The Most Complex Calculation in AoE2? Cataphracts vs Sicilian Halberdiers

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 592

  • @joel_seth_media
    @joel_seth_media 3 роки тому +1421

    Legend holds that a 500 pop 8 player match on Ludakris Sicilians vs Byzantines was the real cause of Rome's fall.

    • @Duke_of_Lorraine
      @Duke_of_Lorraine 3 роки тому +109

      what really caused the game to go over the edge was one player picking the Goths, with the +10 population limit.

    • @emilyding2496
      @emilyding2496 3 роки тому +32

      @@Duke_of_Lorraine , ahhh, that explains why. And they used that extra 10 pop to play some Gladiator Games in the Colosseum with same Lion and Elephant Kings.

    • @iau
      @iau 3 роки тому +18

      Having to calculate damage outputs is what drove Roman emperors to madness

    • @niki8280
      @niki8280 3 роки тому

      Weren't the sicilians romans back then?

    • @Duke_of_Lorraine
      @Duke_of_Lorraine 3 роки тому +6

      @@niki8280 the Vandals took over Sicily at some point

  • @michaeltaylor8698
    @michaeltaylor8698 3 роки тому +609

    I was today years old when I learned that Logistica adds another +6 damage vs infantry as well as trample damage.

    • @MrDwarfpitcher
      @MrDwarfpitcher 3 роки тому +48

      I know right
      I first thought Logistica was overpriced but noticed that without it, the cataphracts severly underperformed.
      How could we have known that it also gives extra bonus damage

    • @ericdunn9001
      @ericdunn9001 3 роки тому +142

      @@MrDwarfpitcher That's always been my biggest gripe with aoe2. How is a kid supposed to figure out all of this stuff back in the day? When I was a kid, I didn't even know about elevation bonuses lmao.

    • @JohnSmith-tg9wc
      @JohnSmith-tg9wc 3 роки тому +37

      @@ericdunn9001 I don't think it was designed for kids... 10 year old me was shit at AOE2

    • @greedyfudge2469
      @greedyfudge2469 3 роки тому +21

      With Logistica Elite Cataphracts kill Goth Halberdier in two hits since those don't get the last armor upgrade, so it can go a long way in specific situations

    • @WitzerlOsiris
      @WitzerlOsiris 3 роки тому +80

      When I was ten, I thought that trample damage applied when they where moving through enemy units. The description in the manual was very misleading

  • @betrerolthorion3897
    @betrerolthorion3897 3 роки тому +767

    On the dispute between Cataphracts and Sicilian Cavaliers, Cataphracts should always win because they look cooler.

    • @ejnaygfantzcg
      @ejnaygfantzcg 3 роки тому +6

      Other way around :P

    • @michaelandreipalon359
      @michaelandreipalon359 3 роки тому +2

      Hey, what happened to the Knight and Paladin?

    • @Nico-kd7uz
      @Nico-kd7uz 3 роки тому +6

      @@michaelandreipalon359 there is not sicilian paladin but would have been fun to compare non elite cata with the sicilian knight

    • @benjaminbundy-weishaupt5912
      @benjaminbundy-weishaupt5912 3 роки тому +20

      I wouldn't bet against a Sicilian when death is on the line

    • @IammAdriian
      @IammAdriian 3 роки тому +1

      I agree @Betrer Olthorion

  • @johntitor1256
    @johntitor1256 3 роки тому +440

    "Cataphracts: negating your attack bonuses since 1999."
    - Spirit of the Law, 2016

    • @sauravtripathi4128
      @sauravtripathi4128 3 роки тому +19

      Actually, since 2000 (AoC)

    • @luggy9256
      @luggy9256 3 роки тому +4

      @@sauravtripathi4128 well I’ve now learnt something else new today, thanks for that haha

    • @RusskiBlusski
      @RusskiBlusski 3 роки тому +9

      @@sauravtripathi4128 Byzantines are one of the original civs from AoK though.

    • @BoazMoerman
      @BoazMoerman 3 роки тому +15

      @@RusskiBlusski Yes, but the bonus defense was only added in AoC.

    • @RusskiBlusski
      @RusskiBlusski 3 роки тому +4

      @@BoazMoerman I see, TIL I guess.

  • @The_Room_2_Doggys_Revenge
    @The_Room_2_Doggys_Revenge 3 роки тому +133

    that would be an interesting topic for a video : "Most broken conversions if civ bonuses applied to converted units"

    • @tom.walder
      @tom.walder 3 роки тому +3

      Seconded

    • @stalinbulldog
      @stalinbulldog 3 роки тому +14

      Sicilian War Elephants (or even Battle Elephants) seem like a big winner to me. Halbs absolutely shred Elephants due to bonus damage but those HP pools are massive.

    • @zeroyuki92
      @zeroyuki92 3 роки тому +2

      @@stalinbulldog Sadly they still don't get heresy, so yeah still easily countered by monks.

    • @sirtaelellevalerie1056
      @sirtaelellevalerie1056 3 роки тому +6

      Frankish elite war elephant.

    • @jefffinkbonner9551
      @jefffinkbonner9551 3 роки тому +8

      Not the most broken but 11 range Briton rattan archers sound annoying AF to deal with.

  • @Bloodark124
    @Bloodark124 3 роки тому +374

    Tell us SOTL - did you use this for your thesis? We’ll be disappointed if AOE2 is not part of your thesis

  • @ericpdossantos7869
    @ericpdossantos7869 3 роки тому +282

    I never noticed that cataphracts are left handed

    • @JimRFF
      @JimRFF 3 роки тому +31

      Hey, me too haha... I don't know why that stuck out in this video more than ever before, but I think something about seeing the cataphract and cavalier side-by-side holding their swords in opposite hands made my subconscious brain uncomfortable haha... but in terms of game design, I suppose it does provide a possible way to quickly identify a cataphract vs a cavalier on the battlefield at a quick glance

    • @vitaobatera
      @vitaobatera 3 роки тому +1

      I'd prefer watching them attack with the unit's back facing the target than this tho =(
      Southpaws should have been banned from the Bizantine Empire... lol

    • @just1689
      @just1689 3 роки тому +1

      @
      Eric P dos Santos that is why left handed people live shorter lives

    • @light_david7
      @light_david7 3 роки тому +13

      They are, aren't they... Wierd. I remember in the original game the knights would switch hands in which they held their swords and shields so that the shield always was towards the player/screen. I thought you just saw a cataphract riding towards the right side of the screen, but I checked, and they are consistantly left handed.

    • @tkdjimmyify
      @tkdjimmyify 2 роки тому +2

      cool to see some southpaw representation

  • @BarbarianGod
    @BarbarianGod 3 роки тому +77

    The Byzantines made a classic blunder tho! Never go against a Sicilian when death is on the line!

  • @C12H22O11rush
    @C12H22O11rush 3 роки тому +105

    Flaming camel with +50 bonus damage vs cavalry forgotten again ... :(

    • @luggy9256
      @luggy9256 3 роки тому +20

      Haha a fine point, for the 3 people that have tried to make them work, they’ll never succeed against Sicilians...

    • @BarbarianGod
      @BarbarianGod 3 роки тому +13

      Never go against a Sicilian when death is on the line!

  • @encoreperformance1081
    @encoreperformance1081 3 роки тому +55

    Hey Spirit Of The Law, Guys Here.

  • @sacker987
    @sacker987 3 роки тому +138

    If Spirit of the Law is not awarded an honorary spot in Hidden Cup 4, then I'M NOT WATCHING GOSH DANGIT

    • @mattender8323
      @mattender8323 3 роки тому +5

      As an analyst?

    • @abaddou1
      @abaddou1 3 роки тому +24

      I hope he would co-cast a game or two with T90

    • @ramsessiereveld2824
      @ramsessiereveld2824 3 роки тому +15

      Spirit of the law should be a hero name, he is a hero to us all! *salute*

    • @aendranireho6038
      @aendranireho6038 3 роки тому +11

      I believe SOTL or T90 said it, while SOTL knows a lot about the background mechanics of the game, he's an average player.
      He'd probably get crushed by the players of HC4 :'(
      But seeing him talk in a T90 steam would be pretty funny

    • @alejandroromero6464
      @alejandroromero6464 3 роки тому

      He should in fact be recognized as a hero of Age fo empires 2.

  • @thewolf7668
    @thewolf7668 3 роки тому +68

    Cataphracts and Sicilian Halberdeirs fighting
    My pc: So you have chosen.. Death.

    • @jorrynmacris9824
      @jorrynmacris9824 3 роки тому

      Haha this is funny and i don't wanna be like cringe and like misunderstanding the joke, but technically the game is calculated on their servers not your computer...

    • @vitaobatera
      @vitaobatera 3 роки тому +1

      @@jorrynmacris9824 Not on Skirmishes... And before DE2, online games were hosted by a player, not run on a server...

    • @TsukimuraMidori
      @TsukimuraMidori 3 роки тому

      Yeah, there's a reason my desktop tanked.

  • @TheAtherion
    @TheAtherion 3 роки тому +31

    Watching the lone Cataphract shred the pikemen is just the best x))

    • @arcan762
      @arcan762 3 роки тому

      it had boosted HP

    • @xShifty38x
      @xShifty38x 3 роки тому +2

      Still just as glorious even with the boosted health

  • @andrewcyrbag
    @andrewcyrbag 3 роки тому

    Why has it taken me this long to find your channel? I'm offended youtube hasn't sent me here sooner. This is the channel I never knew I needed.

  • @SonaraRuna
    @SonaraRuna 3 роки тому +34

    While this was interesting, the most interesting thing I noticed from this video was that camels are much taller than the horse-mounted units.

    • @supermaster2012
      @supermaster2012 3 роки тому +7

      Camels are taller than horses...

    • @ReeperRiopel
      @ReeperRiopel 3 роки тому +5

      Yeah irl camels are huge

    • @luggy9256
      @luggy9256 3 роки тому +2

      Camels are bigger than all but the largest of draft horses

  • @franpschorr3646
    @franpschorr3646 3 роки тому +10

    Great vid, would love to see a vid going over all the cases of “trample” damage in the game (including elephants and Slav inf). I have no idea how far they can reach, and if there are any weird interactions.

  • @Amadeus8484
    @Amadeus8484 3 роки тому +14

    "NEVER GO IN AGAINST A SICILIAN WHEN DEATH IS ON THE LINE HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!" (Falls over and dies.)

  • @benstephens4488
    @benstephens4488 3 роки тому +29

    7:25 did anyone else think that the camels look massive compared to the other units

    • @stalinbulldog
      @stalinbulldog 3 роки тому

      They tower over the dunes - it's why they're called the galleons of the desert... maybe, or maybe it's for that other reason.

    • @metalisamp189
      @metalisamp189 3 роки тому +6

      Camels are way larger and taller than horses, so basically it is that.

    • @bushido791
      @bushido791 3 роки тому

      @@metalisamp189 this

  • @simonc3639
    @simonc3639 3 роки тому

    congratulations on 300 thousand subscribers big dog, you earned it

  • @bbrake
    @bbrake 3 роки тому

    man, I don't even play this game anymore, I barely played it to begin with, but I keep coming back to these videos. Just a chill bunch of numbers

  • @thewavewarden3315
    @thewavewarden3315 3 роки тому +362

    SotL still believes in the moon. What a sheep

    • @Duke_of_Lorraine
      @Duke_of_Lorraine 3 роки тому +55

      The true story is that when NASA asked Stanley Kubrick to fake the moon landing, Kubrick wanted it so much to look real that he asked NASA to do it for real then shoot on location.

    • @andregon4366
      @andregon4366 3 роки тому +3

      I don't even believe you're real.

    • @VeryPeeved
      @VeryPeeved 3 роки тому +15

      @@Duke_of_Lorraine no, no, they built the soundstage in outer space to make it look more real, and now it orbits the earth.

    • @agihammerthief8953
      @agihammerthief8953 3 роки тому +24

      The Moon was faked by Sumerian priests so they could invent another deity and get more donations

    • @jorrynmacris9824
      @jorrynmacris9824 3 роки тому +2

      Yeah i mean obviously bill gates made it with his 5G reptilians that go around raping people. Those guys on facebook are so genuine and they care about us, not about their bank account.

  • @siimkruusmann3695
    @siimkruusmann3695 3 роки тому

    just today i completed Bari campaign and wanted to do some research on the unic unit, and just today you post the right video

  • @UnDeaDCyBorg
    @UnDeaDCyBorg 3 роки тому +21

    Cataphract light performance for the price of one chevalier upgrade looks like a good deal compared to the insane cost stack that is elite Cataphracts with Logistica.

    • @jefffinkbonner9551
      @jefffinkbonner9551 3 роки тому +1

      Luckily on a recent patch the costs for both elite cataphract and logistica were reduced some

  • @Sosuke0727
    @Sosuke0727 3 роки тому +7

    The most math intensive video on this channel, ever. . .
    Even though Don't like math, except when it comes to games

    • @lagg1e
      @lagg1e 3 роки тому +1

      You must have forgotten the wheelbarrow and handcart videos

    • @AlessAbreu
      @AlessAbreu 3 роки тому +1

      You must be new here

    • @Miravoi
      @Miravoi 3 роки тому +1

      You haven't heard about the video about the lone villager chopping the wood of the whole map.

    • @Sosuke0727
      @Sosuke0727 3 роки тому

      @@AlessAbreu I must be new here because I am here since Chinese overview 😒

    • @Sosuke0727
      @Sosuke0727 3 роки тому

      @@lagg1e Sometimes I fall asleep while listening it 😬

  • @erikkarlsson9843
    @erikkarlsson9843 3 роки тому

    You have been waiting for this matchup your whole life! :D

  • @mahdi5301
    @mahdi5301 3 роки тому

    hey spirit, i congratulate you for 300k members. The aoe2 community owes you, because of your efforts.

  • @GoldenRoyal5
    @GoldenRoyal5 3 роки тому +3

    Congrats on 300k

  • @PablitoAndCo
    @PablitoAndCo 3 роки тому +73

    Sicilian cataphracts: the perfect counter to samurais and mameluks.
    No logistica, so they're worse against karambit warriors though.

    • @vitaobatera
      @vitaobatera 3 роки тому +1

      At least now they could enjoy eating cannoli and panelle!!

    • @bigdiccmarty9335
      @bigdiccmarty9335 3 роки тому

      Not like they *need* logistica to be effective vs karambit coin

    • @Real_MisterSir
      @Real_MisterSir 3 роки тому +1

      also remember that logistica is in effect as soon as you are fighting in groups larget than 1v1. Essentially logistica in fights of more than 3v3 units adds 10dmg per hit on top of their base attack, which is quite nuts when you think about it.

  • @sokolovremwwii2205
    @sokolovremwwii2205 3 роки тому

    "ILickToesAtNight". Made my day. Awesome video, as always! Keep up the good work!

  • @ChewingGumFlavor
    @ChewingGumFlavor 3 роки тому +26

    4:25 You mean the remaining 16 is negated by Cataphract's "anti anti-cavalry" armor. Not anti-cavalry armor.

    • @LightKnight_Age_Of
      @LightKnight_Age_Of 3 роки тому +3

      Yeah I was confused too

    • @orisofikusuma7843
      @orisofikusuma7843 3 роки тому +4

      you mean, "anti anti-cavalry cavalry" armor?

    • @Orkimtor
      @Orkimtor 3 роки тому

      While I see your point, it is also called melee-armor and not anti melee-armor ;)

    • @orisofikusuma7843
      @orisofikusuma7843 3 роки тому +4

      still a same thing. anti-cavalry armor means negate damage from anti cavalry damage output. "anti anti-cavalry" armor means an armor which came from unit that had resistance to anti-cavalry bonus damage. not a big deal

  • @lemmonsinmyeyes
    @lemmonsinmyeyes 3 роки тому +14

    ILickToesAtNight is such a good cat name lol

    • @tonyc2638
      @tonyc2638 3 роки тому +1

      I think that's T90's cat... He just told a story on stream about his cat licking his toes.

    • @michaelandreipalon359
      @michaelandreipalon359 3 роки тому

      That's a weird name for a cat.

  • @Badboyben1422
    @Badboyben1422 3 роки тому +24

    Now all we need is to give Byz Cata's Bloodlines, please!

    • @luggy9256
      @luggy9256 3 роки тому +4

      And they’ll be unstoppable, remember they also have paladin...
      Question is what would be a bigger buff to byzantines bloodlines or blast furnace?

    • @Badboyben1422
      @Badboyben1422 3 роки тому +7

      @@luggy9256 Bloodlines would def be a better buff! What byz player uses Paladins instead of Cata's anyway?

    • @arcan762
      @arcan762 3 роки тому +2

      @@Badboyben1422 Depends what they are up against. Paladins do MUCH better vs mass archers than Cataphracts

    • @qualitycontentchannel4443
      @qualitycontentchannel4443 3 роки тому +3

      @@arcan762 ACtually, a mix of cataphracts and Paladins is best combo vs archers. Some archers will target paladins, taking some hits off of the cataphracts.. then once they get in melee range, archers health is no match for byzantines trample damage. Usually if you tech into Byzantines Cataphracts (unless you are playing vs a civ who doesn't get cav) you must also tech into another stable unit to deal with other horses, which is paladin (more than just other horses, so more uses) and camels. Usually standard unit comp for byzantine's is Trash units + camels/paladin + Cataphract + a siege unit. Very good civ honestly

    • @Badboyben1422
      @Badboyben1422 3 роки тому

      @@arcan762 true that palas do have more peirce armor than a Cata's but with more damage from Cata Trample Damage affecting groups once Cata's get into it they are taking out more faster than reg Palas.

  • @oogewoo2165
    @oogewoo2165 3 роки тому

    Literally listen to you every morning on the way to work so I can be prepared for when I get home 😂

  • @sauravtripathi4128
    @sauravtripathi4128 3 роки тому +13

    Well the most simple reason for superiority of Cataphracts is:
    1. It is a Paladin equivalent by definition, not a Cavalier equivalent.
    2. It is produced from Castles.
    3. It costs a ton to upgrade.
    4. It is meant to have a different counter, just like Champions.

    • @stephencarroll4681
      @stephencarroll4681 2 роки тому

      What counter? Cataphracts don't really have one lol

    • @BunnyOnASnuman
      @BunnyOnASnuman 2 роки тому

      @@stephencarroll4681 anti infantry units and archers, ironically

    • @NoMoreCrumbs
      @NoMoreCrumbs 2 роки тому

      Heavy cavalry also does okay, if you have access to paladins. Cavalry archer does well with kiting

    • @weswolverine
      @weswolverine Рік тому

      Paladins stomp cataphracts tho, and elephants

  • @adnanhuzaifa6391
    @adnanhuzaifa6391 3 роки тому

    300k subs congratz manh really love your content

  • @AgentNightfall
    @AgentNightfall 3 роки тому +1

    I don't even play AoE2 but your videos are fun to watch/listen to

  • @ChocolateMilkCultLeader
    @ChocolateMilkCultLeader 3 роки тому

    Jean Paul been an OG patreon man. Respect

  • @eloymitre6226
    @eloymitre6226 3 роки тому +44

    the Byzantines were everyone's first love in age! and the years go by and they are still the best civilization!! ✌🏻❤️🇦🇷

    • @yajurka
      @yajurka 3 роки тому

      No, Japanese are the first love.

    • @acentialpapd9418
      @acentialpapd9418 3 роки тому +1

      Dude Mongols were my first love by far.

    • @dogeofgreatness2222
      @dogeofgreatness2222 3 роки тому

      Nah the Persians are the first love with dem thicc boys.

    • @acentialpapd9418
      @acentialpapd9418 3 роки тому

      @@dogeofgreatness2222 dat true too , when I realised they have a 600 hp 24 attack unit I played Barbarossa 6 only to convert these boys

    • @dogeofgreatness2222
      @dogeofgreatness2222 3 роки тому

      @@acentialpapd9418
      Same man. I also played Barbrossa 6 again and again as a child. And my love for AOE2 sparked a love for history and for my intrests in Iranian and Indian history goes to Thicc boys

  • @RancorSnp
    @RancorSnp 3 роки тому +36

    Imagine by an accident finding the video 10 seconds after going public, and finding there are already two comments, from hours ago, down there smh.

  • @Tamizushi
    @Tamizushi 3 роки тому +43

    Is ILickToesAtNight also a lawyer? If they are, they might suspiciously claim not to be a cat.

  • @cactuscoe9096
    @cactuscoe9096 3 роки тому +16

    As complicated as the relationship between the Eastern Roman Empire and Sicily

    • @CarvaxIV
      @CarvaxIV 3 роки тому

      The Great Alexios vs the sly Robert Guiscard!

  • @thebirthdayskeleton2927
    @thebirthdayskeleton2927 3 роки тому +1

    I swear, you're one of the funniest youtubers around.

  • @chivitogomez9877
    @chivitogomez9877 3 роки тому +6

    Here's an idea for a new video: Sicillian Condottiero vs all those units that got anti-Condottiero damage to offset their anti-infantry resistance to HC.

  • @LFish
    @LFish 3 роки тому

    Just noticed:
    Congrats to 300k subs :)

  • @IsaacWrightMusic
    @IsaacWrightMusic 3 роки тому

    I love this, as soon as you started explaining it I was like "Oh yeah of course, that's genuinely really interesting, I actually would very much like to know what the results are"
    Which is all your fault to begin with, I used to be content with being a decidedly mediocre AOE II player before you showed up with all your interesting and insightful videos. I blame you.

  • @ITACHIULQUIORA
    @ITACHIULQUIORA 3 роки тому

    SoL new video, stop everything, press like and watch a piece of art, never get enough of your videos
    Thanks lot

  • @Duke_of_Lorraine
    @Duke_of_Lorraine 3 роки тому +29

    Does the sicilian bonus also protect against the coustillier's charge ?

    • @SilverKnightPCs
      @SilverKnightPCs 3 роки тому +1

      I've been wondering the same thing

    • @ChewingGumFlavor
      @ChewingGumFlavor 3 роки тому

      No. Because coustillier no longer does bonus damage to archer or anyone after February hotfix

    • @luggy9256
      @luggy9256 3 роки тому +8

      @@ChewingGumFlavor they’re wondering if the charge itself counts as bonus damage, but I’m going to assume no...

    • @petrorlov2599
      @petrorlov2599 3 роки тому

      @@luggy9256 yeah, I would guess so too, since bonus damage is usually not shown in unit stats

    • @harishsundar3409
      @harishsundar3409 3 роки тому +3

      No they don't Coustillier attack is not a bonus damage. It is taken like forging. It is added in the stats. So it is not negated

  • @mathieulavenant9628
    @mathieulavenant9628 3 роки тому +2

    Hey, Spirit of the law, thanks for the content you share !
    I ve been wondering for a long time : do the formations have a real impact in battle ? (Exept splits vs onagers)
    Keep up the good work !

  • @bonchachan6061
    @bonchachan6061 3 роки тому

    I've never played Age of Empires and am never going to but those videos are very fun to watch.

  • @jimr3633
    @jimr3633 3 роки тому

    Uhh, Do you do Fusion 360 tutorials, too? Your voice, high quality videos, clear explanations, and the ability to understand and describe math concepts is outstanding (in both cases?)

  • @PatronusGaming83
    @PatronusGaming83 3 роки тому

    Great video. Given the timeline we are currently in, I would not be surprised if a cat was a master AoE2 player. 😁

  • @adamgasiorek3557
    @adamgasiorek3557 3 роки тому

    Thanks. I’ve found myself more interested in exploring the game than playing it lately.

  • @Vengeange_
    @Vengeange_ 3 роки тому

    Fun fact: at 6:25 you can see how the cavalier attacks with his right hand, and the cataphract with his left hand, despite both holding the sword in their left hand, on their profile picture

  • @crownofglory1264
    @crownofglory1264 3 роки тому

    Spirit of the Law videos are good for mental health.

  • @derekulricgutzlaffilarzi5573
    @derekulricgutzlaffilarzi5573 3 роки тому

    Was wondering, what about a video ranking the civs castles/towers? Keep those samurais runnin, spirit!

  • @aniruddhbhatkal1834
    @aniruddhbhatkal1834 3 роки тому

    That joke about the moon landings is hilarious! Please work that into your intro!

  • @JimRFF
    @JimRFF 3 роки тому +1

    "Big thanks to patrons... and ILickToesAtNight, which I thought was a bit of an odd name at first, until I realized, they're a cat. So, that totally checks out."
    SotL MVP... answering the real hard-hitting questions for us

  • @charlesbackstrom6571
    @charlesbackstrom6571 Рік тому +1

    did i just watch that aztec monk turn into a european one when it picked up the relic?

  • @Orcawarrior2
    @Orcawarrior2 3 роки тому +3

    Honestly I have so many questions about the conversion rules. For example, what if I convert a goth barracks? Does it work faster? Can I train huskarls? Really I guess the difference is whether the bonus is applied as a global thing in post or assigned to each unit and stored there

  • @z911empire
    @z911empire 3 роки тому

    I barely understand any of this and it’s such a good watch

  • @enrique16ish
    @enrique16ish 3 роки тому

    seriously, bout that funny intro and the logic of silician vs a unique cancer, it was a good reason to see why people pick silicans tbh

  • @theknightduck8590
    @theknightduck8590 3 роки тому +3

    Hello Spirit ur vids are nice

  • @alejandroromero6464
    @alejandroromero6464 3 роки тому

    You really know your math, man. Congratulations.

  • @Wobbuffet0
    @Wobbuffet0 3 роки тому +1

    Yay. I can't wait for your Civ overview, and then they will patch the game and change it immediately after you release your video.

  • @HazmanFTW
    @HazmanFTW 3 роки тому +4

    Huh, answers to questions i didn't know i had. I wonder what the most complex in a standard game, matchup could be, if it's not this?

  • @amitvishwakarma7210
    @amitvishwakarma7210 3 роки тому +1

    We need a video on those broken conversion stats that you talked about too...!😄

  • @WJen8
    @WJen8 3 роки тому +2

    I learned more here than in some of my real classes 😂

  • @kimberlylewis5820
    @kimberlylewis5820 3 роки тому +3

    Thank you spirit for answering this. I was curious if everyone’s favorite 1999 unique unit competes in 2021.

    • @luggy9256
      @luggy9256 3 роки тому +2

      Although as someone else pointed out in another comment, cataphracts didn’t get their resistance or logistica till 2000

  • @rodrigomachado5291
    @rodrigomachado5291 3 роки тому +2

    Please, more videos on Byzantines and Cataphracts! Maybe a Byzantine strategy video? PLSSSSS!

  • @AgeofNoob
    @AgeofNoob 3 роки тому +5

    I wish Cataphracts were more viable so we could see them on Pro play more often! :D

    • @qualitycontentchannel4443
      @qualitycontentchannel4443 3 роки тому +4

      Sort of agree, although I think they have their place in the game already. Love the Byzantines.

  • @RaggaDruida
    @RaggaDruida 3 роки тому +7

    What about Condottieri? An Italians ally can give them to anybody they want...

  • @chronographer
    @chronographer 3 роки тому +1

    4:20 - Forget the theoretical Sicilian cataphract, what about the Sicilian condottiero?
    Although doing the maths I think that only makes a difference in the Condo v Cannon galleon matchup. No other gunpowder unit has more than +10 vs infantry.

  • @Gigas0101
    @Gigas0101 3 роки тому

    In this video, only two units actually fight. The video is eight minutes long, and that is very good.

  • @nickbz1303
    @nickbz1303 3 роки тому

    Have you done a video about absolute population effectiveness? I feel an examination of paladins for generic civs vs cataphracts, vs war elephants would be an interesting analysis for you to tackle.

  • @Jacks_Suffocating_Nihilism
    @Jacks_Suffocating_Nihilism 3 роки тому +2

    300k, nice man.

  • @obesechicken13
    @obesechicken13 3 роки тому

    I know I asked last time but I'd also be interested in an arambai comparison from last patch to this one.

  • @KaiserFranzGaming
    @KaiserFranzGaming 3 роки тому +1

    I'd love to see an analysis which explains how 1 of 2 identical units fighting each other wins and the other dies.
    Like a 2 scouts fighting in 1v1... is it pure RNG? Or is the outcome predetermined? Does the game's internal clock favour one player at certain time?
    I did some basic testing and if for example 10 blue scouts fought 10 red scouts, all of the red scouts won. Same applies to any other units (champions vs champions etc.).
    Another testing round it's the blue color that won... I can do more testing myself, but I'd love Spirit Of The Law to do it and share results with us ^^

    • @niksutliff
      @niksutliff 3 роки тому

      MikeEmpires has a series on all units vs unique units, generic, etc

    • @KaiserFranzGaming
      @KaiserFranzGaming 3 роки тому

      @@niksutliff I've seen many of those videos, but I probably didn't explain myself well. For example 10 groups of units fighting 1vs1 have the same outcome at certain time. 10 blue scouts die, 10 red scouts survive with 3 HP etc.

    • @Jacks_Suffocating_Nihilism
      @Jacks_Suffocating_Nihilism 3 роки тому +1

      IIRC, it used to be determined by player position in the lobby. Lobby host had engine priority. Applied not only to first strikes but also unit pathing for the purposes of blocking.
      DE has tinkered with this several times now to remove the manipulable element of lobby position. Based on your testing, it seems likely that the game just randomizes priority at the start of a match.

  • @rishi5856
    @rishi5856 4 місяці тому

    Been playing AOE2 since it came out and only learned what exactly trample damage is today

  • @jishb2505
    @jishb2505 3 роки тому

    'You'll find in Age of Empires 2' assuming we'll ever crunch those numbers with a gem like you walking around

  • @R3stor
    @R3stor 3 роки тому

    Joker: "This is what happens when an unstoppable force meets an immovable object."

  • @emilyding2496
    @emilyding2496 3 роки тому +75

    Spirit of the law: MATH MATH MATH
    me, a third grader, who doesn't understand all the math, but knows the main idea: Cataphracts reign supreme
    Edit: Why did this blow up?

    • @Usuario459
      @Usuario459 3 роки тому +1

      Ok

    • @emilyding2496
      @emilyding2496 3 роки тому +1

      @@Usuario459 yesssssss

    • @HandsomeGamerGuy
      @HandsomeGamerGuy 3 роки тому

      Then you're on a very wholesome and good Channel.

    • @emilyding2496
      @emilyding2496 3 роки тому

      @@HandsomeGamerGuy , oh yes, defiantly, without he's videos, I have no idea how I would survive under intense quarantine pressure.

    • @sinnvollerkommentar263
      @sinnvollerkommentar263 3 роки тому

      No complex math here? Only divisions but that should be in 3th grade

  • @m13579k
    @m13579k 3 роки тому +2

    I've been playing aoe 2 since original release and had no idea elevation bonus was a thing...this is why i stick to single player.

  • @thomasneumann8497
    @thomasneumann8497 3 роки тому +1

    There seem to be quite a few left handed units in AOE2 (at least both Cataphracts and Halbs)

  • @camyron
    @camyron 3 роки тому

    It's things like this that make me think that units should have an attack speed stat clearly visible, and to have unit upgrades include describing changes to their attack speed.

  • @陳柏安-q5k
    @陳柏安-q5k 3 роки тому

    nice update :) very interesting

  • @despicableglowee5207
    @despicableglowee5207 3 роки тому

    "I lick toes at night"
    -Spirit of the Toes, 2021

  • @tkzsfen
    @tkzsfen 3 роки тому +1

    Aren't we going to talk about the instant monk metamorphosis in 3:23?

    • @NelsonSKA
      @NelsonSKA 3 роки тому

      Aren't there sprite for the american monk carrying a relic?

  • @MarcioLiao
    @MarcioLiao 3 роки тому

    The Cavalier is one of my fav models from the game.

  • @KaoticPhoenix
    @KaoticPhoenix 3 роки тому

    2:06 doesn't the 25% only apply to base attack and not bonus damage as well. So instead the order for the halberdier would go
    10 X 1.25 = 12.5 (base)
    - 5 = 7.5 (armour)
    + 16 = 23.5 (bonus)

  • @rubensteeb458
    @rubensteeb458 3 роки тому

    Could you make a video about the best timing to add trade in late game? How much gold should be left to mine, to sustain military production and still keep producing trade carts? Would be an interesting topic i think

  • @rocko0214
    @rocko0214 3 роки тому

    I totally understood everything senpai said. Totally.

  • @Binarokaro
    @Binarokaro 3 роки тому +1

    Holy crap, what a clash of the titans. It's good to know though that in the end, cataphracts still reign supreme over the cavaliers. I think if the Sicilian cavaliers had been equal or greater than the cataphracts, it would have definitely be a big reason to nerf

  • @leonardorivelorivelo9253
    @leonardorivelorivelo9253 3 роки тому +3

    Remember that both Civs are descendents from Rome, i wonder if the Roman empire Somehow gets added they would have a shitton of Damage Reduction and bonus damage

    • @supermaster2012
      @supermaster2012 3 роки тому +1

      Byz IS Rome, they were literally called Basileia Rhomaion (Roman Empire). Byzantine Empire is a modern (less than 200 years old) nomenclature.

    • @leonardorivelorivelo9253
      @leonardorivelorivelo9253 3 роки тому

      @@supermaster2012 By Rome i mean its western part who fell. Thanks for the facts tho

    • @ChewingGumFlavor
      @ChewingGumFlavor 3 роки тому +1

      In game Sicilians are Normans, migrated down there from France though.

    • @Manouil_III
      @Manouil_III 3 роки тому

      Sicilians civ, represent the Norman rule of Sicily tho.

    • @gregoriotauro4469
      @gregoriotauro4469 3 роки тому

      Yes, but it cannot be claimed that the people of Southern Italy are either Scandinavian or French, just like it can't be said that British people are Italians because they were in the Roman empire.
      Normans in Sicily adopted local customs in a flash and were known by their Italian or italianised names.

  • @KlystiEvangelist
    @KlystiEvangelist 3 роки тому +2

    Isn't the Elite Cataphract's damage against infantry 16 not 12? I thought Cata was 12 and Elite Cata 16. I respect your vast knowledge just heard conflicting info.

  • @WikiHL
    @WikiHL 3 роки тому

    Huzzah! Spirit of the Math strikes again!

  • @AntZen85
    @AntZen85 3 роки тому +21

    Wait, Age of Empires 2 is a historical strategy game based on real life. And notice how every AoE2 map isn’t a globe but a 2D flat square with an edge.
    Flat Earth confirmed. Take that globeheads!

  • @brlatv69
    @brlatv69 3 роки тому

    SOTL I would love to see a video of of some really broken Civ Bonus, Unit and Tech combos, if that is possible.

  • @TeaTimeMr
    @TeaTimeMr 3 роки тому +2

    There should be a mode/Mod where you can create your own perfect Civilization by choosing:
    - The Civ (Bonuses and Techtree)
    - The Elite Unit
    - The Castle Age Unique Technology
    - The Imperial Unique Technology
    - The Team Bonus
    Should be pretty fun!
    Did i forget sth?

  • @DerCossack
    @DerCossack 3 роки тому +3

    Is it just me or are the orange halberdiers attacking faster than the red ones (especially in the single cata- cavalier side by side)?

  • @darios.r.3202
    @darios.r.3202 3 роки тому

    Hey! Congratulations for your videos, they´re fantastic... I was wondering if there are scenarios where we could use game theory in our favour... and especially, would you do a video about that? Thank youu