Mackenzie Buchter I get that u mean she’s not a great singer, but I think it was awesome lmao :) they got the real actress for her and she was great at acting and she’s a very sweet person! I bet she was awesome to work with
@@mackenziebuchter8406 Okay, I get where you're coming from. But on the other hand, if they did a spider-man musical and got Tom Holland to be in it, I don't think that would draw away from how amazing that actually is.
While I don’t agree with you on most of these, I appreciate how high avpsy was. It’s truly an underrated show. Side note, I’ve never seen twisted so low on anyone’s list.
When it comes to just ranking Starkid shows I can never choose my number 1, but when you add TBC to it, Spies Are Forever is so far ahead of all the Starkid shows for me. It's just the best musical
I don’t agree with a lot of the placements but y e s Let It Out is so underrated and I’m so happy to see appreciation for it! Also very enjoyable video!!
Sara Lehman Wooooow, trying to get Spies in first place huh?????? I support but woooooow (But I love that idea because I can barely think of serious scenes in these shows)
I don't completely agree with this list, but I gotta say you're the first person I've seen put TTO, Firebringer, and TGWDLM so low, which I do agree with, and the absolute BDE of putting Ani over AVPM and even Twisted
Yay! I totally agree with Spies being number one that show is incredible. Personally i would have Black Friday and then Starship as numbers 2 and three, mostly because i've never actually seen any Marvel/DC movies so HMB wasn't as funny as it could have been to me, but i still love the songs a lot. And yes Brian's voice is literally so good and he deserves so much more appreciation.
Weefwafer I mean to be fair, Black Friday wasn’t out when I made this. But also, I literally live and breathe Batman, so I’m pretty sure I still wouldn’t change my mind.
@@LyleTheWaterAquaticGuy my friends are the same. I'm a huge Harry Potter fan so no matter what shows come out AVPM is always gonna be pretty high up my ranking 😂
I love Ani because it works without watching the movies, I’ve only played LEGO Star Wars, seen a bit of the pod racing scene, been on Star Tours, and watched a parody of the franchise put on by high schoolers, yet I still understand the references and think it’s funny. It manages to work despite being familiar with the source material.
Honestly same. I’ve only seen like 3 full Star Wars movies (all of which have been of the recent run). But I LOVE Star Wars parodies and so I know a lot from those. I also don’t get why people say that “you need to know about Star Wars” as if that makes it bad? It’s a parody, that’s the point. And you equally need to know about HP and Disney to understand AVP and Twisted. Just because I person doesn’t know enough about Star Wars to get the jokes doesn’t mean they aren’t good jokes. Thank you for coming to my Ted Talk.
I absolutely love this channel. It has lots of unpopular opinions and it’s good that you can still put things on UA-cam to do with starkid without be scared that people will hate on you. Luv that😂
It makes me so happy that so many of Brian Holden’s characters are your favorites because I love him so much and he doesn’t get nearly enough screen time in the shows.
Watching this was an emotional rollercoaster. My jaw dropped in shock at Twisted and Starship being so low but I cheered when Ani and HMB were so high. Every time I was surprised by the next placement and I respect that!!
I have NEVER seen anyone else rank Ani that high! It’s honestly one of my favorites from Starkid. I also love that you ranked your favorite things of each show, so it felt less like a comparison.
My ten would look so different to yours! i still respect your opinion though. (i have rlly unpopular opinions) It would be: 1-Spies Are Forevee 2-TGWDLM 3-Firebringer 4-TTO 5-Solve It Squad 6-AVPS 7-AVPM 8-Twisted 9-Starship 10-AVPSY
Hideous creatures can't be my favourie song from starship as long as Kick it up a notch is there but I like the appreciation because I still love that song!
mamd: not watched but i like coreys song, kinda scared to watch because i don’t know if any of the jokes are gonna be a bit outdated if you get what i mean firebringer: would definitely place it higher than you did, i love zazz, climate change is my favourite song but into the night is good twisted: i’m angry at how low this is, best music, i love princess, happy ending is my favourite starkid song ever starship: i’m not patient enough to watch but hideous creatures and kick it up a notch are amazing songs avpm: maybe it’s just the nostalgia but i love this show, dracos my favourite he’s so funny, going back to hogwarts is my favourite song because i’m basic tto: i fucking love this show definitely the funniest, upopular opinion but my favourite song is speedrun, i cant pick a favourite character theyre all so good tgwdlm: my favourite 100%, best song is inevitable but i do love let it out, macnamara is my favourite person ever but idk if it’s just cos i love jeff (tied up my heart is one of my other favourites which is VERY unpopular) avpsy: worst of the avp trilogy, i was is so good i wish darrens mic worked i might also be the only one who absolutely loves get in my mouth, again draco is the best ani: i don’t like star wars and i find the not singing but there being music really weird the dancing just looks awkward i don’t want to watch it (from what i’ve seen it is really funny and without the video the songs are good i just can’t handle it i’m sorry) i’ve not watched any tcb musicals i really need to get on that avps: best of avp trilogy, days of summer manages to make me miss school(crazy) and harry freakin potter is iconic i don’t need to say who my favourite is i think you can tell (umbridge is really funny but i don’t like how they portrayed her it feels kinda transphobic but it was 2010 so... i idk how to feel about tho cos i can’t speak for the trans community (i’m cis) so if any trans people could tell me if they find it offensive please) hmb: also need to get around to watching but rouges are we and the american way are BOPS, robin is really funny from what i’ve seen gay spies??? why tf have i not watched this yet???? this video came out before black friday (i think?) but i’ll say what i think anyway: feast or famine is a bop i fucking love that song, i don’t know if i should like becky or not i think we’re meant to but idk (kim is the most beautiful woman i’ve ever seen tho and her voice is wonderful so maybe take me back is my favourite??? idk ok it’s so good) the whole santa goes to high school bit is fucking hilarious robert is so funny, linda is an icon, GARY AND MAN IN A HURRY ARE MY FAVOURITE CHARACTERS EVER. i’m sorry for how long this is it’s 1am and i’m having opinions. it’s definitely not coherent but yea
so, I was in complete agreement with the order, character and song...but then that changed because...well here's my order 12. MAMD 11. firebringer 10. twisted 9. TTO 8. Ani 7. holy musical b@man 6. avps 5. TGWDLM 4. avpsy 3. black Friday 2. avpm 1. starship (btw, I've never seen and TCB productions, so i can't rank them)
Okay but who’s doing the riff in “Not Alone”????? I’ve listened to that song like 50000 times and only now do u hear the gorgeous riff in the background! I keep replaying it to see who’s not singing the same words as everyone but I can’t see who it is! Does anyone know? I think it might be either Jaime (Ginny) or Bellatrix (I’m so sorry I just blanked on her actresses nameee! I’m horrible at remembering names lmao)
You and I are going to have to have a fearsome battle over Firebringer (just kidding I respect all your opinions). I will start with a comprehensive essay on why I love the show. *Ahem* I am a lesbian.
Holy heck, I disagreed with basically every point on this list. I'm almost impressed. No hate, though, your opinion is totally valid (also!!! Yes!!! AVPSY getting at least the bare minimum amount of love!).
I think this just means you like all the Brians of StarKid
Twisted being so far down on the list made my heart break,,, but, respect, homie♥️
Umm... Firebringer was *below* it!! I just bshjsygwvshbsjejvh
@@_veronica_r Why is that surprising? That's usually the case for most rankings I've seen.
Ikr it’s my favorite sk musical ;(
I love that they got the actress who played Luna Lovegood in the movies to play her in Senior year, that’s a power move if I’ve ever seen one
And it was not a good move 🤣
@@mackenziebuchter8406 why
Mackenzie Buchter I get that u mean she’s not a great singer, but I think it was awesome lmao :) they got the real actress for her and she was great at acting and she’s a very sweet person! I bet she was awesome to work with
@@mackenziebuchter8406 she can sing just not as well as the rest of the cast given that her profession is acting not singing
@@mackenziebuchter8406 Okay, I get where you're coming from. But on the other hand, if they did a spider-man musical and got Tom Holland to be in it, I don't think that would draw away from how amazing that actually is.
While I don’t agree with you on most of these, I appreciate how high avpsy was. It’s truly an underrated show.
Side note, I’ve never seen twisted so low on anyone’s list.
it would have been lower on mine :/
The idea for senior year is there, but its just the fact that they only had a few days to rehearse it with everybody there. Its not their fault 🥺
finally someone who appreciates into the night
Honestly one of my favorite Starkid songs that I just randomly sing for no reason 😂
It means a lot to me, and it's so gorgeous and powerful. The other contender for my favorite Firebringer song is Climate Change though (harmonies!)
OH MY GOD I FINALLY FOUND SOMEONE WHO LIKES 'HIDEOUS CREATURES' TOO
*seriously why does everyone hate that song, even nick has called it the worst starkid song ajsjajsj*
FINALLY SOMEONE ELSE WHO LOVES IT WHY DO THEY HATE IT THE INSTRUMENTS IN IT ARE KILLER
I don't understand why everyone hates that song. It's great
I like that song. Reminds me of my favorite song from Pocahontas. But less racist and genocide-y.
sanityisrelative ha
Also brian rosenthals voice is an absolute godsend thank you for appreciating it
Facts. Have you seen the compilations of him singing? I think they are by Evil King Arthur and I have watched them way too many times.
@@LyleTheWaterAquaticGuy i actually had not which is extremely surprising so thank you!!!!!
Missing you is the best song in avpm and the american way is the best song in hmb and im SO GLAD someone else finally agrees!!!
Right!
100% correct statement!
When it comes to just ranking Starkid shows I can never choose my number 1, but when you add TBC to it, Spies Are Forever is so far ahead of all the Starkid shows for me. It's just the best musical
Lise B your so right I don’t have the words to describe how much I love spies are forever and it need more appreciation!
Twisted???? So low???
I don’t agree with a lot of the placements but y e s Let It Out is so underrated and I’m so happy to see appreciation for it! Also very enjoyable video!!
I would be disappointed at how low Starship is, but I'm used to it. I love the HMB appreciation though. Everything about that show is amazing.
Personally Starship is my second-favorite show (after Spies) but I respect your placement and your Hideous Creatures recognition
HMB at #2
SO VALID
Seriously tho, HMB is so slept on. It's my personal favourite and it's mwah *chef's kiss*. We love this appreciation
HIDEOUS CREATURES, LET IT OUT AND SPY AGAIN RIGHTS YESSSSSSS
spies are forever finally getting the appreciation it deserves
you putting SAF as #1 was bold but correct
You should rank the shows based on how serious the serious parts of the shows are
Sara Lehman Wooooow, trying to get Spies in first place huh?????? I support but woooooow (But I love that idea because I can barely think of serious scenes in these shows)
I’d actually love to see this !!
would def watch
the first ranking where the trail to oregon is at the very bottom lmfao
@@harrywater456 but Black Friday
Omg finally someone who loves Everything Ends. It’s my favorite song from AVPSY and it’s upsetting just how under appreciated Everything Ends is
I don't completely agree with this list, but I gotta say you're the first person I've seen put TTO, Firebringer, and TGWDLM so low, which I do agree with, and the absolute BDE of putting Ani over AVPM and even Twisted
YESS THIS IS JUSTICE TO SPIES ARE FOREVER
So happy seeing someone put Ani so high up! It deserves a lot more recognition.
ANI AND AVPSY?? SO HIGH UP ON A LIST?? FINALLY!! THIS IS THE RANKING I HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR
I don't agree with Twisted being 11 (for me it's one of the best shows) but I totally agree with Spies are forever being number 1
Twisted on 11? Is and always will be the best!
Yay! I totally agree with Spies being number one that show is incredible. Personally i would have Black Friday and then Starship as numbers 2 and three, mostly because i've never actually seen any Marvel/DC movies so HMB wasn't as funny as it could have been to me, but i still love the songs a lot. And yes Brian's voice is literally so good and he deserves so much more appreciation.
Weefwafer I mean to be fair, Black Friday wasn’t out when I made this. But also, I literally live and breathe Batman, so I’m pretty sure I still wouldn’t change my mind.
@@LyleTheWaterAquaticGuy my friends are the same. I'm a huge Harry Potter fan so no matter what shows come out AVPM is always gonna be pretty high up my ranking 😂
HIDEOUS CREATURES SLAPS SO HARD THANK YOU SO MUCH
ABD LET IT OUT !!!
HMB APPRECIATION HOUR THANK U SO MCUJ
THE AMRICAN WAY IS A BANGER
I love Ani because it works without watching the movies, I’ve only played LEGO Star Wars, seen a bit of the pod racing scene, been on Star Tours, and watched a parody of the franchise put on by high schoolers, yet I still understand the references and think it’s funny. It manages to work despite being familiar with the source material.
Honestly same. I’ve only seen like 3 full Star Wars movies (all of which have been of the recent run). But I LOVE Star Wars parodies and so I know a lot from those. I also don’t get why people say that “you need to know about Star Wars” as if that makes it bad? It’s a parody, that’s the point. And you equally need to know about HP and Disney to understand AVP and Twisted. Just because I person doesn’t know enough about Star Wars to get the jokes doesn’t mean they aren’t good jokes. Thank you for coming to my Ted Talk.
FINALLY SOMEONE SAID HMB RIGHTS
Thank you! No one else notices or cares for Spy Again! The recorded version is even better than the stage version too. Best song ever.
I absolutely love this channel. It has lots of unpopular opinions and it’s good that you can still put things on UA-cam to do with starkid without be scared that people will hate on you. Luv that😂
It makes me so happy that so many of Brian Holden’s characters are your favorites because I love him so much and he doesn’t get nearly enough screen time in the shows.
Watching this was an emotional rollercoaster. My jaw dropped in shock at Twisted and Starship being so low but I cheered when Ani and HMB were so high. Every time I was surprised by the next placement and I respect that!!
AHHHHH I"m so so happy someone else thinks hmb is the best starkid show!!! It's my favorite ever I'm obsessed!
And everything ends hits me in the feels every time man
great format! i love how you included favorites from all of them. shows your appreciation of all of them, even the ones at the bottom :)
You're so right for ranking Ani so high. The choreography is mesmerizing.
SPIES ARE FOREVER YES thank you
I have NEVER seen anyone else rank Ani that high! It’s honestly one of my favorites from Starkid.
I also love that you ranked your favorite things of each show, so it felt less like a comparison.
So you’ve chosen Brian’s character in every show except for AVPSY. But Hagrid is the best?!
LAUREN LOPEZ IS MY LIFEBLOOD
Damn why is firebringer so low, it has amazing music and overall amazing production quality
Ahh yes Starkid fandom, the only place where Jar Jar Binks is someone’s fav character😂🤣😂
i am so in love with your editing style and therefore this channel
I subscribed as soon as HMB was second. It is my favourite 😊
thank you for giving hideous creatures rights its AMAZING
Hold up, you are placing Trail To Oregon higher than Twisted, Starship, and AVPM? I’m offended.
It’s real good
It’s what it deserves
You have starship placed higher than trail to oregon on your list? Or high in general? 🤣 jk respect man
*ranks Twisted 11th*
The Twisted Fandom: So, you have chosen Death
senior 👏year👏appreciation
me: hey, this list doesn’t seem too controversial so far-
*puts twisted at 11th*
me: *cracks knuckles*
My ten would look so different to yours! i still respect your opinion though. (i have rlly unpopular opinions) It would be:
1-Spies Are Forevee
2-TGWDLM
3-Firebringer
4-TTO
5-Solve It Squad
6-AVPS
7-AVPM
8-Twisted
9-Starship
10-AVPSY
You are one brave soul for putting Twisted so low...I salute you
First time i've seen someone say "unpopular opinion" to actually have an unpopular opinion
Wow I guess you're a huge Brian stan then (for both!)
Hideous Creatures isn’t my favourite Starship song but you are right, it is vastly under appreciated
Into the night is also my favorite song from Firebringer and I could not sit quietly while the song was playing!
Yesssss I love Hideous Creatures!!! (Maybe not as much as Kick It Up A Notch but still, I love it!)
hideous creatures is a BOP THANKYOU
HELL YEAH HMB AND SAF TIME LETS GO
i know this was posted like 4 years ago but seeing a fellow brolden + brosenthal fan is so nice the brians are my fav starkids ever
THANK YOU FOR APPRECIATING HIDEOUS CREATURES
Love the ani love so much!
Your opinions are so controversial I cannot but respect you.
I don't agree with almost anything in the ranking but the top 3 are undeniably amazing
Thank you for giving SAF the credit it deserves. It is a true masterpiece!!!
I literally can't argue with any of these
FINALLY!!! hideous creatures is a bop and deserves its recognition!! also dick big is an icon. PERIODT
you appreciate the underrated genius that is brian holden, i like you
Hideous creatures is an underrated bop
Hideous creatures can't be my favourie song from starship as long as Kick it up a notch is there but I like the appreciation because I still love that song!
Damn these are solid takes
I LOVE THAT!!! Ani, HMB, Spies
I love that Ani and HMB aren't on the bottom and SPA is amazing. It's my second after TGWDLM.
In my opinion, the only starship song better than hideous creatures is kick it up a notch, I got you dude
Let it out is one of my favorite songs in all of music and I will die by that
Finally, senior year gets the recognition it deserves. So many people have it so low down.
YES FINALLY SOME HIDEOUS CREATURES APPRECIATION!! I LOVE THAT SONG
mamd: not watched but i like coreys song, kinda scared to watch because i don’t know if any of the jokes are gonna be a bit outdated if you get what i mean
firebringer: would definitely place it higher than you did, i love zazz, climate change is my favourite song but into the night is good
twisted: i’m angry at how low this is, best music, i love princess, happy ending is my favourite starkid song ever
starship: i’m not patient enough to watch but hideous creatures and kick it up a notch are amazing songs
avpm: maybe it’s just the nostalgia but i love this show, dracos my favourite he’s so funny, going back to hogwarts is my favourite song because i’m basic
tto: i fucking love this show definitely the funniest, upopular opinion but my favourite song is speedrun, i cant pick a favourite character theyre all so good
tgwdlm: my favourite 100%, best song is inevitable but i do love let it out, macnamara is my favourite person ever but idk if it’s just cos i love jeff (tied up my heart is one of my other favourites which is VERY unpopular)
avpsy: worst of the avp trilogy, i was is so good i wish darrens mic worked i might also be the only one who absolutely loves get in my mouth, again draco is the best
ani: i don’t like star wars and i find the not singing but there being music really weird the dancing just looks awkward i don’t want to watch it (from what i’ve seen it is really funny and without the video the songs are good i just can’t handle it i’m sorry)
i’ve not watched any tcb musicals i really need to get on that
avps: best of avp trilogy, days of summer manages to make me miss school(crazy) and harry freakin potter is iconic i don’t need to say who my favourite is i think you can tell (umbridge is really funny but i don’t like how they portrayed her it feels kinda transphobic but it was 2010 so... i idk how to feel about tho cos i can’t speak for the trans community (i’m cis) so if any trans people could tell me if they find it offensive please)
hmb: also need to get around to watching but rouges are we and the american way are BOPS, robin is really funny from what i’ve seen
gay spies??? why tf have i not watched this yet????
this video came out before black friday (i think?) but i’ll say what i think anyway: feast or famine is a bop i fucking love that song, i don’t know if i should like becky or not i think we’re meant to but idk (kim is the most beautiful woman i’ve ever seen tho and her voice is wonderful so maybe take me back is my favourite??? idk ok it’s so good) the whole santa goes to high school bit is fucking hilarious robert is so funny, linda is an icon, GARY AND MAN IN A HURRY ARE MY FAVOURITE CHARACTERS EVER.
i’m sorry for how long this is it’s 1am and i’m having opinions. it’s definitely not coherent but yea
so, I was in complete agreement with the order, character and song...but then that changed because...well here's my order
12. MAMD
11. firebringer
10. twisted
9. TTO
8. Ani
7. holy musical b@man
6. avps
5. TGWDLM
4. avpsy
3. black Friday
2. avpm
1. starship
(btw, I've never seen and TCB productions, so i can't rank them)
let it out being ur favourite song from tgwdlm.... taste™️
"cutie clark in the background" that's precisely what I was thinking about at that moment!
his smiles make that song so much better
Okay but who’s doing the riff in “Not Alone”????? I’ve listened to that song like 50000 times and only now do u hear the gorgeous riff in the background! I keep replaying it to see who’s not singing the same words as everyone but I can’t see who it is! Does anyone know? I think it might be either Jaime (Ginny) or Bellatrix (I’m so sorry I just blanked on her actresses nameee! I’m horrible at remembering names lmao)
HOW THE FUCK THE MAGNUM OPUS OF STARKIDS IS SO FUCKING LOW?!?!?!
Watched this whole thing saying 'Holy fuck do you like Ani..... Holy shit! THIS placed lower than ANI????' then I rewatched it and I understood
Putting ani so high was a power move and I’d just like to say thankyou
no ones talking about how the favourite character in trail to oregon isnt craphole like thats actually crimilinal
Mine is SWW
Lyle: there are going to be some major unpopular opinions
Me: Okay, okay,
Lyle: put's Twisted as the third last
Me: *surprised Pikachu face*
*i'M NoT GoNnA SiNg wItH YoOoUuU!!*
While I do entirely disagree with this ranking, I love your favorites from each show
are we not gonna talk about *the gu who didn't like musicals*
Nah.
I read this as goo...as in, Pokey rebelled against himself.
Honestly Hideous Creatures is so underrated, It's so good! Especially on the cast recording.
Hey, you remembered Achmed! XD
genuinely read "the guy who didnt like musicals" as "the gru who didnt like musicals" for a quick minute
Spies are fprever in first it's a mood
I couldn't get through the first act of MAMD it made me s o u n c o m f o r t a b l e
i wish twisted was put higher but what can you do
twisted is my personal favorite
Excuse you, placing AVPSY above AVPM is rude
You and I are going to have to have a fearsome battle over Firebringer (just kidding I respect all your opinions). I will start with a comprehensive essay on why I love the show.
*Ahem*
I am a lesbian.
Holy heck, I disagreed with basically every point on this list. I'm almost impressed.
No hate, though, your opinion is totally valid (also!!! Yes!!! AVPSY getting at least the bare minimum amount of love!).
LMAO YOUR FAVORITE STARKID SHOW IS MY LEAST FAVORITE I'M-
Everybody gangsta till TWISTED is ranked 11
YES! FINALLY SOMEONE THAT AGREES WITH ME ABOUT HIDEOUS CREATURES BEING THE BEST SOBG IN STARSHIP
I love seeing hideous creatures get the respect it deserves