SHOULD We BLAME YOUTUBERS When CONTENT FAILS!?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 тра 2024
- Seeing the recent controversy about @mkbhd's recent review and all the controversy it stirred up on Twitter, inspired this video: about the responsibilities of UA-camrs who get to review products and content.
For more SnarkyJay...
Consider subscribing to my Patreon!: bit.ly/3MUrd6h
Follow me on Instagram: bit.ly/3GTPNjY
Check me out on Twitch: / snarkyjaycosplay
Your channel did not convince me that the MCU had gotten bad. I sought out content like yours because I saw the MCU had gotten bad and I wanted to feel less alone in that.
Totally agree.
👍
1000 wit it tho
Same here. I guess it's different with videogames and tech gadgets, but I don't watch movie reviews before I see the movie, I watch them afterwards to see what other people thought.
@@spacehamsterZHSnarkyjay is so hottttttt
Reviewer success is based on honesty, details, & sincerity. I'm not surprised corporate doesn't understand that.
Yep. All it takes is one dishonest cash grab to undo years of trust established with your viewership. Resist selling out.
I completely agree with you, Jay. A reviewer's responsibility is to tell their audience the truth, not to do commercials disguised as reviews.
I find it ironic that one of the few places left to get journalistic integrity is now from UA-camrs that let's face it use clickbait titles and not the so-called mainstreet media. Keep fighting the good fight.
UA-cam reviewers and commentators succeed by identifying with their audience. You value reviewers who generally steer you right. Hence despite the one-step-removed nature of making a decision about whether to part with money based on a review, get it from someone that has a financial interest in giving you the straight-up review, rather than someone that has one in promoting a company's product.
So if it still comes down to make a good product and reap a good reward, then nobody is to blame for failure but the creators.
I believe the issue isn't bad reviews, its the product being garbage and the fact that some people realize its garbage
No, studios and companies need to learn how to cope and deal with criticism
This is a relatively new practice/tactic. Did you ever see a movie star or executive attack Siskel & Ebert for their movie reviews? Nope. Those guys used to rip into movies like there was no tomorrow, and would disagree with each other and get into heated exchanges.
The flip side of the original complaint is that when a reviewer with a reputation for brutal honesty DOES like something, that shit is MADE.
gentle isn't in Jays vocabulary 😂😂
loved the Twitch stream
Boggles my mind how companies and studios are acting as if criticisms and reviews have only existed since the invention of the Interweb. Reviews and criticisms have been around since the dawn of humans. For entertainment - Siskel and Ebert reviewed / critiqued Movies for decades. TV Guide and various entertainment magazines reviewed and critiqued movies and TV shows for decades. Tech magazines such as PCWeek, eWeek, Computer Shopper, etc review and critiqued Tech for years.
I've seen some brutal reviews by Tech mags on big companies such as IBM, Microsoft and Apple for releasing horrible tech.
I remember reading some brutal opinions by Tech reviewers on the performance of various Tech CEOs such as Bill Gates and Steve Jobs.
If the opinion / review of one person can destroy a company, perhaps the company needs to re-evaluate the product that is being reviewed.
"...free finger food, and sandwiches and drinks..."
Duuuude. You got it made.
I love Jay's rants. Feels good to hear that passion.
We live in the dumbest timeline. Let's just all be polite about everything and agree about everything all the time leaving absolutely no space for individual or critical thought. Fuck that shit!
People didn't like our bad movie/tv-show? Let's Blame:
0. Ourselves & make better Movies/TV-shows
1. Men
2. Toxic Fans
3. UA-camrs
The problem is not with UA-cam reviewers, or reviewers on other platforms; the problem is a lack of accountability. It used to be, that people took pride in their work (some still do, of course) and they produced quality over quantity; Quality was job one, quantity came afterwards. Now, people want to produce, produce, produce, and quality of work is strongly lacking, if you find it at all. The entire point of an honest review, Is That It Be An Honest Review...The weird thing is, if they built a really good product, the product would sell itself. No stress, no blame.
First of all, you have shown Integrity with your reviews of these movies and shows. They're just mad that you haven't sold out to them like so many others have. I respect you for that. Second: the idea that they are trying to blame you and other UA-cam reviewers for their products failing is just as ludicrous as blaming the fans. It's their fault for not putting out good-quality in their content. Not you or us fans. THEM. Your Integrity/Honesty is sound. Rock On, Snarky Jay. 🙂
Well, we all know that there's rumours surrounding each and every major project (unless it's done in complete secrecy) : do you guys remember the rumour that The Batman movie would be one of the worst movies ever .... before it's release?
And.... there's also some info that might indicate that the producers are having a hard time coming up with a good product, such as release dates being changed repeatedly or movie directors being replaced.
Yet, once the movie is released... it is what it is : it might be good and appreciated by a lot of people while being hated by some.
Or it might be a very bad movie with a lot of people lambasting it for its low quality.
Historically, some great movies have failed at the box office.
Bad movies deserve to be ignored.
Unless it's a bad movie starring Nicolas Cage... then I'll watch it anyways.
It’s the same with these mcu shills on the internet. They get invited to premieres and give these mcu movies that are garbage 10/10. And when ppl believe it and see the movie themselves, it is completely different compared to their review. And they lose all credibility because of that
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏........well said.....that is the difference between a reviewer and a promoter ................
Happy Friday Jay!!! Great First Twitch Stream last night!!
Excellent commentary .There are some channels out there that give great reviews even though they know
the product was crap .To keep getting the free perks.
Of course they hate people being informed about the quality of a product and saving their time and money
That's why we respect snarky jay getting free stuff and still giving us true reviews
I enjoy coming to your channel and listening to your unapologetic truthful thoughts on whatever happens to be on your mind at the moment. Keep on doing what you're doing!
Such a magnificent display of rage!
Is that gasoline I smell?
The problem with Disney is that the mainstream media is on board with their agenda and the utubers are just doing an actual review.
Happy Friday Jay
Jay, I love what you do and the way you call it, just keep doing what you do. My favorite channels have called stuff that they have reviewed good because it was as per them and called out crap when they see.
Happy Friday Jay! Always making a good point!
Didn’t know you were getting so many kickbacks.. glad to see it doesn’t affect your reviews!!
Its so sad they know you are right Jay! I love your content because its honest, funny, and focuses on the type of content I really love. I agree with the majority of your reviews, but respect when I don't and am willing to check out movies where we differ just to see if I missed something. Keep up the good work!
I always appreciate when a UA-camr is honest about movies, shows, and other products.
You are 1000000% correct. Reviews of any kind should be your honest OPINION. They should be giving an honest opinion about the product or their trustworthiness drops, whether you agree with them or not.
Any artistic endeavor or project in the public eye is always open to criticism, praise, or condemnation. And anyone that says otherwise is some one that would want to suppress and censor the public.
I heard about the controversy they’re trying to hit him with. I subscribed to his channel and liked two of his controversial videos. Never watched the guy before. Not an early adapter of tech usually. But I’m supporting him now.
This goes more in tech UA-camrs. Like LTT a few months ago when they knew they were testing new tech the wrong way, then blamed it on the engineers. By the time the truth came out, the companies were scrambling around doing everything they could to save themselves. But their brand was ruined.
This doesn’t really go to UA-camrs who do nerd culture or anything else really.
Another amazing video Snarkyjay ❤❤😁😁.
Madam Snarky, i appreciate tf out of your reviews, and of course cosplay. Honesty, is by far, the most important. Thank you for your content gurl 🥂✨
it's midnight here and i love you for saying we're all thinking
;)
Your blunt honesty, and cuban snarkiness is why I watch you, thanks for being true.
I respect your honesty and integrity because you are still a relatively new and "small" UA-camr working your way up and you still give your honest opinion.
Marquess is a multi- millionaire so he's at a point where he can give no f's and say negative things. I guarantee when he started out, he grifted and said what he had to to make money and get more views as do most other UA-camrs.
Honest unbiased opinions is all anyone should ask for. You said it integrity, it's the reason I follow and respect you🙌 Awesome content as always
I've been following you for a couple of months, and for the most part your opinions have matched up with mine. Not always, but enough that I feel confident that when you get early access to a movie, or tv show, and you say it isn't worth my time/money I'm inclined to believe you.
I totally agree .
What did the cooking class for The Evil Dead teach you to cook? Haha that's fucking awesome.
At this point, they should just release a film titled 'Heaping Pile of Dog Shit'....in IMAX....with Will Ferrell. Nothing better than just "steering into the skid".....
Yep, many UA-camrs like the perks too much and people can no longer trust their word.... Once you lose your integrity and the public trust it's nearly impossible to get it back.
I follow mkbhd because I am in the tech industry. I think he is one of the most honest and ethical people on UA-cam. If there was someone I would like to be like, it would be him. He didn't go hard like you. He gave a fair review and then he followed it by reviewing another product in the same industry and the review was similar. The truth is that in the AI space, the products are not fully developed. To tell the truth, I would love to hear you review the same product and call it a piece of SH*T!! If Mr. Brownlee says something sucks, it sucks. If he says it is a great product, I will purchase it. Over a long period of time he has earned the trust and respect he has. When it comes to entertainment, I trust The Drinker and then you. Love to hear you rant. Keep up the great work.
There has been a war against any and all negativity or criticism... that's just where the world is at with its audiences and now corporations or big businesses can use that logic to fight any criticism they get. Hope it doesn't work but sometimes we see people defending their fave corporations so it's already kinda there
Thanks for being Honest Abe about all the perks of going to premieres and having to be honest at the same time. I can remember one podcast where the young lady was taken by Warner Bros to the London(England) Premiere of Birds of Prey which was quite splashy with a big afterparty following the film. Of course her review was that the movie was Aaaaawesome.
Just one nitpick though. Daisy Ridley didn't deserve any social media blowback but Tatiana Maslany and the creative staff on the show were doing the attack the fans and mock the viewers tactic from the get go so they are fair game for criticism. Though you should check out all the wildly anti semitic stuff said about Gal Gadot for neutral messaging about her country or Zoe Saldana being bombard by racist remarks for defending Chris Pratt. None of those came from fans of YT channels but just the general public online.
Great video. You're an extremely articulate, intelligent and thoughtful young lady
Sorry I missed your livestream yesterday, hope it went well
I always go back to the kings of movie criticism Siskel and Ebert, they are the reason why I stopped listening to movie critics because one gives a thumbs up and the other a thumbs down, I'm the type of guy that watches the movie first then I'll check out film reviews from others and so far you have been on point... Except for the Godzilla x Kong movie which I happened to enjoy 😊 but what I love about you is that you don't bash those that like or love something you hated, and this is why I'll forever be your fan ❤️
There’s an episode of Friends, where Feebee is invited to sing at an elementary school. She ends up singing about death and divorce. She is fired, but at the end the kids go to find Feebee and they ask “are you the woman who sings about the truth?”
I think that’s what’s happening with Marques. The more corporations get up set with his reviews, the more credibility he gets. This is an easy hill to die on.
Thank you for giving your honest opinion. It's not your fault or any other UA-camr's fault recent entertainment is shitty it's the company's fault for not caring about the audience trying to force us to like their stuff they made to check off DEI boxes like you said. The people that run the companies & actors like that Tatiana Salami need to stop blaming fans & telling fans to shut up they are in major denial that their shit sucks, everytime I hear SheHulk it's like I got PTSD from seeing her and Magyn Thee Stallion twerk and everytime someone shows it it's so horrific.
If creators and manufacturers put out sub-standard products, you have every right to tell us about it. If we want to see for ourselves and get taken, it’s shame on us. With your platform and influence, it is time for “creators” to listen to you Jay, because you have a passion for the material they obviously lack.
Many years ago, the very influential British motoring journalist Jeremy Clarkson did a scathing review of the GM Vauxhall/Opel Vectra, describing it as "bland and awful, designed by comittee" etc.
Despite this, the Vectra went on to be one of the UK's best selling family cars.
If your product is sound, you have nothing to fear from critics...
Stand by your feelings always much respect and admireration for you stay snarky Jay
Tienes toda la razón, Esnarky
Have a blessed weekend, Jay 🫶❤️
7:20 oh, I’m sorry, but I gotta have my dose of salmon patties here in North Carolina yum yum 😋
AMEN preach it Sister!
Why are her videos so darn compelling now? It's like I can't look away.
I agree, very well said😍
It's pretty idsturbing the type of opinion/review manipulation that is going around. I do really admire your integrity, it was definitely something that got me into your channel, hearing honest reviews. Also, I'd never seent he Loki outfit before, very nice.
and that snarky jay, is the snarky way💯
Can't tell you how sick I am of people blaming the Plinkett reviews for Lucas selling Star Wars to Disney.
Screw politeness. If a product sucks, say it.
Let's be real -- honesty and truth hurts. And that's OK. Because going forward, you either sulk and cry, or learn from the mistakes to get better. Embrace the failure, embrace the honesty.
And that's what reviewers of all shapes and sizes are meant to do -- inform the companies on what was a success and what was a failure. And, inform the general audience (i.e.: consumers) from their unique experiences and in the end letting the audience make the decision for themselves to either go see that film you didn't like or buy that product you didn't like for their curiosity. At the end of the day, weather I agree with some reviewers, I try to be civil.
This is actually a fairly serious issue. Dissent is essential in a free society. The ability to express a different point of view is vital not only for democracy but also for free thought. The ability to make a [profit should be the last consideration as this is an issue that involves out very ability to think and form opinions independently. People need the ability to debate the truth or else it is never discovered and lies are free to be sold as the only "truth." Truth is not a commodity that can be sold or bought. Seeking the truth is an ongoing process for any individual person and it is their responsibility alone to discover that truth.
I agree with you Snarky, I found the MCU going downhill before I came across your channel… Same goes with Disney and Star Wars….
When I found Snarky Jay in this universe, I said Hey someone agrees with me about Disney/Marvel. Cool I don't have to keep watching because I agree with Snarky Jay. If anything, she is sacrificing her mental health for us by watching this movies.
If anything if i was a company and I released a new product i think I'd go out of my way to get Marques to review my products and use the feedback to improve
You tell them, Jay!!!! Truth!!!
No! It's the writers producers directors actors and movie studio executives who failed us. That's why our entertainment industry is hemorrhaging 💰. It's this victim mentality, blame everyone else for our failures. Bc they can't possibly be to blame.
as a human, its validating to hear others agree with my opinions. And its great to hear opposing viewpoints too because you might learn something. I came to this chanel for the face, and I stayed because of the snark lol 😅
We had Games Master in the 90s that gave reviews and demonstrations of games. It did what you do and effected the games market back then in the UK.. its not a new thing its now we have 10x the releases
I enjoy Watching your VIDEOS I think you are a very kind person 😇
Good. Excellent. If a company is going to make garbage, charge $700+ to buy it and then a monthly subscription - FOR GARBAGE - then they SHOULD go out of business. Two thumbs up. I watched his review when it was new and it seemed totally fair an accurate. And lots of people are saying its a bad device.
If a company wants a product reviewed, they are opening themselves to both positive and negative critiques. They have no right to kid gloves when it comes to that critique. Fairly simply honestly.
You want someone that does a deep review dive in a product. You don't want something that is trash but yet costs an Arm and a leg. As for movies, the studios need to worry about their storytelling and not critics.
While I feel you're a lil bit harsh on things occasionally your points about the pros & cons of things are SEVERLY well thought out and expressed. And you're harsh about things that you're passionate about. Which makes perfect sense as when you're passionate about something, and it... sucks then of course you're going to be more harsh about things than an average person would be. So yeah I love what ya do, keep it up Jay as you're killing it at what you're doing
*💥May the 4th be with you this weekend!💥*
I don´t trust corporations. I trust hot women on the internet.
Jay once again proving she’s goated 🫡🫶🏽 I hate celebs cuz most of them are sell outs
Honest criticism and reviews
Great video, Snarks.
FWIW, I followed your Twitch channel...👍
It's funny how perfection is demanded of us, but for the super rich the rules are more slack apparently.
That's it! Am blaming youtubers when I fail at my job.
Back in the day before the Internet, movie reviewers generally worked for newspapers, magazines, or broadcast news. The reviewers themselves did not pay to see the movie being reviewed. Sometimes the studio would sponsor it but usually the newspaper bought the tickets. So, what you do to review movies has a long history and is non-controversial. A reviewer’s honest opinion is what readers and followers want. You owe no one explanations and criticisms of critics is like the critics’ work itself, it’s an opinion. People need to lighten up and put things into perspective. Not blame reviewers for bad movies or products.
An objectively honest review is a good review.
Keep up the great work
We are living in the softest of times. Things are going to get a lot tougher.
When did Hollywood & Silicon Valley forget the fact everybody is a critic?
"If I let that influence a review, then every movie I've ever seen [...] would be given 10 out of 10. [...] You would think I was a f... sell-out, because you can't trust me any more." Well, you just described the dilemma for modern movie "journalists".
Hi. As a new UA-camr, I will never get blamed because I wanna be a star. I love your channel anyway.
No, Snarky we shouldn't blame youtubers. It's the elites, their executives, our government, and their arrogance that is destroying companies.
Toy makers, including Hasbro, have been sending packages for years to UA-camrs on the understanding that they give them positive reviews. This isn't new for the community. You can't really take any review one hundred percent genuinely, and must judge based on UA-camr's previous content, if they mean what they say. It's too easy to become a commercial for item/service/etc. A very good and hopefully eye opening (to some) video
Dune part 1 strained my brain and turned it into mush trying to comprehend the appeal that others saw in it.... p.s. normally a fan of sci-fi :/ ...as much faults as I found with the original Dune at least I generally liked the demeanor and acting better in that one, tho it was a little off kilter.
People listen to reviewers who have a similar taste in content. Like with any reviews, it doesn't stop me seeing something I'm really keen to see, unless the reviewer mentions specific issues in quality. But, saying something is great when it's not, is misleading, we lose trust in the reviewer. When someone like MKBHD reviews something, companies should listen and learn, not try to trick their potential customers, same applies to content from streaming companies.