Conservatives and Progressives Debate Feminism (Extended Version)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 тра 2024
- Progressive and conservative women hash it out in the VICE office. (Watch a shorter version of this debate here: • Conservatives and Prog... )
What does it mean to identify as a feminist? How has Me Too impacted women around the world? Where does abortion wrap up into the broader idea of feminism? What about LGBTQ and trans rights? Who voted for Hillary Clinton, and who voted for Donald Trump?
Watch our previous roundtable discussion between black conservatives and liberals: • Black Conservatives De...
TIMECODES OF WHAT WAS DISCUSSED:
00:00 Intro
0:57 - Who here identifies as a feminist?
1:11 - What does feminism mean to you? Why do you or do you not identify as a feminist?
4:59 - Is the term “feminist” inclusive of all women?
6:43 - If you aren’t a feminist, are you anti-women?
7:19 - Are feminists anti-men?
9:07 - Dissenting opinions on society being “dominated” by men
10:11 - How are we going to create the future we want?
11:13 - Women and the GOP
12:44 - Who here voted for Donald Trump?
16:12 - Hillary Clinton
17:55 - How have Trump voters been treated by progressive women?
19:27 - How does abortion wrap into the idea of feminism?
24:53 - Shaming moms and motherhood
26:43 - “Do you support the Me Too movement?”
27:36 - “Believe all women” debate and Me Too
28:43 - Has work culture changed after Me Too?
29:51 - Trump’s “grab ‘em by the pussy” comments
33:10 - Dating culture after Me Too
34:53 - Consent in relationships
36:14 - Are trans-women helping the women and gender equality movement?
37:59 - Do traditional gender roles have a place in society?
39:48 - Are there ways women are privileged?
Click here to subscribe to VICE: bit.ly/Subscribe-to-VICE
About VICE:
The Definitive Guide To Enlightening Information. From every corner of the planet, our immersive, caustic, ground-breaking and often bizarre stories have changed the way people think about culture, crime, art, parties, fashion, protest, the internet and other subjects that don't even have names yet. Browse the growing library and discover corners of the world you never knew existed. Welcome to VICE.
Connect with VICE:
Check out our full video catalog: bit.ly/VICE-Videos
Videos, daily editorial and more: vice.com
More videos from the VICE network: www. vicevideo
Click here to get the best of VICE daily: bit.ly/1SquZ6v
Like VICE on Facebook: vice
Follow VICE on Twitter: / vice
Follow us on Instagram: / vice
The VICE UA-cam Network:
VICE: / vice
MUNCHIES: / munchies
VICE News: / vicenews
VICELAND: / vicelandtv
Broadly: / broadly
Noisey: / noisey
Motherboard: / motherboardtv
VICE Sports: / noc
i-D: / idmagazine
Waypoint: / waypointvice - Розваги
This is the second extended "roundtable" conversation we held in the VICE office, this time focused on women's rights. Watch the shorter version here: ua-cam.com/video/LVXWPjxbLEY/v-deo.html
You can also watch our previous debate, exploring how black conservatives and black liberals view American politics, right here: ua-cam.com/video/HGAsMtcPy_c/v-deo.html
And when is the debate on men's issues happening?
The issue I and numerous other's have with this round table is OBVIOUS! Seriously, you had just ONE person there who voted for the President. Secondly, this group of individuals DOES NOT REPRESENT the US as a whole, it's evident because we have a Conservative President. The only way to resolve any issues is to have a balance and I noticed as soon as you mentioned the President's name "Trump" almost every person there groaned or made a face. This would not be a reliable consensus at all. The only young lady who wasn't biased against normal thinking was the Trump supporter.
FOR THE LOVE OF ALL THAT IS HOLY DO THIS SAME THING BUT WITH ALL MEN YOU WILL BREAK THE INTERNET
@@OG-MONK-NUMBER1 The question is not when it is happening but who will be in it. If they rush it and fill it with all soyboys then it'll be shit. Get some people on like Dr.Jordan Peterson, Dr.Warren Farrell, etc so that the serious shit doesn't get glossed over.
Good job releasing the full video so quickly. Keep it up.
Adding a few older women would have made this even more interesting
yesss, more age variety = more view points, not just right and left wing.
Older women have a home/mother up bringing. What society needs. Not this hipster bullshit.
I think Katie Hopkins would be perfect for this. Maybe a little bit of “KATIE HOPKINS DESTROYS FEMINISTS”
@@ivanaraujo6425 Yeah Katie Hopkins gonna destroy them.
Need some badass hard working country girls in this group 👍👍👍 Now that would be interesting
“I’m not denying anything. I don’t have that much knowledge of it. So I’m listening, and I’m learning” I feel like if there is one core thing to take from this video it is that one statement because it speaks volumes.
I agree and I also admire those women for that because trans women's rights are often disregarded MASSIVELY in the republican/conservative wave of politics so, as an LGBT woman and supporter, it really hits that they wanted to be informed and learn about the problems so many strong women face daily.
Except she said this and they all continued to silence the trans woman. It’s all very well acknowledging your ignorance if you do nothing to address your structural privilege.
I didn’t’t agree with most of what she said, but she’s not stupid and this is why. She is very open to hearing other ideas. Respect
@Lady Fervor Did you really need to type a book in youtube comments,that makes it ironic you calling others radicalized.
@Lady Fervor All that shit you said was literally to YOURSELF. Seek help.
This is the first panel I've seen where no one aggressively dominated the conversation, everyone got equal voice time, and everyone seemed to actually respect each other, what a great mix of people! So much was said, and with such clairvoyance, I was able to really hear it. I was at ease and engaged the whole time. When other panels get heated, it stresses me out. I felt like I learned a lot on this one. Well done! 💙
I am a democrat and am liberal by nature just like all humans, but what it has turned into the last decade is a real circus. Dont the feminists watching this have any questions or concerns on the obvious question that comes to mind when first tuning in. Is a man really the best women they could find for the job as the host for this feminist discussion?? If they are complaining bout equality in the work place what bout the female imposter hosting this equal unbiased show vice always does a great job of showing both sides thats why they are doing so well in ratings .. girrrrrlllll power !!!!! rahrahrah girls we love u vice
I’m gonna have to somewhat disagree. The young woman in the red jacket sitting in the front row talked over people a lot, at times cutting them off and raising her voice to better control the conversation by drowning out other people’s voices, and by extension their opinion.
@@jackmidst8304it’s because she was talking and they cut her off 😂
Tbf it’s also how the series is produced and edited. They take out anything boring or irrelevant so it could see one side dominates but can also be one side just not being good at debate
respect WHERE ???
Trying to compare smoking weed to sexual assault is a wild ass take.
Whenever I watch these types of videos I pause it and talk to myself about my opinion for like half an hour 😭
Same😂😂😂
Omg I thought I was just being weird haha
Same too😂😂and i thought i was going crazy
I thought I was going insane😂, but it is very therapeutic
lmaooo
“ let’s stop talking and actually do something ”
girl you literally agreed to come to a debate i-
legit 😂
my EXACT sentiments , i paused and said.... why are you here???
They picked the dumbest girl I swear
That’s what I was thinking
😭😭😭😭😭
31:21 that girl is brain washed by her father. Oh my god comparing smoking an herb to sexual harassment blows my mind
I’ve been LOOKING for this comment she got praise when she made the comment she made about not knowing things pertaining to trans people so she was “listening and learning” YET SHE COMPARED SMOKING A DRUG TO SEXUAL ASSAULT like I wanted to throw up
Yeah, she’s a bird and a little pick me.
she only talks from personal expeirence (like with her father or wanting to become a billionaire like trump cuz shes jealous)
Yes! The whole video I was just mind blown that she couldn’t ever see the forest for the trees or see her own hypocrisy.
YESSSS, I'm barely seeing anyone talk about this in the comments. She has such a small mind view on all of these things. Voting for Trump because hes a millionare and she would like to become one too, comparing weed to SA, not comprehending how race can become a factor in politics, and so much more. I have no clue how she wasn't challenged more on her views, they're crazy! It really seems like her political stance was brought up purely by the media and conspiracy theories, especially when she mentioned Beyonce and kept talking about how Hillary tried to "try her" but Donald Trump didn't. @@KFA8piece
This was a very good, honest conversation. I'm glad there wasn't a lot of arguing but a lot of fair perspective and open dialogue. Well done ladies
It’s been a year can we invite these women back and have the discussion again
Agree 100%
That would be very interesting
@usa girl excuse me? It sounds like you don’t know the definition and meaning of the black lives matter movement the movement is to spread awareness and get justice for police brutality victims and hate crime victims it’s equality not superiority
@@saharad650 sis she wants attention that her parents didn’t giver her nobody asked
@@ql3790 her username 😭
Red jacket girl
"I'm not denying anything. I dont have much knowledge on it so I am listening and learning"
Man that was so good!!! Its so much better to be silent than ignorant.
@@SharonBoo0305 so are you saying that the white woman in purple is also unintelligent? I ask because the black woman in red noted several points that the woman in purple agreed with and elaborated on.
@@SharonBoo0305 She's actually very intelligent in the fact that she thinks for herself.
@@SharonBoo0305 she is actually the most intelligent there.
@@SharonBoo0305 Yes I understand all of their opinions, I just respect the girl in the red jacket even more because she doesn't go along with the media narrative that black=Democrat who's victimized because of white peoples "privilege." I liked the purple hair girls "pro-life" feminism. I don't think anyone can even define what feminism actually is anymore lol
Samantha Brown I agree and disagree... I think people shouldn’t be afraid of speaking their truth because they might be ignorant... they should say what they want to say, and if they’re wrong they’ll learn and next time they’ll be a little bit sharper next time they talk about it... but I also agree that you have no opinions about the topic don’t try to make an opinion then and there
This is a wonderful debate, I applaud you women for taking such a respectful approach to discourse and respecting differing opinions. Many of you put me in a positon of agreeing with most of your perspectives, and I really appreciate it. Thank you for showing that we as women can support one another respectfully and support each other's differences and differing opinions.
I would’ve been much more interested in hearing these Individuals reconvene 4 years later, than the most recent version of this debate. This was a thoughtful discussion where everyone shared and listened. I felt like I came away with away new knowledge and questions for myself. The most recent version had a chaotic and hostile vibe to it. Very divisive instead of trying to foster a conversation.
I'm glad everyone is wearing a different colour so they can be identified by everyone commenting 😂
lol
Made me spit out my water
And many hair colors too lol
Lmao
The representation thing is mostly about men who are in charge that know nothing about being a woman and still are in charge of deciding what happens with us. Having females on the board would at least help provide insight on what we need and want. It doesn’t make sense to rule over somebody who you don’t relate to
Y'all saw that look Blair (red headscarf) and Deja (yellow jacket) gave each other when girl in black said she voted for Trump as a "joke".
Oh it’s from this girls Instagram.
Yessss omg it gave me chills
they were looking at eachother like 🤨🤨
@@johnkarsh the girl in the yellow jacket TikTok is Deja_foxx
@@iilxlath9164 what’s the account?!
and this is how we do it. I love Vice debates. The hosts are great, the participants hold strong views but they actually listen to each other and they're willing to understand each other. Every one has good points. And they're from different places. Love it.
I would be really interested to see another one of these now! The world has changed so much in these past three years
They have one but it’s pretty terrible loll it’s called “pro and anti feminist debate”, came out 2 months ago I think! But much messier than this one
The woman in black clothes kept rolling her eyes whenever someone made a better point than her or disproved her statements. Pretty uncool.
it was irritating asf 😕
she pissed me off
She’s the worst
I didn’t even notice! When?
@@courtneylee643 a face only a mother can love
“Do I regret my decision? I-I’m not gonna divulge in that...”
Really sounds like your joke vote for Trump wasn’t a joke vote after all!
Was looking for this!!!
Timestamp please?
@@nbucwa6621 16:00
It was actually revealed she's an adamant trump supporter, the whole make America great again
@@briannamccray7947 I’m not surprised, with all that rambling it seemed she was making it up on the spot, just chatting shi t the whole time 😂
That black business girl with the red hoodie is so fucking brave
This was an awesome discussion! I enjoyed this throughly!
this is way off topic but the moderator has GORGEOUS hair
looks like the standard "cheap-shampoo almost dry but still damp" hairpiece that most black women wear to me.
she's GORGEOUS
Her hair isn't the only thing about her that's gorgeous
stonedNcreepy okay, this is getting supper creepy, super fast.
TelecomTitan not trying to be a white knight but black women genetically have beautiful hair
This is what our Presidential debates should look like. Get rid of the clapping audiences and the manufactured soundbites.
Borp OMG yes.
i remember hearing 100 decibals of that stuff when trumpe said bush allowed the saudi to leave usa during no fly zone LOL.
And ask real questions
That would be pretty AWESOME
The problem is, as presidential candidates they're not allowed to be open minded. They have to be "on brand" for what their campaign is already about, otherwise they'll lose supporters. Hell, they don't even nod when others are speaking because they can't agree to shit. The way things work is too corrupt for it to be like this sadly.
This was the most respectful video I’ve ever seen on these topics😭
Bring them back for another discussion ❤
“well obama smoked weed” BRUH HOW ARE SEXUAL ASSAULT AND SMOKING WEED THE SAME THING I-
prove that he actually sexually assaulted someone
@@mr.z2177 hahahahahahahaha he assumes he has consent that doesn't mean he does. Do you have any idea how many women will freeze up if a man tried to grab them by the crotch and force a kiss onto them? Them freezing in fear is not letting him do anything. Fucking trash human being.
@@ldragon8480 You tell em!!!!
That is exactly what I was thinking!
LMFAO FR IM EMBARRASSED
The woman in the yellow jacket did right by calling out the clown in black to her right who approaches voting as if it's a silly joke. In fact, every time the woman in black spoke I lost more faith in humanity.
@Mas Xam feminism: the advocacy of women's rights on the ground of the equality of the sexes.
@@shannonharris674 dw about this dumbass they're just riling up people in a lot of comments unnecessarily.
@@alenamary3137 I’m not worried just disappointed that people think this way
Yea and she stutter a lot
@@mariaignacio236 stutter is not a bad thing, let’s not do that here
I learned so much listening! Please keep speaking
This was a really interesting discussion! Happy that everyone was calm and not constantly shouting over each othersin anger like we see with a lot of these types of discussions.
this comment section really sleeping on the girl with red hair and bangs. she was so polite and did such a good job of hearing out both sides and trying to come to a middle ground. i didnt agree with everything she said but i really appreciate her!!
Most women are brainwashed, they are afraid of hearing the truth
Actually she was the typical, fat, ugly and wannabe Ms. Know it all.
It’s funny how people look at her and think “typical crazy SJW” when that’s actually the girl in the middle with the yellow coat
Ownage Zizou was
@@decayingdaylight1293 I don't think she acted like a "know it all" at all actually. She was really sweet and willing to hear out everyone's opinions. Like I said, I didn't necessarily agree with everything she said, but I really appreciated the way she behaved. And also if your only way of gaging people's worth and intelligence is from physical appearance.... than you're absolutely wrong for that. It's fucked up to make fun of people for what they can't control and just judge them on things that don't matter. What really matters is her actions and I was happy with how she handled herself.
I like how the group let's individuals speak without interrupting each other.
They did interrupt each other multiple times
Did you watch the full vid?
DogsDreamToo do you know what sarcasm is?
Pomegranate Number 3 I believe it’s called sarcasm buddy
TheRealWallyWest
Why are you gæ
Pomegranate Number 3 you are gae
this is a very good video, it's much better than the most recent one. better managed and with better guests!!!!
The girl with red hair is the most educated person on this panel, and the trans girl has the most experience, and unfortunately didn’t get to speak enough :/
"I'm tired of talking about it" yet you were invited TO TALK on a panel.... girl in red, why are you even there if you're tired of talkin. If you're so about the action then why?!
But also like.... who does she think is doing the action? Girl we been fighting for decades, don't act brand new!
If you are about action you can not participate in debates ?
@@nani2155 You can be ‘pro action’ but the objective is to talk about it.
@Smiles and the Twisted MD I kind of feel sorry for you, it must be difficult for you to discuss your views without pulling out the race card, slandering and name calling, it’s really concerning, I hope that’s not how you talk to people in real life situations. Good luck with future encounters mam.
@Smiles and the Twisted MD oh please this is so embarrassing for you 😭 I hope one day you educate yourself on your opinions and your manners and return and delete these comments 😅
please tell me this girl did not just say that smoking weed and assaulting women are morally equivalent
She sure did
No she did not. Thats what everyone wants to believe.
@@elizabethsessions4486 she did. She literally said to put them on the same line which pretty much means to judge them equally
Yes ma'am
@@elizabethsessions4486 she did she literally said it, she compared the two things implying they are on the same scale.
this was so productive and good wow especially after the last discussion which was a bit of a mess tbh
I appreciate that the host and other women were kind to the heavier brunette and the lady with the long hair in the front row. They seemed to be parroting things they’ve heard and everyone was patient with them and explained their views well.
I feel like purple shirt was the only one of the conservatives who seemed open minded about the topics. She voiced her initial opinions and when other people had rebuttals she listened and didnt just roll her eyes and yell over (unlike the all black and red)...
purple hair was chill too
@@sebces2576 she wasn't conservative
The one to the left of purple haired woman seemed to agree on both sides with certain subjects I liked her too. I think she said shes libertatian she was like the middle man for a good chunk of this conversation which is great! We needed that voice as well
She was the smartest one out of all the panel.
I totally agree and she's gorgeous too!
Shoutout to the girl in purple, I’m not a conservative and I don’t really have many pleasant interactions with conservatives but she actually has a good head on her shoulders and she holds some respectable view points.
I’m a recovering leftist and I’ve found that she’s pretty representative of a lot of conservatives. They’re so much more levelheaded than liberals.
@@ohwellwhateverr the way she holds herself is not the way a lot of conservatives do. She may hold the similar values but the way she represents herself is way more poised than a good percentage of conservatives that I’ve experienced.
@@ja-ys4pf I’ve had different experiences. Liberals have a tendency to act like kids and whine, scream, throw tantrums if they don’t get their way. I’ve found conservatives to be more poised and dignified and more receptive to being asked to explain why they believe what they do.
@@ohwellwhateverr let’s be completely honest when it comes to politics all anyone does is complain and whine about who’s values are more justifiable. Conservatives as well as liberals.
@Amber Leigh Rae conservative /=/ five hundred trumpies
This was an extraordinary dialogue. It's seldom I listen to something like this and come away feeling really enlightened, but that's what happened here.
I am a democrat and am liberal by nature just like all humans, but what it has turned into the last decade is a real circus. Dont the feminists watching this have any questions or concerns on the obvious question that comes to mind when first tuning in. Is a man really the best women they could find for the job as the host for this feminist discussion?? If they are complaining bout equality in the work place what bout the female imposter hosting this equal unbiased show vice always does a great job of showing both sides thats why they are doing so well in ratings .. girrrrrlllll power !!!!! rahrahrah girls we love u vice
This discussion is so much better than the most recent one. The women here are much more articulate and civil.
I like the moderator. She obviously was more of a leftist but didn't express bias to the conservative women.
Not a good moderator then. You want them to be completely unbiased.
@@nbtino73 she was completely unbiased. She expressed none of her personal views and let everyone talk, still a pretty good moderator to me.
Wish You Were Here: U dunno if She was a lefty. But I was looking for a comment like that, She was amazing! Super likeble, beautiful And very professional. She Did exectlly what She was supposed to do And made the ladies feel comfortable And express their views.
@@Anastazka00 I mean I just assume so since Vice is very liberal. But yeah, she was great!
@@nbtino73 how would they be unbiased?
“I don’t publicize my votes, actually” girl you coulda just sat there quietly 😂 now we all know you voted for him
People dont say who they voted for, no matter what political side, because of people like you.
Haley Tully the other conservatives in this video were doxxed and had to change their names because people who prop up love and acceptance are the first to threaten and hate others.
Right but she couldnt handle the fact that if she didnt raise her hand it wpuld look like she voted hillary😂
@@lauraellen5270 proof?
everyone under this comment who getting mad definitely voted for trump😭
What a great panel. I was really surprised
Great panel, kept me interested till the end.
The girl with the red hair is so great at expressing her point of view whether those are in agreement or not
Yes, she expresses herself super well. I don't even agree with her viewpoint necessarily since she's a (right) libertarian and I'd consider myself a libertarian socialist (it's different), but she's very intelligent and is extremely well-spoken. She also has great style and is quite pretty
@@yespls4184 libertarian socialist is oxymoronic
@mar not necessarily. On a large scale that is true, but it is very possible to have a libertarian socialist system when you are dealing with small groups, the authoritarianism only becomes necessary and inherent to socialism once the group in question exceeds a hundred people or so.
@@micfail2 exactly, small groups. it is utterly impractical and goes against libertarian basis
I agree. She was able to articulate her views very well. In fact, I liked how this conversation went. We need more of this because the more it devolves into screaming and anger the more ppl can label women as crazy and irrational. It's better to have allies than enemies.
The girl wearing all black was giving me...ion like poc and “it’s cause I’m Jewish” lady from target vibes😕
They face she made at 40:44
Oooooot
Oddly specific but accurate
Nailed it
This is such a hard topic for me being Jewish because on one hand we’re fighting anti-semitism and on the other hand we’re fighting people this girl who has no idea how privileged she is. White privilege is real.
I really enjoyed this particular debate, more so with how most of the people were just very open to listening and understanding within different view sets. Very interesting and informative from a non American woman. 👍
I am a democrat and am liberal by nature just like all humans, but what it has turned into the last decade is a real circus. Dont the feminists watching this have any questions or concerns on the obvious question that comes to mind when first tuning in. Is a man really the best women they could find for the job as the host for this feminist discussion?? If they are complaining bout equality in the work place what bout the female imposter hosting this equal unbiased show vice always does a great job of showing both sides thats why they are doing so well in ratings .. girrrrrlllll power !!!!! rahrahrah girls we love u vice
I appreciate that you kept the comments open on this one, unlike on others.
Girl in red fr said “i always look at every side or else your gonna get eaten alive” BUT THE WHOLE TIME SHE CLOSE MINDED AS HELLLL
I actually think she may not be neurotypical. Especially in the beginning she does a lot of stimming behavior. Not saying that justifies her behavior but it could account for some of her interrupting, rocking etc.
@@lunarforte9515 I don’t agree with her views but did we watch the same video ? Because she wasn’t interrupting anybody and was making eye contact with everyone speaking giving them the floor. As for her being a conservative I do think that’s why she was automatically so defensive. I think that she was a poor choice candidate.
Literally 💀💀
I think she does represent a group of women in America though which is sad
BRUH WHY NO ONE TALKING ABOUT THE WHITE GIRL SAYING SHE VOTED FOR TRUMP AS A JOKE AND ALL THEM SIDE EYEING HER
Edit: I also want to state for ppl on my ass about the specifics of trumps corruptness and whether or not specific things are valid i high-key don’t care you’re taking it up w/ the wrong person i made this comment to make a fun of someone for being dumb
she was sweating like satan in a church
She sounded so nervous when explaining, after they owned her 💀
the girl beside her and the one behind her in the hijab were staring at each other like 👀 behind her back while she talked. i cackled. love nonverbal communication between women when someone else is being absolutely wild for no reason.
It wasn’t a joke those Bernie supporters just didn’t say it, but they voted trump out of anger when they felt like the democratic party betrayed them by fcking bernie up multiple times.
@Eli he fucked with the votes and the whole election what do you mean..
Why does vice ALWAYS only have 2 conservatives and 5 liberals.
Because they are extremely left wing and want to spread liberal propaganda.
Wow, not even two minutes in; Blair Imani gave such a beautiful, complete answer. Very impressive. Knowledge is power. 🙌❤️
y’all talking about the girl in red but the girl in black just literally said “i voted for him as a joke” come on now.
They both said some crazy things. I was all types of shook. 🙀
at least she recognized that wasn't cool and said she thought it was inappropriate now
yeah, i didn't like her at all.
I'm glad the independent woman to the left of the woman with purple hair spoke after them who didnt vote for either...I needed someone to explain the situation America was in during that election and how low the candidates were at the time.
The others who were against the trump voters were rolling their eyes acting like Hillary was the savior of the universe and I'm glad she put out there that she wasnt.
Ppl would love the girl in red jacket exactly as she is if she identified as liberal.🙄
Can we just take a moment to applaud the moderator?! Absolutely amazing job at being or at least not showing your bias
its edited
I felt like she didnt even need to be their has these girls are beating her to her questions she wants to ask from the girls.
i could see it in her face.
Lol no
@@isaacvankooten8850 me too. It's pretty clear where she stands on the issues. Her facial expressions gave it away.
Sex is observed at birth, not
assigned.
Theres no guess work or arbitrary assignment taking place.
Man this is so so much more of a helpful debate than the one vice put on three years later with the same demographic. Its almost like our brains are rapidly declining and our ability to have a conversation
when politics get more radical, so do the conversations surrounding them. both sides have been radicalized which makes it a lot harder to reach common ground.
“I’m not denying anything, I don’t know a lot about this so I’m listening” more people need to do this. Critical thought isn’t valued anymore
Yellow coat was trying hard to call them out but I’m actually glad red hood said that
@@mnlyt2942 And there’s not much to understand. Glad she called out. Yellow shirt did well.
Totally agree, Red jacket said that perfectly.
@Different Pound And that's why you should never debate with radical feminist women on Twitter. They're as much moronic as they would be on other social media outlets.
@@VvvvvaVvvvvvr In their defense, the gynocentric society in some ways are backing the LGBTQ community. Solely because they feel like they're not the worst people on the planet. They're as much law abiding and influential to society. That's why they favor them over the heterosexual world.
The girl who voted as a joke didn’t want to listen to anything and let making faces like 😑😑
and how the girl in the yellow sweater and the girl with the yellow jacket looked at each other when she said it- like ‘is this lady serious?’
I feel like she was super nervous the whole time
I don’t believe she meant what she said about voting for him as a “joke.”Even though she tried to recant that statement, I believe she intentionally voted for Trump. It was right after she said it that she immediately felt condemnation from other ladies, therefore, she blurted out this nonsense of voting for him as a joke. She wasn’t true to her beliefs and seemed more concerned about what the other ladies thought of her. I voted for Trump the 2nd time around and I have no problem admitting it.
People pleasers do not belong in these types of conversations..
Voting for someone just because theyre a woman is just as stupid.
@@2expressmranderson I couldn’t agree more. I might vote for a woman someday down the road, but she must be worthy of a vote and must put The People first. Hillary would have been a nightmare of a president, IMO.
I gotta say, love the name ‘Dee Nasty’ 😂😂
Great conversations! The questions were asked a bit too quickly... Anyways, there should be more of these comprehensive debates around feminism! And not just these long talks on how men are isolated because of us getting more freedom...
Red jacket girl has no idea as to what she is talking about! Lord she should have educated herself!
amen!!
Very painful to watch. I’m embarrassed that she was the representative for black women. I don’t care that she voted for Trump, I care that she’s intellectually lazy.
I had to keep stopping and coming back to it . She is so ignorant and I’m so embarrassed on her behalf
Totally agree! She doesn’t even sound educated on her choices.
Its just your minds that cant comprehend to wat she is actualy trying to say. Open up your closed single track thinking mind
I absolutely LOVED when the girl in red said "I don't have much knowledge on it, so I'm listening and learning." Like, what the hell! That is so amazing!
why tho ? that’s what you at least have to do
Two reasons. One, it's plain honesty, and second, it's a show that she isn't just there to assert her views or support some agenda.
She has a differing view from others, and unlike the way most people seem to behave, she's genuinely interested to know why others see things the way they do.
@@carlosgomezjimenez4458 yeah, what Kris Anticknap said. In my opinion, it shows humility, and although it does seem like the bare minimum a person can do, most humans don't even do that. Humility isn't the easiest trait to develop but it sure as all hell is one of the most impressive.
@@carlosgomezjimenez4458 some don't listen to understand but to respond
I like her the most
In hindsight this was probably one of the most productive conversations VICE has had.
I have been on a binge of such panels and this is the first panel where both sides are making intelligent well-reasoned arguments, listening to the other side, conceding respectfully when the truth is obvious instead of just being blind and deaf to the reality. I saw nuance to who people understand as Conservative v Progressive labels. For these panelists, the labels are not static but rather their stand on each issue is specific to that issue and not a monolithic approach. Basically, BRAVO to them!
why is no one talking about how pretty the girl with the head scarf is, not to mention she is super intelligent
@@oldworldstarkeo Ooo preach 🙏
follow her instagram @blairimani!! she is super eloquent and informed :)
Because we are talking about intellect dear. Take your internalised misogyny elsewhere
@@patienceRachel that's not internalized misogyny, I just noticed that she was very pretty while they were talking and didn't see anyone say it so I did. I was just trying to give her a complement.
@@oldworldstarkeo I was actually very interested by the whole conversation, I was not trying to detract from the conversation just trying to give her a compliment because I thought she was pretty. I did not mean this comment to come off how I'm guessing it did.
Did she really say smoking is equal to sexual assault ???? I cannot deal with her
no she didn't
@@chynacriselle she basically did but ok
@@chynacriselle she said we had to hold smoking and sexual assault "to the same line"...
Yikes 😬
This comment of your shows that u dint understand wat she said. Neither do u knw wat exactly trump said n never read his whole sentence
This group had a much better flowing conversation than the one from 2 months ago, the pro and anti feminist talk.
They were all profesional and legit debaters.good job ladies 👏🏼
Y’all are dogging on the girl in the yellow jacket but can we get a thank you for her calling out the girl that voted “as a joke.”
she misspoke. her point was that she wasn't an actual trump supporter, she just hated hillary and wanted to vote against her. the girl in the yellow jacket responded in a way that was rude and arrogant.
actually voting as a joke would be more like "lol i don't know anything about politics but trump memes are funny so im voting for him." she made it pretty clear that she was a bernie supporter and was actively involved in his campaign which shows that she is informed.
@@cinnamonspice8657 Whether she misspoke or not, we got her intention. She didn't think her vote matter without realizing how many people she could have hurt. She's disgusting and I'm glad she's getting shamed.
Love her.. protect her at all costs
Finger snaps to her for calling her out on that ! I was like damn must be nice to be ✨privileged ✨
@@cinnamonspice8657 no she did not misspeak, she said what she said. you’d think if she was such a big fan of bernie, then she’d vote for hillary since he did in fact endorse her. this election was so important, the girl in the yellow responded exactly how she should’ve. was not rude nor ignorant. and if it was then the girl in black shouldve never said it in the first place.
Purple haired lady's views on abortion were so much more nuanced that other pro-lifers. I'm pro-choice, but props to her
We are pro life because abortion is murder! Science tells us that
@@User-fp8dk Science tells you the exact opposite, babe.
@@ginnundso biology states that life is formed from conception
@@User-fp8dk Biology states that after 12 weeks the embryo is called a fetus. Until then it can not feel pain as the nerve system in the back is only developed after week 12. Also, biology defines a living creature according to this:
- Ability to Reproduction (Embryo doesn't have this)
- Metabolism
- Irritability (Embryo doesn't have this)
- Ability to grow
- Evolution (Embryo doesn't have this)
- Self-regulation (don't know if embryos can do that)
So in conclusion: out of 6 features which define a living creature, the embryo only has 3 or 2. Therefore, your statement is false. Where I got to know what defines a living creature? In grammar school in Germany. I have biology since 7 years. And what defines a living creature is what we had first and what we always mentioned every two years again.
@@ginnundso are you serious? So you support people killing their babies? People try so hard to get pregnant and some can’t, and to just throw away a life like that tells how selfish liberals like you are. You’re NOT equal. And there’s no denying in that.
I like the black woman dressed in red, she seems to be the smartest one and the one that understand what is happening. Also the white woman dressed in blue and the white one with blue hair.
This was a wonderful debate
you guys r dragging the girl in the yellow jacket because she called out the girl in black for voting as a “joke”, as she should.
fr also ur pfp is beautiful stan clairo
I think she was just confused bc she actually did say it was a joke but then elaborated and they were fine :/
if you don't recognize that kind of condescending behavior for what it is then you have obviously never experienced it. the girl in black was not as confident as you can tell by her body language and the few times she stumbled over her words which is why she misspoke. the yellow jacket girl saw that and wanted an opportunity to make fun of her.
@@kirz10q21 omg ty 😁😁
@@cinnamonspice8657 she didn’t make fun of her she pointed out that she had privilege
"Smoking weed is illegal in some places."
Sexual assault and harassment is illegal everywhere
And morally too
But he didnt sexually assault anyone atcall
@@henrymoore3905 yes he did. Look it up
@@turningoff1493 not in the context of him saying “grab her by the pussy”
@@jamztwink18 he did heaps more than that
"Can i curse?" Because this was fucking amazing! Loved this conversation and these amazing women so much. I came directly from the newer video and that was complete dogshit rage bait. Gather these women again please
Wish I could have been part of this interview!!!
Girl in the red hijab CARRIED this convo
That's not a hijab.
@@Reiner914 just a scarf pretty much
@@Reiner914 why is it not?
@@af2954 its more of a head scarf or a veil. a hijab is different
@@Reiner914 she literally said ‘as a hijabi’
i LOVE the woman with purple hair! im pro-choice but the way she put down her pro-life views was fantastic. she didnt shame women. she did make it a negative. she didnt call it murder. she said “i understand why women do it, how can we try and stop this from happening” what a fantastic take! she’s definitely my favorite out of the group.
It's sad that this is refreshing. It used to be the case that "pro-choice" people wanted abortion to be "safe, legal, and rare." I want all of us to try to minimize the need and incidence of abortion, regardless of our various stances. That shouldn't be an ideological issue.
That’s because “Feminist for Life” don’t get any media play. Their mesg is rarely heard. If you think she’s great. This talk from the president of “Feminist for Life” is beautifully amazing!!! Such an honest convo without shaming or berating others.
I agree!
ddlyify that’s true. There are more abortions among the black population in New York City than there are live births. There seems to be a disregard for protection and safe sex. Abortion would not be a huge issue as it is now if we went to the root of the issue.
And there are a lot of issues that should be solved by tackling the roots instead of the aftermath. High crime rates in minority communities? Police reforms are one response, but a much better one would be increasing education quality for children there and increasing community works and employment.
@@alberthammons7782 cool send me to hell then
It's a shame most of the progressives were a bit quiet throughout with the exception of the one in the top left. The conservatives and that libertarian ran their mouth almost the entire time. That one chick in the front right barely said anything at all. People keep talking about it being civil, but it was just the same talking points, over and over and over and over again with a few dominating the whole thing.
I loved how civil and calm yet intelligent this debate was.
Omg what an original comment 💀 u totally didn't just copy this 🎉
So we all agree that the moderator is drop dead geogous
She looks goofy
For sure but she also looks like a time traveller
That's all you took from this video?
G Zino said who
Dee Nasty. Would love to explore why she gave herself that name😅
Red jacket mad annoying, it’s not by the fact that she’s a trump supporter it’s just her whole delivery of her explanations, saying a whole bunch of nothing, I wanna be a millionaire too but girl I-
@Ann nobody said anything about Obama.
@Ann Interesting, thanks for listing examples and links
@Ann good job on the copy pasta
she look like nathan davis jr
@@laiii5195 yea yea
Bring them back !! We need to hear what they have to say now, I t’s been 4 years I think it’s time !!!
This was truly a great discussion. I hope this can be the blueprint for many legislation being made, listen to women
Red HAIR was the star of this conversation.
STAR! Ok
Aaand yellow coat girl😌
agreed she was awesome
She was great. I really liked yellow jacket and orange top aswell.
Anybody got red hair insta or Twitter
“Can we cuss?” the intellectual of the group inquired.
I guess cussing makes you dumb? lol maybe she was worried she’d get very passionate about a topic and may cuss.
Personally, I don't think cursing is immediately the sign of a person with low intellect because I feel far more egregious things happen in this world to be overly offended by cussing.
- I get that👌
- I think it’s ok to get passionate in an argument.
Mags Honey I agree as long as they aren’t cussing AT each other then it’s okay yknow
This was a 1000 times better than the new one
I was going to start on my assignment but got so invested I still haven’t typed one word. All I see is people from the left and right being in opposition together. So many agreements and overlap. Let’s work together more ❤
I bet red hijab and yellow coat legit became friends after this...
Fr lmao
Absolutely
Yupppp
they need a podcast
But red hijab is also wearing a yellow coat had me confused for a second.
The girl in the red jacket is talking about she’s for action and tired of talking but she’s asking what “we’re” going to do. Umm if you’re about action what have YOU done? What are you doing???
Bee M. yeah that was stupid of her to say that
EXACTLY!!
She was pissing me TF off
The more she talked the dumber she sounded
And to be clear it wasn't how she spoke, it was the way she threw opinion out as if it were hard fact just like the idiot she voted for
It’s amazing how people still can’t wrap their heads around intersectionality. “I thought we were talking about politics, not color” … “because they’re intertwined “👏🏼
I absolutely love the youngest voice has a position and willing to stand for it. Consistency, done her father proud!!
Ngl, the two I thought were going to be the stereotypical internet feminist were actually very mature (dyed hair women). I guess I just got my prejudices checked.
true
I guess that’s why the statement goes, “It’s best not to judge a book by it’s cover,” haha
Oh gosh when she said she was pro-life I was shook lol. But also very happy to hear more women with the same beliefs 🤗
No your prejudgment isn’t failing you. I know those colored hair women were smart but there are like a outliner among the actual colored hair girls who act ridiculous. Nearly all the colored hair girls I met were either completely lost or didn’t even know what I was talking about.
Same here.
you should not vote if you are going to take it as a joke. so sad.
Voting is an illusion
She explained that it wasn't a joke, as she said. Ppl make word errors sometimes. I bet u have before
@@strangerinmoscow6858 she clearly said she took the vote as a joke?? what is there to explain.
Bro. She said it and corrected herself. Furthered what she meant. Get over it
@@strangerinmoscow6858 THEN DONT reply to ME?? I don’t CARE if she worded it wrong DONT TAKE VOTING AS A JOKE. YOU are clearly not over it.
Opening question "are you allowed to swear ? "
Why you bringing that energy ?
As a man, I really appreciate having the chance to hear perspectives and discussions like this. Thank you Jubilee.
BEST VICE MODERATOR
she didn't seem biased and was respectful & kind to everyone :)
i totally agree, it’s bothered me that vice’s moderators are so biased. ESPECIALLY the trans discussion moderator. dee was a breath of fresh air and helped the conversation flow.
Watch the conservative blacks and the liberal blacks. The moderator was amazing in that one too
the black liberal/conservative debate mod was my favorite (he actually broke up arguments when they got out of hand)
And she’s pretty cute, too.
My second favorite. You should watch the black conservative vs liberal one. This guy is so in biased it’s crazy. He’s my favorite by far. But this girl is my second.
I LOVE how the girl in the yellow jacket kept talking louder even when she was being interrupted
Yessss she was honestly I think the best one here. I feel like she just won’t act the way others want her or expect her to act
She was great, I anticipated more when she spoke.
she was disgusting lmfao
It looks more like beige
@@awesometimesabillion that’s the best thing you can say 😂💀
I know that this video is only 4 years old but I think this discussion would have been very different today. So interesting to see the shift in the feminist movement even in such a short time