China’s Rising Power: Implications for India, America & Pakistan? Indian View from Delhi
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 тра 2024
- Do give your comments below. Subscribe and Share our video.
Dr Moeed Pirzada tweets @MoeedNj
Follow Global Village Space (GVS) on twitter @GVS_News
Check us out at www.globalvillagespace.com/
/ globalvillag. .
00:00 Introduction
3:58 What’s China’s growing Military budget?
7:47 Is China an aggressive or a defensive power? Chinese Ballet and Road Initiative
12:07 Why has China not opened-up to the free-market?
15:37 Can Indians fight on borders with both China and Pakistan?
19:13 Has China become a great power?
24:36 Who is leading the AI?
29:36 What China wants from India?
34:44 India-Pak and Gray-Zone operations
44:20 Was Palwama a strategic reset?
46:45 India or Pakani? Which Army remained more successful?
1:04:08 What made Pak Army so strong?
1:07:57 Where is Pakistan? In Chinese or Western orbit?
1:23:32 Where is Modi’s India heading?
You can read it here: www.globalvillagespace.com/in...
Dear Dr Moeed, in the recent past I have generally avoided listening such traditional programs conducted on Indo-Pak relationship because it’s a genuine waste of time in my opinion.
However, astonishingly I was glued to this episode till the end and screen got blank.
It’s been an episode of diverse perspectives, information and facts not restricted to Indo-Pak, China but world at large with an agreement to disagree, some abrupt laughters and beyond. Apparently a dry and rotten subject transformed into a light, effective, and time worthy discussion.
It’s evident in all your shows that even after all the bombardment up on few of you who are fighting the war for logic, freedom of expression(s) and truth, you once again remained a humble, intelligent, eager, passionate, respectful true Pakistani in this discussion. Your counterpart, respected Mr. Pravin was equally at par.
These discussions need lot of research, knowledge, time, resources and willingness to learn and to listen the opposite point of view.
That was the hallmark of this discussion.
Regards from Canada.
*Dear Moeed ji*
*If you will read below achievements of BJP under PM Modi ji,you will get 99% answer of your doubts on today's Bharat*
*Why BJP under Leadership of Shri. Narendra Modi ji should continue again?*
● Pakistan wants BJP to lose
● China wants BJP to lose
● Arms lobby wants BJP to lose
● Pharma lobby wants BJP to lose
● Radical Islamist wants BJP to lose
● Anti-Nationals want BJP to lose
● Missionaries want BJP to lose
● Leftists want BJP to lose
● Muslims want BJP to lose
Because...
BJP fulfilled its promise of...
● Ram Mandir
● CAA / NRC
● New Education Policy
● Article 370
● Strengthened Defense
● Tightened NGOs
● Tightened Naxals
● Tightened Missionaries
● 5th Largest Economy
● CORONA vaccination
● Kashi Corridor
● Conquered SPACE
● Erasing signs of slavery
● Infrastructure
● IITs
● AIIMS
● Zero Corruption at the ministry level
● GST
● DeMonetization
● Zero Bomb Blast
● Peace in Kashmir
● 2nd in mobile manufacturing
● 100% Electrification of Railways
● Complete elimination of Railway gates
● Vande Bharat Train
● Destroyed Pakistan without firing any bullet
● Contained China
● Water at every household
● Medical insurance under Ayushman Bharat
● Char Dham Yatra for senior citizens
*•* And many more...
And like Congress..
● BJP won't sell the nation
● BJP won't sign a secret deal with China
● BJP won't go soft on Pakistan, Terrorism..
We will ensure BJP wins again and again.
2024 BJP🚩
2029 yes, only BJP🚩
2034 BJP🚩
And beyond......
Our Children are Safe
Our life is over
We have lived a Good Life
We have to Give a
Secured Society
Secured Life
Secured Future
For our Next Generation
*My Entire Hindu Family/Village/State/country voted BJP in 2014, resulted achieving this SMART Goals.*
*@Sunala1265*
*!As I Live I Learn!*
*Live and Let Live*
*Proud Indian Sanatani Hindu Maratha*
*Jai Hind*
🙏🇮🇳❤️🕉️🙏
Great work! I'm totally agree with Mr Pravin,,, include China and exclude West must be our agenda. Because foreign policy must base on strategic location. But his narrative denied moeed perspective 😂
*Gr8, Moeed*
*RIP freedom of expression*
*When we says nice discussion,your comment - Thanks a lot*
*But when w write in post "Pakistan, Leftists, anti-India, China wants to defeat Most probable winning party BJP - Modi showing their 10+ years achievements,you deleted my entire post*
*Keep it up*
😂😁😅
I tend to agree with you.
I am totally agree with pravin
ڈاکٹر صاحب۔ ایسے ورلڈ ویو رکھنے والے سکالرز سے کم از کم ایک پروگرام ہر ہفتے ہونا چاہیے۔
یہ آپ کا پاکستانیوں پہ احسان ہو گا۔
Bilkul sahee kaha aap ne weekly aik program zaroor ho na chahiye !
Agreed 😊
Yes i strongly agree with you
agreed and we request sir Pravin to give us time
I agree
I always found Indian scholars are real scholars very very literate and very much focused on there discussion.
Assalamualaikum bhai...Indian Muslim here.
I m a viewer of Pravin Sawhney.
Moeed sir ka problem ye he...ke he can't able to differentiate between internal matters and military issues. Wo baar baar Pakistan Army ka interfere in politics pe bol rahe hain...jab ke Pravin sir Military issues pe bol rahe hain
😂😂😂 youthiya spotted
@@IronMan-nu3rbbkl indian muslim? Mc dusree video mein to kashmir pakistan ko dene ki baat kr rha tha..macchar ki jhant
Love to listen Parven Sahib . He is really a man of honor. love and respect pakistan 🇵🇰 india 🇮🇳 ❤
He is a joker who thinks he knows something.
He doesn't know anything. And he doesn't agree with anyone except his own delusional world theories
Tea is fantastic@@mayan5600
Welcome Dr.Moeed Pirzada - a symbol of contomporary and historical knowledge and significant anticipation about future.
Purzada is an embarrassment!
Assalamualaikum bhai...Indian Muslim here.
I m a viewer of Pravin Sawhney.
Moeed sir ka problem ye he...ke he can't able to differentiate between internal matters and military issues. Wo baar baar Pakistan Army ka interfere in politics pe bol rahe hain...jab ke Pravin sir Military issues pe bol rahe hain
Because in case of Pakistan both of these are highly interconnected....
Praveen sahib please stay blessed. You are a great source of knowledge and wisdom. Thanks for your time on Dr. Pirzada's forum for Pakistanis.
He only gives false homes to Pakistanis
@@Truth.always.hurts.. have u lost your mind, isme kha se hindu muslim kar rha hai
we don't consider him Indian analyst @@rajatkm.7
Dear Dr Moeed and Pravin. What a refreshing discussion. Please do it periodically so that we can see an Indian and Pakistani have a cogent, rational and respectful discussion.
Very healthy dialogue
Thank you, Moed sir for inviting Sir Pervin for this discussion.
2 brilliant minds ,great analysis.
Wow, I'm enjoying listening to Mr Pravin Swahney so immensely that its indescribable. Here is a man who has different level of understanding altogether on regional and int politics. I realize how narrow has our vision hs bn made by the bloody rogue politicians and military that we so engrossed in our petty day to day Realpolitik of the bloody military that are almost incapable of looking at the bigger pic.
Thankyou Moeed Pirzada for inviting Praveen Saheb to the programe.
Wonderful and knowledgeable discussion. Ppl with two diverse views. Dr Sb unity of oommand from military point of view is strength but interference of Army into civilian affairs is weakness. I enjoyed the discussion
wow. Two great Analysts in one frame!!...was waiting for such an interaction!
ایشوز کو درست طور سے جاننے سمجھنے کا موقع ملا۔ شکریہ ڈاکٹر معید❤
Chinese should understand that for the Punajbi army generals amercian dollars for themselves and U.S. citizenship for their children are of far more importance than any strategic or economic alliance with China.
Chup kur jaa youthiaaa imrandoo 😂
Afghan KHAD member
No doubt its a bitter truth
Pak foj is now, punjab police ruled by Gen Maryam Safdar
An excellent dialogue with a respected and prominent Indian analyst who is equally respected in Pakistan.
Equally or only respected in Pakistan because I don't think many people know him in India
This is the hypocrisy of the Pakistani elites they always quote arundhuti roy, akar patel, this parvin.... type pseudo secular hypocrite intelectual. @@hritikraghuwanshi2049
Who is this guy😂😂😂
Captain shawney is respected only Pakistan.. he is not even known by one percent of Indians.
Yeh budha he kon 😂😂
It was an excellent show. Dr Moeed please continue discussing with Mr. Praveen in future.
This was an amazing discussion! Please have him back for more!!
اپ کو ان کے ساتھ مزید پروگرام کرنا چاہیے ان کے اندر وہ پاکستان انڈیا والی نفرت نہیں ہے
2 Brilliant People with Brain
@@HarishKumar-sg8kgprove how?
I listened to the interview. And understood despite being an Indian who consumes hours of news each day, why I have never heard of Pravin Sawhney?
Because he doesn't worship bjp
@@alokchaubey3697because he is pro china😂
@@alokchaubey3697he is sucking you
@@alokchaubey3697because he is pro Pakistan and congressi
It was a great discussion..got glued during whole time ...plz continue the same..👍
My favorite Indian analyst Parvin Sawhney .Thank you Dr.Pirzada.
Expected, as he gives u false hope....he is a congress stooge.
He gives you false hope, I stopped listening to him when he once said India we lose a war with Pakistan 🇵🇰
@@abhijazzsharma
A critic should speak beyond personal likes and dislikes; they should rise above their own preferences when discussing. A critic should be honest in their analysis. We don't listen to or admire a critic for mental solace but rather to understand situations. We continue to read Kuldip Nayar, Mani Shankar Aiyar, Seema Mustafa, Khashwant Singh with the same enthusiasm. If you say so, then I'll start liking Arnab Goswami in Pravin Sawhney 's place.
@@krisvin7761 "I am sure these days you are also a fan of Dr. Moeed Pirzada. This does not mean that I will start disliking the doctor these days. hahahaha
@@GardaabTV Pravin is no analyst, it's such aa waste of time listening to him. I mean you can get a different perspective but that too seems like a big waste of time, he has not facts and figures only opinion
زبردست ڈسکشن۔
Loved that discussion ❤
Moeed you don't interrupt guest so much, specially when guest is so respectable. Sawhney Sahib is a very polite and patient person
Salute to Pravin from Paistan , i listen to this gentelman since long , its a discussion between Political analyst ( prsently annoyed with army ) and a military analyst about military . Paravin sb has an uperhand in this discussion.
Yeah Yeah...
This Person Had No Value In India...
And Is Anti Indian... Anti Modi...
Naturally... You Like Him...
Why Not...
@@first6969 I just came to know through your comment that Mr Pravin has No value in India , this is the dilema nowadays, Very unfortunate that such sain voice based on logic & facts is not valued in his country. All that he talks about is baked by facts and figures instaed of his personal opinion.
He was a part of the Indian delegation to Pakistan so i guess he is very mush valued in the Quarters that matter / count.
He is not anti India infact he is a true Indian 😊 , He is not anti Modi either , yes he may be objecting here and there on Modi,s extremist ideology ( where ever it may be) but his objection should be cosidered healty objection in the Indian democratic society.
To grow Financial prosperity is not the only field in which a country needs to excell but there are other sectors too such as Cultural diversity , religous harmony / tolerence , freedom in the true sence to all , equal growth opurtunities to all etc.
For country like India with such a diverse cultre with so many religious minorities an unbiased approach is the best way forward, otherwise internal conflicts / caos will hamper the true growth of india as fabric of the society will be damaged.
Religious extremisim may it be hindu , muslim , christian , jew or sikh has devastating affects on the social fabric.
Mr Pravin may have an unpopulist opinion but that is the truth.
Regards. 🙂
and salam to Mr.Pravin too. 😉.
@@sajidsaif
Of All The People In The World...
I Repeat, Of All The People In The World ..
A Pakistani Lecturing Indian...?
Irony Could Not Have Been More Starker...
Yes This World Is Full Of Hypocrites...
Indeed...
It Is Like The Devil Is Quoting From The Scriptures...
@@sajidsaiflogic and facts? He is literally commie and china sympathisors
سر ایسی مزید ڈسکشنز ہونی چاہیئے میں بلوچستان سے پولیٹیکل سائنس کا طالب علم ہوں اس سے بہت مدد ملتی ہے اصل حالات سمجھنے میں
Wow! This was one of the most interesting and absorbing discussions that I have witnessed. There was soooo much to discuss that the focus kept switching from one topic to the other. I wish you two can make it a regular feature at least once a month, with an agreement to keep the discussion limited to one topic which won't be easy though. I would be eagerly looking forward to.
Thanks Moeed for a great show.
Thank you Parvin and Dr Moeed for this amazing discussion! 👏🏻
We need more of this
An excellent parwin Sawni explored the world's current position. Dr Moed pirzda continues your programm with these intelligent person
OMG 😊, Dr, you have done the best ever job in your career by inviting this gem 💎 Pravin Sawhney!
In ur whole career? Kuch ziyada nahi hogaya?
BTW Pravin Sawhney is not liked by anyone in India...neither he get any importance from Indian people
@Cooper_453 “The ignorance has no boundaries or religion”
@@Alstiyan33this is a real shame. The media should provide ample opportunity to such sane voices, else India will sway with the US who survive on conflicts and hence promoted conflicts, Israel Palestine conflict is a glaring example. The US is nudging India to follow the same path towards China and Pakistan.
r@@sharafkhan6270r u telling me that china is not hostile to india like Pakistan ?
@@sharafkhan6270last time we know..us not claiming indias land..but china is doing so regularly
What a great discussion. Absolutely loved it! Didn’t feel like the vlog was for 1.5 hours. Really appreciate all your efforts to bring forward such insightful discussions without worrying about the number of views and likes.
And I'm glad Moeed Pirzada's perspective of Global South being 'poor' and Western World as the beacon of light for progress of humanity is finally challenged by a bigger analyst on the subject!😊
Dr Moeed ! You're the Treasure of Education. What an Invaluable Discussion with Pravin Sawhney ,HATSOFF to you. Thank you
Assalamualaikum...Indian Muslim here.
I m a viewer of Pravin Sawhney.
Moeed sir ka problem ye he...ke he can't able to differentiate between internal matters and military issues. Wo baar baar Pakistan Army ka interfere in politics pe bol rahe hain...jab ke Pravin sir Military issues pe bol rahe hain
2 Great Analysis...Brave Man and Brilliant minds for both countries India and Pakistan ..
Thank you Pravin and Moeed Sb for such an enlightening discussion. Please do rearrange another session.
بہت خوب۔۔۔۔ یہ گفتگو سن کر مزہ آیا۔
O Both the anchor persons are very intelligent and intellectual, we want to see more vlogs of both of them together
What a masterclass. Thank you. This masterclass must continue on bilateral and multilateral relations.
Really enjoyed the conversation.
With best wishes and blessings to Mr. Pravin, listening first time. Enjoy the discussion of two highly literate persons.
Excellent Analysis DR MOEED and MR Pravin From Both Journalist Good Discussion SIR
I was very anxious of this interview. Thanks doctor and Mr Sahwney.
ہمارے ہاں دشمن بنا کے اس کی طرف دیکھنا بھی گناہ بنا دیا جاتا
کافی لمبی وڈیو تھی لیکن بہت دلچسپ انفارمیٹو زبردست
شکریہ
بہت انفارمیشن پروگرام ھے. ایسے پروگرام مزید ھونے چاہیے.
Dr. Moeed,, today you have surprise me what I know of your intellect.
Pravin Shb is brilliant, so good to hear him. Wish there could more such discussions with Pravin.
Brilliant! It was a pleasure to hear an unbiased and intelligent conversation. Good work Dr. Moeed
Absolutely loved this show! It's refreshing to see discussions on a broad spectrum of topics encompassing regional and global geopolitics.
Thank you for bringing this insightful content, and I'm eagerly anticipating more in the future. Please continue to delve into local politics as well.
Best wishes from Germany!
Thankyou Dr shb and Pravin shb. Please keep such programs coming.
Great discussion.
Highly informative.
Congratulations to Dr Moeed.
بہت اچھی گفتگو ، بہترین کوشش ۔۔۔ ہمیشہ جاری رہنی چاہیے۔۔۔والسلام
Dr Moeed this is one of your best interview in recent time, conduct some more like this. Thanks
I think one of the best discussions on your channel ❤
Thanks for having him on the show I'm a big fan and have been following him for a long time. He is very knowledgeable and an accomplished expert in his field
Hi, I am from Pakistan. Great fan of Parvin Sawhney. I have been listening him for the last 4 years. I greatly appreciate his analysis and explanation of military operations in such simple terms.
Dr. Moeed, I commend you for inviting him on your show. Please my request is to make him a regular guest, if possible ❤
One of the best discussions- hats off to this initiative and keep it up. Enlightened me a lot
Big fan of Mohtaram Pravin Sawhney. An intriguing discussion between both of you. Thank you Dr. Moeed for this amazing program. Love and respect for both of you from Sindh.
معید پیر زادہ صاحب اپ ان کے ساتھ زیادہ پروگرام کیا کریں یہ بہت اچھی ڈسکشن کر رہے ہیں
I must say that this is one of your best discussions,two minds with so much information,perceptions, and future predictions ..thoroughly enjoyed every second of it....Thanks for this effort
Great debate . I hope should b more in future. Thank you 🙏
Thanks Dr Moeed! Once again a wonderful and factual discussion, well done! Now this platform doing wonders for Pakistanis like us( living in island of ignorance and under brutal establishment).
ماشاء اللہ بہت خوب بہت مزہ ایا
بہت بہت شکریہ آپ کا کہ ا تنا اچھا پروگرام کیا ایسا پروگرام ہر ہفتے ھونا چاہئیے شکریہ سر معید اللہ آپ کی خیر رکھئے آمین
Both are my favourites. What a privilege to listen them. All sense
Excellent choice of guest like Pravin sawhney, Expecting more guest like him.
Really interesting discussion. Thank you. Great to get another pespective on current happenings!
It was excellent discussion on multiple topic. much respect and love for both of you
Dr. Moeed, great discussion. Thanks a lot. ❤
A very good and informative discussion between two balanced people on both sides of the border
Good to hear Prawin Sawhney appreciating the independent journalists of Pakistan. He also rightly gives credit to Imran Khan/ Bajwa for improved focus on socioeconomics. He’s also right in that India and Pakistan Armies are balanced in that if Pakistan lost Bangladesh in 1971, India had also lost half of Kashmir in 1948.
Pakistani army should watch Pravin videos. Boost milegaa.😂😂😂😂
Pakistan lost Bangladesh in 1971 and India lost half of Kashmir in 1947...this is very very wrong comparison.
Pakistan actually lost war of Kashmir in 1947 also...J and K was princely state with complete autonomy during British rule.
When Indo Pak were liberated in 1947....Pakistan invaded J and K with the intention that it is an autonomous region and not a region of newly formed India...But still Pakistan failed to take whole J and K and Indian forces restricted them to present-day Azad Kashmir and Gilgit Baltistan...That was actually win of India.
@@Alstiyan33If senior experts of Pakistan are such comedians then just imagine what level of comedians Pakistani people will be..😂😂
@@himashree_das7514 Listen Miss...I m not from India and I just said the truth...and Dr Moeed isn't comedian like u people...see his videos...It was Indian Pravin Sawhney who made such comedy type statement by comparing Bangladesh and Kashmir....watch full video then comment...
Btw comedians are present on both sides of border
@@Alstiyan33 He is the comedian clown, in fact the whole of Pakistan and Pakistan's economy is a comedy show.. and in that comedy circus, Pakistani people and leaders are doing comedy acts under the instructions of pak army🤭
Brilliant idea, this discussion. Pls keep it up
Total eye opener, thanks
Excellent discussion, I would love to hear more of such discussion ❤
Very interesting discussion.
Dr. Moeed, what a gem of a discussion. Highly engaging!
Beautiful discussion. We need more of this. Make this weekly please. Or at least once a month.
Mr Pravin Seb has very deep knowledge & he is right
It's a excellent program, thanks a lot.
Thank you Dr moeed please keep in touch with this gentleman thanks
Excellent, really enjoy the conversation between both of u !
Please talk again again it’s really informative and give us new perspectives to see the geopolitical scenario in the world
Weirdest interview ever. Indian guest is more pro Pakistani and more pro Pakistani army than even a Pak army general. And the Pakistani interviewer is more logical and measured
True... seems like he is lobbying for China
It is called mind Game... Indians chahte hai k Pakistan me status quo barkarar rahay...
It's not pro pakistani... When you are equipped with the insight of reality you will know what Mr. Parvin is talking... You can't ignore the facts and figure and the prevailing reality.... Mr. Parvin is plainly speaking the truth no pro this or that....
@@tapanthakur😂😂 wo nurse major nam ka hi ha, yha usko entertainment k lye sunte han
R a bhai ye indian qamar Cheema hai 😂
This is the first time I have heard him, now I am going to look for his v logs and add to my list. We need more people like him for analyzing and advising. Please have more sessions with him.
It was a treat to watch the enlightened discourse between the two intlectuals. ❤❤❤❤
Very nice program but I request to you please don't interrupt sir parvin we want to listen him
Good discussion by both gentlemen
dear dr moeed sahib i really love watching your videos and i am always keeping up with the videos. This is my first time commenting on your video especially this video, Please every week if you can keep up the india,usa,pakistan and china news up. This video was the best video i have watched so far and i just wanted to let you know that keep up the great work.
thanks, zia
what a discussion, its mind blowing. Please continue such discussion.
Pravin Sawhany is a wonderful defense and strategic analyst.
But why Pakistani army do not watch his booster videos 😆😆😆😆😆
Only justice can lead to emancipation of humanity and democracy is the first stepping stone!
Strongly agree
Very Intellectual and great one ❤
Keep doing more
Love it
Allah bless u 😊❤
What an amazing discussion.
Pravin Sawhney is a Chinese funded person. He operates through wire which is again a china funded newspaper. So take his views as china view.
Very true, his view is exactly what Chinese say
He is a scholar who knows China very well and deeply.
Very important to know your opponent, don't be blinded by hatred and egotism.
If he represents the Chinese view, it is good for now we know what the Chinese are thinking
@@nileem1 that is a possibility..
@@catinbootsnow4267 There was no hatred or egotism in the original comment. He just made an observation.
میرے خیال میں یہ پروگرام بہت اچھا تھا۔ ایک دو چیزوں کے بارے میں میرے خیال میں جو فردر ڈسکشن اپ لوگوں کی ہوگی اس میں ضرور ڈسکشن ہونی چاہیے۔ ایک تو جو پروین سر نے ساؤتھ چائنا سی کے بارے میں جو ڈسکشن اسٹارٹ کی تھی وہ ادھوری رہ گئی ہے میرے خیال میں اس کے بارے میں تھوڑی سی ڈیٹیل ڈسکشن ہونی چاہیے کیونکہ ظاہر ہے وہ ویتنام فلپین تائیوان ملیشیا کے بارے میں وہ جو ایک بتانا چاہ رہے تھے کہ وہاں پے کیا امریکن اسٹکچر کرئیٹ کر رہے ہیں اور اس کا وہ کیا فائدہ لینا چاہ رہے تھے تو اس بارے میں ذرا تھوڑا سا ڈیٹیل ہو جائے۔ دوسرا جو ایٹ دی اینڈ اف دا دیس ڈسکشن جو پروین سوانح صاحب نے وہ ایک اسٹیٹمنٹ دی ہے کہ نیٹو is over انٹرسٹنگ اسٹیٹمنٹ تو اس کے بارے میں بھی تھوڑا مزید ڈسکس ہو جائے۔
Appreciate you concern
A fantastic discussion...Pravin gave a different perspective on many issues supported by some interesting insights!
Dr. Sahab what a mature conversation. Fantastic. Lot to learn from such brilliant people.
Insha Allah everything will be okay
Very nice work
Just finished watching it completely.
Moeed sahab...dnt worry why views are less on few videos and ur other channels...
Have Ive observed the trend grows slowly...there were rarely any significant view presence on this GVS channels also...but now look at it MashaAllah..
Indeed others will grow also.
Very interesting vlog. Thank you Dr. Moeed & Thank you our guest Pravin Sawhney!