Naturehike Star River 2 Review - Is This Tent The One?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 47

  • @CampingSecretsUK
    @CampingSecretsUK  8 місяців тому

    Check the Latest Price: Naturehike Star River 2 Tent 👉 campingsecrets.co.uk/recommends/naturehike-star-river-2/

  • @freeforester1717
    @freeforester1717 11 місяців тому +9

    Do try to remember to place the top cross pole ABOVE the main arc pole, this pushes down on the main arc pole, helping to create additional structural strength in the tent frame and keeping the fabric taut. Set up as you have shown, if you imagine what might happen if the cross joint piece failed, your tent inner would collapse. The Naturehike Mongar has a better door and a symmetrical pole/inner fly arrangement ( so no difference in which way it goes up) in an otherwise similar design, and is highly regarded as such. Other “non-Chinese” brands often have their tents actually made in China also, so it is hard to see why a) they should be so much more price wise, and b)somehow vastly ‘better’ than Naturehike, a very well-established Chinese brand, just like 3F UL and Flame’s Creed are also.

    • @CampingSecretsUK
      @CampingSecretsUK  11 місяців тому +1

      Thanks for the advice - very useful! I think the problem with the cheaper Chinese brands is that they may have 'purloined' the design from the western brands and not paid for the privilege. Certainly goes on alot of the time.

  • @chrisw1090
    @chrisw1090 Місяць тому +2

    An interesting video. I bought this after a lot of other reviews and comparing it to the Mongar. Having less mesh was the thing that swung the choice to the Star River 2 and I find it an excellent tent. As others have said the cross member needs to be above the main spine pole of the tent to give it tension. I was surprised when you said there wasn't enough pegs and that is because you have chosen to use two pegs at each corner, I use one. I'm a cyclist and whilst weight is an issue perhaps more importantly is pack size. I find it far better to carry the pole separately which then allows the tent to be compressed down really small. With one vent I did worry about condensation but I haven't had a problem. For me the great pity is that the poles aren't external to the tent which would allow it to hang the flysheet and allow for it to be a outer/all-in-one pitch which is far more convenient for British weather.

    • @CampingSecretsUK
      @CampingSecretsUK  Місяць тому

      @@chrisw1090 great post Chris. I echo your thoughts completely

  • @DanishMumtazMirza
    @DanishMumtazMirza 10 місяців тому

    I am using this tent with snow skirts, it is amazing, I wild camped on Mam Tor in Peak District UK on a cold, windy and rainy night, it kept me dry and warm. Thanks for the review video.

  • @franklinwill22
    @franklinwill22 9 місяців тому

    Outstanding review on the product...thank you for your time!

  • @pootlingalong8928
    @pootlingalong8928 5 місяців тому +2

    Not sure, but I think you use just one peg at each corner to peg the footprint mat, then the poles go through the footprint and inner tent eyelets, then the fly attaches by way of the buckle clips - no need to use a second peg? Don’t want to be a know-all but just from watching other videos. I’ve just ordered the slightly cheaper version of this tent as I wanted the dark green and yellow colour way. Can’t wait for delivery in a week! Thanks for sharing your video 🤗

    • @CampingSecretsUK
      @CampingSecretsUK  5 місяців тому

      It's funny because after I'd published the video, I wondered why I had used so many pegs - yes you're totally correct! Every time I put the tent up in the wild I also make mistake after mistake - normally putting the fly on the wrong way round - the colour coding is difficult to follow for me. That being said, the tent hasn't let me down, and it's still my go to for a wild camp. Definitely buy some extra guy cords though 👌

  • @adrian-it8ps
    @adrian-it8ps 10 місяців тому

    Thanks for the detailed review! Could you let me know the length of the pole segments? I'm considering using this for bikepacking, shorter pole sections work better. Thank you!

  • @stevemullin1195
    @stevemullin1195 10 місяців тому

    They should make the footprint so it covers the vestibule areas also...I've got this tent but haven't used it yet on a biketouring trip. Was looking at the MSR hubba hubba 2 bikepacking tent due to it being half the weight of this tent plus it has places inside to hang your wet gear to dry overnight. Put its currently $580 USD and doesn't include the footprint.

  • @SomeRandoInternetPoster
    @SomeRandoInternetPoster 4 місяці тому +1

    I have this tent. It's good value, the only complaint is the outer door zips on the fly always jam when opening/closing.

    • @CampingSecretsUK
      @CampingSecretsUK  4 місяці тому

      Yeah agree on that. I always put it up wrong too 😂

  • @clsch7513
    @clsch7513 10 місяців тому

    Great review!
    Thanks a lot.

  • @warpiglet75
    @warpiglet75 Рік тому

    Hi! Great review. Are there pockets on the inside? Namely one to put your headlamp in so you can light up the inside of the tent?

    • @CampingSecretsUK
      @CampingSecretsUK  Рік тому +1

      Yeah there's a couple of pockets which are perfect for that

  • @tonnynijholt7090
    @tonnynijholt7090 6 місяців тому +1

    If you take the 210T version you will also get the inner tent in 210T, thicker material. Man that door is de only thing holding me back to order this tent. Leaning towards the Mongar 2 as well but the disadvantage for me is that is inner tent has such low walls...

    • @CampingSecretsUK
      @CampingSecretsUK  5 місяців тому +1

      Yes that's a good point. Remember the 210T is heavier too. Agree on the door. It's annoying!

  • @jaaa2055
    @jaaa2055 Рік тому

    Hi, it is great review, i' m also 195 cm, do you know other tents that have same high to seat normal on thick mat and the most important lengh to fit real 220-230 cm double layer ??

    • @CampingSecretsUK
      @CampingSecretsUK  Рік тому

      Vango Tay 200 is cheap and good but it's heavy. Plenty of space. Reviewing it at the moment!

  • @roadwarrior8560
    @roadwarrior8560 3 місяці тому +1

    Looks complicate to erect, what would you recommend for moto-camping in good weather? I'm fairly tall so need something roomy and easy and quick to erect, only really be camping in good weather I think. subbed.

    • @CampingSecretsUK
      @CampingSecretsUK  3 місяці тому +1

      So many options mate - if you're not so bothered about weight as you have a motorbike, I've been quite impressed with the Vango Tay 200 - it's two person and sets up really quickly. Under £100 too! campingsecrets.co.uk/recommends/vango-tay-200/

    • @roadwarrior8560
      @roadwarrior8560 3 місяці тому

      @@CampingSecretsUK Thanks, I'll have a look at that.

    • @roadwarrior8560
      @roadwarrior8560 3 місяці тому

      @@CampingSecretsUK Have you any experience of the Slumit Cub 2?

    • @CampingSecretsUK
      @CampingSecretsUK  3 місяці тому

      @@roadwarrior8560 heard that's a good biking tent. No direct experience of it tho. Could be worth a punt!

  • @TheMrLeozao
    @TheMrLeozao 8 місяців тому

    O que esta achando da barraca ? Comprei uma mongar, e acho que seria melhor uma starriver, tenho 1.94m mas acampo com minha namorada, melhor continuar com a mongar pelo espaco lateral mas apertado no cumprimento, ou a strriver com menos espaco lateral e mais comprimento? Lembrando que realmente vou usar em 2 pessoas, obrigado amigo, bom video 👊👊

    • @CampingSecretsUK
      @CampingSecretsUK  8 місяців тому

      ¡Vaya, eres alto! Creo que el Mongar es muy parecido al Star River. Personalmente, no puedo criticar al Star River y me alegro de que tenga más longitud. No dices qué tan grande es tu novia y eso es importante. Esta es una decisión difícil y lamentablemente no puedo darle una respuesta exacta. ¡Buena suerte!

    • @TheMrLeozao
      @TheMrLeozao 8 місяців тому

      @@CampingSecretsUK sem problemas amigo, um abraço do Brasil, mas um resposta curta, 2 pessoas altas, mongar ou starriver ? Sem explicações, apenas seco 😂😂😂

    • @CampingSecretsUK
      @CampingSecretsUK  8 місяців тому +1

      Mongar!

  • @batzpfsaddict2806
    @batzpfsaddict2806 7 місяців тому

    Im torn between this and the cloud peak 2 just wonder what made you choose this one over the other?

    • @ZookLife
      @ZookLife 5 місяців тому

      This is taller than the cloud peak 2 but also a bit heavier.

  • @ManojV80
    @ManojV80 6 місяців тому

    Nature Hike doesn't seem to have any presence in UK and according to their website warranty is limited, customer has to pay for any returns, and sent items back to China.
    How's your experience with after sales service?

    • @CampingSecretsUK
      @CampingSecretsUK  5 місяців тому +1

      I bought the tent on Amazon (with my own cash) and have not had to contact Naturehike since. I've had good use out of the tent and still use it regularly. You may get it cheaper on AliExpress

  • @streiklauzis87
    @streiklauzis87 Рік тому

    I see you bought an older model with the heavier 20D fly sheet. There are 3 versions of the Star River 2. The latest version with my diy 18€ Tesa Thermocover ground sheet and sowen extra gear loft weighs 1.88kg

    • @CampingSecretsUK
      @CampingSecretsUK  Рік тому +2

      I can only see two on their website. The heavier 210T and the 20D which I have. What's the third?

    • @abdelhakmeradi9433
      @abdelhakmeradi9433 Рік тому

      There's no third choice , I have one and it's a very good tent for all seasons , maybe he talk about the snow skirt version

    • @jonneleijenify
      @jonneleijenify 8 місяців тому

      The third option is the 15D fly sheet.

  • @letsupgrade360
    @letsupgrade360 Рік тому

    Awesome video 👏❤
    Sir, please pick another winner for giveaway as previous winner has not claimed his prize

    • @CampingSecretsUK
      @CampingSecretsUK  Рік тому

      cheers - the winner has come forward. There'll be more competitions in the future!

    • @Yorkshirelad84
      @Yorkshirelad84 Рік тому

      Great competition, awesome video with a great review 😊

  • @Radchenister
    @Radchenister 3 місяці тому

    Bar on top.

  • @keven8047
    @keven8047 2 місяці тому

    Wish companies would stop adding galvanizing to hiking tent poles. Adds too much weight

  • @fjdkfdfjdf33
    @fjdkfdfjdf33 10 місяців тому

    dude, you have your own money? :)

  • @nikikho
    @nikikho 6 місяців тому

    if you would have rolled the door/opening neatly and tucked it away as you should have , you wouldn't have said it's messy. what a newbie comment :))

    • @CampingSecretsUK
      @CampingSecretsUK  5 місяців тому +1

      it's more the fact that with the zip following a semicircle upwards, when you roll it up it's effectively along the floor. Definitely non-optimum, but if you disagree that's fine!