@Akmal Ahmad Yes, that is why it all looks so fake and bad. Every dialog scene outside is in studio CGI background with fake lighting and you can see the CGI visual elements not even well blended together. What do you expect from a film with VFX effects hastily done in a few months.
@@smally7505 Social Network or Gravity. Problem with these Avengers movies is, that it uses CGI even where it doesnt need to. And the lighting is very bad. Most of the time you clearly see that actors just stand in a studio with green screen behind them and it is very off putting and immersion breaking.
NecumNaTo I agree that the marvel movies over use cgi when it isn’t necessary, but are you really going to compare how scarily realistic josh brollan looks as thanos to fucking social network??? At least grab a movie with a plot not written by a four year old.
Light is why we can see things at all-makes sense that lighting affects the realism of a scene! A potentially great and fun example: super old video games, re-rendered using modern Raytracing-those blocky polygons and old textures suddenly look more life-like and realistic!
disney is very rich and hollywood don't likes them. They created the best animation to stop having to give their cartoons the best picture. Disney would win almost every year lots of categories if allowed. That is part of reason why hollywood is not based in the tecnical aspects so much, popular movies is not very well seen, is something political and based on what actors and directors enjoy
@@llekseich it's cgi . usually computer animation software have stock textures they can slap on to any 3d model with necessary fixings and then put it in the green screen then editing , lighting , it goes through various stages to make it blend in with the actors
*Vfx artists are the real super heros of these movies and they hardly get any credit for all the hard efforts and time they put into making these movies possible, hattzoff to all the teams*
When there is good CGI, there will still be criticism and complaints from the audience. When there is incredible CGI, no one would even notice it because it would be indistinguishable from reality. Unless those incredible scenes that are actually made up from CGI is revealed later on.
@@alexwales8914 im suprised i tought they atleast shot the city fight in a city so the fire the black order the ring was cgi but not the hole god dame city or the building we saw when tony walked out of the house
The scenes for black panther where sent of to the VFX artists late, so they didn't have enough time to render it. They had to use fast render settings so they could have it in time but that meant it looked worse. The same people that did Avengers: Infinity War did Black Panther as far as I remember.
mike mirabile what programs are used the most, while making a films like this? and for each program do you mind telling me what they are used for? or is it a bit of everything to make a final design (if that makes sense)
@@koolbeans9139 so depends on what you do. It would be easier for me to tell you the software companies rather than the particular products since they change quite often. Autodesk is a big one. Allegorithmic is rising quite steady along with Quixel. SideFX with houdini is used for most VFX. Obviously Adobe products for most 2D needs. There are tons of lesser used ones such as Cinema4D or MODO. As for Rendering and their Engines almost every studio has their own because that is what gives it the "Marvel" look. Shader artists are almost exclusively using HLSL if you're interested in that. There are so many to go into, i apologize that i couldn't get into more detail
Great work overall although I recall the shot of the Iron Man mask completing its nanotech formation over Tony’s eyes being strangely soft and kinda fake-looking and it’s interesting that they omit that shot specifically while showing the moments just before it.
MCAN - Piano Henry Cavill was filming MI Fallout and director Christopher McQuarrie insisted that he can't shave the mustache his character sports in the movie. So for Justice League, while all the fuss was happening with Whedon entering and them doing reshoots, instead of giving Henry/Superman a beard, they removed his upper lip somehow while trying to remove the mustache, it was a bit disturbing in the movie. Of course, everyone noticed it and everyone laughed at them.
100% CGI Humans with realistic animations are incredibly hard to pull off even for a team of highly skilled and seasoned CG Artists. Big VFX studios still need the help of actors to cooperate with them for cutting edge 3D scanning.
Is that Maya? The realistic quality pays credence to the power of render engines. I could only imagine how long that took to render. I want to make something now.
As long as we can blur the fuck out, its a good shot. Makes very little sense to create whatever shots and blur it beyond recognition. But I guess thats what directors think kiddies HAVE TO LOVE.
"Omg that suit transformation looked so fake!" Yeh, I didn't here you complain about the full CG coat as well or that the wall that stark leant up against was a blue screen. Insanely hard working artists on these films.
Some dudes here act like they are VFX masters and can see through layers of blending graphics, and some dudes saying Marvel was able to pulled off these effects while DC can't do a mustache bla bla bla, although the two companies are not the one who did these visual effects :v
This is just awesome. From the breakdown to the final output, this here gets me extremely excited for a career change. Does anyone know what software is being used? I just graduated for motion design but am now learning Maya and want to get into this industry. Any info would be greatly appreciated.
To make a movie it take like 1year or more (something like that) and the question is how much they are actually recording per day 5-10mins? i am aware that this depends of what kind of movie it is and because the scene isn't perfect from the first shot is just a dumb question if anyone knows i am listening
Holy shit that closeup of Maw was something else
exactly, his eye movements creeped me out lol
Looked pretty much real
@Klumsy Kameleon You need a server with a loot of GPUs and days to render it to final form :D
Klumsy Kameleon You'd need a nuclear power plant to run it.
@@xTomikk_ cpus
Best CGI shots are those which you can't realize that they are CGI shots.
So basically none from Infinity War. The CGI is so obvious there it hurts.
NecumNaTo Compared to? Infinity war and end game have literally the best vfx ever put on the big screen
@Akmal Ahmad Yes, that is why it all looks so fake and bad. Every dialog scene outside is in studio CGI background with fake lighting and you can see the CGI visual elements not even well blended together. What do you expect from a film with VFX effects hastily done in a few months.
@@smally7505 Social Network or Gravity. Problem with these Avengers movies is, that it uses CGI even where it doesnt need to. And the lighting is very bad. Most of the time you clearly see that actors just stand in a studio with green screen behind them and it is very off putting and immersion breaking.
NecumNaTo I agree that the marvel movies over use cgi when it isn’t necessary, but are you really going to compare how scarily realistic josh brollan looks as thanos to fucking social network??? At least grab a movie with a plot not written by a four year old.
It's really the lighting and compositing that sells these effects.
yeah that's really what sets great VFX apart from mediocre one
No the lighting makes this all look super flat and fake.
Herman Falck How I’m sorry, where have you seen better?
Light is why we can see things at all-makes sense that lighting affects the realism of a scene!
A potentially great and fun example: super old video games, re-rendered using modern Raytracing-those blocky polygons and old textures suddenly look more life-like and realistic!
@@Lucalaurin aqa!
How did this not win the Oscar for best visual effects
This was nominated
disney is very rich and hollywood don't likes them. They created the best animation to stop having to give their cartoons the best picture. Disney would win almost every year lots of categories if allowed. That is part of reason why hollywood is not based in the tecnical aspects so much, popular movies is not very well seen, is something political and based on what actors and directors enjoy
0:43 I can't believe the wall isn't even real wow
Jorgino you cant just build or bring a wall only for a scene that is only several seconds
But what is it? Is it a 3D wall, or a photo projected onto 3D geometry?
@@llekseich I don't understand what you mean. A 3D scan?
@@llekseich it's cgi . usually computer animation software have stock textures they can slap on to any 3d model with necessary fixings and then put it in the green screen then editing , lighting , it goes through various stages to make it blend in with the actors
@@phoenixstudios7520 I'd wager it's just a projection
GTAV Soundtrack -
Artemy Maltsev whats the name of it
"We Were Set Up"
Many thanks!
was looking for this comment
It's all I could think about watching this. Dammit Lamar, try to keep up fool!
I think this movie will be nominated for Visual effects, very complicated scenes and they do it so well
But First man got the oscar, Infinity was deserved oscar over First man
no, because the effects weren’t nominee standard. iron man looks like rubber
That slow motion close up shot of Tony... that is simple one of the most oddly satisfying shot ever made
*Vfx artists are the real super heros of these movies and they hardly get any credit for all the hard efforts and time they put into making these movies possible, hattzoff to all the teams*
When there is good CGI, there will still be criticism and complaints from the audience.
When there is incredible CGI, no one would even notice it because it would be indistinguishable from reality. Unless those incredible scenes that are actually made up from CGI is revealed later on.
Even if it looked real, something like that massive ring is obviously impossible to do in real life and could only be vfx.
@@alexwales8914 im suprised i tought they atleast shot the city fight in a city so the fire the black order the ring was cgi but not the hole god dame city or the building we saw when tony walked out of the house
@@adrianstjarnfaldt395 cg cities aren't that bad to build compared to other things these guys do
@@Mandelasmind yes
I guess these guys were too busy making Avengers, that they couldn't help to make the special effects on Black Panther better.
The scenes for black panther where sent of to the VFX artists late, so they didn't have enough time to render it. They had to use fast render settings so they could have it in time but that meant it looked worse. The same people that did Avengers: Infinity War did Black Panther as far as I remember.
@@shorm. yeah I heard they had like two weeks or something
@@shorm. they were 2 different vfx studios.
Probably saving up for infinity war and stuff
Played this in 0.25x. They always show these things way too fast. Really interesting to take a closer look at their great work!
You can use . And , to ser it frame by frame, you’re welcome
@@Matt.visualz You're the goat, thank you!
@@Whopcap haha you're welcome man. After i learned it i use it all the time haha
Outstnading work guys as always you do the best VFX in films!!!
0:13 if you pause the video where the circle movement vfx is, you can see that they made it in february 2018, only 2 months before the full movie
Artists should be paid better.
Xavier H for blurring?
i work in 3D animation and VFX. We are paid very well usually . We definitely arent starving artists
I'm glad to hear that, I'd like to work as a 3D artist in the future
mike mirabile what programs are used the most, while making a films like this? and for each program do you mind telling me what they are used for? or is it a bit of everything to make a final design (if that makes sense)
@@koolbeans9139 so depends on what you do. It would be easier for me to tell you the software companies rather than the particular products since they change quite often. Autodesk is a big one. Allegorithmic is rising quite steady along with Quixel. SideFX with houdini is used for most VFX. Obviously Adobe products for most 2D needs. There are tons of lesser used ones such as Cinema4D or MODO. As for Rendering and their Engines almost every studio has their own because that is what gives it the "Marvel" look. Shader artists are almost exclusively using HLSL if you're interested in that. There are so many to go into, i apologize that i couldn't get into more detail
The fact that any of this is possible is absolutely mind blowing!!
Stunning!
The blurry background looked like a picture in the movie. It was so noticable.
Where is it in here?
u clearly know nothing about VFX
Marvel did all this and DC couldn't even get a mustache right?
seriously, but it was worth it for Mission Impossible: Fallout
Randy no excuses
Jae Lee Budget
Goliath Projects Justice League and Infinity War had roughly the same budget.
LoL
Excellent Work ,blow my mind ,this video help me to show value of 3d and VFX Artist
*this music is giving me GTA flashbacks*
Which music it is?
Vaibhav_ panchariya “we were set up”
CGI in these Marvel movies is just breathtaking 👏👏
Right
Excellent work as always!
I salute to VFX maker teams, 😍
This is insane 🔥
500th comment: Film Making have drastically changed the whole scenario of watching SUPERHERO movies. It gives us a great experience.
Awesome VFX
Marvelous job! But can you tell us if Tony's glasses disappeared during his suit-up because they are a part of his nanotech?
Cheers :)
Yes, the glasses are part of the armor.
Did none of you see him taking off his glasses
Yeah, didn’t he throw them onto the ground or something?
He removed his glasses, and then they literally disappeared from view as the suit formed around him.
They disappeared cause they were made of that nanotech as well, so they tranformed and became part of the armor
This movie had better win the Oscar for best visual effects
Great work overall although I recall the shot of the Iron Man mask completing its nanotech formation over Tony’s eyes being strangely soft and kinda fake-looking and it’s interesting that they omit that shot specifically while showing the moments just before it.
I believe different company did that shot (not Framestore).
Tom cruise will puke after watching so much vfx
is it because he doesn't know that 90% of his practical effects are fixed or replaced with cgi?
2:04
Why did CGI Doctor Strange looks like Johnny Sins
Or deadpool
😂😂
And first man got the oscar! This movie deserved it
Idk why ppl complain when there's too much CGI in a movie, if it's good CGI, who cares?
Because the cgi looked half baked
Iron man looks so unreal now, no real weight
Bruuhh i thought they were real buildings
Lmao same😂
Roope Uski marvel is toooooo lazy
Seventhyz Yes they are so lazy, why cant they blow up real buildings in New York
@@briskryant1286 stupid that's not what I meant
@@zeqx4400 pretty sure making an entire scene with flawless VFX is not lazy.
maw cgi is better than what is supposed to be called steppenwolf in 'that' movie.
Aiman H yeah right. It's amazing that a side character/secondary villain has more detail then the main antagonist of 'that movie'
Steppenwolf is way better though. This one looks so unrealistic
Gambello nice joke
Gambello steppencrap is a shit
maw looks more realistic than goro from mortal combat, and that was an animatronic puppet.
That's so cool. We'd love to composite on a movie like this, too.
Holy gods, Maw is gorgeous all around
JESUS ESTÁ VOLTANDO!!!
I could watch this all day long
I love your work and it's breakdowns. Also the song was very nice, isn't it from GTA?
Yes it is
It's the song played when u start flying
Yeah, "We Were Set Up" from GTA 5
son:mom can I have tony stark
mom: but we already have tony stark at home
tony stark at home : 1:21
BOI
I know GTA V music when I hear it! lol
That one dislike is from Thanos but you're getting yours next year bro
This is f*cking awesome and unbelievable at the same time. Good job
Man it would feel awesome to be on the set
And to think DC couldn't even remove a mustache......
Excuse me, ı just didnt hear about the
MCAN - Piano Henry Cavill was filming MI Fallout and director Christopher McQuarrie insisted that he can't shave the mustache his character sports in the movie. So for Justice League, while all the fuss was happening with Whedon entering and them doing reshoots, instead of giving Henry/Superman a beard, they removed his upper lip somehow while trying to remove the mustache, it was a bit disturbing in the movie. Of course, everyone noticed it and everyone laughed at them.
Batman v Superman's CGI was far more superior than this shit. Iron Man literally looks like a PS3 game.
@@3mbthelabel Imagine being this mad
@@NieColall Yeah, you?
I am so excited to learn VFX!
I hope that I might create something awesome like this in future.
Just replace all the actors with CGI. No need to worry about contracts, pay disputes, and scheduling conflicts.
voice actors?
in about 10 years we will start seeing that too.
they are actual actors. much faster to create human like movement when it's done by a human.
100% CGI Humans with realistic animations are incredibly hard to pull off even for a team of highly skilled and seasoned CG Artists. Big VFX studios still need the help of actors to cooperate with them for cutting edge 3D scanning.
+Wayne Xin Quan fgktkgfjfhtjttit
Wow man this actor are amazing they just doing act by imagining
Is that Maya? The realistic quality pays credence to the power of render engines. I could only imagine how long that took to render. I want to make something now.
As long as we can blur the fuck out, its a good shot.
Makes very little sense to create whatever shots and blur it beyond recognition.
But I guess thats what directors think kiddies HAVE TO LOVE.
"Omg that suit transformation looked so fake!"
Yeh, I didn't here you complain about the full CG coat as well or that the wall that stark leant up against was a blue screen. Insanely hard working artists on these films.
Very nice work!
THIS IS SO COOL OMG
This made my day
Amazing!
4 buildings and computer. "I can do this all day" 🎯🧢 "we're in the endgame now" 🤖👨🔧
Damn this so freaking cool
Look at that close-up of Ebony Maw. Meanwhile DC can't even properly remove a moustache
Some dudes here act like they are VFX masters and can see through layers of blending graphics, and some dudes saying Marvel was able to pulled off these effects while DC can't do a mustache bla bla bla, although the two companies are not the one who did these visual effects :v
How do they put the face on the 3d model, I don't think they always model the real face, it would take longer.
*Tony stark* : Friday what we looking at ??
*Friday* idk boss something just entered the atmosphere
GTA V Score - We Were Set Up LOL, better than the video itself
Wish they kept Maw alive, great character
Its insane what can be done with visual effects today. They literally created an entire city that looked 100% real.
Best VFX so far, 75 % of movie s done with VFX and 25 % real.
No, the movie had 3000 shots in which 2900 required CGI which was declared by marvel. Hence 96% is CGI while 4% is real
This is just awesome. From the breakdown to the final output, this here gets me extremely excited for a career change. Does anyone know what software is being used? I just graduated for motion design but am now learning Maya and want to get into this industry. Any info would be greatly appreciated.
Great Work Great Movie :)
i tried to imagine me making all of this
now i have 10 braincells left
you just need a team 😂👌😆
so this amazing scene Is Made by framestore
Which software for the nanotech part plzzzz reply
Houdini
To make a movie it take like 1year or more (something like that) and the question is how much they are actually recording per day 5-10mins?
i am aware that this depends of what kind of movie it is and because the scene isn't perfect from the first shot
is just a dumb question if anyone knows i am listening
This is amazing
Great work
love how they recreated the city down form the wheel 😂
Y'all dont understand how hard one scene is I have trouble even getting one car into a scene rather then all this
2:06 Johnny Sins featuring Dr.Strange XD
Best one yet.
Interesting music choice
Excellent work
Oh
The very first 5 seconds gave me goosebumps cause yea, baby, that's a GTA online sound
Awesome!!!
Great Video.
Awesome!!!
So hard work
Does someone know what program do they use?
1:03 The full-cg stark to iron man transition shot just blew my mind.
Maravillosa creatividad de las mejores
Splendid !
Great job!!
Whoa whoa GTA V soundtrack and no copyrights?
Wow superb bro
If they did a VFX breakdown for Interstellar, the CG part would be very short.
Thank you for sharing!
Awesome!
I mean what's the use of actors? Everything can be done with VFX, SFX and CGI and so on
this gta v soundtrack
how to get realistic textures and shaders like that?
Music name, We were set up of gta v
Most live action superhero films are just animated films with live action actors pasted on top
Damn pretty good job!