Alan Dershowitz Defends Israel

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 лис 2023
  • Alan Dershowitz joins Noam Dworman, Dan Naturman and Periel Aschenbrand. He has been called 'the nation's most peripatetic civil liberties lawyer' and one of its 'most distinguished defenders of individual rights,' 'the best-known criminal lawyer in the world,' 'the top lawyer of last resort,' and 'America's most public Jewish defender.' He is the author of forty books including seven bestsellers.
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 344

  • @cedat1395
    @cedat1395 6 місяців тому +73

    Dershowitz was never stable; now, he lost his mind.

    • @mmm-mq3zr
      @mmm-mq3zr 6 місяців тому +6

      I had my underwear on!

    • @S_Padival
      @S_Padival 6 місяців тому +4

      Epstein withdrawal system 😅

    • @NG-cf7zh
      @NG-cf7zh 6 місяців тому

      @@S_Padivalhe should go visit his old buddy Jeffery 🪢

  • @awdrpepper
    @awdrpepper 6 місяців тому +116

    Alan Dershowitz also defended Jeffrey Epstein. So there's that.

    • @promark5317
      @promark5317 6 місяців тому +7

      Only the best massages on the super exclusive private island.

    • @smittyjonesthethird
      @smittyjonesthethird 6 місяців тому +5

      You know maybe that's a cheap shot and I didn't want to say anything about his involvement with Epstein, but yeah.

    • @berningid
      @berningid 6 місяців тому +3

      He's a lawyer so yeah that's his profession

    • @MrMoss786
      @MrMoss786 6 місяців тому +4

      He kept his underpants on while getting a massage, poor girl who had to see that

    • @thename273
      @thename273 6 місяців тому

      @@MrMoss786 yet Virgina Guffre said she was wrong about Dershowitz being the one she accused. You only say that because you’re a bigoted anti-Semitic Hamas supporter. So there’s that

  • @slavaboggu
    @slavaboggu 6 місяців тому +68

    Thank you Noam for fortifying my opinion on the brutality of Israel. Keep up the good work with showing the crimes and injustice committed on the Palestinian people.

    • @izzykhach
      @izzykhach 6 місяців тому

      Muslims have killed a million Muslims in Syria, Yemen and Iraq. Have you ever spoken out at their brutality?

    • @c.j.4620
      @c.j.4620 5 місяців тому +1

      The straw has broken the camel's back. Today is December 22, 2023.
      After what we now know, I believe many of these debates and interviews are going to play really badly in the future.
      Israel is committing genocide, and Dershowitz is providing cover.
      Everything about this is a horror.

    • @johnfelman5117
      @johnfelman5117 5 місяців тому

      HAMAS SYMPATHISERS ARE DISGUSTING
      RADICAL LEFT LIES

  • @mtc2054
    @mtc2054 6 місяців тому +77

    Calling Aaron Mate 'A fire breathing supporter of Hamas' is unbelievably disingenuous, while tossing softballs to Alan 'my underwear was on' Dershowitz. You people are jokes.

    • @promark5317
      @promark5317 6 місяців тому

      🤣what was Dershowitz referring to when he said that??

    • @mtc2054
      @mtc2054 6 місяців тому +7

      @@promark5317Explaining the nature of his massages at his client Jeffery Epstein's property -“I kept my underwear on during the massage".

    • @promark5317
      @promark5317 6 місяців тому +1

      @@mtc2054 that is so disgusting lol

    • @cameronpatterson130
      @cameronpatterson130 6 місяців тому +1

      @@promark5317most normal zionist

  • @Ssalamanderr
    @Ssalamanderr 6 місяців тому +80

    I'm glad we can get a perspective on this very important issue from Jeffrey Epstein's best friend.

    • @michaelgj23
      @michaelgj23 6 місяців тому +1

      What the hell happened to all of that? When will the public learn about who Epstein’s clients?

    • @bleonorovitz7837
      @bleonorovitz7837 6 місяців тому +2

      Is that the best you can come up with?

    • @ikke2757
      @ikke2757 6 місяців тому +2

      Don't forget he kept his underwear on while getting his massage!

    • @Ssalamanderr
      @Ssalamanderr 6 місяців тому

      @@bleonorovitz7837 In terms of how much of a scumbag this guy is, being friends with Epstein is pretty much the best evidence yeah. But there's plenty more if you do some research!

    • @bernman23
      @bernman23 6 місяців тому

      @@bleonorovitz7837 Kind of pertinent, since Ari Ben Menashe was an Israeli spy who said he was in on the meetings w/ Epstein & it's a blackmail ring, + Ghislaine's father Robert was an agent for Israel who got a hero's funeral there.

  • @DeeDeeCHAUNCEY
    @DeeDeeCHAUNCEY 6 місяців тому +34

    Lost all respect for Noam seeing how he lets disgusting Dersh spew his lies while interrupted the knowledgeable Aaron Mate ever 2 seconds.

    • @zeuseygastony6385
      @zeuseygastony6385 6 місяців тому +3

      Glad I’m not the only one who noticed this. Dude is better than this

  • @esthefanyortizgutierrez4441
    @esthefanyortizgutierrez4441 6 місяців тому +60

    thanks so much for bringing Dershowitz to your show. Listening to his bullshit and spreading lies and misinformation really helped me cement the view that being pro-Palestine is the right side.

    • @zeuseygastony6385
      @zeuseygastony6385 6 місяців тому +8

      Really though, absolutely despicable, can’t believe this guy was a professor at Harvard and the hosts didn’t question or pushback at all. Who listens to this dude seriously.

    • @esthefanyortizgutierrez4441
      @esthefanyortizgutierrez4441 6 місяців тому +1

      @@zeuseygastony6385 absolutely. A lot of contrast compared to Normal Finkelstein who was super respectful and citing all his sources. The hosts were interrupting him, laughing at him, doing ad hominem attacks, etc.

    • @WintersNstuff
      @WintersNstuff 6 місяців тому

      Its crazy how badly Israel’s defenders are fumbling the PR in this latest ethnic cleansing campaign. Like every advocate just makes them look like bloodthirsty freaks, which they are

  • @Yogesh-jq9jj
    @Yogesh-jq9jj 6 місяців тому +64

    Noam talks about how he doesn't like conspiracy theories, and then goes on to listen to Alan Dershowtiz talking about 'lying doctors' and 'complicit UN' who are literally sacrificing their lives. Noam doesn't push back against this. He didn't let Mate complete a sentence before silencing him in the last podcast.

    • @promark5317
      @promark5317 6 місяців тому +13

      Probably because he is a simpleton who has no business commenting publicly on an ongoing war. The guy is completely out of his depth.

    • @KryMoore
      @KryMoore 6 місяців тому +8

      He is a zealot.

    • @comedycellarclips
      @comedycellarclips  6 місяців тому +5

      I don't usually like to get involved, but this is ridiculous.
      1. These are not conspiracy theories.
      2. I did push back. I said the doctors might fear for their lives.
      3. This: www.timesofisrael.com/uk-doctor-who-worked-at-shifa-confirms-gaza-hospital-used-for-non-medical-purposes/

    • @emilianosintarias7337
      @emilianosintarias7337 6 місяців тому

      but what about none of you pushing back on his kapo conspiracy theory against a late holocaust survivor, norman's mom? it was called a disgusting fabrication and bully move on dersh's part years ago, even by critics of finkelstein,. you couldn't have even asked if "maybe he meant ,did you steal food or not help someone or something", instead just letting Alan claim she helped delete juice, based only on his own imagination? @@comedycellarclips

    • @Yogesh-jq9jj
      @Yogesh-jq9jj 6 місяців тому

      @@comedycellarclips What about the UN being complicit ? Doctors could be actually telling the truth as well. Just because they were scared of Hamas at some point in the past doesn't mean they are always lying. The conspiracy theory part still holds because Dershowitz makes it out as if the entire world is biased against Israel, when in fact Israel is able to get away after killing 14,000 people in Gaza, and the U.S. is still making excuses for it, even when the entire world is against this slaughter.

  • @psingh63
    @psingh63 6 місяців тому +50

    Alan Dershowitz Defends Israel ... but keeps his shorts on. Norman G. Finkelstein wiped the floor with Alan Dershowitz in a debate on Democracy Now.

    • @josephgee143
      @josephgee143 6 місяців тому +6

      ABSOLUTELY!

    • @hassaanawan367
      @hassaanawan367 6 місяців тому +2

      Bravo

    • @balle733
      @balle733 6 місяців тому +1

      No he didn’t. He was lying all through.

    • @josephgee143
      @josephgee143 6 місяців тому +3

      @@balle733
      I thought he was lying but Dershowitz apparently did prove that he left his underwear on.

    • @balle733
      @balle733 6 місяців тому

      @@josephgee143 while your Mum*y fellated him happily

  • @emilianosintarias7337
    @emilianosintarias7337 6 місяців тому +19

    48:17 This guy just called an elderly woman holocaust survivor a n#zi collaborator, based on nothing, and you guys let it slide without comment? He first made up this accusation in FrontPageMagazine, his entire evidence was that Finkelstein wrote in an article that he had asked his mother if she ever did anything she was ashamed of to survive (during the holocaust). Nowhere did she, or he, or any other party or historian, suspect she was a collaborator. For all we know the topic at hand was stealing food. This smear was called a "despicable misrepresentation" by academics and historians at the time, none of which were aligned with Finkelstein.

    • @ADag83
      @ADag83 4 місяці тому +1

      It's a real shame that such a smart man has stained his perceived intellectual integrity in so offhand and petty a way.

  • @amnajavaid4803
    @amnajavaid4803 6 місяців тому +54

    Just notice how Norm hardly interrupts Dershowitz here. Aaron could hardly get a word in before being peppered with counter statements.

    • @alaamini92
      @alaamini92 6 місяців тому +5

      With some bs counter , his ‘’counters” are terrible

  • @platitudeypus
    @platitudeypus 6 місяців тому +15

    What an absolute muddled disingenuous misrepresentation of Aaron Mate and his father. Just lazy and disappointing.

  • @mariq9918
    @mariq9918 6 місяців тому +34

    I watched the encounter Mate instigated.
    In my opinion Mate was polite, quietly spoken, & did ask his single question more than once....3 times I recall
    The Senator advised he thought Mate's approaching him in a quiet carriage on a train was inappropriate. He did not address the question and requested Mate to go and sit quietly somewhere else in the train. Mate did that.....and that was end of filming
    The Senator reportedly then called the Train Officer...and requested Mate be removed from the train..which wasb done
    Mate's question was "would the Senator support a Ceasefire for Israel & Gaza?"
    I have held public office for 10 years. I am approached by citizens, and listen then arrange a time to meet & chat. Easy

    • @DrAnac-qh5dc
      @DrAnac-qh5dc 6 місяців тому

      LOL you've never held an elected office in your life.

  • @JoeG.-wl3js
    @JoeG.-wl3js 6 місяців тому +20

    This guy has no credibility after Amy Goodman

  • @mmm-mq3zr
    @mmm-mq3zr 6 місяців тому +14

    "I had my underwear on!" S Dershowitz

  • @hughiedavies6069
    @hughiedavies6069 6 місяців тому +24

    He was absolutely right to ask the senator on the train a few questions. Do you believe politicians are untouchable? I find Mate a decent guy who's also a very good journalist and he ought to be able to ask a politician a question when so many people are needlessly dying.

  • @emilianosintarias7337
    @emilianosintarias7337 6 місяців тому +28

    Finkelstein does not "support Hamas" as you guys falsely accuse, and actually on your very show he detailed that he thinks they don't even have a workable strategy. His entire analogy to the atrocities commited by slave revolts in the name of religion (Norm is atheist and a fan of Gandhi) was clearly to express to you that, when a subjugated people without options fight back, bystanders who do not agree with how they do it or which group organizes it, can't just cherry pickingly condemn them for doing it wrong. Because it was never on them to end the subjugation, and it is "superhuman", if they really are subjugated - to expect them to do anything that big carefully or morally. He then showed that this is not an original take among respectable people in history. I don't agree with it, but it is a nuanced view, and if you want long form discussion but don't want nuance - what are you even doing?

    • @comedycellarclips
      @comedycellarclips  6 місяців тому +5

      He said of the October 7th attack, it "Warmed every fiber of my soul." And he offered no criticism. Does that sound like opposition to Hamas? normanfinkelstein.substack.com/p/john-browns-body-in-gaza

    • @Brewmaster757
      @Brewmaster757 6 місяців тому +16

      @@comedycellarclips He said that was his initial reaction after he heard they had broken through the gates. He amended his view as more details of atrocities came out.

    • @emilianosintarias7337
      @emilianosintarias7337 6 місяців тому +8

      yes, because what warmed his soul was a break out of Palestinians through the fence, headed armed toward gaza command center (which is near the festival area). You know that he has also called what they did an "atrocity", and wasn't it on your show that he said it was just a game of death and revenge (eye for an eye) not a politics of liberation when he recounted the meeting with the hamas leader in his kitchen? Knowing he's a leftist, do you think the rightist Hamas program in general would the palestinian party he supports? There are left wing palestinian parties you know. Also, don't you know when he broke up with BDS it was partially over his suggestion that palestinians march peacefully against Israel, holding signs that say "enforce the law" ? After the 2018 protestors were shot by IDF snipers he gave up on that. His position is clearly that he thinks they have tried everything, get slaughtered periodically and the world doesn't step in, so that anyone who will try to rebel against that status quo is at least not for him to condemn @@comedycellarclips

    • @emilianosintarias7337
      @emilianosintarias7337 6 місяців тому +5

      by the way, why didn't you guys even sneeze when your guest smeared his holocaust survivor mom as a kapo (based on zero evidence)? is there anything worse someone could say@@comedycellarclips

    • @Yogesh-jq9jj
      @Yogesh-jq9jj 6 місяців тому +4

      @@emilianosintarias7337 Thanks for your comments. Very well written.
      It is very dishonest of Noam to have a complete conversation with Norman, have the opportunity to get his viewpoint, and then misrepresent him using one out-of-context quote by Norman.

  • @capoditutticapi3939
    @capoditutticapi3939 6 місяців тому +15

    Where is your super long intro now to bash Dershowitz, ah no ofcourse you had to do some cheapshots against matee. Could you please next time ask Dershowitz whether he misses going to the Epstein island?

    • @josephgee143
      @josephgee143 6 місяців тому +1

      👋👋👋👋👋👋

    • @detrockcity3
      @detrockcity3 5 місяців тому +1

      Lmao exactly. Exposing himself.

    • @josephgee143
      @josephgee143 5 місяців тому +2

      @@detrockcity3
      Correction, he left his panties on.

  • @mmm-mq3zr
    @mmm-mq3zr 6 місяців тому +29

    Pro tip: you can tell he's lying when his lips are moving...🤔🙄🤥🤡

  • @peteunderdown6889
    @peteunderdown6889 6 місяців тому +33

    I don't know if I'm a rabid Finkelstein fan but I mostly find him knowledgable and persuasive . It is uncomfortable but very necessary for us all to talk with people we disagree with and I think Noam Dworman and Dr. Finkelstein both have open minds and that's why I listen to both.

    • @billyconnelly3568
      @billyconnelly3568 6 місяців тому +9

      Dworman's not in Finkelstein's league.

    • @izzykhach
      @izzykhach 6 місяців тому

      ​@@billyconnelly3568true, he can't lie as well. If Finkelstein and his ilk cared nearly as much for the one million Muslims who've killed each other in recent history instead of fixating over Israel

    • @DrAnac-qh5dc
      @DrAnac-qh5dc 6 місяців тому +1

      @@billyconnelly3568 True... Noam's not a grifting liar.

    • @cameronpatterson130
      @cameronpatterson130 6 місяців тому

      @@DrAnac-qh5dche’s a slimy liar

    • @billyconnelly3568
      @billyconnelly3568 6 місяців тому

      @@DrAnac-qh5dc
      I wish I had a percussion to go "ba-dump bump"
      You zionists keep getting manhandled in debate over and over and over and all you have to come back with is "he's a ________" with no evidence attached.

  • @josephgee143
    @josephgee143 6 місяців тому +9

    This would have never happened under Epsteins watch.
    Im glad Dershowitz left his underwear on for the interview.

  • @oz969
    @oz969 6 місяців тому +10

    I don’t think the Finkelstein debate reflected well on Noam And Eli

    • @promark5317
      @promark5317 6 місяців тому +2

      it didnt, have you seen the comment section on that video? This entire interview was a giant cope.

    • @pachamamarecords
      @pachamamarecords 6 місяців тому

      Can't fix stupid

    • @paulinoelsanchez
      @paulinoelsanchez 4 місяці тому

      Eli at least took his L and moved on.

  • @lawrencekagan8688
    @lawrencekagan8688 6 місяців тому +21

    Because we really need OJ and Trump's lawyer to explain the situation...

    • @norga2063
      @norga2063 6 місяців тому +1

      😂😂😂 exactly !!👌

    • @NG-cf7zh
      @NG-cf7zh 6 місяців тому

      He was Epstein‘a lawyer too but I guess it’s antisemitic to mention that this guy is cool with pedophilia

    • @neonlost
      @neonlost 6 місяців тому +4

      don’t forget Epstein

  • @mahdizaker1773
    @mahdizaker1773 6 місяців тому +19

    if you want to put a face on a liar , this dershowtiz guy is the guy
    but then you gotta hear how hateful people think
    so i will endure ... hope I can stand the whole video
    but just right now he says "doctors are the villians " - "lying doctors" 😂😂😂😂😂😂

    • @emilianosintarias7337
      @emilianosintarias7337 6 місяців тому +2

      yeah compare him to Mate, this guy's soul is contorted by decades of fraud

  • @FakeGarbageMen
    @FakeGarbageMen 6 місяців тому +56

    Alan does a really good job at stoking the flames of hatred for people who both agree with him and disagree with him. His analogies were so backwards and cartoonish

    • @mmm-mq3zr
      @mmm-mq3zr 6 місяців тому

      Is.rae.l will not likely survive this character ass.ass.ination upon itself.

    • @FakeGarbageMen
      @FakeGarbageMen 6 місяців тому +11

      I was fairly open minded on these issues. But Alan has really helped sway me to really reconsider what the pro isreal sentiment is, and the host who had 0 pushback to any of his statments really makes me think this might be the pro isreal perspective. I can not sit with people who can not see and admit to there responsibility in this tango. Ive at least heard plenty of pro Palestine voices condemning the October 7th attacks, while watching alan and this host justify and cheer on Israel. At least in this podcast

    • @FakeGarbageMen
      @FakeGarbageMen 6 місяців тому +3

      I really hope this is an extreme example of pro isreali sentiment, and not the general opinion of people who want Israeli people to be safe, which I personally think is completely fair. Because this seems like willingly blind blood thirst

    • @odysseasantoniou6840
      @odysseasantoniou6840 6 місяців тому

      Yeah pushing impelist lies. A thing Alan good at was a Epstein island molesting kids.

    • @smittyjonesthethird
      @smittyjonesthethird 6 місяців тому

      Alan Dershowitz Is not being a friend to the people of Israel here.

  • @renzo3dr
    @renzo3dr 5 місяців тому +3

    How do you NOT challenge Dershowitz for calling Finklestein’s late mother a Nazi sympathizer?! The woman was a death camp survivor. Beyond disrespectful for your hosts to not challenge that.

  • @danielfite2721
    @danielfite2721 6 місяців тому +11

    Noam I love YOU specifically and your brain and your humanity. This was not it… This was wild and kinda stupid. I dunno why you bent a knee to this dude. BUT I know you are better and godspeed going forward.

    • @pachamamarecords
      @pachamamarecords 6 місяців тому

      If he reads the comments he should be questioning his beliefs thus far (hopefully)

  • @conjugatemethod
    @conjugatemethod 6 місяців тому +13

    Approx 28:00 Dershowitz makes the point that there is no distinction between civilians and Hamas. Even if he is right that they allowed their houses to be used the most you could infer is this was for resistance to occupation which their right you cannot inference a mandate for war crimes or other atrocities, so his point has zero persuasive force.

    • @Lord_Nordan
      @Lord_Nordan 6 місяців тому

      He did not say that there is no distinction. He specifically mentioned those who assisted Hamas. Obviously, not all Palestinians are helping Hamas.

  • @brianmckerrow817
    @brianmckerrow817 6 місяців тому +9

    What is this Anti-Isreal equal anti Jewish? That would include a huge sections of Jewish people.

    • @khajad99
      @khajad99 6 місяців тому

      Israel and Zionism are the quintessential antisemitism.jews deserve better than these criminal actors

    • @gruweldaad
      @gruweldaad 17 днів тому

      If by huge you mean 5%.

  • @eatingeatingeating
    @eatingeatingeating 6 місяців тому +4

    Bring back Norman Finklestein to answer this disgusting liar.

  • @ahmedabdelshafy1316
    @ahmedabdelshafy1316 6 місяців тому +4

    bro you never even let aaron mate speak lol

  • @brianclarke4831
    @brianclarke4831 6 місяців тому +7

    I said I’d give this channel a chance. Make an effort to try to understand the other side. 😐 Nope. It’s just lie after lie after lie. 😐

  • @emilianosintarias7337
    @emilianosintarias7337 6 місяців тому +9

    Noam, Dan, Periel - don't you have some responsibility as Jews to not fan antisemitism by taking such a questionable stance here? Going easy on Alan Dershowitz, of all people? Can't you be critical of the IDF and open to the UN and world opinion, in line with the facts, while still underlining Israel's right to exist and Israeli civilans' rights? Why take such an extreme stance just because it's mainstream in the least mainstream country on this very topic, risking looking back someday in shame at being soft on ethnic cleansing?

    • @DrAnac-qh5dc
      @DrAnac-qh5dc 6 місяців тому

      People like you are so transparent. You didn't give a passing thought about the people dying by the tens of thousands in countries all over the world for the past ten years, but if Israel is involved suddenly it's game on! LMAO.

    • @harveymarvey3348
      @harveymarvey3348 6 місяців тому

      @@DrAnac-qh5dc Even if that's true, then obviously you don't give a shit either so why even make this comment?

  • @joeruf6526
    @joeruf6526 6 місяців тому +12

    LOL! Alan Dershowitz. The last line of defense for a guilty client.

  • @dattmougherty_5392
    @dattmougherty_5392 6 місяців тому +7

    you guys are so out of touch with with the sentiment of younger Democrats in the US, especially Jews. I am not Jewish, but I have many Jewish friends who liberal democrats. They are the loudest supporters of Palestine (not Hamas, I've never met anyone my age who outwardly supports terrorism. The furthest anyone will go is to feel sympathetic to the fact that an organization like that would exist, given the conditions in Gaza, and I'd have to agree with that. I can only imagine what type of crazy militia faction would seize power if there were a small sliver of the United States put in the same circumstances as Gaza). The support for Israel in this country comes from right wing Christian evangelicals/ nutjobs, and unfortunately also older people on the left (Gen X and above) who still have positive feelings towards the country. Periel will need to get used to seeing Jewish folks not support Israel because the sentiment among the youth has totally changed. They do not feel that Israel acts in line with the liberal values they hold

    • @izzykhach
      @izzykhach 6 місяців тому

      Yes, there are Leftist Jews who are moral narcissists and exhibitionists. They don't practice Judaism and only care about Israel in regards to whether it flatters their Leftist vanity. You can have them.

  • @sweetcell8767
    @sweetcell8767 6 місяців тому +4

    Sorry, what points did you get through on Finkelstein? The tunnels and the rockets? That’s not how I remember it? He didn’t “change the subject quickly”. He’s documented this stuff pretty carefully. I actually find Norm a bit grating at times, but your interview with him was a clear win for him, don’t kid yourselves.

  • @smittyjonesthethird
    @smittyjonesthethird 6 місяців тому +6

    Noam you started well on this untill you called Aaron a Hamas supporter. That's not honest to make that sort of statement. I do acknowledge you were right in calling out you co hosts' hypocrisy though. Thank you for having these talks. Get Rappaport please.

    • @comedycellarclips
      @comedycellarclips  6 місяців тому +2

      Show me an example of where he has not supported them. His most regular guest has been Finkelstein who has said that the attack, "warmed every fiber of my soul". normanfinkelstein.substack.com/p/john-browns-body-in-gaza
      I will grant you that when directly asked Mate has said he opposes the atrocities. But other than that admission - given only when directly questioned - never offered - TMK he is 100% on the Hamas side of this conflict. Even to the extent of saying that Israel has no right to even attempt to retrieve it's children held hostage.
      Where am I wrong (sourced arguments only - please.).

    • @emilianosintarias7337
      @emilianosintarias7337 6 місяців тому +8

      on your show ,when he said that he doesn't think there is any justification for killing civilians, that's an example. it was when you asked if he shared finkelstein's view that there was an analogy to a slave revolt and he said no@@comedycellarclips

    • @smittyjonesthethird
      @smittyjonesthethird 6 місяців тому +5

      @@comedycellarclips you and Alan basically make the case that by giving more context to the attack on Israel on Oct. 7 , and yes it was a massacre (I think you gave Aaron the benefit on saying as much as well) , means showing support for Hamas. On its own, that's an odd conclusion. Giving context is not an endorsement. Say it did come out that Israel was guilty of a war crime beyond a reason of a doubt (that you yourself would acknowledge as true), would you be pro-Hamas or Anti-Israel in Acknowledging that? If you gave context in that scenario, are you taking a side or showing bias?
      On Aaron I'll look for receipts. He's had Norm on to talk plenty, but I've never heard him agree with him about Hamas being comparable to John Brown. I've actually heard him explicitly disagree with that.

  • @TanerTech
    @TanerTech 6 місяців тому +20

    Professor Norman Finkelstein is someone you should bring back on. He made you guys question your assumptions and narrative and he is coming from a place of absolute knowledge and authority on the matter. I could see you guys were very uncomfortable with truths and claims he made, which for that alone you should bring him back.

    • @izzykhach
      @izzykhach 6 місяців тому

      Muslims have killed a million Muslims in Syria, Yemen and Iraq. Why the odd fixation with Israel? Are they the primary cause of Muslim suffering?

    • @tapiceriaypinturadesenos687
      @tapiceriaypinturadesenos687 6 місяців тому

      You don't like norman can't Blane you he makes you look stupid

  • @Freethinkerppposj
    @Freethinkerppposj 6 місяців тому +4

    Look into the debate that was on democracy now between this guy and Dr Norman F AND you will find out the truth 😂

  • @mmm-mq3zr
    @mmm-mq3zr 6 місяців тому +7

    I had my underwear on!

  • @galanis38
    @galanis38 6 місяців тому +8

    Every single person speaking on this show spews falsities right and left either about previous guests on the show or about the actual history and the ongoing conduct of the war now underway. Most egregiously, they show scant sympathy for the long oppression and indeed occupation by Israel of millions of Palestinians and their lands, or for the mass killing, expulsions and destruction Israel is committing, all of which far far exceeds in magnitude what Hamas did on Oct. 7 and by many around the world is now considered a genocide in the making or actually underway. Furthermore, to support Palestinian rights, including resistance to occupation, does not at all necessarily mean support for Hamas in particular. Condemn Hamas for its Oct. 7 attack? It's a trap designed to criminalize the actions of one party to the conflict while downplaying or ignoring the criminal actions of the other party. I personally would also refuse to answer a question so framed. My answer to such a question would be -- do you condemn Israeli criminal actions before and since Oct. 7? If yes, then I would be happy to condemn Hamas' as well for killing and kidnapping civilians on Oct. 7. This is what Aaron Mate kept trying to say in his recent appearance on this show, but Noam kept shutting him down.

  • @WillyLoman15
    @WillyLoman15 6 місяців тому +7

    Let me ask you something, anyone who is reading this. How do you think Dershowitz would feel about the situation if everything was reversed, and those were all Jews in Gaza. Do you think he would feel the same?

    • @josephgee143
      @josephgee143 6 місяців тому

      👋👋👋

    • @emilianosintarias7337
      @emilianosintarias7337 6 місяців тому

      but of course. he is a man of integrity. he didn't just slander a holocaust survivor on this very podcast and wasn't friends with Epstein

  • @user-uh4hb7tz5y
    @user-uh4hb7tz5y 6 місяців тому +2

    This is just frightening but not in the way Alan and Noam intended.

  • @kerrymcnamara2876
    @kerrymcnamara2876 6 місяців тому +6

    Alan Dershowitz: "First of all, The Occupation is all the fault of the Palestinians."

  • @WillyLoman15
    @WillyLoman15 6 місяців тому +5

    Did you ask him about Epstein’s island? I haven’t watch the whole thing yet. How about if that means the Lolita express?

  • @justinriley158
    @justinriley158 6 місяців тому +5

    lastly, how the fuck do you mishear “cease fire” as “kill all the Jews”?!?!?

  • @OnlyThe1Son
    @OnlyThe1Son 6 місяців тому +17

    GERMANS defended the nazis ... let that sink in...
    ALAN is no different..

    • @mmm-mq3zr
      @mmm-mq3zr 6 місяців тому

      Ashke...NAZI?

    • @DrAnac-qh5dc
      @DrAnac-qh5dc 6 місяців тому

      Kind of like you're defending terrorists who want a muslim state where women are second class citizens and Jews, gays, trans will not be allowed ... let that sink in...

  • @detrockcity3
    @detrockcity3 5 місяців тому +1

    You can tell which side needs tons of help from moderators. 😂

  • @dsecch
    @dsecch 6 місяців тому +1

    You should name the Podcast the wine, the wine that you've drinking during this episode.

  • @pierrefaucon2875
    @pierrefaucon2875 6 місяців тому +4

    Noam have you considered that maybe you've got the wrong take? or that you're in your bubble?

  • @hitmanhart670
    @hitmanhart670 6 місяців тому +1

    I recommend bringing comic Dave Smith on to discuss/debate this issue. He’s very informed on this topic

  • @talmouse
    @talmouse 6 місяців тому +3

    "you slept with a few Arabs"? 1:02:58. You know that was a low blow and I'm calling you out

  • @michaelomalley5172
    @michaelomalley5172 6 місяців тому +2

    You should rethink your opinion when you have to get the likes of Alan Dershowitz to agree with you.

  • @gruweldaad
    @gruweldaad 17 днів тому

    Who knew the guy who owned the comedy cellar was so insightful.

  • @joshbell5387
    @joshbell5387 6 місяців тому +6

    I went from watching the Aaron mate video, then this, you calling him a Hamas supporter is disingenuous. By this standard i shall call you a zionist nazi supporter who belives in an arian jewish state, and the "just moving" of the Palistinian people. Im sorry its harder for you to muddy the waters to excuse Isreal's slow annexation of another people's land.

  • @michaelgj23
    @michaelgj23 6 місяців тому +2

    It would be great to see Alan and Norman discuss Israel and Gaza on the show.

  • @zeuseygastony6385
    @zeuseygastony6385 6 місяців тому +4

    Man this Alan dude is ridiculous. Does no favours at all for Israel side. I know finklestein is bias but at least he presents the facts and tailors it accordingly. I get you guys are pro Israel, but you should really be pro truth and be pushing back on some of the shit he’s saying. Like how do you arrive at the figure of only 2000 innocents being killed? Honestly pretty pitiful man, we need objective truth and you should to, it’s obviously not one sided like he’s making it seem. How was this dude a Harvard professor lol.

  • @S_Padival
    @S_Padival 6 місяців тому +13

    Just when I thought Noam couldn’t get any lower and scumbaggyer…

    • @IkerCasillas-ps7ex
      @IkerCasillas-ps7ex 6 місяців тому

      Ay he's a shyster doing what swifty shysters do, nothing to see here

  • @papasmoke3311
    @papasmoke3311 6 місяців тому

    Where do I recognize this guy from?

  • @mehdiz1052
    @mehdiz1052 6 місяців тому +2

    Alan dursh IS israel. It's like saying apple is food. No need to be redundant.

  • @mack7518
    @mack7518 3 дні тому

    Co-host looking like the Child catcher from the movie Chitty Chitty Bang Bang

  • @meshzzizk
    @meshzzizk 6 місяців тому +6

    54:26 lmao "i just throw together a book and don't bother doing serious research or checking sources" -- weird flex but ok

  • @WillyLoman15
    @WillyLoman15 6 місяців тому +2

    Did you ask him if he kept his underwear on?

  • @khalidbaig3864
    @khalidbaig3864 6 місяців тому

    I wonder how many times he visited the Island?

  • @detrockcity3
    @detrockcity3 5 місяців тому

    Nothing could the necessity of armed resistance more clear than this softball interview.

  • @ramialhamad8768
    @ramialhamad8768 6 місяців тому +1

    Did he just ask her if she slept with more than a few Arab men?! 😅 what did this world turn into to

  • @user-zv5hz4pe1k
    @user-zv5hz4pe1k Місяць тому

    Why don’t you have Ilan Pappe on?

  • @jjaneso
    @jjaneso 5 місяців тому

    Once again, another hilarious podcast from the comedy cellar

  • @tableek
    @tableek 6 місяців тому +2

    ..just counting the comments about Dershowitz and ya boy Jeffery Epstein.

  • @justinriley158
    @justinriley158 6 місяців тому +2

    Ummm, war has always been about people killing other people… as far as I know that’s always been a bad look, not just since Vietnam…

  • @oraz.
    @oraz. Місяць тому

    Periel spoke all facts

  • @hmmmmmmminteresting
    @hmmmmmmminteresting 6 місяців тому

    This question about the atomic bomb was actually asked. The palestinians said they would use it immediately.

  • @brianmckerrow817
    @brianmckerrow817 6 місяців тому +1

    Total agree will Alan removing erhics from University. The individual!!

  • @shoaibmalik6622
    @shoaibmalik6622 4 місяці тому

    Noam’ what if brings Alan and norman together

  • @oh_k8
    @oh_k8 5 місяців тому

    For whatever reason, too many people have convinced themselves that being racist towards Jews and Asians is ok. That is sonething I can agree with Dershowitz on.

  • @bernman23
    @bernman23 6 місяців тому +2

    You were ungracious hosts to not send Alan a minor to give him a massage in his tidy whities.

    • @NG-cf7zh
      @NG-cf7zh 6 місяців тому +1

      It’s antisemitic to bring up this man’s physical attraction to children

    • @bernman23
      @bernman23 6 місяців тому

      @@NG-cf7zh Definitely don't bring up he wrote an op-ed that banging 14 or 15 yr olds should be legal. That would be bad.

  • @S_Padival
    @S_Padival 6 місяців тому +7

    Dersh had to rummage through the Epstein filing cabinet to land this interview 😅

  • @ACooperrocks
    @ACooperrocks 6 місяців тому +7

    Dershowitz hasn't been the same since he lost his pal, Jeffrey Epstein. Hopefully him and Donald Trump can get over their loss through massage therapy, a technique that their beloved Jeff taught them well.

  • @user-ot8ex7eo2p
    @user-ot8ex7eo2p 4 місяці тому

    The only subject I would trust alan about is how to get a massage with your clothes on while not having your clothes on.

  • @DrAnac-qh5dc
    @DrAnac-qh5dc 6 місяців тому +4

    This was the least interesting interview for me simply because Alan wasn't saying anything that hasn't been said a thousand times already on the pro-Israel side IMO (though the Obama story was interesting). TBF neither did Finkelstein or Mate or that Columbia prof, but seeing you make them defend their positions was very interesting (and revealing for anyone without a pre-determined position).
    I'd be curious to see you interview someone who doesn't have a stake - politically or emotionally, in this conflict, and who is also very knowledgeable about the situation. I'm not sure who that would be since this seems to be a very polarizing issue for a lot of people (even though most of them have zero stake in this conflict), but maybe an historian or scholar or reporter from the region (but not a Jew or Muslim) who has been covering this for some time. Maybe a Palestinian Christian or Egyptian Copt?

    • @darknessess
      @darknessess 6 місяців тому +1

      lol Alan D is incredibly dishonest individual, comparing him and Norm F, is a wild thing to do. Moreover Norm is jewish himself with parents who survived the holocaust….If he chose to be pro-palestinian that should tell you something

  • @stella3265
    @stella3265 6 місяців тому +1

    The reincarnation of Roy Cohen.

  • @eatingeatingeating
    @eatingeatingeating 5 місяців тому

    You need to be aggressive to get truth out of liars. You let Alan off the hook.

  • @pervnav14
    @pervnav14 6 місяців тому

    Sometimes I think Noam does so much to help the cause

  • @user-zv3ys2ve3x
    @user-zv3ys2ve3x 6 місяців тому +1

    There are so many ways to represent the best interests of Israeli's but Dershowitz isn't one of them.

  • @justdoit54321
    @justdoit54321 6 місяців тому

    I love my Jewish, Christian, and Islamic brothers and sisters who are standing up against Zonistism. Stop the genocide

  • @israelsilva9750
    @israelsilva9750 6 місяців тому +1

    Your talking about facts, really?!...

  • @sehaconsulting
    @sehaconsulting 6 місяців тому +1

    Netanyahu also supports Hamas and funded them to counter other PLO

  • @PawelKOtrebski
    @PawelKOtrebski 6 місяців тому +3

    Alan Dershowitz has been discredited and is the last person I would bring on to defend the Israeli point of view and actions… hahaha but i guess when you have nothing in the barrel you scrape the bottom

  • @Kpmg12
    @Kpmg12 6 місяців тому

    Get Destiny on! (The political streamer)

  • @selmo6376
    @selmo6376 2 місяці тому

    Im fu@ing tired of this people that sees antissemites under their beds !!!!

  • @claudiamason.
    @claudiamason. 6 місяців тому +1

    This is so pathetic. And Dersh hasn't even come on yet.

  • @FarhatKCh
    @FarhatKCh 6 місяців тому +2

    Thank you for bringing on pedo defender and plagiarist Alan Dershowitz to showcase Israel’s case. And thank you for not interrupting the esteemed Professor when he called Prof. Finkelstien’s mother a capo. You have done much for the Israeli cause.

  • @copiedoften5927
    @copiedoften5927 6 місяців тому

    “…said Polemarchus to Socrates.”😂 Not very Kantian ⚖️

  • @copiedoften5927
    @copiedoften5927 6 місяців тому +3

    Is there a world where scrutiny of policy or actions could avoid being misconstrued and misrepresented as only ‘hate’ or ‘pro’ anything or anyone? A refusal for complexity and name calling as a response isn’t solid ground to stand on for long. The false dichotomies presented pose innumerable inconsistencies and blindspots. Which can be riddled with unending quibbling if commanded to. Kind of shocking the accusation of desensitization to the suffering of one ‘in group’ is ironically met with it in spades for the ‘out group’. Dershowitz sounded like he was ready to write his own ‘Turner Diaries’ or start wearing purple wizard robes like an SNL skit. Eerie stuff here…

  • @2345piratesurfin
    @2345piratesurfin 6 місяців тому +3

    Did He pay Mr.Finkelstein yet? He owes him 10 grand

    • @hmmmmmmminteresting
      @hmmmmmmminteresting 6 місяців тому

      He does not. Not at all.

    • @luccabrunt1771
      @luccabrunt1771 5 місяців тому +1

      well clearly he does sorry you don’t know what alan agreed to

    • @luccabrunt1771
      @luccabrunt1771 5 місяців тому +1

      well clearly he does sorry you don’t know what alan agreed to

    • @hmmmmmmminteresting
      @hmmmmmmminteresting 5 місяців тому

      @@luccabrunt1771he didn't. The only thing Filthtestein could find was a typo that would work against Alan, not pro Alan.

    • @paulinoelsanchez
      @paulinoelsanchez 4 місяці тому

      @@luccabrunt1771Dershowitz definitely owes him that money. Finkelstein got him on a sneaky one, but he got him nonetheless.

  • @Kpmg12
    @Kpmg12 6 місяців тому

    Uncles the Doctors have already left Gaza for good… if they are reporting from Gaza they can’t really say (let’s for argument sake say it’s true about Hamas using their buildings and have the tunnels) that or reveal that while under Hamas control so definitely wouldn’t call them evil (as Alan said)

  • @eatingeatingeating
    @eatingeatingeating 6 місяців тому +1

    These are obvious lies which the presenters just let slip. Disgusting

  • @hellbee105
    @hellbee105 6 місяців тому +3

    That clown at the start looks and sounds like my morning ritual involving t-paper.

  • @cameronpatterson130
    @cameronpatterson130 6 місяців тому

    🔻🔻🔻

  • @alicetusk9290
    @alicetusk9290 6 місяців тому

    This was great.

    • @mmm-mq3zr
      @mmm-mq3zr 6 місяців тому

      Is.rae.l will not likely survive this character ass.ass.ination upon itself.

    • @KristianSkylstad
      @KristianSkylstad 6 місяців тому +1

      Just like America will be again?