Here are the products that I reviewed. More details in the video description. Tide: amzn.to/3zPCi4b Arm & Hammer: amzn.to/4bNFLxl Gain: amzn.to/3WtS50n Persil: amzn.to/4bNmtIs Tide PODS: amzn.to/46qFUWJ Amazon Basics: amzn.to/4cFsxUG All: amzn.to/4f5F9Gh Molly’s Suds: amzn.to/3LrYJyP Seventh Generation: amzn.to/3Wc2RrA ECOS: amzn.to/3SbNEWw Biokleen: amzn.to/3LwiJAx Tyler: amzn.to/4cJ2cVD
Sadly they used to be pretty good at their reviews, but I think they are being paid for favorable reviews now, or the reviews just aren't real life. Thank you Project Farm for your great intensive efforts and reviews!
@@creativeloafer9792 Yeah, but Tide changed it's smell and formula to cheaper synthetic ingredients...many have complained about it. I miss the original Tide from years ago.
I've been only using Tide, Gain and Arm and Hammer for years but mostly Tide followed by Gain. Used Gain and Arm and Hammer when I was broke or running low on funds. I'm glad all 3 brands did well. Might have to go back to liquid Tide as I've been used Tide Pods for about 2 years now because of ease. I don't mind paying more for quality so I'll still stick with Tide unless it's so much more than Arm and Hammer or Gain. Oh, good thing I never tried Persil as they're supposed to be really good but I could never justify the price they charged. They're easily $4 - $5 more than what I pay for my Tide while Gain and Arm and Hammer we're usually $3 - $4 less than Tide.
Who knew laundry detergents could be so dramatic? I was on the edge of my seat waiting to see if the Tide Pods would defeat the mighty gear oil. It was like the World Cup of stains!
The best thing for gear oil, or any other oil is ammonia. I stank up 3 loads of laundry one time when I got a little gear oil from the foot of my boat. The ammonia took that smell, and stain right out.
I don't generally comment, but, in a world full of hype, your channel has to be one of the most useful and well thought out. I appreciate your content.
I would love to see a follow-up video with dedicated stain removers. My experience mirrors yours that no laundry detergent removes stains completely. Thanks for tackling this job. You deserve a raise!
Also adding clorine or oxygen bleaches, or Borax to the wash. How well do the recommended stain removal techniques such as Consumer's Reports or Good Housekeeping advise help?
Here is the result. Worst to best!!13. Water 12. Tyler 11. Bioklean 10. Ecos 9. 7th gen 8. Molly suds 7. All 6. Amazon basics 5. Tide pods 4. Percil 3. Gain 2. Arm and hammer 1. Tide (best) Thanks.
Here is the thing. These videos will not only be useful now but forver. The newer generation of adults every years will need to know what is the best product. My man is literal hero for putting in the work to make this and all his videos. Legend 💯
Amen! Yes Ma'am he sure is! You're one lucky lady for sure! It's SOO nice to see your loving support for what your husband does to educate the rest of us consumers out here who have ALWAYS wondered "are we spending our hard earned & hard to come by money on the correct products, that all have the same claims (or about the same)"? Without the right support system behind a project or someone doing a project, the results are never quite the same as one that has the correct support. So props to both of you for developing & delivering such valuable information and content that we all have been desperate to know about without doing what it is that you both do! Many Thanks & Much Love & support from your followers out here!! Keep up the amazing work & know that YOU ARE APPRECIATED!! Thank You!✌🏼🩷😊
I watch a lot of review type videos and I've been watching these for years and here's what I can tell you. If you watch about a 16 minute video from this guy, you are getting the equivalent to about a 45-minute video from most product reviewer- testers. He talks fast and moves it along and does not beat any subject to death. I like the way he finishes each segment with a full-screen chart that you can pause and analyze. I think this channel and Torque Test are about the best you're going to find on here.
I agree 💯 I haven't seen the other channel but I just shared this video to 20 men over 40 because this matters to us and we don't have time to waste lol
I've used Arm & Hammer my whole life! (64) I have an allergic reaction to some detergents and it does a great job and very gentle on my skin. No itching!💜
Another very important video! This is a subject that every household deals with on a regular basis. You are proving all the time that just because a product cost more, doesn’t mean it works better. No wonder you have 3.25 million subscribers, and you deserve every single one of them! Thank you!
Persil liquid and pods. Dash pods for heavy duty. Dash liquid for colder washes. My working clothes washed with Dash pods. Washing on the right temperature and program is also important. We use a Miele machine btw.
After many years of working on farms, in emergency medicine, in field biological research, vehicle and building maintenance, and having done lots of yard work, I finally realized that charcoal gray clothing solved most of my stain problems. It's pretty much all I wear now.
Although my clothes only get gross through multiple hobbies (carpentry/construction, landscaping, auto mech/tech, Mexican food, etc.), I couldn't agree more. Blacks fade badly through tough washes and whites end up looking like a homeless guy used my shirt as his perpetual catch rag/shelter blanket. So, greys (grays?) have become my go-to t-shirt color because they hold up a LOT better than every other color. The only problem is trying to coordinate them with shorts/pants. Thankfully, there is Costco, where I can afford to just buy one of everything.
Likewise I work in an industry with a lot of similar issues and own dozens of identical dark gray shirts and jeans. I look like I wear the same clothes every day. But it absolutely prevents stains from showing up and it's all easily replaced if it gets too damaged. I love not having to think about what I wear.
That washer is by far the best design washer in the last 50 years. It still reigns King. I would take a 20 year old one of those over a new front loading high efficiency any day.
@@007nadineL My 4.7cf 2020 LG does a better job than my 1988 whirlpool agitator ever did. FLs made a bad impression in the USA market because until the past ten years or so, they were small enough (4cf or less) that an average "big load" filled the whole drum almost, meaning there was no room for water/detergent to circulate, and no room for the clothes to tumble into themselves (which provides the agitation). People were also not told how important it is to KEEP THE DOOR OPEN WHEN NOT IN USE! And running a hot bleach load once or twice a month helps clean everything in general. My gasket is flawless after four years of absolute hell. Anyway tldr old front loaders were too small for the US market until semi recently and they run like shit when they're too full. If you don't overfill, they will work better than an agitator due to removing more water from the clothes during spin cycle, exchanging the water from them more effectively.
Pro tip, you can turn a small dial inside the top cover to allow more water into the front washers. Mine now fills up almost halfway up the glass and does a much better job at washing.
I just noticed that when I open a Project Farm video I habitually hit "Like" even before I start watching. I think I'm just so grateful for this man's ingenuity and commitment to methodical, transparent standards that we all benefit from.
@@ProjectFarm i use degreeser.. then go buy new cloths.. they burn well tho.. ausie..we have tide & ive heard of persell. omo was the best.. but. gretta put a stop to real cleaners..
That’s why I’m subscribed his tests are very thorough and very fair & he’s not afraid to say which is which. I like this channel & I know 3-4 others that watch this channel
Agreed. The only thing I would have suggested for this test is to have the washer a bit more full with other items. Top loaders work better when they have a full load (NOT over full though) because the clothes can rub against each other and help with removing stains during the agitation stage.
Arm and Hammer is the laundry detergent I have also used for several years. It is the least expensive jug at my local grocery store. Seeing how it performed in this test makes me feel so much better about buying it. I have also used Gain, but it is more expensive and I don't care for the fragrance. Many thanks to Todd for an outstanding video presentation (as usual!!)
Concur. I'm a DIY guy, especially with vehicle maintenance. My winter Behr tan colored coveralls get all kinds of stains. Brake fluid, bearing and joint grease, various lubricants and oils, various fluids. Stain removal would be a good test. Thx PF, best channel on YT
@@ProjectFarm as a person interested in hunting and camouflage, I'd be interested in a UV-free clothes washing episode. Military uniforms are supposed to be washed without UV dye to maintain the imagery-resistant properties and coatings. Hunters have learned that deer can see into the UV range so clothes washed with UV brighteners can alert them. Sport wash and old fashioned soaps are what I've seen, but ALL supposedly makes a UV free version available on base. There is also a Sport Wash UV remover.
One thing I learned about laundry over the years as a mechanic, is regardless of what you use, pretreating a stain with a few drops of the laundry detergent directly on a stain, for about 10 minutes before washing, by far makes a bigger difference than any laundry detergent. Now if you buy a cheap toothbrush or use an old one and scrub in that laundry detergent drops into that stain for 30 seconds, that helps even more.
A little bit of borax and washing soda added really boosts performance also. I've been using the Arm & Hammer Odor Blasters with a little borax and washing soda for years. The fresh burst scent stays in the clothes longer than more expensive ones and with the inexpensive additives beats others I've tried.
Yes, stain removers please! Arm & Hammer detergent and Shout stain remover have been out go-to for the last decade, would love to see the stain removers go head to head.
Project Farm hits a new video, and it's 5 am. You know what normal people would do? Yes, they would watch it without any hesitation. I just love this type of informative content!
I have been a mechanic/fabricator all my life and my wife has tried every detergent under the sun to keep my clothes clean, settling on Tide eventually. Guess she picked a winner!
This guy is a savage. Imagine practical testing, un baised, scientifically and subjectivly correct, and detailed. To see arm and hammer on the top is a surprise...❤❤
Yeah been using A&H for a long time too, I didn't buy it based on price either, I'm using a different brand now but that's only because I like the scent.
I've spent years in appliance repair and found by users and self that Tide was the most trusted brand. Personally I use either Tide or Gain detergents in powder form. The only problem I found with liquid form is they over time slimes up the outer tub and outer basket, otherwise they're great. Best additives I use is a quarter cup or so of a Hydrogen Peroxide cleaner for washing and White Vinegar for rinse. The easiest way to add the Vinegar is using a Downy Ball. The Vinegar helps by softening, making colors brighter and eliminating foul odors. As usual, Thanks Todd
When traveling and unable to shower. Add some white vinegar to wipes. Using that to wipe away odors from toes, armpits and crotch area makes a big difference.
I used to use white vinegar in the old Downy ball to make sure the dye on my new cotton clothing was set. It worked compared to when I didn't do that, but I still have no idea why.
I just remember when a guy commented on a different video asking for this for his wife, and I was happy to see project farms commitment to his followers and made this. Thank you for all that you teach us.
As someone in the professional laundry industry, the graying is caused by a process known as redeposition, or redep, when that happens there detergent does not have enough surfactant (bubbles) to carry away the soil. Enzymatic pre-treatment will greatly help on organic food stains, where specialty water-based (typically citrus-based) degreasers are needed for organic-oils and nearly all petroleum oil stains. If you really want that oil stain out go to a drycleaner. The "dry" in drycleaning is just not using water it's washed in highly specialized and controlled solvents.
@@chrisdeneault2735 Alright bud, you tell us: what's your personal laundry soap situation look like today next to your washer machine? Name the products.
I would like to see more laundry detergents tested including ones for sensitive skin (aka "free & clear") and would also enjoy watching stain removers testing. Thanks for all your work!
@@MVEZombie I wish he made an app so i could reference it every time I buy something lmao why pay more because the company lies about how amazing their product is
Tide, Liquid Oxy Clean, Downy. Laundry staples of my life. Also, knowing how to separate laundry, not to overload your machine, pre treating stains, and what wash setting to use are also key components. I never dry whites in the dryer as they can yellow over time.
I swear every video has me either instantly cheering for my brand like it was my favorite football team or wanting a brand of something I don't even have a use for to win. I love this channel!
I really like your videos for 1. The content; 2. You introduce your topic and quickly start the video without saying, "And without further ado; 3. You have no dead time in your videos. Every second is filled with pertinent content. Thank you for all the hard work you do to test so many things. I appreciate it.
Not just stain removers, but since most laundry detergent brands have their own branded stain remover, do the stain remover with its corresponding detergent.
What’s wrong with Consumer Reports? Just the lack of actually seeing their tests? Or are we referring more to their usually dismal consumables testing (except for sunscreen and bugspray, their testing for cleaning stuff is indeed terrible I will admit)?
I love the direction this channel has gone and the fact that a video on laundry detergent could still get 1 million views! I use this channel now whenever I go to buy anything from the store!
This reminds me of how fabric softener is one of the most shockingly problematic products on the market, which is a product I'd love to see you test. They're pretty much 99% marketing, generally adding a waxy layer to your clothes to *feel soft* without actually softening the clothes themselves, and in the long run (or if you use too much of it in a wash) you can actually make it HARDER to clean your clothes because that waxy layer gets in the way. Comparing fabric softeners to regular white vinegar (something that has shown to actually soften the fabric, rather than faking it, and no, there's no vinegar smell after washing) would be amazing to see, although I'm not entirely sure how you'd be able to test them.
Only the Boomer Generation would come up with an idea so insane as "Poison ourselves and two generations of our children to make our laundry 'soft' and smelling like cheap, migraine-inducing artificial fragrances" 🤢.
STAIN REMOVERS! YES YES YES PLEASE! I am currently struggling to remove oil stains and arm pit stains from my work shirts and can't get them clean for nothing!
Before washing clothes with oil stains, smear each oil stain with a vegetable shortening (like Crisco). Rub it in thoroughly, then wash it out with Dawn dish soap. Rinse and repeat as needed.
Arm pit stains Peroxide Use some of your laundry detergent rubbed in with an old toothbrush Cheapo meat tenderizer with no dyes Give it 10 minutes or so to work before washing
When I worked as a tire factory maintenance tech, stains from oils, grease, carbon black and other yucky stuff, I learned to rub down the stains with Gojo hand cleaner before taking off my clothes, and when it came time to wash them (a day or ten later), most of the stains came right out.
From tool reviews now to laundry detergent. Your tests are always ahead of the game and I trust them before anyone else. Thanks for the honest unbiased and well researched reviews! The amount of effort you put in each video should be applauded!
Would love to see a stain remover comparison, as well as a follow-up that tests the Kirkland brand. Thanks so much for all your effort on this channel!
Newly married in the '70's, my husband worked at a Steel Mill. Known in area Laundromats as 'Mill Clothing', with designated machines. Thinking detergents were basically the same, I was driven by cost and coupons for purchase. After years of noticeable differences in cleaning results, I started documenting and rating brand effectiveness. *Tide* was always the best and the ONLY brand I buy for almost 50 years. I don't buy 'Pods' b/c the size of my loads varies. I also don't buy liquid, too bulky and too much plastic. The worst of the name brands was 'All' (consistently). Pre-treat a heavy stain with Wisk liquid : ) YOU'RE WELCOME!
We buy liquid tide and use 1oz per load regardless of its size and have for a very long time. We have not noticed any change. The savings is huge as a couple of bottles will last a person a year. The big bottles that have 150 to 170 oz in them will give you 3 loads a week for a single bottle a year. Consider trying it for a while and quit over using the soap. You do know the same soap sold a decade ago had small amounts. They increased the size so that you waste more soap and spend more money.
My wife wants a stain remover video as well. She would really like you to try Carbona, Fels Naphtha, Lestoil and Dawn dishwashing liquid. My wife never uses cold water. She says it doesn’t really clean clothes.
Todd, you never cease to amaze me. You are THE authority on EVERYTHING. I don't know how I would get through daily life without Project Farm! Thanks again for another informative REAL product evaluation.
Agreed. I used to use Tide, but tried Arm & Hammer after balking at thr cost of Tide. Have not regretted it since. For heavy stains, a little pre treatment works wonders.
Same here. Been using Arm & Hammer for at least the last 20 years. However I don’t use the measuring cup. I use the TLAR method. My clothes get clean and I don’t stink so it’s a win. 😅
@@emmi5581 I have terrible skin as well and have been using Molly Suds because of the ingredient list but like the test shows, it may not clean the best. I tried A&M before but didn't have great results, may give it another shot.
Awesome video. I have another suggestion. Soak the stained t-shirts for 1 or 2 days in a bucket or tray with its respective detergents so that the detergent can cut through the stains further and do another wash. I do this for heavily stained clothes and it works 99% of the time.
Women do that with lingerie. It also works to pour detergent straight on the stain and rub it in. Better if you catch the stain earlier, but it usually works even right before washing.
@@floycewhite6991 Im a guy and I do that too. I work in the field and stains can get into my uniform. Id rather soak my shirt than buy a new one, especially with this economy
Occasionally, I watch one of your videos and think "my wife would kill me if I did that at my house." This is one of those videos 😆 That's why we're thankful that you do it for us. Great video!
I never realized how much this channel influences my everyday choices. And im proud of it. Ive always used Tide. And im glad i dot have to test other brands
Quick note on the heavily perfumed Tyler wash from a guy who is very familiar with it: no one I know who uses it is actually using it for its power as a detergent. We use whatever unscented version of our preferred detergent and then add a capful of whichever Tyler scent we like. That stuff is strong. Depending on how much you use you can get a nice light scent or you can go full "Abercrombie&Fitch outlet store" on your clothes. And when you are only using it to add scent, one jug lasts plenty long to make the cost very minor. I think we had one jug last like a year and a half. Love the videos. You are a Godsend to all us data driven retail consumers.
I’m shocked at the arm and hammer. I always dismissed at cheap detergent but it costs 1/4 the price of tide and performed almost as good. I’m impressed.
Let this be a valuable lesson that the price of something doesn't mean anything. More often than not, you are paying for the name and their marketing budget. Those cheap store-brand items you see are almost always just rebranded name brand products. Don't be fooled.
Great video and comparison per usual. As someone with severely sensitive skin I would really like to see a follow up with free and clear/sensitive skin options. Both compared to each other and their standard formulas. At least with the Arm and Hammer (what I use) and the Tide options, since they were the top picks.
Thanks for confirming what 46 years of seeing my mom use has taught me - no matter how much we were cutting corners in our extremely busy house to save money growing up, mom always shopped sales and cut coupons to be able to buy liquid Tide because it’s cheaper than buying new clothes!! Sent this to my mom to tell her that yet another test proves she was right all these years for doing so…lol. 😂 Great content - this is what side by side comparison reviews should always be like for people to watch!! Nicely done!! 🙌🏼
I'm not entirely sure there is anything people wouldn't want to see tested in this format. Every single time it's informative and useful. I was looking for a new fan and the last video helped me pick one that is a good value (I went with the Hurricane). Thank you for all the hard work!
Dude I just moved two days ago and got done fixing the sink. Made some food and on my way to my room I was thinking "I need to get some laundry detergent tomorrow" now I know the feeling I've seen from other comments, beautiful.
My grandmother used to pre soak my white shirts in kerosene and used a scub board, then wash them with powered All laundry soap and they looked like new. The start of my mechanic career.
A Tide brand executive alum spoke to my college business class. He spoke of their successful proprietary enzymes & ingredients with such conviction, passion, and pride that I've never used another brand in 18 years. (Tide Cold Water when cold water technology was a new thing)
After this video, I will definitely give A&H and Gain a try. Be brand agnostic because sometimes brands will dilute or tweak their formula (for the better or for the worse) to save money or due to ingredients no longer being available. It's always good to try something new once in a while, otherwise we'd still be using landlines or Motorola brick cell phones.
@@SayAhh We use tide and only use 1oz per load regardless of size. We have not noticed a single change in how clean things get. Its worth trying lower amounts of soap. If you do 3 loads a week one large bottle will last you a year.
This episode makes me hopeful that he's actually doing kitty litter. Us mechanics need it too for in the garage mishaps, but also something our mouse finders can enjoy using.
Ya, would be cool seeing various brands of it tested vs dedicated oil cleanup products, and some natural alternatives I've seen like crushed walnut shells.
When I was working as a diesel mechanic we used Tide to clean out the cooling system of oil when the oil cooler leaked oil into the cooling system. We tried many different detergents but only Tide would clean out the system good enough. It did take much time and water to clean but it was easer and much less expensive than removing the radiator and disassembling the engine. Tide is definitely my go to for cleaning clothes, engines and radiators. 🙂
If you’re thinking about testing something, trust me, we’re here for it and there’s never gonna be a video you put out that we don’t watch and want. Love the thumbnail!
We women know that detergent by itself doesn't work on stains. Stains have to be pretreated with a stain fighter such as Shout or Felsnaptha. But, was an insightful comparison!
yes felsnaptha! i now use the white Goop hand cleaner as my stainfighter. even today I got out chicken wing buffalo sauce/grease off my white and turquoise hat with just rubbing it in with my fingers in the kitchen sink, drying now, no stain. kids shirts and spaghetti sauce disappears with it. Cherry bomb is red and still works the same with pumice stone in it. saves me $ by not throwing clothes to the goodwill
Idea for a video... everyone has had a septic tank issue. There are tons of "treatment" and monthly care products on the market for a septic tank, but no one can see if they really work because the ranks are underground. Now that would be an interesting topic.
My wife always goes for expensive ones. Anything on the subject I said to her was not going to convince her. Once I saw this video, the first thing I thought was asking her to come over and have a look. Very useful video for her to understand how to select detergent cost-effectively.
Love the video....Partial to Tide. However...When I was first married, I caught my mom using a bucket to clean some rags. She and my wife had been cleaning a house we had just purchased. She rinsed the rags with the sprayer from our garden hose. Filled the 5 gallon bucket half way, chucked in the dirty rags with healthy glug of Lestoil. Finished filling the bucket and stirred it with a stick every 15 mins for an hour. Dumped the water out, threw the rags in our washer with a tiny bit of Tide and they came out amazing. I use Lestoil on everything but axel grease.
Here are the products that I reviewed. More details in the video description.
Tide: amzn.to/3zPCi4b
Arm & Hammer: amzn.to/4bNFLxl
Gain: amzn.to/3WtS50n
Persil: amzn.to/4bNmtIs
Tide PODS: amzn.to/46qFUWJ
Amazon Basics: amzn.to/4cFsxUG
All: amzn.to/4f5F9Gh
Molly’s Suds: amzn.to/3LrYJyP
Seventh Generation: amzn.to/3Wc2RrA
ECOS: amzn.to/3SbNEWw
Biokleen: amzn.to/3LwiJAx
Tyler: amzn.to/4cJ2cVD
I’m curious if the detergents would’ve done better with more clothes in there, as the friction between clothes could provide more scrubbing action.
It's a odd feeling when you realize your old enough that a laundry detergent face-off is something you really wanna see.
Thanks for sharing!
I'm so old it used to be a box of flakes. Don't even know if thatv is still made.
Most people establish that feeling with a Costco membership. I wish their Kirkland detergent was in the game too. It's an amazing product.
32nd birthday for me today. My wife and I jumped on this video too fast. We old now.
Hadn't thought about it that way. And now I feel old, because I DID want to see it.
I think we all need to take a moment to recognize the sacrifice the washing machine gave to support this video.
I'm now wondering if he's gonna do tests on washers and dryers now.
@@HolyKripple Yeah I don't think he used his own washer and dryer for that. I wouldn't..
I'm sure having a farm, he has washer/driver out in shop, that see's things like this regularly.
@@adfaklsdjf definitely "borrowed" his neighbor's washing machine.. ;)
LOL
This channel is what Consumer Reports should be.
I disagree. Todd's chnnel is MUCH better than
consumer reports!
steve
Sadly they used to be pretty good at their reviews, but I think they are being paid for favorable reviews now, or the reviews just aren't real life.
Thank you Project Farm for your great intensive efforts and reviews!
I subsribed to CR for a year and felt like I had been had.
@@leesonneville1817 I subscribed for 40 years. It used to be very good. Went woke and went bad when the new editor took over. I ended my subscription.
This is your new consumer reports
I'm not sure the 11,000th comment will ever be seen, but this is a vote for stain remover reviews.
I saw it!
A stain remover face-off needs to include Dawn, the best thing I've tried for removing oil-based stains.
@markkempton4579 TIDE/OxyClean.
My wife said “I’d absolutely love to see a stain remover comparison since I’ve not found a good one yet.”
best stain remover I've found so far is dawn power wash. even takes out old stains.
@@hoodrichallstarThanks for the tip! I'm willing to try anything at this point.
I saw a comparison on another channel and what beat all the store brands was plain old hydrogen peroxide with about 20% Dawn dish soap in it.
@@hoodrichallstar It is the only thing I've found that takes out butter stains. Spray N Wash, Shout and others like it do absolutely nothing.
Fels naptha bars!! That and dawn. Fels can be rubbed directly on stain. Or you can grate it with a cheese grater and sprinkle into washing machine.
Bruh, there are NO limits, you tested laundry detergent with bovine excrement. You are the MAN!
Thanks!
Thanks for watching!
Your wash and dryer are the real champs of a true torture test. Hope they smell better soon😮
When he cut into that heap, I could smell it from here...
A no BS test using BS
No one does this better than Project Farm.
Thanks!
NOBODY indeed!!
@@ProjectFarm Not flattery ,it's true.
NO ONE!! May god bless his brilliant mind.. he thinks like the best of us do
@@bennyv3663more
I've been using Arm & Hammer for decades. Good to see my gut instinct for performance and price is correct.
Thanks for sharing.
Same.
I’m a Tide man myself. May have to give your A&H a shot!
@@creativeloafer9792 Yeah, but Tide changed it's smell and formula to cheaper synthetic ingredients...many have complained about it. I miss the original Tide from years ago.
I've been only using Tide, Gain and Arm and Hammer for years but mostly Tide followed by Gain. Used Gain and Arm and Hammer when I was broke or running low on funds. I'm glad all 3 brands did well. Might have to go back to liquid Tide as I've been used Tide Pods for about 2 years now because of ease. I don't mind paying more for quality so I'll still stick with Tide unless it's so much more than Arm and Hammer or Gain. Oh, good thing I never tried Persil as they're supposed to be really good but I could never justify the price they charged. They're easily $4 - $5 more than what I pay for my Tide while Gain and Arm and Hammer we're usually $3 - $4 less than Tide.
Project Farm: "if you want to see a video on..."
The World: "YES!"
Lol!
If he did a 2 hour video on spittoons, I'd watch it.
@@MicahThomason - that would require a lot of saliva …
Since he's Project Farm, he should do a comparison of Pepperidge Farm products.
Today we're going to test which country is better at landing on the moon 😝👽🎬
3.25 million subscribers says it all. RIP Consumer Reports. Awesome review as always. 👍
Thanks!
Yup, consumer reports magazines have gone downhill.
They got woke, like so many other things that used to be successful.
@@MoneyManHolmesno they didn't. Anybody who uses that word is just a grumpy boomer.
Consumer Reports USED to be the masters of reviews! Not anymore! And they charge sometimes to see their reviews. Pffft! We have @ProjectFarm!!!
Who knew laundry detergents could be so dramatic? I was on the edge of my seat waiting to see if the Tide Pods would defeat the mighty gear oil. It was like the World Cup of stains!
Thanks for sharing!
Pods, tastes, great less filling
*Me going on line ordering pallets of this stuff before PF-related demand jacks up global prices.*
Way better than soccer.
The best thing for gear oil, or any other oil is ammonia. I stank up 3 loads of laundry one time when I got a little gear oil from the foot of my boat. The ammonia took that smell, and stain right out.
The fact that plain water beats expensive product is a huge insult to the advertisement market.
It’s a huge compliment to the advertisement market. They managed to sell something that is worse than useless!
spoiler alert.
@@deadsharkisartlol
Plain water didn't do well at all. Maybe rewatch the video!
Gotta stink tho
I don't generally comment, but, in a world full of hype, your channel has to be one of the most useful and well thought out. I appreciate your content.
Thanks so much!You are welcome!
Yes Sir, many of us agree with you, we appreciate the content
Pretty sure his wife yelled at him for the manure smelling washing machine, but it was worth it
@@TKUA11
At least for us
I would love to see a follow-up video with dedicated stain removers. My experience mirrors yours that no laundry detergent removes stains completely. Thanks for tackling this job. You deserve a raise!
Also adding clorine or oxygen bleaches, or Borax to the wash. How well do the recommended stain removal techniques such as Consumer's Reports or Good Housekeeping advise help?
Also fels-naphtha soap!
Thanks for the suggestion. Thanks for the feedback.
I was thinking that also. I would like to see oxy clean used. It may have been the helper for the Arm and Hammer brand in this video.
If we're going to dedicated stain removers, I want to see oxy-clean in a 5 gallon bucket of hot water for a day.
Project Farm is THE gold standard of UA-cam! Incredible analysis!
Thanks!
@@ProjectFarmPlease keep doing what you are doing without “selling out” for “big money”; YOU are valuable!!! 🙏
Here is the result. Worst to best!!13. Water
12. Tyler
11. Bioklean
10. Ecos
9. 7th gen
8. Molly suds
7. All
6. Amazon basics
5. Tide pods
4. Percil
3. Gain
2. Arm and hammer
1. Tide (best)
Thanks.
Thanks!
Why does a low score mean it’s good?
@@alabaster8625its a ranking. Not a score. 1 = best.
Go ahead and fill your clothes with toxic chemicals and then tell me what's best.
I think you need to stock 3 brands to cover most of the situations 😂
Here is the thing. These videos will not only be useful now but forver. The newer generation of adults every years will need to know what is the best product. My man is literal hero for putting in the work to make this and all his videos. Legend 💯
Thanks!
If I’m thinking of buying something I see if project farm has tested it.
@@adammalone3700same here multiple times.
Keep in mind that brands change their formula without telling us.
Amen! Yes Ma'am he sure is! You're one lucky lady for sure! It's SOO nice to see your loving support for what your husband does to educate the rest of us consumers out here who have ALWAYS wondered "are we spending our hard earned & hard to come by money on the correct products, that all have the same claims (or about the same)"? Without the right support system behind a project or someone doing a project, the results are never quite the same as one that has the correct support. So props to both of you for developing & delivering such valuable information and content that we all have been desperate to know about without doing what it is that you both do! Many Thanks & Much Love & support from your followers out here!! Keep up the amazing work & know that YOU ARE APPRECIATED!! Thank You!✌🏼🩷😊
I watch a lot of review type videos and I've been watching these for years and here's what I can tell you. If you watch about a 16 minute video from this guy, you are getting the equivalent to about a 45-minute video from most product reviewer- testers. He talks fast and moves it along and does not beat any subject to death. I like the way he finishes each segment with a full-screen chart that you can pause and analyze. I think this channel and Torque Test are about the best you're going to find on here.
Absolutely NO Filler !
2 of the only few channels out there that don’t waste time and ACTUALLY test products to the fullest extent possible 💯🙌
I agree 💯 I haven't seen the other channel but I just shared this video to 20 men over 40 because this matters to us and we don't have time to waste lol
Amen
@@charleywalker2982 We need to make a comparison video of Project Farm versus other comparison UA-camrs.
I love that you thought to do just plain water as one example.
Thanks!
it's just good scientific process to include a control
that's why he is the goat
It's shocking how well it did compared to some of the actual 'cleaners' 😄
goes to show that just using cold water immediately on a stain is going to help quite a bit ;)
I've used Arm & Hammer my whole life! (64) I have an allergic reaction to some detergents and it does a great job and very gentle on my skin. No itching!💜
Me too! I love Arm & Hammer.
Another very important video! This is a subject that every household deals with on a regular basis. You are proving all the time that just because a product cost more, doesn’t mean it works better. No wonder you have 3.25 million subscribers, and you deserve every single one of them! Thank you!
Thanks!
My Mom uses Persil for colors and tide for white.
I used to think it doesn't make a difference and use whatever.
Moms are Legends
Thanks for sharing.
I guess I’ll stop turning my nose up at the cheap Arm and Hammer stuff. It put a beat down on some of those stains.
Wish he had included Coscos' Kirkland brand laundry detergent
was persil, going to tide liquid .
Persil liquid and pods. Dash pods for heavy duty. Dash liquid for colder washes.
My working clothes washed with Dash pods.
Washing on the right temperature and program is also important.
We use a Miele machine btw.
After many years of working on farms, in emergency medicine, in field biological research, vehicle and building maintenance, and having done lots of yard work, I finally realized that charcoal gray clothing solved most of my stain problems. It's pretty much all I wear now.
I am a maintenance mechanic in a foundry, and my charcoal shirts still look good while the others are destroyed.
Our gardener's clothing is baked-in-green
Although my clothes only get gross through multiple hobbies (carpentry/construction, landscaping, auto mech/tech, Mexican food, etc.), I couldn't agree more. Blacks fade badly through tough washes and whites end up looking like a homeless guy used my shirt as his perpetual catch rag/shelter blanket. So, greys (grays?) have become my go-to t-shirt color because they hold up a LOT better than every other color. The only problem is trying to coordinate them with shorts/pants. Thankfully, there is Costco, where I can afford to just buy one of everything.
I love to wear black but they definitely fade bad, even with woolite.
Likewise I work in an industry with a lot of similar issues and own dozens of identical dark gray shirts and jeans. I look like I wear the same clothes every day. But it absolutely prevents stains from showing up and it's all easily replaced if it gets too damaged. I love not having to think about what I wear.
That washer is by far the best design washer in the last 50 years. It still reigns King. I would take a 20 year old one of those over a new front loading high efficiency any day.
Thanks for the feedback.
Me too. Front loaders don't drain and grow mould
.
@@007nadineLI think the new ones have some advanced technology to allow the washing to be more thorough
@@007nadineL My 4.7cf 2020 LG does a better job than my 1988 whirlpool agitator ever did. FLs made a bad impression in the USA market because until the past ten years or so, they were small enough (4cf or less) that an average "big load" filled the whole drum almost, meaning there was no room for water/detergent to circulate, and no room for the clothes to tumble into themselves (which provides the agitation). People were also not told how important it is to KEEP THE DOOR OPEN WHEN NOT IN USE! And running a hot bleach load once or twice a month helps clean everything in general. My gasket is flawless after four years of absolute hell.
Anyway tldr old front loaders were too small for the US market until semi recently and they run like shit when they're too full. If you don't overfill, they will work better than an agitator due to removing more water from the clothes during spin cycle, exchanging the water from them more effectively.
Pro tip, you can turn a small dial inside the top cover to allow more water into the front washers. Mine now fills up almost halfway up the glass and does a much better job at washing.
I just noticed that when I open a Project Farm video I habitually hit "Like" even before I start watching. I think I'm just so grateful for this man's ingenuity and commitment to methodical, transparent standards that we all benefit from.
Thanks!
Same here.
Yeah, same.
@@ProjectFarm i use degreeser.. then go buy new cloths.. they burn well tho.. ausie..we have tide & ive heard of persell. omo was the best.. but. gretta put a stop to real cleaners..
In college, the laundry room had a sign that read:
“For protein stains, use cold water.”
Thanks for sharing!
Don't eat food on your bed will help 😂
Underrated comment. Thanks for the laugh my friend.
Ummm, someone please explain in great detail the meaning of this.
Loll 😆
@@envisionCamusa it means the condom broke.
I love how you don't skip a step and make sure tests are thorough and fair
Thanks!
@@ProjectFarm
Compare bicycle chains maybe?
Thanks!
That’s why I’m subscribed his tests are very thorough and very fair & he’s not afraid to say which is which. I like this channel & I know 3-4 others that watch this channel
Agreed. The only thing I would have suggested for this test is to have the washer a bit more full with other items. Top loaders work better when they have a full load (NOT over full though) because the clothes can rub against each other and help with removing stains during the agitation stage.
Bro I stand by Arm and hammer. This just proved that this stuff works.
As a user of Arm & Hammer for years, this pleases me.
Arm and Hammer is the laundry detergent I have also used for several years. It is the least expensive jug at my local grocery store. Seeing how it performed in this test makes me feel so much better about buying it. I have also used Gain, but it is more expensive and I don't care for the fragrance.
Many thanks to Todd for an outstanding video presentation (as usual!!)
Same.
Same. Arm and hammer plus odor plasters is chefs kiss
A&H was good for me until they added the Oxiclean .The Oxi causes rashes on my skin.
@@Fred_Benderthey still make the original stuff
As someone who works road/repair construction, I’d be interested in a stain removal episode! Never an unentertaining episode!
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.
maybe with applying directly to the stains (pretreatment) for more real world test.
Concur. I'm a DIY guy, especially with vehicle maintenance. My winter Behr tan colored coveralls get all kinds of stains. Brake fluid, bearing and joint grease, various lubricants and oils, various fluids. Stain removal would be a good test. Thx PF, best channel on YT
Yes, and particularly on dark shirts. Those food oil spots just stay darker. I think we try Shout and it helps.But, we need a PF test.
@@ProjectFarm as a person interested in hunting and camouflage, I'd be interested in a UV-free clothes washing episode. Military uniforms are supposed to be washed without UV dye to maintain the imagery-resistant properties and coatings. Hunters have learned that deer can see into the UV range so clothes washed with UV brighteners can alert them. Sport wash and old fashioned soaps are what I've seen, but ALL supposedly makes a UV free version available on base. There is also a Sport Wash UV remover.
One thing I learned about laundry over the years as a mechanic, is regardless of what you use, pretreating a stain with a few drops of the laundry detergent directly on a stain, for about 10 minutes before washing, by far makes a bigger difference than any laundry detergent. Now if you buy a cheap toothbrush or use an old one and scrub in that laundry detergent drops into that stain for 30 seconds, that helps even more.
Dawn as a pretreater works well.
I did that, and was left with a stain of the friggin dye in the detergent....
The real tip is always in the comments
A little bit of borax and washing soda added really boosts performance also. I've been using the Arm & Hammer Odor Blasters with a little borax and washing soda for years. The fresh burst scent stays in the clothes longer than more expensive ones and with the inexpensive additives beats others I've tried.
Thank you for the tips.
Yes, stain removers please! Arm & Hammer detergent and Shout stain remover have been out go-to for the last decade, would love to see the stain removers go head to head.
Thanks for the suggestion.
Project Farm hits a new video, and it's 5 am. You know what normal people would do? Yes, they would watch it without any hesitation. I just love this type of informative content!
Thanks!
I have been a mechanic/fabricator all my life and my wife has tried every detergent under the sun to keep my clothes clean, settling on Tide eventually. Guess she picked a winner!
Tell her to pretreat the stains with Goop. I've been using it for 40 years on my husband's oily stains.
Thanks for the feedback.
Try tide hygienic. I'm a construction equipment mechanic and it seems to work amazing on all of my oil and grease stains!
I use arm and hammer. With a lil dawn dish soap and a splash of Awesome cleaner. Seems to get about anything out I've tried.
Every time this guy drops a video you know it's going to be 100% quality no BS no filler.
I was just waiting to see what tests he could come up with to be fair and consistent.
I've been using the arm and hammer for years because the price was good and it seemed to work. Glad to know I was making a great choice all along!
Thanks for sharing.
This guy is a savage. Imagine practical testing, un baised, scientifically and subjectivly correct, and detailed.
To see arm and hammer on the top is a surprise...❤❤
I'm not surprised at all. Been using Arm and Hammer for years with great results!
Yeah been using A&H for a long time too, I didn't buy it based on price either, I'm using a different brand now but that's only because I like the scent.
It didn't finish on top. Tide was #1
@@LiveFreeOrDieDH I fell out of using it somewhere , and I'M going back!
@@mantorras7752 Near enough and 1/2 the money or less!
Thank you for finally making this video!! And YES, please bring on the stain remover!
You are welcome! Thanks for the suggestion.
I would like to see liquid and stick stain removers.
Stain removers will be good
My favorite stain remover is Tea Tree oil. It's the best on stains that have already been washed
@@brycekpalmer works on olive or motor oil drips??
I've spent years in appliance repair and found by users and self that Tide was the most trusted brand. Personally I use either Tide or Gain detergents in powder form. The only problem I found with liquid form is they over time slimes up the outer tub and outer basket, otherwise they're great.
Best additives I use is a quarter cup or so of a Hydrogen Peroxide cleaner for washing and White Vinegar for rinse. The easiest way to add the Vinegar is using a Downy Ball. The Vinegar helps by softening, making colors brighter and eliminating foul odors.
As usual, Thanks Todd
When traveling and unable to shower. Add some white vinegar to wipes. Using that to wipe away odors from toes, armpits and crotch area makes a big difference.
Tide and Gain are foul odors.
I used to use white vinegar in the old Downy ball to make sure the dye on my new cotton clothing was set. It worked compared to when I didn't do that, but I still have no idea why.
I'll vouch for the vinegar, I just put it in the softener side, way cheaper than softener, helps rinse out the soap, helps with smells.
Thanks for the info!
Finally someone who let the stains dry, all those commercials always wash them while they are still fresh, no one does that.
Thanks for the feedback.
I just remember when a guy commented on a different video asking for this for his wife, and I was happy to see project farms commitment to his followers and made this. Thank you for all that you teach us.
You are welcome!
I've been a subscriber for about 5yrs now and I still look forward to watching these videos.
Thanks so much!
Same! ProjectFarm = Consistent Excellence / Time
ME TOO !
As someone in the professional laundry industry, the graying is caused by a process known as redeposition, or redep, when that happens there detergent does not have enough surfactant (bubbles) to carry away the soil. Enzymatic pre-treatment will greatly help on organic food stains, where specialty water-based (typically citrus-based) degreasers are needed for organic-oils and nearly all petroleum oil stains. If you really want that oil stain out go to a drycleaner. The "dry" in drycleaning is just not using water it's washed in highly specialized and controlled solvents.
BTW @Projectfarm love your work, keep it up, I have used your hard work in making many decisions! Than you!!
Great info, thanks!
@@chrisdeneault2735 Alright bud, you tell us: what's your personal laundry soap situation look like today next to your washer machine? Name the products.
@@fidel-3470 wouldn't you believe it that I don't get that choice in my house... 😅
@@chrisdeneault2735 LOL
I would like to see more laundry detergents tested including ones for sensitive skin (aka "free & clear") and would also enjoy watching stain removers testing. Thanks for all your work!
You are welcome! Thanks for the suggestion.
This is the kind of money saving content that we need these days. Very informative, but still entertaining.
and Very Impressive!
@@MVEZombie I wish he made an app so i could reference it every time I buy something lmao why pay more because the company lies about how amazing their product is
@@fatguy9
Shop slowly & compare
Omg yes. Laundry detergent is so expensive. Now we can really know which is best!
Very expensive indeed! Thank you
Thankfully almost always the cheapest brands powders outperform the others. At least since many years in german institute testing. Stiftung Warentest
Tide will become more expensive after this video.
Tide always expensive and always the best
@@ibrax5 Priced well beyond sense .
Tide, Liquid Oxy Clean, Downy. Laundry staples of my life. Also, knowing how to separate laundry, not to overload your machine, pre treating stains, and what wash setting to use are also key components. I never dry whites in the dryer as they can yellow over time.
I swear every video has me either instantly cheering for my brand like it was my favorite football team or wanting a brand of something I don't even have a use for to win. I love this channel!
I really like your videos for 1. The content; 2. You introduce your topic and quickly start the video without saying, "And without further ado; 3. You have no dead time in your videos. Every second is filled with pertinent content. Thank you for all the hard work you do to test so many things. I appreciate it.
Thanks and you are welcome!
More words/minute per episode than any other YT video. Not one wasted second.
Todd could very well be the most brilliant and efficient video presenter on YT.
Forgot the best part. No sponsors!
Editing these videos must be a nightmare, yet he knocks or out of the park every time!
Probably the most useful and underrated channel on UA-cam for everyone to digest data.. please do stain fighters next
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.
Not just stain removers, but since most laundry detergent brands have their own branded stain remover, do the stain remover with its corresponding detergent.
Thanks for the suggestion.
A stain remover test would be greatly interesting ! You are a much better service than Consumer Reports publication ! Thanks so much for everything !
You are welcome! Thanks for the suggestion.
What’s wrong with Consumer Reports? Just the lack of actually seeing their tests? Or are we referring more to their usually dismal consumables testing (except for sunscreen and bugspray, their testing for cleaning stuff is indeed terrible I will admit)?
I agree for the stain remover! You can’t tease us like that! Project Farm is the Gold Standard of UA-cam. Thank you for everything you do!
You are welcome! Thanks for the suggestion.
You know what I love about your videos every Sunday is the element of surprise because I have no idea what you're going to test next.
Thanks for sharing!
I love the direction this channel has gone and the fact that a video on laundry detergent could still get 1 million views! I use this channel now whenever I go to buy anything from the store!
Thanks!
This reminds me of how fabric softener is one of the most shockingly problematic products on the market, which is a product I'd love to see you test. They're pretty much 99% marketing, generally adding a waxy layer to your clothes to *feel soft* without actually softening the clothes themselves, and in the long run (or if you use too much of it in a wash) you can actually make it HARDER to clean your clothes because that waxy layer gets in the way.
Comparing fabric softeners to regular white vinegar (something that has shown to actually soften the fabric, rather than faking it, and no, there's no vinegar smell after washing) would be amazing to see, although I'm not entirely sure how you'd be able to test them.
The comparison would be very subjective, but we trust Todd, he’d do the best he could
Thanks for the suggestion.
Brighteners are another gimmick. I guess they leave a chemical residue to help reflect more light instead of cleaning
Only the Boomer Generation would come up with an idea so insane as "Poison ourselves and two generations of our children to make our laundry 'soft' and smelling like cheap, migraine-inducing artificial fragrances" 🤢.
Wait, isn't softness something you feel? How that the fabric softeners only make things feel soft without them being soft?
You took my suggestion seriously...bro thanks
Thank you for recommending this one!!
STAIN REMOVERS! YES YES YES PLEASE!
I am currently struggling to remove oil stains and arm pit stains from my work shirts and can't get them clean for nothing!
Thanks for the suggestion.
I second this!
oil stains require lots of heat. arm pit stains require good enzymes and moderate heat.
Before washing clothes with oil stains, smear each oil stain with a vegetable shortening (like Crisco). Rub it in thoroughly, then wash it out with Dawn dish soap. Rinse and repeat as needed.
Arm pit stains
Peroxide
Use some of your laundry detergent rubbed in with an old toothbrush
Cheapo meat tenderizer with no dyes
Give it 10 minutes or so to work before washing
When I worked as a tire factory maintenance tech, stains from oils, grease, carbon black and other yucky stuff, I learned to rub down the stains with Gojo hand cleaner before taking off my clothes, and when it came time to wash them (a day or ten later), most of the stains came right out.
Thanks for sharing.
From tool reviews now to laundry detergent. Your tests are always ahead of the game and I trust them before anyone else. Thanks for the honest unbiased and well researched reviews! The amount of effort you put in each video should be applauded!
I really do only buy the things he tests and have never been let down. All his oil tests are spot on. I trust this man
I know 3-4 people who agree with you, this guy knows how to compare, & he does the best he can to compare apples to apples.
I'm glad you do things like this. Many people may not own farms or fix vehicles, but everyone washes clothes.
Thanks for the feedback.
Project Farm is the GOAT among all review channels. Y'all set the bar. Thank you
Wow, thank you!
I had a friend, a LONG time ago, he had a
67 GTO, and also had the license plate that
was "GOAT!"
steve
Would love to see a stain remover comparison, as well as a follow-up that tests the Kirkland brand. Thanks so much for all your effort on this channel!
You are welcome! Thanks for the suggestion.
Newly married in the '70's, my husband worked at a Steel Mill. Known in area Laundromats as 'Mill Clothing', with designated machines. Thinking detergents were basically the same, I was driven by cost and coupons for purchase. After years of noticeable differences in cleaning results, I started documenting and rating brand effectiveness. *Tide* was always the best and the ONLY brand I buy for almost 50 years. I don't buy 'Pods' b/c the size of my loads varies. I also don't buy liquid, too bulky and too much plastic. The worst of the name brands was 'All' (consistently). Pre-treat a heavy stain with Wisk liquid : )
YOU'RE WELCOME!
Try Shout. Shout beat up Dutch bicycle tires stains from an Amsterdam gutter on my wife's scarf. Actually, Todd should test Shout against Wisk.
This! Also, I find the Tide powder better than Tide liquid. Wish that had been the tested version.
Tide powder vs liquid? Which?
We buy liquid tide and use 1oz per load regardless of its size and have for a very long time. We have not noticed any change. The savings is huge as a couple of bottles will last a person a year. The big bottles that have 150 to 170 oz in them will give you 3 loads a week for a single bottle a year.
Consider trying it for a while and quit over using the soap. You do know the same soap sold a decade ago had small amounts. They increased the size so that you waste more soap and spend more money.
My grandmother couldn't use Tide because she would have an allergic reaction to clothes washed with Tide.
My wife would really like a stain remover video! This one was great!!
For a stain remover test Dawn dish soap also against laundry stain removers.
Miss mouths stain remover is a real good one.
@@AlGoYoSu lets test that! lol
My wife wants a stain remover video as well. She would really like you to try Carbona, Fels Naphtha, Lestoil and Dawn dishwashing liquid.
My wife never uses cold water. She says it doesn’t really clean clothes.
Todd, you never cease to amaze me. You are THE authority on EVERYTHING. I don't know how I would get through daily life without Project Farm!
Thanks again for another informative REAL product evaluation.
Wow, thank you!
I recently learned to use pre treatment for otherwise stubborn stains. Pre soaking with alittle bit of soap in the water also makes a big difference.
The t-shirts with test zones is giving me 90s infomercial nostalgia vibes.... and I'm here for it
Thanks for watching!
what's the difference between "nostalgia" and "nostalgia vibes"?
@@joebenson528 One is an emotional response, the other more of an intellectual observation
That control with just water was savage 😂 🔥
The fact it wasn’t last in all categories says a lot about the detergents that sit below it
Been using Arm & Hammer for 10+ years. It's always cleaned well for me! This is just another example of higher cost doesnt always equal better..
Thanks for the feedback.
Agreed. I used to use Tide, but tried Arm & Hammer after balking at thr cost of Tide. Have not regretted it since. For heavy stains, a little pre treatment works wonders.
Same here. Been using Arm & Hammer for at least the last 20 years. However I don’t use the measuring cup. I use the TLAR method. My clothes get clean and I don’t stink so it’s a win. 😅
Hes not just using Arm & Hammer it was Arm & Hammer with Oxiclean, Tide and other brands also offer this type of detergent
I can't express how much of an influence you have on the products I purchase. You deserve all of your success for your hard work.
Thanks!
This is great, and a Free & Clear hypoallergenic competition would be incredible! sensitive skin is pretty darn common
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.
@@ProjectFarmplease do it
There's an Arm and Hammer no perfume laundry detergent! I love it and i don't react to it (i have eczema + contact dermatitis)
@@ProjectFarmplease include Kirkland brand if you do it :)
@@emmi5581 I have terrible skin as well and have been using Molly Suds because of the ingredient list but like the test shows, it may not clean the best. I tried A&M before but didn't have great results, may give it another shot.
Awesome video. I have another suggestion.
Soak the stained t-shirts for 1 or 2 days in a bucket or tray with its respective detergents so that the detergent can cut through the stains further and do another wash. I do this for heavily stained clothes and it works 99% of the time.
Women do that with lingerie. It also works to pour detergent straight on the stain and rub it in. Better if you catch the stain earlier, but it usually works even right before washing.
@@floycewhite6991 Im a guy and I do that too. I work in the field and stains can get into my uniform. Id rather soak my shirt than buy a new one, especially with this economy
@@floycewhite6991also rub the detergent in on the back side of the stain, Resolve works 👍🏼
You can tell he did so much research. I didn't even know there were so many TYPES of stains
Thanks!
Occasionally, I watch one of your videos and think "my wife would kill me if I did that at my house."
This is one of those videos 😆
That's why we're thankful that you do it for us. Great video!
I never realized how much this channel influences my everyday choices. And im proud of it. Ive always used Tide. And im glad i dot have to test other brands
Must try All. I've tried damn near all of them. I thought All does best but I'm also a fan of Tide
Quick note on the heavily perfumed Tyler wash from a guy who is very familiar with it: no one I know who uses it is actually using it for its power as a detergent. We use whatever unscented version of our preferred detergent and then add a capful of whichever Tyler scent we like. That stuff is strong. Depending on how much you use you can get a nice light scent or you can go full "Abercrombie&Fitch outlet store" on your clothes. And when you are only using it to add scent, one jug lasts plenty long to make the cost very minor. I think we had one jug last like a year and a half.
Love the videos. You are a Godsend to all us data driven retail consumers.
Thanks and you are welcome!
Abercrombie & Fitch 😂
I’m shocked at the arm and hammer. I always dismissed at cheap detergent but it costs 1/4 the price of tide and performed almost as good. I’m impressed.
Use twice the recommended amount of the Arm and Hammer and you still come out ahead.
Tide causes me to itch, and break out. Arm and hammer doesn't cause me any problems.
@@harpintn Tide also offers a Free & Clear version. Have you tried that?
@@Arnd2it try using 1oz (shot glass) worth of soap and you will find that it does the exact same thing.
Let this be a valuable lesson that the price of something doesn't mean anything. More often than not, you are paying for the name and their marketing budget. Those cheap store-brand items you see are almost always just rebranded name brand products. Don't be fooled.
Great video and comparison per usual. As someone with severely sensitive skin I would really like to see a follow up with free and clear/sensitive skin options. Both compared to each other and their standard formulas. At least with the Arm and Hammer (what I use) and the Tide options, since they were the top picks.
The hero we don’t deserve! Thank you Project Farm
Yes you finally took up my idea. Thank you
Joe Rogan, sorry it took so long! Great video idea!! So, thank you!
Ah so this was YOUR idea lol.
@ProjectFarm i dont care how long it took. I'm glad you did it, and your work is amazing. Thank you so much.
@@Random_4400 i have been commenting it on a few of his videos months ago.
@@ProjectFarm I thought you said it was my idea?
This is the most underrated channel on the internet!
I wouldn’t call having over 3m subscribers underrated.
Yea, wth you talking about. 3.5M subs is not underrated.
Have you not seen how many subs he has 😂
Thanks for confirming what 46 years of seeing my mom use has taught me - no matter how much we were cutting corners in our extremely busy house to save money growing up, mom always shopped sales and cut coupons to be able to buy liquid Tide because it’s cheaper than buying new clothes!! Sent this to my mom to tell her that yet another test proves she was right all these years for doing so…lol. 😂 Great content - this is what side by side comparison reviews should always be like for people to watch!! Nicely done!! 🙌🏼
I'm not entirely sure there is anything people wouldn't want to see tested in this format. Every single time it's informative and useful. I was looking for a new fan and the last video helped me pick one that is a good value (I went with the Hurricane). Thank you for all the hard work!
You are welcome!
Dude I just moved two days ago and got done fixing the sink. Made some food and on my way to my room I was thinking "I need to get some laundry detergent tomorrow" now I know the feeling I've seen from other comments, beautiful.
My grandmother used to pre soak my white shirts in kerosene and used a scub board, then wash them with powered All laundry soap and they looked like new. The start of my mechanic career.
Thanks for sharing.
That kerosene tip MUST be used during the stain remover sequel YOU HEAR ME BOSS MAN!
People used to wash and pretreat with kerosene all the time. They also used gasoline. Then again there were a lot more house fires back then. 😊
@@paulalarsen7697 Sure, but if you ran out of gas you could always stuff your shirt in the tank! 😂
the way you set up your test, even with the vacuum hand held device, is well done. TY. New subscriber.
Thanks! Thanks for watching and subscribing!
A Tide brand executive alum spoke to my college business class. He spoke of their successful proprietary enzymes & ingredients with such conviction, passion, and pride that I've never used another brand in 18 years. (Tide Cold Water when cold water technology was a new thing)
And Dawn liquid dishwashing soap.
@@artsmith103 dawn is amazing. Soooo many uses
After this video, I will definitely give A&H and Gain a try. Be brand agnostic because sometimes brands will dilute or tweak their formula (for the better or for the worse) to save money or due to ingredients no longer being available. It's always good to try something new once in a while, otherwise we'd still be using landlines or Motorola brick cell phones.
@SayAhh I personally love Persil. Cleans great and smells awesome. But for the wallets sake I use Sams brand pods
@@SayAhh We use tide and only use 1oz per load regardless of size. We have not noticed a single change in how clean things get. Its worth trying lower amounts of soap. If you do 3 loads a week one large bottle will last you a year.
This episode makes me hopeful that he's actually doing kitty litter. Us mechanics need it too for in the garage mishaps, but also something our mouse finders can enjoy using.
Thanks for sharing!
Interesting! No cats here, but I'm definitely interested in the off-label use testing
Ya, would be cool seeing various brands of it tested vs dedicated oil cleanup products, and some natural alternatives I've seen like crushed walnut shells.
Yes! This one soon please
That's a good idea.
When I was working as a diesel mechanic we used Tide to clean out the cooling system of oil when the oil cooler leaked oil into the cooling system. We tried many different detergents but only Tide would clean out the system good enough. It did take much time and water to clean but it was easer and much less expensive than removing the radiator and disassembling the engine. Tide is definitely my go to for cleaning clothes, engines and radiators. 🙂
Thanks for sharing.
Love the “in the field test” with you driving the tractor over the shirts…FANTASTIC VIDEO and information! This is REAL life!
If you’re thinking about testing something, trust me, we’re here for it and there’s never gonna be a video you put out that we don’t watch and want. Love the thumbnail!
This guys is the Swiss knife of testing, yesterday he was compairing Oil, today laundry detergent. What a genius.
Cheers from France
We women know that detergent by itself doesn't work on stains. Stains have to be pretreated with a stain fighter such as Shout or Felsnaptha. But, was an insightful comparison!
Thanks!
yes felsnaptha! i now use the white Goop hand cleaner as my stainfighter. even today I got out chicken wing buffalo sauce/grease off my white and turquoise hat with just rubbing it in with my fingers in the kitchen sink, drying now, no stain. kids shirts and spaghetti sauce disappears with it. Cherry bomb is red and still works the same with pumice stone in it. saves me $ by not throwing clothes to the goodwill
Idea for a video... everyone has had a septic tank issue. There are tons of "treatment" and monthly care products on the market for a septic tank, but no one can see if they really work because the ranks are underground. Now that would be an interesting topic.
I have been using Arm and Hammer for decades and after watching your video I will continue to do so. Thanks.
Something about it just seems right, right? I knew my laundry soap was good stuff!
My wife always goes for expensive ones. Anything on the subject I said to her was not going to convince her. Once I saw this video, the first thing I thought was asking her to come over and have a look. Very useful video for her to understand how to select detergent cost-effectively.
Do you think it did much good, don’t say anything if you know what’s good for you !!!
@dirtfarmer7472 . Lol
Love the video....Partial to Tide. However...When I was first married, I caught my mom using a bucket to clean some rags. She and my wife had been cleaning a house we had just purchased. She rinsed the rags with the sprayer from our garden hose. Filled the 5 gallon bucket half way, chucked in the dirty rags with healthy glug of Lestoil. Finished filling the bucket and stirred it with a stick every 15 mins for an hour. Dumped the water out, threw the rags in our washer with a tiny bit of Tide and they came out amazing. I use Lestoil on everything but axel grease.
Would love to see more videos on household products. Stain removers, cleaning products (especially tub and tile cleaners), dish washing soap, etc.