Should India Adopt A 2-Child Policy? [Street Interview] | ASIAN BOSS
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 чер 2019
- In India, a petition was recently filed by a government spokesperson seeking a mandatory two-child policy. So why was this policy proposed, and how do ordinary Indians feel about such a proposal? Our Asian Boss reporter, Karan, hit the streets of Mumbai to find out.
Special thanks to our Asian Boss team in Mumbai.
Tina (Host)
Instagram ► / tiinamina_
Karan (Reporter)
Instagram ► / thiskidsnotalrightstill
Ankit (Videographer)
Instagram ► / halkat.kabootar
Our vision is to build a lasting grassroots movement of young people from every country to report on real social and cultural issues. We believe having meaningful discussions with people with different opinions is extremely important.
For business or media inquiries, reach out to us at inquiries@asianboss.io
Reach out to our founders, Stephen and Kei, directly if you have any questions, feedback or suggestions:
Stephen on Twitter ► / theasianboss
Stephen on Instagram ► / theasianboss
Kei on Instagram ► / asianbossk
Are you curious about real people's perspectives from Asia on various cultural and social issues? Subscribe to ASIAN BOSS for more informative and thought-provoking videos ► goo.gl/TRcSbE
#Overpopulation #India #AsianBoss
![How Dangerous Is India For Women? [Street Interview] | ASIAN BOSS](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/b24PogMa_6s/mqdefault.jpg)
"Look around, more people pass in dadar street than the entire population of greenland"😂😂😂 that hit me up
To get a state with population of Vatican City we need to declare every single street as a state.
@@ashwanikumar-gv6ir LOL
Greenland is not a habitable place so your statement doesnt makes sense.
@@sourabhs14 but it still has around 50,000 people
@@sourabhs14 bruh it has like 50,000 people
Host: Do you personally believe India is overpopulated?
Dude: LOOK AROUND YOU!!!!
Kantutan pa
2:00
Well he's not wrong
SURNAME is one of the main factor.
We need equality for passing SURNAME.
Why not just pass mother's surname to girls, and father's surname to boys, or reversed?
So there'll less desire and ambition to produce more child just want to get a son.
Love that he mentioned Dadar. I'm in Kolkata right now, had to save up some cash and Mumbai gets costlier and costlier each year... but man, do I miss those intense rush hours in Dadar, Andheri, Churchgate. But then again, Mumbai is way too expensive now. 500 Rupees for a dorm bed with fan and no wi-fi? I'm writing this from my 300 Rs single room in Kolkata with wi-fi, free water and all. Too bad tho 'cause Mumbai is truly one of a kind.
I admire the open minded new Indian generation. You can see a bright future of this nation.
I think India can easily sustain 2 billion ppl, our population density is lesser dan japan n korea n we r a agriculture base country
@@abhyudaysinghparmar6055 But to let more India people to have a better life the population needed to be lower down because it'll need more non-agricultural population for all industries. Japan and Korea, although highly developed, are suffering high population density.
@@indreamluo1981 we r at 19th in population density with a tropical environment, our food security program is 1 of de best in de world we can feed 1.4 billion for 2.5 years our food stocks are overflowing. Population is not our problem but rate of increase is which we hv controlled previously it was 3+ child per family , n now it is 2.3 child per women it is not discussed. We hv successfully commercialized agriculture in some parts of country like Punjab farmers kids r studying in canada there. We should rather focus on developing infrastructure.
P.s.:- we hv just touch 33% of our agricultural production capacity so u know🙃
@@abhyudaysinghparmar6055 we have a low population density , but are we going to wait till population density hits the severe mark. we have to adopt measures from an early stage
@@suvigyamishra2003 dont worry, we r barely half of that mark. Population control bill is just a western propaganda, they just can't see India going strong. Always remember
Higher population = higher consumption = higher gdp = more funds for military, space n scientific research = stronger nation
Yea as an Indian, I think it's really mandatory .
Quality matters not quantity.
Yes
Unless you farm
This will not help , more girl child will be killed because people will want boy if there is one child policy
@@rimasingh7367 agreed. The longer term solution is more education of women and enabling them more rights to their bodies. Societies become better as a whole
@@thatindiandude4602 u
Looking at the younger generations responses, you can see how open minded they are. I wish you also interviewed the older generations, i wanted to see the difference on ideals and if they will be willing to support the 2 child policy.
@yulyu when you dont knoe anything dont speak. Do you even know how much it costs to educate a child all through schools and colleges. Its an insane Amount
@yulyu why call it inhumane? The way i see it, it is more humane for people who understand that providing for a decent life for 2 children in the future is better instead of having many then facing difficulties providing for many children. If you watched the interview, they discussed the difficulties of having many children, why they do and what they can do. They are mostly young people who understand and know the benefits of the so called policy. Also, they provided alternate solutions such as using contraceptives, etc. I see that you do not want their government to implement this 2 child policy rule due to being "inhumane" therefore i ask, "why do you think it is inhumane?"
What's the point of interviewing the older generation who will have no/limited role in producing the next generation.
@@shampanath3675 The 1-child policy in China led to women who were 9-months pregnant being kidnapped by the government and forced to have abortions. You support that?
@@RoxanneLavender here we are talking about 2 child policy of india not of china. ( if that is what happened there then its wrong)
Manforce and Durex CEO:
"Apna time aagya"😂😂😂
LOL😂👍😂
Bhai bhai bhai😂😂😂
Lol
And ranveer would do ads for manforce aswell along Durex partnership..
Sirf ayega nehi bhai dorega
I & my wife decided to go for one child 29 years back and are happy with our decision..😊
Rajendra Rao soon muslim will rule on ur descendants becoz muslim have agenda of GHAZWA HIND
Are you sure?? I mean are both kids yours..😅😅😅
That's great!
Mere yaha bhi 1 child policy hogya hain mere family me😂
@@MMaheshThakur whaaattt?
Bihar, UP, WB these States need to urgently adopt a 1 child policy
Stupid, WB's fertility rate is 1.6, comparable to Norway.
Instead they should concentrate on education as they are also some of the least educated states in India. With education fertility rate decreases.
I am from Bihar
And I think you are right
hey man why are u talking about west Bengal, West bengal is the only state from north India having the lowest fertility rate of 1.6(replacement level is 2.1). Uttar Pradesh and Bihar having the highest fertility rate with 3.1 and 3.4 in India. Before you claim anything better you check your facts twice.
Lol west Bengal fertility rate 2 nd lowest in India after Sikkim, below than south Indian state
If people really want more than 2 children there's also an option called ADOPTION.
Yes!
Indians are too conservative in general to go for adoption.
@@Comments_From_All_Channels i am gonna set an example in my society. I have already decided to adopt one kid and will have only 2 kids.
I fully support adoption. I'm not planning to have any kids but in future if i feel like having a kid, I would rather adopt.
I want my own kids
Let us appreciate how Indian people are so smart and well spoken. Great video Asian Boss!
wow did you just generalize a population of 1.2 billion by looking at 6-7 young people? You must be at the next level of stupidity.
@@MikeMessiah and you judged her intellect just by a comment she made.. you must be on a higher level of stupidity than her. Gtfo jerk.
Monique I'm sorry. I hope you understand that I was just pointing out his hypocrisy .
@@MikeMessiah actually they are....u can see wherever Indians migrate they live in better condition than their general population
@@kkaim08 savage 🤣🤣🤣
I am an Indian and I will NEVER have more than one kid...NEVER. Whether the child is a girl or a boy. I don't care.
Same. Atleast people like us will contribute in population control 😂
I will not get married and I will not have kids also
@@akshay-jr1qz 😂😂
@@akshay-jr1qz I wanna die
@@akshay-jr1qz I guess you're in your early / mid teens, I used to think like that too
If you want more than 2 child and can afford the expenses then ADOPT!!!
mackenzie morgan muslim don't adopt . Thy marry four wives and 30 children here in india
@@MMaheshThakur yeah cuz people like that r dumb af
@@MMaheshThakur lmao true 😂😂
@@MMaheshThakur their men are very lucky😁😁😁
@@MMaheshThakur I don't know why they are even allowed 4 wives, non-Muslims are not allowed multiple wives, they will be thrown in jail for that 🤦♂️ Minority appeasement is a curse for India
I had a friend who came from India. Her family have 5 children, 4 girls and 1 boy. The youngest one is the boy. We all know what that means.!
It doesn't necessarily mean that.
The superstitious beliefs of a girl child bring bad luck and a male child brings good luck. And we tax payers cannot even afford to have children
This is happening in all Asian countries including China. The more educated women are, the less likely for them to have many babies. Why not start with equal opportunities of education for women?
@Rain u
That's very rare. Probably the family is from UP or Bihar or Harayana.
Just do it in my beloved state UP man.. Seriously the whole country will be saved
not sure about UP but bihar they shoudnt not give birth to anything
Just nuke Bihar and UP and boom, Population problem solved just like that 😎
@@whatsrwo0sh358 the problem is not in UP but in bihar,UP has plenty of space to accomodate people but is small state with huge population with no signs of imprvment...UP also faces the migration issue from nepal & bihar
Crime state up
@@Aledgamingtamil UP population according to Election Comission estimates for 2019 General Election is 221.9 Million in 2019 >>> 45 Million of North East
As an Indian ,we should marry in our thirties
Bad idea. Fertility drops after 33 drastically.
heroicassassin97 fertility does drop but it’s a case by case situation, it’s all about the health and genetics of a couple
@@heroicassassin97 I am pretty sure that was his point
Like People in Europe Marry in thier thirties.
@@kamikazesikh6931 😂
Rich and educated : 1 or 2 kids
Poor and uneducated: 3 to 6 kids
Education is the key to reduce population.
1 and 2 is more like upper middle class or middle class
A lot of rich and educated people have 3 and 4 look at the upper class none of them have 1 child only, but that's the pattern in the west, I don't know about India much
@@sabrina1380m look even ambani has 3 kids . He can afford to feed them.
The point i am trying to make is have the no. of kids who you can feed throughout their life . those who barely cant afford meal for a day has dozens of kids so it puts extra pressure on the parents and as well as govt.
while education is the key but at THIS point in india there needs to be a law anyone who breaks the law should be severely fined.
You mean 10+
Yeah but if anyone has triplets
Water scarcity is a serious issue in India
ya you are right
but how to control population 🙄
Not all over India ,It is major problem in South India. I live in East side of India and I have never faced such type of problem but, problem of population is all over the India
I think it will start arising in North after 10-15 years .60% population of India live in East India which don't face any water problem . May be this is one of the reason why they accounts for "60%" of population.
More resources= more people
But today you can buy Resources with money so everything is messed up
I'm surprised Asian boss hasn't made a video on that. India has been hardly hit with climate change. The weather patterns are so extreme that reservoirs are drying up and people have to use groundwater. At the rate at the which they are utilising groundwater, some cities in India are expected to have *0* groundwater left by 2050
just drink wood alcohol Michael
Not just India but the world needs this. We are getting overpopulated.
Eastern Europe is declining, others also would have to do this, if we don't want wars for clean water or food in the future.
@@hiphipjorge5755 Yes, it's also true. Fertility rate declines in most of Asian countries and Central and South America.
its too late now
@@nerdherbs Horrible Mentality, with that attitude, you will get nowhere in life.
@@blazingcoder3196 lol I'm doing good in my life thanks
what did i say wrong its a fact that its already too late to control the population neither you or me can do anything about it
As an Indian I honestly think our India needs a 1 child policy with how over populated this country is 🙄🙄
Go to China and see why did they abolished their one child policy in 2015
@@atv9231 Because it has done it's job. It was never meant to be a permanent policy.
@@comediangj4955 no, China's in a mess right now. They don't have enough females to marry to men, and there is only one child to pay for both the parents and grandparents retirement. Because of this they are no longer having children. The one-child policy just fricked up China. The damage is also done, people still have on average less then 2 children.
@@hershey1141 no pain no gain. It all depends on the balance. And seeing how much china growed from when the policy is implemented to now. It's clearly worth it. The problems you mentioned while exist, they are blow way out of proportion by the media, as usual.
2 or 3 child
I know this is a serious subject but when the guy said "but what if durex isnt working" 😂
🤣🤣🤭🤭
😂😂😂😂
If india adopt 2 or1 child policy
Indian know which community will protest first
Some indians are ashamed of even buying a durex.😂 so the end up creating a soccer team .
@Simulated Being it's a good policy I will send to government
I personally believe having two kids is enough, Even after that I feel like having more...just adopte one.💜 You can make someone's future. 💕
Do you see the problem with your comment?? You are legislating your own preference and views on others!
What's next?
Family size is a personal matter that has no business for you to meddle in!
Of course, adoption is a worthy thing to do!
@@lenitaa7938 am not legislating nor meddling in other people's matter. It's my opinion and have right to express it like yours. If you like to have more en do who's stopping you but having more kids without any conscience is not a good choice... Because you can't give em all the resources they need, more kids = lack of resources else you are rich enough.
What is wrong with having two child. and adopting one?
@@simp8966 Nothing.... (v_v) just different point of views of differ people.
Why not to live a solo life😏
Y'all should honestly try to hit Banglore and Hyderabad too. Not only Mumbai.
Agreed... South India is populated because of its job opportunities (being IT sectors) that attract people from other states of India as well.
@@skandabalasubramanya8714 only Bangalore and Hyderabad not all of south india.
Yeah. Every video is in Mumbai only.
Its for all Indians
Don't misunderstood it
"Believe? Dude... there is nothing to believe. Look around you". 😂
Yeah because mumbai is now home of immigrants
Only Uttar Pradesh and Bihar should be forced to have a two-child policy. The rest of India already has a stabilized population.
Bangalore only has some 1.5 crore abv population.this is mandatory everywhere
@@mosaicbrokenhearts2886 this should be implemented in every state.
@Sudiksha Pandey except for 10 states with lowest fertility it should be implemented everywhere .
@@ashwanikumar-gv6ir that's what i mean.
@Sai Bharadwaj up and Biharis migrated to other states look in delhi they live in slums and in mumbai also
As an Indian. I think we need Thanos 😊
You know what's shocking, even if you remove half of the Indian population you will still be the second most populated
We need two or more snaps from Thanos!!
@@himanshusoni1422 lmao..
Good one lol
@@natasharules770 stop rubbing salt on our wounds and bring me THANOS...
Migration and their mentality of having boy child is the major issue
That mentality of having a boy child has been changed in most of the areas
Lol who told u so 🤣🤣🤣🤣
It's only in few areas and nowhere.
People usually prefer girls in my state.
I agree
Praful chandravanshi they are the minority stop blaming the minorities in India most India is dominated by Hindus maybe you should blame the “MAJORITY” just stop the blaming game and start doing something about it
@@Ram-wu6xv racist
While taking interviews of Korean, japanese etc. Asian Boss always speak in their language that way they can express more but why do you always speak in English... I mean it's not bad thing that you want the world to show that Indian's can speak... How abt a change.... Listening more of people's thought not the Language..????
They always go to Mumbai. If they go to other cities then u'll see people speaking in native language too
@@rohitshinde865 it's not dat look most of Indian youth can speak basic English so if u start a conversation in English naturally he will also respond in English. So if da interview starts in marathi or hindi we will also respond in the same way.
It's just the fact that the channel wants to cater a broader population
It's not like that if someone is talking in Hindi, how people from NE or south will understand your word....... It's like, Central indian trying to impose their already destroyed Hindi language to our historicaly rich mother tongue.........
@@joshuatheunkownuniverse.2475 no one wants to impose Hindi on everyone, it's just that Hindi speakers are propagating their language very well than other speakers. Many a times people feel ashamed talking in their native language, that's not the mistake of Hindi speakers.
For those of you who dont know,to all Indians and non Indians just an update 2 child policy is already put into practice today.
No there is still high birth rates in some remote areas of India. There are also plenty of couples who have more than 2 child in big cities too.
@@Comments_From_All_Channels true, I do not want to bring a new kid into this cruel world
@@wildwebx me too
seriously? in lockdown only more than 2 crore child births are expected.
@@mosaicbrokenhearts2886 are you serious ??
Come on two is enough.
Small family is a happy family
Don't you heard of it.
It's not about that... family planning can teach that to people....but government enforcing strict policy use something else
@@ayushithakur9059 who cares.
@@bravequeen4650 a small thing called *rights*
@@ayushithakur9059 The problem is a lot of India people is very close minded about it.
@@L16htW4rr10r that's very true. it's a cultural thing to have many kids but the topic of sex is considered very taboo, thus lack of conversation --> prone to more mistakes. I'm Sri-Lankan Indian so I can state this: Indians (Desis in general also apply here) are very emotional people and mostly insecure as they're afraid of what others think of them. To talk about sex education for them is to ask to be judged, when in reality no one gives a crap.
So un just said that in 2027 india will be most populist country surpassing china
I am indian and the young generation of my country have this mindset that they do not want more than 2 kids I live in an urban city everyone has this kind of mindset only so if government bring this policy then we will obviously support it but things are different in rural areas things need to change from there.
Yes,me too!!
@Kleco102 so for hindus the law which illegals polygamy came into 1956 but since muslim are been governed by their own personal law so in Islam having 4 wives is legal but honorable supreme court has given various judgement where they have said that no law can be above and in violation of rights of women. But no law has been really bought by parliament where they could illegalise polygamy.
@@sulsur4151 Absolutely right ! Their culture is only to ensure supremacy of their own religion and nothing else.... and fear-filled religion, where millions of things are prohibited, stops their ability to even think. Truly speaking, people who staunchly believe in such fearfull cult, effectively become zombies !
Its like a plague on planet Earth.
@@sulsur4151 what about people who have abusive spouses? Shouldn't they divorce and get another chance at life?
@@solitarypilot1482 there are so many laws for the protection of women in India could you give even one law for protection of male if the spouse is abusive they can draw a suit under protection of women from domestic violence act, 2005 and get relief ask for alimony or maintenance and if the women want to move on than probably remarry.
Population is increasing only because of UP , Bihar ,MP , RJ ,Assam ( migrant Bangladeshi )
MP has lower rates of population
Bihar and uttarpradesh ....
Overpopulation Problem solved.
@sachin uchiha .yeah right
@@zeliang5101 agreed
Sahi pakde hai.. And now their politicians are telling them have 5 kids so that their vote bank increases
@@infinity-gn9xq only in bihar not in UP
@@passionisinspiration1912 UP comes first in population rate in india
I mean the Indian government should. There’s like way too many people to handle and a lack of resources to go around. I’m all for people having the right to do as they please, but as soon as it starts affecting others negatively enough, there’s needs to be some discussion.
Agreed. Sad to see young people suffer in poverty and having to compete unfairly in the job and education market.
There are plenty of resources in this world. In fact we overproduce food and other supplies by vast amounts. Its the distribution that is the problem.
Just make them pay 1000$ as fine for the third child. They'll automatically not have it
@yulyu
If the problem is happening in India, and it is it's people who have to solve it, implementing this law isn't racist (it would still be the same if it happened in other countries, with people of a different ethnity).
Despite believing everyone should have control over what to do with their bodies, if what they do is harmful then the government is in their right to pass down laws to limit said control (having too many children is negative for the world and India itself).
And as a side note, don't say the lack of resources isn't real. There are countries literally fighting for water.
@yulyu
How is it racist? If this was necessary in my country (Spain) or say, the US/UK/any other country, the law would still need to be passed down. It isn't a matter of race, it's a matter of what's better for the world and the people that are alive at the moment.
You may not realise it, but we are running out of non-renewable resources (out of which, many are important despite polluting). Having more mouths to feed EVERY YEAR won't help control those resources, nor make a good use of the renewable ones.
However, leaving the resources aside, many children are still a problem. Poorer families are usually the ones who have more children, and this leads to an inability to provide correctly for those children. Lowering the birth rate to two children will ease the struggle to provide for their children for poor/not as rich families.
I'm pretty sure you think it's okay to send criminals to prison because they are a danger for societies, even if you are technically violating their rights (it's their body so they should decide whether they want to kill someone or steal something). It happens the same with too many children; it technically is the parents's rights to decide how many they want, but it has a negative impact on the world as a whole (thus why these policies are needed).
*I'm Indian and I support 2 child policy*
Same
I m In
I'll support too
No....this is not answer ...only states like up bihar mp Rajasthan orrisa jharkhand needs awareness.... Other states are already doing well infact they have declining population
@@ayanverma5746 I'm from Manipur and people here are already following this policy
Why can't Philippines be like this? Support this kind of movement please
Show me a Muslim family in India with only child ...😂
It's kinda like,Ager dikha diya to kar Dunga 25 din me tera paisa double 😂😂😂😂
Ya...show
Unko to unka religion badhana hai wo thodi 1 bachha paida karke chup bathenge😁😁
Rare
Per wife??
Where is blue shirt kid?
Collecting the infinity stones.
Birthing 2 kids
✋
maybe he moved to Sweden
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 Busy -Being - LiT 🔥 🔥 🔥 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
I think it is a good policy the world is getting too overpopulated and we need to find a solution at least until we find another planet or something
Until we find another planet? We'd all be dead by then
We will never find another planet we were created on this planet we will stay here no other planet can support life in our solar system we destroyed this planet we fix it or we destroy the planet more and we go extinct. Why with all this fantasy lol. We pay the price for what we have done end of story lmao.
yeah know we can ALL fit within the space of TX,LA and OK at the same density as cities in Asia.
The human race has an end as everything in life.
All these replies are sad lol
give education to people specially bihar, UP, jharkand rest all are fine
Yes
True
True...
Especially the village
We are not inventing fire here Buddy
The fact that people cant seem to talk openly about anything sexual has led to consequences far worse than I've seen anywhere else in the world. The young generations seems to be on the right track forward and that gives me peace of mind. Some things that have happened in India are unbelievable.
2:25 wtf is that the guy they just interviewed in the background? xD
LOL TRUE
Haha it is
Observation level is high.
He just entered to another dimension bruh
that's how random these interviews are.
Philippines should do this also. Country is already overcrowded and population just keeps growing.
Overpopulated for a small country.
True
Having too much children is irresponsible
I think, what India really needs is a no-child policy.
That's the truth they need to ban having children
AGREE 😂
@@Frozen_flames_ ban on having children for next 10 years from 2023-2033.
@@abhisheknahar7363 yeah great idea we can make India slum free atleast
@@Frozen_flames_ then 1 child policy till 2060 and 2 child policy till 2100. This way we can bring population down to about 500-600 million people by 2100 still slightly above china and Nigeria.
The young man at 3.47 has a great point. He is very smart.
In my locality Muslim family have 8 children 😑 and they fall under Below poverty line they say that every child will going to help family by working and am like expenses on education health
Because koran says increase your population. This one told by my muslim friend.
@Preety Moonlight they put there child into child labour to get some money at home
Rocklee 101 not all Muslim families have many childrens more like all old school families around the world in every religion prefer to have a big family
@@Varun-uv4li So does the Christian Bible! Common sense has to prevail, though! Those teachings are over a thousand years old! Times and Society's needs change!
Not for us to judge this Muslim family! Every family is different!
Not for the Gov't to legislate a family size!
A gov't can encourage smaller families, provide education, and free birth control!
Even raising single child is too difficult...
@Lana Joy even existing is too difficult
Having siblings teaches children to share and how to get along with others, how to work together!
And provides important companionship! Single children are often lonely! Having friends helps, but not the same as having siblings!
How so?
@@lenitaa7938 alright lenita, alright.
' 'Okay we barely feed ourselves this month lets have 5 more children ' '
06:20 everyone think a mandatory issue is too harsh. that's the reason why it's so hard to utilize the two-child policy.
the selfish people want less people in this country. but when they are asked "what if gov doesn't let you have more than 2 children". they all unhappy about the policy. that's so ridiculous.
There are more people in india and china than south america,north america and europe combined
Think of that lol
China is a huge country tho
It's always been that way, for thousands of years.
India also huge it is 7th largest country in terms of area
Human population has been the highest since ages in these countries.. It's not something new
These countries are some of the oldest and largest in the world its not a surprise.
I think they should campaign to make people think if male and female baby is same and after that campaign 2 child is better for them.
I feel bad for every kid who live in poor economy family but has a lot of siblings. I am gonna blame the parent for it.
Well.....many many people in India know that there is equality b/w males as well as females .the indian Government even brings campaigns regarding this but still there are people with conservative mindset and who try to make India a male dominated society.... :(
I totally agree. Forcing the two child policy is also good for gender rights. I'm a Chinese girl, when I was born my parents was happy but my grandmother is super disappointed because I'm girl. But my parents raises me well and educated me well since I'm the only child, now I more successful than any of my brothers 😉
@@whitewhite4426 I totally agree with you. What's the point of having multiple kid's just because the family needs a boy and living in poverty. The kid's too get the message as boy's are superior to girls and the cycle goes on.
@@whitewhite4426 and you hold much value more than your male counterparts..
@UCsyV8Hat9Y0cRip60SYyz2Q most young people I know prefer one child though. And with more 68% population under 35, India can think about 2 child policy as it won't affect the old to young ratio.
I am Childfree in Senegal. My country is 15 million people, not very crowded compared to india. But anyway I have chosen not to have kids. I think life is too horrible to confront a Child. India needs urgently to reduce population. Development can never cope with overpopulation.
Right. But in India fertility rate is 2. Nigeria is 5, Niger 6.
Yes 😊😊
My sister and her husband had decided to go with one child of their own and one adopt child who need parents and they did it
And now they are happy and
Still proud of their decision they never make discrimination between them.....❤❤❤
India was founded on large families. My grandparents grew up in India and they had like 10 siblings lmao
Modern medicine didn't exist back then. So that's why they had more kids because only few of them would reach adulthood. Many die from preventable diseases or malnutrition.
I don't know how many siblings my grandparents had but only 3 survived.
It was necessary in the past but times have changed
@PSYCHO乡KANEKI Gaming recently about a month ago I got to know that my mom had 2 more siblings they don't talk about. Generally children who have families are remembered. Anyone who dies before that is forgotten. Ask your grandparents whether any of his siblings died when they were kids.
Moreover even if that's not the case, 90% of Indian families weren't as lucky as your grandparent. What I said was the general thing going around. Not a hard and fast rule. There will always be exceptions
Same goes for the developed world if you turn back the clock 70-100 years
"PEACEFUL" religious groups won't ever let such a law pass....it's impossible for any government to do that in India. 👍
I am a part of your so called "PEACEFUL" group and I don't find anything wrong with this Law.
@@aamishmurtaza2262 But u r rare bro...You don't represent your group...u don't even represent your own family. You represent nothing. So stop saying stuff like your opinion actually matters. 🙂
@@ravikumarsingh5116 I will tell you just One thing which is the Nexus to each of the Problems in Muslim Community "LITERACY". I am a single child and I have 5 Aunts whom are having maximum of 2 childrens not anymore than that, while on the otherhand our maid who lives in slums is having 7 girl child. When I asked her why she is having so many babies,she replied that she wants a son. According to the sacchar commitee report Muslims are the least educated community in India.
@@aamishmurtaza2262 Wish all Muslims were aware like you man. Respect. Population is the biggest threat to our development, be it any religion. And ppl must realise this as soon as possible. No one...no government...no celebrity..no influencer talks abt this. I commented on your religion cuz everytime I have talked about this issue in my group of friends, it's always been Muslims who have opposed me with weird religious beliefs.
@@aamishmurtaza2262 bro In our locality well educated family each having 3-4 child...which is considerably more than people of equal status and education from other religion.....
Maybe I'm wrong but there is some problem in your community.
It's the Muslim in India who are least willing to change
True bro..
@Nilesh Sharma I don't care about Europe but they are trying to destroy India too
@Nilesh Sharma just search "baptism in India " on UA-cam or "no conversion" on fb and all your love for Europe will be gone
Sorry Sharma ji..due to your name I was mistaken
@Nilesh Sharma so?
India should pass bill of no child policy for 5-6 years
Tell me you want a demographic collapse without telling me you want a demographic collapse
Bro what are you talking 😒😒
This coukd destroy the society
😂😂😂😂😂👍
5 wife's
25 kids
And one shop of repairing as a asset
And they say modi is causing inflation
You are getting particular community for every problem
Well, what do you even expect from a nation which considers 350 million people as minority just to use them as vote banks ?
@@nitishsinghsingh1280 you are a libtard,facts don't care about your feelings
@@omshree2448 wait they are 172 million
@ARKAPRAVA DAS those illegal are consider as refuge and government is deporting them
Government knows there location - old Delhi west bengal(almost half) Kashmir Assam( Assam deporting them fastly) and remainings are in Rajashthan par unhe jald hi deport kar denge
Ab aate hai Hinduo pe to ye baat bhi sach hai ki Pakostan ke almost aadhe Hindu to India me aa chuke hai Bangladesh ke bhi bahot se Hindu India me hai umeed hai inhe jald e jald citizenship mile
Aur mullo ko deport kar diya jaye
I think the educated sector will probably have no problem with it.
But try convincing the uneducated sector. Its way harder. Especially certain communities.
@Lana Joy yes. Thats why we need to make this as a law. I mean the south and north east have reduced population. Some of the states are following the policy there for years now.
@@kkaim08 NorthEast India has adopted two child policy. You won't find families here with more than two child. They are kinda cleaner too. They do hate people with backward mentality and have a preconception that mainland indians are not only dirty and stinky but have backward mentality too.
@@gamaboot3090 dont speak for all 45 million here buddy. Then mainland will justify racism against us too. Nobody thinks they stink. Speak for yourself. Or maybe you are just a spineless idiot who camaflouges his opinion as a communitys own. As your bio says F**k off.
Not just the uneducated sector but educated mullas too, they would oppose this law too
1:08 इस लड़की को कोई मेडल दो । जब तक ये चीज नही बदलेगी । भारतीय लोग जनसँख्या बढ़ते रहेंगे ।
Correct
@Akshara Verma वो फिर xy xx क्रमोसोम का खेल है । उंसके बारे में कुछ नही कहा जा सकता है ।
"More people pass through here everyday than the entire population of greenland"
Like, everywhere has more people than the entire population of a giant rock full of ice but still, this is funny.
My fellow Filipinos, listen to these Indians
@@DramaTV2613 means Indians are open to the idea of reducing population and the commenter is asking his fellow Filipino's to follow and understand.
Yes but jesus disagrees
@@souslicer who cares about Jesus ka opinion yaar
You mean this meme:
“Humayo kayo at Magpakarami” in a Tagalog translation of the Bible which means: Be fruitful and multiply
Instead of focusing all over india.... Just focus on states like UP, Bihar, Rajasthan, Jharkhand, MP.....spread awareness campaigns more over here.... Other states are already doing well they have fertility rate below 2 .....They don't need such harsh Impositions
Include Maharashtra also in top ten populated state's Maharashtra ranks 2 nd and UP top's the list ,3rd rank is Bihar than West Bengal
Guddi Kumari but Maharashtras fertility rate is low.
@@guddikumari3505 UP , bihar, hyderbad what not is ther here
@@tarun_6864 Hyderabad has low fertility rate only the reason is due to migration.
@@knightwarrior2606 no knowledge about that bro
1:01 This girl answers perfectly what the problem is: Culture/Social Status Needs/Beliefs
Bihar : "Imma suppose I didn't see that"
if china can, india can do too
@@sukhadathobbi8047 you too exol
@@sukhadathobbi8047 yes of course haha
Ryan Kiddo Although the government is different. We have the same problem in population. China had one child policy since 1989 and declared last for 30 years. Eventually the population grew slower than before. However society got old faster. The proportion between young people and old people is imbalance. That’s quite a serious problem in China nowadays.
@@Johnson-Young thats right.. so if india can have 2 child policy from the start(if they implement this) , they can avoid things like what happened in china crisis(gender imbalance, age etc)
@@Johnson-Young that's a problem China foresees because of their current economy. India doesn't have that problem now. Statistically, India is more poverty stricken than China when they first initiated the one child policy. If the unemployment rate indirectly affects a nation's economy, and if India resists this change, then goodluck with that.
The thumbnail pic of train is not from india... Cause its illegal to travel on the roof of the train... Check your sources AB. 👀
You sure? Because i've seen such pictures on newspapers too...
@@ru_iru7092 the trains are electric .... That's why you can't travel on rooftops. ...
@@ru_iru7092 That is a very old picture.. Nowadays it’s not possible, most lines are electrified.
@@dragonstormdipro1013 it's in Bangladesh , during Eid people sit on the roof of train to go their own home.
@@koustavchowdhury1226 Aren’t those the colour schemes of ICF coaches?
I'm Indian and support two child policy
For muslims
I'm Indian and i support 1 child policy
@@sudhirghosh_ for evryone 300 million muslims will become 150m then 70m then less than 35m on the other hand 1 billion hindu will become 500m then 250m and then 120m... At the end India will finally become 200m
@@Frozen_flames_ wtf😂
*More than 20-25 million illegal immigrants people in India*..
Mainly in West bangal And Assam state of India..
Report of Indian home minister in 2017.
One of the main reason India population increase so fast. 😢
And also cuz of the desi mullas too
And each family produces drift of pigs...... hate them
@@bittumandal7505 Well you're racist. 20 million is nothing compared to like 1 billion
Govt should remove all those illegal immigrants from India.
Do you Even know how many lacs are there in a Million? Let me tell you something boy your Home Minister is an Anpadh Gawar. According to his own NRC Report his myth of so called Illegal Immigrants has been Busted as the Report states that there are less than 2Million(Around 19 Lakhs) Non-Nationals in the State of Assam. Which will further go down as Many people are there whose Children are not included in the List, also some of the Veterans who fought in the Kargil war were declared Non Indian by this list as well.
THERE'S A THIN LINE BETWEEN NATIONALISM & XENOPHOBIA- BESIDES, HATRED OF FOREIGNER COULD LATER TURN INTO A HATRED OF INDIANS DIFFERENT FROM ONESELF - RABINDRANATH TAGORE.
Pay heed to our Founding father words not these present Minister scums who reach any low to stay in Power. Even if it means a Civil War in the Country.
Last but not least BSF is there on the border to stop any Illegal entry into the Country. Thank You.
Too late too little. Or rather too late too many.
Or too little too late
India's population proliferation is purely disgusting and abhorrent
@Ankit Banerjee chill out Pajeet, you're on fire
@@Basuko_Smoker sure karen
@@uchihamadra2722 you can't even see the original comment i reply to, get back to your cave in reddit
As an Indian I completely agree with this policy. The over population is the major cause of so many problems like unemployment, high crime rates, falling economy etc. And this problem is more severe in rural area cuz people there are still uneducated and also don't really know about contraceptive methods.
Dude speaking on sex education. 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
It's Bangaldeshi train in thumbnail
Bhai hamarae yaha bhi aisi hi situation hai
Think about Bangladesh, a small country with 20 crore people.. 😂😂😂
I know abt many Bangladeshis they r illegal immigrants,coming to our country.(not hate)
@@rishiranjan003 so true
More like 16 crore
And half of them immigranted to India illegally and reproduce uncontrollably
Bangladesh has 160 million population
Being an Indian..I will support the 2 child policy if the govt implements that
It should be 1 child policy. That will be good.
Wow ...young Indian speaks ALIEN language fluently w8 good thoughts
Appreciated
Rising population is not only any country issue it's about our planetary environment too
@Neha P but why Is that even necessary
@@RespectAiSM what's the harm of knowing 2 langs? An average Indian knows 3-4 langs
Knowing multiple languages is a culture in India
🖕
@@RespectAiSM Because India has 22 official languages(English is one of them) and each state has it's own language so you need one universal language to interact with everyone.
i dunno where you conducted this interview (maybe near a university) but every single subject was very well informed and articulate
in Mumbai
Mumbai is like what bay area or nyc is to america. Large progressive and educated population
Do it, that's the only way. If you wanna have more than 1, you gotta prove to the government that you can provide basic needs to your children and financially stable. Maybe set a minimum annual income for each household
Jason Saw more than two you mean. its a two child policy not one child policy like china
Jason Saw The Old Hag Stripping Off
Who is going to decide how much money is enough?? The gov't?? No, thanks!
This opens up to Corruption and abuse!
i want to have more than 10
wow Indian people are quite beautiful
All human is beautiful
Brown guys are the best 😍
@@dadam2609 Racist
@@dadam2609 well that's rude
If someone doesn't match according to you're beauty standard that doesn't mean they are ugly
Two children are reasonable for all countries.
2:37 did he stopped the guy with specs while interviewing another person ???
I agree with the guy at 1:35
He's right, because that's the problem all over the world tbh
@Ankit Banerjee Are you gonna cry and reply to every single comment?
@Ankit Banerjee You really should stop. Nothing is funny about rape. You of all people should know.
Kudos to these opinions! It is worthwhile to have these discussions.
I want a NO CHILD policy, am indian by the way.....
Me too
Yeah there should be ban on having children for atleast 20 years.
same
Same 😅
If you want more than 2 children, adopt one. It can help fulfil your wish of having more children and at the same time those kids can have a family
india's greatest mistake was to end it's forced sterilization program in 1980 or so. when green revolution kicked off and people got fed, they started to breed like dogs, 9-10 were normal.
Stereotypical thumbnail! 😌
You can't deny that its real
@@nora4981 Maybe 10-15 yrs ago in "some"(2-3%) places on certain "occasions" ONLY.
But almost totally deniable since most of past decade! Also there are high tension electric lines above so, not really possible mostly.
Pratyush Jhingran That's still the truth tho 😄
@@didiprangsak1757 disagreed! 😁😊
@@nora4981 no there are electric or metro trains.
I haven't seen this kind of train with passengers in its roof.
Indonesia already did this in 80's, at least it worked for us.
indian fertility rate is 2.3 & declining ,so two child policy wouldnt make much sense ,as most indians already for 2 kids only ,the policy should be for 1 child
@@rajuseth1683 what about who has more than 2? It won't hurt to implement it either
India fertility rate is 2.3 while indinesia is 2.36. Nothing worked in Indonesia.
it's not enforced enough, i still see tons of people with 5 kids there. Only major cities and educated people maybe follow this.
No. Religious retards win
I think "forcing" people to have fewer kids isn't ideal, but the government can provide benefits to housholds with one or two children.
All of them are well spoken and obviously well educated.. They need to interview an older age bracket or people from villages.
Why do i feel that A Good Education is like THE SOLUTION for most of our social problem.
Indian guys are cute
yes indian boys are cute and adorable too. 😊
@gorkha Li :(
@gorkha Li lol what ? thats not true
😨
@gorkha Li at least we are not little like small nepalis 😂😂😂😉
I'm happy towards the end they touched the actual important point: You need to educate people, but also give people resources and opportunities for it to work. The government prohibiting is not solely a solution, there will still be inequality, lack of employment and social injustice.
Instead of punishing people for having more than 2 kids, they should give financial incentives for families having fewer kids and couples who practice birth control. And make sure to educate the poor people about it. And give couples who want to stop having children free/subsidized access to vasectomy or getting their tubes tied.
You don't want Indian babies being abandoned to die like Chinese babies with their one-child-policy.
A zero child policy would do the earth a favor
Lolz
@kwolf lol
Someone of my interest
Nice
Completey agree
Agreed
I could listen to that accent all day
I thought people hated Indian accent 😂
Ew 😂
Asian boss talks about 2 children policy
*muslims left the chat fearing Allah*
Lol what about Muslim?
Question for seculars: once M population reaches 51%, will India be secular?
Islamic Republic of India
*Thanos: Let me present myself to you*
First China, now India
Just For Fun China has different government, their policy is different
I know a Muslim family. They have more than 6 children . They don't even have money to feed let alone one child. So once I told them about this and they were like " it is blessing of Allah". They don't send their children to school . So there will be more manpower to earn money. And also another reason is that they wanted to make India a Muslim country. So if there will be more Muslims then their vote bank will increase. People who are aducated they are mostly having one child. Because thay wanted to give their children best. And ofcourse the education in India has became really very expensive. So now most of the people are having only one child not even two.
Rg Gusai soon muslim will rule on ur descendants becoz muslim have a long term agenda of GHAZWA HIND
The guy with black shirt got my attention! Dude I like the mindset and perspective you have!