@ThomasDeLauer Since I am only few months short from turning 50years old replaying your videos to understand the awesome science and common sense info on your videos over a month has improved body/mind health, energy and body shape. That being said a couple of questions: since I learned from your videos that is after 16 hours that fasting give over the top life-changing results and, also from your videos, you explain that instead of eating soon post workout you find that eating a while longer after physical exercise is the best, I am starting to workout at night to break my fast around 11am the next day; am I okay in following these methods? and last, if I understood one of your videos correctly before eating lunch with a little carb in it, you recommend to have a little bit of fat without carb so that the body re-start turning fat into energy rather than storing it, is that right? and with the bone broth alone am I getting that fat to break my fast with and a hour later then have the meal with some carbs in it; correct? I hope you don't mind me squeezing in like 3 questions in one comment.
Could you please make a more in-depth video about which vitamins, minerals, and amino acids break a fast? Also, which ones would have to be taken during one's eating phase versus which ones are okay to take during one's fast?
Thanks Tom. I'm doing keto again this year and really doing it properly thanks to all of your help. I'm on week 5 of Keto and oh my god it is working. My weight isn't moving on the scales yet but I have dropped a seize in clothes already. I only follow you and it's working. I was unsure about stevia. Thanks so much for all your amazing videos. I've been watching you for two years now. Keep doing your amazing videos.
"Despite having a minimal effect on blood sugars, both aspartame and stevia raised insulin levels higher than even table sugar." Jason Fung - The Obesity Code His source for this claim is: Anton SD et al. Effects of stevia, aspartame, and sucrose on food intake, satiety, and postprandial glucose and insulin level. Appetite. 2010 August; 55(1):37-43 Dr. Fung also points out that there are conflicting studies on this and that at times, you will need to determine who paid for the study to help determine its validity. (Not a direct quote, just my interpretation of what he wrote in his book.)
mommalisa52560 www.marksdailyapple.com/artificial-sweeteners-insulin/ Here it quotes multiple studies and concludes that aspartame doesn't affect insulin levels.
CATHY NORDAHL But what about insulin? I have also noticed that my blood sugars were pretty stable with those sweetners, but possibly a larger problem are the spikes in insulin. also, I have cravings with all of those sweetners.
mommalisa52560 i just did a 14 day fast, drank coke zero and zevia and water. I lost 35 pounds in 14 days. Amd in the last 6 days i lost 3 inches off my waist. So in my case... Those dont break my fast.
max hunter I agree. Now neuroscientist Tamas Horvath, of Yale University in New Haven, and colleagues report in Nature that nerve cells called pro-opiomelanocortin (POMC) neurons play a key role in this process. POMC had generally been thought to promote satiation, but Horvath's team found that POMC neurons in the brain release not just a hunger-suppressing hormone, but also one that promotes appetite. Which hormone is secreted is regulated by a protein in the cells' mitochondria, structures that regulate energy levels. When the CB1 receptor is activated, this mitochondrial protein induces POMC to switch from secreting the substance that suppresses gorging to one that supresses it. Both β-endorphin and α-MSH are in fact derived, via cleavage, from the same precursor protein-POMC, after which the neurons are named. For this reason, Horvath had suspected long ago that POMC neurons might both stimulate and suppress appetite. However, he dropped this early theory after an abundance of experimental evidence suggested otherwise. Indeed, even when β-endorphin itself is deleted from POMC neurons in mice, said Cone, you get “animals that are hyperphagic and obese.” I think an argument can be made that, as long as one can overcome the munchies, smoking marijuana should actual help fasting. If your body is saying it is hungry then wouldn't it consume what is available?
Thomas, thank you for all you do on YT !!! I’m getting back to fasting and getting into keto…vegan keto actually. I’m a vegan for 6 years but I was getting very confused and never knew what I really should eat. Keto is new to me but I love it so far…I’m learning sooooo much from you !! Your passion for healthy body is very contagious!! Please keep up the fantastic work that you do. Don’t get discourage by any mean comments…sending you and your family hugs and lots of love 💜🌺💜🌸
Dietsoda's do increase insulin. A study was done in men harvesting sugar canes. Some got coke, some got dietcoke. Both groups harvested more sugar canes after the drink, but the latter group had a major crash and got less productive. The theory behind it is that the pancreas starts releasing insulin as soon as the sugary taste is noted. The insuline lowers the (low) present bloodsugar because the body is expecting a replenishment. When the expected sugar doesnt come in, bloodsugar has crashed which causes fatigue and cravings. You could say that this does not affect the fast as long as you withstand your cravings, but it does effect the way the body reacts. The increase in glucose causes an initial decrease in glucagon which is the hormone that helps mobilize fatty acids and glycogen. Afterwards, glucagon will spike due to the low blood sugar, but you end up feeling pretty bad in between. This being said; Isn't it better not to drink dietsoda's? And another question: I dont like coffee so i take caffeine in pillform. It has a gelatine capsule. Does 1 really break the fast? If i take the capsule at 12, when i break my fast, i wont be able to sleep.
There are lots of new studies coming out that shows the artificial sweeteners kills different types of gut bacterias, and they are thinking that is responsible for the reason why people who consume diet things don't loose weight.
Hi Thomas, I was wondering about all my multivitamin say take in the morning. Is this something that can break my fast for example fish oils, magnesium, potassium, etc etc. Thank you
They can and will end your fast. In fact, some can even kick you out of ketosis. I personally do IF and a fairly strict keto. Every other day, in my eating window, I take my supplements. Give it a go.
as a biochem/bio-science major I appreciate this info being consolidated into a concise video so I don't have to go all over the place looking for it. Citations would be awesome though, but I am a little obsessive. Thanks again!
The oils may break the fast but trace minerals maybe not especially if they are in liquid/ionic form but just a guess i'm not 100% sure myself. Just take D and Omegas with meals and the rest with meals you don't need them as your body adapts to fasting you load up the night before and get daily sun way better than vitamin D.
Multivitamins at least the ones that I have bought would be a no go, they contain carbs from fruit concentrates, and apparently gelatin carries non essential amino acids namely glycine, glutamic acid, proline, and alanine (I looked it up) so gelatin would be ok since it doesn’t carry leucine which Tom mentioned causes a spike.
Capsules have usually carriers which can break fasting, so it's better to use supplements in forms of pure powders. Omega 3's are basically fats, so can break fasting. Calcium, minerals - don't break fast (if in "pure" forms). Vitamins are often made in capsules with other carriers like fats or forms of sugars. Gelatin is basically protein, so if BCAA makes little spikes in insulin level then it might too.
I found this video 17 hrs in and I was struggling with just water. Now its water, black coffee, and green tea. Time to smash this 72 hour fast and reset my immune system!
@@yordanos2739 I just need to know what I'm allowed to do and what I'm not allowed to do in a 72 hour fast to get those immune system benefits. I was so anxious 44 hours into a 72 hour fast about whether I broke my fast or not I just gave up.
Incredibly informative. I had several questions and stumbled across your video. Your explanations are concise and I feel more empowered in the decisions I'm making during my IF. Thank you!
The more I listen to Thomas the more I like and agree with his teachings. This guys thinking aligns with my feelings on fasting but he adds for me an educated well taught understanding as to why I feel these suggestions and recommendations are best for fasting. I really appreciate this guys knowledge and his presentation to explain and inform! Thank you Thomas! It all makes perfect sense to me 👍🏼
Dr. Fung disagrees..... there’s 2 types of fasting (weight loss or autophagy) so....... you can do BPC IN MODERATION but for autophagy ZERO calories. This is because mct, coconut oil, HWC won’t cause a rise in insulin ....
It will just a reduced or blunted respond. Its not true that insulin is at zero when fasting anyway. It's just reduced. Even if you have 30 calories or so you'll enter the fasting state pretty quick.
Not sure this dude is correct. I just listened to Dr. Rhonda Patrick on Joe Rogan discussing fasting and she said everything but water triggers metabolic enzymes and stops the fast. She's a scientist and gave a pretty good explanation.
Thank you for including cannabis in this discussion! As the industry evolves, so does the science, esp. learning exactly what makes us feel the way we do. Terpenes are found in ALL plants, and they are specifically responsible for feelings of euphoria, energy, relaxation, hunger, etc., aaand specific ones have even been known to suppress appetite. As a post-bacc Neurobiology labrat whom joined the professional side of cannabis a few years ago, it really is amazing to finally see the science behind this force of a plant. Caution on edibles:. Our bodies breakdown and digest the endocannabinoids in MJ much more completely than smoking/vaping, and take much longer to kick in. Exercise restraint and moderation when consuming. Remember, you can always eat more, but you can't eat less. Also exercise caution when medicating with concentrates- oil, distillate, vape, wax, etc: these are 'concentrated' mediums of THC, producing a stronger effect. I personally recommend flower to start, seeing as how you get the full spectrum benefits of the plant rather than THC alone. I could go on, but by all means if anyone sees this and has questions, don't hesitate! =)
Bummer! I was beside myself of hunger yesterday so i made some Coconut coffee this morning to feel less hungry.(I do OMAD in the evening) But it makes sense now why I am such a long time getting in to ketosis because I have drunken coconut coffee some days.. There is soo much to understand in the Keto diet! Thank god for UA-cam!
Thank you so much Tom for the info. I'm glad you straightened it out concerning MCT oil, coconut oil, bullet proof etc. now I can really hone in on my IF.
I heard coffee can raise insulin which makes the fat burning in fasting slower can you do a video on that and perhaps measure your blood level before and after drinking plain coffee? Thanks for the vid btw🤗💖
sara c hmm I’ve always heard caffeine increase fight/ flight and can become a performance enhancer because it releases FFAs for energy. Not sure how fasting changes this
Black coffee doesn't raise insulin, it raises cortisol, so technically it doesn't break your fast. Cortisol and Insulin are the 2 hormones that store fat & prevent fat burning. That's why there's a lot of people who recommend water first thing in the morning and waiting for breakfast to have your coffee.
Ok a few questions, diet soda specifically diet coke doesn't effect insulin? Because I hear from Dr. Fung first soda can cause a insulin spike greater then sugar. Second the items in your ok list won't effect me achieving autophagy? Third is a friend started a water fast but with coconut water included and from anything I read coconut water has calories. So what do you think. Right now I do water fasts and if it's long fasts a week or more I do a dry fast during a water fast of a day. Thanks!
yes plz answer this. Because i need to know if ive been wasting my time doing "fasted cardio". because i drink one of these before each "fasted" workout.
because of how Branch Chain Amino Acids are broken down, he considers them to be a "no-go". @5:21 - leucine causes an insulin spike to break it down. he speaks about it very clearly. very very clearly. lol
Technically, anything other than water breaks a fast. This is because the microbiome and enzymatic activity in the gut is awakened to work the second anything other than water enters the system. Teas will have herbs and other, often fibrous, ingredients that requires the gut to work. Once the gut is working on intake items, you’re no longer fasting. This is my understanding on a basic biology level.
True, this is the same oppinion as Dr. Rhonda Patrick who is very knowledgeable about fasting and its benefits. It makes complete logical sense too. Any tea or coffee etc will have xenobiotics (not naturally produced in the body) compounds which will need to processed. I like sticking just to water myself. It just makes things simpler.
Adam Das you cant drink water when you are fasting. That breaks it. He doesnt seem educated in this. Your fast will be broken if anything enters the body. If u were allowed to drink all of that stuff, then fasting would be dead easy. But the whole point of fasting is to get hungry, thirsty, tired nd tha. which makes you greatful for the food that comes on the table at dawn. And to bring u closer to our god. This whole video is wrong. He isnt even muslim. No hate, im just saying he should hve done some research before making this video.
27 of fasting and I just finished watching this to realize that I’ve been having my coffee with a little sugar free coffee mate because I thought anything less than 50 calories was good to go 🤦♀️
so a dirty fast which is different than a pure fast does allow up to 50 calories as it shouldn't spike your insulin levels soo much but check the sugar content on the coffee mate it's usually like 8gr of sugar which is much more likely to throw you out of a fast than the 35 calories coffee mate has
Dawn McKenzie I think he made a mistake there. He actually said it was a no-go, right? But while he said that, he wrote it down in the wrong column because that was the one he was working on.
2 Questions: 1. Does having a couple slices of lemon in my hot water break the fast? And 2. Does have a sprinkle if cinnamon in my coffee break the fast?
I think it depends on what your goals are. I noticed that clear chicken broth doesn't seem to really raise my blood sugar. I think i could lose weight sipping it but it would probably knock me out of some of the really neat benefits of fasting like autophagy and increased production of human growth hormone. It may well be that they are both correct but Thomas is just hardcore.
What would be your response to someone like Dr. Eric Berg, another foremost expert on fasting, that has a video that says that bone broth, ACV, and erythritol IS all fasting safe?
Y'all are killing me here with all the "not a real doctor" and shit. Listen to who you choose and see who helps you more. You don't have to be a medical doctor of anything to be an expert. Just ask Thomas...a real non-medical doctor himself.
I was just going to ask about that, I mean he does say that it breaks a fast, and honestly it IS obvious, but seeing how he put it on the gray area made me wonder.
Interesting to see ACV in the gray area section. Even if there may be a single calorie in ACV, isn't there typically 5 calories in a single cup of black coffee? Which shouldn't be enough to impact a fast. Thomas, I'm wondering if you could make a video discussing the best time to drink ACV, in relation to controlling glucose. E.g. before or after a carb heavy meal? At the start or end of a fast?
@@chantalbaxter9126 Stevia doesn't have carbs. It's carb-free and calorie-free. If it's mixed with erythitol or maltodextrin, then it won't be carb-free but that isn't the stevia adding the carbs.
Yeah, I was pretty curious about this a little while back so I did some looking around and it seems to be safe for a fast: ua-cam.com/video/uFHENWooEe0/v-deo.html
Good video as always dude, very informative, felt a bit guilty for having a Diet Coke last night when I was in my fast but now you’ve put my mind at ease a bit. Been watching for quite a while now but I’ve only started to truly implement your methods over the past ten weeks. I’ve lost 12.8Kg’s so far. And I’d just like to say thanks Thomas for all the awesome videos. Take care, Craig.
Thank u for including medical cannabis. I’m a legal patient and use THC and CBD daily. I’m coming to the end of a 3 day fast right now. I’ve been smoking and vaping my medicine, but obviously no edibles, so my pain is significantly higher.. sometimes on occasion, I’ll ingest some decarbed, raw cannabis. I checked online and it said 1 gram of raw cannabis is only 1-2 calories. Would you find this acceptable? Thank you!
It may be acceptable but I would recommend to go for shorter fasts as marijuana increases your hunger and I would recommend you to stick to the inhaling methods or anything that does not involve ingestion because 1 calorie or a 100 it will break you fast.
I've been wondering about Vaping. I have Vaped for 9 years after smoking for 20. I love Vaping. It has literally saved my life.My asthma has disappeared and I get a pulmonary lung exam done by my doctor every year and she says I have the lungs of a non-smoker. I do get juice in my mouth (called Spit Back) and I vape a lot. However I've been in Ketosis for a few weeks now. So I agree Vaping doesn't knock you out of Ketosis. However I feel like I get my sugar rush from the juice. So it's a win win😁 Also down 40lbs in 3 months. Am off Diabetic meds and my A1C is under 7😆. All my cholesterol numbers are in a healthy rangs now as well. Again thanks for your input on the subject.
My favorite non-caffeinated tea is Celestial Seasonings Cinnamon Apple Spice. The ingredients are: Cinnamon, hibiscus, chamomile, natural cinnamon and apple flavors with other natural flavors, roasted chicory, orange peel and roasted carob. I bet this probably doesn't break a fast. But I wonder what the hormonal impact of the ingredients is. It would be interesting to watch a video on teas and flavored beverages and their effects. What dosage of tea would cause a material effect. Even green tea is suppose have a negative effect on test.
Thomas, thank you for this video. I do have a question though about the use of the sweeteners on your safe column. When you mentioned BCAA's were no-go's it was because of the insulin spike the produce. However, when I was reading Dr. Fung's book The Obesity Code he quotes research that shows the artificial sweeteners, including stevia, spike insulin. And not only a little spike but up to 3x as much as real sugar would. If spiking insulin qualifies as kicking you out of a fast, then it would seem the sweeteners would be on the no-go list. Am I just misunderstanding what he was saying? I know that the key benefit of fasting for someone who is insulin resistant is to be in a prolonged period of time where insulin is not be produced. I've always errored on the side of caution and skipped them when fasting. But wanted your input, maybe in another video? Thanks again for your videos, I look forward to them every time!
Steven Perry That's exactly what I've found in my research. As a result, I slowly weaned myself away from using them, so I don't actually need sweeteners for anything. It makes my fasting periods easier and it keeps my wallet a little heavier, as a bonus.
I agree on the use of sweeteners and Dr. Fung uses human based research results in his book which I prefer over lab animal tests. However, I am going to guess you don't watch Thomas' videos on a regular basis because he does put references to studies to back up the facts he is using. This video may be more of an opinion based one, but his science and research is always spot on. I watch some other keto "bloggers" that quote a lot of "bro" science. But one thing that sets Thomas apart from these others is his use of researched facts and science. Thomas also has a lot of experience in helping others navigate their fitness journey, and more importantly their health journey. Practical experience and knowledge trumps a study every time.
Steven Perry the sweetners he said were ok have been tested on people. Some people get a sugar spike, some dont. Its a grey area. However there are some sweetners that def raise bsl.
If you reread my comment you will see that I said they raise insulin levels not blood sugar levels. These are two completely different issues. And if you listen to what he said when he said BCAA's were out it was because they spike insulin, not blood sugar. My comment/question was if spiking insulin was a reason to kick out out of your fast, then the sweeteners would also kick you out of the fast because they too spike insulin.
Milevskis Fitness. The study shows the augmentation of insulin with use of artificial sweeteners in the presence of glucose on rats. This is not really showing that they produce an insulin spike themselves, but rather increase the insulin response to glucose.
Curious about essential oils and if they trigger an insulin response? I’m new to intermittent fasting and based on what I’ve researched so far, am thinking citrus oils would actually be helpful? Thank you for your time and great video!
Wezz - He’s not speaking, he’s typing, but I’d wager the audio version isn’t much different from the texted version. Give him a break, that poor Millennial is versus the whole world and there appears to be a long line of complaints.
Two Fit Docs did a physical test checking ketones, insulin etc. They checked MCT, coconut oil, butter etc. Any artificial sweetener caused a spike, mct and butter did not. In fact BPC had an effect of helping the ketones. Just sayin’ check it out.
Hahah was gonna ask you about weed before the video even ended but then I realized I should watch the rest and of course you covered it. Good video, really informative. Thanks :)
Jill Lopez I'm here for the same question I usually workout after having my last meal at 8 but I need my post workout what should I do fasting time is 16/8 ?
True but it is important to get electrolytes in during a fast because if you are going 12-16 hours on just water, youre going to be urinating a lot, dumping a lot of sodium and potassium, it is good to replenish those.
I should rephrase : remove minerals from there. Really only vitamins need food to absorb. Minerals dont require any food to absorb. Some Lemon Sea salt water in the morning goes a long way
Marco thanks for the correction. That's correct and in fact, historically we've gotten many of our minerals from the water we drink (and anyone who drinks well water still does)
Does Pink Himalayan Salt break a fast? Also what about toothpastes (is a significant amount absorbed in the mouth, enough to cause a metabolic response)?
velishan1 im 2 weeks late, but it may. Because from what i understand, canned tabacco like that is sweetend with sugars (for taste obviously) even though it may not seem like it to some people. That may make ir break. Just a heads up to look into.
Love watching your videos, you upload great content. What sugar free gum would you recommend for fasting. I am a weirdo about fresh breath and work around other people. Thanks for any insight you have.
Thank you so much for this. I've watched a lot of these "does it break a fast" videos and I think that this one by far is the clearest and most concise. I really appreciate all that you do. You're videos are very helpful and I think it's generous of you to take the time to research and create them for our benefit. Also, I adore your dogs! They're absolutely beautiful. Australian Shepherds?
I'd say: why do people need to eat all the time? Don't snack, don't eat anything out of the meal time! It's simple as that. Eat once of twice per day and that's it. And eat healthy, do not consume chemicals, hormones, pesticides, antibiotics, taste-enhancers and artificial sweeteners! Why would you need soda for example, drink water, lemon water, tea...whatever is natural sugar and chemical free.
![What Breaks A Fast & What Doesn't [The Complete Guide]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3S2gLa8cLaQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![What Breaks A Fast & What Doesn't [The Complete Guide]](/img/tr.png)
Free Intermittent Fasting Meal Plan (downloadable): thomasdelauer.lpages.co/fastandfeast/
Free Keto Diet Meal Plan (downloadable): thomasdelauer.lpages.co/real-person-keto/
@ThomasDeLauer Since I am only few months short from turning 50years old replaying your videos to understand the awesome science and common sense info on your videos over a month has improved body/mind health, energy and body shape. That being said a couple of questions: since I learned from your videos that is after 16 hours that fasting give over the top life-changing results and, also from your videos, you explain that instead of eating soon post workout you find that eating a while longer after physical exercise is the best, I am starting to workout at night to break my fast around 11am the next day; am I okay in following these methods? and last, if I understood one of your videos correctly before eating lunch with a little carb in it, you recommend to have a little bit of fat without carb so that the body re-start turning fat into energy rather than storing it, is that right? and with the bone broth alone am I getting that fat to break my fast with and a hour later then have the meal with some carbs in it; correct? I hope you don't mind me squeezing in like 3 questions in one comment.
What about Pickles?
What about l carnitine?????
Does “no sugar” energy drinks break a fast? Ultra Monsters, AlaniNu’s, etc?
Could you please make a more in-depth video about which vitamins, minerals, and amino acids break a fast? Also, which ones would have to be taken during one's eating phase versus which ones are okay to take during one's fast?
Thank youuuuuu! So helpful! I'm on day 4 of a fast and have been having acv, black coffee and green tea. Good to know that I'm not ruining the fast :)
The most knowledgable person ive ever seen on fasting and health, and very easily understandable teaching! Thank you bro!
Exodarion I appreciate that!! Thank you for tuning in!
@@ThomasDeLauerOfficial what about vanilla extract? Like a couple drops in coffee. Does that break a fast. YOURE AWESOME & INFORMATIVE BTW!!!!
Thanks Tom. I'm doing keto again this year and really doing it properly thanks to all of your help. I'm on week 5 of Keto and oh my god it is working. My weight isn't moving on the scales yet but I have dropped a seize in clothes already. I only follow you and it's working. I was unsure about stevia. Thanks so much for all your amazing videos. I've been watching you for two years now. Keep doing your amazing videos.
This was golden! I was using collagen in my black coffee after 3 weeks of IF and my weight loss slowed and I couldnt figure out what it was. Thanks!
Christian James + so how do you incorporate your collagen now? I need to know cuz I take it for my knee tendons...
Dianne Oehman I will now take it only on refeed days. :) Not daily in my coffee. :)
Christian James + Oh...wow!...you do some serious fasting! I'm thrilled if I'm able to do one meal a day!....I wish I had that fortitude!👍🏼
Do I trust the guy who lost 100 lbs and is ripped af? Or do I trust the know-it-alls in the comment section? hmmm
Lol agree
Cory Cool Dangerous Agee
Comments for sure
Lol thats a damn good point!
🤔 hmm that’s a hard one lol
"Despite having a minimal effect on blood sugars, both aspartame and stevia raised insulin levels higher than even table sugar." Jason Fung - The Obesity Code
His source for this claim is:
Anton SD et al. Effects of stevia, aspartame, and sucrose on food intake, satiety, and postprandial glucose and insulin level. Appetite. 2010 August; 55(1):37-43
Dr. Fung also points out that there are conflicting studies on this and that at times, you will need to determine who paid for the study to help determine its validity. (Not a direct quote, just my interpretation of what he wrote in his book.)
mommalisa52560 www.marksdailyapple.com/artificial-sweeteners-insulin/
Here it quotes multiple studies and concludes that aspartame doesn't affect insulin levels.
Mr Knarf, will check it out. thanks
mommalisa52560 My husband is a type 1 diabetic. He drinks a lot of diet pop and aspartame definitely does not cause blood sugar to go up.
CATHY NORDAHL
But what about insulin? I have also noticed that my blood sugars were pretty stable with those sweetners, but possibly a larger problem are the spikes in insulin. also, I have cravings with all of those sweetners.
mommalisa52560 i just did a 14 day fast, drank coke zero and zevia and water.
I lost 35 pounds in 14 days. Amd in the last 6 days i lost 3 inches off my waist.
So in my case... Those dont break my fast.
Finally, CBD oil and marijuana was mentioned in relation to fasting, thanks 🙏
So vaping marijuana won't break a fast?
Marijuana gives you the the munchies
To answer your question: yes, eating dog does break a fast
Damn it 🤦🏾♀️
That god someone cleared that up for me he never touched on that at all!
Good old kagogi.
He does not say anything about eating the dog
Does melatonin break a fast ?
Protein powder grey area? I think that was meant for No-Go.
Definetly! I think it was just a mistake he didn´t notice at the moment.
Protein will break Autophagy.
He did say they will definitely break the fast, but he mistakenly wrote it on the grey area group.
yea that definitely breaks a fast
he wouldnt fight about it just stay behind the screen
Respect for not avoiding the sensitive subject of marijuana .
max hunter
I agree.
Now neuroscientist Tamas Horvath, of Yale University in New Haven, and colleagues report in Nature that nerve cells called pro-opiomelanocortin (POMC) neurons play a key role in this process. POMC had generally been thought to promote satiation, but Horvath's team found that POMC neurons in the brain release not just a hunger-suppressing hormone, but also one that promotes appetite.
Which hormone is secreted is regulated by a protein in the cells' mitochondria, structures that regulate energy levels. When the CB1 receptor is activated, this mitochondrial protein induces POMC to switch from secreting the substance that suppresses gorging to one that supresses it.
Both β-endorphin and α-MSH are in fact derived, via cleavage, from the same precursor protein-POMC, after which the neurons are named. For this reason, Horvath had suspected long ago that POMC neurons might both stimulate and suppress appetite. However, he dropped this early theory after an abundance of experimental evidence suggested otherwise. Indeed, even when β-endorphin itself is deleted from POMC neurons in mice, said Cone, you get “animals that are hyperphagic and obese.”
I think an argument can be made that, as long as one can overcome the munchies, smoking marijuana should actual help fasting. If your body is saying it is hungry then wouldn't it consume what is available?
max hunter not sensitive anymore, it’s 2018.
Vicious Cycle You'd be surprised.
Thomas, thank you for all you do on YT !!! I’m getting back to fasting and getting into keto…vegan keto actually. I’m a vegan for 6 years but I was getting very confused and never knew what I really should eat. Keto is new to me but I love it so far…I’m learning sooooo much from you !! Your passion for healthy body is very contagious!! Please keep up the fantastic work that you do. Don’t get discourage by any mean comments…sending you and your family hugs and lots of love 💜🌺💜🌸
Breakfast will break a fast.
andyottito1 no sh*t
Really fast 😋
andyottito1 Cause it's literally break-fast!
You idios, anyottito was just kidding around. Sheesh.
andyottito1 haha hence where the name came from
Dietsoda's do increase insulin. A study was done in men harvesting sugar canes. Some got coke, some got dietcoke. Both groups harvested more sugar canes after the drink, but the latter group had a major crash and got less productive. The theory behind it is that the pancreas starts releasing insulin as soon as the sugary taste is noted. The insuline lowers the (low) present bloodsugar because the body is expecting a replenishment. When the expected sugar doesnt come in, bloodsugar has crashed which causes fatigue and cravings. You could say that this does not affect the fast as long as you withstand your cravings, but it does effect the way the body reacts. The increase in glucose causes an initial decrease in glucagon which is the hormone that helps mobilize fatty acids and glycogen. Afterwards, glucagon will spike due to the low blood sugar, but you end up feeling pretty bad in between. This being said; Isn't it better not to drink dietsoda's?
And another question: I dont like coffee so i take caffeine in pillform. It has a gelatine capsule. Does 1 really break the fast? If i take the capsule at 12, when i break my fast, i wont be able to sleep.
so, what about sucralose and stevia then? would it cause the same reaction because they are sweet?
@@KittyLovesGlover I'd say yes.
There are lots of new studies coming out that shows the artificial sweeteners kills different types of gut bacterias, and they are thinking that is responsible for the reason why people who consume diet things don't loose weight.
When I drank diet soda, I found it made me more hungry and tempted to eat. So I would avoid them.
Hi Thomas, I was wondering about all my multivitamin say take in the morning. Is this something that can break my fast for example fish oils, magnesium, potassium, etc etc. Thank you
nfpaezinvesting ya me too
They can and will end your fast. In fact, some can even kick you out of ketosis.
I personally do IF and a fairly strict keto.
Every other day, in my eating window, I take my supplements.
Give it a go.
nfpaezinvesting omega3 is a fish oil which is a lipid that breaks the fast.. not sure about the minerals such as magnesium though!
Bobby Sweeney I also do I.F with strict keto and literally feel amazing and have had some great results :)
nfpaezinvesting I've wondered the same. Great question.
as a biochem/bio-science major I appreciate this info being consolidated into a concise video so I don't have to go all over the place looking for it. Citations would be awesome though, but I am a little obsessive. Thanks again!
Braking a fast with Multivitamins? Omega 3’s? Calcium? Vitamin D? Minerals? Capsules with gelatin?
I want to know this as well.
The oils may break the fast but trace minerals maybe not especially if they are in liquid/ionic form but just a guess i'm not 100% sure myself. Just take D and Omegas with meals and the rest with meals you don't need them as your body adapts to fasting you load up the night before and get daily sun way better than vitamin D.
Multivitamins at least the ones that I have bought would be a no go, they contain carbs from fruit concentrates, and apparently gelatin carries non essential amino acids namely glycine, glutamic acid, proline, and alanine (I looked it up) so gelatin would be ok since it doesn’t carry leucine which Tom mentioned causes a spike.
Capsules have usually carriers which can break fasting, so it's better to use supplements in forms of pure powders. Omega 3's are basically fats, so can break fasting. Calcium, minerals - don't break fast (if in "pure" forms). Vitamins are often made in capsules with other carriers like fats or forms of sugars. Gelatin is basically protein, so if BCAA makes little spikes in insulin level then it might too.
How about fresh ginger steeped in hot water, then strained. Does that break a fast?
The 1st thing needed is a clear definition of a fast. It seems there are now thousands of things people refer to as a fast.
It's like when you need a blood test and they tell you to fast. Nothing but water is allowed. That is a true fast.
Linda L a true fast is a og with no water either
at least 60mph
Not eating
I love his intelligence, speech and positive vibes. Such a well-educated man sharing his knowledge with us. I appreciate ❤
I found this video 17 hrs in and I was struggling with just water. Now its water, black coffee, and green tea. Time to smash this 72 hour fast and reset my immune system!
Didn't make the 72 hour fast. I figured out I broke my fast brushing my teeth and using mouthwash. This stuff is hard, lots of preparation required.
@@PontoLyone no you didn't. If you were doing a hard dry fast yes, but you were not so it's okay. Thomas has done a video about that.
@@yordanos2739 I just need to know what I'm allowed to do and what I'm not allowed to do in a 72 hour fast to get those immune system benefits. I was so anxious 44 hours into a 72 hour fast about whether I broke my fast or not I just gave up.
Good for you!!
Incredibly informative. I had several questions and stumbled across your video. Your explanations are concise and I feel more empowered in the decisions I'm making during my IF. Thank you!
I think the dog on the right breaks a fast...
his right or the viewers right?! :D
I don't think it matters what dog you eat, they would both break a fast.
Depends on how fast the dogs are.
Blake Bauman it's cleary the one on the left!
😂😂😂
The more I listen to Thomas the more I like and agree with his teachings. This guys thinking aligns with my feelings on fasting but he adds for me an educated well taught understanding as to why I feel these suggestions and recommendations are best for fasting.
I really appreciate this guys knowledge and his presentation to explain and inform!
Thank you Thomas!
It all makes perfect sense to me 👍🏼
Dr. Fung disagrees..... there’s 2 types of fasting (weight loss or autophagy) so....... you can do BPC IN MODERATION but for autophagy ZERO calories. This is because mct, coconut oil, HWC won’t cause a rise in insulin ....
Hi Karla do u know if aloe Vera gel breaks the fast?
@mehazad rahman what ?
@Karla Maria
There's calories in fat you are making me laugh
It will just a reduced or blunted respond. Its not true that insulin is at zero when fasting anyway. It's just reduced. Even if you have 30 calories or so you'll enter the fasting state pretty quick.
The mct powder I use is only a half scoop which is 35 calories...is that okay?
Phew, so glad chocolate didnt make the "No Go" list. Nom nom 🍫
HAHAHAHA
Yep nor did cheeseburger
Not sure this dude is correct. I just listened to Dr. Rhonda Patrick on Joe Rogan discussing fasting and she said everything but water triggers metabolic enzymes and stops the fast. She's a scientist and gave a pretty good explanation.
totally with you there reniam
I agree, I watched the same podcast and I think she is pretty spot on about almost everything she talks about
Try watching Dr. Berg and Dr. Berry, they're actual MDs
Yes definately agree and she mentions anything with caffeine breaks a fast.
reniam female scientist lol a fake scientist who is just educated not a scientist lol. Funny people oh dear oh dear
Thank you for including cannabis in this discussion! As the industry evolves, so does the science, esp. learning exactly what makes us feel the way we do. Terpenes are found in ALL plants, and they are specifically responsible for feelings of euphoria, energy, relaxation, hunger, etc., aaand specific ones have even been known to suppress appetite. As a post-bacc Neurobiology labrat whom joined the professional side of cannabis a few years ago, it really is amazing to finally see the science behind this force of a plant.
Caution on edibles:. Our bodies breakdown and digest the endocannabinoids in MJ much more completely than smoking/vaping, and take much longer to kick in. Exercise restraint and moderation when consuming. Remember, you can always eat more, but you can't eat less. Also exercise caution when medicating with concentrates- oil, distillate, vape, wax, etc: these are 'concentrated' mediums of THC, producing a stronger effect. I personally recommend flower to start, seeing as how you get the full spectrum benefits of the plant rather than THC alone.
I could go on, but by all means if anyone sees this and has questions, don't hesitate! =)
Thomas you need to be on a Joe Rogan podcast
YES. I WAS THINKING THE SAME THING
Rip joe rogan
No, a different form of fasting on the podcast and not about inducing autophagy.
Doesn't he just have weird alt-righters on these days?
S11N Yas!
What about meds? Like aspirin or antibiotics?
Does gum break fast? Stevia sweetened?
Bummer! I was beside myself of hunger yesterday so i made some Coconut coffee this morning to feel less hungry.(I do OMAD in the evening)
But it makes sense now why I am such a long time getting in to ketosis because I have drunken coconut coffee some days..
There is soo much to understand in the Keto diet! Thank god for UA-cam!
More videos like this one please.
The dogs look so done with you 😂
Thank you so much Tom for the info. I'm glad you straightened it out concerning MCT oil, coconut oil, bullet proof etc. now I can really hone in on my IF.
Thanks!
I heard coffee can raise insulin which makes the fat burning in fasting slower can you do a video on that and perhaps measure your blood level before and after drinking plain coffee? Thanks for the vid btw🤗💖
sara c hmm I’ve always heard caffeine increase fight/ flight and can become a performance enhancer because it releases FFAs for energy. Not sure how fasting changes this
Black coffee doesn't raise insulin, it raises cortisol, so technically it doesn't break your fast. Cortisol and Insulin are the 2 hormones that store fat & prevent fat burning. That's why there's a lot of people who recommend water first thing in the morning and waiting for breakfast to have your coffee.
ua-cam.com/video/iAv-1UHHjeg/v-deo.html
If cortisol increases with coffee intake, wouldn’t it be counterproductive to drink? I thought cortisol inhibits fat loss.
Ok a few questions, diet soda specifically diet coke doesn't effect insulin? Because I hear from Dr. Fung first soda can cause a insulin spike greater then sugar.
Second the items in your ok list won't effect me achieving autophagy?
Third is a friend started a water fast but with coconut water included and from anything I read coconut water has calories. So what do you think.
Right now I do water fasts and if it's long fasts a week or more I do a dry fast during a water fast of a day. Thanks!
What about, vitamin supplements, calcium tablets and omega 3 oil ? also does anyone have a recommendation for a preworkout that doesn't break fasting?
Raymond Williams oil I think definitely would break a fast/ not sure about vitamins and calcium I think it could all just depend on the ingredients
Lol what are you doing writing on Jeff Cavalier’s chalkboard? ❤️
Energy drink name BANG has bcaa but zero calories and carbs, my question is if is a GO or a NO GO.
i think he means the BCAA's themselves will break it. hmm
yes plz answer this. Because i need to know if ive been wasting my time doing "fasted cardio". because i drink one of these before each "fasted" workout.
i need to know if ive actually been breaking my fast before i work out
He said in the vid, bcaa's gonna break your fast
because of how Branch Chain Amino Acids are broken down, he considers them to be a "no-go". @5:21 - leucine causes an insulin spike to break it down. he speaks about it very clearly. very very clearly. lol
Technically, anything other than water breaks a fast. This is because the microbiome and enzymatic activity in the gut is awakened to work the second anything other than water enters the system. Teas will have herbs and other, often fibrous, ingredients that requires the gut to work. Once the gut is working on intake items, you’re no longer fasting. This is my understanding on a basic biology level.
What abt brushing? I mean brushing the teeth
Harishkumar A as long as you’re not swallowing the toothpaste, it’s not breaking the fast.
True, this is the same oppinion as Dr. Rhonda Patrick who is very knowledgeable about fasting and its benefits. It makes complete logical sense too. Any tea or coffee etc will have xenobiotics (not naturally produced in the body) compounds which will need to processed. I like sticking just to water myself. It just makes things simpler.
shanesthedude indeed. I’m a big fan of Dr. Patrick and Dr. Panda.
Adam Das you cant drink water when you are fasting. That breaks it. He doesnt seem educated in this. Your fast will be broken if anything enters the body. If u were allowed to drink all of that stuff, then fasting would be dead easy. But the whole point of fasting is to get hungry, thirsty, tired nd tha. which makes you greatful for the food that comes on the table at dawn. And to bring u closer to our god. This whole video is wrong. He isnt even muslim. No hate, im just saying he should hve done some research before making this video.
27 of fasting and I just finished watching this to realize that I’ve been having my coffee with a little sugar free coffee mate because I thought anything less than 50 calories was good to go 🤦♀️
50 calories? No way! Here I was.....worried about my apple cider vinegar, haha
I do the exact same thing. The sugar fee coffee mate. I wouldn’t worry too much about it. I’ve been having it and still see results from my fast.
How much do you lose?
so a dirty fast which is different than a pure fast does allow up to 50 calories as it shouldn't spike your insulin levels soo much but check the sugar content on the coffee mate it's usually like 8gr of sugar which is much more likely to throw you out of a fast than the 35 calories coffee mate has
Give up the coffee and do a true fast to feel the benefits.
Just stick with water and green tea during your fast and you might live longer
How in the world is a protein powder a grey area but yet bone broth is a no go? Protein powders should definitely be a no go.
Dawn McKenzie I think he made a mistake there. He actually said it was a no-go, right? But while he said that, he wrote it down in the wrong column because that was the one he was working on.
Bernardo Sutter I agree, I think he made a mistake in the board.
Dawn McKenzie he put it in the grey area because some do and some don’t depending on the ingredients.
Lady's Things you're stupid. The point is to avoid calories. It's definitely not in the gray area.
But what about tide pods?!?!
Kidding, love these videos. Keep 'em coming!
Does Xyla sweetner break a fast? Thanks!
If it's a teenager that's doing tide pods, then they're not breaking a fast.
2 Questions: 1. Does having a couple slices of lemon in my hot water break the fast? And 2. Does have a sprinkle if cinnamon in my coffee break the fast?
Ground spices? Such as ginger, cinnamon, cayenne pepper...?
Bella Santana i asked about ginger he said if its below 1/4 teaspoon its ok
kick ass preworkouts i mean if teas are okay less than 1/4 tsp should be fine too i guess
When he began the video talking about the dogs, I was like what?😂
I just watched a video that showed testing on heavy cream, mct oil, and butter. None of them broke a fast! So who to believe?
I think it depends on what your goals are. I noticed that clear chicken broth doesn't seem to really raise my blood sugar. I think i could lose weight sipping it but it would probably knock me out of some of the really neat benefits of fasting like autophagy and increased production of human growth hormone. It may well be that they are both correct but Thomas is just hardcore.
I did too. It was a medical doctor so I am going with that.
Heavy cream doesn’t break a fast I’ve heard
Thank you SO MUCH Thomas! You are really helping me improve my diet.
What would be your response to someone like Dr. Eric Berg, another foremost expert on fasting, that has a video that says that bone broth, ACV, and erythritol IS all fasting safe?
you mean eric berg the non medical doctor (chiropractor)
I've watched many of his videos on various subjects and don't believe he is an actual expert on anything.
Fair, but then you have to question Thomas as they have done video collaborations together.
Y'all are killing me here with all the "not a real doctor" and shit. Listen to who you choose and see who helps you more. You don't have to be a medical doctor of anything to be an expert. Just ask Thomas...a real non-medical doctor himself.
Dara Jones so you believe the guy that says diet soda is safe?
Water_Tea_coffee_AVC_Lemon
Ok noted
Thanks Thomas
Maybe better do a pop-up in the video regarding the error of putting Protein Powder in the grey area🙃
I was just going to ask about that, I mean he does say that it breaks a fast, and honestly it IS obvious, but seeing how he put it on the gray area made me wonder.
What about cinnamon powder? Adding a dash with my coffee in the morning typically less than a teaspoon worth
Most spices and herbs are fine on a fast. Cinnamon is fine
Added benefit .. cinnamon can help with insulin resistance..
Interesting to see ACV in the gray area section. Even if there may be a single calorie in ACV, isn't there typically 5 calories in a single cup of black coffee? Which shouldn't be enough to impact a fast.
Thomas, I'm wondering if you could make a video discussing the best time to drink ACV, in relation to controlling glucose. E.g. before or after a carb heavy meal? At the start or end of a fast?
CJ Sheets yaaaah... same with stevia, it's not calorie free and DOES have carbs. I think he's mistaken...
@@chantalbaxter9126
Stevia doesn't have carbs. It's carb-free and calorie-free. If it's mixed with erythitol or maltodextrin, then it won't be carb-free but that isn't the stevia adding the carbs.
What about salt? Like a small amount in the water ill drink throughout my fast.
Yeah, I was pretty curious about this a little while back so I did some looking around and it seems to be safe for a fast:
ua-cam.com/video/uFHENWooEe0/v-deo.html
In another video, Thomas speaks about the benefits of adding a little salt to your water when fasting.
Good video as always dude, very informative, felt a bit guilty for having a Diet Coke last night when I was in my fast but now you’ve put my mind at ease a bit. Been watching for quite a while now but I’ve only started to truly implement your methods over the past ten weeks. I’ve lost 12.8Kg’s so far. And I’d just like to say thanks Thomas for all the awesome videos. Take care, Craig.
Dr Berg said creamer, mct oil and bp coffee don’t break a fast.
Does taking vitamins and supplements break a fast?
Thank u for including medical cannabis. I’m a legal patient and use THC and CBD daily. I’m coming to the end of a 3 day fast right now. I’ve been smoking and vaping my medicine, but obviously no edibles, so my pain is significantly higher.. sometimes on occasion, I’ll ingest some decarbed, raw cannabis. I checked online and it said 1 gram of raw cannabis is only 1-2 calories. Would you find this acceptable?
Thank you!
It may be acceptable but I would recommend to go for shorter fasts as marijuana increases your hunger and I would recommend you to stick to the inhaling methods or anything that does not involve ingestion because 1 calorie or a 100 it will break you fast.
Ok, thanks ! 😊👍🏾
I've been wondering about Vaping. I have Vaped for 9 years after smoking for 20. I love Vaping. It has literally saved my life.My asthma has disappeared and I get a pulmonary lung exam done by my doctor every year and she says I have the lungs of a non-smoker. I do get juice in my mouth (called Spit Back) and I vape a lot. However I've been in Ketosis for a few weeks now. So I agree Vaping doesn't knock you out of Ketosis. However I feel like I get my sugar rush from the juice. So it's a win win😁 Also down 40lbs in 3 months. Am off Diabetic meds and my A1C is under 7😆. All my cholesterol numbers are in a healthy rangs now as well.
Again thanks for your input on the subject.
Way to go Steven 👏🏻💪🏻
Fellow vaper here too. 5 years strong 💪
Congrats!!! 😁
What about chewing gum? Which types are safe to chew during a fast?
i'll suppose with no sugar on it will not break the fast
i assume the ones with any carb or sugar values on it will break a fast
My favorite non-caffeinated tea is Celestial Seasonings Cinnamon Apple Spice.
The ingredients are:
Cinnamon, hibiscus, chamomile, natural cinnamon and apple flavors with other natural flavors, roasted chicory, orange peel and roasted carob. I bet this probably doesn't break a fast. But I wonder what the hormonal impact of the ingredients is.
It would be interesting to watch a video on teas and flavored beverages and their effects. What dosage of tea would cause a material effect. Even green tea is suppose have a negative effect on test.
Don't artificial sweeteners spike insulin as well but slightly
Thomas, thank you for this video. I do have a question though about the use of the sweeteners on your safe column. When you mentioned BCAA's were no-go's it was because of the insulin spike the produce. However, when I was reading Dr. Fung's book The Obesity Code he quotes research that shows the artificial sweeteners, including stevia, spike insulin. And not only a little spike but up to 3x as much as real sugar would. If spiking insulin qualifies as kicking you out of a fast, then it would seem the sweeteners would be on the no-go list. Am I just misunderstanding what he was saying? I know that the key benefit of fasting for someone who is insulin resistant is to be in a prolonged period of time where insulin is not be produced. I've always errored on the side of caution and skipped them when fasting. But wanted your input, maybe in another video? Thanks again for your videos, I look forward to them every time!
Steven Perry That's exactly what I've found in my research. As a result, I slowly weaned myself away from using them, so I don't actually need sweeteners for anything. It makes my fasting periods easier and it keeps my wallet a little heavier, as a bonus.
I agree on the use of sweeteners and Dr. Fung uses human based research results in his book which I prefer over lab animal tests. However, I am going to guess you don't watch Thomas' videos on a regular basis because he does put references to studies to back up the facts he is using. This video may be more of an opinion based one, but his science and research is always spot on. I watch some other keto "bloggers" that quote a lot of "bro" science. But one thing that sets Thomas apart from these others is his use of researched facts and science. Thomas also has a lot of experience in helping others navigate their fitness journey, and more importantly their health journey. Practical experience and knowledge trumps a study every time.
Steven Perry the sweetners he said were ok have been tested on people. Some people get a sugar spike, some dont. Its a grey area. However there are some sweetners that def raise bsl.
If you reread my comment you will see that I said they raise insulin levels not blood sugar levels. These are two completely different issues. And if you listen to what he said when he said BCAA's were out it was because they spike insulin, not blood sugar. My comment/question was if spiking insulin was a reason to kick out out of your fast, then the sweeteners would also kick you out of the fast because they too spike insulin.
Milevskis Fitness. The study shows the augmentation of insulin with use of artificial sweeteners in the presence of glucose on rats. This is not really showing that they produce an insulin spike themselves, but rather increase the insulin response to glucose.
Munk fruit and almond milk? Teaspoon measurement in my morning green tea.
Can you please discuss what vitamins will or will not break a fast ???????
vitamins will not....by this i mean if you are on vitamin tabs
Damn another classic dropped by Thomas Delauer
Curious about essential oils and if they trigger an insulin response? I’m new to intermittent fasting and based on what I’ve researched so far, am thinking citrus oils would actually be helpful? Thank you for your time and great video!
I have the same question. I ingest 1-2 drops in 40 oz water during my fasted state. Does it affect insulin levels/break a fast?
Thank you so much for your work! Does Monk Fruit break a fast? And, how many servings?
I have same exact question, for Monk Fruit,
does breathing break a fast? answer fast pls, cant hold my breath much more
if you breath from your nose no but from the mouth yes
Millennial vs. The World What language is it you’re speaking there..? 🤨
😂😂
Wezz - He’s not speaking, he’s typing, but I’d wager the audio version isn’t much different from the texted version. Give him a break, that poor Millennial is versus the whole world and there appears to be a long line of complaints.
..only if you're breathing while standing next to a Cinnabon
What about ginger? Like with your acv and lemon
Mary Nsaidoo-Storph need an answer ASAP
Shouldn’t the protein powder be in the no-go column? Like you said, it definitely breaks a fast cause it’s still food.
Hey there. Thanks for all your great videos.
Just wondering: does turmeric tea will break the fast?
I think that falls under the category of herbal tea that doesn't contain fruit
what about vitamins in pill form, D3, Omega 3?
MrMixCro Vitamins and Minerals are not digested.
Two Fit Docs did a physical test checking ketones, insulin etc. They checked MCT, coconut oil, butter etc. Any artificial sweetener caused a spike, mct and butter did not. In fact BPC had an effect of helping the ketones. Just sayin’ check it out.
Jamia Burcham I saw that test! Now I hear Mct brakes it! Oh my! So many opinions! Geeeze!
It still is calories so it stops the autophagy effect so yes it breaks it
@@Acularis Stopping autophagy and breaking fast are two different things. You can still be in the fasted state and have no autophagy.
You're awesome, thank you for all your work. Keto changed my life and will change more in the future, super excited about it! 💯✨😊
Hahah was gonna ask you about weed before the video even ended but then I realized I should watch the rest and of course you covered it.
Good video, really informative. Thanks :)
Would some vanilla ice cream on top of a chocolate brownie get me out of ketosis?
IAmAgainst - Funny
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
IAmAgainst nah
no. please have all the ice cream and brownies you want. guaranteed instant ketosis for sure! 👌🏽
Please!!!!!! Can you tell me when to take my bcaas and protein powder if I workout fasted in the morning and I won't break fast till 4 pm??
Jill Lopez I'm here for the same question I usually workout after having my last meal at 8 but I need my post workout what should I do fasting time is 16/8 ?
Have it after you break your fast😎
Esther Jeudy start your fasting window after your post workout calories
Why not change your eating window?
Rogal Dorn busy schedule I can't eat at 2 pm ... im at work maybe I will try to workout earlier or so
What about omega 3 (oil fish) and glycine / malate magnesium (capsules) supplements?
fish oil breaks a fast
Can you list pre workout brands that we can buy
What about vitamins and minerals supplements?
Vitamins break a fast, minerals(at least electrolytes) do not.
Shouldnt really be taking in vitamins and minerals without food anyways for absorption, so theres that
True but it is important to get electrolytes in during a fast because if you are going 12-16 hours on just water, youre going to be urinating a lot, dumping a lot of sodium and potassium, it is good to replenish those.
I should rephrase : remove minerals from there. Really only vitamins need food to absorb. Minerals dont require any food to absorb. Some Lemon Sea salt water in the morning goes a long way
Marco thanks for the correction. That's correct and in fact, historically we've gotten many of our minerals from the water we drink (and anyone who drinks well water still does)
Does Pink Himalayan Salt break a fast? Also what about toothpastes (is a significant amount absorbed in the mouth, enough to cause a metabolic response)?
Salt does not break a fast
Use a water pik
I've been constantly pondering that as well
Thank you very much for this easy to follow,practical information. Much appreciated 🙏🏻🌷
Your use of the white board is getting much better. You are learning well from Dr. Berg, grasshopper.
Mrlr J but the green color though was hard to see
Very informative....I was disappointed to see BCAA's....as breaking a fast.
Thomas, I hate to ask (mainly because I know I need to quit anyway) but does dip i.e. Copenhagen, Skoal, etc break a fast?
velishan1 im 2 weeks late, but it may. Because from what i understand, canned tabacco like that is sweetend with sugars (for taste obviously) even though it may not seem like it to some people. That may make ir break. Just a heads up to look into.
i take a herbal tea ginger turmeric and 1clove of garlic. will it kick me out of fasting autophagy? also stevia? regards
Love watching your videos, you upload great content. What sugar free gum would you recommend for fasting. I am a weirdo about fresh breath and work around other people. Thanks for any insight you have.
I hate to tell ya, but chewing breaks a fast. Brush teeth or mouthwash
One thing that definitely DOES NOT break a fast...smashing that like button!!
Thank you so much for this. I've watched a lot of these "does it break a fast" videos and I think that this one by far is the clearest and most concise. I really appreciate all that you do. You're videos are very helpful and I think it's generous of you to take the time to research and create them for our benefit. Also, I adore your dogs! They're absolutely beautiful. Australian Shepherds?
Oh wow he actually knows about the ETC i trust this guy!
Will powdered collagen break fast?
Mark's Daily Apple discusses Collagen (in coffee)... www.marksdailyapple.com/does-coffee-break-a-fast/
I'd say: why do people need to eat all the time? Don't snack, don't eat anything out of the meal time! It's simple as that. Eat once of twice per day and that's it. And eat healthy, do not consume chemicals, hormones, pesticides, antibiotics, taste-enhancers and artificial sweeteners! Why would you need soda for example, drink water, lemon water, tea...whatever is natural sugar and chemical free.
srbjbt people have habits. They snack when they’re bored or anxious or purely out of habit. Some people have more hunger cues than others.
So if i inhale a dohnut will that break a fast?🤣
nah I think you're good to go
Stevie Lack you can't break a fast, If your dead...😂
😂😂😂😂
Don't look at it either lol
If you inhale like Kirby then yes it will
The famous Dr. Jason Fung said bone broth, butter and mct are ok in coffee and it doesn’t break a fast.