every starkid song ranked by voting
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 чер 2020
- We've finally made it to the end of the series! This is the last of my starkid 'songs ranked by voting' videos (until the next show comes out that is), but I may very well do a spies songs ranked by voting if y'all want me to.
This is a part of my series of starkid shows songs ranked by voting.
All the instalments of this series: • soundtracks ranked by ...
If you would like to help fill out a form for a future video of mine then the links to the ones currently open are at: lyle.carrd.co/
I also have some starkid/tcb personality quizzes if you're bored, they're linked at: lylequiz.carrd.co/
(Shameless plug)
Tumblr: / brianrosenthalapprecia...
Twitter: / lylethewaterguy
Instagram: / brosenthalappreciation...
Redbubble: rdbl.co/3cN7KA9 - Розваги
So in conclusion, the Starship fans love:
- Ensemble pieces
- Joey
- Dylan
- Villain songs
Yes
That is honestly pretty accurate.
Know what you meant, but *Starkid
we love all of them
@Rosemary McBratnie EXACTLY WHAT I THOUGHT
I always wonder why some songs are so low, but then I realize: They are just all so good
its true though the top 100 songs are all over 3.5 so thats a really good percentage for so many different styles and themes to be so liked.
Yeah, I don't think any of them were ranked below a 2.0
factss
Yeah I was a bit hurt in my soul when “you tied up my heart" was literally second to last
@@Emily-ox6yn same it’s literally one of my favourites (it’s second place out of the songs from TGWDLM for me, I have it above show stoppin number because of the fact that show stoppin number has so much dialogue that makes it a bit slower)
In conclusion: Starkid’s villain songs are GOD TIER
correction: SATAN TIER
Most villain songs are, not just Starkid's
in conclusion: this is why the guy who didn't like musicals is my favorite
ALL the songs are the villain songs
Wow y’all did firebringer dirty
@arandum Hufflepuff
Black Friday sucked XD
@arandum Hufflepuff
Well maybe my comment was a bit harsh. It's just not my favorite and certainly not as good as tgwdlm imo
@arandum Hufflepuff Sounds like a typical Starkid fan to me XDD
@arandum Hufflepuff and TGWDLM
@@_veronica_r you gotta admit the song “our doors are open” and characters like gerald are awesome tho
There's so many that I go "how is THAT so low?!" But then, the next song comes up and I go "oh that makes sense now" and I repeated this process the entire video lol.
Really there's some I'm going why is that so high? Like for god's sake who in the world can tell me half of the songs If not any of them any of them from 33 onwards are Better than "I was"
I was just confused the whole way through why people don’t like Sam’s song where he’s trapped in a chair. It’s a good song...?
And what do you want Paul
@@calvinjohnson6242 yah that song’s pretty good
You Tied Up My Heart definitely deserves to be higher, should be in the early 3.0s
twisted is a musical masterpiece
Facts
whoever wrote the lyrics for that show is a master of their craft and needs to be writing songs for actual Broadway shows.
And yet everything and more and the power in me are pretty low???
@@msilvia4807i love everything and more, her performance was so good
kick it up a notch reprise being that high shows that the starkid community really does have great taste
i was so nervous that it was going to be low! i just want to talk with everyone who rated it less than five stars tho, brian fucking killed it
@@cshmr0 Honestly Brian doesn't get enough credit. He's amazing
Is it one of the hottest moments of any of their musicals? Yes. Yes it is.
No they don’t. They put my favorite song at 107th😢😢😢😢
tumblr sexyman worthy
Ron: am I the one who steals the show? No I'm not
Also Ron: * is in the top ten of Starkid songs*
LOL
What Do You Want Paul is a bop and I feel attacked that it’s this low
Me too.
At least it's above Tied Up My Heart
Paul? Paul... PAAAAAAAUUUUUUULLLLLLL!!!!!!
Several songs from that musical were done so dirty tbh
@@GodlyGremlin. Several Jeff songs were done dirty.
deserved so much better
-we are people now
-i wanna be
-adore me
-the entirety of firebringer
-i steal everything
-join us and die
-a thousand and one nights
-the entirety of tto
Also take me back
Add Not your seed
What do you want Paul
-Cup of Roasted Coffee
-Starship
we are people now is highkey a bop and y’all are sleeping on it
It makes me feel so many emotions
the harmonies give me chills everytime
I'm surprised it's so low honestly? It's a very solid ensemble piece imo.
Exactly. It should've been in the top 100 at least
Y’all did Jeff blim do dirty and I’m not here for it :(
it's just that he uses his falsetto alot and sometimes it can ruin the songs for some people :/ just my opinion, sorry if I offend you
he wrote a lot of the songs tho so he’s high up there in the end
@@emotionalmess1286 thank you :) he's a great singer but just not my taste
I can't deal with Jeff's falsetto, it's just painful... And he writes the songs, knowing he will end up struggling with those notes... I'm sorry but I'm not on team Blim
I think the reason I love TGWDLM so much is that every song is essentially a villain song. Literally, every song is sung by an antagonist. La dee dah dah day? You bet your ass it's a villain song. Show Stopping Number? Hidgens literally has the heroes tied up. It's so interesting.
While this is true literally, in the structure of musical theatre it also makes sense, since the antagonists often sing the “I am” song, which almost all of tgwdlm’s songs are
The fact that Get in My Mouth is above What Tim Wants is sacrilege
yeah
Thank you yes
What Tim Wants is so good and I'm annoyed it isn't higher
What Tim Wants was way to low, if I'm being honest.
What Tim Wants should be Dylan's ticket to Broadway. I mean that's true for every Dylan song but damn. He's extra vulnerable in that one.
Take Me Back and What If Tomorrow are two of the best Starkid songs and I will die on this hill
Both in my personal top five.
And obviously moana
@@copperrose4376 SING THE BEGINNING OF MOANA
@@yourownmother9604 idk why but my mind went: MOANA (like their version), MAKE WAY! FOR PRINCE ALI
Take Me Back was definitely the moment where I went "oh THIS is when Jeff snapped on this show"
The fact that no song got lower then 2 stars is amazing. This community is just too niiiiice
Or all the songs are just BOPS
the fact that the top 5 are all villain or generally evil songs says a lot about what we, as a fandom, like
also!! the highest ranked song from MAMD is higher than the highest ranked song of 5 or 6 other shows (i'm bad at counting) and that makes me stupidly happy. i'm glad everyone can appreciate aj's magic
Villains always get the best songs. Just look at disney
Maybe TGWDLM is so well liked because every song is technically a villain song.
@@ZimtPorridge I honestly don't know why people don't like tied up my heart and what do you want Paul
@@peterosborne8315 You tied up my heart is my least favorite song of the show as well. I like what do you want Paul though. :)
@@ZimtPorridge hmm, maybe my love of the Blim has blinded by taste...
I love how high duck is lord it really shows what type of fandom we are
I thought the same thing about Hermione Can't Draw lol
Thelastcarriage6270 well it is a great song, so sad it is not on spotify.
kick it up a notch really just hits...different. i feel like it would be in a disney film
This is so off topic but I can’t stop staring at your profile picture, it’s just too magnificent
Well Starship is essentially space Little Mermaid
Have you heard the SPACE tour version? It is utter perfection
Also Not your seed is criminally low!
YES it is one of my favorite songs and it does not get enough love
YES
Best song I ever heard
"You Tied Up My Heart" deserved so much better, Jeff Blim is a blessing.
I know right?? I’m so confused how it’s all the way at the bottom
i LOVE that song so much
EXTREMELY unpopular opinion: You Tied Up My Heart is better than SSN
@@nataliedraper926 You know what, I can totally see where you’re coming from, YTUMH is incredibly underrated in my opinion :,)
@@nataliedraper926 ssn as show stopping number? Should we kill him? Should we kill him?
I honestly think You Gotta Go would be a great song had they not had the.. uh.... complications.
It IS a great song. :P
I wish there was a version without the sound effects, like the joke works just with the absolutely punfull lyrics.
@@jahnabanana Except the humour is for toddlers
It was NOT funny. I found it quite irritating.
I love that song but it makes me so uncomfortable too
Caulk your wagon is a bop and i will go to my grave saying that
IKR!! i dont get why people dont like it, yeh it can be interpreted as having quite a dirty double meaning but its starkid what do they expect?
Maddie White I think some people get uncomfortable by it because of the sexual innuendos
Leah Scarth i guess
@@mads9966 I'm kinda indifferent to it but I thinks its cause it's not really needed to be sung and cause joey had a badass villain song earlier and his next singing solo isnt evil at all? Idrk
the fact that the first Ani song is 7 and a half minutes into the video is exactly what that show deserves, the music is god tier
The music for Ani is so underrated, it's 10/10
All of Jeff's songs deserve so much more love, it makes me sad seeing them all ranked so low. :(
I think it's just that Blim usually plays characters that are either villains or uncomfortable to watch, so while nobody doubts his talent, his songs just aren't as enjoyable
@@serene7995 I mean 1 and 2 were villain songs
@@serene7995 In any good musical, the villain's song is at least top 3 imo.
@@serene7995 see it’s that factor that I like him for, he’s like that one person in the friend group who has one best friend who can understand him and the rest of the group is unable to deal with it
Honestly I find his style a bit repetitive and his singing voice is not that great. Fans may maul me for that but I think he writes his songs too high for his voice
How some of the songs are cut is just criminal
I almost cried at the cut of Happy Ending.
When they cut World at Stake Reprise right before the voice crack
@@museofbastille13 its the best part...
on the last video we were all disagreeing with basically everything and i just wanted to say: no matter what we think of ranking thank you so much for putting so much work into the series! it was really fun to vote and even more fun to see every single revealing the results. we love you!!
this!!
yesss!!!
Yeah!!
Yay!
Yes
firebringer was done *DIRTY*
Song that isnt on this list but is still the best:
Rouges Medley from the Apocalyptour.
a God tier mashup that I wish they still preformed because all of those songs are amazing by themselves but together they are just the biggest bop.
If I see another person complain about Firebringer and Black Friday being "bad" I swear to god I’m gonna set your wagon on fire
The night belongs to us deserves better.
ALL the songs in Firebringer deserve better.
Yes agreed, it’s an easy top ten starkid song
@@duckislord7187 why... Does this keep happening
@@constantTVstatic I'm guessing because you're watching lots of StarKid-related videos and we have similar taste in these videos, haha.
@@duckislord7187 haha probably
i’ve gotta say “show me your magic carpet” is pure fucking lyrical genius
i think in the soundtrack its "ill be your magic carpet" which is just as good
Fun game I’m playing: try to sing along to the songs without the sound
glad feast or famine is FINALLY getting the recognition it deserves.
Despite the general opinions of the sk fandom I will always agree that the MAMD soundtrack and all Jeff’s songs all slap
i agree so much
No One Remembers Achmed will always be first in my heart
You remembered Achmed
What we have learned from this is though Laren is an icon, and the duck is lord, Dylan Saunders needs to be on Broadway.
Broadway is overrated
WHAT TIM WANTS IS CRIMINALLY UNDERRATED AND YES I WILL DIE ON THAT HILL
Jaime being in every song in the top 5 is such a power move
it makes me really happy that 11 of their 12 shows have at least one song in the top 20. the only one missing is ani
Samuel L Jackson but also an interesting thing about Ani’s ranking in this, it takes the longest time in the video for ani’s worst ranked song to come up out of all the starkid shows, proving that every single one of ani’s songs are bangers
I haven't watched the show yet but have been listening to the soundtrack and like???? it's so good???
“we are people now” is so beautiful, it’s criminally low on this list.
if feast or famine isn’t in the top 10 i’ll be sad
edit: hell yes
Ooh the best part of Orphaned At 33. Gimme that "I'M GONNA LIVE FOREVER!" any day. (Are all these comments about my Jeff bias... oops)
ME OMG I HAVE SUCH A JEFF BIAS
Ok I just don’t get the extremely low ranking of You Tied up My Heart, What Do You Want Paul and What Tim Wants. I guess some people just don’t like Jeff’s vocals, which I understand, but What Tim Wants is Criminally underrated. Dylan’s vocals are phenomenal and give the song so much heart even if it lacks a bit of a place.
Also Show Stopping Number is very low. I get that it’s overrated, but it’s still a top notch StarKid song in my opinion
I LOVE WHAT TIM WANTS AND IF I FAIL YOU I WILL DIE ON THIS HILL
That's literally what I thought too. Show stoppin' number I can live with because legit any of the last 25 could be put at one and it would make sense, and someone had to put them into an order. But legit, I thought TGWDLM was gonna do really poorly when like 3 songs in I see Sam tied up to hiss chair.
y’all did made in america dirty. i get chills every time i listen to it
And joeys monologue before is amazing. He is such a great actor
Me shocked that chorn is so low. The talent on that, I remember that was the song that stuck me on starkid
“Do You Want To Play” gives me chills every time.
I’m having a brain fart and forget the girls name, but her voice is so chilling 😱 Makes it such a good song
Kim Whalen! Honestly, I fear for my life whenever I hear it 😆
I only had one condition while watching this: If “If I Believed” wasn’t in the top 15, I was gonna completely disagree with this entire video. I agree with this video.
If climate change isn’t in the top 25 I might get dysentery and die hehe. Thank god! It is!
WHO allowed Duck is Lord to get that high 😂😂
Should be higher, smh
Because DUCK IS LORD 🦆
Chorn
WE ARE PEOPLE NOW IS BEAUTIFUL
I think the reason that this ranking is so chaotic is because people voted in reference to the show, like for me Wizard Of The Year & Sidekick are my favourite songs in Senior Year so I would rank them highly in reference to the other AVPSY songs but not necessarily with Starkid as a whole (just a thought with a random example idk)
I love the transition at 23:22 “so look alive and don’t forget-” “mother nature’s really great”
Nobody cares but here’s my top ten❤️
10) Feast or famine
9) Super friends
8) The night belongs to us
7) What if tomorrow comes
6) The way I do
5) Inevitable
4) When the worlds at stake
3) Dream a little harder
2) Get back to hogwarts
1) Kick it up a notch
Honourable mentions for top ten: Ready to go, Wagon on fire, With my own eyes, Granger danger, status quo and happy ending
No love for 1001 Nights or If I Believed?
No show stopping number
This just reminded me that Joey has the best solo's. Look at the facts
1. Status quo is my favorite song ever
2. Sidekick is my second favorite starkid song
3. Life is an underated jam
4. Made in America is my favorite bf song
5. Wagon on fire.
All of those (except life and made in America) are ranked so close to the top so like, we stan?
Side note: Harry freaking potter > Goin back to Hogwarts fight me
This just reminds me that every single show has at least 1 amazing song in it.
yet more evidence that firebringer is underrated
Number 2 rolled around and I was thinking “What!? What’s better than Wagon on Fire!?”
And then I remembered.
Edit: I love seeing that people like Ani more than they’re willing to publicly admit. It’s one of my faves.
A lot of the lower songs are outwardly loved by a lot of people, looks like the “unpopular opinion” people are actually the silent majority
i’ve previously said in comments that i don’t like Ani, but i think i’m finally swinging around because of Joe Walker and Nick Lang
31 seconds in and I'm shook, You Tied Up My Heart is the best TGWDLM song and no one can tell me otherwise
Most valid person in this comment section
Can someone explain why ‘What Tim Wants’ always scores low? It’s gorgeous...
I don't necessarily like What Tim Wants, but Black friday's songs in general werent my cup of tea
Here are the shows with the most songs in top 30:
Avpm, Starship, HMB, Twisted ~ 4 songs
TGWDLM ~ 3 songs
Avps, Mamd, Avpsy, Firebringer, Black Friday ~ 2 songs
Trail to Oregon ~ 1 song
Ani ~ 0 songs :(
I think Long ago and Far Away totally should’ve been in the top 30, but great list nonetheless!
Long Ago and Far Away is in my top 10 personally. Such a beautiful song.
Seeing my favourite songs low hurts but most of Starkid's songs are great anyway, I don't know what I'd switch to put them higher.
You Tied Up My Heart deserved better
Y’all are still sleeping on If I Fail You it never fails to make me cry every time I hear it
THANK YOU !!!!!! 10000% agree
I WOULD LIKE TO ASK WHY 'What Tim Wants' WAS SO DAMN LOW
Oh wow Caulk the Wagon deserves better, the song is so funny and witty and fits McDoon perfectly
Honestly pleased by how high When The World's At Stake is but it still feels too low. Top 10 for me most likely.
Whaaaaattt!? Take me back is my 3rd favorite starkid song!
I know! I expected it to be way further up there. It’s so beautiful!
i would like a word with everyone whos votes are responsible for monsters and men being so low
and adore me
and if i fail you (this is where i realise that my black friday ranking is probably quite unpopular)
every time i see even though so low i makes me sad because its in my top ten favourite starkid songs and i really love it
SPEEDRUN AT ONLY 85!?
AMERICA IS GREAT AGAIN IS THE BEST TGWDLM SONG AND DESERVED BETTER THAN 80TH
ok, no way is my favourite song of all time ever and 59th is just too low
ok the top 20 are all some of my favourites so thats cool, im still salty that no way is only 59th
I lowkey love Get In My Mouth and it makes me uncomfortable how much I love it. My Jeff bias is a bad influence. :P
you tied up my heart is criminally underrated
I think it makes a lot of people really uncomfortable, which explains its ranking
Wow, i love how even the lowest ranking is a 2.39.
honestly tho whenever dylan starts singing i want to cry like especially in twisted i just wanna sob coz he’s making me feel emotions
there are things in here that make me very happy and things in here that make me SO ANGRY
I love that you put in a trigger warning for arachnophobia, a lot of people don't with Get in My Mouth💕
Also, can someone tell me why a ton of people hate on Monsters and Men?
It's a mystery. I'be seen pretty good reasoning to why people hate a certain song in a show, but "Monsters and Men" is a great song and I haven't seen anybody say exactly WHY they don't like it, just that they do.
@@duckislord7187 It's cause they don't like Jeff and it PISSES ME OFF
personally i love monsters and men but i cant stand jeffs falsetto - its not bad but its not a pleasant sound to listen to for me and i think monsters and men would have so much more potential if it was sung by a female belter like jaime or even curt (his voice is amazing)
@@duckislord7187 i have no clue, monsters and men is soooooo good
@@freya6306 I can respect that.
I really wanted Hermione Can’t Draw on top
I find it very interesting that in the video where the ranking was based on “what is your favourite song” the top three were kick it up a notch, wagon on fire, show stoppin number. But in this one (where people actually rated the songs individually) show stoppin number is the only one that dropped. So a lot of people have it as there favourite but everyone who doesn’t doesn’t care for it that much. Meaning: if you’re one of the people who got pissed at and attacked me for putting it at number 30 in my own ranking then you’re in a very loud (and very annoying) minority.
Never really got the hype over SSN. Sure working boys is iconic but I feel like the fandom hyped up the whole song to be better than it is
@@albieemery2828 I think it’s a hilarious scene, but I can definitely see how the song itself might have gotten a little over hyped. Like the dancing and the reactions never fail to make me laugh- but the song isn’t exactly playing on repeat on my spotify
@@ellawanless641 thats pretty much how I feel- it's amazing in the context of the show but people making it out like its sent from jesus christ himself makes me almost like it less
For me personally it definitely deserves to be on the top 20 (maybe number 15 or so) but attacking someone for disagreeing is so stupid. In fact it really saddens me when I see someone on the comment section being agressive like that because it actually also affects the perception and popularity of the song itself, as many people are fed up with it and think it's overrated (which again, for me it isn't really because I love it but whatever)
I feel like SSN is just very popular with the gays (myself included) and thats why. I genuinely love the song because of how gay I find it if that makes sense but you shouldnt get attacked.
Kinda surprised and a little bit sad that granger danger and superfriends missed out on the top 10!
that top five is strong as f
The fact that Starship songs are so loved makes me so full and happy !! that musical is a blessing
it would ber really interesting to redo this in a month or two and see how it changes
the transition at 23:20 "so look alive and don't forget MOTHER NATURE'S REALLY GREEEAAAT" gave me whiplash lmaoooo
Wagon on fire is my second favorite! I think that’s the first one I agree with!
Speedrun is what I sing in my head while swimming
honestly the fact that none have less than 2 stars, and that the ones with less than three are still all too low
the video we didnt know we needed
Wow, show stopping number is shockingly low
I refuse to accept What Tim Wants being so low. I sobbed like a baby the first time I heard it
Oh my god not If I Fail You too
Why does everyone hate You Tied Up My Heart >:(
I knownright? Second to last...
I’m saying! I absolutely love that song, it’s one of my favorites
Ikr that song is funny and I love it
Yes! It kinda gives me chills but in a good singing-zombie-monster type of way
i personally don’t like it because it makes me uncomfortable. the song itself isn’t sung bad, it’s just the lyrics and the dancing
I personally would've ranked all the firebringer songs much high. I was surprised so many were ranked lower
HOW FAST DO YOU EDIT?!?!?!
I'm assuming that by this point all of these clips are cut and ready to paste together so it's a bit easier
IF I FAIL YOU AND WHAT TIM WANTS ARE SO LOW WHAT IS THIS BLASPHEMY
unpopular opinion but I think that while Firebringer doesn't have a great plot, it has one of the best soundtracks.
it's really underappreciated by starkid fans imo
you tied up my heart being ranked below every single song from MaMD is fucking bananas
"Everything Tim Wants" is a massive bop tho
"If I fail you" is the best star kid song and I will stick by that statement till I die
I did not expect to go into a Starkid Musical and bawl my face off, but "What Tim Wants" and "If I Fail You" happened...
My Mommy heart was in Pieces.
I’m sorry but our doors are open and it pays to be an animal need to be higher!
Also everything ends needs to be in top ten!
I read this as "everything needs to be top 10" and I was like preach dude
WaluigiTime OwO me too lmao
WaluigiTime OwO I mean that’s also true...
People finally remembered achmed XD
i get why some of them are low (cause theres better ones) but "not your seed" being that low is just criminal