BEST XBOX EXTERNAL STORAGE!! Seagate Expansion Card vs SSD vs HDD - Which Should You Buy?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 сер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 136

  • @kamerons76
    @kamerons76 2 роки тому +287

    It’s absolutely disgusting Xbox thinks it’s okay to charge basically the same price as the console 2tb is barely any space these days games are huge I got like 6 Xbox series x games installed and the entire console is full

    • @lapatabelluda2240
      @lapatabelluda2240 Рік тому +16

      Dude you getting the console for cheap a PC has like 500 ssd thus faster so stf

    • @Termin8or18-onXbox
      @Termin8or18-onXbox Рік тому +30

      @@lapatabelluda2240 False information you can find damn good ssds for way less then 500 bucks obviously not a techy and comparing a console that cost 250 on average to a pc is stupid anyways 😂

    • @its_finn96
      @its_finn96 Рік тому

      Quit bitching…they charge what they charge because people will pay for it. If you can’t afford it (like me) you get to either deal with a cheaper and less effective option or simply save until you can afford. Stop whining, just makes you look pathetic

    • @JALC-x
      @JALC-x Рік тому +14

      and the funniest thing is the xbots are praising microsoft for making it easy for them because they don't know how to install an m.2 drive 💀 convenience is always nice but £254.99 RRP for 1tb @2400mb/s 2 years after release is criminal

    • @gamingclipz7309
      @gamingclipz7309 Рік тому +2

      Y’all 🤡

  • @grodriq
    @grodriq 2 роки тому +96

    Great video. The differences in memory expansion are explained thoroughly and in an easy to understand manner. Thank you.

  • @jeroendenhertog4975
    @jeroendenhertog4975 2 роки тому +32

    After several videos about this Expansion Card and why you shouldn't buy it, only regarding the price, finally a real and good explanation why you should!
    Imo, a combination of a 1TB Expansion Card and an USB SSD harddisk is the best option.

    • @cayatfaishGaming
      @cayatfaishGaming Рік тому +14

      Yeah, but imo the price is much more important due to the fact that it’s a gaming console mostly used by CHILDREN with no money, let alone a bank account. And if your thinking “oh if their children why don’t they just ask their parents to buy it,” then I wonder what kind of parents you grew up with that would but you everything you wanted, if I asked my mother to pay 200 dollars for a expansion card after I just got the 300 dollar console itself, I would receive a lecture on the value of money so long and in detail, it would put a fucking Tedtalk to shame.

    • @WillVandomhale
      @WillVandomhale Рік тому +1

      @@cayatfaishGaming the worst thing that she would be right.. i mean in her perspective.
      Microsoft did good thing with console that enabled to run new games in 1080p for that price but those memory cards darn, seems a good decision but I rather save on PlayStation then buying those expensive cards..

    • @JoeBrannin
      @JoeBrannin 8 місяців тому

      @@cayatfaishGamingsame. I’m glad the did too because I know the value of money and the evil behind it

  • @mooble1
    @mooble1 Рік тому +21

    something to keep in mind if you are getting an external drive and intend to swap games to and from your internal storage, do not get an external SSD. they degrade much faster than hard drives if you are repeatedly deleting many files from them at once then redownloading them. i'd personally just get an external HDD no matter what, but if you really want an external SSD, only get it if you're not planning on repeatedly swapping games.

    • @goosehammy4837
      @goosehammy4837 10 місяців тому +1

      yah, bus who will redownload if you can swap ?
      + even if one ssd is good for one year for a big gamer, its cheaper to change 3 ssd's if in case its gets damaged, and evn so i think probably gamer will change console type faster thank those ssd's will break.

    • @RUSIFPH72
      @RUSIFPH72 7 місяців тому

      You damage the HDD Everytime you transfer this is common sense expansion is designed to keep not switch your gonna damage it (Wich is what these companies want to get you to buy internal cards) you're better off getting a super external that has fast loads and download and use the 3.0 for it otherwise your gonna buy more externals like I did after doing this . Also after 2 weeks of saving I got the card and use card and internal my 3xternal is for older games now and surprising it loads as fast now Wich Vega the question of they are watching our memory and using it to determine how to get us to buy shit

  • @MetalGateDragon
    @MetalGateDragon Рік тому +11

    Honestly, I'm perfectly happy with my external HDD. Yeah, it may be the slowest option, but it does the job when I want to transfer games. It is still a lot faster than downloading them again and with ISP data caps still a thing in this day and age, it works flawlessly.

    • @micahhughes8447
      @micahhughes8447 9 місяців тому

      What one do you use?

    • @MetalGateDragon
      @MetalGateDragon 9 місяців тому

      @@micahhughes8447 I had an old SATA II 5400RPM lying around. 1TB. I bought an enclosure.

    • @greenninja187
      @greenninja187 9 місяців тому +1

      How long does it take to transfer games?

    • @aterraxanime
      @aterraxanime 7 місяців тому

      ​@@greenninja18715-30 min

  • @mitchell808
    @mitchell808 Рік тому +6

    Very very good video. You deserve a lot more views and likes. Thank you for being so crisp, clear, and concise with your info

  • @ivanfry6138
    @ivanfry6138 2 роки тому +18

    A lot of the public is forgetting load times. External SSD CANNOT RUN OPTIMIZED X/S TITLES. It only stores them. you still have to move to internal anytime you wanna play and depending on title will add extra time to your day moving titles back and forth vs the ridiculously expensive yet convenient memory card that runs X/S optimized titles. I’d say do both if you have the money one for old generation. One for new optimized titles.

  • @lego_minifig
    @lego_minifig 2 роки тому +25

    Personally, I’d never buy an external SSD. They are often overpriced in my opinion. Its way more affordable to buy an external 2.5in, M.2, or NVME enclosure and then buying the drive separately. The enclosures run from $10-50 depending on the type of drive. (2.5in being the cheapest and NVME being the most expensive) You can get a 1TB SSD for roughly $100.

    • @bobsander4739
      @bobsander4739 2 роки тому

      I've also had this same thought. My only question is whether or not a Samsung evo 970 (for instance) would be optimized as well as a dedicated external SSD for this specific use case?

    • @lego_minifig
      @lego_minifig 2 роки тому +1

      @@bobsander4739 I’ve used both m.2 drives and 2.5in drives quite often in this manner. Never had any issues. I only have a NVME enclosure that I used for cloning so I don’t get to use it enough as an external drive to judge it. Though I assume there wouldn’t be an issue. Only caveats is that you need to format the drive before use which may throw off someone ignorant of that process.

    • @bobsander4739
      @bobsander4739 2 роки тому

      @@lego_minifig that's great insight! Thanks for the reply!

    • @lego_minifig
      @lego_minifig 2 роки тому +1

      @@bobsander4739 Np, though I did think of one additional thing to keep in mind when it comes to NVME drives after the fact. They often use different cache technologies. TLC and QLC are the most popular. TLC is faster and QLC is more durable and cheaper. QLC which is the cheaper variant can be found in drives like the intel 660p. Those drive have a small TLC cache, but most of it is the slower QLC. It’s excellent for a boot drive, but would make a poor external drive due to the QLC cache. Once the cache is filled up the drives will slow down substantially to the point that downloading files onto the drive will be slower than a HDD. This only occurs during massive file transfers though. For an OS drive this problem won’t occur as often (especially if you have your downloads folder linked to another drive), but as an external drive it may be more problematic if you are using the drive to transfer let’s say movies from one PC to another.

    • @wAiEr1009
      @wAiEr1009 Рік тому

      They won't run x/s unless you re-download

  • @leaf7887
    @leaf7887 Рік тому +2

    Thanks a bunch
    Very good well said information

  • @andrewzak1831
    @andrewzak1831 Рік тому +3

    Tony Stark glass wearin' Great Value brand Tom Holland lookin' ass...

  • @istupid4454
    @istupid4454 Рік тому +2

    Answered all my questions thank you!

  • @keystonekid
    @keystonekid 2 роки тому +9

    Fantastic and straight to the point. I'll subscribe to help u out my guy..we need more people like u

  • @chm1701
    @chm1701 2 роки тому +3

    Great info. Thank you.

  • @tizzle4305
    @tizzle4305 Рік тому +2

    Thank you. Actually helpful and straight forward really appreciate it

  • @user-lu8mf8vm6r
    @user-lu8mf8vm6r Рік тому +3

    I bought the samsung T7 500Gb 3.2 usb ssd which is a very very fast drive but it still won't reproduce any X/S optimised games at all, it is only capable of saving the huge size new generation games on it, and simply you can copy them on the internal ssd disc to be able to run them.

    • @gatomarbellero
      @gatomarbellero Рік тому

      Halo Masterchief Collection,Ori,and other games optimized work fine with ssd.Try it!!!

    • @abdullahdeeb836
      @abdullahdeeb836 Рік тому +3

      How long does it take to move like a 100 gb game from and off the ssd?

  • @wolfking1184
    @wolfking1184 11 місяців тому +1

    This has been very helpful

  • @Maj275
    @Maj275 2 роки тому +3

    Since the Series S is my first XBox, i thought that "Storage Expansion" Port is for legacy Storage things. ^^ not for modern SSD expansion. ^^

  • @maxjensenjames9622
    @maxjensenjames9622 Рік тому +2

    I know these videos are old now but after waiting a year to be able to get a ps5 and still not being able too I need to upgrade. I did not consider the series s a good contender. I was hugely mistaken. I have been watching as many of you xbox series s videos I can find. And will be ordering one very soon.
    I hope to be to find some new ish series s videos

  • @High.Vibe.Living
    @High.Vibe.Living 9 місяців тому +1

    You missed critical information...
    What is the read speed on USB SSD vs USB HDD
    Like actual transfer figures and numbers....
    Atm my current usb HDD has a read speed of 1000mbps / 125MB/s

  • @Ramazvous
    @Ramazvous Рік тому +2

    Got portable 30Tb SSD for android i hope it would work on xbox. Seems like it will

  • @Doodz22
    @Doodz22 Рік тому +4

    If you’re planning to buy Series S and Seagate Expansion Card, Just purchase the series X! It’s cheaper Hahaha

  • @spgreacts4507
    @spgreacts4507 2 роки тому +2

    Can I ask why you have a $299 price tag on your thumbnail for the Seagate expansion card?

    • @StrawHatGuy_
      @StrawHatGuy_ 2 роки тому

      He set it up as a slight clickbait I guess. Annoyed me to be honest.

  • @turnpiketumbler8938
    @turnpiketumbler8938 2 роки тому +1

    Interesting video. So, could I play the likes of Battlefield 1+5, COD and RDR2 straight from the Samsung SSD card?

  • @babyboy1971
    @babyboy1971 2 роки тому +6

    I just got an Xbox series S and bit the bullet and bought the 1TB Seagate expansion card. Laughably, I am already running out of room and would love to have a fast external SSD hard drive, would the Samsung be the best bet for that?

  • @caseybelew1262
    @caseybelew1262 Рік тому +2

    I got the series x..I bought madden 23..nba 2k23..modern warfare 2..and assassin creed vahalla..I got like 100 gb left. I think ima get the Seagate 2 tb card and I be good..I'm just getting back into gaming etc and I'm so behind lmao

  • @flaminninjaシ
    @flaminninjaシ 2 роки тому

    Great video

  • @reneescheepers3693
    @reneescheepers3693 2 роки тому +2

    great video

  • @batterygib7513
    @batterygib7513 Рік тому +2

    On average whats the speed to transfer hames from ssd to internal storage?

  • @P1ecez_76
    @P1ecez_76 Рік тому

    Thank you for the help

  • @jackstacey5647
    @jackstacey5647 2 роки тому

    in my opinion, declawed all the next-gen games on the Xbox and the rest on the SSD so I can play all the games straight away.

  • @ygbodybuilder3023
    @ygbodybuilder3023 Рік тому +2

    Wouldn't it make since to just get the series x

    • @Mr.GalaxyYT
      @Mr.GalaxyYT Рік тому

      You're pretty much buying it when you get the series s and memory 😐💀

    • @cxlappsed1548
      @cxlappsed1548 Рік тому

      1TB is still not enough for these days

  • @lewissrants3649
    @lewissrants3649 8 місяців тому

    I'm in a split the Samsung ssd £82 but the xbox series s/x expansion card is £149 I don't what to get

  • @babyboy1971
    @babyboy1971 2 роки тому

    I’ve heard the T7 gets hot, vs T5, is that true? Any issues?

  • @jonathandiaz4997
    @jonathandiaz4997 7 місяців тому +1

    13 months ago 😂😊

  • @S_12344
    @S_12344 Рік тому +1

    Does the Samsung one work on Xbox one s?

  • @chrisbuxton7790
    @chrisbuxton7790 Рік тому

    I dont understand the point because if you need to transfer a game back onto the internal drive. Then you would need to delete a game on your internal drive to make room for it wouldnt you?

    • @micahhughes8447
      @micahhughes8447 9 місяців тому +1

      No cause you can transfer a series x or s game to the drive, you just can't play them unless they're on your console.

  • @darrenandnat1983
    @darrenandnat1983 Рік тому

    What is that game from the video 2mins 43s Looks very similar to Tomb Raider / Uncharted kind of game

  • @supermariokun8509
    @supermariokun8509 Рік тому

    Will this be good if I want it for movies

  • @StrawHatGuy_
    @StrawHatGuy_ 2 роки тому +7

    Eh, I got the $220 one for only $25 because the store I bought it at screwed up. I got super lucky

    • @groo115
      @groo115 2 роки тому +1

      good joke

    • @StrawHatGuy_
      @StrawHatGuy_ 2 роки тому

      @@groo115 trust me, not a joke

    • @HangeyCowYT
      @HangeyCowYT Рік тому

      @@StrawHatGuy_ wow then ur super lucky that is funny

    • @StrawHatGuy_
      @StrawHatGuy_ Рік тому +3

      @@HangeyCowYT you think that's funny, there is also another time i got even crazier lucky but sometimes things happen that no one will ever believe. Believe this other true story if you want or not. I ordered ship to store a LG OLED C1 65 inch for ship to store - store pick-up. I signed for it when I picked it up but I guess they never finalized it. Got an email the next day as I was wall mounting it no joke, they emailed me that because they supposably noticed I never picked it up, they refunded my Target credit card of like $2000. I post this to share my story only to share this true thing that happened to me. Anyone reading this can choose to believe me or not, doesn't change the fact the I got a free $2000 tv 😁

  • @helexdarkness6272
    @helexdarkness6272 8 місяців тому

    So If I was to get a Samsung SSD T7 external drive I can play series s/x games through the drive?

  • @WillVandomhale
    @WillVandomhale Рік тому

    So you saying even if I’ll buy the b Samsung blue external SSD thing (not the card) I’ll will still not able to run games from it?…

  • @freakysep6364
    @freakysep6364 11 місяців тому

    so can i store rdr2 on my external ssd and play it while my ssd it connected to my xbox series s whihout the need of exporting the game files from ssd to internal storage?

  • @jg3_75
    @jg3_75 6 місяців тому

    Wait….I get what u said about the hard drive and the external ssd…. But in regards to the sea gate expansion card, can you play series x/s optimized games directly from it?

    • @mrzee321
      @mrzee321 4 місяці тому

      Yes you can

  • @zenvi7023
    @zenvi7023 2 роки тому

    still dont understand how you only got 30k followers

  • @georgeathansiou
    @georgeathansiou Рік тому

    So im not going to be able to play games like warzone if i pick an ssd?

  • @TebTengri
    @TebTengri Рік тому

    The fact they didn't just let people use m.2 drives that pass a speed test is BS

    • @UltraCasualPenguin
      @UltraCasualPenguin Рік тому +1

      Then get PS5 or PC. Point of console is ease of use and that you don't have to be tech savvy.
      Also, let's just ignore how many people have broken side panel on PS5 or even bricked their console as result of NVMe installation.

    • @TebTengri
      @TebTengri Рік тому +1

      @@UltraCasualPenguin if they can't install an m.2 drive without breaking something... that's on them and their lack of skills/dexterity 🤣

  • @fog340
    @fog340 Рік тому

    ayo Ben, The person holding the xbox memory card at 0:27 might have psoriasis, Connective tissue disorder, Alopecia areata, or an autoimmune disorder that causes hair loss or Zinc deficiency it's been over a year, and i hope thyure okay, but said person might want to go get checked out

    • @R4k05
      @R4k05 Рік тому

      What

    • @R4k05
      @R4k05 Рік тому

      Is this a joke or real

    • @fog340
      @fog340 Рік тому

      @@R4k05 No i am sadly not joking. I really do hope Ben informed the person (or they regularly go to the doctors). If you look at his nail, the little dents them is one of the signs of an issue. especially if its on all his fingernails.

  • @Memezz06
    @Memezz06 Рік тому +2

    This might be a weird question, but I was wondering if the external ssd can be used on an Xbox one s? This means i don't have any games optimized for Xbox one s or x, so I feel like it might be the best deal. Any advice is greatly appreciated

    • @Longliveyt-n7z
      @Longliveyt-n7z Рік тому

      For those I’m pretty sure you can play them directly off the ssd because I’ve seen people have games downloaded on a hard drive and just disconnect it from their Xbox and plug it to another and play instantly

    • @tyicbranch2734
      @tyicbranch2734 Рік тому

      I have the seagate game drive 2tb it can play all last generation game's even games with 4k just not optimised game's I have it for my Xbox series X but you can use it any console but its optimised for Xbox games it cost like £80 pounds or less depending on were you get it From probably cheaper on the Facebook market

    • @Memezz06
      @Memezz06 Рік тому

      @@tyicbranch2734 ok thx

    • @tyicbranch2734
      @tyicbranch2734 Рік тому

      @@Memezz06 honestly you want regret it in the future you will probably need a memory card but not any time soon not much next generation games to be honest and with the 2tb seagate game drive you get between 700mb to 1g download speed I downloaded a 95gb game in no time

  • @is2fiftyslowfsport744
    @is2fiftyslowfsport744 2 роки тому +3

    Paying $200 for a 1tb ssd card or paying $190 or a 8tb seagate external hard drive?! this is a no brainer, less is more!!!!

    • @platongiourtis3851
      @platongiourtis3851 2 роки тому +1

      Isnt 8tb a bit over kill?

    • @is2fiftyslowfsport744
      @is2fiftyslowfsport744 2 роки тому +5

      @@platongiourtis3851 Nope because it's better to have more than less storage

    • @vagabond4576
      @vagabond4576 2 роки тому +1

      @@platongiourtis3851 Having more memory also can be faster and also considering current games running over 100 gb its not overkill. Plus that's a stupid question.

    • @jeffdowell1255
      @jeffdowell1255 Рік тому

      @@vagabond4576 Tell me you don't know anything about computers without telling me you don't know anything about computers.

    • @UltraCasualPenguin
      @UltraCasualPenguin Рік тому

      But noise of spinning drives though.. And they're really sloooooow. Let's not even talk about what can happen if you drop one from waist height.

  • @zombiekiller3481
    @zombiekiller3481 Рік тому

    Can I use any external SSD on series S to play Xbox 360 and Xbox one games.

  • @GalacticGamingClips
    @GalacticGamingClips Рік тому +1

    Man needs to cut his nails, but video very informative xD

  • @jesseobrien5864
    @jesseobrien5864 Рік тому

    Hey. I keep seeing 2T Seagate Storage dealymuhbobbers. But I thought X Box Series X only could handle 1T external storage. I'm new. Disabled. Not sure how long I got left (bad medical problems) so I bought an XBox X. What the word little brother? Oh. Mine didn't come with a manual. Can I download one someplace

    • @cayatfaishGaming
      @cayatfaishGaming Рік тому

      I just bought my XBOX SERIES S which is like the little brother to the SERIES X so I don’t know how the info translates but I would gladly send you a couple pictures of the manual if you need sir, I. So sorry about your condition and I hope that you get better soon. You can reply to this comment if you have any questions or if you want me to send the pictures, just make sure to tell me where I can send them ok? Have a wonderful day sir.

  • @siddharthajain6944
    @siddharthajain6944 Рік тому

    can i use my ssd on other console. Let say if i have Game Pass on one and my friend does not have. I download. a game thats free on game pass. i download it, copy to external SSD and the my friend can use my external SSD and play the game that was for free through Game Pass to me only. But he got it for free.

    • @UltraCasualPenguin
      @UltraCasualPenguin Рік тому +1

      Only if:
      - you give your account to your friend (which AFAIK is against ToS)
      - your friend gets Game Pass subscription

  • @undefined7141
    @undefined7141 Рік тому +1

    Finally someone else talking about this. My Xbox series S is my streaming machine, I have it with a 8tb seagate drive. You nailed it, it’s a game pass beast.
    I didn’t notice but how much faster is the external ssd vs the mechanical?

  • @jonathandiaz4997
    @jonathandiaz4997 7 місяців тому

    13 months ago 😂

  • @bweir5455
    @bweir5455 2 роки тому

    Great video although I do have a question, he says he can't play series s or series x games but does that mean you can still play them on the internal storage or would that not work?

    • @ivanfry6138
      @ivanfry6138 2 роки тому +1

      You can still play from internal the problem is once your internal is full. Mine is ready full from just 8 optimized x/s titles.

    • @kamerons76
      @kamerons76 2 роки тому +5

      @@ivanfry6138 yup it’s absolutely disgusting this is what they went with if 6 games already filled 1tb which mines full also getting the 2tb expansion card is still nothing and they are basically charging the price of the console itself

  • @xxbigshamelxx8759
    @xxbigshamelxx8759 10 місяців тому

    Xbox holy shit bro this is ridiculous wtf is the point of a hard drive when u can’t play games on your hard drive tf is everyone supposed to do when they run out of space on it or your internal hard drive don’t have space then u need to transfer a game every time tf u think I bought the hard drive for smh

  • @sidster3321
    @sidster3321 7 місяців тому

    Great video. God bless you in Jesus's Powerful name..

  • @davodke6352
    @davodke6352 2 роки тому

    ssd external support all game for x/s or only for 8gen game?!

  • @meeekeeey
    @meeekeeey 2 роки тому

    Cool

  • @RideTheGamer
    @RideTheGamer 2 роки тому

    *wassup wassup*

  • @yusagorur7723
    @yusagorur7723 2 місяці тому

    Bro cut your nails

  • @ChrisKing-qp9dt
    @ChrisKing-qp9dt 11 місяців тому

    cut your finger nails.....

  • @yanislak
    @yanislak 2 роки тому +3

    Do « xbox series titles » include titles of past generation that have been updated and optimized for xbox series like Fortnite, RDR2, Battlefield 1/5 ect ?

    • @ivanfry6138
      @ivanfry6138 2 роки тому

      Correct. The Xbox would opt into the version optimized for it.