Alastair Mcdonald has a catalog of great versions of jacobite songs aswell as before. Checknout his scottish battle ballads album an prince charlie album. Both on UA-cam. Audentior Ibo! And a health to king James!
While i am not a fan of christianity, i have a huge amount of respect for the Jacobites, as we finns had a similiar struggle against occupation. Nationalism lives!
Almost all conflcits in history have to do with class struggle. The fact that there were divisions bettween Williamites and Jacobites such as religion and ethnicity signify a war that must be studied for its social aspect as well.
Would you mind explaining how you got to that conclusion? The things you mentioned (religious and enthnic/national faultline), along with the fact that the Jacobites had the law on their side or at least felt they did, seem to be a completely adequate explanation for this conflict. By your profile picture, it seems to me like your worldview might make you see class conflict where none exists.
The Jacobites were ethnically Scottish and follow Catholicism while the Williamites were mainly English and followed Protestantism. Although the cause of the war was focused around Monarchy the reasons of the conflict had surely deeper routes. I cannot help it but see it as all conflicts, a struggle between oppressed (Scottish) and oppressors (English) on the other hand the "glorious" revolution did brought progress and constitutionalism. I need to dwelve more on the Jacobite wars.
A non-negligible part of the Jacobites were english and followed various flavors of protestantism. Scottish nationalism and outrage at Parliament doing as it pleased had in the past been reason enough for war and combined here it's no surprised that these uprisings happened. The relationship between Scotland and England is also more complex than a simple dynamic of oppressor and oppressed. The Scottish and English are two distinct ethnic and cultural groups forced to share a limited landmass. Invasions went back and forth, and England only came out as the dominant force because it was larger. Don't get me wrong, class wars can and have happened. But not all conflicts are between oppressor and oppressed. When it comes to things like scarce resources, dominance of a shared region or even the elimination of a possible future threat, people can get bellicose, no matter who is stronger at the time.
Never heard a better musician
Alastair Mcdonald has a catalog of great versions of jacobite songs aswell as before. Checknout his scottish battle ballads album an prince charlie album. Both on UA-cam. Audentior Ibo! And a health to king James!
Good one. I like the Steeleye Span version too.
Steeleye span version is fantastic! Maddie is the best!
This is fantastic!
That Goosie got ol' Geordie actin' foolish.
The Sow got that rump tho...
Actually goodie and the sow were not Bonnie lasses
But soldiers of the rebellion. It’s a symbol.
Actually goodie and the sow were not Bonnie lasses
But soldiers of the rebellion. It’s a symbol.
Actually goodie and the sow were not Bonnie lasses
But soldiers of the rebellion. It’s a symbol.
Actually goose and the sow were not Bonnie lasses
But soldiers of the rebellion. It’s a symbol.
Freedom and Liberty!!!!
There's a Steeleye Span version that is probably the best ever cover of a song! That and Jeff Buckley's cover of Halleluja by Cohen
George III of Denmark, Queen Anne's husband, was also a Guelph.

👍
@gorn_fremen
You’re correct sir. The SOW was my great grandfather Gordon! The Cock o North 🏴🇷🇺☦️🪆
Scottish and it's burst
While i am not a fan of christianity, i have a huge amount of respect for the Jacobites, as we finns had a similiar struggle against occupation. Nationalism lives!
the old ways will return to glory once again
They weren't nationalist they were Catholic traditionalists
Thats right brothers n sisters ❤❤, lionn❤ Algebra celt scot irish decendant @@ivankomadanvonrakovac8415
@@ivankomadanvonrakovac8415so trve and based
Awesome Bl. Karl pfp
@@ivankomadanvonrakovac8415some Jacobites were both
Hits different in 2x speed
British class war
The Jacobites were monarchists, supporting a king against another king supported by monarchists. Class had very little to do with it.
Almost all conflcits in history have to do with class struggle. The fact that there were divisions bettween Williamites and Jacobites such as religion and ethnicity signify a war that must be studied for its social aspect as well.
Would you mind explaining how you got to that conclusion? The things you mentioned (religious and enthnic/national faultline), along with the fact that the Jacobites had the law on their side or at least felt they did, seem to be a completely adequate explanation for this conflict. By your profile picture, it seems to me like your worldview might make you see class conflict where none exists.
The Jacobites were ethnically Scottish and follow Catholicism while the Williamites were mainly English and followed Protestantism. Although the cause of the war was focused around Monarchy the reasons of the conflict had surely deeper routes. I cannot help it but see it as all conflicts, a struggle between oppressed (Scottish) and oppressors (English) on the other hand the "glorious" revolution did brought progress and constitutionalism. I need to dwelve more on the Jacobite wars.
A non-negligible part of the Jacobites were english and followed various flavors of protestantism. Scottish nationalism and outrage at Parliament doing as it pleased had in the past been reason enough for war and combined here it's no surprised that these uprisings happened. The relationship between Scotland and England is also more complex than a simple dynamic of oppressor and oppressed. The Scottish and English are two distinct ethnic and cultural groups forced to share a limited landmass. Invasions went back and forth, and England only came out as the dominant force because it was larger.
Don't get me wrong, class wars can and have happened. But not all conflicts are between oppressor and oppressed. When it comes to things like scarce resources, dominance of a shared region or even the elimination of a possible future threat, people can get bellicose, no matter who is stronger at the time.