This Naturehike Star River 2 tent costs just £109 from Camperlists for the very latest version. This is exceptional value for money. www.camperlists.com/products/naturehike-star-river-2-upgraded?ref=azpizuhxua
I can buy it from the Naturehike Ebay store for AUD $175 here in Australia.....really enjoyed watching this video and it's exactly what I want. At almost 65, i hope i can get in and out of it 😂
I have the Cloud-up 2 and think that is a great tent. But after my last 10 days of backpacking through the Alps, I found that tents with a side entrance are more practical. Easier to get in, easier to get your stuff in, and when it rains you don't have that very sloped entrance door to get through (so you get wet). So I was already looking at this Star River one for a while and your review is certainly helpful. And though it's 300 grams heavier than the Cloud-up 2 (and I was actually looking for a lighter tent), I think I will be buying this model for 3 seasons and maybe the VIK as well for warmer regions.
I have the 2021 model. It is a true 2 person tent but it really does suffer from condensation as it only has one vent. This can be relieved a bit by really pulling out the ends to get a bit more airflow. It can be pitched fly first using the footprint but it is a faff. Also, in my opinion at +2kg it is too heavy. It is a big agnes clone but 600gm heavier. The advantages are the width and head height are excellent. It is well made and well stitched. Unlike the mongar it isn't all mesh. The star river's side walls have solid panels which are great in colder windier months. We took it on a 5 day hike in France. It did well apart from the weight and condensation.
It weights more because they take the floor saver weight into consideration also so don't be fooled a d that weight is not heavy at all I don't get this it's too heavy thing
@@SAMMIEJONESJUNIORyeah, I would like to see the true weight of each like for like I doubt there would be much in it, I seen one with the cloud up vs one similar 4 times the price and there was about 80 grams difference.
thx for the review. I bought the Star-river 2 for motorcamping. I usually camp solo and I need room for my bikinggear. Got a great deal on Amazon €129. I had some coupons for €100. So i paid €29 in cash! 😀
Just walked my fIrst long distance 150km hike with this tent and I was super happy…haven’t tried it in windy conditions but I. wet ones yes and it hold throughout the whole night of heavy raining. I can only recommend too had no issues at all and looking forward to more hikes with it. But I’ve just realised I’ve been pitching wrong the whole time 😄 never did the liner on the mat first but in actual tent 🤷♀️ it worked well though 😅
I wished they'd offer a Star River 1 for 1 person bikepacking. This tent seems way overkill for 1 person, whereas the Cloud Up 2 really is a 1 person tent with some bags and gear. And it needs to be also additionally available in olive/forest green for stealth camping.
Great film , thanks to your film , I had a naturehike star river 2 delivered today, going on a Lake District wild camp tomorrow, excited about trying this,
Brilliant review. I'm a fan of Naturehike tents after having the Cloud Up 2. The extra thought that's gone into certain features really sets them apart. Think this might be my next purchase 🙂
Brilliant review. This is going to be my next purchase. I'll keep my oex coyote 3 for the family and use this one for myself for longer hikes and wild camping.
Great review ... however, the tent lost me when I realised it doesn't pitch 'as one', I have a Nebula 2 and that does and it makes things a breeze. Love your videos so keep em coming!
The main reason these are overlooked for the cloud peak is that they pitch inner first. I had a mongar that is practically the same as the star river and returned it. It was a nice spacious tent but when going out with friends in their vango / hilleberg tents they were set up, unpacked and making a brew whilst I was still messing around with the tent. The cloud peak ground sheet, inner and outer can be left all connected. Chuck it on the ground, put the 3 poles across and clip it on, job done. I really do like the look of the star river but I know which one I’d rather set up / pack away in wind and rain : )
@@BackpackingUK I want more tents though haha. I fancy a lanshan next to cut some weight (but without spending z-packs money)… I use poles now anyway so might as well. Just need to decide on the exact version. Don’t fancy the single skin though.
I asked Naturehike Europe official Store on Aliexpress about upgrade version. Answer: "The difference between the upgraded tent and the normal version is the fabric of the tent." -_- ... i asked about detail... " The size of the tent has not changed, only the fabric of the tent has been upgraded". No comment...
what are the differences between the old and the upgraded version? I have the old one, and didn't find any differences between both...By the way, I absoltutely love this tent.. Its really great and spacious for one person!
Great review! I just ordered mine today and sent back a Naturehike (Spider) 1 person backpacking tent. Loved the setup but it didn’t have much headroom at all and only one door and vestibule. I really think this Star River is going to be a perfect fit for me!
Thanks for this review! I was dead set going to buy the Mongar 2 until I watched this review. I do prefer the Mongar design and I hate the Star River doors... But what sold me is the taller privacy walls. I wanted to minimise drafts across my face while sleeping in winter and was willing to put up with the stupid doors for that. Also, thanks to the popularity of the Mongar, the Star River I got was heaps cheaper ;)
If you intend to use the tent it winter the Star River 2 is much better than the Mongar 2. Watch my Sprinkling Tarn video, my mate was freezing in his Mongar 2!
@@BackpackingUK Also trying to decide between the Mongar and the Star River. Which one would you recommend for 3 season ~(March- Oct) UK mild weather use? Using OEX Fathom 300 sleeping bag
You should’ve just bought the mongar 2 modified inner with higher fabric wall like the star river and cloud up. They sell it through aliexpress. Then your problem would be solved
Have a look at the Campz Lacanau, it's basically a Mongar with non-mesh lower walls. They are likely made in the same factory with slightly different materials and waterproof ratings.
I bought the cloud up 2 but I’m not so fond of the walls that cave in. Really like the headroom in this, the fact that it has another door, and another vestibule. The extra weight/packing size on the SR2 is worth it I think?
Once you've had a twin-door tent it's quite hard to go back. My favourite tents tend to be free-standing dome tents because they are good in the wind and rain with less flapping and general noise. Personally, I think it's worth the extra weight but weight doesn't bother me too much. If I was going on long multi-day trips I'd go for the lighter option.
I bought some tents but i bought it for views. two sides can be flexiable to see where beautiul views are. I am hiker for views, It is not really ultralight but it is good for a week hike, I will bring it to JMT this year or next year.
Hi. What's upgraded about it? There's a new version been out a while that's 15d (blue) and only 1.8kg. Been looking at it as I'm 6'4 and it has good length and height.
Hi both. Both you guys have great channels 👏🏻 I'm torn between Cloud Peak 2 and Star River... im 6ft 2 and don't want feet touching ends / getting wet any advice?
Nature Hike doesn't seem to have any presence in UK and according to their website warranty is limited, customer has to pay for any returns, and sent items back to China. How's your experience with after sales service?
The need to first set up the inner with the poles and then put the fly on top is exactly why I'm actively avoiding this tent :P I really like the poles to either be on the outside of the tent or to have dedicated "tunnels" like the Quechua QuickHiker 2 I've been using for about 5 years now.
I used to buy a naturehike cloud up 2 on amazon and the tent pole was broken by me after using it for a year, I tried to find them for after sales, no response. So I tried to contact camper lists, they also sell. Since I bought a lanshan 1 before, I'm glad they were able to help me contact the naturehike factory to sell me new tent poles
does anyone know the difference between the upgraded versions and the old one..? the amazon naturehike shop sent me the old code and keeps telling me they don't make any differentiation between the two..
Hi. Great review. I’m new to your channel,but not new to camping. I’m looking for something a bit more ‘modern and lightweight’,to replace my 1996 Outbound Rocky,which I bought for a staggering £59.99! ( lot of money back then,it’s all relative). One of these look pretty amazing,and I may go for it. Regards.
Naturehike tents are excellent value for money and their designs are superb. If you're after a 2 person tent check out the Cloud Peak 2, Mongar 2 and Cloud Up 2 as well. If you check out my other videos I've reviewed the Cloud Peak 2 and Mongar 2.
Great video mate. I’ve had a cloud up 2 for the last few years and it’s served me pretty well. But I’ve been thinking a side entry tent will be better. Do you prefer this one to the cloud up 2?
From my experience, this applies to all tents. It happens when the tent it pitched too taught. To rectify, simply back off the guy roles a little and it will be fine.
Can you recommend a tent with similar footprint and good venting, but heavier materials? I just had delivered a Snugpak Journey Duo and although heavier, the material feels very durable and the whole seems well made. The only two cons are the smaller footprint for two and the lack of good venting.
The Naturehike Mongar 2 has much better ventilation (the fly is higher off the ground and theres more mesh). It's definitely a 3 season tent, perfect for summer. Check out that review.
@@BackpackingUK I compared them on Amazon and I'm not a tent expert, lol, but I couldn't see much difference between them. Some fabric differences. But maximum height is the same, footprint in the same and the mesh seems to be the same. I'll search on YT for more reviews.
No, that’s wrong. You can choose which side of each entrance to open. In the video the wind was coming from the left so I had the left side of the doors fixed and the right side open. If the wind was coming from the opposite side I would have reversed the doors. Hope this helps 👍
I had this tent and sold it to buy the Mongar. I really dislike the doors. Once opened they are laying on the floor. You get more head 10 mm more head room but loose out on symmetry. You can get a winter inner tent from 3fUL if you want to use it for the winter months.
Do you think it can be used in late autumn? Maybe even the version with the little skirt? I'm searching for a very versatile tent: near 2kg, 130cm of width and ventilated but well covered for colder months... obviously I don't wanna go at 2500m in winter with this, but do you think it can be good for max 1000m late autumn-begin winter?
Don't get the version with the skirt, it will be annoying in the wind and it will reduce ventilation. This is a proper 3 season tent so I would say late autumn should be ok as long as you have a decent sleeping bag and mat.
@backpackingUK Hi! Do you have any experience with the grey one when lit from within with a lamp? Is it kind of see through? I don't like the bright green one and the 20T dark green is too heavy for me.
I always say I think the best value tent out there is the Naturehike Cloud Peak 2. This is out of any brand tent. Hilleberg Allak 2 tent design for around £150. I love it and most other owners think the same too. This Star River 2 isn't far behind either.
@@BackpackingUK Thanks Andy I have the cloud peak 2 do love it. There is always compromises with weight and size. I really like my helm 1 compact great little sturdy tent. And my lanshan 1 plus. I have only been wild camping for less than 2 years but have 5 tents already .🤦♂️🤣🤣 Love your channel by the way Cheers Graham
Does it smell like fish as i can read in amazon reviews? And the outter tent also gets holes and rips after 4-5 times of usage? And is there really a lot of condensed water in the tent?
Hi Andy. Im STILL looking for a new tent to replace my 30 year old Outbound Rocky So far,it’s a toss up between this one and the Monger 2. So which one would you choose if you were me? Regards.
Hi! thx for the awesome review! I know you mentioned the dimensions on the video and description, but since I've bought a naturehike opalus II before and the measurements were actually less than what was announced(I'm 6'7'') so the dimensions are really important for me. Have you actually measured the inside of the tent to confirm the 215cm lenght? (because I myself am 2.02m tall) It would be super awesome if you could confirm that! I'd be glad to help you by buying from your affiliate link too if you helped me by measuring this! Thanks!
Most tent brands measure their tents from the very edges. If the fabric comes into the tent sharply often the real size of the tent is smaller (sometimes much smaller!). It also depends on how well the tent is pitched too. Unfortunately I don't really want to measure the tents myself as I don't want any comeback.
@@BackpackingUK i also think cloud up could be warmer because it has less internal space, but it has quite less solid mesh at the door. The star river has more solid mesh at the door. So i am not sure which one would be warmer
Yes, I think Naturehike have definitely borrowed the design. Definitely not half the quality though. Similar story with Naturehike's Mongar 2 and the MSR Hubba Hubba NX 2.
nice review, liked and sub .. oh wait, i already subscribed 😀 two questions: what's the upgraded part? what changed, compared to the version before, do you know? And second, what about ventilation and condensation issues? I've heard others reporting some problems in that area, especially compared to the Mongar 2. I'm still unsure which one to buy, but so far i'm leaning to the Mongar 2, 15D version ... Again, thanks, greetings from Germany
The Mongar 2 has more ventilation / mesh therefore less condensation. However, the Mongar 2 can get very cold so I tend to call it a summer tent. Great design though, it's based on the MSR Hubba Hubba NX2.
The main difference for me is the entrances. Personally, I like side entrances and having two is even better, so the Star River 2 is the winner for me. However, the Cloud Up 2 is lighter and better in poor conditions. Both are great tents though!
Looks great and look like their skipped the shoelaces to tie up the outer to the tent poles (looked really cheap ) i just wish they could do something about the doors to inner terrible idea ( gonne be used as a doormat at some point). And naturhike has this idea peps want white and limegreen tents why????? anyway a good review
I know what you mean about the door. I believe the new Cloud Peak 2 has the same door too. However, it's still a great tent and I think this is a minor issue.
Question! In the Naturehike video, they put the top pole below the transversal pole. Can you elaborate more? I'm a noob on camping stuff 🙂 thank you ua-cam.com/video/k1YKUfIdTbs/v-deo.html
Love your videos but hate any tent that pitches inner first. To me that is totally idiotic who,when it's raining wants a soaked inner tent. The designers of such tents obviously know nothing about camping!!!!!!!!!
Don’t understand why so many people have this hate for inner pitch first tents. Been a regular camper since early 1980s and can count on one hand the times I had no choice but to pitch in the rain. Too much is made of it. Besides that, the Star River - as with most inner pitch first tents - CAN be pitched outer first.
This Naturehike Star River 2 tent costs just £109 from Camperlists for the very latest version. This is exceptional value for money. www.camperlists.com/products/naturehike-star-river-2-upgraded?ref=azpizuhxua
Camperlists free tax
I can buy it from the Naturehike Ebay store for AUD $175 here in Australia.....really enjoyed watching this video and it's exactly what I want. At almost 65, i hope i can get in and out of it 😂
I have the Cloud-up 2 and think that is a great tent. But after my last 10 days of backpacking through the Alps, I found that tents with a side entrance are more practical. Easier to get in, easier to get your stuff in, and when it rains you don't have that very sloped entrance door to get through (so you get wet).
So I was already looking at this Star River one for a while and your review is certainly helpful. And though it's 300 grams heavier than the Cloud-up 2 (and I was actually looking for a lighter tent), I think I will be buying this model for 3 seasons and maybe the VIK as well for warmer regions.
Finally someone who knows how to do a review. Thank you for making it so that I feel like I'm there.
Thanks 🙏
I agree. Amazing review
I have the 2021 model. It is a true 2 person tent but it really does suffer from condensation as it only has one vent. This can be relieved a bit by really pulling out the ends to get a bit more airflow.
It can be pitched fly first using the footprint but it is a faff. Also, in my opinion at +2kg it is too heavy. It is a big agnes clone but 600gm heavier.
The advantages are the width and head height are excellent. It is well made and well stitched. Unlike the mongar it isn't all mesh. The star river's side walls have solid panels which are great in colder windier months.
We took it on a 5 day hike in France. It did well apart from the weight and condensation.
It weights more because they take the floor saver weight into consideration also so don't be fooled a d that weight is not heavy at all I don't get this it's too heavy thing
@@SAMMIEJONESJUNIORyeah, I would like to see the true weight of each like for like I doubt there would be much in it, I seen one with the cloud up vs one similar 4 times the price and there was about 80 grams difference.
The grey/white version of this tent reflects the heat better in hot weather!
thx for the review. I bought the Star-river 2 for motorcamping. I usually camp solo and I need room for my bikinggear. Got a great deal on Amazon €129. I had some coupons for €100. So i paid €29 in cash! 😀
Just walked my fIrst long distance 150km hike with this tent and I was super happy…haven’t tried it in windy conditions but I. wet ones yes and it hold throughout the whole night of heavy raining. I can only recommend too had no issues at all and looking forward to more hikes with it. But I’ve just realised I’ve been pitching wrong the whole time 😄 never did the liner on the mat first but in actual tent 🤷♀️ it worked well though 😅
Thanks for sharing!
I wished they'd offer a Star River 1 for 1 person bikepacking. This tent seems way overkill for 1 person, whereas the Cloud Up 2 really is a 1 person tent with some bags and gear. And it needs to be also additionally available in olive/forest green for stealth camping.
I feel the same. I hope they make a Cloud Peak 1 someday too!
got to agree with that on bikepacking. if only it could be lighter
I get mine tomorrow in forest green!! From Amazon $124 I have the Big Agnes HVUL 2 so I might do a video comparing them, great vid as usual thank you
I was led to believe it’s based on a Big Agnes tent. I didn’t realise they did a green one!
Can you please tell what exactly has been "UPGRADED" in this tent, compared to the old version.
Great film , thanks to your film , I had a naturehike star river 2 delivered today, going on a Lake District wild camp tomorrow, excited about trying this,
It's a great tent!
Brilliant review. I'm a fan of Naturehike tents after having the Cloud Up 2. The extra thought that's gone into certain features really sets them apart. Think this might be my next purchase 🙂
I genuinely really rate this tent!
@@BackpackingUK awesome, well I'll have the best of both worlds, I bought a new Mongar and just won a Star River 2 off ebay 😄
@@oscartravis5740 What is the difference between morgan and star 2 and which one is better? Thank you
Brilliant review. This is going to be my next purchase. I'll keep my oex coyote 3 for the family and use this one for myself for longer hikes and wild camping.
Great review ... however, the tent lost me when I realised it doesn't pitch 'as one', I have a Nebula 2 and that does and it makes things a breeze. Love your videos so keep em coming!
I know what you mean, my Cloud Peak 2 pitches as one. However, unless it's raining it's not really a problem. Thanks for watching 👍
The main reason these are overlooked for the cloud peak is that they pitch inner first. I had a mongar that is practically the same as the star river and returned it. It was a nice spacious tent but when going out with friends in their vango / hilleberg tents they were set up, unpacked and making a brew whilst I was still messing around with the tent. The cloud peak ground sheet, inner and outer can be left all connected. Chuck it on the ground, put the 3 poles across and clip it on, job done. I really do like the look of the star river but I know which one I’d rather set up / pack away in wind and rain : )
Yes, you can't beat an all-in-one pitch tent in the rain. I love my CP2!
@@BackpackingUK I want more tents though haha. I fancy a lanshan next to cut some weight (but without spending z-packs money)… I use poles now anyway so might as well. Just need to decide on the exact version. Don’t fancy the single skin though.
I've got both the Pro and Non-Pro 4 Season. Everyone buys the Pro but I say the traditional 4 season is much better.
@@BackpackingUK I think that’s what I’ll choose : )
I asked Naturehike Europe official Store on Aliexpress about upgrade version. Answer: "The difference between the upgraded tent and the normal version is the fabric of the tent." -_- ... i asked about detail... " The size of the tent has not changed, only the fabric of the tent has been upgraded". No comment...
Cracking review, and it looks very decent. Thanks for your time in putting this film together.
No problem 👍
what are the differences between the old and the upgraded version? I have the old one, and didn't find any differences between both...By the way, I absoltutely love this tent.. Its really great and spacious for one person!
I think in general Naturehike's 'upgraded' tents have better fabric material and fixings.
Great review! I just ordered mine today and sent back a Naturehike (Spider) 1 person backpacking tent. Loved the setup but it didn’t have much headroom at all and only one door and vestibule. I really think this Star River is going to be a perfect fit for me!
I think you definitely made the right choice!
Thanks for this review! I was dead set going to buy the Mongar 2 until I watched this review.
I do prefer the Mongar design and I hate the Star River doors... But what sold me is the taller privacy walls. I wanted to minimise drafts across my face while sleeping in winter and was willing to put up with the stupid doors for that.
Also, thanks to the popularity of the Mongar, the Star River I got was heaps cheaper ;)
If you intend to use the tent it winter the Star River 2 is much better than the Mongar 2. Watch my Sprinkling Tarn video, my mate was freezing in his Mongar 2!
@@BackpackingUK will do 👍 in in Perth western Australia though, so our winters are a little different from yours 😉
@@BackpackingUK Also trying to decide between the Mongar and the Star River. Which one would you recommend for 3 season ~(March- Oct) UK mild weather use? Using OEX Fathom 300 sleeping bag
You should’ve just bought the mongar 2 modified inner with higher fabric wall like the star river and cloud up. They sell it through aliexpress. Then your problem would be solved
Have a look at the Campz Lacanau, it's basically a Mongar with non-mesh lower walls. They are likely made in the same factory with slightly different materials and waterproof ratings.
Good thorough review, Ill probably choose this over the Mongar tent because of this good review, thanks
I would, the Mongar is definitely more suited to summer only.
Ooh been a while since your last NH tent review! Hope you & the family are doing great. Merry Christmas & Happy New Year!
You too, thanks for watching 👍
Good review. Thanks mate, I m buying it!
Really good review. I was thinking about the Mongar but you conivinced me of this one instead. Thanx.
No worries 👍
Love that tent !
This is a bargain!
Awesome review! How strong wind did this tent handle on your trekkings? Thanks!
It's not too bad in the wind but I would definitely advise using the additional guy ropes provided.
Thanks for the review. What part was upgraded? Between the mongar 2, cloud peak 2 and star river 2, which one do you recommend the most?
My favourite tent is the Cloud Peak 2. However, the Mongar 2 is a better summer tent. This is somewhere in the middle. All 3 are really good.
I bought the cloud up 2 but I’m not so fond of the walls that cave in. Really like the headroom in this, the fact that it has another door, and another vestibule. The extra weight/packing size on the SR2 is worth it I think?
Once you've had a twin-door tent it's quite hard to go back. My favourite tents tend to be free-standing dome tents because they are good in the wind and rain with less flapping and general noise. Personally, I think it's worth the extra weight but weight doesn't bother me too much. If I was going on long multi-day trips I'd go for the lighter option.
I bought some tents but i bought it for views. two sides can be flexiable to see where beautiul views are. I am hiker for views, It is not really ultralight but it is good for a week hike, I will bring it to JMT this year or next year.
Hi. What's upgraded about it? There's a new version been out a while that's 15d (blue) and only 1.8kg. Been looking at it as I'm 6'4 and it has good length and height.
Hi both. Both you guys have great channels 👏🏻
I'm torn between Cloud Peak 2 and Star River... im 6ft 2 and don't want feet touching ends / getting wet any advice?
Do you got Any advice for a tent?
A great value tent, certainly one I would consider buying.
For just over £100 you really can't go wrong. I'm genuinely really impressed with this tent.
Nature Hike doesn't seem to have any presence in UK and according to their website warranty is limited, customer has to pay for any returns, and sent items back to China.
How's your experience with after sales service?
Great review pal
Thank you very much.
No worries!
That 215cm length is great! Most of the other naturehike tents are 210.
The need to first set up the inner with the poles and then put the fly on top is exactly why I'm actively avoiding this tent :P I really like the poles to either be on the outside of the tent or to have dedicated "tunnels" like the Quechua QuickHiker 2 I've been using for about 5 years now.
I know what you mean, fair enough. Like I’ve said before, unless it’s raining to me it doesn’t matter if I have to pitch the inner first.
You can pitch fly first using the footprint similar to the way msr do it.
I used to buy a naturehike cloud up 2 on amazon and the tent pole was broken by me after using it for a year, I tried to find them for after sales, no response. So I tried to contact camper lists, they also sell. Since I bought a lanshan 1 before, I'm glad they were able to help me contact the naturehike factory to sell me new tent poles
Thanks for sharing!
Hi! great review and I love the tent but I don't like the doors placement of the zippers and the pegs. what tent pegs do you recommend?
Take a look at my tent peg review!
@@BackpackingUK I will! 👍
does anyone know the difference between the upgraded versions and the old one..? the amazon naturehike shop sent me the old code and keeps telling me they don't make any differentiation between the two..
Hi. Great review.
I’m new to your channel,but not new to camping. I’m looking for something a bit more ‘modern and lightweight’,to replace my 1996 Outbound Rocky,which I bought for a staggering £59.99! ( lot of money back then,it’s all relative). One of these look pretty amazing,and I may go for it.
Regards.
Naturehike tents are excellent value for money and their designs are superb. If you're after a 2 person tent check out the Cloud Peak 2, Mongar 2 and Cloud Up 2 as well. If you check out my other videos I've reviewed the Cloud Peak 2 and Mongar 2.
@@BackpackingUK Thanks. I will.👍🏾
Great video mate. I’ve had a cloud up 2 for the last few years and it’s served me pretty well. But I’ve been thinking a side entry tent will be better. Do you prefer this one to the cloud up 2?
I prefer 2 door tents but the downside is they tend to weight a little bit more.
Hi, in another review someone mentioned they had issues with zipping-up the tent as it was too tight. Have you ever experienced this problem ? Cheers
From my experience, this applies to all tents. It happens when the tent it pitched too taught. To rectify, simply back off the guy roles a little and it will be fine.
Can you recommend a tent with similar footprint and good venting, but heavier materials?
I just had delivered a Snugpak Journey Duo and although heavier, the material feels very durable and the whole seems well made. The only two cons are the smaller footprint for two and the lack of good venting.
The Naturehike Mongar 2 has much better ventilation (the fly is higher off the ground and theres more mesh). It's definitely a 3 season tent, perfect for summer. Check out that review.
@@BackpackingUK I compared them on Amazon and I'm not a tent expert, lol, but I couldn't see much difference between them. Some fabric differences. But maximum height is the same, footprint in the same and the mesh seems to be the same. I'll search on YT for more reviews.
Hey Andy, Nice review ☺️ I’ve hit the subscribe button. Ben from Uk wild camper ⛺️
Cheers Ben 👍
@@BackpackingUK my pleasure 👍🏻
Is it me, or does the supposed into wind end, also have the opening doors, which will provide no shielded vestibules and they'll act as wind socks?
No, that’s wrong. You can choose which side of each entrance to open. In the video the wind was coming from the left so I had the left side of the doors fixed and the right side open. If the wind was coming from the opposite side I would have reversed the doors. Hope this helps 👍
Do you think this tent would be better in hot climates, like Australia?
I wouldn't say that. It's probably more suited for the average climate. No too hot, not too cold.
I had this tent and sold it to buy the Mongar. I really dislike the doors. Once opened they are laying on the floor. You get more head 10 mm more head room but loose out on symmetry. You can get a winter inner tent from 3fUL if you want to use it for the winter months.
Interesting, thanks for sharing 👍
Any chance you could provide a link to the winter inner Richard? 🙏
Great review!
Thanks! 🙏
Do you think it can be used in late autumn? Maybe even the version with the little skirt? I'm searching for a very versatile tent: near 2kg, 130cm of width and ventilated but well covered for colder months... obviously I don't wanna go at 2500m in winter with this, but do you think it can be good for max 1000m late autumn-begin winter?
Don't get the version with the skirt, it will be annoying in the wind and it will reduce ventilation. This is a proper 3 season tent so I would say late autumn should be ok as long as you have a decent sleeping bag and mat.
@backpackingUK
Hi!
Do you have any experience with the grey one when lit from within with a lamp? Is it kind of see through?
I don't like the bright green one and the 20T dark green is too heavy for me.
It's not too bad, obviously it's not perfect, but it doesn't shine like a beacon.
Thanks for your fast reply as always!
Hi Andy
Always a tough question if you had only 1 tent you can keep which tent wound you pick ??
Cheers Graham
I always say I think the best value tent out there is the Naturehike Cloud Peak 2. This is out of any brand tent. Hilleberg Allak 2 tent design for around £150. I love it and most other owners think the same too. This Star River 2 isn't far behind either.
@@BackpackingUK
Thanks Andy I have the cloud peak 2 do love it.
There is always compromises with weight and size. I really like my helm 1 compact great little sturdy tent.
And my lanshan 1 plus.
I have only been wild camping for less than 2 years but have 5 tents already .🤦♂️🤣🤣
Love your channel by the way
Cheers Graham
@@BackpackingUK don’t you mean hilliberg soulo design ? Sorry if I’m wrong great videos
Does it smell like fish as i can read in amazon reviews? And the outter tent also gets holes and rips after 4-5 times of usage? And is there really a lot of condensed water in the tent?
That’s all nonsense!
Hi Andy.
Im STILL looking for a new tent to replace my 30 year old Outbound Rocky
So far,it’s a toss up between this one and the Monger 2.
So which one would you choose if you were me?
Regards.
Mongar 2 for a summer tent, Star River for a proper 3 season tent.
@@BackpackingUK Thanks. What would you suggest for a winter tent,then,Andy?
2.1kg is with additional ground matt?
Yes, including the ground mat too. You could save weight and leave it at home if you wished.
Hi! thx for the awesome review!
I know you mentioned the dimensions on the video and description, but since I've bought a naturehike opalus II before and the measurements were actually less than what was announced(I'm 6'7'') so the dimensions are really important for me.
Have you actually measured the inside of the tent to confirm the 215cm lenght? (because I myself am 2.02m tall)
It would be super awesome if you could confirm that! I'd be glad to help you by buying from your affiliate link too if you helped me by measuring this!
Thanks!
Most tent brands measure their tents from the very edges. If the fabric comes into the tent sharply often the real size of the tent is smaller (sometimes much smaller!). It also depends on how well the tent is pitched too. Unfortunately I don't really want to measure the tents myself as I don't want any comeback.
does it get warmer in the star river 2 in comparison with the 20D cloud up 2 in cold weather conditions?
I’d say the Cloud Up 2 would be warmer. It’s got less internal space, has a low fly and lots of solid mesh.
@@BackpackingUK thank you so much dear Mister :)
@@BackpackingUK i also think cloud up could be warmer because it has less internal space, but it has quite less solid mesh at the door. The star river has more solid mesh at the door. So i am not sure which one would be warmer
is it possible to build the tent also without the footprint to save some weight?
Yes, the inner goes up first.
Nice! I have a Hiby3. Its very good too.
Nice! I haven’t seen one of these out there yet.
Nice review. Almost identical to the big Agnes tiger wall. Suspect half the price though. Question is… is it half the quality?
Yes, I think Naturehike have definitely borrowed the design. Definitely not half the quality though. Similar story with Naturehike's Mongar 2 and the MSR Hubba Hubba NX 2.
nice review, liked and sub .. oh wait, i already subscribed 😀
two questions: what's the upgraded part? what changed, compared to the version before, do you know? And second, what about ventilation and condensation issues? I've heard others reporting some problems in that area, especially compared to the Mongar 2. I'm still unsure which one to buy, but so far i'm leaning to the Mongar 2, 15D version ...
Again, thanks, greetings from Germany
The Mongar 2 has more ventilation / mesh therefore less condensation. However, the Mongar 2 can get very cold so I tend to call it a summer tent. Great design though, it's based on the MSR Hubba Hubba NX2.
whats the difference between star river ang galaxy?
Do you know if I will be caught out by customs charges ordering from that site to the UK as its an American store?
Incorrect.
Are there any vents on the fly to help reduce condensation?
Yes, I missed this in the video, there’s a big vent on the big end.
Hi, great review. How tall are you if you don't mind me asking ? Cheers
I'm 5'8" or 172cm.
Realy nice reviews. Im happy I found your Channel. What tent do you think is warmer; the Naturehike cloud peak 2 or that starriver 2?
Good question! I think the Cloud Peak 2.
@@BackpackingUK thanks! What tent of them do you think is best for 2 adults?
I would definitely choose a tent with two doors / vestibules. Avoid the tent that just have one front entrance.
@@BackpackingUK thanks for all answers 👍👍
What is the up grade thanks
How would you compare it to the Cloud Up 2?
The main difference for me is the entrances. Personally, I like side entrances and having two is even better, so the Star River 2 is the winner for me. However, the Cloud Up 2 is lighter and better in poor conditions. Both are great tents though!
Great tent for the price but pitching the inner first puts me off, if you want a similar tent review the Decathlon Forclaz trek 500
Thanks for sharing!
Hi
What makes this a three season,but the cloud peak is four season?
Good question! The Cloud Peak isn’t a proper 4 season tent. However, the fly is a bit lower with a bit more solid mesh than the Star River 2.
Is this tent better than the mongar 2
No far is better in hot weather, this is for the rest of the time.
Have you used it in heavy rain?
Not yet, possibly this weekend!
Star river or mongar?
Can i use it in summer?
Yes, definitely!
Hello and thank you for this great video. woderful to hear proper english these days😍
Thank you! 😃
Are there other colors?
Yes, I’m fairly sure they sell it in green too.
WHAT I SEE IN THE FUTURE REDONDO BEACH PORT AND CARE OF BISNESSES
Looks great and look like their skipped the shoelaces to tie up the outer to the tent poles (looked really cheap ) i just wish they could do something about the doors to inner terrible idea ( gonne be used as a doormat at some point). And naturhike has this idea peps want white and limegreen tents why????? anyway a good review
I know what you mean about the door. I believe the new Cloud Peak 2 has the same door too. However, it's still a great tent and I think this is a minor issue.
Looks a lot like my Marmot Tungsten 2P.
Yes, I think it’s fair to say they find inspiration from other brands 😂
SOLD!
It’s a great tent 👍
Why do you call it “upgraded” ??
Rather than Naturehike call it a V2 they call it ‘upgraded’ instead.
@@BackpackingUK I bought mine like 5-6 yrs ago. Does this means that the newer one is different ??
TY
Question! In the Naturehike video, they put the top pole below the transversal pole. Can you elaborate more? I'm a noob on camping stuff 🙂 thank you ua-cam.com/video/k1YKUfIdTbs/v-deo.html
very thorough tutorial though. thank you 👍
Why do you review tents which are clearly aimed at the American/South Asia market... They are clearly a waste of time for the climate of the U.K
40% of my viewers are from the UK, so the majority are from abroad 👍
Love your videos but hate any tent that pitches inner first. To me that is totally idiotic who,when it's raining wants a soaked inner tent. The designers of such tents obviously know nothing about camping!!!!!!!!!
When people say this I totally understand! However, this does pitch quick.
Don’t understand why so many people have this hate for inner pitch first tents. Been a regular camper since early 1980s and can count on one hand the times I had no choice but to pitch in the rain. Too much is made of it. Besides that, the Star River - as with most inner pitch first tents - CAN be pitched outer first.
@@pootlingalong8928 can you actually pitch the outer first on this tent??