Honda Elevate vs Kia Seltos vs Hyundai Creta vs Maruti Grand Vitara vs VW Taigun | Autocar India
Вставка
- Опубліковано 19 чер 2024
- The Honda Elevate might be all-new but it's up against a very competent field of rivals. Nikhil Bhatia and Jay Patil bring the Elevate together with the updated Kia Seltos, Hyundai Creta, Maruti Suzuki Grand Vitara and Volkswagen Taigun to help you find the right midsized SUV for your needs.
Camerapersons: Mrityunjay Chakraborty, Sharad Vegada, Roshni Manghani, Harshad Panchal
Editor: Mohit Sharma
0:00 - Introduction
1:12 - Size and styling
2:55 - Elevate interior
4:02 - Grand Vitara interior
4:41 - Taigun interior
5:32 - Creta interior
6:21 - Seltos interior
6:59 - Features
9:50 - Touchscreens
10:20 - Elevate rear seat
11:16 - Taigun rear seat
11:53 - Grand Vitara rear seat
12:44 - Creta rear seat
13:43 - Seltos rear seat
14:25 - Rear seat features
14:30 - Boot
15:09 - Engine-gearbox options
15:45 - Suspension and tyres
15:58 - Elevate driving experience
19:17 - Grand Vitara driving experience
21:00 - Taigun driving experience
22:45 - Creta driving experience
24:41 - Seltos driving experience
25:48 - Safety equipment and crash test results
26:40 - Braking
26:53 - Fuel economy
28:00 - Verdict
30:22 - BTS
SUBSCRIBE to Autocar India for the hottest automotive news and the most comprehensive reviews ► bit.ly/AutocarInd
Autocar India is your one-stop source for test drive reviews & comparison tests of every new car and motorcycle launched in India. We also offer a great mix of other automotive content, including weekly news, motor show reports, travelogues and other special features.
Website: www.autocarindia.com
Facebook: / autocarindiamag
Instagram: / autocar_india
Twitter: / autocarindiamag
New car reviews ►bit.ly/ACI-NewCarReviews
Comparison tests ►bit.ly/ACI-Comparison
New bike reviews ►bit.ly/ACI-BikeReviews
Features ►bit.ly/ACI-Features
#suvcomparison #hondaelevate #autocarindia #suv - Авто та транспорт
I got Elevate last month and here is my my view on the same.
1. Interiors won’t feel very plush but it’s very comfortable and easy on eyes. Hence pricing is much competitive.
2. Moonroof is just wide enough. I strongly believe Panasonic sunroof is just a show as it compromises the integrity of the car from roof side.
3. Elevate is good for people upto height of 6 feet. I am 5’11 so it’s just alright. Bonet view is superb and is notch above all the cars in this segment.
4. Engine options are lacking however Honda Engines are much reliable than all the engines in competition.
5. As rightly pointed while driving, superb control and ride quality is very good.
6. Yes 3 people in back is bit cramped however it’s good for family (me, wife, dad, mumma, and 4 year old kid)
7. Engine is noisy but what’s worth its take off after RPM of 3. It’s just a 🚀.
I think price wise it’s a decent purchase and infact if driven nicely in cities it will give average of 12 13 KMPL. Will share the update after first service of the car.
Iam 6ft1 , so is it a problem?
elevate is wannabe from honda dont take it wrong way i also have honda but this car is not up to mark
Can you please let me know which Variant have you opted for and the On road price? Is it a CVT or manual?
Hyundai Creta: The undisputed king of the market.
Kia Seltos: A luxurious avatar of the Hyundai.
Grand Vitara: The VFM pick of the lot. Just look at the package.
VW Taigun: For the enthusiasts in the market who want pure power.
Honda Elevate: The new kid on the block with Honda City reliability.
What a perfect shootout this is! Thank you so much Autocar India. ❤
great information thank you so much you provided this I'm absolutely appreciate it 😊🩵💖
Also Honda Elevate is cheaper
Grand khatara is vfm ? It only has higher fuel efficiency, not much else.
Creta is king of sheep market
Honda Elevate is Thalaiva (Boss) with no nonsense Car.. Road presence is Killer with Cadillac front grill & Muscular boxy classy look ..Very cleaver job done by Honda.
Elevate is a no nonsense car..such a balanced product. 👍
It's competition is bolero classic
Seltos is a frustrationfree car. A more balanced product.
elevate : glorified 4 seater.
no headrest for 5th passenger. primitive lap belt for 5th passenger. rear AC vent intrudes into 5th passenger.
honda had so much time to make things right but they were lazy.
Was waiting for this one. Personally, I would buy a Honda Elevate because it is what my brain would choose as the most sensible of the lot, even though Taigun stole my heart ❤️
Also, Nikhil turned out to be quite the specimen for measuring the boot space 😂😂😂
Just get a test drive of both the cars and I bet your heart will win your mind.
I see more emphasis is more on feel good factors like sun roof than safety ratings, ADAS, reliability, long term maitainance, handling and high speed stability factors. These are key things that a review should emphasise so that new buyers can make an informed choice.
Feel good things are something a potential buys can experience in showrooms. Howevers reviews and comparisons like this video should highlight the other factors
The mega comparison every auto enthusiast has been waiting for.. And brought to us by none other than Autocar; as always...🙌🏼
😮
An “auto enthusiast” waiting for a comparison of crossovers (read: sUVs) isn’t really an auto enthusiast now, is he?
Elevate surely a no nonsense car and VFM in this segment, drive quality and comfort is top notch. Impressed with Honda's proposition.
29:55 Fail to understand the obsession around panaromic sunroof in our country. It’s not practical, less safer and heats up the cabin faster. Why would you not mention these points?
Hey guys, great video loved the spec-to-spec analysis but just wanted to ask why didn't you wait for the new Creta to launch in the market and then make the review? Perhaps it could have changed the outcome.
A car needed with Honda's power and bootspace, Maruti's mileage, Creta's features, VW safety, and Seltos interiors 😊
Elevate Ground Clearance to bhool hi gye
I think Honda elevate V CVT @ under 15 lakh on road is the best option for family
Nice!
Is there a similar comparison for Sub-4m SUVs like Venue, Nexon, Breeza, Kiger, Magnite being planned?
Excellent comparison, very detailed, how narrow is the powerband on the Taigun?
I really like the Honda Elevate. It is a no nonsense car.
Did someone notice that elivate's passenger side has door colour mismatch😳
Excellent Review Team. One of the most wanted for people get confused as which one to buy. Hats off.
Nice review .Why was mg astor not included in test?
Nice comparison at right time during Diwali season... I don't understand one thing, why does almost every reviewer say that, "ALL IMPORTANT SUNROOF" it's not all important, it's not required also...
I have Honda elevate zx mt I m fully happy n satisfied the engine which is best in class n good mileage to
Superb Comparison.Elevate has the potential to rule the segment.Come on Honda,kindly plonk your superb diesel engine under its hood along with an automatic and load it with more features. It will set the sales chart on fire.May be Honda can take a leaf out of the South Korean twins book.
Not until people and auto journalists focus on useless features like panaromic sunroofs
Nah, diesels making a comeback is not happening in the BS7 age.
@@callingbell-ix5se💯 in long rides majority don't even use infotainment system and 76% of Indians below 20L buys base and 2nd base variant of cars...
This is the reason skoda and volkswagen starts giving alloy wheels, infotainment system etc from second variant itself..
Honda was right to launch elevate at it is... Yes, it needs more engine option but features wise, they are perfect...
If Honda wants to win the competition, it should include the 1.5L turbo with 160hp.
Some where Autocar has to think about build quality and safety ratings of the car in process of deciding who is better. I think Autocar has no need to carried way with just feel good factors.
25:48 is dedicated to safety.
@@NikhilOnCars They talked about it but did not give any extra weightage for recommendation
As a customer its a win win situation for us.. There are so many rival cars in this category and all are fantastic products in their own way.. For different requirement, there is something available there. Kushaq and astor are also there.. Curvv will be launched in few months. Don't hate any product guys.. Every product has its own USP, if not then the segment will be killed just by creta and GV. Ultimately we are winners due to luxury of 6-8 multiple products. 🔥🔥🔥
Loved the side by side comparison and the charts. Will save some trips to the dealership. Well done. Thank you!
Can anyone pls advise, by when the new Creta facelift will be launched in India & any idea on the price of its base model ? Is it really worth waiting for its launch rather buying the current one ?
Elevate sales really disrupted kushaq and Taigun sales , i was not expecting that . Already in 3rd spot on sales . Its surprising because it is less feature packed and only 1 engine option 😢.
😂 power of trust and reliability 🎉🎉 Honda Rocks ❤
Just wait as Honda might launch the new indonesian wrv which is based on amaze platform... That's car looks so good for its segment and interior of that wrv is same as Indian amaze too...
The engine itself is a masterpiece
Not sure how the elevated highway numbers are accurate… I recently bought one and on highways I am easily about to extract around 16-19 deepens medium my on how I drive… I didn’t see 13 at all
Pls do such mega comparisons for compact suvs like punch, exter, magnite, kiger etc
Great comparison!!!
I just bought elevate cvt and am quite happy with it. The reason I didn't go for a much more powerful suv is because I have 700 dsl and 530d.
Is there good enough room for 3 people behind? I mean i have i20 at present. Do elevate has atleast i20 for 3 people ?
dude just flexed on the rest of us good for you bro👍
dude its much better than creta n seltos
I will share a way to judge a car for yourself if you are out to get one (works with every other kind of comparo).
1. Break the whole scoresheet into different categories. Keep the number games out, just what you feel. Like comfort, not the suspension setup. Agility, not the power figure.
2. Give every category a multiplier score like from 1 to 5 based on how much you want from that category.
3. Score each car. It's always best to have all the stakeholders score and average them up.
4. Multiply the individual score with the multiplier for that category
5. Add up all the multiplied scores.
6. To factor in the price (if thats a concern) then you can minus that from a set number. Like here minus from 20. And give 20L car a 0, and 12L car an 8 (or 4 if it's 1-5).
7. You can add an addendum to reflect your personal liking (but that makes it less objective.)
Try it!
Great review...thanks from South Africa
Out of all cars which have the best base model? VFM?
Clearly Elevate is a better option out of all these cars. However, lack of engine options is a big miss by honda.
Lack of engine choice but do remember it cost 5 lakh less than competitors
I also came to the same conclusion after seeing this.
Honda's entry level engine is definitely better than Hyundai & Kia. If you can spend more then get the turbo motor from Hyundai or Kia.
Engine, build quality and driving experience means VW, features means Seltos/Creta, value for money means Honda, mileage and may be low cost maintenance means Maruti.
Honda - value for money ,build quality and engine , driving experience ❤
A review or a comparo is always incomplete without Autocar India, such is their finesse ❤
Autocar India's comment section is incomplete without ducatimultistrada 🙏
Elevate is a better option in this segments.
For me elevate has all the major attributes, 1 build 5 star should be as its based on the city, build which creta or seltos lacks, 2 engine reliability which the vw group might lack specially the 1 litre 3 and handling better than the Koreans maybe par with the vw twins 4 base model itself is loaded just add a camera and a music system
Please confirm Elevate is not the roomiest , I think it is and certainly better than Seltos and Creta which you claim .
Saw elevate today in Mumbai , it looks far better than what we see in the reviews.
Needed this ❤
Saw Red VW Taigun one day.. its color and finishing looked so good! i was staring it for some time🤩😘
Thankyou very much for this comparison. Was going to book a mid size SUV this Diwali. Your video cleared my confusion. ❤
Im using GRAND VITARA alpha automatic smart hybrid variant. What AUTO CAR reviewr said in this review is absolutely right. I have done 3500kms. It is exactly the same opinion i have about the car. I felt the car to be little slow apart from that the car feels smooth and refined when you are not driving it in a hurry. It is a proper family car for a matured driver who doesn't wanna drive like a rally driver. Chassis of grand vitara is highly capable of having a much powerful engine but maruti prefers mileage as a selling point to indian customers. In city i get 14 and on highway easily 20.5 and above. The gearbox and engine is so tuned from mileage. Automatic grand vitara is very smooth and relaxing to drive.
Don't you think mileage is too low....
How's the suspension on bad roads? Are they right about that as well
Yes but its painfully slow.
Can make video of comparing the mid size sedans škoda slavia, volkswagen virtus, honda city, hyundai verna, Maruti Suzuki ciaz
Brilliant shootout. 5 years ago similar shootout helped me choose the Jazz CVT. That was the video (baleno/jazz/i20) which hooked me to Autocar.
Although not looking for a change yet, this shoot out seems of similar level 👍
Personally I would go with the Elevate for being absolute bang for the buck offering 😊
Hope tata curve will be a proper 5 seater with 5 star rating. Elevate dissapoints with rear seat that only suits for 2. Does anybody knows when curve will launch?
Best handling and Steering feel - Elevate
Best seats - Elevate
Best suspension - Elevate
Best acceleration - Elevate
Best braking - Elevate
Best pricing - Elevate
Best Boot - Elevate
Best long term reliability - undoubtedly Elevate
and finally ..
Best safety - Elevate (most probable or at least at par with VW /Škoda)
Need anything else??
If Honda just add ventilated seats and rear sun-blinds, there is no stopping Honda!
Ventilated seats available as an official Honda accessory for Rs. 6000 only
After a long time, Autocar has nailed the comparison test! Although I wanted the chauffeur-driven perspective from the rearseat
Hello Brothers ✌️, love from North- East Keep up the good work.
Honda Elevate is the best all rounder out of all the options currently available
Surely, With respect to the price, Honda Elevate hits the spot with being more practical, more spacious and most importantly NA engine at the core.
NA engines are underrated. People will understand when these newer turbos cross the 1 lakh KM mark 😂
Seltos IVT is NA my friend.
All n all the interiors of Elevates looks most eye soothing n simple.
why you guys are not using topend models to compare try to use top end of each models and compare it with each other. currently in the feature list not shown the available features in the top end versions of each of the cars
Eagerly awaiting the latest Compact SUV Comparison with updated Sonet... Please upload soon!
I have Grand Vitara CNG - City Milege - 28 , Highway Milege - 35-37 with smooth driving 🙌🧘♂️🧠
Wish elevate got Hybrid option.
I wsih they bring back disel for Elevate , it will be priced probably 2 laks more but disel is what honda needs
Bring comparison between tata harrier, xuv700, hector..
Same as this one, means not the top model but the middle spec variants
super great comparison of those suvs but there are super fantastic 😊😍🩵
I went to buy kushaq and brought slavia 1.5 mannual and loving it
Elevate is the best over here easily, most value for money and no nonsense
The grand vitara looks old school, just like old american suvs from the side
Elevate for reliability and seltos for features🔥
Seltos is as reliable. What issues did you notice?? I booked Seltos IVT.
So cool to choose variants priced at par. Best comparison review 👍
Is anyone of these in rwd or awd options in India???
The elevate won in cvt with taigun and other cars is suprising to me cause the manual of this is just so powerful compared to the cvt one ❤❤ wow
Why No Astor ? It’s the most well rounded package of the lot.
Joke of the decade
Superb
Smile on their face when driving Taigun😊.
Smile on everyone's face when they see the Seltos.
Definitely VW TAIGUN is absolute class with Elegance 👌
How much are safe?
I will either go for Elevate or Maruti Grand Vitara
My favourite video is here ❤
Thanks 👍
Elevate is the best of all, a proud owner🤪
Good review but not sure why Astor is missed
If there is a Honda, its a no brainer. You have to give it to the engine. Ideally the comparison shud have been b/w the naturally aspirated Honda engine Vs natural or turbo, doesn't matter, of others. Honda wins it hands down. Cars should have more weightage for their engine, that way comparison will be better.
Elevate
Would have been great
If you would have spoken about the quality of switches, door panels and most importantly the lack of under thigh support in both rows
The interiors - those chunky seats look a tad below it's class
High NVH levels
Spoke about heat / sunny days twice but couldn't mention the ventilated seats in🤔 VW
Nice review team
I have picked Taigun
I will go new face lift seltos worth for money all safety equipped and adas level 2 that very good update
Honda could plonk in the 1.5t from civic with 180hp and Seltos with 1.6t with 180hp and take the segments to a whole new level
Why you picked VW Taigun 1.0 instead of 1.5?
Paying for Base mode vw & skoda >>> Mid model Maruthi, Honda & Hyundai. You can get Škoda Kushal from 13.7 l which is great deal if you ask. Just take a test drive and see for yourself.
This is an excellent comparison video, I am Looking forward to the BMW x1 vs Benz GLA 220d comparison
Without even watching this review Honda is my choice...I love this car
Good video
Where are the SUVs in the video by the way ?????🤔 SAFARI, SCORPIO, XUV700/500????
I never imagined elevate will be the most vfm automatic of the lot
Why not the Taigun 1.5?
guys mg astor?
@autocar India- if you have to choose between shletos and creata , in terms of everything what would you choose ????
Will go for elevate high end don't need ventilated seats and panaromic sunroof
You get ventilated seats as well
You will get a manual driver seat bro. Honda should have given a power seat.
Addition of thr all Important sunroof in seltos . Nikhil seriously bro? Anything
Elevate in sensible choice
Would be curious to see the MG Hector in this same video
What about a Harrier? Seems almost the same price.
elevate is the duster but 10 years later.
I would still call Duster the king of segment, especially above the Korean feature boxes.
why is nexon not in here?
Skoda kushaq is the most fun to drive and better engine and safest car among all its competitor's