Tank RO Units vs Tankless RO Units Review
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 жов 2020
- In this review I wanted to test the difference between Tank RO Units vs Tankless RO Units. I also compare them to tap water and a basic refrigerator filter to see if they are even worth it to begin with.
- Навчання та стиль
![TOP 5 Best Tankless RO Reverse Osmosis Water Filtration System [ 2024 Buyer's Guide ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/caCO5Z1o0fA/mqdefault.jpg)
![TOP 5 Best Tankless RO Reverse Osmosis Water Filtration System [ 2024 Buyer's Guide ]](/img/tr.png)
Thank you for not making boring video about water. Good information what I want to know to make decision on tank vs tankless
I have the same tank RO system and just found out tankless is a thing. Came to your video while trying to find TDS test. Pleasantly surprised with results. I installed a permeate pump on mine so my water loss is 1:1.
Excellent thank you for the video. I am a home brewer looking for a RO system to purchase. You helped me make a choice for a tankless system.
How has this worked out for you plz!!
I'm at a crossroad seems to me holding water would not be good! Not to mention crowded under stink!
Thanks for the insightful video and I'll do my best to not die.
Hey Davil, great video, one of the only of its kind on UA-cam actually. Any update on the Waterdrop tankless system? Do filters last about as long as advertised? I've read a lot that TDS reading varies a lot in the first 10-20 seconds after the system sits for a while, anything noteworthy that you've seen?
Thanks! I've replaced the filters twice since I made this video. The ro one once, so yea they do last as long as expected and the unit beeps when they need to be replaced. I haven't really noticed any increase in particulates in the water either.
Thanks for the video. The one thing I'm interest the most was the water taste between the APEC and the tankless system. I didn't get to see that. I just installed the APEC ROES-50 system because I was tired of buying, carrying, and recycling. The APEC water system tastes amazing just like bottled water from Costco or Aquafina, not that crappy Arrowhead bottle water.
Really no difference in my opinion.
I have same system. Try adding APEC's alkaline filter. Makes difference in taste and will help to add minerals to your water.
Thanks a lot man, this helped me make a decision. Great video.
This was well done. Thank you.
Great video subbed
Nice comparison! I couldn’t see that many videos like this, thanks! My RO system is aging, thinking about trying new WD system to save reduce some water waste
The difference may be due to types of filters ... etc. My tank Ro System has a mineral filter. My tap water from Detroit is pretty good with around 123 ppm. My RO system brings it to zero, so I added a mineral filter to it now avg. between 13-20 ppm. *So what do the filters filter concerning the Tankless vs what do the filters filter with the Tank???
Super helpful thank you!
One question did you try to test water from battle ? I’m just curious what tester can show
Depends on the type of bottled water. Some like Voss or smart water are basically 0. Others like Dasani are essentially tap water
I would never drink from disposable plastic water bottles. For 1, those things sit in warehouses for ages, toxicity and chemical leaching happens on those plastics. Secondly, plastic water bottles require 17 million barrels of oil and 2.5 million tons of CO2, and that's just for the US. Worldwide multiply that times 50 to 75, it's not good.
@@1TUFZUK i mean drinking tap water full of hazardous chemicals/pollutants/microorganisms vs drinking bottled "spring water", im opting for the bottled water.
Thank for the Video. How is the sound coming out of the tankless system? Some reviews on Amazon say that the sound from it similair to that of dryer.
It's not extremely loud, I would compare it to a small circulation pump for a fish tank or a d5 pump for computer water cooling, it's noticeable if you're listening for it.
The one I bought has a battery to operate the filter reminder but otherwise there's no noise but water moving through the pipes basically.
Very informative. Thanks.
Have you tested the tap water after letting it sit on the counter for 1 hour? The chlorine is said to evaporate after a while, and maybe the test would show lower TDS without the filter systems?
Haven't, chlorine isn't really in my water though from what my test strips say
Good video. Since the pump turns on when you run the sink, what about hooking it up to a refrigerator ice maker (I’d split the the line going to the faucet.) Would the ice maker have enough demand for the pump or would it cause the pump to run constantly, etc.?
I would imagine anytime there is demand it will turn on so it should work. Ice makers generally just pull water to fill the tray so would run all the time.
It will meet the demand of the ice maker so long as the ice maker is asking for water, which will cease once the ice tray is full and trips the shut-off lever.
Hi Davil. Thanks for the video. I want to go tankless as I have very little space under my sink. I noticed that you tested your refrigerator water at the start of the video, is there a way, or some kind of attachment, that would allow me to run my water line from the RO to both the sink and my refrigerator? That would be great. Sorry if you have already gone through this--I did not read all the comments.
The hose it comes with looks like it should fit but still have to tie in the waste water to drain somewhere
Thx for review! How many gallons does tankless waste as it filters? Manufacturer usually understates their, wondering your real world opinion & how it compares to the tank RO systems. Thx!
Haven't tested that but generally for tankless they say 1 to 1 compared to the 2 to 1 from my tank model. I can say that with the old one I could hear the waste water going down the drain, but with the tankless I don't, so it seems like less for sure.
thank you for the informative video. i wish you would compare the flow rate of the tankless and tank unit.
It's not significantly different, they're both pretty slow to be honest. It takes about 10 seconds per cup so quick math says about 2 minutes 40 seconds per gallon.
I currently have the exact same Apec RO system you had. I'm considering making the switch to the same tankless system you did in this video. Will you please let me know how you like it after having it for a couple of years now? Thanks.
Yea, I do like it a lot better if only because replacing the filters is so much quicker and it reminds you with a beep whenever you need to change them.
Thanks,Overall a good video.
How is the Waterdrop working one year later? How often do you need to change the filters? Any issues getting filters?
Only been 8 months so I haven't had to replace them yet, still working well though and I ended up getting a remineralizer since it's supposedly healthier. I didn't see any issue with getting filters though, still plenty on Amazon.
@davil why do you have two faucets? What do you use the non-RO faucet for?
The water coming out of the ro unit is very slow and doesn't have much pressure. The normal sink is for washing dishes and other stuff that I don't need drinking water for
Tankless RO systems have RO creep. If you were to run it for 10 seconds instead of right away, you would have had a very higher TDS reading. After about a minute the TDS reading goes down again. This happens with all tankless systems.
I'll give that a try and see what happens.
@davil, what do you think after some years of ownership? I've read that tankless doesn't have a remineralizer as a last stage processor, so the water may have some effects similar to drinking distilled water.
I ended up get a remineralizer and it's fine. It still works well and filters aren't expensive.
@@TheRealDavil Awesome! If your water filter broke, would you get your old APEC or get another tankless WaterDrop?
Just installed mine TDS read 002 first now is 001, i haven't tested my water but i know our water is not bad...
Your first RO had a post filter which increased ppm. I have 2 and after Ro I have 3 but after filters about 50, the water is nice smoother.
So you like the tank version better than tankless because of that effect?
You mentioned the flow quickly. Do you notice if the WD is slower than the traditional in filling up a glass?
It might be slightly slower but not particularly noticeable. I also fill up several 1liter bottles at a time so it works better than the tank one.
@@TheRealDavil Good deal appreciate it. As long as it's similar enough the family can't complain
I’m thinking of getting the 5 stage Waterdrop tankless system. I see a lot about tds, but not sure how that relates to chlorine. If my main concern is chlorine will the tankless system work good ? Or any other recommendations?
Depends on the unit, but they should all reduce the level to some degree. Mine does remove chlorine according to the manual, doesn't say how much though.
That one remove chlorine but only the 5 stage remove chloramine
To remove chlorine taste and odor, use a carbon filter. RO is overkill for simply to remove chlorine.
@@TheRealDavilhow often should TDS , BE tested after install of new filters? And does sanitizing the system every so often lower overall tdm in an aged filters in the system. 1 more thing, do you recommend cleaning filters?
Thanks for the video. Any tips on how to add outlet under the sink? Did you add the outlet yourself?
I did install one myself. I just found the closest power source and branched a new line off of it. In my case the dishwasher is on the other side of that cabinet so I cut a hole and mounted a new outlet box. Just be sure if you're doing that you want to have a gfci type outlet somewhere in the circuit and ideally also a cover over it so it doesn't get splashed if something sprays under the sink.
@@TheRealDavil thanks. Last question, in your case did you pull out the dishwasher when branching out the power line?
My kitchen is set up so i have to run a water line about 15 feet from my sink. does this provide enough pressure to accommodate both sink and fridge?
I don't know if you can do both at the same time. Should be able to split the water line to the faucet and go to both though. They make a refrigerator connection kit so it's for sure possible to get water to both, just not sure if the pressure would be enough
😂🤣😆 you're comment is funny "yeah, tap water and new RO water tastes basically the same".
Thanks for sharing.
I'm not picky, I grew up drinking out of paper cups.
@@TheRealDavil indeed, i even drank out of hoses as a teen. Realistically though, I'm genuinely concerned about the harmful toxins, so I'm researching for the most affordable tankless system that delivers quality results. The toxins i ultimately care about are chlorine fluoride lead arsenic micro plastics.
@03Lorac I put in a whole house filter that covers all that the other day, dropped the tds number to about 300, and my girlfriend says the water smells better. So that is an option too if you can do some basic plumbing.
Sold by “to quote the goonies”. Well basically looks like a revamped fridge filter. Curious to see what your reading will be 6 months after install.
Thanks for the vid,
I couldn't tell you because I added a remineralizer. But even with that I get about a 22 and I haven't changed filters yet.
Hi Davil, any interest in doing a product review of water meters used in RO Units?
Maybe, wouldn't be a bad idea
How and where did you add the remineralization filter to the new tankless system?
It goes right before the faucet. You just have to cut the tube that goes to that and plug the remineralizer in.
You didn't ask for my opinion but, as a ex water filtration salesman, I can tell you that remineralizers are kind of a gimmick - you're getting 99% of your minerals from solid food.
Spend that money on quality meat and veg instead.
Best wishes,
Random internet commenter
Minerals are just for taste, not some health benefit.
How long have the filters been lasting you and how big is your household?
They can be cleaned, but I change them out once a year so far
@@TheRealDavil Thanks!
Does anyone know what are the main differences in Apec's rotl models? they have 3, one(in the video) and then 2 others that around 600$ (of those 2 one reintroduces 'minerals'). im just curious why is there not an easy way to compare these 3 similar models specs on their web page for a few $100s more in price. The 600$ also have the filters in front and have 3 separate filters vs the lower budget one which is just one, but spec wise i see no difference
Also thanks so much for the great review video
I bought a remineralizer separate, but they all function about the same
Just ordered this unit on Amazon during prime day how do you like it after having it for a few months
Works great, filter changes are way easier than they were with my old one. The one thing I added on was a remineralizer because it's supposedly more healthy.
One is supposed to get minerals from food
Can the tankless system also connect to the fridge ice maker?
Never thought of it but seems unnecessary since most have filters anyway
Yes
im 65 years old carpenter retired. never done any plumbing if i buy this setup would i be able to install it my self easily or super easily or is it pretty difficult?
Super easily, I'm not a plumber or carpenter I just do a lot of work around my house and for friends. The hardest parts are drilling a whole in the drain line for the sink and wiring an outlet if you don't have one already.
@@TheRealDavil thank you would you recommend the tankless or the one with the tank?
In the event of power cut do u get a restricted flow
Do u have access to water
Good question I hadn't tried, but I will. My guess is nothing will come out because there is an electric pump that pushes water through the membrane.
@@TheRealDavil u can try switching electrics off and see if u get water.. please do let us know
How did you manage to have a power outlet under the sink? That is my concern at my place. Someone please help!!!
I installed one by branching off from the dish washer. Depending on the way your garbage disposal is wired if you have one, that is also an option to branch off of.
@@TheRealDavil I was thinking the same thing. Tap off the garbage disposal unit. I’m having an issue with my tank RO system and I think I’ll simply buy a tankless when I can conjure up some cash.
Have a tankless system, water pressure to the machine is fine but water out of the facet isn’t good!
Assuming a standard flowrate of 0.4 gpm, that's about 12 gallons of waste each time. Seems like they get it on the front end
Yeah seems like overkill lol, probably be fine after a few gallons.
Ph would be cool to test
Don't forget to have your drain line on a high loop
Hi what do you mean by this?
@@hellapellanyc6465 just like your dishwasher discharge, your RO waste/drain line needs to be on a high loop. High loop is when you have the tubing looping above your sink, tacked up at the highest point in your undersink cabinet. by doing this, you are ensuring that you have no black flow coming from your drain and all of your waste is going where it needs to be. before high loops were allowed, an air gap was required. in this circumstance, a high loop is fine.
You can even tail by the difference in color in the RO water that it's better quality.
I read RO takes minerals away and washes the nutrients away when used for cooking. Is this true, I just installed a system under my sink and also a water softener, Did i just made a big mistake? I have small children and will drink a lot of water. How about acidic water?, I read ph needs to be at 8, how do I make sure ph in water is good and we are not drinking acidic watet? Please help
I gave my son and niece ro water with their formula pretty much always, no issues. I drink it exclusively and have no issues. I don't really cook with it often but that shouldn't make any difference either. There are studies advocating for and against purified water so I would say it's probably fine. For ph, most home stores have water test kits or you can buy a bottle of pool tests strips that test ph as well.
@@TheRealDavil Thanks for your input, I was worried, I also read, I could install something to remineralize the water, did you do this with your system?
@@sandragarcia3454 R.O. basically strips everything out of water, including minerals.
Water salesmen use this to freak people out and scare them into buying remineralizers (I know this because I used to work in the water filtration industry).
The reality is that humans get all the nutrients they need from *_solid food._*
There's no way your health is going to be negatively impacted by not getting the minerals from water.
Instead of spending on a remineralizer, just buy quality meat and veg.
If you have a water softener, then you likely have hard water. Hard water is water rich minerals such as calcium and magnesium. A water softener reduces these minerals and replaces them with high levels of sodium. Which is why the water feels slimy.
Now an RO SYSTEM removes all disolved solids, including your added from softener sodium now. I believe the added sodium is no good for a baby or anyone to drink, and thus an RO system is beneficial. Water is at a PH of 7 (not 8), and RO water is slightly acidic because of it's void of minerals. So I advise that you add US calcium carbonate remineralization filter as the final filter on your system.
10:09 "they both taste like water"
Nice info anybody got any idea what the best tankless RO system is as far as performance/price. I don't mind paying uo but I can't stand over paying. I'm looking for the best value not necessarily the most expensive
This one wasn't too expensive prices may have changed a bit but there are a pretty big range of options.
APEC by far
Ha-ha! You still managed to make your video funny. I laughed. First at your gay watch, then at your "both taste like water" joke. Nice! Very nice, informative video.
I put a fallout pipboy skin on it cause the water in those games is always radioactive.
@@TheRealDavil A pipboy, eh? It seems I misjudged you. The force is strong in this one.
Lmao 🤣" yup taste like water"
Yeah that taste like water too!
What is that light blinking under your sink?
My disposal has a motion activated led light on it.
@@TheRealDavilWhat a great idea!
what brand was that tankless ro? thanks
Waterdrop is the brand, still going strong.
Is this the 400 gpd or 600 gpd?
It is 400gpd
"If the water is gone I still has the tank with water in the old system"
The new system if the water is gone and or if the POWER is gone then no clean water. ⛲💦💧🚣
Good to have some in the fridge then.😉👍
What about connecting to ice maker/ fridge.
Could be done but the flow rate compared to what normally goes into the fridge is significantly less so you would likely have some problems
Does the tankless unit slow down to a trickle like the tank RO system?
No it's a constant flow the whole time, about the same speed as a full tank.
Thanks very informational
Hmmm, so No Electricity, No Water... Not a good situation to find yourself in here in hurricane country, LOL Nice Review however. Some may want you to post a link to the device.
Thanks, yea that is the downside of not having a tank. But the reality is that hurricanes don't happen unexpectedly. There's usually a few days warning, so filling several gallon jugs up with water is a better option than relying a one gallon tank anyway.
It doesn't replace your normal faucet
The electricity is only for the filtered water.
If you are in Hurricane Country, then you know to keep stocked up on essentials.
For instance three or four 5-gallon bottles of water.
Great to see you're worried about the water however I see on your kitchen counter you have Wonder bread and all toxic cleaning products I think you should work on that next
They're disinfectants, what else am I supposed to use?
@@TheRealDavil essential oils obviously 😂
@@TheRealDavil alcohol & vinegar are less toxic. But the toxic criticism from this person you cannot control ;)
@@TheRealDavil look up dr bronners products 18 in 1 soaps u can use for everything non toxic
most filters dont reduce TDS much/efficently, if at all, that's what Ro is for.
Ok?
the tankless one makes quite a bit of noise even when water isn't being used..hmm
i don't hear anything from the tankless unless its running.
I think 3 to 5 is about as high as i would want
Well the thing is drinking water with less than 50 is generally not all that good for you according to some sources. I'm actually considering remineralizing my water after reading some information.
I would not even use a RO if I wanted to keep it that high I'd just use 5 micron filter and a carbon filter with a carbon block filter then a 1 micron filter cost may $150.00 to set up
Nice video but i would wear a shirt not covered in dogs or cats hair
Good feedback, I have 2 dogs and I just don't think about it all that much anymore.
I liked the video, then you said water taste like water.. in my eyes I lost all respect for you then... Lol jk
He wouldn’t talk like this in flint Michigan lmao
Accurate
Thats not a very good tds seems high to me
What do you consider to be low
I'd add a mineral tank to add minerals to the water. Otherwise the RO water will leach minerals like calcium from your body. At least that's what I read somewhere.
The whole leeching minerals thing is somewhat questionable. There is plenty of bottled water with lower tds and even pitcher filters like 0 water that make it 0 and there aren't really any issues with those.
There is no leaching of minerals...it is a fraud theory. Distilled water prevents disease,so does RO water ,BigPharma cant make money from healthy unvaccinated organic humans.
Never understood why people have this theory. You guys act like you get so much nutrients from your water LOL. Don't you eat food?
“RO water will leach minerals … from your body”
True
And the Earth is flat.
Also true.
Who is this guy. Every city has different quality water. I live in Southern California the weather here is quite bad. Systems without tanks never work because we have so many contaminants in the water. Before you listen to a guy like this what’s his resume when it comes to the water industry.
Ok... I just showed the difference between a tankless system and one with one using a tds tester. I don't need a resume to do that. You can do whatever you want but this was my result, tankless worked better.
@@TheRealDavil then you have no real knowledge of the water industry. Every ZIP Code in the United States has different quality water. There’s even a national database that will show you contaminant on everyone’s water. Tankless systems never ever work in Southern California.
Who is this commentator? It’s literally a review on UA-cam 😂 if you want scientific data perhaps you should read the manufacturer literature and inspect your own city drinking water quality reports. And don’t watch consumer reviews on UA-cam 😆
Tap water does not taste the same. U trippin.
Have someone put tap water in a glass and filtered water in another. You probably won't be able to see much of a difference.
Dude no. There's a big difference. Tap water is so gross.
How do we reverse this video to pull our spent time out?
I don't know, but maybe in my review of dumbest comments I'll go over yours.
@@TheRealDavil 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Dude... can you go faster? This video doesn't need to be this long.