan never supported the Talibans! Where do you guys get this bullshits?!
Pakistan is govern by corrupted army generals. They only care for their own pocket. They're allies of USA. Pakistan is not at all Islamic state.
Play stupid games, win stupid prizes 🎉
Pakistan accusing others of terrorism is crazy 💀💀💀
Pakistan isn't a terrorist country as much as the US.
@@overlord3481 both aren't terrorist
@@overlord3481 Terrorism isn't some value judgement that can be quantified. The United States and Pakistan are states that support terror, as are most major world powers. Terrorism and destabilization has been the key political weapon since WW2.
Smartest pajeet
@@Pehount before calling names do check about 26/11 , taj hotel , parliament attack and then look up who claimed responsibility for all those incidents , and then check where do they live
Meanwhile in India: DO IT! DO IT! DO IT!
India wouldn’t want a war near its border.
India after Pakistan gets Wakhan: shid nod good.
@@Techuser704 Thank you for helping the Taliban. Now they don't have to deal with ISIS there
@@Techuser704 wakhan lmao even fata is slipping out of their hands.
Naa bro, there's already enough wars going on right now
"Heartwarming: The Worst People You Know Are All Fighting."
This!
I many of those worst people u know personally know shame on u racist biget
Did murikan civil war start? or you talking about slavs killing each other in ukraine?
Keep coping abdool, dont forget your goats😂😂😂😂@@FarhanRajper-ik1fq
pakistan has problem with iran they have problem with india they have problem with afghanistan and they have probelm internally with balochistan and the pashtun reigon? wtf are they even doing?
They have problems with every country in the region. Genocidal maniacs. Pakistan doesn't have a military, the military has Pakistan.
Khud ki marwa ha rahe hain 😅
they even have a problem with non muslim
Pakistan is govern by corrupted army generals. They only care for their own pocket. They're allies of USA.
@@shoukonishimiya9931 nah they dont
Important clarification, the Taliban were not part of the Mujahedeen. The Taliban were created by Pakistani ISI well after the Soviet-Afghan War. ISI recognised the benefits of an allied Islamic state in Afghanistan and so trained young Afghan men being taught at religious schools in Pakistan and Kandahar. They were formed in 1994, 2 years after the Soviet-Afgan War was already over and began fighting Mujahedeen groups who had been fighting against the Soviets and were attempting to form a new government. There were some Mujahedeen fighters who later joined the Taliban, but it is completely historically inaccurate to say that the Taliban were Mujahedeen, it's usually done to criticise the Americans however they never supported the Taliban. The Mujahedeen who received US support became the Northern Alliance and later the government of the Afghan Republic.
No,
Taliban were created by Afghans in Afghanistan, America utilized them initially against USSR. So we're funded by the US and trained by Pakistan.
@@jahangirashraf4128 Wrong. Taliban were formes in pakistan by afghans. The US supported the mujahedeen groups. After the soviet retreat they began fighting amongst themselves, which led to the capture of Kabul by the taliban in 1996. The mujahedeen kept fighting the taliban backed by the US until 2001.
@jahangirashraf4128 no they weren't, the Taliban did not fight the Soviets because they didn't exist in Afghanistan until after the Soviet withdrawal. The US worked with the Mujahedeen groups, some of which had similar ideologies to the Taliban, but they were not the Taliban, nor was the Taliban created from the Mujahedeen.
Didn’t the leader of the Northern Alliance try to warn America about the dangers posed by AQ and the Taliban before 9/11 and was assassinated shortly after. What was his name again?
the US heavily supported the "Peshawar Seven", which is to say Mujahedeen situated in Pakistan, and the US does in fact have a long history of providing support for Pakistan. trying to divorce the US from its funding of islamist jihadis in the region by trying to neatly divide Mujahedeen from Taliban is like trying to claim an arsonist only tried to burn down a single apartment, not the whole building.
Taliban need an external enemy to keep their hold on Afghanistan. They refuse to dismantle the TTP because many of the TTP fighters moonlight between both “branches” of the Taliban and they fear cracking down on TTP will lead to TTP fighters joining ISIS-K (an enemy of the Taliban). The Afghan Taliban also lay claim to Pakistani lands which has always been the case since the inception of Pakistan no matter who ruled Kabul at the time. Afghanistan was the only country that fought against allowing an independent Pakistan into the UN.
Now there is talk in Pakistan about Pakistan not accepting the same border and seizing the strategic Wakhan corridor if the Taliban do not change course. Long story short, things may get hotter soon.
I mean it makes sense as to why the afghans wouldn't accept the border. As Pakistan is a state which was artificially created. and most of its people dont need to look far back to trace their afghan routes
I hope it does that would keep them busy to bother most international countries with their terrorist if they are killing each other.
@ozone1894 It is shocking to me how some useful idiots advocate for joining Afghanstan. Why would you want to be ruled by these extremist terrorists? I'm so glad I don't have to live in Afghanistan, and I would much rather that it remains that way.
@ozone1894 Not considering the fact that twice as many Pashtuns live in Pakistan than the total population of Afghanistan.
Plus Afghanistan tried retaking the provinces in 1961 and the local did not want to join Afghanistan at all.
If anything it should be the other way around, Pakistan should absorb the Pashtun elements of Afghanistan.
@ozone1894 actually no, that border was the condition for Afghans being free of direct invasion by the British. Their Emir of the time accepted it in exchange for full diplomatic recognition as an independent country. So without the durand line and the treaty of rawalpindi then Afghan would not exist as a sovereign recognized state. Mind you the Afghans started the third Afghan British war, so them trying to do away with the results of said war now can also mean that Afghans very statehood can be rejected by Pakistan.
So has anyone learned to not sponsor islamists yet?
Clearly not. Al-Qaeda just took over Syria with Turkish backing.
Clearly, Islamists didn't learn to not sponsor other islamists.
Instructions unclear. New holy war started.
Shouldn't promote Islam either.
Pakistan is govern by corrupted army generals. They only care for their own pocket. They're allies of USA.
Pakistan is basically A Punjabi colony ruled by the Punjabi Millitary and Business Establishment which is like the East India Company of Pakistan
Not a Punjabi Colony, instead a colony of military although mostly military generals are Punjabi.
Punjabi Muslims. Not sikhs
Yes Muslim Punjabi’s are currently a majority of the population of Pakistan 🇵🇰 so its unsurprising that they have most senior Pakistani Military officers are of that ethnicity and the British Raj has a direct responsibility of borders were made by their colonial government hence the Pashtun, Balochi and Kashmir peoples borders now across two or three countries. What a nightmare caused by the collapsed British colonial rule who ran away from their collective colonialism administration after World War 2 this is major reason why these two Muslim countries are now at the Brink of war as badly run colonial administrations can’t be fixed by creating new problems.
Why do you hate Punjabis??
false
pakistan is home to punjabi, pashtun, baloch, kashmiri and so many other ethics group
the enemy of my enemy... is NOT my friend. It's funny how many times politicians have to re-learn this
Please do a video on What's happening in Bangladesh. Total confusion over there.
Hello , My Friend I am from India so i can tell you what's happening in my neighborhood
First some context you need to know the previous elected government led by Sheikh Hasina has some problem with Americans
now you wonder what's the problem with Americans they want's a navel base in Indian Ocean so they put pressure on Hasina but she don't bow down
So mr Biden give green light to CIA to do something so they did what they are doing since there birth toppling democratic elected governments
now you are wondering but how they CIA did it so in bangledesh there is reservation in government job for people who family members flights against Pakistan in the liberation of Bangladesh so there is a massive protest and CIA with help some Islamist organisation launch a coup in disguise of civil uprising. As always CIA loss control over them they start having havoc around attacking Hindus shops targeting Hindu women's and committing atrocities on other minorities you know classic Islamist Jihadi
Now what's happening now so after sleep joe losses the election i mean get thrown out of race new Trump administration is not so happy with current care taking prime minister Md yunsh bcz his anti India and pro china stance untill now bangledesh army was on stand by but now entire country becoming a wild west and despite months the violence is not ending maybe make a move so without no Americans support or army support there is chance yunus will run away and military will take over I hope now your update with current situation if not you can ask me anything
Write off that people, nothing great comes from that place.
Diagnosis: Islam.
Imo US is attempting US 2.0 there, though much more subtly.
Can't ignore possibility of pakistan's involvement either.
@@sagar3455 the US doesn't give a shit about Bangladesh.
The Taliban were NOT a faction of the mujahedeen. This is a common misconception. The Taliban formed after the Soviet-Afghan war, made up largely of refugees of the soviet-afghan war returning after being educated in Pakistani Madrasas.
not a single Taliban was educated in pakistan
Wait, wth, lol. So not true. Pakistan didn't churn out Taliban mate. Funny how a country efficient at nothing did something like this. Way to put the blame of the idiots in the west and the corrupt officers of the east solely on Pakistan Madrassas.
Yes meaning they splintered off
A huge number of members in the talibhan were in fact muhjahedeens who later formed the talibhan
I have sympathy for the people but not the Pakistani government, they have never been civilian led, its always been under a junta.
Don’t worry, even pakistani people don’t have sympathy for Pakistani government
You are wasting ur sympathy 😂.. pakistani civilians are same .. they'll support anyone sharing their beliefs and someone fighting west😂
Pakistan & Bangladesh exist because Indian Muslims from Punjab, Bengal, Gujarat, Bihar, Lucknow/Hyderabadi etc didn't want to live with the Indian Hindus & Sikhs & Jains & Buddhists etc. These are the fruits of their hatred for the Kafirs.
Pakistan will split into four countries in future. Balochistan and Sindh for sure. They mind in India's business too much that they forgot how their own mechanism is functioning.
Source: wion 😂
LOL 😂
@@PakistaniConservativeSocialisthe's not wrong
@aarthirajaraman7453 you guys have been saying stuff like that for 80 years now and been wrong every time 😂 the truth is, China will free Assam soon, and we will free Kashmir The rest will happen on its own
@@PakistaniConservativeSocialist. The video is telling who’s in problem 😹😹😹🤲🏻
There are rumors circulating by netizens that Pakistan may try to take Wakhan corridor.
That'll be pretty nice actually, the indosphere and russophere would touch again after a century
@SharanyoDutta-h4pthat means, help from Tajikistan to invade
Their official had met already
The one thing the British didnt want to happen
@SharanyoDutta-h4p My Hindu son. Pakistan would share a border with Tajikistan as a result. What spheres are you talking about?
@@cuteorpyarahamza ah but Pakistan is still in the Indian sphere of influence no. We still exert great cultural influence. And we could've had political influence too if it weren't for the nukes. Honestly wait a few decades till another Subhas or Indira comes to power and then you'll see what spheres I'm talking about
To quote a former Israeli Prime Minister “We wish the best of luck to both sides”
Not really. It helps Iran get a grip on both of them.
@@user-sh3cf7kd6e I think it would be more likely to help India get a better grip
@user-sh3cf7kd6e if Iran wants to spend what little money it has in trying to get "control" of Afghanistan let them. It will all go to waste.
Pakistan seems to have learnt nothing from recent history: you do NOT invade Afghanistan.
Two major military powers tried, and both got kicked out in shame.
the state cant control the military in pakistan, it's like they are completely seperate
Actually Pakistan is the only one to win against Afghanistan in recent history, during the time Afghanistan invaded in the early 60s, No you do invade Afghanistan, what you dont do it occupy it for multiple decades and accept surrender by you enemy when you can. Both russia and the US had refused t cut their loses early and this is what it resulted in
pakistan doesnt dare to invade Afghanistan. it's only propaganda
@@memeconsumer773LoL pakistan never won a war and it's region stood under Afghan rule for centuries
Pak army would fare much better at an Afghani invasion tbh. They have fairly similar weather and landscapes, much better for the soldiers to endure, whereas soviets and the US military were from another continent, different climate and landscape.
Pakistan thought that their former ally would come together again but that backfired.
They were warned not to support the group but ignored, now they reap what they sowed.
FYI, the ‘ch’ in ‘baloch’ and ‘balochistan’ is pronounced like the ‘ch’ in ‘channel’
Pakistan complaining that the Taliban are providing safe harbor for terrorist is one of the greatest instances of sweet irony that i have ever heard of.
The great irony here is that for the longest time Pakistan was underhandedly funding the Taliban, seems like karma caught up to them.
Pakistan when a british line gives india kashmir: REEEEE BRITISH COLONIALISM ARBITRARY LINES
Pakistan when a british drawn line gives pakistan pashtun land: this is good
British never gave India Kashmir
@@masterkhan06you are right, kashmir's king gave kashmir to india. finally you admit the truth 😅
@@djokonole-j6vthe king that lost most of Kashmir to its people and had no legitimacy whatsoever? That agreement holds as much weight as salt holds water.
What are Brits doing in Asia?? oh wait you're telling me they are also in Africa? and the middle east? why don't you stay in Europe and leave the rest of the world in peace?
@@shujah9746 really ? if he had lost the people, then when pakistan's forces went into kashmir to supposedly "liberate" them, why did they start supporting the sikh regiment ?
just one regiment of india pushed back pak's forces aswell as majority of kashmir population. right, makes absolute sense. 😅
btw not only the king, but sheikh abdullah also, who was the main opposition also supported india. I have no idea who these so called 'people' are who you talk about. folklore maybe ?
Every Country in the world has an Army. But Pakistani Army has a country.
They wanted to befriend the taliban during America’s war? This is what they get.
What did they get?
India watching from the side: ☕☕
P@jeet thinks he's cool👶🏾
the tea is fantastic isn't it panjeet?
Why mad when India is just chilling plus ain’t that you ? Awh so cute
The one you can’t afford ? Hmmm how is the 93k donation ?
@Soul_King_Aizen Yes, it is 🐖
Rudyard Kipling once wrote a poem “the Ballad of East and West” about this area of the Pakistan/Afghanistan border (back then Pakistan was part of British India). It’s one of my favorite poems…
"UNDIVIDED INDIA"
When Pakistan is worse than the Taliban
You don't know basic geopolitics kid
lovely kurdistan flag left half pfp
You don't know kid how Pakistan is worse@@cyberverse9141
Kurdistan is and will remain a dream
@@abdulmohid3519delusional. In 20 years both balochistan and kurdistan will be free
To all those saying Pakistan should have not supported Taliban are vastly underestimating the situation.Pakistan's biggest mistake was not supporting the Taliban but supporting the US in 2001 and allowing them to attack Afganistan due to this many of the Taliban fled towards Kyber region of Pakistan and found refuge but not from Pakistan but from the mountains .You see unlike the US which could use drones to safely fight the Taliban Pakistan could not do this and a ground fight with the Taliban and growing insurgents was deadly and as a result fight against insurgents was intially slow it took Pakistan more than a decade to drive out the insurgents from the Kyber region.
Now I will admit Pakistan did support the Taliban to some extent but the comment section is acting like the taliban had full support from Pakistan which they did not.
I urge you all to learn and study this conflict deeply and see both perspectives of the war.
Pakistan should never have supported America and this war destroyed Pakistan more than it benefitted it.America recived full support from Pakistan in this war they allowed American troops a passage into afganistan and often allowed them to fire ballistic missiles into afganistan off which many would fall into Pakistani areas and hurt the local people.
True 🙌
@@SomeGoatedPersonisi and pakistan army literally trained talibani fighters😪
@@HimanshuMahajan-zn3nq but not the TTP
Pakistan: we’ve supported you and kept you alive for over 20 years. Now be our puppet.
Taliban: Nah
Next: USA invades Greenland. 😐 It's a crazy world we live in.
Basically it's not going to happen, do you really believe what Trump said?
Nah that's a joke. The US doesn't have casus belli against Greenland and an annexation will be almost universally condemned. So ain't ever happening unless the US actually becomes a dictatorship. Remember such an action will even be unpopular among Americans
It’s not an invasion… he literally offered to buy Greenland and it’s ultimately up to them to decide if they want to break away from Denmark and join with the U.S. an invasion will result military action which there’s none
@@coffeelink943he said he would use military force
@@coffeelink943u fool. He said military intervention is not off the table
"Oh no! The terrorist organizations we let lay in our lands is now causing us problems. Who could have foreseen this happening?"
As an Indian... I hope we don't get involved (probably won't)
If Pakistan equips Bangladesh with Abdali missiles then India will have to equip Taliban with weapons.
@@Nonamejhsja And then all three of them would play Ghazwa e Hind with India
@@Nonamejhsja India has already equipped them with weapons. Also India will get Involve because of Wakhan.
@@cuteorpyarahamza Who needs Ghazwat al-Hind when the Hindus are destroying their own image with all of their street shitting and scam calling.
@@NonamejhsjaChina from LAC say Hi men. 👋
2 ones of poorest countries in the world going to war that’s sad
Rich by money,poor by heart
There are many African countries which are poorest of the poorest but they don't start a war
And 2 most inbred 😂
You'll be called Indian/gay American for saying this🤬😡
@@tacossergiobella8736for people to care you must have value or important strategic position . Pakistan and Afghanistan,regardless of how poor or messed up they are both have that . Those poor african countries doesn't have that ,it is that simple ,unless they have resources , that's the only thing they have that majority of the world is intersted in .
@@tacossergiobella8736 Do you ever study AFRICAN HISTORY?? 😵💫😵💫
My Fellow Indians
Who wants 🍿🍿
It's not hindu culture to enjoy others sufferings.
pay 28% gst😂
I'll be having that, thanks! 🍿🍿
@OfficialUKGov wese to 80 crore log bhookay hein India mein chalo emoji hi kha lo
We ain't be paying 18% tax 😂😂
02:40 Demographics - If Ethnicities like Sindh, Balochistan and Pashtunustan reject Pakistan, and Brown is Punjabis, than means only half of Brown on the left of India is actual Pakistan.
Classic example of FAFO !
As the old saying goes, you can not keep snakes in your back yard and expect them to bite only your neighbours.
Meanwhile Burma is eyeing territories of Bangladesh
Hasn't there been a civil war going on in Burma for decades? It looks like the Burmese government has enough trouble keeping control over Burmese territory.
Didn't expect the comment section to be this based! Even the "good Taliban" turned bad for them lmao
MEME
The Taliban were not part of the war against the Soviet Union. They were the refugee children from the nearly 20 year civil war that followed. They grew up in Pakistan and were educated in the Madrasas. They didn’t exist until nearly 20 years after war with the Soviet Union.
Doesn't change anything. They were influenced by the Soviet war, thus became refugees. The US has always been at fault, be it the middle east or South Asia
A lot of idi*ts who scream "THE US SUPPORTED THEM AGAINST THE USSR ZOMG" don't seem to realize this.
Crazy
@@polishherowitoldpilecki5521 What’s crazy?
Pakistan is govern by corrupted army generals. They only care for their own pocket. They're allies of USA.
So the lesson is that no matter what, Pakistan will never have good relations with Afghanistan’s actual government
Shame really, Pakistans biggest motivator for its involvement in all 4 wars in Afghanistan was to convince them to just accept the border, but yet we're still at square one
😂
Pak thought they got a "Strategic Depth" in Afghanistan while the only thing which they got was "Tragic death"
Abhinandan 🩳😂🤣😂😂
@@SamHollandSamHolland 93000 xD
@Jewishpatriot1 Abhinandan 🩳 dhinka Chika Dhinka Chika AAAAA Aaa
The graveyard of empires will claim another trophy.
lmao only idiots think that Afghanistan has been invaded many times
I wonder who made afghanistan the graveyard of empires
@@bangg_bhai420Muslims
That is a myth
Graveyard of Afghans**
"Pakistan and Afghanistan might be going to war over each other"
👍 *_India liked this._*
EDIT: Joke's on the angry pakistanis in the replies; this was meant to make fun of everyone, even India. 🙃
I don't think India wants this.
@@cunningfox1798bhaijan, economy ... If Afghanistan brother wants aid, take it...
If want medication help, take it ...
We will take our land peacefully with no war ?.?
@@cunningfox1798 you clearly don't know the history between India and Pakistan.
@@cunningfox1798 india is friendly with taliban and was friendly with last government too . India also give food aid to Afghanistan so India have not much to lose only way india be threatened if pakistan take kabul and somehow install another government who is anti india . And chances of that are ..
Pajet
Pakistani government reaped what they sowed. Hard to be surprise.
Wow... Shocker. If only they had this warning years prior..
How are Pakistanis able to deport 500k Afghans in a year but we supposedly can't deport any?
The US has deported more people than 500k
Yeah, pakistan doesn't has a reason to, pakistan promised to return them once the war and bombing ended. pakistan is simply following its contract.
Because the so called leaders of the west are incompetent cowards
The UN, charities and pressure groups don’t bother criticising non western governments
Pakistan is govern by corrupted army generals. They only care for their own pocket. They're allies of USA.
The Taliban are not unpopular and incompetent, as you say.
Everyone there needs to just chill out and relax a bit. All this tension is bad for your skin.
Most of Pakistan's land is the traditional lands of Iranic tribes who are essentially ruled by Muslim Indians in the southeast of the country. Afghanistan, Iran, and India should work together to liberate the Iranic tribal lands. Its a big win for everyone.
One of the biggest problems here was that Western powers drew the borders 100 years ago without considering the ethnic and religious roots of the region, and today these problems are not only occurring between Pakistan and Afghanistan. The same scenario exists throughout the Middle East.
Well, if the had considered the ethnic and religious factors, they would have had to divide the Middle East into hundreds of states, some of which not bigger than a single village. I am sure that would not have made it more peaceful.
Natural boarders are built on geography, the colonials didn’t build it based on geography. As an example at 2:40 in the video all the ethnic groups want to seperate apart from the brown coloured one. Compare that to the geographic landscape. The seperate ethnic groups Pink/Yellow/Green are naturally divided by mountains and desert but the brown coloured part has direct access to places like Kashmir/india and thus similar culture. This was not followed, causing the issue. Same stuff in india where you have things like Khalistan and eastern/southern part considering themselves distinct from the northern part
@@cuddlywuddlybear "Natural boarders are built on geography,"
Not always, not even in Europe. The Pyrenees are for instance a geographic boundary between Spain and France, but there is no such border between Spain and Portugal. And you could drive all the way from Amsterdam to Moscow without encountering natural borders.
That was deliberate.. as it is easy to control unstable countries and their government
Oh no! Whoever could have seen this coming from a mile away!
Weren't they celebrating taliban victory some time back ?
Governments changed, so did the ISI chief. Therefore their policy changed quickly
Actually they were celebrating USA's exit from Afghanistan 😂
Jammu and kashmir is integral part of india ✅
not pakistan ❌
Toyota is ready to make some easy money😂
You should’ve titled this “Afghanistan vs Pakistan”. Also to quote Ishiro Serizawa, “let them fight”.
May Both sides aim be true.
The fact that there’s more Pashtuns in Pakistan than Afghanistan
Even if there was just one Muslim left on the planet his left hand would still be fighting his right foot😅
Not about muslims. Pakistan and Afghanistan have never gotten along. not during the Secular afghan kingdom and governments or Islamic. If it was a muslim problem how come just across the Persian gulf there are Muslim countries more modern and successful at the current times then most secular states?
Tbh, as much as hate to admit it, you're right.
Sectarianism and takfirism is rife in the Ummah
@ozone1894 Oil is why
Also it's funny you call them "modern" when none of those countries are safe for LGBT people
Not exactly known as a smart bunch of people😂
@ozone1894Those countries have vast oil reserves.
Just imagine
If taliban tries to sabotage the Upcoming cricket champions trophy about to held at Pakistan 💀
I guess instead of people we will be hearing crickets
That's why indian cricket team is not going pakistan 💀
So the religion of peace is at it again, between brothers, interesting
edit: this comment it's ragebait btw
it's not ragebait, it's just accurate
it's because of the dirty politics and power games.
ME has a serious case of “splitters“, different factions fighting amongst each other. Not surprising, given the religious and resource circumstances. They may all be “Muslim“, but it‘s not difficult to find a faction that claims it‘s “true“ Islam, while other Muslim factions are not true to Islam. Remember, a heretic is someone who *almost* shares the same beliefs as you do! :/
no it's clearly because that british guy is bad at drawing, they should've let the japanese draw
Talking about Christianity, Ukraine and Russian peace or Ireland and N.Ireland peace?
You guys said nothing about the attacks on Chinese workers and teachers as well.
pretty much reporting that the sky is blue or grass is green
It's like when the nerds used to fight back in my school days. 😂
Not funny at all bish
1:40 how about using a UN designated map instead of showing whole J&K as disputed?
Even Islamabad is marked as disputed, which obviously can just be wrong.
Its not pronounced Balock bro💀
It’s Baluç
I was about to comment the same thing. It’s Baloch (च) at the end.
This pretty much tells u how little they know about this issue.
@@IAjayMukhiyathat’s how you find out who is a propagandist
@@IAjayMukhiya Balochi zaanay tao?
@IAjayMukhiya Rubbish. You can't expect them to know how to pronounce every single place name on the planet.
I live in Australia and the vast majority of English speaking videos mispronounce our capital. But that doesn't automatically mean the underlying information in the vid is wrong.
Afghanistan has the right to defend itself
countries like Britain, USSR, USA have tried to occupy Afghanistan and failed miserably, Paid heavy price... No way Pakistan can occupy Afghanistan
Difference is that Pakistan is a superpower with 7th gen F-ALLAH unlike those countries
@ unfortunately common man in Pakistan is suffering from very high inflation, poverty, unemployment but Pakistan is buying 5 th generation jets from china…
What the occupying part was the easy part. The forming a modern centralized government was the impossible part. Afghanistan has never had a strong central government even back when it was a kingdom. I don’t know why the us and ussr though they could impose something that never existed in that area.
Pakistan can occupy it because they have more ethnic pushtuns than there are in their own homeland
@@Estonado 3 thousand black jets of allah
Peaceful vs peaceful🤔
"The taliban is incompetent" well so is Pakistan so not much difference there.
One word. Religion.
Peace vs peace =master peace
Benjamin Netanyahu, Xi Jing Ping and Trump are the most famous influential i would say. There are others but not really famous
He said that the Taliban is 'obviously unpopular and incompetent' (7:34) is there any truth to that assertion?
Unpopular and incompetent can be said about almost any government in the world, its almost meaningless to say
@@beuyhs1000 Hmm. Looking in, it seems like the Taliban are popular enough... as for competency, I suppose it takes time to build institutions for good governance..
@@RedSoloCuppppp I mean banning women from speaking can't be too popular I assume
@@RedSoloCupppppthey're unpopular bcz of food security in Afghanistan ever since USA invasion population of Afghanistan is ballooned it's virtually impossible to feed all of them without some high tech agri like Israel or china use or buy it from outside but to buy u need foreign cash reserves or foreign aid and taliban is isolated. Bad situation really
@ That would cause the government to be unpopular. I wonder if the people blame the Taliban for it or western forces.. or even both
In a proper, conventional war Pakistan would win. However, Taliban won't fight conventionally, as they take advantage of mountainous terrain and fight guerilla style. Pakistan will, most likely, attack key objectives of Taliban and retreat, taking advantage of their clear air superiority. Hard to imagine either side winning a decisive victory in this war
Isn't it same case with India and pakisthan
Why would Taliban fight in a fashion that limits their chance of victory? Most probable case imo is a wide scale revolt in Pakistan's Pashtun region. They are not great fan of Islamabad government any way.
most of the Pakistani military is trained in the mountainous area of kashmir
Pakistan did same...by sending mujahideen to indian kashmir and not fighting a conventional war.
@@puneetmishra4726 Because that can back fire too, one reason for their hostility towards Pakistan is that would unite most of the non Pashtun population who dont like the Taliban, but a unconventional war on both sides would lead them to revolt just like the Taliban once did Also one must keep in mind that most Pashtuns love Pakistan, they dont like the current goverment there is a difference and with Pakistani Pashtuns alone being more than Afghani pashtuns, that says something
The title: WHOAA!!! WHO'VE WOULD'VE GUESSED!?!? WOWIE!!
Who'd have thought the Taliban would turn out to be untrustworthy?
i remember when they used to support the Taliban against the usa .... now they are fighting each other i see this as a huge w for all 2 Islamist states doing everyone a favor by decreasing each other.
hope the best of the beluch .
neighbouring cow country man here?
To be honest, I prefer the old intro, this one is too...different....
who cares
Pakistan actually falling for the oldest trick in the book is ridiculous lmao
the new tldr intro gave a new aura to this videos congrats
as a indian our government literally prepare for something very interesting 😏👍
Wish you good luck Abhinandan 🩳
People accuse pakistan of supporting taliban, not knowing that the Pakistani state has no control over its own military or intelligence services
That is true, but aren't the members of the armed forces Pakistanis as well?
Pakistan when a state based on radical religious fascism fails: 🤯🤯🤯
The only stable countries in South Asia are the secular ones.
@isaacjude91 pakistan is probably the best example for Deep State.
And almost every corrupt official in every country is a national, so what's the point?
The Pakistani military IS the Pakistani state. They decide who to go to war with, what businesses will be allowed to run, who the prime minister will be. Everything. Pakistanis call their army the "establishment", because it's the only stable establishment or organisation in that country.
@@isaacjude91 Pakistan is probably the best example for the deep state.
Being a national doesn't make you obey your authorities, if that's new to you.
You need a chain or faith in authority to hold your supposed subordinates.
Plus, corruption is a good way for nothing to work properly.