Snape never died. Think about it when Harry uses the stone he sees all his relatives, as well as Sirius and lupin and others important to him (beside dumbuldore) Snape isn’t there. Also in the books all the people that died are laid in the great hall but Snape isn’t there. Just a thought I had
She wasn’t a devoted follower. She was never a true Death Eater. I believe she always loved her family more than anything and if she found any chance to defy or delay Voldemort, she would have. I don’t have kids, but I cannot imagine having to watch my son try and kill his teacher. At this point, even Lucius defied Voldemort.
I think that initially she might have been a "go-along", because her husband was a follower and she wasn't in a position to defy him ... especially not since the person he was following was Voldemort. I don't have my books at hand at the moment, but I do seem to remember her saying some very cruel things about those who opposed Voldemort, including those who had lost family members to the Death Eaters. But (IF I am correct in that -- please correct me if I'm not) again, is it a question of her being a believer, or of her just trying to do the CYA thing, so as not to bring Voldemort's wrath down on her family? You're right that she never got the Dark Mark and so was never a full-fledged Death Eater.
@@YellowBear-kx1ff He wouldn't be an upstanding person, though. He was still birthed because of a love potion. Even if Merope lived, he was always the heir of Slytherin. His overwhelming thanatophobia might not have happened, but he may have become a Dark Wizard all the same.
Alex Downs No duh Sherlock ik her name I’m not dumb I just finished all the books main books and I am now reading fantastic beasts I know this story like the back of my hand my mom read it to me when I was little and I just started reading it again. So shut up
I’m not sure he will be better person (good wizard) but maybe he take a different paths we all know he has no love emotions we all know how and why so that won’t change even if his mom had raised him .
THAT MOMENT IS THE ONE I HATE THE MOST!!!!!!! Because I would have said something to Draco, whether I was standing right there beside him or far away where I have to yell! I would have said something. I am not in love with him but I do care about him.
We could also add that due to the weak state Voldemort was right after casting the avada kedavra on harry, he may have relied on the psychic bond between them, rather than using legilimency. Psychic connection that was no longer there due to him having just killed that part of him that lived inside harry. Therefore he may have thought Harry was dead. Also his Vanity would make him think that Narcissa would never dare lying to him, so what is the point on checking on her.
„It was because of your mother. She sacrificed herself for you and that kind of act leaves a mark. Oh, no. This kind of mark cannot be seen. It lives in your very skin.“ „What is it?“ „Love, Harry.. Love.“
It would be great if there was a segment about that one time when Harry successfully penetrated Severus’ mind during one of their lessons, experiencing some of his memories and how come that wasn’t the beginning of Harry becoming more accomplished in either legilimency or occlumency.
Yess,,,,.in the chamber of secrets when tom is talking in parsletounge he was looking at the basilisk sooo,,,I think je can and even,I think that salzar can,....
@@anuradhagangapure6903 Actually I believe that neither can, seeing as though that was only a fragment of Tom's 16 year old soul, and not his physical being. We have no real proof of either of our theories, so i thought i'd just share my opinion.
@@anuradhagangapure6903 It does open the possibility though that if speaking parseltongue makes you immune from dying when you look into the basilisk's eyes, then Harry went to quite a lot of extra effort in the chamber that he didn't need to do :D
She just saw Harry survive the killing curse a 2nd time so she probably thought things weren’t going to end up well for Voldemort and by allying herself with Harry at the last minute she could avoid a life at Azkaban.
I sort of have a soft spot spot for narcissa , she is a family person and genually caring person although she was on the wrong side of the war if the war never happened Lucius and narcissa would be amazing parents
Voldemort still makes the mistake of attacking Harry with the Elder Wand but there is a snag. When it backfires on Voldemort it doesn't finish him off because Nagini is still alive. What happens next would greatly depend on how the Death Eaters react to this
The death eaters would think Voldemort is cursed To lose and abandon him not a good sign when the boy who lives moment happens twice such a important moment in the book but honestly didn’t change the outcome one way or the other
@@animejerk05 Maybe. The biggest problem for Harry is that Bellatrix is still there and she's a bit unstable and far more powerful than he is unless he had the sense to accio the Elder wand from what's left of Voldemort and fight her with it which I'm not sure he would. Harry would likely be pretty screwed if she went after him, especially if she got any help. Even if they decide to kill off Harry which is quite possible but no guarantee for sure , there's still a chance Nagini would get hunted down because of Ron, Hermione, and Neville. Though Nagini might prove elusive considering Dumbledore wasn't able to track her down during Voldemort's first long absence. It's kind of a murky scenario
Yes, I think so because Narcissa would at least lave a chance to escape with her husband, she knew the good guys had a huge chance to prevail and win.And I also think narcissa would want to be free, don’t forget, she also kind!
2:02 yes but why use the skill on someone you aren’t expecting to betray you? But that was always Voldemort problem underestimating people and not figuring emotions into his plans, both times he was defeated was because of a mothers love for her child, once for Harry and once for Draco.
@deepa joshi well your right They are lifeless Well I was like 7 I thought they were like having no face So they would steal peoples face to have a beautiful face
The answer is "nothing." Dementors are amortal, meaning they can't die because they aren't alive in the first place. Although the spell might make them catch fire because that's what happens when the killing curse hits an inanimate object as we learned in OOTP. Now dementors aren't exactly inanimate.... But they're kinda in that region, lol.
@@EM18DAGOAT Yep. It's in the duel between Dumby and Voldy. Voldy misses Dumby and the spells hits a desk or something behind him and bursts into flames.
I think it's a lot more complex than that. Besides, there wouldn't be any point in just lying when you could achieve the same thing with the truth without risking your life. If she was telling the truth, he would have tried to kill Harry until he succeeded, and she would have gotten to her son, without risking her or her husband's life. Narcissa seems a lot smarter to me. She sees beyond the battle. Her family has fallen from grace. If Voldemort wins, he will always be a threat to her family. If she saves Harry Potter's life and Harry wins the battle, her family's future will be a lot brighter. She wants to know if Draco is alive because she wants to know if it's worth the risk. If Draco were already dead, there wasn't much left for her to risk. But he's alive and save, so she's lying hoping to save her family in the long run. She will certainly have taken into account that Harry is then in her debt. It's about a lot more than just getting into the castle, she really didn't have to lie for that. But with Harry alive after such a killing curse, there is long-term hope. So she saves him. And Voldemort is just a narcissist who probably wouldn't even think that a simple trophy-wife would dare lie to him.
To be fair, Voldemort did try and confirm harry's death. He used the cruciatus curse on Harry and nothing happened. He automatically assumed that Harry was dead. Voldemort didn't consider the possibility of the elder wand belonging to Harry. Firstly Voldemort was surprised that he was knocked out or he also went to some limbo like state after performing the Killing curse. Secondly he was afraid that he had again failed to kill Harry, hence he did not check himself whether harry was dead or not. And lastly he felt relief once Narcissa declared that Harry was dead and he did not even think about using Legilimency thinking that Narcissa would lie about such thing.
I wanted to know that in Harry Potter 4 the Goblet of Fire , Harry Potter saw that Lucius Malfoy was a death eater but he didn't to tell this to Dumbledore , Why?
Harry tells Dumbledore most of the things and maybe some of the things he didn't tell Dumbledore suspected it. Point is Dumbledore knew everything or as he would say guessed right..its just that Ministry of Magic didn't provide them any support
She lied to save her son. Because she knew Draco had failed. And him still being alive meant Voldemort would kill him. So she switched sides to give her family a window to escape during the chaos. It was purely about family/self-preservation. Not because she wanted Harry to win, she just knew Voldemort wanted her son, and likely husband, dead. Which would likely extend to her as well.
No, the death spell didn't work the first time because Voldemort destroyed horcrux made by himself. Even the second time, he wouldn't have been able to kill Harry because the wand belonged to Harry and there is no way the wand would have hurt it's own master
But Narcissa doesn't know these things. If it's only about going to the castle for her, she could have just told the truth, without risking her Life. And even if Voldemort couldn't kill Harry with a wand, he could do it with knife or whatever... Risking her life like that, while knowing that the truth would have the same Outcome, means that its more for her. Now she knows that her son is alive and she wants a future for her family without constant threads. Her Family had fallen from grace, so I could Imagine that she saw a better future for her family without Voldemort.
It would be very interesting to know how the Death Eaters that broke out of Azkaban were able to get their wands back. I thought the ministry snapped them upon sentencing.
After Voldemort and the deatheaters' extended stay at Malfoy Manor, I'd imagine Narcissa had quite enough of them messing up her cherised home and furniture.
She cared more about Draco than serving Voldemort. Narcissa Malfoy was worried about Draco so she didn't care about Voldemort. She was grateful that Draco is alive.
I dunno but maybe after watching your sister, son, husband get tortured every time they see Harry might have something do with it. Maybe Bella and narcissa had a couple of fights about what was good, and uh, snape visit
The Dark Lord is giving Draco the most awkward hug, his wand is positioned at Draco’s neck so it looks like he is trying to curse h8n or something, has Voldemort ever hugged someone again-?
I also think Narcissa was an Occlumens as well. The other thing is when Voldemort killed Harry, he too was injured in the action and may not have been fully recovered. Otherwise he wouldn’t have needed for anyone to see if Harry was still alive.
Theory.. what if Voldemort returned in Chamber of secrets itself as his 16 year old self?? he wouldn't remember what happened in his life after he made it a horcrux would he?? just like a save game book in earlier HP video games... even if he returned as Tom Riddle he wouldn't be half as dangerous as Voldemort someone please enlighten me
I'm not sure Narcissa was a devoted servant to the dark lord. I believe she agreed with his purification, pureblood status cause. She was not a Death Eater. After Voldy shot his killing curse @ HP he fainted/blacked out. I think that he underestimated Narsissa (assumed she would tell him the truth) and had not fully redeemed of his strength.
The first assumption is so wrong.If she wanted to she could just tell him that he is not dead and then Voldemort would just try again to kill him and they would eventually go to the castle anyway...The second part is true she just lost her faith to Voldemort after all the things her family went through because of him
Him failing to kill Harry yet again dissolved what little faith she had. I feel this is a backhanded deal with Harry- I'll let you live if you help my family. I wonder if she knows that Draco lied when Harry was their prisoner and is trying to follow that example.
I would really like to know why voldemort didn't kill Hagrid in the forbidden Forrest but had him tied up . And as morbid as it is why he didn't have nagini eat Harry after he thought he was dead . Just for good measure
That still makes zero sense, cuz if she said he's alive, she wouldn't have to risk anything, Voldemort would just kill him on the spot and then they'd walk to the castle like they did thinking he's dead.
Tomas Kotrejch I think so too. I think she lied because she wanted to safe Draco and she was knowing that only Harry could defeat Voldemort, so she get her family back together.
Voldemort had sent her son on a suicide mission to kill Dumbledore. He would repeatedly insult her husband because of his incompetent leadership at battle of department of mysteries and even took away his wand. Her house was being used against her will a d she had no authority even in her own home. So she was fed up with voldemort already.
I don't agree that Voldemort was beaten by "motherly" love and just that. I think people around him when they got to know him and his madness realized that he is not just your average "dark" wizard, he is an unpredictable maniac. There is a difference to be dark and powerful and another thing to be a gory sadistic psychopath that's willing to sacrifice any person for his ultimate gain. He didn't kill people who weren't loyal to him, he was killing loyal people too like Snape. The guy didn't had a shred of any honor inside his brain, he was all over the place. Of course some of his followers will turn on him. Harry potter didn't fought against someone dark, he fought against one of the worst clinical cases of psychopathy we have ever seen on TV.
because basically Dumbledores only request (besides strictly following his orders while horcrux hunting) was for Harry not to tell a soul besides Ron and Hermoney, and Harry being “Dumbledores man through and through” took the request very seriously
I think she lied cause after realizing that Voldemort didn’t kill Harry, she had the hope there was still a chance to stop Voldemort. Plus, like the video argues, she wanted to protect her son. Also think that if for any reason her or her son where to be in danger with Voldemort, Harry and his entire friends would protect them, specially Harry. Despite Harry and Draco having their differences, Harry would still save Draco and also knew Draco was being forced to do something he didn’t want to be part of.
Hoping you will return to your Mirror of Erised videos soon. If you would like a character suggestion, perhaps someone who couldn’t come across the mirror, like the Dursley’s; or a darker character like Belatrix.
The main reason why is because narcissa cared about her son so much that she wouldve done anything to make sure he is okay, including lying to voldermort, she was never a true death eater, she was just with lucius at the meetung things, shes also an amazing occulenes, like serverus snape. Sorry if i didnt make any sense!
Q: Why did Narcissa lie to Voldemort about Harry’s death? A: She was in Harry’s debt for saving Draco’s life from the Fiendfyre in the Room of Requirement.
I believe that had Voldemort’s mother lived, as heartbroken as she was would have loved her son Tom Jr (Voldemort) and he would have turned out different.
It was obvious why she lied, she just witnessed Voldemort hit him with the killing curse and he was still alive. She knew it was over for Voldemort and had no reason to stay loyal. She knew that if she helped Harry, she would be able to see her son again
I know not many fans really like "The Cursed Child" but I'm more curious as to how Delphini could have been conceived. Of course Voldemort couldn't feel love due to he himself being conceived under a love potion... But how would Bellatrix have managed to have a child with him? Would she have used a potion too? I'm really curious about this...
Can u do how purebloods and halfbloods and mud bloods are classified. As both harries parents a wizards but mud bloods. Does this make Harry pure blood because his parents are wizards or mudblood?
Draco was always a kid in the series. He most likely grew up to be a good-hearted person. Both through his mother’s love, and that his father was sent to Azkaban for life. He basically had to fend for himself and he had to write his own future. After a great wizarding war, I doubt he’d go to the dark side. He was forced to take the route of good and put his talents to great use for once.
Just thought of this while reading another comment, but why didn't the Elder Wand backfire unto Voldemort when he tried to kill Harry in the forest? How did the curse get to him?
It did backfire yet at the same time it didnt. pls watch the scene carefully. Voldemort fell on his bck n got unconscious. His body finally got weak with only one horcrux nagini left at that point. Plus due to the ancient charm of love n sacrifice, the piece of Riddle's soul in harry's body got destroyed by the elder wand thereby keeping the physical body intact. We saw that flesh of Voldemort in Harry's afterlife where he went to the place of In Between n met albus dumbledore. That's why he was suspicious after gaining consciousness if Harry was really dead. There are 2 factors here which kept Harry safe here. First Lily's love protection in his blood n the allegiance of Elder Wand to Harry which clearly voldemort was unaware about.also you r forgetting one major thing here. Harry went to the forbidden forest on his own account of sacrificing himself for others. To keep others safe from harm while he dies. His desire of protection kept him safe again. He cant die basically cos Tom Riddle foolishly bounded Harry to himself to Lily's protection with Harry's blood while resurrecting himself.
I think the reason for Narcissa lying to Voldemort is simply plot convenience. JKR tried hard to explain it, but I don't find the explanation convincing.
Because Malfoy family actually hated Voldermot. They only yield to him in fear not for respect and was not interested to make him dictator ruler of wizarding world. Even Draco had the same thought so he lied duing identification of harry in Malloy Manor
I hate the plot point of voldermort not being able to feel love doesn't that essentially mean he was less that human from conception, with no option to change? It makes it sound as if it was just his nature to do what he did how could anyone say that was wrong?
Your reasoning makes little sense to me honestly. If Narcissa would have said that Potter lived, they could have killed him again and would have gone to the castle anyway.
Just thought in philosophers stone harry got the stone when he looked in the mirror and "wanted to get it but not use it" so it appeared in his pocket but that raises the question where was the stone? Because it couldn't have been in the mirror (quirrill actually suggested that but voldemort at once says "use the boy" no doubt realising that motives matter) where was it really?
Before watching this video: I think she lied because she’s a mother and no mother wants their son dead and I know that she isn’t Harry’s mom but she is one
bang on on the why but here is the how. She only told Voldemort what he already believed strongly to be true. He felt the connection to Harry break and thought it was because Harry died because he didn't know Harry was one of his horcruxes and the severed connection was caused by the death of that Horcrux.
my question: why do students get afraid of the sorting hat when they clearly get placed into the same houses as their siblings. i know its the first day of hogwarts but they must have a firm idea of where they are going. also has there been a witch or wizard which has been placed incorrectly excluding harry
Same person like me who has been a long time follower who knows this is no more than a reload of old content. With the new beast movies there’s so much to explore nobody is trying to explore it like the black market magical world or the circus and so much more. As a loyal follower I have even suggested videos for a magical unemployment office and exploring the many jobs that a witch or wizard could get despite their magical skill.
I don't agree with the first part of your analysis, Voldemort would go to Hogwarts whether she told the truth or not. From her perspective, had she said the truth, Voldermort would simply rekill Harry, for real this time, and go to the castle anyway. So lying entails an unnecessary risk on her part. I believe the latter part of your analysis is what happened here: she realized good can prevail, and was also grateful to Harry who told her that Draco is safe, and perhaps even realized that Harry had something to do with it.
I think the book explanation really doesn't make sense. Like if she said he was still alive Voldemort could have just killed Harry for real and then they could have still went victorious and got Draco. If Harry had been defeated, Voldemort would have been so pissed at her that she lied about Harry being dead, definitely kill her and probably her family too. Maybe Harry misunderstood and she did this because she thought that keeping Harry alive was the only way to defeat Voldemort and then she could run off with her son, but if her son was dead she didn't even care about hopes of running off or like even living...
Get over it. The books are filled with plot holes. (not to mention the sexist approach. even the lord of the rings trilogy was better at representing a powerful female character with only one at hand than the harry potter series wich was filled with females all of whom were weak.)
Thanks for watching guys! As always, leave your video suggestions down below
Idk if u already did this vid but maybe litas sacrifice in fb crimes of grindelwald cast a protection on newt/thesieus scammander
I have an idea for your next vid.
How did the horcrux in harry survive when harry got the basilisk tooth in his arm
Dante Carette yasssss
@jack rogers yea but if he had to die for the horcrux to die as well why didnt he die in the last movie
Snape never died. Think about it when Harry uses the stone he sees all his relatives, as well as Sirius and lupin and others important to him (beside dumbuldore) Snape isn’t there. Also in the books all the people that died are laid in the great hall but Snape isn’t there. Just a thought I had
Mother's love defeated Voldemort twice.
❤
3
3? If you are talking about molly weasley well she deafeted Bella trip and not Voldemort
Amikko Gacha She kept Harry safe. Gave him a family a home. 😊
Another maternal love defeated his last best lieutenant.
Even if she was a Pure-Blood Elitist, she was still a loving mother
Every character in the Harry Potter series has their own interesting story
Actually enough lure to make a whole novel on 95% character
Really shows how deep and impressive jk Rowling even the fantastic beasts series are really good too
Even Wilkie Twycross.
@Retarded cat she has backstory too. Why you think she doesn't have it
AT9777 ya missed the joke
She wasn’t a devoted follower. She was never a true Death Eater. I believe she always loved her family more than anything and if she found any chance to defy or delay Voldemort, she would have. I don’t have kids, but I cannot imagine having to watch my son try and kill his teacher. At this point, even Lucius defied Voldemort.
Yes and also she never actually got the dark mark
I think that initially she might have been a "go-along", because her husband was a follower and she wasn't in a position to defy him ... especially not since the person he was following was Voldemort. I don't have my books at hand at the moment, but I do seem to remember her saying some very cruel things about those who opposed Voldemort, including those who had lost family members to the Death Eaters. But (IF I am correct in that -- please correct me if I'm not) again, is it a question of her being a believer, or of her just trying to do the CYA thing, so as not to bring Voldemort's wrath down on her family?
You're right that she never got the Dark Mark and so was never a full-fledged Death Eater.
and she knew draco just a pawn for voldie, after he killed Dumbledore ofc draco will be killed
The mothers are always badass in the movies!
In real life to
mhm!!
Except Neville's mother who lost her mind from Bellatrix, Crouch Jr. and friends. She can no longer even wipe her own longbottom anymore.
Especially Molly Weasley. She's my favourite
@@SquirrelASMR stop😭
And this is why I love Narcissa so much! Super underrated character, she's my favourite!
I like narcissa to she's a nice women she never done everything wrong according to me ❤
Theory: what if Voldemort’s mom didn’t die, would that change the story it self
McKappy First of all, her name is Merope Gaunt. Second of all, if she had lived to raise Voldemort, he would be a better person.
@@YellowBear-kx1ff He wouldn't be an upstanding person, though. He was still birthed because of a love potion. Even if Merope lived, he was always the heir of Slytherin. His overwhelming thanatophobia might not have happened, but he may have become a Dark Wizard all the same.
Alex Downs No duh Sherlock ik her name I’m not dumb I just finished all the books main books and I am now reading fantastic beasts I know this story like the back of my hand my mom read it to me when I was little and I just started reading it again. So shut up
I’m not sure he will be better person (good wizard) but maybe he take a different paths we all know he has no love emotions we all know how and why so that won’t change even if his mom had raised him .
Just a total different timeline so much
The pause when Draco waited to answer his mothers call and go to the dark side he waited for someone to stop him but one did 😖
THAT MOMENT IS THE ONE I HATE THE MOST!!!!!!! Because I would have said something to Draco, whether I was standing right there beside him or far away where I have to yell! I would have said something.
I am not in love with him but I do care about him.
Rest in peace Helen McCrory
We could also add that due to the weak state Voldemort was right after casting the avada kedavra on harry, he may have relied on the psychic bond between them, rather than using legilimency. Psychic connection that was no longer there due to him having just killed that part of him that lived inside harry. Therefore he may have thought Harry was dead. Also his Vanity would make him think that Narcissa would never dare lying to him, so what is the point on checking on her.
Wouldn’t Narcissa’s love for Draco shield her from Voldemort’s legilimency?
„It was because of your mother. She sacrificed herself for you and that kind of act leaves a mark.
Oh, no. This kind of mark cannot be seen. It lives in your very skin.“
„What is it?“
„Love, Harry.. Love.“
I would watch a 7 movie series just about the malfoy family
One of the best of 3 HP channels, keep it going & let’s get this channel growing 🤙🏻🤙🏻
Declan George who r the best
FreshLynx No particular order; HP FOLKLORE, MOVIEFLAME & HP THEORY
It would be great if there was a segment about that one time when Harry successfully penetrated Severus’ mind during one of their lessons, experiencing some of his memories and how come that wasn’t the beginning of Harry becoming more accomplished in either legilimency or occlumency.
Just curious, could Voldemort and Salazar slytherin look into the basilisks eyes without being killed?
Hmmmmmm that’s a good question.
Yess,,,,.in the chamber of secrets when tom is talking in parsletounge he was looking at the basilisk sooo,,,I think je can and even,I think that salzar can,....
@@anuradhagangapure6903 Actually I believe that neither can, seeing as though that was only a fragment of Tom's 16 year old soul, and not his physical being. We have no real proof of either of our theories, so i thought i'd just share my opinion.
@@anuradhagangapure6903 that wasnt actually tom, that was a horcrux so i dont think he can
@@anuradhagangapure6903 It does open the possibility though that if speaking parseltongue makes you immune from dying when you look into the basilisk's eyes, then Harry went to quite a lot of extra effort in the chamber that he didn't need to do :D
Love..
Because when love takes over
Everything rise
Lmao shut up
@@ethanklimenko5065 bruh
@@ethanklimenko5065 bruh
Ethan Klimenko bruh
@@ethanklimenko5065 bruh
She just saw Harry survive the killing curse a 2nd time so she probably thought things weren’t going to end up well for Voldemort and by allying herself with Harry at the last minute she could avoid a life at Azkaban.
Narcissa : Is he alive, Draco is he alive?
Harry: Yea and I tried to kill him once using sectum sempra but snape saved him.
Narcissa: Avada Kedavra
I sort of have a soft spot spot for narcissa , she is a family person and genually caring person although she was on the wrong side of the war if the war never happened Lucius and narcissa would be amazing parents
Can you do what if she told the truth about harry
Voldemort still makes the mistake of attacking Harry with the Elder Wand but there is a snag. When it backfires on Voldemort it doesn't finish him off because Nagini is still alive. What happens next would greatly depend on how the Death Eaters react to this
The death eaters would think Voldemort is cursed To lose and abandon him not a good sign when the boy who lives moment happens twice such a important moment in the book but honestly didn’t change the outcome one way or the other
@@animejerk05 Maybe. The biggest problem for Harry is that Bellatrix is still there and she's a bit unstable and far more powerful than he is unless he had the sense to accio the Elder wand from what's left of Voldemort and fight her with it which I'm not sure he would. Harry would likely be pretty screwed if she went after him, especially if she got any help. Even if they decide to kill off Harry which is quite possible but no guarantee for sure , there's still a chance Nagini would get hunted down because of Ron, Hermione, and Neville. Though Nagini might prove elusive considering Dumbledore wasn't able to track her down during Voldemort's first long absence. It's kind of a murky scenario
@@gugurupurasudaikirai7620 bellatrix was killed by Molly Weasly...
@@aaravsood100 Bellatrix was still alive at that point - her death happened at hogwarts
this has become one of my favourite channels! Loving all the content!
If Harry told narcissa draco wasn't alive would narcissa still have lied to voldemort?
cotton candy I think no
Yes, I think so because Narcissa would at least lave a chance to escape with her husband, she knew the good guys had a huge chance to prevail and win.And I also think narcissa would want to be free, don’t forget, she also kind!
If draco did die narcissa would have given Harry what draco didn’t have, freedom.......
Narcissa was never a bad woman and she felt genuinely sorry for harry. She would have still lied.
2:02 yes but why use the skill on someone you aren’t expecting to betray you? But that was always Voldemort problem underestimating people and not figuring emotions into his plans, both times he was defeated was because of a mothers love for her child, once for Harry and once for Draco.
I have suggestion
What happens when you use “Avada Kedavra” on a Dementor?
It may be worked !
@deepa joshi well your right
They are lifeless
Well I was like 7 I thought they were like having no face
So they would steal peoples face to have a beautiful face
The answer is "nothing." Dementors are amortal, meaning they can't die because they aren't alive in the first place.
Although the spell might make them catch fire because that's what happens when the killing curse hits an inanimate object as we learned in OOTP. Now dementors aren't exactly inanimate.... But they're kinda in that region, lol.
Abhishek Lama ok, btw just checking, OOTP mean Order Of The Phoenix right?
@@EM18DAGOAT Yep. It's in the duel between Dumby and Voldy. Voldy misses Dumby and the spells hits a desk or something behind him and bursts into flames.
You are an actual wizard. I saw Deathly Hallows II today and was thinking about this subject.
I think it's a lot more complex than that. Besides, there wouldn't be any point in just lying when you could achieve the same thing with the truth without risking your life. If she was telling the truth, he would have tried to kill Harry until he succeeded, and she would have gotten to her son, without risking her or her husband's life.
Narcissa seems a lot smarter to me. She sees beyond the battle. Her family has fallen from grace. If Voldemort wins, he will always be a threat to her family. If she saves Harry Potter's life and Harry wins the battle, her family's future will be a lot brighter. She wants to know if Draco is alive because she wants to know if it's worth the risk. If Draco were already dead, there wasn't much left for her to risk. But he's alive and save, so she's lying hoping to save her family in the long run. She will certainly have taken into account that Harry is then in her debt.
It's about a lot more than just getting into the castle, she really didn't have to lie for that. But with Harry alive after such a killing curse, there is long-term hope. So she saves him. And Voldemort is just a narcissist who probably wouldn't even think that a simple trophy-wife would dare lie to him.
To be fair, Voldemort did try and confirm harry's death. He used the cruciatus curse on Harry and nothing happened. He automatically assumed that Harry was dead. Voldemort didn't consider the possibility of the elder wand belonging to Harry.
Firstly Voldemort was surprised that he was knocked out or he also went to some limbo like state after performing the Killing curse.
Secondly he was afraid that he had again failed to kill Harry, hence he did not check himself whether harry was dead or not.
And lastly he felt relief once Narcissa declared that Harry was dead and he did not even think about using Legilimency thinking that Narcissa would lie about such thing.
I wanted to know that in Harry Potter 4 the Goblet of Fire , Harry Potter saw that Lucius Malfoy was a death eater but he didn't to tell this to Dumbledore , Why?
He told in the book
Harry tells Dumbledore most of the things and maybe some of the things he didn't tell Dumbledore suspected it. Point is Dumbledore knew everything or as he would say guessed right..its just that Ministry of Magic didn't provide them any support
The books where better then the movies
He told in the the book
You can't always rely on the movie to make sure every dialogue has been told
The movie would just be too long
me too, i was thinking abt that.
Video idea: What if the basilisk had killed Ginny in the chamber?
VDLS yeah
Tyleah Morales Harry HATED draco he wouldn’t have married him lmao
White Diamond ツ
*the fanfic writers say otherwise*
The Saddo System fanfic - not canon xd
Harry would have been forever alone
She lied to save her son. Because she knew Draco had failed. And him still being alive meant Voldemort would kill him. So she switched sides to give her family a window to escape during the chaos. It was purely about family/self-preservation. Not because she wanted Harry to win, she just knew Voldemort wanted her son, and likely husband, dead. Which would likely extend to her as well.
Yeah she lied, not because she cared about harry, but because she wanted her family including her son draco alive.
If she hadn't lied, wouldn't Voldemort just use avada kedavra again then go into the castle to show off? She would still see Draco then
No, the death spell didn't work the first time because Voldemort destroyed horcrux made by himself. Even the second time, he wouldn't have been able to kill Harry because the wand belonged to Harry and there is no way the wand would have hurt it's own master
But Narcissa doesn't know these things. If it's only about going to the castle for her, she could have just told the truth, without risking her Life.
And even if Voldemort couldn't kill Harry with a wand, he could do it with knife or whatever...
Risking her life like that, while knowing that the truth would have the same Outcome, means that its more for her. Now she knows that her son is alive and she wants a future for her family without constant threads. Her Family had fallen from grace, so I could Imagine that she saw a better future for her family without Voldemort.
Rest in peace Helen McRory you will be missed what a great actress she was
It would be very interesting to know how the Death Eaters that broke out of Azkaban were able to get their wands back. I thought the ministry snapped them upon sentencing.
Omg ya
They got out because Voldemort can control dementors
they might have stole from someone. Or Ollivander ,after he was kidnapped,might have been forced to make wand for the death eaters
Lucius had his old wand, and I think Bellatrix had hers too
Harry was saved by a mother's love more than once..he was never alone
Totally satisfying theory with all the details. Thank You!
After Voldemort and the deatheaters' extended stay at Malfoy Manor, I'd imagine Narcissa had quite enough of them messing up her cherised home and furniture.
i love this channel SO much!!!!
I think it's more because she told Voldemort what he already wanted to believe... so he didn't question her assessment.
again another welcome to another installment of harry potter
She cared more about Draco than serving Voldemort. Narcissa Malfoy was worried about Draco so she didn't care about Voldemort. She was grateful that Draco is alive.
Amazing Video, As usual!
I dunno but maybe after watching your sister, son, husband get tortured every time they see Harry might have something do with it.
Maybe Bella and narcissa had a couple of fights about what was good, and uh, snape visit
LOVE YOUR VIDEOS!!!!!
The Dark Lord is giving Draco the most awkward hug, his wand is positioned at Draco’s neck so it looks like he is trying to curse h8n or something, has Voldemort ever hugged someone again-?
I also think Narcissa was an Occlumens as well. The other thing is when Voldemort killed Harry, he too was injured in the action and may not have been fully recovered. Otherwise he wouldn’t have needed for anyone to see if Harry was still alive.
Theory.. what if Voldemort returned in Chamber of secrets itself as his 16 year old self??
he wouldn't remember what happened in his life after he made it a horcrux would he?? just like a save game book in earlier HP video games...
even if he returned as Tom Riddle he wouldn't be half as dangerous as Voldemort
someone please enlighten me
Great vid 👍
I'm not sure Narcissa was a devoted servant to the dark lord. I believe she agreed with his purification, pureblood status cause. She was not a Death Eater. After Voldy shot his killing curse @ HP he fainted/blacked out. I think that he underestimated Narsissa (assumed she would tell him the truth) and had not fully redeemed of his strength.
I think she was influenced by her sister and husband and jut went along with them. She's a trophy wife pacifist.
The first assumption is so wrong.If she wanted to she could just tell him that he is not dead and then Voldemort would just try again to kill him and they would eventually go to the castle anyway...The second part is true she just lost her faith to Voldemort after all the things her family went through because of him
Him failing to kill Harry yet again dissolved what little faith she had. I feel this is a backhanded deal with Harry- I'll let you live if you help my family. I wonder if she knows that Draco lied when Harry was their prisoner and is trying to follow that example.
I would really like to know why voldemort didn't kill Hagrid in the forbidden Forrest but had him tied up . And as morbid as it is why he didn't have nagini eat Harry after he thought he was dead . Just for good measure
Great video once again
That still makes zero sense, cuz if she said he's alive, she wouldn't have to risk anything, Voldemort would just kill him on the spot and then they'd walk to the castle like they did thinking he's dead.
Tomas Kotrejch I think so too. I think she lied because she wanted to safe Draco and she was knowing that only Harry could defeat Voldemort, so she get her family back together.
Voldemort had sent her son on a suicide mission to kill Dumbledore. He would repeatedly insult her husband because of his incompetent leadership at battle of department of mysteries and even took away his wand. Her house was being used against her will a d she had no authority even in her own home. So she was fed up with voldemort already.
Yeah but Voldemort wont be able to still kill harry cos of two things. The elder wand n Lily's love in Harry's blood.
@@AtulSingh-uu9vt Yup, that sums it up.
I don't agree that Voldemort was beaten by "motherly" love and just that. I think people around him when they got to know him and his madness realized that he is not just your average "dark" wizard, he is an unpredictable maniac. There is a difference to be dark and powerful and another thing to be a gory sadistic psychopath that's willing to sacrifice any person for his ultimate gain. He didn't kill people who weren't loyal to him, he was killing loyal people too like Snape. The guy didn't had a shred of any honor inside his brain, he was all over the place. Of course some of his followers will turn on him. Harry potter didn't fought against someone dark, he fought against one of the worst clinical cases of psychopathy we have ever seen on TV.
Video Suggestion: why didn’t Harry tell anyone in the order what he was doing when hunting for horcruxes.
Because he knew they wouldn't let him go
because basically Dumbledores only request (besides strictly following his orders while horcrux hunting) was for Harry not to tell a soul besides Ron and Hermoney, and Harry being “Dumbledores man through and through” took the request very seriously
If many people would have known voldemort would have found out
Because Dumbledore had told him not to.
If your reading this, harry potter theory, I really like your videos and they help me understand the harry potter books better.
I think she lied cause after realizing that Voldemort didn’t kill Harry, she had the hope there was still a chance to stop Voldemort. Plus, like the video argues, she wanted to protect her son. Also think that if for any reason her or her son where to be in danger with Voldemort, Harry and his entire friends would protect them, specially Harry. Despite Harry and Draco having their differences, Harry would still save Draco and also knew Draco was being forced to do something he didn’t want to be part of.
Hoping you will return to your Mirror of Erised videos soon. If you would like a character suggestion, perhaps someone who couldn’t come across the mirror, like the Dursley’s; or a darker character like Belatrix.
Bellatrix could be a fun one to do, I will make that one next!
@@HarryPotterTheory Thank you! I feel very honoured and privileged to contribute to your work in this way.
The main reason why is because narcissa cared about her son so much that she wouldve done anything to make sure he is okay, including lying to voldermort, she was never a true death eater, she was just with lucius at the meetung things, shes also an amazing occulenes, like serverus snape. Sorry if i didnt make any sense!
Great video
Q: Why did Narcissa lie to Voldemort about Harry’s death?
A: She was in Harry’s debt for saving Draco’s life from the Fiendfyre in the Room of Requirement.
How would she have known about that, though? And even if she had known, why would she have needed to ask HARRY if Draco was still alive in that case?
Theory: What if Voldemort wasn't concieved with a love potion
I believe that had Voldemort’s mother lived, as heartbroken as she was would have loved her son Tom Jr (Voldemort) and he would have turned out different.
When harry got up why didn’t Voldemort kill narcisa
Bc she and lucious and draco ran away as soon as Harry woke up and fought Voldemort
Harry was the bigger threat.
He would have done it later.
Draco would have been tortured.
It was obvious why she lied, she just witnessed Voldemort hit him with the killing curse and he was still alive. She knew it was over for Voldemort and had no reason to stay loyal. She knew that if she helped Harry, she would be able to see her son again
I know not many fans really like "The Cursed Child" but I'm more curious as to how Delphini could have been conceived. Of course Voldemort couldn't feel love due to he himself being conceived under a love potion... But how would Bellatrix have managed to have a child with him? Would she have used a potion too? I'm really curious about this...
People don't need to be in love to have sex and have a child.His lack of emotions wouldn't affect the way he functions physically.
Bellatrix is a Vergin Mother.
Viagramusilus spell
Accio cum
Well you know.... they fucked
I wonder if the Malfoy 's actually wanted Harry to live?
I'm wondering this too
amazing video btw
Great Job i Love your films
Probally because she was done being loyal to him too
Can u do how purebloods and halfbloods and mud bloods are classified. As both harries parents a wizards but mud bloods. Does this make Harry pure blood because his parents are wizards or mudblood?
Why the snow effect?
Is it the power of love that made Narcissa able to lie to Voldemort (a powerful legilimens) without him reading her thoughts?
She Loves 💚 her son above everything else
Draco was always a kid in the series. He most likely grew up to be a good-hearted person. Both through his mother’s love, and that his father was sent to Azkaban for life. He basically had to fend for himself and he had to write his own future. After a great wizarding war, I doubt he’d go to the dark side. He was forced to take the route of good and put his talents to great use for once.
Did Dumble notice Crouch jr. when Crouch taught at Hogwarts
Just thought of this while reading another comment, but why didn't the Elder Wand backfire unto Voldemort when he tried to kill Harry in the forest? How did the curse get to him?
It did backfire yet at the same time it didnt. pls watch the scene carefully. Voldemort fell on his bck n got unconscious. His body finally got weak with only one horcrux nagini left at that point. Plus due to the ancient charm of love n sacrifice, the piece of Riddle's soul in harry's body got destroyed by the elder wand thereby keeping the physical body intact. We saw that flesh of Voldemort in Harry's afterlife where he went to the place of In Between n met albus dumbledore. That's why he was suspicious after gaining consciousness if Harry was really dead. There are 2 factors here which kept Harry safe here. First Lily's love protection in his blood n the allegiance of Elder Wand to Harry which clearly voldemort was unaware about.also you r forgetting one major thing here. Harry went to the forbidden forest on his own account of sacrificing himself for others. To keep others safe from harm while he dies. His desire of protection kept him safe again. He cant die basically cos Tom Riddle foolishly bounded Harry to himself to Lily's protection with Harry's blood while resurrecting himself.
I think the reason for Narcissa lying to Voldemort is simply plot convenience. JKR tried hard to explain it, but I don't find the explanation convincing.
I disagree. She lied because it was the only way for her to make sure Draco was safe. Despite everything, she loved her son
Because Malfoy family actually hated Voldermot. They only yield to him in fear not for respect and was not interested to make him dictator ruler of wizarding world. Even Draco had the same thought so he lied duing identification of harry in Malloy Manor
Just this Chanel can’t get bettter!
Can you do what would Hagrid see in the mirror of erised.
I love how narcissa and lucius had different love for draco
Narcissa did the "Italian switcheroo"
I hate the plot point of voldermort not being able to feel love doesn't that essentially mean he was less that human from conception, with no option to change? It makes it sound as if it was just his nature to do what he did how could anyone say that was wrong?
Your reasoning makes little sense to me honestly.
If Narcissa would have said that Potter lived, they could have killed him again and would have gone to the castle anyway.
No, Voldemort wanted to kill Harry himself but he couldn't, and think about the fact that Narcissa only had few seconds to make a decision
Just thought in philosophers stone harry got the stone when he looked in the mirror and "wanted to get it but not use it" so it appeared in his pocket but that raises the question where was the stone? Because it couldn't have been in the mirror (quirrill actually suggested that but voldemort at once says "use the boy" no doubt realising that motives matter) where was it really?
great theory!! i just watched the last movie and wondered why she did that but i had my hunch
Can you do a video about why voldemorts wand was kept safe?
This is why you always double tap.... Just to be sure
Why did they not use "liquid luck" to win the battle against evil?
But they did...?
Because as slughorn said it is almost impossible to make and extremely dangerous if Made wrong.they aren’t the exact words but the the along the lines
Or the opposite
Before watching this video: I think she lied because she’s a mother and no mother wants their son dead and I know that she isn’t Harry’s mom but she is one
And all the other people that were standing there didn’t notice her lying either I assume?
bang on on the why but here is the how.
She only told Voldemort what he already believed strongly to be true. He felt the connection to Harry break and thought it was because Harry died because he didn't know Harry was one of his horcruxes and the severed connection was caused by the death of that Horcrux.
my question: why do students get afraid of the sorting hat when they clearly get placed into the same houses as their siblings. i know its the first day of hogwarts but they must have a firm idea of where they are going. also has there been a witch or wizard which has been placed incorrectly excluding harry
Peter Pettigrew
Siblings dont always get sorted into the same house, see Parvathi and Padma Patil. They are identical twins in different houses
@@jencyannamathew535 there is Regulus Black n Sirius black as well. One is slytherin n other gryffindor
Whose finger slipped and hit the dislike button?
Good one
Not mine
Same person like me who has been a long time follower who knows this is no more than a reload of old content. With the new beast movies there’s so much to explore nobody is trying to explore it like the black market magical world or the circus and so much more. As a loyal follower I have even suggested videos for a magical unemployment office and exploring the many jobs that a witch or wizard could get despite their magical skill.
Not mine.
Bellatrix Lestrange
I don't agree with the first part of your analysis, Voldemort would go to Hogwarts whether she told the truth or not. From her perspective, had she said the truth, Voldermort would simply rekill Harry, for real this time, and go to the castle anyway. So lying entails an unnecessary risk on her part.
I believe the latter part of your analysis is what happened here: she realized good can prevail, and was also grateful to Harry who told her that Draco is safe, and perhaps even realized that Harry had something to do with it.
How would Narcissa verify if Harry Potter is speaking the truth about her son?
I really love to see a mothers of the wizarding world
R.I.P. Helen McCrory
I think the book explanation really doesn't make sense. Like if she said he was still alive Voldemort could have just killed Harry for real and then they could have still went victorious and got Draco. If Harry had been defeated, Voldemort would have been so pissed at her that she lied about Harry being dead, definitely kill her and probably her family too. Maybe Harry misunderstood and she did this because she thought that keeping Harry alive was the only way to defeat Voldemort and then she could run off with her son, but if her son was dead she didn't even care about hopes of running off or like even living...
Get over it. The books are filled with plot holes. (not to mention the sexist approach. even the lord of the rings trilogy was better at representing a powerful female character with only one at hand than the harry potter series wich was filled with females all of whom were weak.)
I wonder if Luna put her hand on his shoulder would have Draco gone.