Then they weren't paying attention during the training, this shouldn't shock a dispatcher who hasn't even seen a dead body, besides, that voice didn't sound like someone in shock, it sounded like someone unbothered @@NHWatching
Damn, imagining Roberto getting betrayed like that is chilling. One minute, going down the stairs, the next getting clobbered and assaulted, trying to fight for your life. Before you can figure out why your family is doing this, you're getting hammered to death. Then they mutilated his body, set him on fire, and lastly ruined his name as someone who deserted their family.
What is particularly chilling is that this cruelty came from those Caraballo trusted and lived with. The betrayal by a spouse and a stepdaughter underscores a profound moral corruption, as they turned familial bonds into instruments of murder. This case highlights how human beings can rationalize and carry out extreme acts of violence, completely dehumanizing their victims in the process.
I agree. My brother Bobby was murdered when I was a kid. He was a golden glove boxer. He walked up to a party & a guy was beating up his girlfriend in the front yard. My brother intervened & whooped the guys ass. The next day, Bobby was on his way to practice riding his bike: and he stopped at the corner store. The guy he beat up, the stupid girlfriend that he saved, & a couple more dudes kidnapped my brother. They took him down by the river, tortured him before brutally murdering him. They all got off light did maybe 10 years each. No regard for his bright future. Snuffed out for nothing. Anyways; I find comfort in these assholes getting their karma. Love & light to you all.
@@felicianafullmer8552 I'm deeply sorry for your loss and what happened to Bobby. It's heartbreaking to hear about such a tragic and senseless act of violence. Your brother's bravery and kindness in stepping in to help someone in need shows the incredible person he was. While nothing can undo the pain, I hope you find some solace in knowing that karma often finds its way. Sending love and light to you and your family. Stay strong.
Most of them give off asshole vibes ever now and then you Will get one that saves the day and is on point but it's like they're clueless most of the time
I read up a lot about this case cos before he was identified I always wondered if the victim was my uncle who went missing around the same time, and from what I know, it was the police who name him Jack in the Box. like even on official police reports and things like that he was classified under that name so even though it might seem disrespectful, I think they are just being accurate, which I personally appreciate
Right the cold and ask many ? send a police hello it was done to me when my son was diagnosed diabetes and he was pale and took for ever to send Ambulance
M7 Crime Storytime I just found your channel this evening and I'm hooked! I became an instant subscriber! My favorite videos are the shorter ones as the 3hr ones are a bit much for me. I enjoy both the stories as well as your voice. 🤗
The narrator has the best voice , so soothing despite the crimes presented ! Reminds me sometimes of the narrator of Forensic Files , Mr. Peter Thomas! Not the voice itself but how calming it is .
I read up a lot about this case cos before he was identified I always wondered if the victim was my uncle who went missing around the same time, and from what I know, it was the police who name him Jack in the Box. like even on official police reports and things like that he was classified under that name so even though it might seem disrespectful, I think they are just being accurate, which I personally appreciate
If Deneen was the instigator and primary perpetrator she wouldn't have called in the tip about the identity of the John Doe. The person with a pathological need to be in control claiming they didn't know what was happening in their own house is ludicrous.
I commented in depth about this. We don't even know how old Dineane was when the murder took place. She was absolutely manipulated by Beverly. Thanks to Dineane this case was solved. Her lawyers failed her by not arguing mitigating circumstances. Beverly had her kids go to burn the body hoping they'd keep quiet. I think she fabricated the abuse too.
It is a really stressful job. I agree some are a little far fetched but being a 911 dispatcher is not easy. You are on the phone with someone that needs help and all you do is talk to them and get as much information as you can. There has been many times I just wanted to crawl through the phone and help them. It really weighs on you heavy and it is mentally draining. You have to have that , for a lack of better words, coldness or you will lose your mind. I cannot even count how many times I got off shift and sat in my car and cried.
🕊️🥀This channel has fast becoming my #1 true crime channel!!! You are so good with bringing details and facts to a case. All the criminals should have gotten life with no parole!! RIP Roberto!!💔🙏🏽
Wow that’s an incredible story so far. U guys are really incredible with your informative videos such great detail and breaking down these cases with such precision well done.
What happened to the death penalty? If the wife was missing the husband would be in prison right away, but when the husband is dead and the wife is a killer the court will look the word “ self defense “ to let the wife go for free
Jack in the box?! Really tho? Smh I've never heard anything more disrespectful said about a deceased person! So wrong on so many levels and I know all y'all in the comments will agree on how disgusting that is to say!
How old was Dineane at the time? Am I the only one who thinks she was manipulated by Beverly? Dineane was the person who came forward, gave the John Doe a name, a backstory, providing the only lead. She WAS involved in Roberto's murder- I think that she only did it because of her mother. Beverly probably fed her the lies about the abuse of her sisters. If Dineane hadn't participated Beverly may have killed her too. I respect Chris for being honest. I despise Beverly for blaming it all on Dineane. I truly believe Dineane thought she was innocent. Whether or not she truly was, is a different story. She deserved to spend some time behind bars but not life. Her lawyer failed her. There was sufficient evidence to introduce mitigating circumstances. That tyrannical woman ruled with an iron fist. Taking all her kids to burn/dispose of the body was deliberate. Beverly believed if they were all involved then they would all keep quiet.
Beverly was the mastermind behind Roberto's death & she didn't care who she blamed. My heart goes out to sweet Sicily as it appears her Dad did change his life and gave her structure and love. Did they ever investigate her other missing spouse? 😳
I know this is minuscule in this story but that 911 operator immediately pissed me off. Way too many calls I’ve heard where these ppl suck at their job! Just my opinion
The cruelty and the brutality involved in this case is mind boggling and is beyond diabolical. All three of them had no remorse or regret for what they had done. I wonder why Deneen ever reveal about the murder. I am sure that all three of them were fighting and wanted to get on each other's back. Deneen surely had a grudge against her mother Beverly for some reason, probably financial motive.
Im guessing that anybody can b a 911 dispatcher in those days and nowadays. Like, isn’t it their jobs to take every call serious!?!?!? Whether joke or not!?!????
It’s wild that when they found her to be the step daughter she gave them all the info if she said she knew nothing other that he left the house one day and never came back they would have gotten away with it .. idk how the mom got second degree is wild tho
Thankfully, for Beverly, there was a crowbar on the stairs, and she was agile enough to twist her body to hit him on the head while he's grabbing her ankles. (1st story) 🙄
Documentary idea was a good idea. What a bunch of psychos! OMG! These people had been walking down the street like nothing ever happened all those years. I don't think I believe the abuse allegations against Roberto. . The mom was clearly the abuser.
The fact that this channels narrator keeps repeating this disgusting and disrespectful "Jack in the box" reference to a deceased person really pisses me tf off! Sooo gross!
Wtf is wrong with 911 operator? I called 911 in Memphis Tennessee to report a 100÷ pound dead dog in the road one night to avoid traffic accidents. The diversity hire told me I needed to call animal control. I informed her that I was driving and she needed to do her job before the dog caused a traffic fatality
Of course she want him out he was being a dad for he’s daughter and she wanted to get high and probably jealous of he’s relationship with the daughter Roberto was handsome no wonder he’s daughter is beautiful
Poor Roberto. I'm glad his beautiful daughter Sicily has remained loyal and caring toward him 💜
What's the 911 operator's problem?
No kidding
The more I watch these the more I think they are just all terrible people.
Probably just shocked, having never received such a call before...
I thought they did okay.
Then they weren't paying attention during the training, this shouldn't shock a dispatcher who hasn't even seen a dead body, besides, that voice didn't sound like someone in shock, it sounded like someone unbothered @@NHWatching
I think the first requirement to become a 911 operator is a terrible attitude
“what do you mean a body?” really pissed me off. cause like what else could that possibly mean
Damn, imagining Roberto getting betrayed like that is chilling. One minute, going down the stairs, the next getting clobbered and assaulted, trying to fight for your life. Before you can figure out why your family is doing this, you're getting hammered to death. Then they mutilated his body, set him on fire, and lastly ruined his name as someone who deserted their family.
This is one of my favorite channels I listen to them all night every night thanks for all your hard work truly
Thank you for watching. I am glad you are liking the channel. Much appreciated
Thanks for listening
What is particularly chilling is that this cruelty came from those Caraballo trusted and lived with. The betrayal by a spouse and a stepdaughter underscores a profound moral corruption, as they turned familial bonds into instruments of murder. This case highlights how human beings can rationalize and carry out extreme acts of violence, completely dehumanizing their victims in the process.
I agree. My brother Bobby was murdered when I was a kid. He was a golden glove boxer. He walked up to a party & a guy was beating up his girlfriend in the front yard. My brother intervened & whooped the guys ass. The next day, Bobby was on his way to practice riding his bike: and he stopped at the corner store. The guy he beat up, the stupid girlfriend that he saved, & a couple more dudes kidnapped my brother. They took him down by the river, tortured him before brutally murdering him. They all got off light did maybe 10 years each. No regard for his bright future. Snuffed out for nothing. Anyways; I find comfort in these assholes getting their karma. Love & light to you all.
@@felicianafullmer8552
I'm deeply sorry for your loss and what happened to Bobby. It's heartbreaking to hear about such a tragic and senseless act of violence. Your brother's bravery and kindness in stepping in to help someone in need shows the incredible person he was. While nothing can undo the pain, I hope you find some solace in knowing that karma often finds its way. Sending love and light to you and your family. Stay strong.
Just wanted to say, that was really well written. It's refreshing to see a fully formed, clearly stated thought in the yt comments. ❤
Dispatcher pissed me off with that dumb ass question 😒
Most of them give off asshole vibes ever now and then you Will get one that saves the day and is on point but it's like they're clueless most of the time
Shitty attitude too. It’s the type of job that requires endless patience. Some people that do it are poorly suited.
Calling him jack in the box is so disrespectful
No worse the the " boy in the box" look it up
At least he got a name here
Or it could of been " John in the box "" witch sounds like Johnny on the spot .
Pffff….😫
I read up a lot about this case cos before he was identified I always wondered if the victim was my uncle who went missing around the same time, and from what I know, it was the police who name him Jack in the Box. like even on official police reports and things like that he was classified under that name
so even though it might seem disrespectful, I think they are just being accurate, which I personally appreciate
what do you mean a body? "A DEAD PERSON"😐
I caught that. Like its 911 lady wtf do you think he means by a body? What the hell else would he mean??
yeah that shoud be quote of the year! how thick is that dispatcher
Lighten up guys, think about the thirty-five times someone's reported a dead possum like that. It's funny but it's not that critical.
“What part of “a body” are you having trouble with!?”
One thing I’ve learned from watching true crime, is that A LOT of dispatchers are not very bright.
It could be so burned he couldn't tell the gender.
I wonder though if BECAUSE of prank calls, like, I'd like to report a body
Of Water😂😂😂
Which is funny
But still.......
@@sharonmccarton2817 hahahaha
She probably would have understood if he said 'I'd like to report a mannequin'.
These stories are wild! Thanks for sharing 🫶🏽
I was my mothers henchchild, as well. I absolutely can not imagine having my children do my dirty work. But many "mothers" see no issue with it🤦🏼♀️
"What do you mean a body?" What was that dispatcher smoking? Smh
😂
A body of water?
A body of an animal @@bujfvjg7222
There are many 911 operators that shouldn’t be allowed out in public let alone in emergency situations
😂 agree
Right the cold and ask many ? send a police hello it was done to me when my son was diagnosed diabetes and he was pale and took for ever to send Ambulance
😅these dispatchers are there for our comic relief.
M7 Crime Storytime I just found your channel this evening and I'm hooked! I became an instant subscriber! My favorite videos are the shorter ones as the 3hr ones are a bit much for me. I enjoy both the stories as well as your voice. 🤗
The narrator has the best voice , so soothing despite the crimes presented ! Reminds me sometimes of the narrator of Forensic Files , Mr. Peter Thomas! Not the voice itself but how calming it is .
Yesss! I absolutely LOVE Peter Thomas. Forensic Files is what got me into true crime.
I can’t understand what he’s saying.
Jack in the Box is so disrespectful
Extremely...and to keep saying it. It's one thing if that's how they described him but John doe or victim would be appropriate
Very
😂makes me think of Jack in the box 📦 fast food place 😂
Might as well call him 😂😂 jig a 👻 in a box huh?
I read up a lot about this case cos before he was identified I always wondered if the victim was my uncle who went missing around the same time, and from what I know, it was the police who name him Jack in the Box. like even on official police reports and things like that he was classified under that name
so even though it might seem disrespectful, I think they are just being accurate, which I personally appreciate
"what do you mean a body?" Seriously, of course its a human dead body, Why ask stupid questions. Rip Roberto.
If Deneen was the instigator and primary perpetrator she wouldn't have called in the tip about the identity of the John Doe. The person with a pathological need to be in control claiming they didn't know what was happening in their own house is ludicrous.
I commented in depth about this. We don't even know how old Dineane was when the murder took place. She was absolutely manipulated by Beverly. Thanks to Dineane this case was solved. Her lawyers failed her by not arguing mitigating circumstances. Beverly had her kids go to burn the body hoping they'd keep quiet. I think she fabricated the abuse too.
It is a really stressful job. I agree some are a little far fetched but being a 911 dispatcher is not easy. You are on the phone with someone that needs help and all you do is talk to them and get as much information as you can. There has been many times I just wanted to crawl through the phone and help them. It really weighs on you heavy and it is mentally draining. You have to have that , for a lack of better words, coldness or you will lose your mind. I cannot even count how many times I got off shift and sat in my car and cried.
🕊️🥀This channel has fast becoming my #1 true crime channel!!! You are so good with bringing details and facts to a case. All the criminals should have gotten life with no parole!! RIP Roberto!!💔🙏🏽
Man this is the best channel to listen to at night the voice will knock you out
@@richardc2410but I get nightmares
"Yes I'd like to report a body 😀"
Imagine any one of us waking up to a burned body in a box on our property??? What a f*cking nightmare.😮
I don’t think he woke up
@@geminimac613reread again 😂
@@oluwafunkezeey7457 whoops 😬 🤦🏾♂️🤦🏾♂️🤣
that dispatcher needs sacking - poor caller has had a shock of finding a body and she is nothing but rude and aggressive
Wow that’s an incredible story so far. U guys are really incredible with your informative videos such great detail and breaking down these cases with such precision well done.
So what happened to the Jamaican husband who's missing to this date? Renee?
Beverly probably manipulated some folks into killing him...
Operator: "..what do you mean a body?" Wtf?! Did she think he meant a body of a water??
😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂
DEI hire.
What happened to the death penalty?
If the wife was missing the husband would be in prison right away, but when the husband is dead and the wife is a killer the court will look the word “ self defense “ to let the wife go for free
Why didn't they check the local gas stations to see if anyone bought petrol in a canister?
Due Justice…may the daughter find peace!
I can’t take these dispatchers… wtf did you think he meant by body 😑
Nice job on the video! I hadn’t heard of this story before and it was really well told! New subscriber 🎉🎉🎉
Awesome! Thank you!
@@M7CrimeStorytime thank YOU!
Jack in the box?! Really tho? Smh I've never heard anything more disrespectful said about a deceased person! So wrong on so many levels and I know all y'all in the comments will agree on how disgusting that is to say!
How old was Dineane at the time? Am I the only one who thinks she was manipulated by Beverly? Dineane was the person who came forward, gave the John Doe a name, a backstory, providing the only lead. She WAS involved in Roberto's murder- I think that she only did it because of her mother. Beverly probably fed her the lies about the abuse of her sisters. If Dineane hadn't participated Beverly may have killed her too. I respect Chris for being honest. I despise Beverly for blaming it all on Dineane. I truly believe Dineane thought she was innocent. Whether or not she truly was, is a different story. She deserved to spend some time behind bars but not life. Her lawyer failed her. There was sufficient evidence to introduce mitigating circumstances. That tyrannical woman ruled with an iron fist. Taking all her kids to burn/dispose of the body was deliberate. Beverly believed if they were all involved then they would all keep quiet.
Rest In Peace, Roberto! ❤️🕊️
Beverly was the mastermind behind Roberto's death & she didn't care who she blamed. My heart goes out to sweet Sicily as it appears her Dad did change his life and gave her structure and love. Did they ever investigate her other missing spouse? 😳
Not too thrilled about calling them Jack in the box. Seems a little insulting to the victim. They could’ve shown more sensitivity.
Deneen was trying to play a game, but it backfired. Lol, how are you gonna snitch no yourself after 15 years
Damn, I've listened to a ton of true crime and finally got a case from the small michigan city I grew up in. Wild!!!
I know this is minuscule in this story but that 911 operator immediately pissed me off. Way too many calls I’ve heard where these ppl suck at their job! Just my opinion
Bob Donker has the best name ever spoken.
I’m Donker. Bob Donker.
Yo! 👋🏾😃
How many cases can be 'the most mysterious'?
All three are responsible for the crime Justice finally Served
RIP 🌹 🙏
So nobody is gonna look for the other husband she murdered and they still cant find🤔
Calling him "Jack in the Box," feels insulting to the deceased. I get how emergency personnel can have a dark sense of humor, though.
Beverly the mouth breathers got her jaw hanging loose and open In Every photo
I feel like most of the dispatchers in these videos need to be fired or find a new career
You see that gas price of $1.79?
I hear that Beverly and her daughter are roommates in jail and have forgiven each other. They are working together on their appeals.
Where did you get this information from? Anything on the other missing husband?
The cruelty and the brutality involved in this case is mind boggling and is beyond diabolical. All three of them had no remorse or regret for what they had done. I wonder why Deneen ever reveal about the murder. I am sure that all three of them were fighting and wanted to get on each other's back. Deneen surely had a grudge against her mother Beverly for some reason, probably financial motive.
Hart and condolences 🙏
Italy should be ashamed
So Beverly got caught in Italy, but they wouldn’t send her over unless her charge changed from first to second degree murder? How does that work?
BLACK WIDOW 100%
Im guessing that anybody can b a 911 dispatcher in those days and nowadays. Like, isn’t it their jobs to take every call serious!?!?!? Whether joke or not!?!????
Does the dispatcher usually get trolled or what? Why is she so defensive?
Your voice is extremely soothing. This is a wild story, I just knew from the outset of the anonymous tip that Deneane knew more than she was telling.
Sounds AI to me.
Beverly should have been charged with 1st Degree Murder- but 2nd Degree conviction and basically life sentence was appropriate.
“Who had lit the match to his fiery end” 💀
"a crisp spring morning", why does my mind think like that! I'm sorry.
-"hello, 911, I found a body."
-"a body? what is that?"
-".... a Maytag washing machine...."
I mean, seriously? wow
😢😢
It’s wild that when they found her to be the step daughter she gave them all the info if she said she knew nothing other that he left the house one day and never came back they would have gotten away with it .. idk how the mom got second degree is wild tho
Id like to report a body
What do you mean a body?
Jesus lmao
Thankfully, for Beverly, there was a crowbar on the stairs, and she was agile enough to twist her body to hit him on the head while he's grabbing her ankles. (1st story) 🙄
Whats up with dispatchers being so rude and bad attitudes
I hate hearing ppl say “splatter” when they mean SPATTER.
What do you mean ”a body”? Oh, I just mean thge incredible sheen and bounce in my glorious hair, 911 lady!
"What's in the box Mann!?!?"
entsetzlich wie er getötet wurde 😢😱
Rest In Peace, Roberto 🤍🤲🌈🪦
Sounds like a family of winners!
The operator should be fired bout "what about a body"...bih!
Horrible and painful death. Life without parole.
911 operator like not having it today lol. Like shes pissed at something or maybe on her period.
Dispatcher acted like an ass…
Apparently she also killed the Jamaican dude.
Horrible mother And daughter. And that 911 operator should've been Fired.
I was that 911 operator, how dare you insist my kids didn't have food in their mouths! Shame on you
Going to Pakistan, especially as a woman, is like putting yourself in prison.
What monsters are they,real devils they are
Yeah that 911 operater has a major attitude sounds like that s not her line of work
So did she also kill her second marriage as they went missing too ?
What bobo county courtroom lets a witness wear those goofy shades during a testimony?
Documentary idea was a good idea. What a bunch of psychos! OMG! These people had been walking down the street like nothing ever happened all those years. I don't think I believe the abuse allegations against Roberto. . The mom was clearly the abuser.
What do you mean a body?
Oh not a person. I called 911 about a truck body. A 77 Ford.
1:30 please tell me the “crisp” spring morning pun was intended 😭
I literally had to pause the video and go directly to the comment section to make sure I heard that right. 😭😭
Another idiot dispatcher
If you want to hear a good cross examination this is the one
A body of water?
She should had got worse she ruined her kids lives as well as Reberto and his family.
"What do you mean a body?"
Yeah, you're right. He was obviously talking about a helicopter. Pfff some people...
The fact that this channels narrator keeps repeating this disgusting and disrespectful "Jack in the box" reference to a deceased person really pisses me tf off! Sooo gross!
Wtf is wrong with 911 operator? I called 911 in Memphis Tennessee to report a 100÷ pound dead dog in the road one night to avoid traffic accidents. The diversity hire told me I needed to call animal control. I informed her that I was driving and she needed to do her job before the dog caused a traffic fatality
I like to report a body
What do you mean a body?
What
i think that Beverly is a serial killer.
WHy wouldnt you search the basement?? Why would you help kill someone? wow a real black widow Second degree.
BAWX OR BOX
Didn’t see the Pakistan part coming
Of course she want him out he was being a dad for he’s daughter and she wanted to get high and probably jealous of he’s relationship with the daughter Roberto was handsome no wonder he’s daughter is beautiful