How Was Narcissa Malfoy Able To Lie To Voldemort? Updated + Extended Version
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 вер 2024
- Please watch: "The Life Of Marius de Romanus (Vampire Chronicles)"
• Video -~-
Hey everyone, so due to the success of my recently updated and extended video on why the weasleys were so poor, there was always one more video I intended to update and extend after the Weasley one and that was the How Narcissa Malfoy Was Able To Voldemort. When you grow as a youtuber, you take a lot of pride in delivering the best most informative content and unfortunately, my older videos appear to have the right topic but just poor quality, so I really want to take these videos and make them into the videos they should be so thats exactly what I’m going to do in todays video. I’ll be thoroughly and properly analysing all the factors that contributed to Narcissa being able to do the one thing that was believed to be impossible to do..lie to Lord Voldemort and get away with it..So how exactly did she pull it off? Let’s find out.
Check Out HPF’s artist Dany’s Work Here:
Facebook: / danyddoodles
Webcomic: www.underground...
Check Out UpTheHill’s Work Here:
Deviant Art: www.deviantart...
Lend your Patreon Support goo.gl/ZoHfRf
Follow me on Instagram goo.gl/jBAkX2
Merchandise Store TSHIRTS teespring.com/...
Subscribe to the channel goo.gl/anpK3E
Follow me on Instagram goo.gl/jBAkX2
Like Us On Facebook goo.gl/64LmGP
Follow Me On Twitter goo.gl/BjgbBi
Shop Amazon for everything Harry Potter: goo.gl/JAjC2g
Narcissa loved Draco more than she feared Voldemort.
Nice The Last Airbender reference.
Brandon Theurer I’m so happy somebody got the reference
Mai to Azula!
Mai loved Zuko more than she feared Azula
“No, YOU miscalculated! You should’ve feared me MORE!” What a great scene.
Narcissa: I lied to lord Voldemort once
Snape: LMAO I've been doing it for years
Narcissa : but you died ❤️
Lol
Narcissa: Half-truths aren't the same as lies, Severus
@@iennguyenkaizen3993 Remember, Snape could have said that Elder Wand belongs to Malfoy. 😎
@@riofelix5513 Snape saved Malfoy's life
And for the second time, Harry was saved by a mother's love.
That's a poetic way of putting it! Makes me appreciate the scene all the more.
Well technically 3rd cuz 1st it was from Lily then it was Molly for taking care of him now Narcissa
He wasnt really saved by her
I-Am Sax he was LOL voldemort might cast another killing curse to harry
I love the scene where Ginny is saved by her mother's love. "NOT MY DAUGHTER YOU B@#$!"
Voldemorts own arrogance in believing that no one could fool him helped too.
Agreed. I believe he was a genius wizard, but his narcissism was a fatal flaw so that he didn’t think about common sense things or do the basic checks and balances. Thank goodness 😅
Maybe Narcissa was skilled in Occulmency?
@@ewaleokadia76 after all Bellatrix taught Draco occlumency well enough he could block Snapes attempts at legilimency. Probably a skill that ran in their family.
Yes
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Voldemort's real weakness: a mother's love.
He probably thought that because his own mother died giving birth to him and didn't stay alive to raise him that no mother ever truly loved their kid even though the majority of mothers do. That's why as an 11 year old he said to Dumbledore "My mother can't have been magic or she wouldn't have died."
Well, I just say love in general
@@maragathamsomasundaram9704 mothers love is very different from 'love' in general. Every situation of 'love' is accompanied by a baggage of expectation which needs to be fulfilled. A mother's love is always always unconditional and fierce.
Voldemort couldn't feel any love. It's explained, as he was conceived under the influence of love potion (Voldemort's mother used it on his father), Voldemort would never be able to feel love.
So Voldemort might have been underrating "love" in general and therefore it has tricked him multiple times. Also, the creation of the horcruxes split his soul, it has to influence your view on love somehow.
@@Xehanort10 It was also because he was born on a love potion. So, he couldn't feel love.
Snape and Narcissa are the only characters that had the guts to lie to the dark lord in the face and got away with it.
Don't forget about Regulus Black (R.A.B) he lied to him to!!
To think that these 3 were his supporters(except for Snape after Voldemort killed Lily)makes it even more amazing.
@@alexstergiou653 regulus wasn't
@@alexstergiou653 Narcissus wasn't his supporter. She supported her husband
@@lh8167 exactly.. narcissa was loyal to lucius and bella and loved her son but was never a deatheater herself.. the fact that bella and lucius and later draco where deatheaters always put her in the middle of it all but she wasn't loyal to voldy at all.. and towards the end of the story all of them except bella drop their loyality towards voldy entirely and start to support harry actually.. well lucius doesn't support harry but he also doesn't care about voldemort and his plans anymore and narcissa and draco do both safe him.. draco surely knows that it's harry in malfoy manor inspite of his swollen face.. he is with hermione and ron after all and draco isn't dumb.. but he started to see what an evil fuck voldy is and how bad he treated his father and started to realize that harry is the only one who can end this.. and narzissa ofc safes him in the forrest.. so neither of them really cares anymore about voldy and anyone except their family, the 3 of them..
Lie to Lord Voldemort? Impossible?
*Snape's ghost has entered the chat*
Actually Snape never lied to him...it was just half truth...
@@3choohc3 he's the half-truth prince
@@dutchpangermanist5673 lol
He lied when he said not getting Lily didn't matter
Also as Voldemort being The Greatest "LEGILIMENCE"
Snape was The BEST "OCCLUMENCE" Against him .... So he could very much lie to him all the time ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Narcissa: Draco... Is he alive?
Harry nods
Narcissa: Congratulations!!! Harry Potter you're dead...
LMFAOOOOO good one!!!
Lol
😂😂😂
😂😂
Voldemort : Hehehehehehehehehhehehe
Andromeda was lawful good, Belltrrix was chaotic evil, Narcissa was true neutral. She did whatever she needed to do for the people she loved.
Isn't that neutral good?
True neutral is seeking perfect balance in their actions, words and deeds. And that isn't Narcissa
Hoi im temmie neutral in the sense that she was good when she wanted and bad when she wanted,or should I say needed
She was different from her sisters she was not “good” but she was not “bad” eather.
She was just what she needed to be for her family
@@chiedzamadzima2844 lawful neutral it is
I would say she was neutral evil. Because she could adapt easily enough to the status quo but her preference is to have everything the way she wants and she's willing to do whatever it takes, no matter the act, for her own personal gain. Just because she lied to save her son doesnt make her good, because if she had the preference then pure bloods would rule unchallenged. Voldemort was just too evil for her and serving him did not derive her any true benefit, but it doesnt mean that she or her husband had the balls to turn on him either, they merely acted to save to own skin, but if they had the chance they'd be tyrants too.
A true neutral wouldn't care who was in charge as long as they would have no preference. But narcissa clearly had a preference to put her pure blood status first. Which makes her more, neutral evil
I think all Thea’s points are valid and that narcissa is a more complex character then what the story portrayed she easily lied to Voldemort when her son needed it but she always stood firmly by the dark lord
And I think that her loyalty to voldi came solely from her upbringing and had little to do with her personality.
This scene made Narcissa ultimately turn into a hero for me.
She just did it for Draco🙄
Julia S. one good act doesn’t absolve her of being a death eater, a pure blood supremacist and the fact she only did it for Draco, she was no hero
Harley O'Keefe 💕💕👍🏻👍🏻
@@harleyokeefe5193 that's your opinion
Julia S. “help will always be given at hogwarts to those who ask for it:)”
Narcissa loved Draco just as much as Lily loved Harry. It was her love for Draco that let her lie to Voldemort's face.
Her love for draco is much bigger than her fear to the dark lord.
@@gigit8234 god atla is so good and it makes me happy people still reference it.
Here's my theory on how Narcissa was able to lie at Voldemort: She is highly trained at occlumency. Proof: not like her sister, Bellatrix, she is capable of love. She was similar to Andromeda though she fears she could be banished like her sister. So she taught herself on how to close her mind from her parents, her sister, Bellatrix, and even to her husband, Lucius. If this is not enough to say that she is capable of lying, then maybe when she struck a deal with Harry, that also made her shielded with the power of sacrifice/love and able to close her mind from Voldemort's legilimency.
Daniel Noveloso same
I think Narcissa became proficient at Occlumency later in life, in between the beginning of HBP and the end of DH. In HBP, it's Bellatrix who gives Draco Occlumency lessons the summer before his sixth year, so he can be an effective spy and block out Snape's attempts to enter his mind. If Narcissa had been skilled at Occlumency - at least as skilled as Bellatrix - she might have just taught Draco herself. It's possible that Draco didn't tell Narcissa about these lessons, but I doubt he could have kept that kind of secret, since Draco and Narcissa (and likely Bellatrix as well) lived together at Malfoy Manor. Narcissa probably picked up (or at least greatly improved) her skill at Occlumency after Lucius' fall from grace put their family in danger. Having Voldemort actually live in her home meant Narcissa would have worked very, very hard to protect her mind (and protect her loved ones as well).
definitely a sacrifice similar to Lilys minus the death- given the chance narcissa wouldve been mudered by Voldemort
Daniel Noveloso I agree, she a very skilled occlumency remember Bellatrix taught Draco the entire summer to be an Occlumency . So I’m pretty sure she taught her sister as they had worked together to protect Draco.
Damn. That changes a lot. A shame this happened the way it did. I imagine lily and narcissa had much in common as mothers.
Voldemort: Harry Potter is dead
Harry: Pretty sure you're wrong
The Deadeaters: * shocked *
Narcissa: Uh oh what a shame
Voldemort realising he got played by another mom
Deatheaters*
Its deatheaters not deadeaters
Y.E.S.
I wish people would stop with the correcting and just enjoy the comment. 1 correction is enough no need for 3 ppl to correct someone.
Voldy, you never learn (sighs)
I really don’t believe she used occlumency personally, I always thought his greatest flaw was his arrogance. He clearly lacked respect for Narcissa, not only because the Malfoys had fallen out of favour but because he hadn’t seen anything from her to indicate she was a particularly talented witch. He would have assumed that she wouldn’t dare lie to him because he believed his followers feared him too much to try and so he doesn’t even bother to check. It’s that arrogance in that moment that is his downfall.
Also, he sent her, not Bellatrix, because Narcissa was disposable, a little pawn without importance. I think he wouldn´t care about Legilimency because he didn´t believed she could lie, or that her thoughts would be so important.
This is it
I though so too.
@@vilwarin5635 my thought is that she finally got the gusto to have occlumency work for her in that second when she decided to ask for Harry's help...
We see for a long long time, Hermione telling Harry he has to concentrate on blocking the dark lord out. When he's not concentrating on blocking it, he gets in...
I think it was possible for Narcissa to master the skill and keep it going, with her determination to find her son.
She was expendable, and she likely knew that too, which also helped her determination.
@@alerislib I believe the magical world is so immense that it's probably a mixture of everything from: Narcissa knowing occlumency, to the Dark Lord being so arrogant he didnt bother reading her mind, to Harry's Shield extending out to protect her family. It all lead up to the Dark Lords down fall anyway
Technically I never left the world of harry potter
Same
We never do 🥰🥰
Same
I know right!
What are you talking about folkLaure
BLACK BRAD I mean, it’s hard for me to like the same franchise for many many years while nothing comes out, that’s why my interests move towards comics and comic movies, like DC and Marvel, there’s so much to read and do there, while Harry Potter comes out with a new FB movie every 5 years.
I'm never this early. I've always found Narcissa interesting. Her only priority was Draco.
Just like Morly
ByeBitch 《 《 doesnt mean she’s not interesting
@ByeBitch 《 Wow, you didn't think too hard about this did you?
@@Apple_Slices. Exactly
@ByeBitch 《 but it's interesting that she exhibits so much love for her family when her sister in stark contrast has no love for anyone. It is interesting :) there must be more to her than she ever shows. That is mysterious, and that is interesting
I believe JK Rowling relates to a "A mothers love is the most powerful magic and can defeat even the most powerful of evils" due to her own past. I think her children are a big reason she escaped from her marriage which ended up saving her in my opinion. Thats why its such a crucial part of the story on both light and dark sides. There are no limits to great when it comes to a mother protecting her child and i think JK Rowling believes that on a personal level.
JK Rowling didn't write Harry Potter
@@Gunplabro Really? We have been deceived...
YES, AND BECAUSE HER OWN MOTHER DIED BEFORE SHE COULD READ IT :-( (( ( THAT IS TO IGNORE THE FACT THAT JK JUST HEARD A WITCH TELLING THE STORY TO HER CHILDREN WHILE GOING TO KINGSCROSS TO DROP THEM TO THE HOGWARTS EXPRESS)
Yeah, Harry Potter himself is the real author. They’re auto-biographies. :P
@@Gunplabro right, Harry himself wrote the books
It is impossible to lie to The Dark Lord
Snape: Hold my potion
i read snaps line in his voice
LOL!
snape: hold my lily
@@itz_galaxyfam6626 Now that's just sad.
More like-- hollld myyy poootion
Mother's love is one of the thing the dark lord never experienced and that's the reason he lose twice because of mother's love.
Narcissa is my fav HP character .... i loved the scene where Narcissa drapped her hair over Harry and asked if Draco was still alive. She could have outed Harry for still being alive and Harry could have outed Narcissa for lying . She protected Harry like any mother would. If her Draco was in this situation, she would hope someone would protect him.
I agree that she could have outed that Harry was alive once she knew that draco was there. However Harry could not out her lying without giving away that he wasn't dead
@@shivasurya7008 thats true
@@shivasurya7008 yeah but she wouldn't because, if she outed harry as not dead, they might not have gone to the castle and she still could not look for draco
And someone did protect Draco, Harry saved his life. So even though she didn't know it she was returning the favor.
Till they messed her hair up the actress I loved by I was way sad about the look they chose to give her
.... Narcissa was only 5 years older than Lily, i wonder if she had met Lily before. It seemed everyone knew Lily for her eyes. Maybe Narcissa did too
Narcissa probably meet Lolly a few times because she was still at Hogwarts when Lilly came
Narsissa was2 years older then Lilly her second oldest sister was 5 years older Bella was 7 years older or 8 I think 8
My theory is that narcissa hated that Voldemort didn’t have a nose and made her paranoid
XD
Lol
Rewrite : really laughing loud on the floor 😂😂
😂😂😂😂
Voldemort's nose detached itself from his face to become Narcissa's sleep paralysis demon
xD
One correction: Harry didn't feel the crutiatus curse. Through him being willing to die, he protected everyone from Voldemort, including himself. You can read that in the book, he wasn't affected by the crutiatus curse!
Yes, that's what I thought too! I thought I might have remembered it wrong, that he didn't feel pain...
It's also implied, isn't it, that the Elder Wand cannot hurt it's owner? That's what I always assumed, anyway!
@@juliad857 I have to say I didn't think about that, but true.
This is why I think Narcissa was able to lie. Harry’s sacrifice protection protected everyone in the school, including Draco and Draco and his mom share that love bond and so Narcissa is also protected from Voldemort. Her willingness to lie is because of her love for her son and she is protected because she made that choice (out of love). It’s a theory.
At that point in the book, cruciatus had no effect on Harry because the Elder wand refused to harm its' master.
Your pfp 🥴
What do you mean Power in molly we never thought we'd see?
molly has always been terifying.
Second scariest woman of the series.
after only McGonagall
Someone forgot of Umbridge's existence, lucky you.
@@noxillius1363 I don't count Evil as scary.
I would love to piss off umbridge.
As did the entire school.
But I do not want to cross
McGonagall
MRS. Weasley.
Madam Pomfree,
or Angelina Johnson
As true as that is, Molly was probably punching above her weight going up against Bellatrix one-on-one. She's a capable witch, and downright terrifying (to her children), but never DEMONSTRATED dueling/defensive magical abilities once over the 7 books (beyond the boggart she failed to destroy in book 5). In the Order of the Phoenix (the group, not the book), she was never shown to be one of the front-line fighters like Lupin, Tonks, Kingsley, or even Bill and Mr. Weasley. She was always in the background, the one who stayed at the Burrow or Grimmauld Place to keep house. Hence seeing her not only fight Voldemort's top lieutenant but kill her is so unexpected.
Again, the power of a mother's love; and the ability to channel anger and use it to advantage, rather than abandoning one's self to it the way Bellatrix generally did.
Lahly Bird even though she wasn’t really a woman at the time, Hermione was scary as well
Both times Harry was saved by mother's love. First his own mother's and later Narcissa's love to Draco
Bruh
He didn't even die
Three timed*
In defense of Lucius: Despite the horrible things he has done; he too seems to value his family beyond Voldemort. If the way he acted in the end was any indication.
You mean didn't join the war, cause between the 3 of them they didn't have 1 wand?
@@parisakamali4123 It was done much better in the book where it said Narcissa and Lucius ran around the battle, without a wand, like you said, just calling for their son, not even bothering to pretend they cared about the battle.
Yes the movies made them look cowardly running away, but in the books they were simply wandless and defeated and decided they weren't going to fight just sit there awkwardly. Far more anti Voldemort than running away.
@@parisakamali4123 Sitting there awkwardly after the fight yeah, but I never said Lucius was heroic or Anti-Voldemort just that he valued his family over Voldemort.
Only thing missing was Lucius saying "Give him hell Potter" before they escape.
One thing that's a possibility: Bellatrix was skilled in legimens, and she was teaching Draco. Who's to say that she didn't teach Narcissa, or that Narcissa didn't already know how to block everyone out from an early age? It would make it far easier for her to use a focus to successfully lie to Voldemort
I think par Snape nobody were better than voldermort so o think he would have found out
That’s what I thought. Not necessarily about Bellatrix teaching her, at least not in recent history, but about Narcissa being a good occlumens.
At the end of the day, she lived alongside the Death Eaters for years and never got her dark mark, never actually took part in operations, obviously never put Voldemort first, and yet no one at all ever questioned her loyalty. On a lesser note, her family also lied about their involvement with Voldemort in the First Wizarding War and she grew up with very strict parents. I wouldn’t have thought much of any of this alone, but this scene kinda made it stand out for me.
Not saying she’s necessarily as good as lying to Voldemort for years. Maybe she was quiet and a good enough liar in the muggle way to avoid scrutiny for the most part, and in this case her love for Draco may surely have enhanced her abilities, but chances are she was at least significantly skilled at occlumency.
Bellatrix was skilled in occlumency, NOT legilimency which she taught Draco
Legilimency is the art of reading people's minds, Voldemort and Queenie Goldstein from Fantastic Beasts were Legilimens
Occlumency is blocking people from reading your mind. it was what Bellatrix taught Draco and what Snape tried to teach Harry
dragonweyr44 yes, but you have to *use* Legilimency to teach someone Occlumency. You can’t teach someone to dodge bullets by throwing pebbles at them.
dragonweyr44 I also feel like ultimately they go hand in hand for definition. Whether you want to read someone else’s mind or block others out of your own, you have to know what makes a mind vulnerable in the first place. It makes sense that someone would simply be more skilled at one or the other due to practice or character, but I doubt they should be thought of as completely separate even if we didn’t know Bellatrix was skilled in legilimency enough to teach occlumency.
"It is impossible to lie to Voldemort!"
*Snape: Hold my chemistry set*
Snape: *Wait give it back, I have a class to teach*
I'll hold your lilies instead
Oh wait
Snape: hold Harry's swine of a father lol
This analysis is great, but I think there is another factor. When Harry is in "limbo" I feel like Dumbledore offered him a choice, to fully die, or to live and go on. That suspension of life, that moment of limbo, could have also fortified Narcissa's lie.
Nope. When Narcissa asked him if Draco was dead, Harry was able to say Yes. If he was in limbo, he wouldn't have been able to answer her question. He was fully conscious when Narcissa checked him.
@@tasi4372 yep the book is clear it was after he came back, he was not in limbo anymore
Question: “How was Narcissa able to lie to Voldemort about Harry’s death?”
Answer: Her love for Draco protected her.
Question: “Why did Narcissa lie to Voldemort about Harry’s death?”
Answer: She was in Harry’s debt for saving Draco’s life in the Room of Requirement.
how did they she know that malfoy are in trouble at room of requirement? i meant that malfoy tried to stop harry there that means malfoy is in team voldy so no worries?
Dumbledore explained it in the Prisoner of Azkaban. A life debt will always pay off, sooner or later.
Harry saved Peter Pettigrew and was saved by him, Harry saved Dracos live, Narcissa saved his
@@francolaurana yeah but she didn't know about the whole thing what Happened at the room of requirement. She wasn't there, she met Draco only afterwards
(I haven't read the book, only seen the movies)
Aastha H is right. Narcissa didn’t know harry saved his life not only in the room of requirement but also when a death eater came at Draco cus he didn’t recognized him as one them, so Harry saved him again. In the book it said that Narcissa knew that the only way she would be able to go into Hogwarts was if Voldemort thought that they have won, that Harry was dead. So that’s why she lied, so she could go to Hogwarts and find Draco. At that point, she didn’t care if Voldemort won, she just wanted her family safe.
@@francolaurana peter pettigrew saved harry but whem
Snape lied to him first
And KEPT lying, right up to his death, it seemed.
And was so good at it that Voldemort taught Snape how to fly
Snape was also a master of occlumency
@@chrisabitong7636 Do the books explicitly say when Voldy did that? It seems to me Voldy woulda had time to do it before 1981 versus after, but perhaps I just made that choice on my own, since I think most believe he did it between 1995 and 1998.
@@lisakaz35 I took from it that he did it after his resurrection... unsupported flight probably would have been mentioned during the first wizarding war
9:03 No, there was no pain. The Elder Wand was Harry's at that point, so the wand refused to harm its master. If the curse worked, Harry couldn't withstand it. No one can withstand it, and I think people keep forgetting that.
As always The Power of Love triumphs over evil especially if the love is coming from a mother. A mother's love is easily the most powerful and will always stop evildoers from succeeding.
Awww wonderfully stated!
Does anyone else hate it when Voldy pushes Bellatrix down when she's trying to get him up?
No I found it hilarious 🤣🤣
@@kristinapetrovski1132 me too hahahahah
I hate it too
@@bluesquirrel2472 🤣🤣🤣
“Voldy” lmao😂😂
The torture curse didn’t work on Harry “post fake dead” because Voldemort was using the elder wand, and that wand can’t hurt it’s real master.
dietdrpepper15 I didn’t see it that way at the moment, really good point, I agree. Also probably why the killing curse only affected Voldemort’s part in Harry and not Harry himself.
@@jmrggrmj9330 Yup that is 100% right. Walking into the forest Harry had 3 things working for him: the wand, the inner Horcrux and Lily's sacrifice. Voldemort didn't stand much of a chance of killing him. Dumbledore knew that(Lily's blood for sure), but couldn't say because it had to be a sacrifice on Harry's part.
*Narsissa after Voldemort asks why she lied* "I love Draco more than I fear you"
I think Dean that with the eliminating of each of Voldemort's horcruxes up to to the point that the only one left was Nagini. This would have weakened Voldemort so that his ability of occlumency would have been weakened. But Dean keep up the great work and I have seen your videos are more polished from when I first watched them. Keep up the great work.
Harry didn't feel any pain from the cruicatus curse in the book, he just didn't move. He didn't feel any pain because the Elder Wand couldn't hurt its master and because Harry's sacrifice was a protection to everyone he loved.
Awesome updated and extended version Harry Potter Folklore and keep the awesome job. Love your channel
Again voldomort was defeated by a mother who cared for her child
Ok but... the reason that the cruciatus curse doesn’t work is because Voldemort doesn’t own the elder wand
I agree with you there
Not likely. Voldemort was still very capable even if the elder wand is limiting his power. He was even able to fight Prof. McGonnagal and Prof. Slughorn at the same time while using it. He's just that powerful but it also became his fall from demise because he underestimated the power of sacrifice.
@@danielnoveloso9754 i think you proved their point instead of your own. "He was even able to fight Prof. McGonnagal and Prof. Slughorn at the same time" - neither of whom were the master of the elder wand, while it never worked fully for him (not being the owner) it did still do something - which is how he fought them both at once, but Harry *_was_* the master of the wand, which is why it refused to harm him.
when fighting Profs. McGonnagal and Slughorn the wand was indifferent between all 3 of them and was content to comply, but when used against its master it downright refused to act properly at all. the most powerful wand in existence, in use against it master, Harry, was also the most useless, regardless of the wielder.
however, it is also possible Lilly's blood in Voldemort's veins may have had an impact too. unsure how though...
Definitely agree. What sort of cheeky-ass wand would allow for an unforgivable curse to be cast on its own master? Not the most serious one out there, is my guess.
No. It was because Harry sacrificed himself to everyone else. He made the same protection that Lily made to himself and everyone who fought the battle
My theory is she did it because of love and Voldemort can’t understand it.
Love your videos! I can’t even remember when I started or how I found you. But your videos are awesome. Could you make one on why did Regulus decided to betray Lord Voldemort!?
It’s so crazy that your older video on these topics informed me on what I wanted to know, but your updated versions teach me new things that I never knew I wanted to know! I look forward to every video you make for little things like this 🧙♀️
"The one thing that was believed to be impossible" But Snape lied to Voldemort all the time working as an undercover "deatheater", didn't he?
That's because Snape was a superb Occlumens, though. :) He closed his mind at will.
“If you want something done then you do it yourself”
*Voldemort watches intensely dreamatic*
Narcissa: Dead.
Harry Potter Folklore: Her maternal operating sytstem turned on a whole other level
After Voldemort possessed Harry, he probably automatically blocked out feeling of love that people were having, and since her motivations were based on that, that could also contribute to it.
Life Of Albus Dumbledore 🖤
I don't think he does that anymore because movieflame does it.
When Voldy fell over, Bellatrix had to help him up because he's a pensioner.
I disagree with one thing: you say at 8:04, that it wasn’t magical love. I completely disagree, I think all bits of love spark a little bit of magic. Yes, with muggles to. The love that she had for Draco blocked Voldemort from seeing this lie.
I've always thought the same thing as u just presented, since both the 7th book and 7th movie (part 2 in particular) were released!
I knew that, when Harry went back to save Draco from the fire in the room of requirement, it would have a positive effect on a later scene, just like when he stopped Sirius and Lupin killing Wormtail has had an effect later in the series! As soon as Narcissa found out Draco was alive, her love for Draco - the strongest magic of all - would help her lie to him without a problem! And, just like Lily's love for Harry giving him protection from Voldemort, I don't think she even needed to use occlumency to block Voldy out! Her strong maternal love for Draco - and maybe even a bit of gratitude to Harry, however miniscule that might be - protected her mind for her! ... That was always my opinion anyway!
Great video as always though, keep it up!
Dean:No one can lie to the dark lord except narcissa
Snape: WTF!
Narcissa: I lied to Voldemort one time
Snape: *Inhales* BOI those are rookie levels I've been lying to him for yearsss..... *cough* Get on my level *cough*
You can just say that after Lord Voldemort destroyed his Harry Horcrux, he was so weakened that his power/ability of legilimence was at wreck. So Cissy was able to lie to him.
Hey love your videos watching since the beginning and I'm from south America Guyana ...much love
I always thought Narcissa was very much like Petunia Dursley, not Lily Potter. Both Narcissa and Petunia grew up being overshadowed by an exceptionally gifted sister (Bellatrix and Lily, respectively). Both were affected psychologically after this, as each had one child, and only one child, whom they spoiled and coddled immensely, so Draco and Dudley would never feel second-best or unappreciated. Both were very snobbish, preoccupied with the 'proper' way things should be, and looked down on anyone who didn't belong to their social cachet or didn't fit into a specific mold. Both supported their family, even when it went against their natural inclinations (Narcissa with Bellatrix and Lucius, and Petunia with Harry). Both were fiercely protective of their respective husbands and children and frightened for their safety. And mother's love is a key aspect of their personalities.
If you haven’t done it yet could you do a life of fred or george
Yes that sounds awesome.
Please can ya
Sadly he can’t because Movieflame wanted a monopoly on life of videos.
@@emmaherron5121 what do you mean
Hate to break it to you •Aesthetic•Subs• but he is not allowed to do the life of [ insert charters name here ] videos any more............
Updated and extended, yes, but feels like so much more Dean.
Excellent, as always, my good sir!
Looking forward to the next one!
I believe the main reason of the lie being sold, along with Narcissa's incredible deception and Voldy's arrogance, is that Harry is the true master of the Elder Wand, when he disarmed Draco, after Draco disarmed Dumbledore. (So Dumbledore was disarmed by Draco, then he was the true master, then Harry disarmed Draco, making him the new master.) Bellatrix states that in order for the Killing Curse to work, the caster must mean it, which of course, Voldemort did mean it, so much that he was knocked off his feet. Along with this, the Cruciatus Curse was also casted. It is stated that the Wand chooses its owner, not the Wizard or Witch. So no matter how powerful of a Witch or Wizard you are, the wand will not work for you if you are not its master or owner. The Elder Wand will not harm its true master, this being Harry. When Voldy casted Avada Kedavra onto Harry, he only ended up destroying a part of himself, the "Horcrux" part. (simplified to being a Horcrux in the movie.) I believe this is the case because well, the Elder Wand will not hurt Harry as he's its true owner. So, the Killing Curse casted by Voldy was redirected from Harry, to the only part of Harry that wasn't Harry. (Voldemort's soul.) Which is why he only ended us killing part of him, Ressurection Stone etc etc. Also badass, Harry the Master of Death, rightful owner of all 3 Deathly Hallows.
I've been waiting for this vid for a while and I'm definitely not disappointed at all. Keep up the great work!
That was one of your best videos to date. The analyzing of not only the character's thoughts but searching their past psyches just phenomenal. All together just an awesome job.
Thanks for your wonderful work. Cheers from Ontario Canada
The magic of motherly love is the one bit of magic that Voldemort never understood.
Dean you’re too hard on yourself, the original version of this wasn’t poor quality at all. However I do love this extended one :-) x
There is nothing more fierce and more powerful in this world, than a mother protecting her child.
Awesome update and extended version. I love your channel, keep up the good work!!!
Harry didn't actually feel anything when Voldemort used the Cruciatus curse on him because the spell didn't work. This is because the Elder Wand doesn't truly belong to Voldermort, it belongs to Harry so any spells used on him won't work. Sorry to anyone who thought Harry could feign death whilst being tortured.
In the book, when Harry is brought to Hogwarts alive but supposedly dead Voldermort uses the silencing charm on the good side but it doesn't work hence why he has to keep using it. Another example of how the Elder Wand doesn't work for him.
I missed you Dean! I'm glad to hear your voice 😋💚
Hey man I don’t think you’ll ever see this comment but don’t feel bad about the “quality” I have ALWAYS enjoyed you’re videos and all the information that you have given us. There are SO MANY things that I didn’t even know about that you cleared up/answered for me. Thank you 🙏
This is pretty much what I thought was the reason behind it. Love the video.
I love the video. Im so glad you're growing your channel. Please keep up the great work!
Harry never felt the pain from the curse because he was protected by his sacrifice
My theory is: Narcissa was trained in Oclumency, probably making her more skilled than Severus. She shielded her mind while asking Harry and lying to Voldemort. She was probably so skilled that Voldemort couldn't penetrate into her mind. This is just a guess lol.
She is not at all a better occulemncer than Snape, Snape mastered that ability.
Video idea: How do legilimency and occlumency translate into muggle world? Like dementors and patronus charm manifest as depression and power of gratitude (my guess) accordingly. Maybe discuss how we can master these as well, because while there is a charm, most of the work, at least for occlumency, seems to be psychological.
I think since Voldemort was born with the love potion playing a huge part hence he has his achelli's hill in love
The Power Of Love❤
Narcissa loving Draco makes sense,
as the prophecy said in the middle
"He shall have power the DARK LORD
KNOWS NOT" And that power is love
which Voldemort is incapable of feeling
so yeah.
A mother's love for a son has always blinded Voldemort.
Narcissa: You miscalculated, I love Draco more then I hear you.
Voldemort: No you miscalculated! You should've feared me more.
Tom Riddle was never the greatest legitimate. We see that Snape over powered him for years and we know that legitimacy was practiced by the death eater a magical practice not widely known, Tom riddle was just full of himself he thought he was the best, not taking in anyone else’s talent or skills.
@Curtis Ball I don't think that's the case, as Harry was being taught by Snape?
Snape was a very accomplished occulmancer, but riddle was the best legilimancer
@Curtis Ball not really. There were people who were born like that, like that sister of Tina (I forgot the name). But that doesn't mean it can't be learnt. I think we only met her, with this kind of power born, at this point.
@Curtis Ball You can born like that, but you can also learn the spell and train to use it. I think it could be "like" a born musician and a person who learns to play piano in later life
Archaia queenie goldstein
Umbridge´s torture practises on Harry might have given him extra experience in taking wee bit punishment.
The power of love; the greatest magic of all.
How ironic. Voldemort desired power, greater power and control and yet he never had the greatest one of all: Love
David Sperling this is because I was born to a father under the influence of amortentia. As a result he was born without the ability to love.
I thought the cruciatus curse didn't affect Harry. The book literally says " Harry had been expecting it: knew his body would not be allowed to remain unsullied upon the Forest floor, it must be subjected to humiliation to prove Voldemort’s victory. He was lifted into the air, and it took all his determination to remain limp, yet the pain he expected did not come." Maybe this is due to the Elder wand not wanting to hurt its true owner. Otherwise, great video!
stan queen narcissa! 👑😂
All I learnt from this was not to mess with a mother's love
The one I always waited for
If you haven’t done one, you should make a video talking about how big the magical world is , that sounds fascinating I’ve never fully understand where the wizarding world is and how it’s kept hidden and how big it is ！ love ur videos
Narcissa has always been one of my favorite female characters in HP.
keeping your videos updated and informed is very smart and a professional thing to do. Very good!
Honestly you'd think Voldemort would have checked himself after all that time. Plot convenience I guess.
He was too cocky
Voldemort was, I believe, too nervous. He didn't believe all had gone to plan.
Common sense wasnt Voldemort’s strong suit
He did check himself.... with the Cruciatus Curse. He's always been overconfident in his magic.
@@NileSWPhotography you are right. He was too nervous to check for himself, so he sent the most disposable person he had (Narcissa) to do the dirty job. THEN, he dared to curse Harry
Thank you Dean for another great video.
Narcissa was always one of my favorite characters. I find narcissa and Draco one of the best characters. Oh by the way love the videos
I also think at that point, Voldemort who was well known for knowing when being lied to, he was slightly weakened from what happened but could see no reason why she would lie to him at that point. I mean as mentioned, Voldemort never understood love so he would not have foreseen the motherly love of Narcissa to be so brazen as to lie, let alone her reason to.
There was no pain when the cruciatus curse hit him, voldermorts magic was harmless to harry after the avadar kedvra curse, so he was only feigning death. Read that part again he waited for the pain but nothing came he was only tossed around and decided to remain limp and play dead.
8:03 - 8:22
This was, in my opinion, the best, the most descriptive, the most powerful, and the most inspirational description of Narcissa Malfoy's successful lie to Voldemort.
"Now, while I don't exactly believe it was the magical power of love that helped her block out Voldemort's attempt to penetrate her mind, it was the maternal power of love that gave Narcissa the ultimate level of focus and concentration to reconfirm Voldemort's already assumption of Harry's death."
And I say it was inspirational because it was not magic now; it was purely maternal love... I think (and this is just my personal opinion) that J.K. Rowling means to convey that Muggle mothers are also capable of such a thing without magic, that a mother's love is perhaps the most powerful force of all.
eyyyy... I’m first
luv the vid btw, your videos are always so great❤️❤️❤️
Sorry love
Emily E. wrong I was first then the other dude onhere
oh
Emily E. ya
Your voice is soooooo chill I can listen for my whole life to your vids