Glenn Greenwald and Alan Dershowitz Debate Bombing Iran
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 чер 2024
- The Pulitzer Prize winning journalist Glenn Greenwald takes on famed lawyer and author Alan Dershowitz.
reason.com/podcast/2024/05/24...
------------
Professor and legal scholar Alan Dershowitz and Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Glenn Greenwald debate the resolution, "The U.S. should strike Iran's nuclear facilities."
Taking the affirmative is Dershowitz, an American lawyer and law professor known for his work in U.S. constitutional law and American criminal law. From 1964 to 2013, he taught at Harvard Law School, where he was appointed as the Felix Frankfurter Professor of Law in 1993. He is the author of several books about politics and the law, including The Case for Israel, and The Case for Peace. His two most recent works are The Case Against Impeaching Trump, and Guilt by Accusation: The Challenge of Proving Innocence in the Age of #MeToo. In January 2020, he joined President Donald Trump's legal team as Trump was being tried on impeachment charges in the Senate. He is a strong supporter of Israel, self-identifing as both "pro-Israel and pro-Palestine."
Taking the negative is Greenwald, a constitutional lawyer, investigative journalist, and best-selling author. Acclaimed as one of the 25 most influential political commentators by The Atlantic, one of America's top 10 opinion writers by Newsweek, and one of the Top 100 Global Thinkers for 2013 by Foreign Policy, Greenwald has won the highest awards in journalism, including the 2014 Pulitzer Prize for Public Service for the NSA-Snowden revelations.
This debate was moderated by Soho Forum Director Gene Epstein.
Chapters:
00:00:00 Introduction
00:02:06 Dershowitz's Opening Statement
00:19:43 Greenwald's Opening Statement
00:37:48 Dershowitz's Rebuttal
00:45:27 Greenwald's Rebuttal
00:53:56 Q&A
01:35:08 Dershowitz's Summation
01:40:22 Greenwald's Summation
The only good thing about Alan Dershowitz is that he's 85.
😂😂😂😂
Not old enough imo
even lucifer doesn't want him. though he may be found victim of an "apparent" sueyside on a massage table wearing his depenz
Total scumbag
85---- closer to his sentence to hell for eternity!
As a veteran, it’s always sickening to me to hear people like Dershowitz(a person who has never and would never serve in the military and has never been in combat) always talk so pompously about jumping into wars on behalf of foreign countries.
Glenn Greenwald didn't serve in the army either. Why is he allowed to have an opinion?
You don’t need to have been to say no war. But if advocating for war but you have never been in one it gives you less credibility especially if the precious ones you have advocated for have gone terribly wrong
@@elanakirshenbaum9658 He is not the one preaching for war. Are u seriously that stupid not to under this simple thing?
Amen dude
@@elanakirshenbaum9658 Because he has the facts on his side about how dumb these kinds of 'preventive' wars are and because he isn't advocating a dumb war ..... duh? BTW You know which nation didn't contribute a single dollar or a single member of the military to the Ir - ack war in 2003? Yep, that would be is real! Not a red cent, but lots of egging on!
People like Alan Dershowitz are literally why we don't have world peace
Radical Islam is the main reason today actually
Dude, that is a perrrrrrfect analysis, man. Absolutely 💯 true!
A psychopathic Nethanyahu disciple is Allan.
@BSCTrainerRob Worse than radical Christians? You know, the ones who waisted millions in that region
@@BSCTrainerRobNo they are a byproduct of the destruction the States leaves behind.
Dershowitz was a regular at Epstein Island. Here he is with some moral words of wisdom.
Wearing his underwear
Alan knows all the secrets.....he knows
Alan knows all the secrets
What moral words ? How about you explain.
But kept his underwear on
"Israeli pilots would refuse to drop bombs on civilians"
Is this old fart for real?
He was talking about nuclear bombs.
@@evamurray2564 yeah only if the pilot actually understood the potential consequences to their homes would they refuse.
Ever heard of the Hannibal directive?
The way these cold war pedasts talk is exactly the same as the Israelis; they are caught up in a biblical crusade where reason and humanity has no place.
Do you know how to tell a jew is lying? Some say it is his mouth moving.
@@MrSzczyglowski well said
Glen Greenwald won this debate
Lol no he didn’t. He lied and tried to smear his opponent. He had no argument other than war is bad and America is evil and should just bend over and take it. Maybe Glenn is into that in the bedroom but let’s not project his kinks into reasonable policy of a sovereign country he’s not a citizen of
Glenn is brilliant but he had a clear advantage defending the truth against a lie that has being repeated multiple times costing countless lives.
@@magnero2749 💯
@@magnero2749 I agree it's much harder to defend B.S. than it is to defend the truth.
Glenn had a far easier prompt to argue for, and he still looked lousy. His entire argument was “bring them into the league of nations and they wont do anything bad” and used the iran deal as an example of it working, when the entire world knows Iran never stopped their nuclear program.
Greenwald is incredible, makes Dershowitz look ridiculously naive and stupid
To be fair: Dershahalfwitz also makes himself look that way without any help🤣 Glenn did well still.
He is ridiculously naive and stupid.
(not hard to do...)
How about bringing democracy to the west .
Exactly my thought
Exactly!
Explain why you think there's no democracy in the west? Especially in contrast to east! China , russia , north Korea! Yes you're comment is a joke
@@Yoger100 we have the illusion of democracy. We vote for politicians in hope they will represent us but their loyalty is to money, Israel, multi-national corporations, Satan but not necessarily in that order.
@Yoger100 greetings FED
"Israeli pilots would refuse to drop bombs on civilians" yeah ok
Lol, the things they say, this is why they want to ban tik tok, they know if people see what's going on, they'll look ridiculous
I'm glad I'm not the only one who noticed that.
Such a mental thing to say 😂
Honestly, students should stop applying to Harvard Law School if these are the arguments put forth by faculty members. Unbelievably absurd assertions.
lol comment Dershowitz is a dinosaur becoming extinct
The men of the USS Liberty would strongly disagree.
Glenn needs to be protected; he goes up against some of the most powerful and murderous folks in the world.
He goes up against people and gets Iran wrong. It was comical to think Iran stopped their nuclear program.
all propaganda
Protected? From what? A guy in his 80’s with a different set of ideas?
@@jr-zo9githat’s just the U.S. president but Glenn’s made a lot more adversaries in positions of power.
@@jr-zo9gi Not the 80-year-old plagiarist and genocide propagandist, no, but his tribe's assassins of whom he is so proud
They both forget that Iran had a free elected government in 1951. The CIA did not like the results and overthrew Mosaddegh to reimpose the Shah rule.
You obviously don’t know what you’re talking about. There was no election or voting system for people in Iran back in the the 1950s. Prime ministers (in this case Mosaddeq) got appointed by the King of Iran (the Shah). Please do more research before you comment on history.
@@sev2300 en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1952_Iranian_legislative_election
@@sev2300it’s obvious you don’t know what you’re talking about. The British Mi6 & The US CIA overthrew the Prime Minister of Iran reinstated the Shah fast forward to the Iran Hostage crisis & here we are today. You should be QUIET & LEARN SOMETHING!
@@plantpapi614Mossadegh was elected through the same system as all his predecessors and successors. He then tried to grab power beyond what the constitution granted him, effectively attempting a coup. The Shah was within his constitutional right to relieve Mossadegh of his position. Although the US and GB did execute a propaganda campaign, this was not a coup. It was stopping a coup by Mossadegh, who has ties to Fedeyin e Islam(who attempted an assassination of the Shah and used violence to stifle their political opponents) as well as USSR allied factions in the country. Had Mossadegh maintained power he would have tanked Iran’s economy (which he had already began doing) because they didn’t have the means to operate the nationalized oil system, and probably led Iran to become a Russian client state.
@Keof420 Sure sounds a lot like America's government, with things like the Kennedy assassination, lawmakers paid off by lobbyists to make laws that please corporations while they produce toxic products and avoid taxes, making endless wars at the expense of taxpayers...the corruption goes on and on. Amerika is a super-corruption.
l think Dershowitz needs to explain his relationship with Jeff Esprein a little more in detail and he should not be so worried about Iran!
What a dishonest actor Dershowitz has proved he is.
Even way back when he was caught plagiarizing
and pedo
@@anitapodsudek8041Yes, under nickname "Claudine Gay"
Dershowitz is garbage
even way back with o.j
Alan has proven here to be extremely dangerous to all of humanity. No doubt he believes what he says. Glenn, you were astoundingly clear. Deeply appreciate your voice. Thank you.
Alan is a typical Zionist.
💯
He was dangerous during the plandemic. He said the gov't had the right to require you to be a Guinea pig.
He's bought his own nonsense
I think he's happy to believe what he's told
Mr. Greenwald debated using factual information.
Professor Dershowitz debated using emotions, narratives, and speculation.
Mr. Greenwald won this debate rather easily.
I can NOT listen to this it turns my stomach . Glenn Greenwald i can listen to all day.
Glenn is a legend. Alan is a disgrace!
Radical Islam is the snake 🐍 hiding in the grass. Moderate Islam is the grass hiding the snake... 🐍
That the prosecutor is a pakistani and a muslim called KAREEM KHAN says it all. The lawfare jihad continues after the botched October 7th Hamas genocide.
Nakba day/October 7th:
We tried to kill you.
We lost.
We are the victims.
Losing a war that you started is NOT genocide.
Glenn sounds just like a idiot with no buts
Both are highly intelligent and both had sound arguments. Neither is without personal bias.
@@jeffrp8388nonsense Alan has no point other than the same ol imperialist, war profiteers who done nothing but create chaos, suffering and and lead to a more dangerous world. So please don't sell us that bs.
100% spot on
This man will be in favor of sending you to jail for a crime you “might” commit in the future..
Minority Report Dershi.
the worst part is, Those persecuting you have committed said crimes
@@aman-qr7wh exactly my thoughts...
@user-it4qz4xw1t oh so what you’re the thought police? You wanna Jail everyone who poses a potential threat??
@user-it4qz4xw1t shalakham valkhan......
It should be mandatory for all politicians to send their kids to serve their country and you'll see if they will still be calling for wars.
Alot actually do!
My words exactly ! But then they will allow marriage to multiple wives ! Trust that !
Never seen a moderator have this many strokes in a single debate before
Agreed
Mr. Dershowitz, here's a thought: you, whose primary allegiance is to Israel, stop trying to shape U.S. foreign policy.
Good idea; also move into a settlement in Pisrael
Alternatively, you could abandon your allegiance to Iran.
thats our problem, zionists rule us all
@@jaialaiwarrior…so it’s either you’re with us or with our enemies. Please continue with your comedy act🍿
LMAO our government is zionist captured, our foreign policy is to benefit them
Greenwald wipes the floor with this shill.
He preempted ALL of Alan Dershepstein's arguments in the first round and the old man proceeded to say EXACTLY those things like everybody's got no memory 😂😂😂
Well, it may definitely seem so to one-size-fits-all, one-bit thinkers who don't know much about history.
I have a great deal of respect for Glenn's accomplishments. Unfortunately, in this case, I was disappointed with the style of his argumentation, and I found it somewhat ironic that while himself straying considerably from the norms of a serious rational and logical debate, he called Alan's arguments "propaganda".
if only that was how the audience saw it
@@rexnemovi6061 because this disgraced child sex predator with a bullshit ‘civil libertarian’ credit for defending pornographers (and never movement activists arguing for a war that would cost millions of deaths & destroy the economy
So Israel can have a nuclear monopoly in the Middle East?
This obscene and unhinged; fuck those who wring their hands in discussion over decorum in face of these obscenities are themselves obscene
He said Iran only sent missiles to Israel on weak drones to warn them. That’s hilariously ridiculous. This conflict is never going to end and contrary to what they both said, talking about it isn’t going to solve anything. Who won this debate is worthless. All it does is polarize people even more.
I love that Alan Dershowitz' first argument is that he agrees with Joseph Goerbels about how to justify wars of aggression.
Israel is parody of itself, blaming everyone for things they do.
@@kjetilhvalstrand1009 Netanyahu certainly is.
He and Dershowitz are both part of a philosophy that is of the same extraction as the Nazis, NOT the Israelite religion.
"Saudi Arabia does not export terrorism" bro literally forgot 9/11
Saudi Arabia had nothing to do with 9/11😂
@@sumerianastrologycheck the citizenship of hijackers
@@arundel3177 you mean of the passports the fbi magically found in the debris?
Only idiots believe the official story of 9/11
@@sumerianastrology hijackers were saudis, G. Bush and his neo con gang wanted the MSM to relate that away from Saudi Arabia and stick it to Iraq and Afghanistan.
What a disgusting war warmonger...
Dershowitz believed zionist own America and thus should use America for the good of Zionist: this guy sees his people on a different level and America deserves to serve them: 👇
ua-cam.com/users/shorts1SpgUHh3L14?si=XS6Pr3Jx8pZp58fi
AD isn't in favor of war. Rather he seems to prefer to avoid war.
Shut up. Americuah firrst!
@@cantdance3077 PROPAGANDIST. AD IS A ZIONIST MOUTHPIECE. THESE PROPAGANDISTS ARE BLOOD THIRSTY.
@@ibrahimkuyumcu2649 lol
Glenn Greenwald is an amazing debator. Wiped the floor with the Israeli schill
Destiny destroyed Glenn. Dershowitz loses most debates
@@boliusabol822 Destiny is an unread more on, and so are you... Imagine being impressed by a college dropout who only reads and gets sources from wikipedia, embarrassing.
@@user-rh1iv7yp2c I didn't say I am or am not impressed by him. I said Destiny destroyed Glenn in debate. Try comprehending English
And I bet you think the Ayatollah is an amazing leader wiping the fooor of the Middle East killing millions in Yemen Iraq and Syria
@@boliusabol822😂😂😂
Did he seriously refer to dropping atomic bombs over Japan as "surgical interventions"?...
This man must be a madman. Israel pilots are the ones bombing women children all very innocent civilians but he thinks the airforce pilots would not want to bomb Baghdad because of killing civilians. Who does he thinks are dropping bombs on the civilians,maybe he knows they would always have the excuse “a very sad mistake”
This disgusting war monger should be condemn and locked out. He is dangerous.
You mean the ayatollah who is a war monger who has killed millions of people in Iraq Syria and Yemen ?
The ayatollah should be condemned and locked up he is dangeorous
People like you who cannotknow stand hearing anything that is not a reflection of their own opinion. By the way the opinion you hold shows a lack of knowledge will never learn anything new
He is very dangerous , it's terrorizing .
Because he's a member of the tiny hats .
He should have been thrown in jail a long time ago along with the rest of these warmongering neocons.
At 39 min.: Iran is months away from a nuclear bomb ( for the last 20 years). Got it.
Free free plastain
All of you are eviel not only isreal
Watch out, it's coming. It's close. It's very close now. Any minute. Are you scared yet? You should be. A matter of seconds. Brace yourself!
So True
Maybe longer
Thank god that Dershowitz finally debated someone who is more informed about international affairs.
thanks Glenn Greenwald. As an iranian i do not want any bomb in my country and i want a real democracy without help from freign country .
Glenn Greenwald knocked it out of the park👏👏👏
Blasted it!!
Mind Begs the Question:
▪︎If those once Dehumanized
▪︎Dehumanize others
▪︎Following footsteps of their Oppressors,no?
No competition!
I am Iranian and all he said was lie
@@Js34514 just because you’re Iranian doesn’t mean you’re objective.
Hiroshima was a surgical strike? is he senile?
It is hard to say, given that he extremely dishonest and insane even in his youth.
HE’S A WARMONGER ‼️
Yes.
Possibly. Type 3 diabetes is a threat to an American male of his age. Probably he’s telling the truth how he’s been spinning it for 50 years
Nah he’s horny. He gets all confused when he goes more than a few days without raping a teenage girl. It’s been very hard for him since Epstein’s island got seized.
Audience member "mistaking" Dershwitz for Dulles was priceless! 😅
Bill Maher will never have Glenn on again because he schooled him last time and left him speechless.
The old guard is losing their grip, finally...
But then watch out they can become very dangerous dragging the world into the abyss
@@FadiaKadamani-fj1sithat’s what I think is gonna happen too
Then we must ban tik tok!
Dershowitz believed zionist own America and thus should use America for the good of Zionist: this guy sees his people on a different level and America deserves to serve them: 👇
ua-cam.com/users/shorts1SpgUHh3L14?si=XS6Pr3Jx8pZp58fi
Thank God, The Gods, both Trump and Biden only get 4 more years. Next in line are much younger. I’ll be voting for RFK.
Never trust a guy wearing religious socks.
Speak a little louder, Adolf
He's wearing those $2 rubber shoes also. I'm all up for saving money... but my net worths not 20mil.
Nice catch! I wouldn't have caught that.
Imagine his underwear. Wait don't
Tasteless
People are getting tired of Israel
Dershowitz defended Eppstein tells you everything you need to know.
That’s unfair. Our legal system, needs lawyers to defend the accused. I bet you’d want a lawyer if you were accused of something.
This isn’t me dismissing what Epstein was accused of & what he more than likely did. I’m commenting on the fact that you can decide anything about a person based on them, as a lawyer, defending them someone bad in court.
There’s plenty other, valid reasons to be distrustful of Dershowitz
@@candycolrivno it’s fair. They were also long time family friends and he visited the island many many times. Look up the article he wrote about how he thinks rape should be legal. It’s in the Times of Israel
@@candycolriv Yes...but think about it !!...that exactly HE choice to defend him..
is NO coincidence..all these bastards are connected to defend eachothers back, and
most things dont even make to court or news.
Dershowitz is not only a warmonger of first degree, but a dangerous one connected to all the wrong people, who likes to think they deserve to be kings of the world. Never underestimate the entitlement and arrogance. NOTICE with what EASE they talk about killing people in other countries.
Like they dont matter to them. Its a rationalisation only deeply disturbed people have
and the elite power, is full of these coldhearted types, who likes to play chess with the world. His ideas is completely flawed in human big perspective, when he can justify these attrosities of us wars and interventions. Kissinger was the same.
Thank god we have people like Greenwald out there too !
Iran is a theocracy? So is Israel.
And the US is trying to go there too.
The madness of reactionary politics.
now who force genital mutilation on kids and women to fight ...
@@auroradawn4531what you said is equally wrong & misguided. You’re a gullible person for believing that. However, I do wish it were true.
@@jamesb6857the Zionists in charge are largely motivated by religious or quasi-religious ends. We have politicians openly trying to orchestrate their apocalypse with insane rabbis from Israel.
Than why do Muslims serve on the Supreme Court in Israel and in the parliament ?
"We can put the son of shah in power "
Does Alan Dershowitz think the Iranians are stupid and they accept who ever he wants to be in power ??
I guess he forgot what happened to the last Shah of Iran.
@grifdenton5224. You mean the last Shah of Iran who lived the rest of his life out in the United States with his family and died in NYU hospital? Nothing really happened to him. He lived out his life in luxury.
@@LlyleHunter And why did he live out his days in the United States, instead of the country he ruled? Oh right, because he was OVERTHROWN, fleeing the country.
@@LlyleHunter Sure, He lived out his days in the US _after_ being forced to flee his own country by the revolution.
@@LlyleHunter
You missed the little detail of the Shah being overthrown, and people possibly resisting a foreign government imposing a ruler on them.
I totally trust Alan "Lolita Express" Dershowitz 😂😂
No, "preventive" aggression is NEVER legitimate.
It CANNOT be justified.
It is the must fundamental violation of the rules of Just War.
Glen's a global treasure. One of the few voices standing against the rising authoritarianism in western democracies.
I love Glenn. Mousy little gay guy goes full word Ninja and leaves you wishing you'd just been punched in the mouth.
He's no Dershowitz
@@shmosel_ Thank God. You can worship that relic all you want. I listened to losers like him for decades. Then I finally noticed that nothing had ever gotten better.
Consistently. Regardless of the flavor Glenn has been a stalwart against authoritarianism
But you’re ok with leaving authoritarian governments in Iran that have killed millions in Iraq Syria and Yemen ?
For those who don't have the time to watch the debate, Greenwald won.
Appreciate the spoiler.
I just want to see an edited version with Dersh deleted so only intelligent info can come forth.
Nobody with morals could possibly agree with Dershowitz.
Nah, Greenwald is a simpleton. He literally leads by calling the question simple and going on a rant about a bunch of things no one ever said.
@@knifedance2402 Pulitzer Prize winning simpleton or Dunning Kruger post? I’ll let you try to decide
Even most of the sanctions on Iran 🇮🇷 is illegal or at the very least unfair given the fact that the Iranian population is most affected by the sanctions more than the intended target is the government of Iran.
One example of this is sanctions not to sell planes or parts to Iran and this has resulted in numerous tragic accidents involving regular Iranians falling out of the sky to their deaths.
Iranian economy and inflation is hurting the most vulnerable sect of society pushing them into severe poverty while the government is enjoying what remains of the revenue of what is allowed to be traded.
Lack of medication is hurting cancer patients and children and again the most vulnerable . While Iranian officials can fly out to receive treatment abroad. So who is the sanctions for again?
GLEN KILLED IT 😂
Last time, Alan won a debate was when he was in college... MAYBE 😂
Is it possible to discuss the Middle East without mentioning Nazis or Hitler?
Dersh knows nothing of the people, regions or history of the places he wants to bomb. Mind-boggling how these kind of stances are even morally acceptable.
That's one of Glenn's points!
No, Hitler is reincarnated approximately every 5 years or so, and coincidentally always in a country that the United States needs to attack.
Well, Muslims and Arabs do hate Jews.
Five minutes in I was thinking the exact same thing
My ears feel dirty after listening to epsteins buddy give his opening statements
#MeToo
I'm glad to see your comment, I can't stand him either.
starts at 19:50.
When the opening statement are about ww2 and that's not the topic of the debate you can usually assume you're about to hear a load of bull
@@jesse123185I know, right? Historical examples of things are bad. We should ignore all of that and just do whatever sounds nice now.
@@knifedance2402 can't tell if you're seriously this obtuse. Historical examples sure but he picked the most loaded tortured overused Historical example but none others. The version of that particular conflict most contemporaries use is akin to a marvel movie for all that it's based on actual history. He didn't really use a Historical example though he used a point in history as a jumping off point to paint a fantastical hypothetical narrative.
Glen is a amazing! His point was my vote. It's really a question of Deplomacy vs war regimen change? Which one works better?
We know a lot about Alan simply from his socks😂
I effing hate Dershowitz.
Why? You’re emotions are making you feel hatred for man you don’t even know. It’s irrational. It’s the same reason he’s being so irrational about this issue.
Jeffrey Epstein's lawyer is pathetic
Because you are a fool
@@Kunfucious577he defended epstein and went to his island
@@Abshirayamisra JE and OJ! Let's not forget. And then there is his view on age-of-consent. And that person wonders why he is disliked? eesh!
"Israeli pilots would refuse to drop bombs on civilian" last 7 moth shows everything.
😂
Alan forgot
Alan is delusional
They act like losing Israel is a bad thing.
who tf would want to part with Alan Dershowitz?
Did anyone else fast-forward through Dershowitz’s babbling to get to Greenwald’s part?
19:51
Awesome. Ignore everything you don’t want to hear.
@@Kunfucious577 lmao funny coming from a person who calls any and everything anti$emetic that they don’t want to hear. Awesome 😂😂😂
@@HJay-ln3xy I don’t call anyone antisemitic. I don’t care about this conflict. It’s happening on the other side of the planet and doesn’t really affect me. All I know is that my country needs attention right now and this has succeeded in distracting everyone. it’s especially ironic that most people don’t even understand what’s actually happening over there. Ask a random “protester” and they couldn’t tell you what a Zionist is and I’m starting to understand why. What kind of fool would fight their own family over their neighbors problems all based off rumors.?
NO.
Coincidentally, when Madeleine Albright was asked if the 500,000 dead children in Iraq had been worth it, she began her reply with "That is a very hard question." Then she continued with "But we believe it was worth it."
thats physicalism for ya.
whats wrong with melting down a few 100,000 or even a few million advanced laptops with delusions of being alive. especially when you can get more rich and powerful by doing it. its a no-brainer.
Albright, HClinton, Nuland......others?? definitely👍
She said this in 1996. The deaths were a result of the sanctions.
9/11 was in 2001
That was not even the Iraq war from the 2000's that from 1991 to 1996 after peace deals where signed in 1991 but want to know what expired in 2001 ? Oil contracts signed in 1991.
Lord Farquad's iconic line "some of you will die, but that's a sacrifice I'm willing to make" is based on that Albright's response..
If dictionaries used pictures of people to define words, then a picture of Alan Dershowitz would be right next to the word “asshole”.
Dershowitz is a dangerous clown 🤡
This man is not a clown, clowns make people laugh, this man is a danger to humanity 😮
one of many that claim love for America . Levin, Hannity,etc
Glenn is not a good debater his arguments are emotional
Darshwits is a zionist and hence capable of making big lies. He proved what Glen said. Israel is pushing the US to go to war and change regimes to install their own puppets who can take orders from Israel and the US and subjugate their people not to resist when their resources are being exploited. In fact soon after the king of Iran had an interview in which he expressed his view on israel being in power in the US, he was removed. He was a dictator but was removed only for his view on Israel. That's a fact and the video has been removed from UA-cam. So even their puppet king knew he was under their thumb. They have waited 45 years for people in Iran to forget what their dictator King did, so they can install his son to do their bidding. The Israel zionist is simply a charlatan. They are thinking about people, they are just want bloodbath but an outcome to servevl them. Iranianbpeople must learn not to listen to either Israel or the US but find the best way to rise and rule themselves without their interference.
@@adriennefried5368 because he knows other countries are the one who pays the ultimate price. If Is-real wants to go to war then they can go to war without dragging us.
Greenwald is the dude, he totally destroyed this fool Dershowitz ✅🎉
UM Greenwald looked like an infant who doesnt unerstand how the world works. As usual. Hes a hack.
Easy to destroy someone who is arguing for the existence of Santa Claus, the Tooth Fairy and Peter Pan.
But yes.
Greenwald didn't just beat him.
He ground him into a fine paste.
@@robbiet1969 Greenwalds arguments were impotent. One would need to have the cumulative intellect of a school of goldfish in order to think his arguments hold water. They are immoral, fundamentally, based on a leftist delusion , and infantile arguments. And many lies. Iran would fall in a month. Not even. 70% of their people want the IRCG out of power. Greenwald supports the oppression of Iranians. Everything Greenwald stated shows a complete ignorance of the actual situation as it stands in reality. Hes a slimy toad.
As were Plato and Aristotle. The greatest thinkers are always the cool dudes. Reason and logic dude... And Iran is so chill and reasonable bro.
@@jacobrebibo9217 An Iran is so chilld and reasonable? I hope being sarcastic lol thats insane. 70% of Iranians want to see their own government fall and regularly protest asking Yizreal to free them. lol Greenie is deluded or worse.
Tyranny doesn’t do diplomacy…
Glen is very very good, so calm and so clear!!!!
Glenn: Opens arguments by listing several historical examples of lies
Alan: Responds by repeating the same lies verbatim.
Moral of the story- If you repeat a lie enough times it becomes Israel.
Glenn repeated the lie that Iran stopped their nuclear program
This comment need elevation... STAT! 😎
YT deleted my comment. Its a lie that Iran stopped their nuclear program and he kept repeating the lie.
Lool so true
Good point
Anyone else skip Douchahalfwitz and just watch Glenn?
🤣🤣🤣 Noice!! Lower your shields and power down your weapons. Your nickname for Alan Douchahalfwitz will be assimilated. Resistance is futile. 😎🖖
YES, i was doing exactly that
I was watching Alan at 1.75 speed and was switching back to normal when Glenn was speaking 😬
Yes, I did same.
@@fridaray4128Nothing new from the douche.
We've been hearing that Iran is "months away" from a nuke since the 90s. That's Netanyahu's favorite line.
WHY IS THIS EVEN BEING DEBATED? IT'S INSANITY
Alan Dershowitz is actually insane.
That’s excusing him. He’s just evil.
Alan Dershowitz is wrong in every issue
Because he lies. Count how many times he says “Iran’s nuclear *capability” versus “Iran’s nuclear *arsenal”. Those are two very different realities but he says them interchangeably. He’s an Israeli propagandist on, nothing more.
he's compromised on every issue. At least, every one he chooses to speak on, for some reason
Mossad has very compromising videos of him.
Isn't Alan Dershowitz the guy who defended Jeffrey Epstein in court? Lmao
Dershowitz is an extraordinarily rude and bad mannered debater. I've never seen a debate at this level where one debater constantly shouts down his opponent and prevents him from finishing his argument. What a loser!
How about regime change in Israel that's where you need regime change
THIS!!!!!!!!!!!! Thank you!
Unfortunately the escalation of the "War" i.e. the Genocide is what is keeping the current regime in power.
Peace, Love, Health, and Freedom, to all who are fortunate enough to strive for these goals. 🙏
ct
Exactly! And we have to disarm the Israeli regime
Best response yet💯
Yes to use Dershowitz's on rhetoric: Israel is the most "evil" country in the world. It works through surrogates and we will never know how much destruction we can prevent if we force a regime change.
The title of this video should be "Dunking on Dershowitz: How facts defeat propaganda"
🤣🤣🤣 noice!
Truth 😂😂
Dershowitz gets worse with age.....
Dershowitz believed zionist own America and thus should use America for the good of Zionist: this guy sees his people on a different level and America deserves to serve them: 👇
ua-cam.com/users/shorts1SpgUHh3L14?si=XS6Pr3Jx8pZp58fi
@@doginuhe ages like a rancid fart.
Gotta respect the moderator though, must have had a hot date waiting
Seeing the intense crowd and its grief, on the occasion of the funeral of the president of Iran recently, it doesn't feel like people over there were oppressed
Yikes, what a dangerous man
Well, he is Jewish
Glenn is dangerous he is not based in reality...
Look up Coup 53 documentary. It’s nothing new unfortunately, the US have been trying to destroy Iran for 70 years
Next debate "Whether or Not to Throw Palestinians in Gass Chamber"
Alan Dershowitz: Its very important to have this debate, there are great arguments on both sides.
How magnanimous of him.
He actually wrote a piece on the new York post magazine that was titled, are gazans civilians really innocent?
If we swapped Gazan for Jewish, would that be anti-Semitic?? 🤔🤔
Then it would be antisandwichistic@@adamgates1142
E P S T E I N S. L A W Y E R.
Dr. Epstein wasn't prepared for how aggressively Dershowitz would talk out of turn, but I suppose that's to be expected with the man who represented both OJ Simpson and Jeffrey Epstein
this old man is some kind of vampire... scary... he accuses Iran of being theocratic, quoting the Bible...
Not to mention he’s Jewish and loves to defend Israel, also a major theocracy.
So Iran is theocratic and evil, but how about Israel? Only jews are allowed citizenship and benefits from the state based on their 'birth right' (religious affiliation at birth): access to property, free health care, free annuities, etc. etc.
Do you deny that Iran is an Islamic Republic?
It is theocratic and repressive. Doesn’t mean it isn’t a rational actor on the international stage.
@@samahen522 do you condemn hamas?
I was a reporter in Beirut (2006 ~ish) I travelled through Southern Lebanon with some Hezbollah guys. I was told that if the US ever attacked Iran all hell would break loose . It wasn't a threat. They just saw it as a fact!
Islamic army's are useless,they can only fight from holes.
Dershowitz believed zionist own America and thus should use America for the good of Zionist: this guy sees his people on a different level and America deserves to serve them: 👇
ua-cam.com/users/shorts1SpgUHh3L14?si=XS6Pr3Jx8pZp58fi
Agree this would be a big mistake
There is also the fact of the huge military age population they have. A disaster
They're far stronger now.
I am Iranian
We don't want to restore Pahlavi denasty
We want prince Reza Pahlavi assures a smooth pass from Islamic Republic of Iran to Republic of Iran.
Please understand that Iran is not Iraq, Afghanistan, Lybia, etc
'Iran has weeks, days, minutes to the bomb!'
This has been said for the past 20 years. We are so tired.
"Worse, worser, and worsest", the best lesson I learned from a professor for free.
Imagine people paying to go to Harvard to hear that crap.
A Harvard professor at that!
Glenn was in top form. Every one of his points holds up. Dersh was only recycling Neocon failures and his sole theme is just theoretical opinion.
Relic
The criminals at YuckTub illegally deleted a comment of mine that simply listed the Rules of Just War.
That says everything about them.
They need to be prosecuted.
UA-cam is totally censoring everything
@@drdhakan87 Yes, and it's a violation of The First Amendment.
This is because they are doing it in collusion with Congress, which means they are the proxy of Congress.
And Congress shall make no law abridging the freedom of speech.
That “Iranian” was for sure a plant
Absolutely
Alan Dershowitz: Iran is the new Nazi Germany
Also Alan Dershowitz: Iran is not the new Nazi Germany
What???
Also at 1:39:54 he makes the argument that debating whether it was right to “get into the nuclear deal with Iran or to get out of the nuclear deal with Iran” is yesterdays news, and that this is today, etc…
As if bringing up old events is not pertinent. And yet he gladly and constantly mentions WW2.
@davidswanson5669 He contradicted himself so much that I bet he forgot this was being recorded. How are you gonna gas light us on a statement you made 10 minutes ago? We can rewind this shit! Haha
AD is himself.
@@dvegule920 He comes across as a fascist lunatic.
@@davidswanson5669he goes back as far as the Versailles treaty and how we should have enforced it's terms - a treaty that is 100 years older than the Iran nuclear treaty.
This old man is obsessed with wars and Iran very strange.
Except his family
Typical zionist missionair.
Was that the great Jose Vega with the question at around the 1:28:00 mark?
What's the difference between preventive action and offensive action?
I can’t believe, Harvard professor argues for regime change in an other country in the name of democracy.😂😂😂 Obviously, the professor have a memory loss, he argues North Korea is less evil because it’s not exporting arms to the third party and the same person on the same seat he said Iran gets Nuclear from North Korea
The arrogance & hypocrisy of the US knows no bounds.
@@m.hughes8605 Dershovitz doesn't speak for the US.
@@sabinereynaudsf No, he doesn't, I agree.However the actions & political interference of the US on other sovereign nations does speak volumes for itself.
He is Zoinsit Jew first and then an American citizen, he wants Americans to die to protect this genocidel regime
Wake up America
12:58 How to justify your first strike 'preventive' aggression, while congratulating yourself for being more moral than any other army in the world. insane argument, insulting your intelligence.
what makes it completely insane and blows the mind aside from the consideration of basic historical facts and statistics is that when one might perceive the insanity of an argument there are so many that get swayed and cling to the core instinct of fear and once you can bring that about you can attach anything to that emotion and then totally dismiss rational.
Maybe they have the minority report girls in the pentagon to justify that?
Dersh knows almost ZERO about drones or that whole exercise!
I almost threw up listening Alan's arguments. I kept listening just to be able to list his lies later.
Glenn teaches reason.Alan fought hard to legalize torture in u.s.a.
And fought for the age of consent to be lowered to 14! Something very unsavoury about him!
U.S. has done enough damage since the begining of the last century till now, this garbage of a human waste Derschawitz still is being given a stage is beyond me.
Needs to be noted that Iran's policy is to NOT have nuclear weapons. Also to note that Iran doesn't need nuclear weapons because it has hypersonic missiles which cannot be imtercepted; they likely have lots of them. Further, Russia is not going to let Israel and or the U.S. regime change Iran. If that warmonger thinks Russia is a despotic regime, which it most certainly is not, then that pretty much indicates how Israel sees Russia; F-aroumd with Russia and find out.
Dershowitz: I want regime change in Iran
Greenwald: oh why don't you just just come out and say it
Dershowitz: What? That I want regime change in Iran? I just said that.
Greenwald: We all see past your dogwhistles
Alan went from, "Well, sure, I would like regime change, but this is not about that", to, "It's a two-step process." in a heartbeat.