Migration Crisis on the Polish Border | ARTE.tv Documentary

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 141

  • @artetvdocumentary
    @artetvdocumentary  Місяць тому +2

    Watch next 📺 Croatia: Re-establishing borders
    The principle of freedom of movement between member states is enshrined in European Union law, but are border controls making a comeback within the bloc? That seems to be the case, at least in practice, in some parts of the continent. Eight member states have reintroduced border checks, citing an increase in the number of migrants and the threat of terrorism.
    Find out more 👉ua-cam.com/video/JHGDgxVX2t0/v-deo.html

  • @kittylor-e5s
    @kittylor-e5s Місяць тому +130

    There are immigration laws, which each person in the country should abide to. Refuges cannot exist above the laws. Crossing the border illegally is a crime and should be prosecuted.

    • @piotrwojdelko1150
      @piotrwojdelko1150 Місяць тому +1

      there are procedures and Polish people don't know how to behave ,because such a problem with migration has never been before .Experience from soviet Union was very cruel for such type of crime ,many years in prison for attempting it

    • @kolokowalsky772
      @kolokowalsky772 Місяць тому +5

      Refugees have a different legal definition, Egypt is a free country.

    • @eliaskuru3289
      @eliaskuru3289 Місяць тому +1

      Bull shit

    • @kolokowalsky772
      @kolokowalsky772 Місяць тому +3

      @@eliaskuru3289 Are you illegal yourself?

    • @Lexus3377
      @Lexus3377 Місяць тому

      Unless you are white.

  • @kristafluit3042
    @kristafluit3042 Місяць тому +29

    I'm sure Putin loves us blaming the Polish authorities for his despicable actions

  • @FabStream-y5t
    @FabStream-y5t Місяць тому +75

    Why isn't that Polish lady helping migrants find work and housing in Belarus?

    • @kolakpatolik1857
      @kolakpatolik1857 Місяць тому +4

      Humm, maybe because she's Polish, and she lives in Poland, genius?

    • @sharrablackfire7337
      @sharrablackfire7337 Місяць тому

      @@kolakpatolik1857 these people and their antagonistic garbage comments, don't pay them any heed. I'm a Texan and border walls do nothing but harm, the world has not learned from Texas' mistakes, or they simply do not care because the cruelty is the point

    • @nostro1940
      @nostro1940 Місяць тому +5

      ​@@kolakpatolik1857it's impossible to be Polish in Belarus?

    • @yakp1p
      @yakp1p Місяць тому

      Because polish minority in Belarus is being prosecuted

    • @Princessdream-p9k
      @Princessdream-p9k Місяць тому +2

      ​@@kolakpatolik1857 😂 But if she want to help migrants so much. The safest way is helping them in Belarus. Polish can travel to Belarus from time to time.....

  • @iXmovie
    @iXmovie Місяць тому +28

    Here it goes again: the same type of people always helping immigrants. They have a similar look-nose piercings, unusual body piercings, dyed hair, no makeup. They appear feminist, far-left, and physically weak, not “alpha.” They seem to be a group rejected by mainstream society but are always at the forefront of helping others. They show so much empathy that they often end up being used by the very people they’re trying to help and never seem to learn from it.

    • @JDM_000
      @JDM_000 5 днів тому

      Great observation!
      Respect

  • @cankirsehirli
    @cankirsehirli Місяць тому +22

    You can not say that fence is not stopping migrants. You need to share the statistics over the issue.
    Do you have the numbers shared by the border police and independent sources?

  • @LS-Moto
    @LS-Moto Місяць тому +9

    16:00 I don't think the fence is expected to prevent 100% of the migrants from crossing. It serves more as a barrier, so that the authorities don't get run over by huge flocks of migrants they essentially can't handle. So its more to slow down migration and that the authorities can remain in control of the situation, including the number of those who crossed the border. At least that's how I think the fence is thought of strategically.

    • @kroldoge2218
      @kroldoge2218 20 днів тому +1

      Its a way to stop or slow groups from crossing, and give authorities time to react. There is nothing to stop in 100% people from crossing, beacuse it can be cutted etc, but it really slow them so service can react before they enter/stop them fast

  • @nostro1940
    @nostro1940 Місяць тому +16

    Belarus is a safe country

    • @soprotivleniye7620
      @soprotivleniye7620 Місяць тому +1

      No, it is not. I am Belarusian and I am an asylee myself.

    • @nostro1940
      @nostro1940 Місяць тому

      @soprotivleniye7620 it's a safe country otherwise people wouldn't risk going there. Disgusting fake asylum abusers

    • @Aleks96
      @Aleks96 Місяць тому +3

      ​@@soprotivleniye7620 Belarus is safe if you don't say anything against Lukashenko.
      There is no war there and these migrants came to Belarus voluntarily.

  • @Nostrama
    @Nostrama Місяць тому +18

    Follow the law, apply for visa

  • @szczepionzabijaka8476
    @szczepionzabijaka8476 Місяць тому +31

    Nie ma kryzysu migracyjnego jest kryzys przemytników powiązanych z fundacją Batorego

    • @szczepionzabijaka8476
      @szczepionzabijaka8476 Місяць тому +1

      @francismcdonnell8149 What exactly do you have in mind? That I think smuggling illegal immigrants is a crime?What EU rights did I get enlighten me because I only see more orders and restrictions

    • @tatra25
      @tatra25 Місяць тому +3

      ​@@francismcdonnell8149 Common sense and national security is above all EU "rights" and all EU countries behave like that, so stop shaming polish citizens for protecting our country from hybryd warfare. Hope your country respects ALL European standards, I bet it doesn't....

    • @barbararadon4796
      @barbararadon4796 Місяць тому

      I rządowych biurokratów wspierających grupy pomocowe na granicy.

  • @shazzshank6393
    @shazzshank6393 Місяць тому +36

    WE HAVE NEVER HAD ANY COLONIES SO IF YOU HAVE A PROBLEM GO TO NETHERLANDS, GERMANY, FRANCE, ENGLAND AND LEAVE US ALONE ! STOP THE BLACKMAILING !

    • @AlphamanKing
      @AlphamanKing Місяць тому +1

      They're just using poland as a crossing in order to get to Germany and other rich countries, so stop over estimating yourself, polish dude. You're not a prime destination, neither wealthy.

    • @shazzshank6393
      @shazzshank6393 Місяць тому +8

      @@AlphamanKing "over estimating yourself" said a guy that's not even white lol

    • @shazzshank6393
      @shazzshank6393 Місяць тому

      @@AlphamanKing Oh on the side note do you think they want them in Germany ? Not really lol no one wants you here or there, and I know my value so no ni*** like you will bring me down :) and my country is much wealthier than your shi---- hole

    • @shazzshank6393
      @shazzshank6393 Місяць тому +4

      @@AlphamanKing oh btw do you know how many germans, english, spanish moves to Poland ? MANY why ? because of you !

    • @shazzshank6393
      @shazzshank6393 Місяць тому +2

      @@AlphamanKing You are not even considered human basically anywhere in the world yet you yap here your bs pfff typical.

  • @barbararadon4796
    @barbararadon4796 Місяць тому +8

    Przemyt ludzi przy pomocy polskich organizacji opłacanych przez światowych awanturników, NGOsy i urzędników państwowych. Czego pani uczy dzieci? To są nielegalni nachodzący.

  • @Aleks96
    @Aleks96 Місяць тому +6

    Migrants not "Refuges"!

  • @shchenka5973
    @shchenka5973 Місяць тому +6

    The translation from Polish is completely off in this video :(

  • @dawidskok8870
    @dawidskok8870 Місяць тому +9

    Pieprzyć tych lewicowych aktywistów!!! Niech otworzą swoje domy...ciekaw jestem co wtedy?!!!

    • @sharrablackfire7337
      @sharrablackfire7337 Місяць тому

      By aiming your hatred at the asylum seekers, you are the pawn of Russia. Russia is telling you to hate them instead of focusing on the real problems, and here you are, dancing to their tune

    • @ekkolima
      @ekkolima Місяць тому

      I agree with you and I think that if these Western countries would stop meddling and looting in these 3rd world economies, then there'd be no crisis on your border.
      Also, my parents 🇹🇹 legally immigrated to America 40 years ago. The government didn't give my parents free shit back then and they became productive members of American society, LEGALLY!
      This illegal migration is a big slap in my face. Wheres my free shit at, 🤣..? Same bullshit on our Southern border.
      Leftists and illegals can exit our countries and live together!
      Make America and Poland great again! May the Left burn in hell, Amen!

    • @ekkolima
      @ekkolima Місяць тому

      Agreed. No more lefties! I'm a son of legal immigrants to America. This illegal nonsense is a slap in my face.
      If my parents didn't get free stuff, then neither should they.

    • @LS-Moto
      @LS-Moto Місяць тому

      @@sharrablackfire7337 You do know that Russia and Belarus are mobilizing these people, right? And they force them towards the border, not allowing them to retreat back into Belarus, essentially making them stuck in no mans land. And you are now telling me that Russia tells us to hate these people as a distraction of something, when in fact, they are the very root of this problem? Btw. Russia isn't just a problem for us with that, they are also a problem for the very people they are sending as migrants, putting them into these bear grills situations and isolating them there, with false promises of course.

  • @MartinSnow-lk1pc
    @MartinSnow-lk1pc Місяць тому +4

    Free border activists expressing concerns about a physical border, who would have thought. Design wall less climbable, to reduce risk of people trying and injuring themselves

  • @zawiszaczarny7876
    @zawiszaczarny7876 Місяць тому +6

    Running in the woods with human traffickers that help criminals break into the country, qute...

  • @terjeoseberg990
    @terjeoseberg990 2 дні тому

    Why don’t they stay in Belarus?

  • @KlavsLiepins
    @KlavsLiepins День тому

    And this polish biologist is also traitor of the nation.

  • @nostro1940
    @nostro1940 Місяць тому +1

    Land (ines) work amazing

  • @Sylviakw
    @Sylviakw Місяць тому +1

    Wygląda to na jakiś francusko xxxx piknik .

  • @JDM_000
    @JDM_000 5 днів тому

    Typical french documentary.
    That animal guy should change his job.
    This is not about animals, it's about the safety of your country

  • @dionysos3146
    @dionysos3146 11 днів тому

    Europe need someone's like trump to fix the borders.

  • @robheilmann3339
    @robheilmann3339 Місяць тому +4

    Why's is the first guy speaking fluent french???? Refuge and immigration are two different things. One person needs to the other wants to .....
    lack of prospects is a personal thinking and not a reason like refuge.....

  • @fredteff2078
    @fredteff2078 Місяць тому +2

    Arte une des meilleures chaînes de la tnt

  • @mikeohandley1922
    @mikeohandley1922 Місяць тому +7

    Immigrant candidates coming to free western countries should all be asked by immigration authorities the following questions and should be required to sign a document affirming their answers:
    1. "Do you believe that if someone drinks alcohol that is his/her own business, not yours?"
    2. ""Do you believe that every person of every other religion has just as much right to exist as yourself and should never be harassed?"
    3. "Do you believe that women are equal to men and should have all the same privileges as men, and do you agree that while you are in this country this country's laws concerning the age of consent and the age of majority prevail over any norms of your own culture, and that forcing any female into sex against her will is rape and should be punished severely under the law?
    4. "Do you agree that if a woman in this culture wants to go around with her head uncovered or her arms or legs revealed that she has a right to do so and to the extent our law allows her to, and that any punishment exacted in this land, is the business of the state and none of your business?"
    5. "Do you believe that, if someone of your own religion, if you have one, wants to leave that religion and join another religion, or become an Atheist, Agnostic, or Deist, that he or she is free to do so and should not be molested or harmed by anyone for that decision?"
    6. "Do you agree that, since one of our customs is freedom of speech, everyone here should be allowed to draw pictures of whatever they want, or say whatever they want to say, within the limits of OUR law, even if it offends yourself or someone else or someone's religion, and that they should never be molested or harmed for doing so?"
    7. "Will you agree that, if you ever are caught supporting terrorism by speech or by action that you will allow yourself to be unceremoniously deported back to your country of origin; and, even if you'd attained citizenship in this country since arriving, to give up that citizenship voluntarily and leave?"
    8. "Do you agree that if you are ever convicted of committing violence of any sort during a protest that you will immediately give up your citizenship here, or your visa allowing you to stay, and can be immediately deported back to your country of origin without a trial?"
    9. "Do you agree that this country owes you nothing and that you'll have to work to earn a living here and that, if after the first thirty days, you don't have a job, you will no longer accept public assistance, and that, if you fail to find a job within six months, you will voluntarily leave the country and return to your country of origin or go to another country?
    10. "Do you agree that Jews have just as much right to exist as people of any other religion, including Muslims, and that should you ever be caught denying those of another religion, or Atheists, Agnostics, Deists or Jews their rights, or Israel's right to exist, that you will allow yourself to be deported to your country of origin without a trial?"
    11. "Do you agree to abide by all laws of this country while you are here, and to respect the customs and traditions of all other religions present here?"
    12. "Do you agree that this country's laws take precedent and that, even if this country's laws conflict with those laws which you are used to, this country's laws always apply while you are here?"
    Those who answer Yes to all twelve points above would go to Line 1 and be granted asylum until their country of origin is stable, after which they would be deported to their country of origin or a country of their choosing, unless they've applied for citizenship, sworn an oath to abide by these laws and customs and have not violated any laws of this country.
    Those who answer No to any one of the twelve points above would go to Line 2 and be immediately bussed to the nearest embarkation point and be deported to their country of origin and forbidden to ever return.
    If anyone deported ever returns and unlawfully enters the country, and is convicted of unlawfully entering the country, he or she should automatically earn a ten-year prison sentence without parole or time off for good behavior.
    Key to this, whether here temporarily for asylum or here as a new citizen, will be the requirement to swear an oath of allegiance that includes all of these points. ANY violation of that oath, even one so simple, as verbally harassing someone because their customs are different than one's own, once reported to the authorities, will require the violators deportation to their country of origin upon a guilty plea or finding of guilty in a court of law.

  • @thewanderinghermit7609
    @thewanderinghermit7609 Місяць тому +4

    No Borders

    • @wuuduu609
      @wuuduu609 Місяць тому +1

      go home

    • @zawiszaczarny7876
      @zawiszaczarny7876 Місяць тому

      Borders exist, law exists, and dumb little twats like yourself also exist...

    • @cherylk.2474
      @cherylk.2474 Місяць тому +8

      No borders for your home or country if you wish, but the rest of us choose to have borders.

    • @tatra25
      @tatra25 Місяць тому

      Yes, no doors to your home, car, family- live like that, share your property with agressive, demanding people from desert. We in Poland won't do that. Don't like it? Go and live in suburbs of uk cities or other no go zones...

    • @constantin4317
      @constantin4317 Місяць тому +5

      How would Palestine exist without borders?

  • @Znation27
    @Znation27 Місяць тому +5

    it is so shameful a country in Europe is doing such kind of things to migrants!

    • @shazzshank6393
      @shazzshank6393 Місяць тому +32

      Ok mohammed, take them to your home. good bye

    • @shazzshank6393
      @shazzshank6393 Місяць тому

      I bet you ain't even white... how's lebanon, gaza ?haahahahahahahaha

    • @shazzshank6393
      @shazzshank6393 Місяць тому +17

      how many migrants do you take ? ahh ethopian haaha

    • @Adam_Malcher
      @Adam_Malcher Місяць тому +29

      Well sir, hate to tell that to you but in every normal country illegal border crossing meets consequences. May be in your country no one gives a damn who and how is passing the border but trust me they (Poles) care.

    • @lietuvaitelietuvos3650
      @lietuvaitelietuvos3650 Місяць тому +13

      A very one sided video. Border certainly works and keeps Poland safe. All these 3 people look from their own perspective, not from the perspective of their country.
      It isn't Polish people who bring migrants there. Migrants come to Europe with their own agenda. I wonder how Africa or Middle East would react if Europeans start coming in huge numbers to their countries?? Europe can't take in the whole world and it is overpopulated already. As for animals, they are very good at adapting.

  • @soprotivleniye7620
    @soprotivleniye7620 Місяць тому

    Anna, thank you very much for helping these poor people. What Lukashenko is doing is outrageous but what the Polish authorities are doing is also outrageous: these asylum-seekers have the right to due process, the Polish border guards are obligated under the UN Convention on the Status of Refugees to accept and review their asylum applications. They DO NOT have the right to push people back to Belarus. I do not understand how they can stand and watch through that fence people dying of cold and hunger in the forest.
    Also, there was a Polish border guard who fled to Belarus and claimed that Polish border guards had been killing asylum-seekers and burying them in the forest. I am not 100 percent sure that he was telling the truth but it does seem plausible to me.
    The Polish authorities should do more to depose Lukashenko and thus get to the root cause of the problem instead of building fences and brutalizing the asylum-seekers.

    • @tatra25
      @tatra25 Місяць тому +1

      Come on stop that bullshit. We dont want to pay a price for acts of hybrid war against us. There are ways of legal immigration to our country. Many people use them. World has dramaticall changed. Have you noticed? War is coming to us but peopleike you prefer to live in the illusion and by helping illegal, agressive immigrants to improve your self estime. Your time is over, luckilly.

    • @tubaeseries5705
      @tubaeseries5705 Місяць тому +2

      these people are not applying for asylum

    • @soprotivleniye7620
      @soprotivleniye7620 Місяць тому

      @tubaeseries5705 Yes, they are.

    • @tubaeseries5705
      @tubaeseries5705 Місяць тому

      @@soprotivleniye7620 no they aren't, you can't apply for asylum in the middle of random forest while throwing stones and spears, you do it at a border checkpoint

    • @barbararadon4796
      @barbararadon4796 Місяць тому +2

      To są przemytnicy nie Lukaszenko. Przemytnicy mają powiązania z naszymi grupami pomocowymi.