Skeleton Crew... why didn't they make this sooner?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 415

  • @mattblom3990
    @mattblom3990 3 дні тому +331

    I like how they appear to have found good, affordable, CGI-based special effects for aliens that essentially digitize them but they look like 1970s/1980s puppets or suits, which just feels right for Star Wars.

    • @shatter_point
      @shatter_point 3 дні тому +27

      From what I understand there is a ton more practical effects in this than you may think!

    • @snart2195
      @snart2195 3 дні тому +13

      The freaking big lobster/crab guy at the pirate port blew me away. If it was mostly CGI, it's seamless. If it was a big ass suit it was stunning.

    • @SonOfTheChinChin
      @SonOfTheChinChin 3 дні тому +8

      practical suit as reference and cgi for touch ups

    • @magmapixel8627
      @magmapixel8627 3 дні тому +10

      @@snart2195 funny that the practical props are so good that they’re mistaken for CGI, and the CGI is so good it’s mistaken for practical props

    • @snart2195
      @snart2195 3 дні тому +4

      @@magmapixel8627 I know it's just so refreshing especially since this isn't a massive tentpole movie. Makes me excited for what we'll be seeing in upcoming films

  • @jasonmarbach
    @jasonmarbach 3 дні тому +153

    The show is great and fun so far. It doesn’t have to be deep to be fun, but the show is still a lot deeper than I personally was expecting. The little At Attin mystery in particular is very interesting, and was unexpected.

    • @chefdean7257
      @chefdean7257 3 дні тому +11

      @@jasonmarbach There's something really off about daily life on that planet. A lil something too familiar, and too forewarning of our own future.

    • @jasonmarbach
      @jasonmarbach 3 дні тому +9

      @@chefdean7257 agreed, and isn’t that interesting? I can’t wait to see how they handle it

    • @jilliebean6312
      @jilliebean6312 2 дні тому

      Im thinking its just supposed to be the planet humans originally settled at referencing a galaxy far far away explaining why this planet has similar architecture to earth civilization

    • @chefdean7257
      @chefdean7257 2 дні тому +1

      @@jilliebean6312 Earth didn't exist yet. Long, Long time ago ? Galaxy far, far away ?

    • @jilliebean6312
      @jilliebean6312 День тому

      @ “long, long time ago” doesnt specify any specific amount of time or when the story was being told relevant to our existence, and a different galaxy doesnt mean its not the same universe…

  • @TheAshHeritor
    @TheAshHeritor 3 дні тому +147

    That ending segment is why you're the only Star Wars youtuber that I still watch.
    Thanks for staying measured, calm, and reasonable!

    • @d-resmin
      @d-resmin 3 дні тому +14

      I'm the same way. He was the only Star Wars UA-camr to point towards a sign that this show could be good.

    • @lorigoshert6667
      @lorigoshert6667 3 дні тому +8

      I agree. There were some other channels I used to follow, but I realized they were impacting my enjoyment of the shows.

    • @ledinyourwalls
      @ledinyourwalls 3 дні тому +4

      I think there's a difference between being cautious and being some all caps rage culture warrior that demands people be hung by their entrails for enjoying something they didn't, I mean if you include animated shows only 55-60% has been good,rest has been pretty mid, so of course you have be a bit cautious with your excitement about modern SW, which most channels were, although imo I thought I'd be a good show just because it didn't fall into the same tropes a lot of other sw media fell into

    • @afunkymonke
      @afunkymonke 3 дні тому +8

      Yeah it's kinda wild how a year or two ago I could name several channels I enjoyed watching that cover Star Wars, now it's just our boy GT. We need more like him being open minded and trying to be positive, instead of just making hate videos to make a quick buck for the views. If people genuinely don't like something that's one thing, but some people make it their entire personality to hate.

    • @TheAshHeritor
      @TheAshHeritor 3 дні тому +2

      @@ledinyourwalls For sure, no disagreement there.

  • @greedokenobi3855
    @greedokenobi3855 3 дні тому +67

    Didn’t expect much at all but to my surprise I really like these first two episodes. Great beginning!

  • @MattStryker
    @MattStryker День тому +2

    I'm 56 years old, and I LOVED this show. Not even ashamed. I can't add anything you haven't already said, but I finally have good feelings for Star Wars again after so many years of watching its decline. When I saw Star Wars in the theater back in '77, and Luke Skywalker was staring out at the twin suns, wishing he could be more than he was, I FELT that, even at 10 years old. This is the first show since then that I felt that again. I feel this is going to be a wonderful series, and I'm sure I will enjoy every episode.

  • @snart2195
    @snart2195 3 дні тому +51

    Nick Frost as the pirate droid was so good

  • @Pit.Badger
    @Pit.Badger 3 дні тому +25

    The little Ferryman looks like Teek’s race from the Ewok direct to TV movies. I love the mix of practical costumes they used. Fantastic designs

  • @irenecue8206
    @irenecue8206 3 дні тому +29

    Always love your videos and comments especially the geopolitical ones.
    However, as an old gal I hope we adults leave this show to the kids. I grew up with Lost in Space (1960’s) which set me off on a lifetime of loving anything set in space, Sci-fi, Isaac Asimov, Ray Bradbury et al. Thank you Alan for pointing out this series is primarily for children, I hope it ignites a life long love of all things sci-fi, space themed, fantasy which has enriched my life and will hopefully enrich the younger generations coming up. Please grown ups don’t sour it for them.

  • @afunkymonke
    @afunkymonke 3 дні тому +48

    I was definitely not expecting the first episode to open with a huge pirate battle, and the mystery about what's up with their home planet is already more interesting than what The Acolyte tried to do in its's first 2 episodes. Also, I liked the nod to Andor when they name dropped Aldhani. Wasn't really expecting that to come back except maybe during Andor season 2.

    • @MariOmor1
      @MariOmor1 День тому +4

      I like how the pirate battle is similar to the one at the start of A New Hope, even with similar dialogue and actions

    • @philosophical.traveler
      @philosophical.traveler День тому +1

      It's a good show but I'd rather see Acolyte season two

  • @Alargeselfhatred
    @Alargeselfhatred 3 дні тому +66

    Woah, Finally a good Skeleton Crew video! I'm hoping for this show to be as good as the trailer shows it to be, and not a show that just gains dust. It looks amazing, and the plot seems good too.

    • @dreadzilla_9548
      @dreadzilla_9548 3 дні тому +6

      I thought the first two episodes were for lack of better words, just fun.

    • @byronhorde5892
      @byronhorde5892 3 дні тому

      I just finished watching the one "Emergency Awesome" put out. It's good.

  • @moopiemoopie
    @moopiemoopie 3 дні тому +34

    I love it so far. Nice change of pace.

  • @GuyInWalls
    @GuyInWalls 3 дні тому +41

    I like the direction they are taking with the show. very unique in the star wars saga

    • @AcornElectron
      @AcornElectron 3 дні тому +1

      It’s fun huh? Star Wars has always been kid friendly at the core. This gets us back there to clone wars and maybe even the original trilogy. Or at least episode one 😂

    • @GuyInWalls
      @GuyInWalls 2 дні тому

      @@AcornElectron its always been for kids but thats not what I meant. I simply the style of the show like the characters and plot feel refreshing

  • @lerneanlion
    @lerneanlion 3 дні тому +31

    Should we expected Hondo Ohnaka to eventually appeared in the series? He has been described as the Jack Sparrow of Star Wars after all.

    • @MrIan1086
      @MrIan1086 3 дні тому +4

      I’m getting a Long John Silver vibe from Jude Law.

    • @lerneanlion
      @lerneanlion 3 дні тому +2

      @@MrIan1086 Like the one from Treasure Planet?

    • @MrIan1086
      @MrIan1086 3 дні тому +4

      @@lerneanlion or Muppets Treasure Island. 😁

    • @Logaan777
      @Logaan777 2 дні тому

      ​@@MrIan1086 Long John Silver from Black Sails? Keeps coming up with plans that never work and changing sides all the time?

  • @devo1977s
    @devo1977s 3 дні тому +19

    I swear I could hear the Pirates of the Caribbean theme song playing in the background but a with Star Wars twist.

  • @bear499
    @bear499 2 дні тому +4

    I was hesitant about this one. But every Star Wars youtuber is giving it glowing reviews, even the most critical ones. Definitely will be checking it out.

  • @mrrewog
    @mrrewog 3 дні тому +31

    Latchkey, free-range kids... definitely for the genX audience.

    • @MrIan1086
      @MrIan1086 3 дні тому +5

      Yeah, we were basically feral

  • @peterbrazukas7771
    @peterbrazukas7771 3 дні тому +63

    I died when I realised the droid is named Smee.

    • @azraelrazor
      @azraelrazor 3 дні тому +3

      Ikr. So awesome

    • @DarthRelkew
      @DarthRelkew 3 дні тому +1

      Yeah, I thought that was pretty cool

    • @johnelliott7020
      @johnelliott7020 3 дні тому +3

      I liked that the robot on the ship - I thought of one eyed Willy from goonies.

  • @AR-io8fv
    @AR-io8fv 3 дні тому +3

    Generation Tech is the hero of the Star Wars UA-camverse

  • @sirlad9180
    @sirlad9180 День тому +2

    This is the second time a star wars show (first being Andor) that i wasnt that excited for has hit that spot for me.

  • @willucario
    @willucario 3 дні тому +15

    Great video, I always appreciate your take on things!

  • @samuelolson9230
    @samuelolson9230 3 дні тому +7

    Jude Law’s character intro reminded me of Maul meeting Ezra Bridger in Rebels. The whole lost planet of Atatin is sure to drive the story well.

  • @joshuawells835
    @joshuawells835 2 дні тому +2

    I've been describing this series to my folks as "Goonies in Star Wars." When watching it, I both agreed that At Attin looked a little too suburban for Star Wars and recognized my younger self in the characters. I was that kid who had pretend lightsaber fights and read a lot of history and fantasy books. I also remember the animosity between boys and girls, especially the kind of girl who thinks she's so smart and can talk her way out of any situation. This show brought me back to childhood. I also picked up on the Pirates of the Caribbean vibes in Episode 2.

  • @pokemaster123ism
    @pokemaster123ism 3 дні тому +17

    Kinda funny the shows everyone was hyped for (Ahsoka/BOBF/Mando S3) had mixed reactions while the show not many people were excited for (SC) is getting pretty good reviews

    • @ukmediawarrior
      @ukmediawarrior 3 дні тому +1

      Depends what you mean by reviews. The critics from major media outlets loved those shows you mentioned, only after they were being aired did less positive reviews appear. As for this one, not surprised its getting good reviews, but its not for everyone. It's a kids show and that isn't what many people find fun. Oddly Star Wars has always been for kids, so I was a little confused why they spent so much money on this show to attract a kid audience

    • @afunkymonke
      @afunkymonke 3 дні тому +4

      Mando S3 just compounded the issues we started with in BOBF, the fact we couldn't get a single episode that season without Grogu by his side says it all. In my opinion they shouldn't have reunited them so fast, especially not in a completely different show that shouldn't have had Mando in it to begin with. Cobb Vance should have been the Mando role showing up to save the day alongside someone that he kinda stole his armor and wouldn't see eye to eye with at the start due to Boba being a prior enforcer for Jabba and probably causing trouble for people like Cobb and the others of that town. Instead they stuck him in a bacta tank and we have no idea if we will ever see Cobb come back.

    • @Himmiefan
      @Himmiefan 3 дні тому

      @@afunkymonke Agreed!

    • @HylianSith920
      @HylianSith920 2 дні тому

      I feel like that already described people's impressions about Andor.

    • @TheHipsterGamer
      @TheHipsterGamer День тому

      A lot of the people that moaned about Ahsoka never watched clone wars or rebels. Can’t take those opinions seriously.

  • @leshaygood6054
    @leshaygood6054 3 дні тому +6

    Yeah, I stayed up because I was waiting for your response to this new series. Love your video and insights as always, Alan!

  • @supersonicgamer4568
    @supersonicgamer4568 3 дні тому +9

    I'm excited to see your review.
    For my own thoughts quick, I love the look of the show, it looks incredible, SM-33 was awesome, and the kid characters are quite fun to watch actually, overall I'm quite optimistic for this show, can't wait to see the future episodes and see how some mysteries are solved.

  • @KyleStevensVermont
    @KyleStevensVermont 2 дні тому +2

    The little alien ferry transport pilot is a Teek from 1985s Ewoks movie Battle for Endor the same year that the Goonies was released.

  • @rupertpendergrass4014
    @rupertpendergrass4014 3 дні тому +8

    I like how you said Goonies In Space, hits it right on point. And next generation Star Wars. I hope the culture doesn't mess this up for future Star Wars fans

  • @andrewlim9345
    @andrewlim9345 2 дні тому +1

    Thanks for your review. Having watched part of the first episode, I had the feeling that At Attin is a lost High Republic colony that has been isolated from the rest of the galaxy for centuries. The reference to the Republic (not the New Republic) and Great Works was a clue. I read in the Wikipedia article that the series was originally going to be set in the High Republic era but that the showrunners decided to move it to the New Republic era. Even Star Wars Theory has praised the first two episodes, which is a relief.

  • @F0XD1E
    @F0XD1E 3 дні тому +6

    It was better than I expected as well. Wonder if Jude Law is actually a jedi, or if that's just some parlor trick to get them to lead them to their hidden planet.

  • @drakeshadowraven2162
    @drakeshadowraven2162 20 годин тому +1

    One of the pirates was a pirate in Mando season 3. Played by same actor so it would seem to take place in same time as Mando

  • @Himmiefan
    @Himmiefan 3 дні тому +2

    Skeleton Crew is soooo good! So funny! I love how they incorporated what many fans have done: play lightsabers complete with making the sound. My favorite SW quote is now, "My guts! They're everywhere!"

  • @AlannaCDP
    @AlannaCDP 3 дні тому +3

    Always great reviews. I go to your reviews to get an an unbiased view of what I might want to watch. Thanks, Alan!

  • @A_Certain_Point_of_View
    @A_Certain_Point_of_View 2 дні тому

    Been awhile for me Allan, thank you for the consistent content while I check in and out of Star Wars. Excited to watch this show and tune into gen tech over the next couple weeks. Love the great perspective and great community tied to your channel 🤙

  • @Chaedron1
    @Chaedron1 3 дні тому +2

    I was presently surprised by the premier, there was so much doom and gloom surrounding this show that I'm glad they seemed to have pulled it off. Jude Law I think will be awesome with the kids, like he was in AI. I also thought it was funny that they straight up ripped that scene from Pirates of the Caribbean, it was a cool reference. I got Goonies and even ET vibes throughout the show. I hope they can keep up the pace of the premier, with just 6 episodes they will have to keep it tight.

  • @nathansmith9633
    @nathansmith9633 День тому +1

    The werewolf guy isn’t a bothan, he’s a shistavanen which is really cool to see!

    • @AZTLANSOLDIER13
      @AZTLANSOLDIER13 6 годин тому

      Especially because Lucas tried washing him out of Star Wars cannon. That creature they replaced him with in the special edition was awful

  • @dreadzilla_9548
    @dreadzilla_9548 3 дні тому +6

    The show is definitely fun so far, really enjoyed the first two episodes

  • @lorigoshert6667
    @lorigoshert6667 3 дні тому +5

    Any other High Republic fans thinking that At Attin decided to keep some of the Stormwall technology?
    Enjoying this so far, thanks for the review! I laughed quite hard about the werewolf pirate being named Brutus, having known more than one German Shepherd with that name.

    • @afunkymonke
      @afunkymonke 3 дні тому +2

      I'm not too familiar with the HR stuff, but that would probably make sense considering they kept talking about "The Great Work" which we haven't heard any other of the New Republic stuff mention before if I remember correctly. That sounds more like a high/old republic era thing, kinda like post ww2 era US. A by gone era that has remained in a bubble is a very interesting way to go about things, especially the fact they talk so much about the Jedi in an era where most still think the Jedi are urban legends or remember the stories the Empire would tell to try and keep people in line.

  • @dumbguy1007
    @dumbguy1007 2 дні тому +1

    I like the growth of the "pirate nation" I've always been interested in a 3rd party semi legitimate government forming out of the lawless and wild areas of the galaxy, who are strong enough to hold territory from the empire or republic. The Mandalorians seem to be forming such a group and you also have the pirate nation as well as potentially the crime families, although with Boba Fett not being continued, I doubt we will see much more depth into them. This could be partially an explanation for the civilian fleet from rise of Skywalker but I wouldn't want every project to be beholden to explaining the sequels.

  • @shamussilliker-vz6iz
    @shamussilliker-vz6iz 2 дні тому

    So happy to be enjoying another star wars adventure with you bro

  • @justinreilly6619
    @justinreilly6619 3 дні тому +2

    Yes! I haven't watched this yet, but looking at a number of thumbnails of UA-cam reviews of this series, it seems Skeleton Crew has garnered pleasantly surprised/positive reviews throughout. Bravo Disney! 👏 Now I'm really looking forward to watching the first episode.
    Thank you Allen for sharing your thoughts once again 👌

    • @ledinyourwalls
      @ledinyourwalls 3 дні тому +1

      Sadly although actual fans are happy the storms coming over the horizon fast, only a matter of time before reactionaries use the show as the source of rage bait content, and the discourse will be completely polluted

  • @mikemonk4375
    @mikemonk4375 2 дні тому +2

    Actually it’s Treasure Island in space. Or Treasure Planet with Star Wars guys, depending on how you wanna look at it. Disney doing a rehash, of their own rehash, of their own live action rehash, of R.L. Stevenson’s book.

  • @spacemanspiff3052
    @spacemanspiff3052 3 дні тому +2

    I liked what I saw 2 episodes in. Stronger start than both “Ahsoka” and “The Acolyte”. While the former didn’t quite stick the landing, it certainly didn’t collapse in dubious disaster like the later, so I’m hoping “The Skeleton Crew” can sore clear above the acceptable Ahsoka bar and FAR above and beyond the Acolyte smoking crater.

  • @ebikeengineer
    @ebikeengineer 3 дні тому +1

    You've convinced me to restart my Disney+ subscription.

  • @PopRivet-s7w
    @PopRivet-s7w 2 дні тому +1

    So in Goonies the ship was Captained by One Eyed Willie. In this the Droid has only one optic, or am I crazy?

  • @UpcycleShoesKai
    @UpcycleShoesKai 2 дні тому

    Ready Player One was a power fantasy. Dude saves the world, has unlimited money, even points out the stagnation of life. After saving the world, he keeps the money to his friends, and limits the use of VR.
    Dude could of built a new society, use VR to train new skills to people, but he kept it to his own circle. Nothing has changed except for him.

  • @Nico_6967
    @Nico_6967 3 дні тому +3

    Somehow, I think this show will get seriously DARK

  • @brandonking2679
    @brandonking2679 3 дні тому +2

    This is easily the best directed Star Wars tv show so far.Maybe not my cup of tea exactly but it feels the most “film” like of any of the tv shows thus far.

  • @andrewlyon4495
    @andrewlyon4495 3 дні тому +6

    Brutus is a Shistavanen, not a Bothan.

  • @skyrider4789
    @skyrider4789 3 дні тому +2

    "if you want them to be weak." 😹I agree with your review. It's fun!

  • @andyb1653
    @andyb1653 3 дні тому +3

    I liked these first two episodes. E2 in particular was a lot of fun.

  • @wahn10
    @wahn10 2 дні тому

    Honestly I'm shocked they made it at all. Such an entertaining show, makes me remember childhood, my friends and why we loved Star Wars and Spielberg to begin with.

  • @Irish37
    @Irish37 День тому

    "Don't make it your personality." Bravo. Perfect. I have things about Star Wars that I love, and things that I love less. But that's as far as it goes. Being a Star Wars hate-troll is something I could never even imagine being, or doing with my life. I hope the haters find something they like soon, and move on with their lives.

  • @Stahl42
    @Stahl42 2 дні тому +1

    I enjoyed it and found it fun. The Holiday special cameo was hilarious.

  • @Functional_Dissident
    @Functional_Dissident 2 дні тому +1

    I was very pleasantly surprised

  • @NoneOfanyonesbusiness
    @NoneOfanyonesbusiness 3 дні тому +4

    Reminds me of the opening scenes of Fallout 4, with a bit less campiness.

  • @stevejobs7353
    @stevejobs7353 3 дні тому +2

    In these 2 episodes I can't find a character i don't like. I'm loving this.

  • @joshuawells835
    @joshuawells835 2 дні тому

    It was also brought to my attention in a comments section that SM-33 spells out Smee, as in Mr. Smee, the first mate to Captain Hook from Peter Pan.

  • @scottcurry8976
    @scottcurry8976 День тому

    This feels like a great entry-level Star Wars for all age groups. The likes of which has not been created by Disney. No background knowledge needed for most viewers and they get a fun naive perspective/POV to mirror their own. Meanwhile, for the lore junkies, they have the carrot of unraveling the mystery of how this fits into the universe they know. Very well done.

  • @jamoecw
    @jamoecw 3 дні тому +1

    Every generation has their own thing. Lucas Arts sub contracted to different companies so that they supported the creation of new development studios to increase the amount of unique entertainment we had, with them being an important part so they were never left behind. Now that it is all under one roof, so to speak, the question of 'who is it for' is important as if it is for a new audience and not the old then logic dictate that they expect to build their audience themselves and not rely on fans funneling them the next generation.

  • @VAULT-TEC_INC.
    @VAULT-TEC_INC. 3 дні тому +1

    1:18 “How bad can it be?”
    Remembers how Ahsoka decapitated FOUR members of Deathwatch in one swing (while back flipping!) in The Clone Wars. 😱

  • @kooziesan
    @kooziesan 3 дні тому +1

    The SM33 peter pan reference was spot on

  • @Fore-Four-Dee-Too
    @Fore-Four-Dee-Too День тому +1

    Trying to get people to stop complaining on the internet is a a lost cause. I commend you for trying.

  • @wtfamiactuallyright1823
    @wtfamiactuallyright1823 3 дні тому

    If they continue down this path, they will capture the next generation.
    This IS what kids need and want and even I'm enjoying the first two. I just hope they don't fail on the story, for everything else is spot on so far.

  • @d-resmin
    @d-resmin 3 дні тому +11

    I don't want to get on the bash Kathleen Kennedy train, but some have questioned her ability to pick creative talent. They picked out the right talent here and hopefully it will continue.

    • @Klaaism
      @Klaaism 3 дні тому +1

      Favreau and Filoni thankfully predated KK's ascension to galactic emperor. They worked on the Clone wars and maybe some projects before then even.

    • @ledinyourwalls
      @ledinyourwalls 3 дні тому +2

      I never understood the hatred and vitriol towards Kathleen, she's just a bad leader for the franchise not some comic book supervillain trying to destroy western culture or some bs like that

    • @d-resmin
      @d-resmin 3 дні тому +1

      @@ledinyourwalls It's a common problem in the business world called the Peter Principle. People do a good job and then get promoted into a position they are not good at.

    • @merafirewing6591
      @merafirewing6591 День тому

      ​@@ledinyourwalls *cough* The Sequel Trilogy. *cough*

  • @Keseleth
    @Keseleth День тому

    I am genuinely charmed by this show. Kid characters are believable and fun and that's always difficult to get right in that kind of shows with appropriate casting and screenwriting. (I wish there was this level of competence involved with the Acolyte.) Skeleton Crew gives me the vibe of a Treasure Island and even though it is predictable to a degree, I am perfectly happy with that. It's just simply endearing.

  • @hepburnj75
    @hepburnj75 3 дні тому +1

    Seems to me that SM-33 is actually Smee from Peter Pan! Which to be fair fits quite well.

  • @dennisud
    @dennisud 3 дні тому +1

    Since I'm not getting Disney+ back until a certain show comes up I like the non spoiler review, Thanks!

  • @pancakes8670
    @pancakes8670 3 дні тому

    I hope this could mean exploring the Star Wars universe outside of the aspects we already know. That was the best part of the Prequels, they expanded the setting and whats possible in it beyond our realm of understanding in the Originals

  • @BlueTiberium5198
    @BlueTiberium5198 3 дні тому +2

    Direction is good. Acting/casting looks good so far, and the mysterious is intriguing. Plus, a badass Droid 😎 👌

  • @gramthefan1.051
    @gramthefan1.051 21 годину тому

    It’s been fun so far. Excited for more. Love the idea of the barrier

  • @farwoodfarm9296
    @farwoodfarm9296 3 дні тому +1

    The most intriguing part of this show so far is the mysterious planet the kids come from. I don't like how short episode 2 was.
    I enjoyed it, so far it's more interesting than Ahsoka and Acolyte and I'm a TCW/Rebels fan.

  • @seathrunmagaoinghous4119
    @seathrunmagaoinghous4119 3 дні тому +1

    really liked it and much better than I expected

  • @B.matrix
    @B.matrix 2 дні тому

    Watching with my kids and we’re having a great time!

  • @AcornElectron
    @AcornElectron 3 дні тому +1

    11:55 my kids are already old enough for me to go ‘you’ll like this, it’s not Andor but it’s better than that final jedi film thing. I can never apologise enough to my daughter for 7-9 after getting her hopes up with 4-6, telling her that even 1-3 were not exactly good there might be a 7-9 one day….

  • @ScottMobley1138
    @ScottMobley1138 2 дні тому

    Hey now! Excellent analysis and breakdown. Thanks for the positivity. I'm kind of interested to find what the haters hate this time around.

  • @James_Wade
    @James_Wade 3 дні тому +1

    Well put my man.
    Being a gen x-er, I’m going to subvert any expectations, and just enjoy this show.

  • @73jbirch
    @73jbirch 2 дні тому +1

    It It kind of reminded me of when I saw raiders of the lost ark At about 12 years old. So far so good

  • @MrIan1086
    @MrIan1086 3 дні тому +1

    I think 8 episodes is plenty to tell the story well. Goonies and Muppets Treasure Island both had under two hours run time and told their stories just fine. This series is probably three times that length, so there's plenty of room for world building and lore.
    Did anyone else notice that Wim was carrying Old Republic credits? That's like having gold Doubloons for pocket change, or walking into The Broken Drum with 2000 rhinu. Something definitely strange there.

  • @captcorajus
    @captcorajus День тому

    I really enjoyed the first two episodes and am looking forward to the rest.

  • @Aaron-fb6mb
    @Aaron-fb6mb 3 дні тому +4

    Could you also do a video discussing what would’ve happened if Padme had reported Anakins sand people murder to the Jedi council?

    • @F0XD1E
      @F0XD1E 3 дні тому

      They knew

    • @Aaron-fb6mb
      @Aaron-fb6mb 3 дні тому

      @ no way

    • @Aaron-fb6mb
      @Aaron-fb6mb 3 дні тому

      @ I know Yoda could sense pain and screams but did he know exactly what happened?

  • @debbralehrman5957
    @debbralehrman5957 3 дні тому +1

    I liked it. Thanks Alan 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼

  • @stuartgrier5605
    @stuartgrier5605 3 дні тому +7

    Simple answer: YES.
    If you don't watch it you have no right to comment.

    • @katakesh8566
      @katakesh8566 3 дні тому

      I'll bite. Why? Do u mind elaborating?

    • @stuartgrier5605
      @stuartgrier5605 3 дні тому

      @@katakesh8566
      Because it's Star Wars.
      I am fed up with people who criticise Disney Star Wars for no other reason than "Disney". I have enjoyed almost all of Disney Star Wars, except the sequel trilogy.
      Just look at all the detractors Andor got before anyone seen it, now everyone loves it - even those who hated it initially.
      Give it a chance. Wait till it's finished and then comment.

    • @Spearhead401
      @Spearhead401 3 дні тому +1

      ​@@stuartgrier5605Watched it, hated it, 2/10 I miss star wars.

    • @stuartgrier5605
      @stuartgrier5605 3 дні тому

      @Spearhead401
      So you have written off the whole series just after a single episode?
      Why did you hate it?

    • @justinwainwright5069
      @justinwainwright5069 3 дні тому

      ​@@stuartgrier5605now your moving your own goal post. They said they watched it and they don't like it.

  • @CullenRick
    @CullenRick 3 дні тому +1

    This was an excellent start to the series. The battle was very good - and the children do act like children, but in a realistic way as the actors certainly have the required ability.
    Perhaps, JK will finally get that win that she wanted to retire on?
    Possible Spoilers:
    1) New Republic? The evidence seems to be that their home planet isn't involved in that at all. Old Republic credits? Lost planet considered a legend? Starships banned from the planet? Just saying, Palpatine must have had his "hoard" gathered from the Clone Wars era hidden somewhere.
    2) Jude Law - Jedi Padawan -> Pirate Captain -> prisoner -> redemption arc?
    This is far from mindless. Like the best children's media, it has a lot of depth below the basic entertainment.

  • @benjames4502
    @benjames4502 3 дні тому +3

    Gen X nostalgia, star wars Goonies. 👍👍

  • @drakeshadowraven2162
    @drakeshadowraven2162 20 годин тому

    The main pirate chasing the kids for credits was in Mando season 3. Same actor, same alien which implies the time period is that around Mando era

  • @d-resmin
    @d-resmin 3 дні тому +2

    Something did seem off about having to pass a career placement test. They are only matching them to potential careers. I've taken a few. In countries with major pass or fail tests, like Germany, those aren't done until much later. I took a few major tests as a kid, but those are more about measuring the school's progress. It was never a big thing I had to pass. There is something dystopian about it.

    • @ryankwon8785
      @ryankwon8785 День тому

      It feels like a world run by droids and the adults somewhat act like droids. Remember how the robots in Wall-E took charge of humanity?

  • @johnelliott7020
    @johnelliott7020 3 дні тому +1

    This show is much much better than the Acolyte. Several reasons, they are using the hero’s journey and a straight time line♥️. This is so Star Wars and George Lukas much like Andor. Where as the Acolyte time jumped around was not a hero’s journey for any of the characters - it was about a disaster and poorly acted. The pace was straight forward and showed a highly controlled world run to be bored dull and repetitive. Then the break from this jail like world .

  • @DaleESkywalker
    @DaleESkywalker 21 годину тому

    I watched this as a kid every day for 50 years !!!
    ... in my mind.

  • @TheEasyvid
    @TheEasyvid 3 дні тому +2

    Are you going to do anything like a breakdown or theory type videos? I would love to hear your thoughts on the at attin mystery so far

  • @laughingowl7896
    @laughingowl7896 3 дні тому +3

    I'm an old man and I'm liking Skeleton Crew so far. Btw, not all "boomers" think like boomers. Thpbpbpbpbt. And it's not nostalgia either. Amblin style doesn't really mean anything to me.

    • @Spearhead401
      @Spearhead401 3 дні тому

      No you're right some boomers think like children because you don't have any friends your age.

    • @laughingowl7896
      @laughingowl7896 3 дні тому +1

      @Spearhead401 It truly is a pity your life is so pathetic that that is all you have for a reply.

    • @ledinyourwalls
      @ledinyourwalls 3 дні тому

      ​Just shaming people for liking something they didn't, mostly ignorant kids , but you do get the balding gooners in their 50s every once in awhile

    • @AZTLANSOLDIER13
      @AZTLANSOLDIER13 6 годин тому

      Why would it a boomer would be outside that generation. Are you Gen x or a boomer?

  • @AR-io8fv
    @AR-io8fv 3 дні тому +1

    If it keeps this up…
    Tier 1: Skeleton Crew and Andor. Please Disney make the new Jedi movies this quality
    Tier 2: Mando Season 1-2, Rogue One
    Tier 3: Force Awakens, Ahsoka, Solo
    Tier 4: All other Disney live action Star Wars
    Tier 3-4 and below are unacceptable going forward

  • @beddeb45
    @beddeb45 2 дні тому +1

    Better than TBOBF and Acolyte.

  • @jeffreycarman2185
    @jeffreycarman2185 3 дні тому +1

    Mandalorian seasons 1 and 2 were great, Andor just knocked it out of the park, the other shows have been middling to good (with the exception to some that started out middling to good but then the filmmakers couldn’t deliver, and they ended up being not that good).
    I’m hoping this is the show that delivers from start to finish. It has a fun premise and a lot of possibilities…

  • @DidWeWin1
    @DidWeWin1 3 дні тому

    Cautiously optimistic. There seems to be a lot more production value than the Disney Channel quality shows we've gotten recently, besides Andor of course.

  • @EthanKironus8067
    @EthanKironus8067 3 дні тому

    Congratulations on having a wife and a daughter. They are very lucky to have you.

  • @drewrubtheMando
    @drewrubtheMando 3 дні тому

    I love that SM-33 was a nod to Captain Hook's first mate Smee in Peter Pan.

  • @captain1jones354
    @captain1jones354 День тому

    I actually enjoyed the show. Looking forward to seeing future episodes

  • @orokusaki1243
    @orokusaki1243 2 дні тому

    Yeah, as Yoda said: "you must unlearn what you have learned."
    When people go into it with a bad mood or attitude, they will certainly get a bad experience. It is far better to just go in with no (stern) expectations and let the show entertain you, first and foremost. Being an armchair critic, picking it apart and saying how wrong or bad it is, shows that one may have lost sight of the spirit.

  • @bram7703
    @bram7703 3 дні тому +6

    Early af but lets do this

  • @jh6031
    @jh6031 11 годин тому

    I’m hold enough to have seen Star Wars (Befoe it was A New Hope) in a movie theater and I think Andor is incredible. I was skeptical about Skeleton Crew but ended up really enjoying it and am looking forward to the upcoming episodes.