'Bonnie Dundee' - Scottish Jacobite Song
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 сер 2024
- 'Bonnie Dundee' is a song written by Walter Scott in the 1820s celebrating John Graham, who would become 'Viscount Dundee' in 1688, and leading the first Jacobite rising in 1689, he died during the Battle of Killiecrankie, going down as a hero.
During the Jacobite uprisings. In 1689, following the Glorious Revolution, Graham declared his support for King James VII of Scotland and led armies of men in a Jacobite rebellion in an attempt to restore the Stuart monarchy in Scotland, and in England. - Фільми й анімація
As a Polish Catholic and a friend of Scotland, I bow down to the heroic Jacobites
Doesn’t matter how their struggle ended, they became heroes and we should remember them!
Bonnie Dundee's the ancestor of Ridin' a Raid by about 170 yrs
The song was written 40 years before riding a raid afaik
Minor issue with subtitles, should be "Claverhouse spoke," not "claver who spoke," as Dundee's family estate and title was Claverhouse
Er I owe the usurper I'll crouch wie the fox.
The dialect of 'Bonnie Dundee' seems to give Net lyrics transcribers a great deal of trouble. It's as if they can't make sense of what they're writing.
You'd hardly believe how they render 'brave dunewassails' which most notes on the song helpfully describe as clan soldiery.
They might have an easier time of it subtitling 'Killecrankie' accurately.
It’s not really that incorrect anyway since he was referred to as clavers sometimes
I found this song in Victor Hugo's book "Seafarers".❤❤
@@ulviyyehuseynova23 Que incrível coincidência, estou lendo os trabalhadores do mar também.
I am apparently a descendant, though, as a bastard. Supposedly John Graham was quite prolific in his travels.
I think not?
As someone born in Dundee, I approve
I'm English and Catholic so this is an interesting march
Well the Jacobites weren't really Scottish they were Catholics and those who believed in the power of the king over parliament.
@@jacobite2353 based.
Excellent .My family were Jacobites !
Mine were the opposite, they fought the Jacobites, well most of them did some joined them.
@@KiernanRenaud That happened a lot. Like the Mckintosh were the wife of the Chief of the Clan, Anne Mckintosh, choose to side with Bonnie Prince Charlie and rallied the Clan to side with the Prince while her husband fought for the goverment has a officer.
Eventually her husband was captured by the Jacobite army and the Prince paroled Captain Mackintosh into the custody of his wife, commenting "he could not be in better security, or more honourably treated". She famously greeted him with the words, "Your servant, captain" to which the Prince replied, "your servant, colonel" thereby giving her the nickname by which She would be know for decades to come Colonel Anne.
Oh cool i didnt know that,@@lucario2188
This went from some random bagpipe music to my favorite song
The second and fourth pictures show the battle of Dunkeld, a Jacobite defeat (a few weeks after the costly triumph at Killiecrankie) and the third is of the Boyne, another Jacobite defeat. What about the song The Haughs of Cromdale being added on this channel, though there's no known song for Dunkeld, though of course the Cromdale song is woefully inaccurate; with references to Cromwell and it being a Jacobite victory!! Or what about the song about Glencoe (which was made into a low budget film), to complete the Jacobite song trilogy for 1689-92?
Love this
irish rovers with muskets nice
Don't ask a Jacobite/Royalist/Tory what Claverhouse did to the Covenanters at Bothwell Bridge
Nothing wrong
LOVE LOVE THIS SONG
This song is mentioned in Victor Hugo book.
And, sideways, in Kipling.
0:58 that sounds like “the protestant Muslims”
Sounds similar to the Confederate song: riding a raid
I’ve noticed a lot of British tunes find their way into American music from the late 19th century, it’s pretty interesting how many of the melodies were recycled into American music
@@Imperial_BritanniaAt least half of the music from the American Civil War are originally Irish folk tunes.
Bonnie Blue Flag, Irish Volunteer, Kelly's Irish Brigade, Wearing of the Gray, to just name a few.
@@Imperial_Britanniaaye, shame about the Revolution
@@Imperial_Britannia also, The Confederates used Cavalier as one of the names for their Cavalry
@@Imperial_BritanniaAh yes, a guy complaining about the IRA whilst condoning an empire that killed millions. Even police in the UK during the Troubles were worse, they mostly attacked civvies while the IRA mostly attacked cops and military. Little N*zi.
Bonnie.
Not exactly Scott's words. For one thing (among many differences) in the original it's mostly 'bonnet' (singular).
Killiekrankie next?
I have been trying to get some more Scottish music up, but most likely not from the 89 rising, finding enough content for this one was extremely hard, so I probably finish clearing my current in progress videos before going to try again with the 1680s, same with the James II song that I posted, it’s a really under documented era in film.
@@Imperial_BritanniaI see
Who is singing here?
What is the name of those wars depicted in the video?
major Jacobite conflicts as follows , Killiekrankie, Dunkeld 1689. Boyne 1690 Aughirm 1691. Sherrifmuir 1715, Glenshea 1719, prestonpans,falkirk and culloden 1745.
They’re all from films and documentaries about the Jacobite rising of 1689.
Great Video! I just got to see it. Would you please be so kind as to tell me the name of the actor who is seen at 0:50? I'd appreciate it a lot.🙏@@Imperial_Britannia
@@Imperial_Britannia Can you list them?
🇱🇮🏴🏴🏴
is similar to Confederate song riding a raid
Riding a raid is an adaptation of it
You so do some Ulster Loyalist songs because pro.